Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by kposehn on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:55PM
(#28961127)
Marketer here.
Numbers: low nine-figures spent over the last 7 years or so on RTB display and GDN/YT
Outcome:
* Google on display tends to be much higher quality than most major DSP platforms. Incremental ROAS on Google's non-search ads tends to be better, with YouTube being the best performer.
* When you use GDN and YouTube, you are bidding on a much more accurate set of behaviors and first part data in addition to the content matching, which is second to none for large scale.
* One of the better audience types Google gives you access to is search intent. You can target people that have exhibited search behavior that indicates their interest or likelihood to purchase what you have on offer
* Despite these advantages, like any platform Google can also have major quality issues if you do not manage your campaigns well and click fraud can happen easily (thankfully in my experience they're decent at detecting and refunding fraudulent spend)
Edit: I would caution people commenting here to not use their own behavior as examples of how an ad platform is/isn't effective. HN users tend to be significant outliers vs. the general population.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by nickff on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:24PM
(#28962924)
>"Edit: I would caution people commenting here to not use their own behavior as examples of how an ad platform is/isn't effective. HN users tend to be significant outliers vs. the general population. "
Self-reported behavior is also extremely unreliable, and I would take all their comments with a grain of salt.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by kposehn on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:33PM
(#28980677)
Edit 2:
1. Self-referencing in my last point refers to gauging your own response to ads as a barometer of their effectiveness.
2. My points above are based on spending at scale globally (over 70 countries) for B2B and B2C products with multiple avenues to monetization
3. The outcome of my experience is based on this data in aggregate but I do not assume that past behavior indicates future success. The market is changing rapidly.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday October 22, 2021 @08:47PM
(#28964579)
"Edit: I would caution people commenting here to not use their own behavior as examples of how an ad platform is/isn't effective. HN users tend to be significant outliers vs. the general population."
In other words, exactly what the top comment is doing.
That said, we could apply the same principle to the parent comment from the marketer. He is using his own behaviour as an example of how the Google ad platform is/isn't effective.
There is a serious lack of transarency in the "open market" system Google is both overseeing and participating in. In the long run, that opacity could spell disaster, so says a former Google lawyer.
This opacity is a problem that seemingly inconsequential litigation like this from the Texas AG is (unintentionally) helping to address. Discovery helps us understand what Google wants to hide from the public.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by reayn on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:43AM
(#28958614)
Just curious, what constitutes the "quality" of an ad for you? I've never really thought about ads that way; for me it was just whichever service can stuff their name down your throat the most often was the most successful.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by vkou on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:39PM
(#28960878)
You're being downvoted, but it's true.
Move away from the big-boy ad networks (The likes of Microsoft, Google, Facebook), and there's a long tail of networks that will happily run the worst ads. Unsurprisingly, a lot of legitimate companies aren't super-keen on having their ads run next to ones for fake download buttons and penis enlargement pills.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by colechristensen on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:48PM
(#28961796)
* not a scam, virus, or other lazy attempt to manipulate me
* not visually obnoxious
* represents something that somebody actually wants
* represents something i don’t know about and might have interest in
Some ads are legitimately quite useful, others just abusive, lots in between.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by milesvp on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:11PM
(#28959825)
You know it when you see it...
I worked in the newspaper industry on the web side for many years. Remnant ads are the worst. These are the ad networks that you use to fill up the last of your ad spots that you weren't able to sell directly. They can fill volumes of ad spots for pennies per 1000 ad impressions. These are pure trash. Ignoring the common problems with actual virus payloads that they might try to inject, these are the most obnoxious, awful ads. They often have big animations with flashing background and jarring colors. They are full of click-bait titles. They are the reason people install ad blockers. I might not be able to tell you what a quality ad looks like, but I can tell you the other end of the spectrum, and it is pure filth.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by treeman79 on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:47AM
(#28958668)
Was in adtech for awhile.
Making sure clicks are real is a massive challenge with many ads networks.
There are a lot of tools that help in sure spambots aren’t stealing all the ad money but they also slow down serving of the ads and sometimes they mess up and block things that shouldn’t.
