News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by foepys on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:27AM (#28177899)
Super illegal in Germany, luckily. It's shocking to me how people here accept this as normal.

You shouldn't lose all rights just because someone is paying you any amount of money. The company does not own you. You're not a soulless resource that can be used and tossed whenever your boss pleases.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by grecy on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:13AM (#28178991)
> You're not a soulless resource that can be used and tossed whenever your boss pleases

Once healthcare is tied to employment, that is exactly what people are.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by loftyal on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:39AM (#28179383)
Kind of ironic isn't it, the people against universal medicare are the same ones spouting "freedom", but infact universal medicare would give them more real individual freedom than any other bills sent to the Senate these days.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by concordDance on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:06AM (#28179504)
The USA system is particularly broken. Just because healthcare is private doesn't mean it needs to be ruinously expensive, most other countries manage.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by loftyal on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:45AM (#28179892)
Most other countries provide universal health care, private health insurance is optional.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by beckman466 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:48AM (#28180208)
> Once healthcare is tied to employment, that is exactly what people are.

Yep, and this marvelous US productivity hack by employers and lawmakers (/s) - of making affordable healthcare conditional to employment - is unfortunately growing around the world. Parallel to this move is the continued commodification of most other resources and relationships.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by lotsofpulp on Saturday August 14, 2021 @10:49AM (#28181080)
In the US, anyone can buy the same health insurance from healthcare.gov. However, if you are not self employed, then you will have to pay with post tax dollars as opposed to pretax dollars.

Employers do pay a portion (usual 50% or more) of the health insurance premiums, but these days it is just another form of compensation, worth somewhere around $200 to $1,200 per family member per month (pretax).

Before ACA, it was true there were cases you simply could not get health insurance without an employer, as you could be denied for a multitude of reasons.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by bserge on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:02AM (#28178683)
> You're not a soulless resource that can be used and tossed whenever your boss pleases.

I am.

Just thinking everything's great doesn't actually change reality lol

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by beebmam on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:40AM (#28178849)
You can always work somewhere else. Or start your own company. Or even organize, which is a legally protected ability in the United States.

Don't accept that bullshit. Especially if you're a software engineer and have a million opportunities.

I resigned from a big tech company because I refuse to build any weapons, period. I'll always refuse to build them as long as I live. I can easily get hired somewhere else.

Have some self respect and demand to be treated with dignity. To hell with the bosses' intimidation

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by southerntofu on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:16AM (#28179002)
To hell with the bosses. Organize with a few friends/coworkers and start a workers cooperative, where every one is paid the same and has a say in decisions.

However, that requires some savings and some political perspective. I understand why someone who just struggles to pay their bills every month "thanks to" their corporate overlord (i.e. "wage slavery" as that is/was called) would not consider it a viable option.

Organize with your fellow workers. Sabotage the company. Make your managers' lives miserable, but do it collectively ;)

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by janto on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:13AM (#28180039)
Or create your own company. Sabotaging someone else's company and feeling entitled that they should give you money for your activity sounds like... theft?
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by loceng on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:49AM (#28180213)
Sabotage is arguably far worse than theft; would be glad to have this kind of unreasonable-malicious individual filtering themselves out of my company - and ironically they certainly are a supporting point for companies who want to monitor and control to catch stated malicious behaviour/sabotage; they clearly have resentment and won't be as successful themselves as otherwise because they're wanting to waste energy, perhaps energy from anger - but certainly that of resentment - rather than directing it to do better themselves, which doesn't include sabotage or wasting energy; that's a violent and self-harmful act IMO.

Re: theft - they didn't mention theft in their comment (unless they edited it out; why not version control on HN?) but the problem I have with theft is that it allows thieves to gain resources that they didn't develop to earn themselves, that they don't yet deserve - giving them power they don't deserve nor have learned how to wield adequately.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by janto on Saturday August 14, 2021 @09:55AM (#28180636)
I got an entitlement vibe from their comment which is why I brought up theft.

