News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by ksec on Saturday August 14, 2021 @09:48AM (#28180588)
This may be a Rant, or an unpopular opinion.

Life is strange. As if God is reminding me something.

It was only yesterday Overthinking [1] was submitted on HN. A little over 10 years ago many of my friends and colleagues told me to stop overthinking about things. It was causing me some stress and depression because when you start doing analysis many level deep the only conclusion is any small variance will simply cause Chaos. I look it up on the internet and that was the first time I learn about three body problem, Chaos theory, and the much more widely known butterfly effect.

I wish I was taught about this in school or told a lot sooner. To me it is much more about life than it is to maths or physics. Where everything could start out as deterministic, and yet the small difference made end results unpredictable. Over time it also evolved or taught me another concept, many many things or solutions in the world are somehow counter-intuitive.

Then I had a few successful project under my belt, but when I was asked in a Job interview I always attribute to "luck" more than anything else. Which happens to be a word HR and many people hate. Americanism ( which also spreads to non-Americans working inside American companies ) views on the world suggest if you work hard you will get it. I wish that was the case, but there were hundreds if not thousands of known moving parts. And possibly thousands of other unknown unknown. It worked. We worked hard. And it worked. It was everyone involved and lots of luck. I was only a small part of it.

I am sure those who interview me are all pretty smart. May be they should try to solve the three body problem.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28158435

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by jjcdtunb on Saturday August 14, 2021 @10:38AM (#28180996)
> Americanism ( which also spreads to non-Americans working inside American companies ) views on the world suggest if you work hard you will get it.

America is a big place. I'm seventh generation American, with a patriotic family.

I wasn't raised to believe that if you work hard you WILL get it. No, it's that if you DON'T work hard, you WON'T get it.

You see, success is hard work + luck. You can have luck without hard work, but you have to have a lot more of it to get rich and you still might squander it if you didn't earn it because you won't know what to do with it if you get it by pure chance

You can have hard work without luck, too, like most of the folks in flyover country have. They know they aren't getting rich, they're just trying to get by.

But you can't have real success without both hard work and luck. You might win the lottery with just luck, but you won't wind up running a successful enterprise.

I don't know who is learning from their parents that if you work hard you'll get rich. Mine taught me that if I work hard and have a little luck, I'll get by. A little more luck and I'll be successful. A little less, and I might need to rely on my family or community. That's what they're for.

There's this characiture of American culture and the idea of our meritocracy that I see represented here and in media and it doesn't ring true to me -- I would be interested to know if the people who think luck is the only necessary component for success are Coastal or Flyover, and how much luck they've had

I know for myself, I've needed both work and luck. Without the work, I never would've been in a position to take the opportunities offered by luck.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by thayne on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:25AM (#28181374)
> I don't know who is learning from their parents that if you work hard you'll get rich

Rich people. It's the result of survivor bias, "I worked hard and got rich, so if you work hard you can get rich too." And they discount the "luck". And it is reinforced by the fact that being born to wealthy, well connected parents is really luck.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by PragmaticPulp on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:41AM (#28181513)
> I wasn't raised to believe that if you work hard you WILL get it. No, it's that if you DON'T work hard, you WON'T get it.

Well said. I think the common misconception comes from reducing these wisdoms into aphorisms that are short, but easily misunderstood. Any adult who has lived more than a few years in the real world quickly understands that hard work doesn’t guarantee success, but that success isn’t going to fall in your lap without putting in work.

The online discourse has become particularly bad, with the pendulum swinging between extremes of “You can do anything if you follow your dreams” to the opposite of “Nothing you do matters because it’s all blind luck”.

The latter, cynical mindset has become particularly popular as a way of dismissing or downplaying the success of others. I can’t count how many times I’ve heard people try to attribute Jeff Bezo’s success to that one time he was lucky enough to receive a loan from his family. Yes, it was a lucky break, but it should be obvious that something like receiving a loan from one’s family doesn’t automatically predispose someone to lucking into building a trillion dollar company. Yet there’s a growing contingent of people who want to believe that Jeff Bezos tripped and fell and landed in the founder seat of a successful company by pure luck.

I think the truth is that a lot of people, especially younger people still finding their way, are insecure about their own success or place in life. It can be extremely comforting to surround yourself with explanations that nothing is actually within your control or that others’ success or happiness is the result of randomness. I think this is why we see the oft-repeated trope (on HN especially) that people who post happy photos on social media must actually be secretly sad and miserable behind the scenes: It’s a convenient excuse to downplay the happiness and success of others.

