News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German parliament pens letter to Apple with concerns over... by hannasanarion on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:44AM (#28235289)
By crossing your fingers and hoping that the Apple reviewers mistake the grey blobs for porn, the NCMEC reviewers mistake the grey blobs for porn, and the police, DA, and judges all mistake the grey blobs for porn, and that the person being targeted doesn't notice the mysteriously appearing grey blobs on their phone in time for that entire process to happen?
Re:German parliament pens letter to Apple with concerns over... by Zababa on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:48AM (#28235332)
Or you could find pornographic pictures with a person that looks quite young in them, and slighly modify the picture until you get a collision.
Re:German parliament pens letter to Apple with concerns over... by hannasanarion on Thursday August 19, 2021 @12:01PM (#28235519)
And why would anybody be more interested in framing somebody with an image that looks so similar to child porn that it convinces dozens of professional child-porn investigators and yet technically isn't, instead of just sending the actual child porn?

They neeed to already have the original image to make the hash collision. In your scenario, what does the attacker gain from sending a visually-indistinguishable collider instead of the original?

Re:German parliament pens letter to Apple with concerns over... by Zababa on Thursday August 19, 2021 @12:51PM (#28236196)
They gain that the image won't be detected by CSAM detecting systems on their devices.
Re:German parliament pens letter to Apple with concerns over... by hannasanarion on Thursday August 19, 2021 @07:29PM (#28240597)
Yes, it would, because they need to have the original CSAM image in order to forge the hash collision. This method doesn't work unless you have the original photo to look at, meaning that your device will be raising alerts just as much as the targets, except you will be the only one incriminated since the target doesn't actually have any CSAM, only the hash-collided fake that you've made.
Re:German parliament pens letter to Apple with concerns over... by Zababa on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:48AM (#28244360)
You don't need to, you only need the hash itself to create a collision. Which means that you only need a malicious actor to steal and/or sell the hashes.
Re:German parliament pens letter to Apple with concerns over... by hannasanarion on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:43PM (#28251743)
And how then are they going to make an image that is visually indistinguishable from the original?

Remember: the hash collision is only the first step in the process. You also need to convince the Apple reviewers that the image is pornographic, and convince the NCMEC reviewers that the image is in fact the same as the one that it met a hash match with (apparently by magic, since you're imagining that the original image that you have to make a visually-indistinguishable match to isn't available).

I ask again: how is this process any more potent than any regular old fashioned pornography framing?