Indeed yes, sabotage is worse than theft.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by newbamboo on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:38AM (#28180165)
All the agonies you suffer You can end with one good whack!! Stiffen up, you ornery duffer And dump the bosses off your back
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by Valakas_ on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:01AM (#28179478)
"You can always fight and become a gladiator champion to win your freedom."

If the alternatives suck (being poor or a social outcast) or are hard (entrepreneurship) or not that different (another soulless corporate job), how much freedom is there really?

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by janto on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:25AM (#28180103)
Freedom allows you to find a way to survive on your own terms.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by lnxg33k1 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:15AM (#28179544)
You can't accept to work anywhere else, companies need to adhere to the needs of the people working, and have respect. If we start dodging problems by moving companies instead of fighting back, we'll soon have no company where we can work which is respectful.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by BrandoElFollito on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:02PM (#28183919)
Out of curiosity, does the refusal of designing weapons include the ones used by the police forces to protect you?

I have no stake in the question, live in France where guns are an exotic thing - just genuinely curious about the limits.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by bserge on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:52PM (#28183845)
Right. Personally I'd love to build anything, especially weapons. And I'd be good at it. Guess many people should be thankful I don't heh
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by slim on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:38AM (#28179377)
I'm sorry for you. But maybe your situation will change in the future and you will recover your freedom. Most of us chose to fight when necessary and take the risk to lose the battle
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by saiya-jin on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:35AM (#28179617)
Exactly what makes starting/owning a company in US so great and efficient. Exactly what makes being an employee in US often such a crapfest for most of ones active life
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by Hasnep on Sunday August 15, 2021 @05:56AM (#28187547)
Capitalism?
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by GekkePrutser on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:35AM (#28179364)
No but the law does, in the EU
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by bserge on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:01PM (#28183916)
Yeah, you know people just ignore it, right?
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by unethical_ban on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:44PM (#28182046)
You're missing something.

A person can recognize reality while knowing it should be different. Recognizing the need for something to be different is the first step in it becoming different.

Learn to read the OP's sentence as "A person should not be a soulless resource..." - that is often what is meant.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by stickaquarius on Saturday August 14, 2021 @09:32AM (#28180477)
My employer in Germany (U.S. company with an incorporated branch in Germany) recently started using Deep Packet Inspection and is decrypting all SSL traffic. While they're not logging all keystrokes, they can read everything.

Reading about this topic, it seems this is also not legal, especially when limited personal internet usage is allowed as well in the contract.

What's the right way to approach this issue? I guess if someone brings this up, they'll just update contracts and say that personal internet usage is forbidden? It still feels like someone is watching you.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by yladiz on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:24PM (#28183677)
If you have legal insurance, ask the lawyer to look into it and write a letter. This seems very illegal and a single letter from a lawyer will scare the company enough to stop it.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by BrandoElFollito on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:05PM (#28183941)
They probably inspect the traffic for information security. Specifically to check if there is no hacking going on (suspicious data extraction, c&c calls etc)
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by ciex on Monday August 16, 2021 @06:20PM (#28203683)
Systematic monitoring is always illegal in Germany, even if they forbid private internet use.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by WhyNotHugo on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:25AM (#28180097)
Well, that's not the American view of things.

It's clear that, in their super-capitalistic view, if they pay you a salary they own you for 8 hours a day. Property doesn't have rights, so neither do you.

This has been clear for quite some time, but it's reaching exaggerated extremes in recent years.

It's worrying how US companies are expanding so intensely into the EU as well.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by kwhitefoot on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:28AM (#28179816)
Probably illegal here in Norway too. If not then I think would probably require the assent of the Norwegian Data Protection Authority (Datatilsynet).
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by ok_coo on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:00PM (#28182180)
Well, in the USA we are literally called Human Capital Stock. So, I would disagree that's the case here.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by s5300 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:47AM (#28178371)
>You're not a soulless resource that can be used and tossed whenever your boss pleases.

