Allowing college students with an out of state drivers license to vote with their college ID guarantees them TWO votes- because they can legally file a mail in vote to the state they have that driver's license in.
Some hunting licenses require residence in the state that issues them. For those that do, provided they have a photo or something similar, there is no reason to not accept them. Odds are though, if you have a hunting license, you also have a driver's license.
Voter ID generally isn't supposed to be proof of residence, its proof of identity; it exists to prove that the voter is the person registered, not that the registered person is authorized to vote.
Most IDs acceptable for voting do not prove authorization (or even “authorization but for the potential of disqualification by felony”), so not accepting college ID because it doesn't prove authorization to vote is...not well justified, even in the public logic of voter ID.
Of course, voter ID proponents have let out the private partisan internal logic lots of times when they thought only people aligned with their faction were listening, so we don't need to speculate why the rules are inconsistent with the public logic.
1. a citizen with the legal right to vote
2. a resident of the district the vote is cast in
My dad moved around a lot (Air Force) and I learned from him that to avoid trouble with the state tax people,
1. register to vote
2. get a driver's license
3. vote
to establish a residency for tax purposes. Otherwise, you can get dinged for taxes from multiple states.
Proving residency again on election day is just a pointless hoop for voters to jump through. That will have already have been taken care of.
These are all significant factors in a tax residency analysis but not the only ones.
If you find yourself facing a question over tax residency, factors like where you spent your time, where you have residences, where your job is located, where your service providers (doctors, lawyers, etc.) are all
For example, if you rent an apartment, have a driver's license and are registered to vote in Nevada, but you own a large house in California, spend most of the year there, and your most substantial professional and personal dealings are in California, good luck defending your Nevada tax residency claim if the FTB comes knocking.
Super convenient if you would like to vote a few dozen times in different places, I'm sure, but that's not what it's "supposed to be" at all. I want people voting exactly once, and _only_ where they are residents, and _only_ if they are US citizens. That's the law.
It's not hard to imagine how a rural university or large manufacturing facility could sway things in state level elections if a ton of people went across the street to vote on lunch break rather then went home and voted at home after work/school thereby changing what district they vote in.
Some databases also include Canadian provinces.
You have to prove residency (electric bill or something) and they invalidate your former driver’s license so you can’t do something like just hop across the border and get a new license because you lost your last one for whatever reason.
People sign when they vote and signatures can be matched against registrations. When we examine this, we don't find a large number of people performing voter impersonation.
But since voting records are public, this would be trivially detectable.
People voting multiple times isn't really a risk, because it's incredibly stupid. It's a felony, so if you get caught, you go to jail. But if you get away with it, you've flipped one vote, and even a very close election isn't going to be settled by a couple of votes.
There were a very small handful of people who got caught voting twice in the 2020 election, or casting someone else's ballot: two or three in Georgia and in Pennsylvania. Most voted twice for Trump.
Slightly tangential, but you are required by law to get a new license when you move to a new state. And the DMV will take your old license when they give you the new one. You can move around within a state and have a stale address on your license pretty easily, though.
Can you give a good source or two please?
Senator Rand Paul: https://talkingpointsmemo.com/news/rand-paul-voter-georgia-r...
Chairman of Arizona Govt and Elections Committee: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/everybody-shouldnt-b...
etc etc, this is just what immediately came up in the last year. Among "the right sorts" they'll occasionally get complacent admit it's all about partisan advantage and not actually about fraud at all.
The Chairman of the Arizona's Gov't and Elections Committee is simply expressing what has been a common conservative sentiment for ages--that voting is a responsibility, not just a privilege, and one that shouldn't be exercised lightly. Rand Paul, at least if we're being charitable, is making the same argument.
None of those sentiments are inherently discriminatory, neither conceptually nor in practice, which is fundamentally what matters. The belief that the government should actively "Get Out the Vote" is a policy preference, not a constitutional imperative--at least not in the U.S., which lacks mandatory voting laws. "Get Out the Vote" is just a pithy statement of one's preferred policy.
Though, without rigorous oversight it's quite easy--almost trivial, even--to apply those sentiments in a discriminatory manner. AFAIU, Thomas Hofeller, the infamous Republican strategist and redistricting consultant whose personal papers were revealed by his daughter after his death, approached voter ID laws this way--drafting them in ways that were inherently, knowingly, deliberately discriminatory, supported by reams of empirical data, though I'm not sure if racially or otherwise illegally discriminatory on their face. Some of his gerrymandering proposals, by contrast, were explicitly racially discriminatory. ("Hofeller's hard drive also retained a map of North Carolina’s 2017 state judicial gerrymander, with an overlay of the black voting-age population by district, suggesting that these maps—which are currently at the center of a protracted legal battle—might also be a racial gerrymander.", https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-secret-files-of...)
