I thought these advertisers paid per-click, so in some sense Google and any competitor are fungible. Do people really care where their ads are shown so long as people click on them? Are the competitors placing ads in those crappy web sites that encourage accidental clicks?
Of course they care. They pay per click, so they want the ads well-targeted so they have a high conversion rate, otherwise it's wasted money. Some ad networks literally scam businesses by placing ads everywhere so they get clicked on accidentally but of course this does nothing for conversion.
Perhaps temporarily, but search has been stagnant for 5-10 years.
Alternative smartphone app stores charges way less than 25-50% of Google or Apple. You need to compare electronic markets with electronic markets like this, and the big players tend to take out extremely high fees in those areas.
Although, I agree that charging high fees in these areas is a problem and should be fixed, but it isn't like this sort of thing is uncommon.
Edit: As an example, Apple takes 30% cut. A competitor taking 7.5% cut would cost 25% of Apples app store.
I guess those various people need to prove that they are needed so they make changes for the sake of doing something.. and quality of the product declines.
Google is the big bad competitor who you're trying to out-compete.
You can't out-compete google without going below it in price. Everyone is desperately trying by charging FAR less.
I just want to note, it doesn't necessarily mean google is overcharging, but that nobody can enter a well established market by charging more and providing no other real value.