We’ve had campaigns where we had to allow more spambots simply because the client couldn’t spend enough money, they were willing to waste more to get better reach.
But most clients absolutely love the results when you have really good filters in place. Very low spend and good lead generation.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by summerlight on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:39PM
(#28960882)
There's pretty complicated dynamic regarding ad quality because each participant (users, advertisers, publishers etc) have different goals and ad network needs to balance it.
For an advertiser side, one possible, measurable metric is advertiser value per spending money. Value can be defined by advertisers pretty arbitrarily but you can think it as something like how much money you earn from ad conversions. Of course, this is very hard to measure accurately, massive ad network like Google has some advantages though.
But note that this is just one of possible metrics, there are hundreds of metrics ad networks want to improve and some of them are conflicting each other by definition. And some of them don't even have an objective way to measure so still depending on user study.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by soared on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:05AM
(#28958170)
Most major brands use multiple dsps, as performance is easy at low spend volumes and gets more difficult as you spend more. Dsps have access to unique inventory (through direct deals, pmps, etc) and unique technologies. For example, many companies use google, a vendor for mobile, one for ctv, one for retargeting, etc.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by eitland on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:14PM
(#28960590)
Measured by how much I've bought by clicking on Google ads vs by clicking on Facebook ads, Facebook ads are better by a couple of orders of magnitude at least I think (I'm actually not sure if I ever bought something based on a Google ad).
Add to this how little time I use on Facebook vs Google properties and how I used to love Google and despise Facebook it becomes even worse.
Maybe Google just failed spectacularly for a decade and everyone else had fantastic experience but I doubt it.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by short12 on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:32PM
(#28960789)
Absolutely agreed. Facebook ads are mildly targeted (and terribly inaccurate) and then incredibly repetitive. But they are leagues ahead of Google ads which are just complete shit
It's amazing their incredibly terrible advertising actually funds a huge breadth of services. Marketing departments really are that dumb I guess
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by ribosometronome on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:44PM
(#28961731)
I've found ads on a platform like Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Youtube, etc considerably more blatant/similar to traditional ads compared to an ad when searching using Google. It's easy to miss the "Ad" text next to a top result on Google and click a relevant ads without realizing it. Meanwhile, buying artisanal chocolate at 2 am on Facebook feels very much like, "Ok, you got me this time Facebook ads!"
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by dillondoyle on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:22PM
(#28961474)
I buy political ads. Probably spent low middle double digit millions over last 10 years.
Facebook has the best direct response ROI (e.g. a donation, a volunteer, a tracked conversion to voting).
I used to be able to get > 100% ROI immediately but with iOS changes it's becoming hard to impossible. I think FB will become more of a brand ad and loose a lot of app install or direct to consumer business.
Those are what most people consider relevant, for instance i get a ton of athletic shorts ads after I hover on one (usually because they use sexy images lol...).
Google has great DR ROI for search, though if your website is already #1 is that valuable? Big brands have to pay so their competitor doesn't get the slot though.
Google video, e.g. YouTube is very high quality and low CPMs compared to say Hulu and FB video 'view optimization' sucks like they count a 3 second scroll pass and the total complete watch % are absolutely tiny.
If you spend big (like 10k a day i think) you can access google's surveys which show a good amount of recall.
I've done my own surveys I built mobile survey interstitials and retarget people who watched video ads. Generally see a few point % bump in head to head voting (e.g. vote candidate X over Y) and actually a really high amount of recall candidate names with very few picking the fake spoiler. Again though with iOS this becomes hard/impossible.
Stories ads are valuable to me I love a digital native ad that fits the format.
Open market RTB video is mostly shit. Unless you do a kind of hybrid called a private marketplace deal (and a lot of other acronym buzz stuff) which gets you the high quality inventory but it's just an easier way instead of reaching out to each of the sites individually. Most websites are either auto spam content generation or layer so many auto play videos with sound off you're just wasting money. And they can lie in their bid saying it's a large size or audio on. Have to then spend $ and time on fraud prevention.