Ignore the extremes. Accept that success isn’t guaranteed. Know that luck is a factor, but it’s not the only factor. Hard work is your lever to maximize the cards you’ve been dealt. We’re all dealt different cards, but it still comes down to your own actions in leveraging the hand you’ve been dealt.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by Sebb767 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:45PM (#28186103)
> I think this is why we see the oft-repeated trope (on HN especially) that people who post happy photos on social media must actually be secretly sad and miserable behind the scenes

This is not about success, but about being realistic about what you can expect from your life. Everyone is going to be unhappy from time to time and everyone will have downs ; this is just not what you usually see on social media. So when people say this, it's to reduce people's feeling of being inadequate, not to take away success.

If you think about it, it's actually two sides of the same coin: People only see humongous companies and insane salaries, but not the years of hard work that went into getting there. Similarly, they only see happy faces on social media, but not the bad sides that everyone has.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by WalterBright on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:15PM (#28182293)
> It can be extremely comforting to surround yourself with explanations that nothing is actually within your control or that others’ success or happiness is the result of randomness.

On the other hand, accepting responsibility for results is empowering, because it means one can be successful.

I don't see anything happy about deciding one is a hapless victim of others.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by smolder on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:40PM (#28183417)
The comfort in shifting your locus of control outward comes from relieving the shame of failure, not from being an overall positive experience. In fact, it's common for people to both take credit for their successes while blaming their failures on external factors to relieve the shame.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by WalterBright on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:15PM (#28184388)
Blaming failure on others or external factors doesn't lead to success. It leads to bitterness and resentment.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by smolder on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:46PM (#28185264)
Right, I wasn't really disputing that.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by godelski on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:15PM (#28182791)
There's a saying: the harder I work, the luckier I get.

I read this as the harder you work the more you're able to take advantage of lucky moments. But those lucky moments still need to happen for you to take advantage of them. I think a lot of people don't like to admit that luck had anything to do with it because we have a culture that often suggests that it's luck or work but not some combination. While there are cases on the extreme ends of the spectrum I'm willing to bet that the vast majority are from a combination of hard work and high luck.

Veritasium did a (pretty obvious) simulation that showed those on the top end up having both high luck and hard work.[0] I think this should make sense to most people given how the simulation was run.

[0] https://youtu.be/3LopI4YeC4I

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by bigfudge on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:08PM (#28181735)
Interestingly though, when asked Americans rate luck as much less important in financial success than other cultures. Euro countries in particular are more comfortable attributing a higher fraction of their success to luck than those in the US. And by asked I mean a reasonable well designed study… I can’t find the ref just now but will post if I do when home again.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by robocat on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:41PM (#28184157)
It makes perfect sense to have an irrational belief in hard work.

You are likely to have more success if you believe in work. Certainly believing that 100% of outcomes is luck seems like a bad strategy.

At the level of a society then average beliefs matter. I find some less successful countries seem to obsess over the role of external influences, fate, god, and chance.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by bigfudge on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:08PM (#28318388)
This is wonderfully North American. I would judge countries like France, Germany much more successful than the US because they still have functioning political and cultural life. Those are only things that can survive if individual financial success is not the only metric used.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by fahadkhan on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:35PM (#28181968)
> There's this characiture of American culture and the idea of our meritocracy

But earlier

> if I work hard and have a little luck, I'll get by. A little more luck and I'll be successful. A little less, and I might need to rely on my family or community.

This isn't a meritocracy that you are describing

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by simonh on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:03PM (#28182200)
Sure it is. Hard work weights probability in your favour and gives you more opportunities. Surely that's the best anyone can ever hope for? Do you have a system in mind that makes guarantees?
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by Supermancho on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:53PM (#28183849)
A meritocracy isn't about guarantees, other than ranking is by performance not externalities. By most definitions, a meritocracy is impractical, granted. In a real-world sense, the socio-economic status of every individual on earth is primarily governed by luck/circumstance. Not to say there aren't exceptions, but there has to be an inordinate amount of "merit" AND luck to overcome the initial state, statistically. To whit, a human lifetime is more complex and complicated to navigate, than the 3 body problem.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by WalterBright on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:15PM (#28182297)
Right. Successful people make their own luck.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by kergonath on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:04PM (#28183936)
> No, it's that if you DON'T work hard, you WON'T get it.

There are plenty of born-rich counter examples. New-rich counter examples as well (see Bitcoin millionaires). Frankly, this is just as false as the other one.

Never mind the fact that “working hard” depends quite a lot on the beholder. For example, I would challenge a lot of those self-declared gritty, hard-working ideologists (such as Bezos and quite a few armchair billionaires) to live a year as a minimum-wage single mother in a city.

In any case, there are lots more hard-working poor than hard-working rich, regardless of how you define hardness. So it’s about as valuable as “all the winners played the lottery”, i.e., amusing to say but not really a good way of living.

Anyway, my feeling is that successive people are very good at gaslighting the others to justify their wealth, and that America has a workaholism problem.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by WalterBright on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:12PM (#28182269)
> I wasn't raised to believe that if you work hard you WILL get it. No, it's that if you DON'T work hard, you WON'T get it.