Really all the address proves is that I was able to get mail at this address when I got my license.
A bit of an aside, when I moved to California I wasn't able to vote in the primaries because I refused to pledge loyalty to the Democratic party, though registering to vote was rather easy. In Texas registering was rather easy and I could vote in primaries.
That would be sad, because local governments are the ones that pass ordinances criminalizing homelessness (e.g. sleeping and urinating outside). I think it would be unconscionable to prevent people from having a voice in their governance based on their landownership status, but I guess we can hardly call such an idea out of line with America’s founding values.
When I came to California it was kind of funny that I was able to vote in local elections immediately. I hardly knew anything about the area, what could I possibly vote for?
I still don't get why people think they are entitled to participate in party-internal candidate selection elections without even claiming membership (with absolutely zero commitment ot pledge of loyalty of any kind) in the party.
(There are primary elections that serve different functions than selecting party nominees, often simultaneously with party primaries, and you've always been able to vote in them in California without identifying with a party; California has extended the scope of them and gotten rid of most party primaries, though the Presidential primary is still a closed party primary.)
[1] https://www.sos.ca.gov/elections/primary-elections-californi...
[2] https://www.sos.ca.gov/elections/political-parties/no-party-...
But it's okay, because they just need to "fix their own problems first" as you put it in such a blasé fashion.
When I was working as an archaeologist, I often lacked a residential address. I had a stable job, supported local communities, and generally met residency requirements, but establishing that in the normal ways was impossible. I've also had at least one ballot rejected as a result of similar clerical issues.
It's often helpful to be a bit more open-minded about how different other people's lives can be to your own.
Homelessness is a state, not a capability. The majority of homeless people exist in this state only temporarily (eg, victims of domestic violence who flee their abusers)
A static document doesn't prove current residence. And someone can reside in more than 1 state. They just have to pick 1 for taxes and voting.
I’m aware of no state in the country that mandates a driver’s license for all residents. It would really defeat the purpose of a driver’s license! Only residents _who drive on public roads_ are required to obtain a license. That’s absolutely not the entire population.
> guarantees them two votes
This is an absolutely inaccurate claim. They are not _guaranteed_ two votes, because no one is offering such a guarantee. And no one offers such a guarantee, because voting in the same election in two different states is illegal, and is fairly trivial to catch, since who voted in which elections are public records in most (all?) states.
Registering to vote in two states is a really easy way to end up in jail.
Isn't that an (easily detectable) felony?
We just went through a 6 months long audit of the results in Arizona’s Maricopa county. The auditors there claimed massive fraud that would have flipped the election occurred. After much fanfare for months, they quietly packed up shop and did everything they could to avoid mentioning their conclusions were that the results of the previous audit were upheld.
I’ve been hearing about the voter id debate since I was in high school decades ago, and still no evidence this behavior is occurring. It’s well enough to conjecture this thing might be occurring, but eventually after decades you need to put up the evidence.
Often they are even lawmakers! Pro tip never get high on your own supply, there, chief. But I get that state legislatures are cowtown nobodies and yeah they often actually are dumb enough to believe the prolefeed.
https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/559812-ohio-republi...
https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/crime-and-court...
https://www.dailylocal.com/2021/01/14/chester-county-man-fac...
https://www.azmirror.com/2021/07/13/vote-fraud-scottsdale-wo...
https://www.newsweek.com/man-charged-voting-dead-mother-trum...
https://madison.com/wsj/news/local/govt-and-politics/fraud-c...
Whether you voted is public record, and literally anyone can pull death records as well, and compare the two. Mostly not a match, but every now and then it turns up a few republicans who thought they'd "even the score" since "it's so easy to get away with".
The fact that MA will conscript nonresidents for jury duty is morally wrong, but besides the point.
If you want to drive in that state. Seems odd to require a drivers license to vote if you live on a college campus where everything is in walking distance.
Things become a whole lot simpler when stuff can just get tacked on to your ID, and appropriate institutions can check the status of such endorsements in a central database.
> In theory, this should make both sides happy.
One side will never be happy, because their entire strategy (according to leaked internal documents) is voter suppression.
A reminder: there is very, very little voter fraud in the US. Most of cases of fraud that have been discovered turned out to be members of that side that is so very concerned with voter fraud.
I am all for a national ID (please, PLEASE end using Social Security for this), and migrating to a national standard for driving that generalizes most of the 'how to drive' and 'how signs must look'; ideally also some minimum of how roads should be designed (less enforced, more of a guide).