Open market desktop display ads (banners) are scraping shit off the floor usually IMHO. And then open market stuff like Taboola or when a website puts a link farm at bottom of page are like rectum licking in the scale of quality, to extend this gross metaphor.
Snap/twitter are interesting but haven't provided a ton of audience/value for me in my campaign audiences. Twitter is cool like targeting specific handles - havent done it in a while maybe not able to anymore with iOS idk. Snap is cool to try and get younger people IMHO.
Mobile interstitials can be valuable. I've built fun 'playable' interactive ads but I don't know of any other campaign or political vendor who has done something that is truly mobile native. They mostly just have static banners.
examples for game install ads they show previews that are playable. I like to think of interactivity that works on mobile to pull a voter into the ad experience. Twitter is selling mopub maybe? That's a higher quality network for this inventory.
Connected TV is great (a bunch of acronyms and definitions/sources, but basically anything steaming to a tv). Though it's insanely expensive during the election because all the TV buyers are fighting to buck viewership trends and selling campaigns equivalency - which is fairly valuable.
all the other corporations in the world are spending more on digital as broadcast TV dies but the incumbents in the political space have too much power and money at stake to follow the eyeballs. Most only spend like 15% on digital which is INSANE to me. A 'good' campaign i've never seen spend more than like 35%... IDK maybe bloomberg got to over 50% which is where it should be if you includ CTV.
TV people usually win because historically the TV vendor is the main consultant of a campaign setting message and direction.
Instead of a digital firm buying/owning as a whole package which I think makes more sense.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by dillondoyle on Friday October 22, 2021 @08:19PM
(#28964435)
FB let's you upload lists of 'purchases' to match, we can just make a vote a purchase.
and then they black box tie them to impressions/ad events.
It only works with early voting, where you get a list of voters who have cast or sent in mail ballot each day.
though arguably you're already targeting a tight list in FB of likely early voters (who are likely to vote themselves even without seeing an ad) so who knows if the ad actually got any extra votes in.
You could do an AB test, randomly show ads to only half the audience and measure lift but there are only a couple weeks of early voting usually and relatively small audiences unless you're statewide. I imagine it would work better for Presidential i've never worked on one, kind of a bucket list dream but also would suckkkk for a few years
You can also upload a final voting list after the fact as offline conversions, but doesn't make much difference after the votes are counted though I guess cool stats
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by dillondoyle on Saturday October 23, 2021 @04:07PM
(#28971767)
I personally disagree; I don't think better targeted ads is nearly as problematic as 'organic' self reinforcing political craziness.
Though I do see the point that some apps relying on addicted 'whales' making micro purchases. FB is (or was before iOS started crippling) really great at targeting and optimizing to acquire those best revenue generators no matter if you're getting donations to a non-profit or running an app casino.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by partiallypro on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:12PM
(#28962148)
I don't think I've clicked on a Google ad in a long long time, but I get ads on Facebook and Instagram that on occasion lead directly to a purchase. I'd say Instagram being the most frequent, especially for clothing.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by jsnell on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:53PM
(#28963221)
But the thesis of the GP is that their ad targeting is no better than the competetitors, so any price discrepancy must be due to foul play. Are you disagreeing with that, and saying that the ad targeting is actually materially better thanks to this data?
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by Justsignedup on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:48AM
(#28957930)
I would like to note...
Google is the big bad competitor who you're trying to out-compete.
You can't out-compete google without going below it in price. Everyone is desperately trying by charging FAR less.
I just want to note, it doesn't necessarily mean google is overcharging, but that nobody can enter a well established market by charging more and providing no other real value.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by phkahler on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:26PM
(#28960018)
>> Everyone is desperately trying by charging FAR less.
I thought these advertisers paid per-click, so in some sense Google and any competitor are fungible. Do people really care where their ads are shown so long as people click on them? Are the competitors placing ads in those crappy web sites that encourage accidental clicks?
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by Mikeb85 on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:03PM
(#28961228)
> Do people really care where their ads are shown so long as people click on them?