Hahaha. We Americans have this little term called "Human Capital"

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by foepys on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:50AM (#28178392)
The term "Human Resources" is slowly creeping into German corporate speak. Before that it was called "Personalverwaltung" (employee management) which I think is a way better and more fitting name.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by BLKNSLVR on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:58AM (#28178669)
You're a good decade behind - for the better. In Australia the terminology HCM is working it's way into common corporate usage.

Human Capital Management.

Another scale up (down) from where you're moving to.

Next step might be rolling HCM into a function of the Finance Department. (moreso).

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:24AM (#28178768)
Holy hell. "Human Resources" implied that as an employee, you're a resource to be exploited - used up and discarded. "Human Capital" implies your employer owns you.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by rvense on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:34AM (#28179363)
I got a new co-worker (product manager) who seemed like a nice guy, well-spoken, seemed to listen to us techies, fun to have lunch with. The only thing that seemed "off" about him at first was that he unironically referred to people as resources. "We can deploy without a proper review for now since the design resource is on holiday". Like, there was only one "design resource", he was called Andrew and their desks were next to each other! I thought it was weird, but I just brushed it off since other than that he seemed fine.

At first. After a few months, though, he proved himself to be classical politicking a---hole and a horrible bully if you got on his bad side. I take that as a lesson to trust my instincts more.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by skeeter2020 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:09AM (#28180018)
I think the difference is that at the C-level, executives play checkers, where every piece is the same and you can allocate "resources" (aka people) as commodities. Below that we're playing chess and every person is a distinct individual. It's at the transition in either the hierarchy or in this case you're co-working trying to position himself in the former while working in the latter where it gets unpleasant and weird.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by BrandoElFollito on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:10PM (#28183978)
Did everyone knew Andrew and what his role was?

Though I must admit that design resource is hardcore :) I must try that at the office and look at the reactions.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by siva7 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:39AM (#28179629)
always when i hear someone calls a fellow colleague a ressource (in corporate context) or device (in sport context) it always proved true that these people were manipulative as hell.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by sokoloff on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:47AM (#28179659)
What’s an example of the device usage?
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by siva7 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:18AM (#28179762)
in dance sport calling your partner a sport device ;)
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by arethuza on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:40PM (#28182013)
I think the R in ERP systems might have contributed to this ghastly habit.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by mdp2021 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:55AM (#28179182)
Not really, though you are probably just making jokes.

"Resources" can surely mean "assets" (note that the relevant resources are selected...), which is not at all diminishing or ghastly, and also honestly means "what is available to fulfil a need". Implication of «expoitation» (or, even farther, "expendability") is not necessary, though "being used" is surely there - but that is the job itself.

"Capital" implies "investment" - what you invest is the principal, "capital", while the additional returns are the secondary part -, not necessarily that «ownership» that implies a loss of freedom: contractually, you allow your employer to make your work part of an investment. Again, it is the job itself. The capital is what you have invested and returns after having brought fruit: again, they are assets.

Terms have broad semantics, it is never a good idea to interpret with partiality. :)

Edit: I am not denying that some employers may de facto as if interpret "resources" and "capital" dishumanly: I am stating that the fault is not in the jargon.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by skeeter2020 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:05AM (#28179991)
What does "People Management Team" mean? That's what our HR has adopted, I think to sound less scary but to me it comes across like total social control.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by paganel on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:45AM (#28179136)
> Human Capital" implies your employer owns you.