This is really key here. Practice shows 2 things: (1) a national ID is needed to operate the United States and (2) in lieu of a proper system, a much worse system is being used with ongoing catastrophic impacts to people's lives from fraud and identity theft as well as the commensurate cost to the state at every level.
Why does it get bipartisan support in Oregon, a state known for intense partisan demonstrations and showdowns? Because it’s so much easier that you’ll never want to do it another way.
Mail-in voting has a lot of benefits:
- It’s automatic. You’ll get a ballot every election at your home, so you don’t need to remember about elections.
- You get a pamphlet with statements from each candidate and supporting organizations. This helps you get informed about everyone.
- You have time to send it back. This allows you to make a more deliberate choice.
- You don’t have to take time off or go anywhere.
- You can verify via a web portal that your ballot was received and counted.
Is voter ID actually solving any real problems with the system? To my knowledge, fraud is normally sniffed out and prosecuted. I think a well-oiled mail voting system provides so many clear benefits to voters that we should be encouraging it in more places.
From what I understand, signature-based validation is secure enough to prevent most fraud problems. At least to the extent that it’s not much different from any other voting system.
Again, I support federal ID, but to me that’s separate from voting. Maybe I put my federal ID number on the ballot, and then states can ensure it was only used once.
Adding things to the FEC responsibility is not a solution, because the FEC is by structural design nonfunctional in normal conditions, and has sometimes been (e.g., most of 2020) completely nonfunctional due to lack of a quorum.
Rumors are the mob delivered the election for Kennedy; even those historians who argue otherwise essentially characterize it as the democratic party stealing the election "An order from the mob to work for Kennedy only insured a total Chicago effort of the kind that historically had been known to work miracles in the early-morning hours of vote counting"
Lyndon Johnson famously stole his 1948 senate election
Democrats were plenty happy to use vote harvesting to take Orange County, Ca while arguing against it in Georgia (2018).
[ed] And a new one just hitting news today, https://www.phillymag.com/news/2021/10/13/marie-beren-voter-...
I would respectfully disagree with your assertion this is a one party issue
I think you mean paid for by taxes and/or insurance, not quite the same as free
and in case this isn't obvious. it's always bad no matter who is doing it. i just think its ridiculously stupid to suggest that only 1 group would do it and the other wouldn't given the opportunity.
If things shift the other way and democrats start suppressing the vote I'll be just as outraged at them - regardless of whether "my guy is winning" or not.
i think we almost entirely agree with each other.
And, in America at least, these voter restrictions have always historically minimized the black vote. So I do think there is one group that has been consistently quite happy with voting limitations - they aren't the republican party, but they currently find refuge under its wings.
1. This last election has been (IMO fairly) decried as a waste of taxpayer money and a move that endangered the public simply to strengthen Liberal dominance (even if it failed hilariously).
The Civil Rights Act of 1964 did not pass along party lines.
More Democrats voted to pass it than Republicans by numbers. Republicans only had 33% of the House and about 33% of the Senate.
Now, Republicans did have a larger percentage of their members voting for.
But when you split it by region, the picture comes clear. The old Union voted overwhelmingly to pass the act while the old Confederacy voted Nay.
Northern Democrats outvoted all other groups by percentage and numbers for the act. And not a single (of the 12) Southern Republican voted for.
So yeah, miss me with that "Democrats are the party of the Confederacy" stuff. The South was the party of the Confederacy.
-- Bill Moyers in his book Moyers on America on LBJ following the signing of the 1964 Civil Rights Bill...
"These Ne**es, they're getting pretty uppity these days and that's a problem for us since they've got something now they never had before, the political pull to back up their uppityness. Now we've got to do something about this, we've got to give them a little something, just enough to quiet them down, not enough to make a difference... I'll have them ni**rs voting Democratic for the next two hundred years."
Like: literally yes, please, actually do something that will make me want to vote for you for a generation. Unironically. I'm 100% serious. That's what you're supposed to be doing.
And yeah, sure, politicians dole it out slowly so they don't have to do too much, that's not really a revelation either.
That depends on what you mean by “group”; its the same ideological faction, attached to the same historical narrative and much of the same factional symbology.
They are largely associated with a different political party than in, say, the late 19th and early 20th century, due to a long period (or two overlapping periods) of partisan realignment between the 1930s and 1990s, in which they were marginalized within one party and then courted by the other.
Probably comes with being one of the most rural states in the country, but also with major population centers nearby.
Would love to move there someday tbh.
I don’t think this is true at all.
You'll find that the right opposes this idea. National IDs spook the "don't tread on me" crowd and cutting DMV availability is a common "money saving" approach taken by the same people demanding additional documentation for voting.