Of course they care. They pay per click, so they want the ads well-targeted so they have a high conversion rate, otherwise it's wasted money. Some ad networks literally scam businesses by placing ads everywhere so they get clicked on accidentally but of course this does nothing for conversion.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by makeitdouble on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:28PM
(#28959233)
It happens on most industries where there is a de facto standard. MS Windows alternatives cost way less down to 0. Photoshop competitors also are cheaper. Same for Word competitors, GoPro alternatives etc.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by mupuff1234 on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:44PM
(#28959452)
It's actually hard for me to think of any consumer driven industry where that isn't the case: cars, fashion, fitness & tech all have brands that come with a significant premium.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by Jensson on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:12PM
(#28959849)
> I’m not aware of any industries where competitors charge 25-50% of the price of their main competitor.
Alternative smartphone app stores charges way less than 25-50% of Google or Apple. You need to compare electronic markets with electronic markets like this, and the big players tend to take out extremely high fees in those areas.
Although, I agree that charging high fees in these areas is a problem and should be fixed, but it isn't like this sort of thing is uncommon.
Edit: As an example, Apple takes 30% cut. A competitor taking 7.5% cut would cost 25% of Apples app store.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by rvba on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:46PM
(#28959488)
Google search seems to have regressed in quality.
I guess those various people need to prove that they are needed so they make changes for the sake of doing something.. and quality of the product declines.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by hnaccount_rng on Saturday October 23, 2021 @02:28AM
(#28966242)
Any kind of hardware tools? Furniture? I’m pretty sure I can come up with more examples if I’m thinking about it. But those just came immediately to mind
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by sofixa on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:47PM
(#28959506)
ISPs and mobile network providers? On the French market Orange (the former state monopoly) is usually 25%-50% more expensive, with less features, slightly better coverage (for mobile networks) and "enterprise support" than the 3 other competitors. Having them as an ISP makes absolutely zero sense - no IPv6, IPv4 gets rotated daily, shit hardware. They have time limited exclusivity for some places (e.g. if they put down fiber in a city, they have exclusivity over the network for 2-3 years and then anyone can use it), but that really doesn't explain their market share.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by nova22033 on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:55AM
(#28958039)
So there are rival ad networks that charge way less than google? How does this fit with the anti-trust narrative? The customer clearly has choices.
You're entitled to a choice...you are not entitled to the ad network with the most reach.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by whimsicalism on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:49AM
(#28958689)
I agree that this is problematic - although in principle since they are paid by the click they would be incentivized to direct the bids towards the site most likely to generate a click.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by Retric on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:42PM
(#28959417)
No, Google receives 100% of the profit from directing traffic to their own properties. However, they receive whatever percentage their competitors chose to allocate to advising which can’t be 100% while maintaining profitability.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by epivosism on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:01PM
(#28958837)
This way of writing headlines can be exploited.
situation: A has 0% take rate, B has 1% => "B charges infinitely more than A"
Perhaps better in that case would be just stating the facts "A takes 0%, B takes 1%" or "A leaves you 100% , B leaves 99%".
The point is, from a consumer pov the take rate actually doesn't matter as much as the opposite, the "keep rate". And just adding in multipliers is so easily exploitable.
Not defending google, just as written the implied math has multiple interpretations, some okay some bad.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by mdavis6890 on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:59PM
(#28960417)
Good argument in general, but doesn't apply here. There's no keep rate, in the same way there's no "keep rate" when you buy a hamburger. It's just a fee to serve adds, and this article says that the fee is 2-4x with Google. There's nothing to "keep" in this sense.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by jtsiskin on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:28PM
(#28965433)
No, the price paid out to the publisher is the “keep”, and the fees google collects is the “take”. If typical ad networks charge 1%, and google charges 2-4%, you could also phrase this as a “keep rate” of 99% vs 96-98%. It would be a lot clearer to give the actual amounts rather than say “2-4x”
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by dantyti on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:16AM
(#28958291)
> The share the Alphabet Inc. subsidiary takes of each advertising transaction on its exchange—a marketplace for ad buyers and sellers—is typically two- to four-times as much as the fees charged by rival digital advertising exchanges
If I understand this correctly, this is about auctions/exchanges (middlemen which have little to do with ad targeting and quality), not ROI, as some commenters have suggested.