Which goes to show how correct Marx was, at least from a sociological perspective.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by janto on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:42AM (#28179876)
Well, Marx will always appear correct from a Sociological perspective. It's at the foundation of that perspective.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by wiml on Saturday August 14, 2021 @09:01PM (#28185327)
This must be some new meaning of the word "sociological" of which I was previously unaware.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by janto on Sunday August 15, 2021 @05:29AM (#28187413)
I took it as a synonym for sociology.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by gorgabal on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:39AM (#28179864)
I like that term. Going to try to slip that into conversations every now and then. Thanks for the inspiration.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by mdp2021 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:09AM (#28179245)
Sorry, which term(s) in German is(/are) used for "Human Resources"?
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by foepys on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:37AM (#28179854)
Companies use the term "Human Resources", literally. Without translation. Ridiculous if you ask me.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by mdp2021 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:55AM (#28181633)
I noticed the intrusion of that terminology in the German speaking area from a small thing, a joke from Miguel Fernandez:

«Wo is der Azubi?! Sie meinen der Primary Business Solutions Executive Assistant. ...Der is grad kacken.»

I think the trend comes from the globalization of business and trade, so that when parts meet there is no translation of titles but a sort of spontaneous international convention. This avoids questions like "So, what is exactly your job as /Azubi/?".

(Of course, still tongue-in-cheek, it may remain a justified question to ask "What is exactly your job as PBSEA".)

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by fuzzfactor on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:53PM (#28182635)
>Companies use the term "Human Resources", literally. Without translation.

Interesting.

When it arose there must not have historically been anything similar commonly seen.

Could be all previous German engineering success has been best accomplished without anything resembling an American-style HR approach.

After all, today's HR designation took root during the belt-tightening of the '80's under Ronald Reagan, and as we have seen has declined in usefulness from there continuously over the decades.

No translation was given back then either, and that was in the USA :)

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by StreamBright on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:20AM (#28179295)
Workers are minor annoyance for amazon. If they could do everything with robots they would. This is the tragedy of automation and robotics. As soon as it becomes an option there will be massive unemployment unless we figure out a better model.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by howaboutnope on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:29AM (#28179820)
Let's see if people will also shallowly dismiss Stephen Hawking saying the exact same thing you just said.

> If machines produce everything we need, the outcome will depend on how things are distributed. Everyone can enjoy a life of luxurious leisure if the machine-produced wealth is shared, or most people can end up miserably poor if the machine-owners successfully lobby against wealth redistribution. So far, the trend seems to be toward the second option, with technology driving ever-increasing inequality.

-- Stephen Hawking, https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/3nyn5i/science_ama...

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by treeman79 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:23AM (#28180081)
Farming was 97% of the population at one point. Then automation took over.

Rough at the time for sure. But few would wish to go back.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by Nextgrid on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:39PM (#28183756)
> But few would wish to go back.

Do they?

Back in the day when everything was manual I think you could reasonably make a living farming your own land. It was hard work but it was possible.

Nowadays everything is so optimized that margins are razor-thin and the remaining farmers are being squeezed from every side, both from the demand side for their produce (supermarket chains driving prices down) and from the equipment side (John Deere & co intentionally making equipment that's impossible to repair unless you pay them exorbitant prices).

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by treeman79 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:32PM (#28185197)
Missed the point. Hardly anyone is a farmer. We all have many luxuries because people who otherwise would be farmers are to some degree instead doing useful things other then fighting gophers and locusts.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by howaboutnope on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:18AM (#28181313)
This isn't about automation separated from the world it is used in, this is about automation speeding up inequality that isn't just growing, but accelerating -- and the predictable outcome that those who exploit and don't share with people when they still kinda need them, will certainly not share once they no longer need them for anything whatsoever, and can kill them in vast numbers trivially. If it was already occasionally possible to get soldiers to do it, how much more so owithout pesky humans and their consciences getting in the way.

> But few would wish to go back.