And make sure those remaining offices are nowhere near any bus lines, so if someone does not have a car they either have to take an expensive cab ride or spend a lot of time walking when they go to get their ID. And make sure that IDs are only issued during work hours in midweek so you can't get your ID on a weekend--which means many minimum wage workers will have to lose a day's pay to get their ID.
And once people do have whatever ID you require, there are still ways to make it harder for the "wrong" group to vote.
• Restrict absentee/mail-in voting so people have to show up in person, but also greatly reduce the number of polling places in areas with too many of the "wrong" group.
• Make it illegal to provide food or water to people waiting in line to vote.
The first can result in polling places where people have to stand in line for several hours to get their turn to vote, and can only drink whatever water they happened to bring with them. Of course they could leave the line to go get water, but then might lose their place and have to start all over.
[1] https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-...
[2] https://amp.theguardian.com/politics/2021/jul/04/millions-in...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_identification_laws
Reading that quite short list, it seems like Australia, Canada, UK and the US are the only ones which do not require IDs. I wonder if it has something to do with old British legal system, that they kind off share.
If the would be voter doesn't have ID, then someone who knows them has to make a sworn affidavit that the voter is who they claim to be.
Thats not the same thing as we have in the US
EDIT: Note, in particular, that a utility bill (e.g. a gas bill as mentioned in an ancestor comment) is sufficient in Ontario. For the purposes of this comment thread, this would fall into the (allegedly) laughable situation of lacking voter ID.
[1] https://www.elections.on.ca/en/voting-in-ontario/id-requirem...
Unfortunately, federally assigned IDs are a weirdly hot-button issue in America. Whether it's the libertarian insistence that national ID leads to authoritarianism[1], or the evangelical strain that sees it as a potential Mark of the Beast[2].
[1] https://www.cato.org/commentary/you-value-privacy-resist-any...
[2] https://www.huffpost.com/entry/the-national-biometric-id_b_5...
In Canada, my grandmother didn't need any "ID" to vote, period. All she needed was for me, who had acceptable ID to vouch that she was an eligible voter, voting in a riding that she was eligible to vote in.
Somehow, the country has not yet devolved into an orgy of lawlessness.
Thats not what they have in the US. I can literally come up with a common name, say Ben Levi, and vote on Ben’s behalf. If Ben decides to show up, he’s in trouble, not me.
In Canada you are typically required ID. If you lied about your grandma and the real Ms. vkou shows up to vote, she’ll have ID proving who she is, and Elections Canada has your name written down to throw you in jail for lying under oath.
I’m joking of course, a hunting license isn’t a form of ID. Curiously, my CHL isn’t a form of ID, even though it is state issued, has my pic, and I had to be finger printed to get it.
There is, of course, no bias in the types of people that have one but not the other.
In terms of rigor of identity authentication: CHL > Driver's license.
But at the state level you will need much more. We are talking 12 years of transcripts and a high school diploma. Vaccination records going back to birth. Income information (paystubs, bank accounts) on you and your family so they can verify your ability to pay tuition or qualify for aid. In order to qualify you’ll need to undergo background checks (felons are not eligible for aid). Then you need letter of reference from at least 3 individuals and your HS guidance counselor. Finally, you will need official SAT test scores, and the college board does their own process of identity verification.
Is the process perfect? No. But if you were looking for a vector for fraud, student IDs are probably one of the most onerous.
In a free and fair election, the right to vote is not be based on your detailed personal history, or whether you have done something that looks off and might cause you trouble with authorities.
Even if it's just fear of imagined trouble that puts people off feeling safe to obtain the necessary approvals to vote, that's enough to prevent a free and fair election.
All I am saying is we have a good idea that the person with a CCL is that person and they are not a felon (in some states felons cannot vote).
Anybody can go to a community college including a noncitizen. There is no background check and no real verification the person is who they say they are. You just show up and have your picture taken.
If you are going to trust one of these forms of IDs it is clear that it should be the CCL.
What I meant is we know the person is who they say they are when they have a CCL. This means if a noncitizen has a CCL they would be unable to use this as proof they are a citizen.
If a noncitizen goes to a university they could claim they are somebody other than who they are and could use the fake ID as proof to vote. Since there are no background checks to get a university ID it isn't really proof of anything.
But I think student IDs do undergo a pretty significant verification. They are going to at least need transcripts and some other ID card like a driver’s license to prove your id. They do background checks as a matter of course for funding. Community colleges do verify residency to determine which tuition rate you pay. 99% of the students most community colleges are state residents anyway. They could have just made a requirement that state funded schools must display residency information and an expiration date in the card, and there would be no problem.