Correct me if I’m wrong, my adtech knowledge is limited.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by kuroguro on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:40AM
(#28958577)
Reminds me of a local story about contraband cigarettes in the central market - the sellers had set up agreements on who cans sell where. By far the best spot was near the entrance since more traffic = more sales. The guy selling there was charging ~2x more and still got more sales than anyone deeper inside.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by putlake on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:02PM
(#28958848)
It should be noted that the WSJ is owned by News Corp, which runs an ad network of their own for their properties. This launch announcement even talks about how they combine their first party data about their subscribers with data from Mastercard Ad Intelligence to "create bespoke marketing and advertising solutions" : https://newscorp.com/2017/12/05/news-corp-launches-news-iq/
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by ocdtrekkie on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:41AM
(#28957829)
While many behaviors of big tech monopolies are hard for laws from the Standard Oil era to wrap around, this is one of the most straightforward issues in monopoly law: Lack of competition and internal collusion between products means they can charge extreme and excessive markup.
While it might be hard to break up any given monopoly that offers "free" products with existing laws, this is the avenue that is straightforward.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by soared on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:59AM
(#28958078)
I can’t read the article due to the pay wall, but this makes sense. If you own the software to buy, the software acting as the intermediary, and the software to sell, you’ll make 3x more than a competitor who only owns one piece.
(I don’t use the products and I’m sure the names have changed, but dv360/dcm, whatever they call their exchange, and dfp)
I’ll leave the morality/legality/etc of as an exercise for the reader.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by HillRat on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:15AM
(#28958279)
Yeah, it’s worth noting that, roughly speaking, advertising supply chains provide 51% of spend to publishers and 7% to agencies, which means the middle of the chain (supply/demand-sides, DSPs, analytics, etc.) consumes 42%, or what GOOG allegedly takes at the high end. Given that they represent a fully-integrated supply chain, this doesn’t seem unreasonable, especially given how many competing ad networks are just bubble gum and duct tape.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by disgruntledphd2 on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:30AM
(#28958476)
So, if they have access to more information than their competitors such that they can maximise their own chances of winning proifitable auctions, it's problematic as its unfair competition.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by JAlexoid on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:29PM
(#28960049)
Capable and able are not the same. You can start collecting that data right now. It's also not a particularly complex task to collect information about people's habits.
I'm not capable of running a mile in 4minutes, that's not unfair for me to loose to someone that trained hard to be able to run that mile in 4 minutes.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by doomslice on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:42PM
(#28960200)
They sometimes (often) have "last look" -- so a bunch of companies compete to win an auction against each other, and then Google gets a chance to win against the winner of those. This means that Google can essentially maximize the profit they receive if they have a better bid, because they know exactly how much fee they can take without losing. Everyone else on the other hand, has to compete with _lower_ fees so they can win that first round of the auction.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by HillRat on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:30PM
(#28959262)
I think the issue is more around GOOG allegedly using illegal tactics to keep people inside their integrated supply chain — e.g., trying to discourage header bidding.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by liveoneggs on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:36PM
(#28960846)
don't forget about owning the consumers with -- browser (chrome), the platform (android/chromeOS), google analytics tracking data, and nest devices with microphones/cameras, and who knows what else they buy from 3rd parties
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by celestialcheese on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:59PM
(#28962670)
Off the top of my head, googles Display Product has quite a few.
- Magnite (Formerly, Rubicon)
- Xander (Formerly, AppNexus)
- GumGum
- Index Exchange
- Facebook
- Sovrn
- Unruly
- Sharethrough
- Triplelift
- OpenX
- Amazon A9
- Conversant
- Yahoo (AKA Gemini)
- Outbrain
- Revcontent
- Medigo
That's most of the bigger players, but there are hundreds. Many aren't worth the time, and are spun up when one rep takes some budget from a large brand and does "Direct" deals and tries to start their own shop with "Guaranteed CPMs". It's all bullshit
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by erhk on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:50AM
(#28958706)
I wish that HN users had to disclose their potential conflict of interest when commenting. If google writes your paycheck or makes up a portion of your portfolio I want to know that when you are defending them online.
