Since a few days, I have finished switching over from a Mac Mini (M1), iPhone and Watch to a desktop (with a proper graphics card, unlike the M1), a phone with LineageOS (and microG, so no/little Google) and an Amazfit GTR 2e watch. Apple is missing out on 3-4k in purchases from me in this year alone.
- synology nas to replace iCloud
- XPS 13 (hopefully running Linux, or at worst a heavily locked down Windows 10)
- Pixel 4 with grapheneOS
I’ll be selling my 12 Mini, M1 Mac Mini, Watch 6, and iPad; Apple services subscriptions have already been canceled. Signal seems to be a capable replacement for iMessage so far.
I was really looking forward to the fall hardware announcements, but I’m glad I found out Apple is an untrustworthy actor before I gave them any more $$$
As a data point, make sure you have some kind of backup for that NAS too. Preferably not stored in the same location as the NAS itself (just in case). :)
I'm not gonna sell my iPad or anything, but I have no plans on vaulting into the walled garden now
But my personal boycotts of mainstream social media, advertising, and weaponised viral clickbait have had absolutely no effect on the general adoption of such practices.
Collective action and regulation are what is required here. Parliaments are the effective mechanism. Possibly class-action suits.
This isn't Minority Report.
Everyone knows that the worst CSA happen in lawless countries and regions. This is mere pretext to build generalised surveillance infrastructure, or more importantly, normalise the concept of being continuously surveilled by faceless entities. That is the big push society is heading generally towards. It started with CCTV and will end with brain implants, unless society decided enough is enough at some point instead of endless hair-splitting.
But everybody agrees that outlawing the possession of CSAM in general is the right thing to do. This was the case even in a time when the Internet was still in its infancy.
The apple technology only adds passive detection. In the event of a framing, passive detection is not necessary.
This technology doesn't enable any new attacks.
They neeed to already have the original image to make the hash collision. In your scenario, what does the attacker gain from sending a visually-indistinguishable collider instead of the original?
Remember: the hash collision is only the first step in the process. You also need to convince the Apple reviewers that the image is pornographic, and convince the NCMEC reviewers that the image is in fact the same as the one that it met a hash match with (apparently by magic, since you're imagining that the original image that you have to make a visually-indistinguishable match to isn't available).
I ask again: how is this process any more potent than any regular old fashioned pornography framing?
If enough people do the same, Apple will realise how much merit our opinions collectively achieve.
If people would really care about their privacy, Facebook and Instagram wouldn't be as big as they are, nobody would use facebook messenger for communication and a lot fewer people would use Windows and Android. Despite the warning of privacy advocates, experienced users, etc, people don't seem to care and I doubt this will change with the CSAM debate.
I bought a pine phone when they announced it. Looking forward to leaning into it when it arrives.
I know there will be some pain, but I'm getting off the ride here.
Believe me, I know how frustrating it is when nearly everyone on the internet is wrong (or you feel like they are), but comments like this don't help, they just make things worse. If you want to patiently provide correct information, in a form people can actually learn from, that's great. If you don't want to do that, not posting is also an option.
Now it's pretty much all BS.
"Apple is looking at my pictures, I'm switching to Android."
Nobody stops to think before saying something stupid.
it's 1am, and this has been discussed to death. Good night
Better options are (1) post something thoughtful and substantive, or (2) don't post.
Apple say they won't do that, but it's perfectly healthy to not trust Apple on that aspect.
But the fact that they're scanning for CSAM images doesn't change the above in any way. If they back down and stop scanning for CSAM images, that won't have any effect on the above. The governments can still pressure them to add this to their phones. Or even worse. Maybe they have.
It's like people disabling exposure notifications because they don't trust Apple. If that's the case, why do you trust the toggle to actually do anything?
You either trust Apple that they won't bow down to pressure, or you don't, in which case, buy a phone from a company that you trust more.
As someone said on a podcast recently, this isn't a technological problem, it's a government problem. The solution is to vote, not to change your mobile phone.
My arguments seemed obvious. Yet the all the top comments are "OMG, apple is looking at my photos".
I'm not an Apple fanboy. They are doing some horrible stuff, especially for developers. For example: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/08/iphone-keyboard-...
But I think this is honestly a good thing Apple are doing with respect to CSAM. And before we get on the "slippery slope" band-wagon, read about what kind of pictures are on that database, and then get back to me.