Honestly I think the best solution is to just give a free ID to everyone. As far as I know every state that requires an ID for voting has free IDs. We should make it easier and more convenient instead of allowing a bunch of alternative forms of ID. Driver's license, voter ID license, generic state ID or federal ID (passport) should be sufficient.
Private institutions have a flat tuition rate (although if you are an international student they will verify that you have the financial capability to pay full tuition, since as a non-resident you wouldn't qualify for federal aid, and their tuition rates are set anticipating that you will qualify for federal aid). When there is actual money involved, you can be damn sure that processes are in place to verify you are paying the correct rate. As always when real dollars are at stake, the process is vetted, inspected, and verified at multiple levels. The proof of residence for my local community college was not dissimilar from the DMV. People want to get paid what they're owed.
But again, if there are any concerns about the stringency of this process, they could have been resolved via recently enacted legislation. But they weren't, and that may have been an intentional omission.
Look, I'll agree that student IDs are not up to par with other forms of IDs in terms of the information printed on the actual card, and that maybe some of the processes should be standardized across the state. Just because my local CC is good with these things and has sensible protocols doesn't mean all CCs strive to achieve that standard. There are a lot of CC and state schools out there. But the fact that an entire party has made securing the vote their raison d'être, yet steadfastly refuses to consider students valid voting constituents is strikingly indicative of a bad faith effort.
Undocumented, student visas, etc are banned from buying guns
You're correct, there's no bias on the system for background checks. Anyone of any race, color, or creed can get a background check to verify their eligibility to exercise their right to own/carry firearms and vote.
I agree, and it's in Texas' state law: any legal resident regardless of race, color, or creed can apply for a concealed carry license. It's truly bias free.
How is that different from accepting college IDs because students are more likely to vote for the "right" party? Seems like both options are biased one way or another.
College students are residents. The policies of the local government affect them. Regardless of who they'd vote for, they deserve a say.
If concealed carry licenses are accepted, student IDs should be as well. That's what he's saying.
https://www.ncsl.org/Documents/Elections/The_Canvass_May_201...
What state governments issue a college ID? It’s been a while for me but I don’t recall much evidence required for me to get a college ID and even though I went to a public state university, it definitely was not government issued. Nobody would have accepted it as proof of identity besides the college, certainly not for voting
Form I-9 says school ID card with a photograph is a document that establishes identity.[1] It doesn't say it has to be state issued.
Form W-2 is a wage and tax statement from your employer. What identification is involved?
[1] https://www.uscis.gov/i-9-central/form-i-9-acceptable-docume...
But it points at the ways in which any additional legal hurdle at all can become far more burdensome than lawmakers expect it to even if no one is intentionally trying to make it hard. It's all levels of government plus nature itself all adding new hurdles at the same time.
* prevent college students who live most of the year in-state, and can prove it, but have an out-of-state driver's license, from voting.
* place extra hoops on people whose name doesn't match their birth certificate, make them produce every document with every change and toss their registration if there's a typo (this mainly affects married women, who are more likely to vote for the "wrong" party). This is an effective way to disenfranchise a lot of older women who don't have a current driver's license.
---
Do you have studies/papers/numbers for any of these groups?
I really don't understand why that was not the focus whenever this came up. Not having ID is a huge impediment to constructive participation in society. Need to open a bank account, take out a loan, rent a house, drive a car, fly somewhere, get a job, etc., etc., then you'll almost certainly need ID.
Voting once every now and again of course is important, but to people who genuinely don't have the means to get ID for themselves, I'm sure it's a vanishingly small problem compared to their immediate concerns of surviving day to day.
It's crazy that the outrage is about the ID requirement for voting and so much effort has gone into that, rather than being outraged about people not being able to get ID and the effort going in to making that easier for them.
Generally fixing this issue is done with very time intensive, high-touch non-profit work. States rarely put in the effort to assist the most complicated ID cases.
There are lots of old people in the Mississippi Delta who never got birth certificates and who can’t use the most common documents to prove citizenship/ eligibility to vote. IIRC they can try to petition a judge / court, but it is a big hurdle, especially for people who are not highly motivated to vote and are people who don’t drive. Some people are left behind, but I can’t find good stats/estimates of how many are affected.
Certainly not the loudest, party leaders, media, etc who have been telling us the problems they will have if voting required ID for years and years. Pretty terrible that they have been aware of this and have done really nothing to help those poor people except when it may affect them getting votes. Really makes you cynical about their motives and selfishness.
I'm sure it's easier said than done, but they're passing trillion dollar budgets, going to war and bombing the brown people in Syria and Libya, bailing out banks that caused housing collapses, etc. They absolutely could solve this problem with a tiny modicum of effort in comparison.