Re:Google takes two-to-four times as much as the fees charge...
by nmca on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:18PM
(#28965082)
Various comments here talking about the conversion rate of FB/Goog. But for me personally Spotify is the one way ahead - I get ads for gigs I want to go to, and buy tickets a double-digit percentage of every time they come up. A dreamy business model.
I'd be curious whether the conversion rates on the marketing side back up my gut instinct on the consumer side. Any marketers here with numbers?
Numbers: low nine-figures spent over the last 7 years or so on RTB display and GDN/YT
Outcome:
* Google on display tends to be much higher quality than most major DSP platforms. Incremental ROAS on Google's non-search ads tends to be better, with YouTube being the best performer.
* When you use GDN and YouTube, you are bidding on a much more accurate set of behaviors and first part data in addition to the content matching, which is second to none for large scale.
* One of the better audience types Google gives you access to is search intent. You can target people that have exhibited search behavior that indicates their interest or likelihood to purchase what you have on offer
* Despite these advantages, like any platform Google can also have major quality issues if you do not manage your campaigns well and click fraud can happen easily (thankfully in my experience they're decent at detecting and refunding fraudulent spend)
Edit: I would caution people commenting here to not use their own behavior as examples of how an ad platform is/isn't effective. HN users tend to be significant outliers vs. the general population.
Self-reported behavior is also extremely unreliable, and I would take all their comments with a grain of salt.
1. Self-referencing in my last point refers to gauging your own response to ads as a barometer of their effectiveness.
2. My points above are based on spending at scale globally (over 70 countries) for B2B and B2C products with multiple avenues to monetization
3. The outcome of my experience is based on this data in aggregate but I do not assume that past behavior indicates future success. The market is changing rapidly.
In other words, exactly what the top comment is doing.
Sample size=1. Methods=unknown ("seem 2-4x better")
That said, we could apply the same principle to the parent comment from the marketer. He is using his own behaviour as an example of how the Google ad platform is/isn't effective.
There is a serious lack of transarency in the "open market" system Google is both overseeing and participating in. In the long run, that opacity could spell disaster, so says a former Google lawyer.
This opacity is a problem that seemingly inconsequential litigation like this from the Texas AG is (unintentionally) helping to address. Discovery helps us understand what Google wants to hide from the public.
Move away from the big-boy ad networks (The likes of Microsoft, Google, Facebook), and there's a long tail of networks that will happily run the worst ads. Unsurprisingly, a lot of legitimate companies aren't super-keen on having their ads run next to ones for fake download buttons and penis enlargement pills.
Some ads are legitimately quite useful, others just abusive, lots in between.
I worked in the newspaper industry on the web side for many years. Remnant ads are the worst. These are the ad networks that you use to fill up the last of your ad spots that you weren't able to sell directly. They can fill volumes of ad spots for pennies per 1000 ad impressions. These are pure trash. Ignoring the common problems with actual virus payloads that they might try to inject, these are the most obnoxious, awful ads. They often have big animations with flashing background and jarring colors. They are full of click-bait titles. They are the reason people install ad blockers. I might not be able to tell you what a quality ad looks like, but I can tell you the other end of the spectrum, and it is pure filth.
Making sure clicks are real is a massive challenge with many ads networks. There are a lot of tools that help in sure spambots aren’t stealing all the ad money but they also slow down serving of the ads and sometimes they mess up and block things that shouldn’t.
We’ve had campaigns where we had to allow more spambots simply because the client couldn’t spend enough money, they were willing to waste more to get better reach.
But most clients absolutely love the results when you have really good filters in place. Very low spend and good lead generation.
For an advertiser side, one possible, measurable metric is advertiser value per spending money. Value can be defined by advertisers pretty arbitrarily but you can think it as something like how much money you earn from ad conversions. Of course, this is very hard to measure accurately, massive ad network like Google has some advantages though.
But note that this is just one of possible metrics, there are hundreds of metrics ad networks want to improve and some of them are conflicting each other by definition. And some of them don't even have an objective way to measure so still depending on user study.