What does that even mean? I would love to "go back" and deal with things by not just letting the masses starve while people in costumes play god and smell their own farts, which is exactly what they do today. I would LOVE to see see that space exploration and awesome inter-species music festivals we might have in 2021 if the last few millenia hadn't been such pathetic ass.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by dmos62 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:30AM (#28179339)
Automation is as much of a tragedy as 3/5 people not having to work in agriculture or not having to spend hours washing your clothes by hand. A job becoming unnecessary should be a good thing. If you become unnecessary, something is wrong, and not necessarily with you.
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by alias-dev on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:30AM (#28178547)
> Slightly tangentially to your comment, I believe that people tend to vote based on the fact they believe they either are, or will soon be, part of the one percent.

As quoted in A Short History of Progress (2004) by Ronald Wright: > John Steinbeck once said that socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires. This helps explain why American culture is so hostile to the idea of limits, why voters during the last energy shortage rejected the sweater-wearing Jimmy Carter and elected Ronald Reagan who told them it was still “morning in America.” Nowhere does the myth of progress have more fervent believers.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by edoceo on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:16AM (#28178739)
Steinbeck is brilliant. Heres more quotes and links to other books.

https://en.m.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_Steinbeck

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by southerntofu on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:25AM (#28179043)
Socialism/Anarchism has serious roots in the United States. See the history of the underground railroad, the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) and actual gun battles against the militias of the bosses (Pinkermen), workers opposition to the first world war and their jailing for anti-war propaganda (anti-war doesn't mean anti-revolution, on the contrary), etc..

At some point of course a lot of people are gonna think a 0.001% to become a millionnaire and 99.99% chance to stay a wage slave all your life is better than great chances to be detained, mutilated or assassinated by the police or a militia.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by vidarh on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:56AM (#28179452)
The irony of how little May 1st means in the US today, is that May 1st as the international day of labor demonstrations stems in part from the AFL announcing to the First International that they planned to pick up demonstrations for the 8 hour day again, in part in commemoration of the Haymarket Massacre.

So in large parts of the world organised labour annually takes part in demonstrations as a direct result of the commitment of US unions.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by runarberg on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:33AM (#28178563)
Indeed, I think HN has a bug[1] where posts about labor rights are implicitly downranked. This can happen even when the topic is technologically interesting (such as here) and the workers in question are tech workers. I hope we’ll fix this bug soon, because HN is really the perfect place to voice concerns about labor right issues related to tech workers.

That said there were some pretty goods discussions following the walkout at Blizzard/Activation where this implicit downranking didn’t happen. I want to see more of that.

1: https://github.com/minimaxir/hacker-news-undocumented#implic...

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by AdrianB1 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:04AM (#28179224)
I guess it is not the discussions about labor rights that are downvoted, but politically turning it into "capitalism bad, socialism good" when labor rights are not specific to one of these options.

It is similar to people pretending morality exists only within religion, human rights and labor rights are perfectly compatible with capitalism: positive example France, Germany, negative example - all the failed socialism attempts in the past 100 years, from Soviet Russia or North Korea to Venezuela and Cuba.

Note: I see labor rights part of the human rights, not as an economic or government system. I definitely consider "progressive social issues" a fake term trying to suggest the notion that "progressive" is related to real (positive) progress, while "progressive" is a term the socialist movement in USA hijacked for their benefit, completely unrelated to "progress" as in the English language dictionary.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by rbjorklin on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:05AM (#28179993)
> all the failed socialism attempts in the past 100 years, from Soviet Russia or North Korea to Venezuela and Cuba.

As someone from Northern Europe I feel the need to point out that socialism != communism. The failed states you mentioned above all have/had a communistic rule. My impression is that media in the USA portrays these as being the same and evil which I don’t agree with.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by AdrianB1 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:39AM (#28180171)
(as someone from Eastern Europe) I agree with you, but the confusion is so widespread people get the wrong idea about it.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by BLKNSLVR on Monday August 16, 2021 @01:25AM (#28195167)
I believe this confusion is intended, so that people get the wrong idea about it.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by BLKNSLVR on Monday August 16, 2021 @01:21AM (#28195155)
The unique-to-the-US narrative that socialism == communism is another valuable tool that works towards maintaining the current imbalance of power in the US (hence my comment above about how people vote).
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by pessimizer on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:45AM (#28179887)
> I see labor rights part of the human rights