The really sad thing now with results like this is that they're likely to just stop caring about the problem entirely and forget these people if it doesn't actually affect their vote.
> It’s hard and expensive.
Again, I don't think it is relative to what else gets spent and what else gets done. Social services spending on a state and federal level is just gargantuan and increasing so I don't see quite where your last sentence connects to reality.
https://madison.com/lifestyles/the-us-states-spending-the-mo...
Your link shows that a lot of money is being spent, but not nearly enough, or perhaps in the wrong places. The ~$3000 per capita spending numbers are laughably small. People on average are going to use more than that per year. So the question is: how is that money actually distributed? Who is getting more than they need, because plenty are going without enough. Social programs are famously not very well funded, so your argument that social welfare programs are swimming in "gargantuan" levels of cash doesn't ring true to me, and the numbers you show bear that out. Like I said, expect people (like yourself) to balk at requests to increase funding in social programs. Usually the number one response I will get from legislators is that the already spend enough as is, why do they need to spend more?
My wife was a social worker for a number of years, so I got to see how "social welfare" is actually spent. From what I witnessed inside the social work industrial complex, a number of corporations have sprung up that work to milk this government money without ever actually helping anyone in the process. They will hire social workers to visit people in need of crisis management or some other social service, but essentially their job is to just fill out reams and reams of paperwork leaving no time to actually help anyone. The corporation gets a huge stack of state dollars, the social worker gets a mere $14.00 for their hour, and the person in need is left wanting and in need. It's a difficult system to change because there are entrenched interests now dependent on the revenue stream. If you want in on that money, you're going to need the same lobbying power as these corporations.
I wasn't saying nobody does, I'm sure some under appreciated and under resourced groups who actually want to make things better for these poor people are doing great, difficult work and care deeply about the issue.
That does not include any federal or state politician of note though, nor any media corporation or their journalists, or any other "activists" or twitter trolls who only pretend to care about it when voter ID comes up.
I'm not sure if my rhetoric wasn't quite clear -- I did not mean to imply that literally nobody cares about getting people ID for reasons other than voting, or has ever once raised the issue until that post I just made.
Honestly if there are people without ID and an inability to acquire one that's a bigger issue because of the many things you can't do without an ID voting is pretty low on the list.
I mean, yeah, you don't have to be a resident of the state or even a citizen to go to a university in the US.
Doesn't matter if you're a resident of the state. https://help.vote.org/article/17-i-am-a-college-student-shou...
> The choice is legally yours. You have dual residency, so you can register back home or on campus as long as you don't register to vote in both states. You can use our Voter Registration Tool to register to vote in less than 2 minutes.
This is the exact reason that issuing indistinguishable driver's licenses to non-citizens was controversial.
> Doesn't matter if you're a resident of the state.
The point is that maybe it should. It's reasonable to say that people should vote in the place where they're a permanent resident and not somewhere they're likely not going to reside by the end of the term of office for the election in question.
It's not as if they can't vote, they can vote where they're actually from. Or demonstrate the intent to move to the state where they want to vote by getting a state ID there.
That doesn't really have anything to do with voter ID at the polls, because the point of voter ID at the polls is not to prove that you are eligible to vote. Proof of eligibility should be taken care of when you register to vote.
The point of ID at the polls is to show that you are the person who you claim to be, so that the poll workers can check to see if you are on the registered voter list.
No, it wasn't.
Because nondistinguishable licenses for immigrants had been issued for generations when the controversy, which was about licenses issued to people without valid immigration status, erupted.
A lot more US citizens have a driver's license than a passport. It's the most common form of identification and if it doesn't specify citizenship then there will be millions of people who don't have any picture ID that can prove their citizenship status.
That problem could easily be solved by specifying whether you're a citizen on your driver's license. It's a poor excuse to extend the problem to other forms of ID that don't prove citizenship status.
No, I don't. Because there is no reasonable on topic argument you could be getting at.
> A lot more US citizens have a driver's license than a passport. It's the most common form of identification and if it doesn't specify citizenship then there will be millions of people who don't have any picture ID that can prove their citizenship status.
Which is fine in the context of voter ID, because presenting ID to vote is notionally to confirm that the person presenting to vote is the person registered (authentication), not that the person registered is allowed to vote (authorization).
Authorization of registered voters and removal/disqualification of unauthorized voters is, even in Voter ID systems and proposals, handled separately from voter ID, typically by the same kind of processes used without voter ID.
I don't think it's ever been controversial to permit permanent residents to have drivers' licenses.
34 states require a birth certificate or proof of legal residency.