Compare to most small news sites, that have top/bottom banners, inline ads and the curtains.... I hate the curtains!
Add to this how little time I use on Facebook vs Google properties and how I used to love Google and despise Facebook it becomes even worse.
Maybe Google just failed spectacularly for a decade and everyone else had fantastic experience but I doubt it.
It's amazing their incredibly terrible advertising actually funds a huge breadth of services. Marketing departments really are that dumb I guess
Facebook has the best direct response ROI (e.g. a donation, a volunteer, a tracked conversion to voting).
I used to be able to get > 100% ROI immediately but with iOS changes it's becoming hard to impossible. I think FB will become more of a brand ad and loose a lot of app install or direct to consumer business.
Those are what most people consider relevant, for instance i get a ton of athletic shorts ads after I hover on one (usually because they use sexy images lol...).
Google has great DR ROI for search, though if your website is already #1 is that valuable? Big brands have to pay so their competitor doesn't get the slot though.
Google video, e.g. YouTube is very high quality and low CPMs compared to say Hulu and FB video 'view optimization' sucks like they count a 3 second scroll pass and the total complete watch % are absolutely tiny.
If you spend big (like 10k a day i think) you can access google's surveys which show a good amount of recall.
I've done my own surveys I built mobile survey interstitials and retarget people who watched video ads. Generally see a few point % bump in head to head voting (e.g. vote candidate X over Y) and actually a really high amount of recall candidate names with very few picking the fake spoiler. Again though with iOS this becomes hard/impossible.
Stories ads are valuable to me I love a digital native ad that fits the format.
Open market RTB video is mostly shit. Unless you do a kind of hybrid called a private marketplace deal (and a lot of other acronym buzz stuff) which gets you the high quality inventory but it's just an easier way instead of reaching out to each of the sites individually. Most websites are either auto spam content generation or layer so many auto play videos with sound off you're just wasting money. And they can lie in their bid saying it's a large size or audio on. Have to then spend $ and time on fraud prevention.
Open market desktop display ads (banners) are scraping shit off the floor usually IMHO. And then open market stuff like Taboola or when a website puts a link farm at bottom of page are like rectum licking in the scale of quality, to extend this gross metaphor.
Snap/twitter are interesting but haven't provided a ton of audience/value for me in my campaign audiences. Twitter is cool like targeting specific handles - havent done it in a while maybe not able to anymore with iOS idk. Snap is cool to try and get younger people IMHO.
Mobile interstitials can be valuable. I've built fun 'playable' interactive ads but I don't know of any other campaign or political vendor who has done something that is truly mobile native. They mostly just have static banners.
examples for game install ads they show previews that are playable. I like to think of interactivity that works on mobile to pull a voter into the ad experience. Twitter is selling mopub maybe? That's a higher quality network for this inventory.
Connected TV is great (a bunch of acronyms and definitions/sources, but basically anything steaming to a tv). Though it's insanely expensive during the election because all the TV buyers are fighting to buck viewership trends and selling campaigns equivalency - which is fairly valuable.
all the other corporations in the world are spending more on digital as broadcast TV dies but the incumbents in the political space have too much power and money at stake to follow the eyeballs. Most only spend like 15% on digital which is INSANE to me. A 'good' campaign i've never seen spend more than like 35%... IDK maybe bloomberg got to over 50% which is where it should be if you includ CTV.
TV people usually win because historically the TV vendor is the main consultant of a campaign setting message and direction.
Instead of a digital firm buying/owning as a whole package which I think makes more sense.
How do you measure this with reasonable certainty?
and then they black box tie them to impressions/ad events.
It only works with early voting, where you get a list of voters who have cast or sent in mail ballot each day.
though arguably you're already targeting a tight list in FB of likely early voters (who are likely to vote themselves even without seeing an ad) so who knows if the ad actually got any extra votes in.