Reminds me of when the CEO of GM said "What's good for General Motors is good for the country." Except he didn't say that. The press did a hatchet job on him by reporting it that way. The actual quote is "what was good for our country was good for General Motors, and vice versa."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Erwin_Wilson#General_M...

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:23PM (#28183260)
you think that making the "and vice versa" explicit ("... and what's good for General Motors is good for our country") is a hatchet job?
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by WalterBright on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:27PM (#28183306)
Leaving off crucial parts of the statement makes it a hatchet job.

Just like if someone says "more or less" and the journalist leaves out the "or less".

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:49PM (#28183472)
You believe that the first clause somehow balances the second?

When this (partial) quote is used, it's generally in a context where the first clause is arguably irrelevant. I don't think it's like your "more or less" analogy. There are not many corporations that fail to benefit when the country does well, so the first clause is broadly agreed upon. The second clause, however, is controversial, and has implications that are quite independent of the first clause.

"It will be sunny today, and tomorrow there will be snow" - if you hear this weather forecast at 13:00 on a sunny day, the first clause is close to information-free, but the second is very striking.

So it is with the quote from the head of GM.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by WalterBright on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:19PM (#28184419)
> You believe that the first clause somehow balances the second?

It doesn't matter if I believe it or not. It's a hatchet job to selectively misquote people to pursue the journalist's agenda.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:46PM (#28185262)
You think it is selective misquoting. I think it's entirely appropriate quoting. We disagree.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by spaetzleesser on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:51PM (#28183490)
"I don't know who is learning from their parents that if you work hard you'll get rich."

I read that line a lot from successful people: "I have achieved X. IF I can achieve it, you can too. Let me explain how. "

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by prairiedogg on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:12AM (#28181253)
> No, it's that if you DON'T work hard, you WON'T get it.

Depends on how much you start with.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by dclowd9901 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:34PM (#28182453)
My parents’ attitudes are very much more oriented toward hard work becoming success and that if you haven’t gotten what you wanted, it’s because you haven’t tried hard enough yet.

In a way, they’re right. I’d love a 911 GT3, and I could almost certainly get one, if only for a short period of time, and with the benefit of armed robbery.

There’s a lot of things I’ve “chosen” to consider instead of putting everything aside to chase a dream. In more concrete terms, anyone can have anything they want, but what you have to give up for it matters. And that’s something I think my parents and people like them don’t think about. Not everyone has the emotional construction, or even the ability to give up aspects of their life to achieve what they want. I think a large part of “luck” is when the time comes to make a hard decision like that, some fortunate circumstance made swallowing that pill a bit easier.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by PragmaticPulp on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:25PM (#28181888)
> It was causing me some stress and depression because when you start doing analysis many level deep the only conclusion is any small variance will simply cause Chaos.

With n-body simulation problems, we don’t actually observe immediate chaotic behavior following small perturbations. In fact, we can readily simulate these systems with considerable accuracy if we want to spend the compute resources. For example, simulating our own solar system with far more than 3 bodies in play can be done with a high degree of accuracy to timescales far beyond our lifetimes.

However, the n-body problem isn’t a good analogy for your sense of personal agency anyway. You aren’t a chunk of rock floating helplessly through space. You are a human being who can take action to influence your own trajectory. You can apply pressure and course correct in a feedback loop, unlike a planet hurling through the solar system.

That doesn’t mean you can influence everything, but it it does mean that it’s wrong to assume that your life is chaotic or that nothing you do matters. (FWIW, The latter feeling is a very classic, and erroneous, thought pattern present in depressive disorders. Correcting that misconception is a core principle of CBT therapy).

You are not a planet hurtling helplessly through space for billions of years. You’re more like a satellite being launched optimistically into the right general area, but it still has to use the limited amount of thruster energy onboard to push itself into the right place. It doesn’t always work exactly as planned, but not using the thrusters at all would assure failure.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by jvanderbot on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:49PM (#28183036)
You are more like a ship than a bottle in the sea. And like a ship, require maintenance, helping hands, bravery, and a destination.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by function_seven on Saturday August 14, 2021 @10:54AM (#28181123)
I think you’d like Ted Chiang’s short story “Anxiety is the Dizziness of Freedom”

Touches on these themes and really made me think about the overlap of chaos and (“macro”?)determinism.

https://onezero.medium.com/anxiety-is-the-dizziness-of-freed...

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by sgregnt on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:15AM (#28181282)
To me it is not surprising that an interviewer would not be satisfied if you attribute your success to luck alone. What can you contribute to a new work place if you rely purely on luck? It is important to identify how you were in a position to take advantage of the lucky circumstances that you had...