16 states do not require the above, but that does not mean that no identification at all is required.
A driver's license proves state residency (one of the requirements needed to vote), a student ID does not.
Neither a school ID nor a drivers’ license says anything about citizenship. They’re the same in that regard.
That's not what that says. Students can proclaim residency in the state they are attending school, yes. That also means in Texas you have 30 days to register your car, 90 days to change over to a Texas driver's license, etc.
>Neither a school ID nor a drivers’ license says anything about citizenship. They’re the same in that regard.
We're not talking about citizenship, we're talking about residency. A student ID does not prove state residency, so it does not past muster whatsoever. Texas has legal explanation covering this specific scenario: https://www.sos.state.tx.us/elections/elo/gsc1.pdf
I'll state it again: a student ID does not prove residency.
The comment upthread I initially replied to stated student IDs aren't appropriate because they don't demonstrate citizenship; I pointed out neither does a drivers' license.
The appropriate time to look at residency/citizenship is at the voter registration step. This is already done!
Except student IDs don't even do that. They prove your student status, not state resident identity. That's why you can't use student IDs to buy alcohol, board a plane, or purchase a firearm. Voting and buying guns are both constitutionally guaranteed rights. Are you OK with people buying guns with student IDs? If you are, at least you're being consistent.
Many student IDs are not even issued by the states (private schools). Also, there are hundreds of schools per state, being a student at Piney Woods Community College isn't easily verifiable if it's even in the state.
>The comment upthread I initially replied to stated student IDs aren't appropriate because they don't demonstrate citizenship
Nor do they demonstrate residency, nor are they valid for a number of other rights and privileges so it holds that they're not accepted.
>I pointed out neither does a drivers' license.
Which is true, but not what I stated above.
>The appropriate time to look at residency/citizenship is at the voter registration step. This is already done!
Some states have same day registration so it is not already done. Nonetheless, a student ID is a poor ID for exercising a person's right to vote.
I can hear leftists screeching from here over this proposal. That's exactly what Republicans want... Now student IDs can't be issued to illegal immigrants, need the same verifications required for DLs, which is White supremacy or something.
> school in most cases already knows this information because they need it to verify the tuition rate for which a student qualifies.
Which is hilariously inaccurate. I knew many students who feigned residency to save themselves tens of thousands.
>But GOP-run state legislatures didn’t do this and the reason why seems obvious given the public intonations coming from these individuals.
Because it was shot down by Democrats. Republicans just want to bring the US to the 21st century and match what the rest of the first-world countries are doing. Anything else is regressive.
Nonetheless, as far as Texas is concerned, students can get a free voter ID that qualifies, so the student ID point is moot.
I am a leftist. I see nothing wrong with this proposal (I mean, I proposed it, right?). Illegal immigrants going to CC wishing to pay resident rates will have to prove their residency just like everyone else, as is the current situation. I don't see an issue with that. Do you? It seems to me maybe you have a caricature of leftists in your mind if you think this proposal would have leftists screeching.
> I knew many students who feigned residency to save themselves tens of thousands.
Which is fraud and can be detected and caught easily. If legislatures wanted to fortify the requirements to make them more uniform across counties they could have. They didn't. And it's telling.
> Because it was shot down by Democrats.
Shot down? The bills that were passed were written and supported by Republican legislatures and signed into law by Republican governors. Democrats didn't have a say over anything. Republicans could have passed anything they wanted and Democrats were and are powerless to "shoot" anything down. Not sure how it's cogent to bring up minority opposition here.
> Nonetheless, as far as Texas is concerned, students can get a free voter ID that qualifies, so the student ID point is moot.
You mean free as long as their time is worthless, right? Because they already have an ID that should qualify, but doesn't because of "reasons". Where those reasons are vague and unsupported by fact and evidence. After all, we have no evidence so far to support the idea that students are committing widespread voter fraud. Republicans can't seem prove such a thing is happening despite decades of searching for it (gee, maybe because it's not happening).
We know.
>I see nothing wrong with this proposal (I mean, I proposed it, right?).
No problem with denying illegal immigrants student IDs because they have to be at the same standards required for other voting IDs? Awesome, glad we agree.
>Illegal immigrants going to CC wishing to pay resident rates will have to prove their residency just like everyone else, as is the current situation.
Correct, except now they'll have to prove lawful presence, and residency if they are to be the same standard as other voter IDs. They can't prove lawful presence because they immigrated illegally, so my point stands.
>I don't see an issue with that. Do you?
Not at all! Tax money for citizens and legal immigrants should absolutely not go to illegal immigrants. No issues here, glad we agree.
>Which is fraud and can be detected and caught easily.