You could do an AB test, randomly show ads to only half the audience and measure lift but there are only a couple weeks of early voting usually and relatively small audiences unless you're statewide. I imagine it would work better for Presidential i've never worked on one, kind of a bucket list dream but also would suckkkk for a few years
You can also upload a final voting list after the fact as offline conversions, but doesn't make much difference after the votes are counted though I guess cool stats
this sounds like a good thing for facebook users
Though I do see the point that some apps relying on addicted 'whales' making micro purchases. FB is (or was before iOS started crippling) really great at targeting and optimizing to acquire those best revenue generators no matter if you're getting donations to a non-profit or running an app casino.
As a consumer I certainly wouldn’t think they are 2-4x as useful.
I think their price is based on the fact that they have a near monopoly on search and lock-in with search on android.
But this has nothing to do with search ads. It's about display advertising on 3rd party sites.
Google is the big bad competitor who you're trying to out-compete.
You can't out-compete google without going below it in price. Everyone is desperately trying by charging FAR less.
I just want to note, it doesn't necessarily mean google is overcharging, but that nobody can enter a well established market by charging more and providing no other real value.
I thought these advertisers paid per-click, so in some sense Google and any competitor are fungible. Do people really care where their ads are shown so long as people click on them? Are the competitors placing ads in those crappy web sites that encourage accidental clicks?
Of course they care. They pay per click, so they want the ads well-targeted so they have a high conversion rate, otherwise it's wasted money. Some ad networks literally scam businesses by placing ads everywhere so they get clicked on accidentally but of course this does nothing for conversion.
Perhaps temporarily, but search has been stagnant for 5-10 years.
Alternative smartphone app stores charges way less than 25-50% of Google or Apple. You need to compare electronic markets with electronic markets like this, and the big players tend to take out extremely high fees in those areas.
Although, I agree that charging high fees in these areas is a problem and should be fixed, but it isn't like this sort of thing is uncommon.
Edit: As an example, Apple takes 30% cut. A competitor taking 7.5% cut would cost 25% of Apples app store.
I guess those various people need to prove that they are needed so they make changes for the sake of doing something.. and quality of the product declines.
You're the person seeing the ad, but you're not party to the transaction.
Websites often run an auction at request time. The ad networks are actually competing, even if you get targeted by Google exclusively, personally.
A bit part of US antitrust law is harm to customer. And higher prices is a harm to customers.
I assume the argument is something like “Google is monopolizing search and charging higher prices as a result”
situation: A has 0% take rate, B has 1% => "B charges infinitely more than A"
Perhaps better in that case would be just stating the facts "A takes 0%, B takes 1%" or "A leaves you 100% , B leaves 99%".
The point is, from a consumer pov the take rate actually doesn't matter as much as the opposite, the "keep rate". And just adding in multipliers is so easily exploitable.
Not defending google, just as written the implied math has multiple interpretations, some okay some bad.
If I understand this correctly, this is about auctions/exchanges (middlemen which have little to do with ad targeting and quality), not ROI, as some commenters have suggested.
Correct me if I’m wrong, my adtech knowledge is limited.
Assuming people who dont know how ads industry works all they see is an article about an evil monopoly over charging.
While it might be hard to break up any given monopoly that offers "free" products with existing laws, this is the avenue that is straightforward.
(I don’t use the products and I’m sure the names have changed, but dv360/dcm, whatever they call their exchange, and dfp)
I’ll leave the morality/legality/etc of as an exercise for the reader.
I think there are much more compelling arguments around regulating Google.
I'm not capable of running a mile in 4minutes, that's not unfair for me to loose to someone that trained hard to be able to run that mile in 4 minutes.
WSJ charges two to four times as much as my local paper.
I believe Microsoft still operates a large ad network.
Taboola is everywhere.
Amazon has a huge ad network as well, ~14B in revenue, though obviously limited in terms of what is advertised.
Verizon Media also apparently operates a sizable ad network.
https://newscorp.com/2017/12/05/news-corp-launches-news-iq/
(from putlake's comment above)
That's most of the bigger players, but there are hundreds. Many aren't worth the time, and are spun up when one rep takes some budget from a large brand and does "Direct" deals and tries to start their own shop with "Guaranteed CPMs". It's all bullshit
It's not a complex business to start, you know.