My two cents: A well thought out design process tries to augment luck with a controlled progress: where you try to move towards your goals in a systematic, more controlled, way so the final outcome is less dependent on luck but more dependent on your ability to properly adjust and execute your design plan. It might be that luck was more important than the process in your case, but that hard to build on, and more importantly, to make any learnings for the future, it still good to analyze how the process could be made better, how you could better take advantage of the lucky circumstances you had.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by WalterBright on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:06PM (#28182227)
> if you work hard you will get it

That's a misunderstanding. It's working hard on the right things. Working hard digging a hole then filling it up again will never lead to success.

As for luck, the idea is to put yourself in a position where luck can find you. For example, you'll never meet the partner of your dreams by never leaving the house.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by SubiculumCode on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:41PM (#28182526)
A rain drop forms in the sky and begins to fall. What path it takes, no one knows, but that it lands, we can surely assume.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by DiggyJohnson on Saturday August 14, 2021 @09:51AM (#28180607)
I agree. I’m writing a book about why people play MMORPGs, and you just got at the heart of (part of one of my) theses.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by wincy on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:16AM (#28181293)
Ugh I think back to my server-first raid boss kills in wow, my giant space battles in EVE Online, my lasting relationship trauma from being "catfished" before it was even a word on Second Life, and wish I'd just gone to college or something instead of spending my teens and 20s playing MMOs. What a terrible trap these things are.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by bgroat on Saturday August 14, 2021 @09:56AM (#28180647)
Is there an email list where I can subscribe for information about this book/pre-order?
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by DiggyJohnson on Saturday August 14, 2021 @10:51AM (#28181097)
Not yet, but I'll start thinking about it. I've never talked to anyone about it other than close friends, I probably should share more as progress continues.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by ghoward on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:51PM (#28182110)
I think it's great that you're not hyping it, and hope you don't until it's close to ready.

That said, even though I am not an MMORPG player, I'd be interested in seeing it.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by DiggyJohnson on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:44AM (#28199395)
Thank you for the encouragement. I'm glad to have this approach validated.

The good part about being so low key about this project is that "small" - though I'd argue human-to-human scale communication isn't small, it's human scale ;) - feedback like your comment are extremely encouraging. So far, 0 people have not been interested...which is awesome.

I've been fascinated to discover that the process of writing a book is (can be) a lot like the experience of playing an MMORPG. It's a framework that captures your individual achievement, and that achievement is backed up by legitimately hard work an admirable ability to set and achieve our goals.

I could go on-and-on... Cheers!

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by petercooper on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:59PM (#28183098)
I would also be keen to follow progress on this when you reach such a point.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by DiggyJohnson on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:46AM (#28199411)
See my reply to a sibling comment, but long story short: thanks for sharing your interest. You are on a (very short) list of individuals that I'll include when I start communicating or publishing some of my progress.

Thanks!

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by nathanvanfleet on Saturday August 14, 2021 @10:37AM (#28180993)
That's actually pretty interesting.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by DiggyJohnson on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:50AM (#28199451)
I've never talked about this project online, so this comment really does mean a great deal to me. See my comment to another reply in this thread: but I have a great deal of excitement about this topic.

I think a lot of people would have a hard time answering: "why do you play?"

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by ksec on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @06:04PM (#28215390)
Very late to the reply. I got a little emotional typing out that story so I didn't check the comments section for a few days.

Is it because of deterministic outcome? Would be interested to hear more about the book as well.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by hippari on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:55AM (#28181636)
Lots of classes function are infeasible to compute, but they're deterministic nevertheless. The whole universe might not have enough computational power to give you the answers.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by PragmaticPulp on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:07PM (#28181734)
> Lots of classes function are infeasible to compute, but they're deterministic nevertheless.

Exactly, and it also depends on the timescale and precision you're looking for.

It should be obvious that planets in our own solar system aren't showing up at unpredictable locations after a few years, even though our solar system has significantly more than 3 bodies in orbit.

The chaotic behavior in these systems shows up eventually but it's a mistake to think that it's chaotic from the start. We can, and do, predict these systems quite accurately around the starting conditions and time.

The philosophical mistake in the OP's comment is equating a hands-off chaotic system (n-body problem) with a system that has many feedback loops (a person's life). Planets orbiting in space can't take action to change their trajectories. Humans navigating their lives can and do take actions to change their trajectories.

Humans can make moves to correct their own course. Planets cannot. Equating the two is a misunderstanding of personal agency.

Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by m3kw9 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:20PM (#28181845)
If you think about it, the universe did compute the answer it just takes time to get there.
Re:Scientists find an effective solution for the three-body ... by Borrible on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:10PM (#28181758)
>but when I was asked in a Job interview I always attribute to "luck" more than anything else

Reframe that to recognizing potential and realizing it with great success.