Apparently not. There are hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants defrauding the government by using other's social security numbers, etc. and it's been tough to stop it.
>If legislatures wanted to fortify the requirements to make them more uniform across counties they could have. They didn't. And it's telling.
They did... What are you talking about? This is a state standard that is the same across all counties. It's telling that you have absolutely no clue here.
>Shot down?
Yes, national IDs, voter ID laws are continuously shot down by Democrats, or are tampered in committees etc.
>You mean free as long as their time is worthless, right?
Just like voting, buying a gun, etc. It's not 100% free in time to exercise your rights.
>Because they already have an ID that should qualify,
Except they don't, as I have laid out above. Student IDs are not valid practically anywhere for identification such as airplanes, bars, buying alcohol, purchasing firearms, etc.
>but doesn't because of "reasons"
Yes, "reasons", also known as "uncomfortable facts that go against the narrative."
>Where those reasons are vague and unsupported by fact and evidence.
Those reasons are well defined and support by facts, logic, and evidence.
>After all, we have no evidence so far to support the idea that students are committing widespread voter fraud.
Thankfully because they're not allowed to use their student IDs, glad we're treating them like normal citizens.
>Republicans can't seem prove such a thing is happening despite decades of searching for it (gee, maybe because it's not happening).
Cool, same how there haven't been illegal weapons purchases with student IDs because they're not allowed for that either. Glad the Republicans are being consistent.
The state already knows John Jones, born 1st January 1970, is eligible to vote - I merely have to prove that I am John Jones, born 1st January 1970.
It actually does not know this. This is a very hard problem to solve in the US. There can be positive evidence of this (John Jones has been a resident of California since birth, has a birth certificate (state document) and a Social Security (federal) number reflecting that), but John Jones may have been born in PA with no Social Security number or birth certificate at all and be a current resident of California, having moved there last year, and a perfectly legitimate US citizen eligible to vote in California for local, state, and federal offices.
There is no national US citizen registry, mostly for historical reasons, and making one is a total political nonstarter. Further, states are individually responsible for determining if someone is probably an eligible voter, and so there’s different processes and checks in place depending on the state.
It's more fundamental than that: states are individually responsible for determining who the eligible voters are. There are variations from state to state as to the terms of residency in the state, whether felons or people who have been declared mentally incapacitated [0].
That, among other things, causes a substantial difficulty in attempts to (say) conform presidential elections to the national popular vote outcome; one of the functions of the electoral college is to (mostly in a very nonlinear binary fashion) normalize the results by state to the total population rather than simply the enfranchised population (hence the 3/5ths rule being a compromise between "count the slaves" and "don't count the slaves" in the weighting process).
Here are the voter registration requirements in New Hampshire, to pick a state out at random, for example: https://sos.nh.gov/media/nbhlz4bt/registering-to-vote-in-new...
You can literal simply pinky swear and sign a document in front of an election official at your voting place and time that you are an eligible voter to register, and then go vote. They have no practical way of truly verifying what you say in most cases. There are legitimate edge cases that need this, so that’s why things work this way.
For most taxpayers, that's the SSN, and its widely used for other purposes.
Republicans mostly seem to have a problem when people point out that their incompetence is causing them to leak publicly, e.g., https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28867562
[1] https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/taxp...
You go to vote. They check ID to determine whether the person standing there is who they claim to be. Then they check the voter registration rolls to see if that person is eligible to vote.
Have you ever tried to buy beer with a school ID? There is a reason they aren't accepted as a government issue legal ID.
The US federal government and at least some states accept school ID to verify identity.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/22/us/politics/filibuster-vo...
https://www.texastribune.org/2021/08/30/texas-voting-restric...
Your comment reads like it's either from someone not really familiar with US politics, or someone who is being deliberately dishonest.
I'm a limey Brit, so I'm honestly asking...
Second, he never said either party was the underdog.
He just outlined how voter ID laws can only be a first step to disenfranchise voters.
Examples of ways to put your thumb on the scale:
* refuse to accept college IDs as valid for voting, even those issued by the state government because it's a state school (college students are more likely to vote for the "wrong" party). Hunting licenses? Cool (people with hunting licenses are more likely to vote for the "right" party).
* prevent college students who live most of the year in-state, and can prove it, but have an out-of-state driver's license, from voting.
* place extra hoops on people whose name doesn't match their birth certificate, make them produce every document with every change and toss their registration if there's a typo (this mainly affects married women, who are more likely to vote for the "wrong" party). This is an effective way to disenfranchise a lot of older women who don't have a current driver's license.
* close as many DMV offices as you can in counties where people don't vote your way, restrict the hours on the remaining offices.