If you think people implying that advancing issues important to powerless people is positive progress is some evil socialist deception, it's strange that you've latched on to the term "human rights" as if it refers to anything that exists or can be enforced.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by AdrianB1 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @08:41AM (#28180180)
No, I am only saying socialism = progress is false. I am pro labor rights and more widely pro human rights, but I don't accept socialists hijacking the term "progress" for their benefit, they can be openly calling themselves socialists.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by awsthro00945 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:15AM (#28178197)
>wannabe capitalists with a dream of one day being the oppressive CEO abusing their workers

Alternatively, we're just people that recognize that it's absurd to think you have, or even deserve, to use someone else's property for whatever you want.

Do you also think it's oppressive that public libraries have rules against using their computers for porn?

Nice ad hominem, though.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by foepys on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:27AM (#28178276)
> it's absurd to think you have, or even deserve, to use someone else's property for whatever you want

How you read this into my comment is beyond me. An employee cannot use the company-provided resources in whatever way they like. If they do, that's grounds for termination.

German labor laws recognize that total surveillance is not aligning with the values of a free society. Life does not stop at work, every company event should tell you that. Instead there needs to be indications that the employee is acting in bad faith, then the employer can "surveil" the employee in a limited fashion, like read work emails (not private emails) or search their desk. The same as police cannot search you whenever they like without reason.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by andylynch on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:54AM (#28178658)
It’s worth remembering that many Germans still have direct experience of living in the surveillance state of East Germany, and I would expect know better than most how these tools can be used
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by hyperman1 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:53AM (#28178907)
This is not only a fact in Germany. Belgium has comparable protections. I'd assume the EU has them.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by southerntofu on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:27AM (#28179049)
I think the parent poster meant that the memory of a surveillance State is alive and well in East Germany because it was only two generations ago.

In other countries like France and Belgium, the surveillance State has been aimed at specific communities and at remote colonies lately, but a generalized state of surveillance has not been seen since the 1940s so people tend to underestimate the dangers of that based on little living memory of how authoritarianism grows.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by xelia on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:38AM (#28178323)
Perhaps we should return to feudalism, as it is absurd to think you deserve to use a lord’s property without putting in any labor for them.

To me it’s absurd that the system is such that the one’s doing the most don’t get to decide what happens with the fruits of their labor, and are under the mercy of whoever happens to own that workplace.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by garmaine on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:59AM (#28178099)
Even when the company owns the computer and it is on company time?
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by neolog on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:43AM (#28178352)
"Company time" is steering you wrong there. When a worker's shift starts she doesn't become chattel property of the employer for the duration of her shift. Instead, she's doing work that the company paid for while retaining her own personhood.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by garmaine on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:16PM (#28181812)
My question is about German law. Company time is relevant because a contract requires compensation in order to be in effect (which you are paid for under company time).
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by chrisco255 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:29AM (#28178284)
It's a huge security risk to add a keylogger. It's also a deep invasion of privacy and compromises the ability of employees to conduct private one on ones, which are important for the mental well-being of a company of people. Imagine working from an office with a microphone attached to your desk that pipes everything you say to your boss, your boss's boss, all the way up the chain. People need to vent. Sometimes people need to waste time and shoot the shit about things unrelated to work. People need to be able to discuss things in private without fear. Otherwise the culture will descend into a constant state of paranoia and dysfunction.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by randycupertino on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:31AM (#28178554)
It basically devolves the workplace into wargames where the employee focus becomes an "us vs them" battle stalemate with management re: tracking and obsessing over the KPIs vs how to beat the KPIs.

I worked in call center management and saw this play out real time. They made clients wear fitbits and hit metrics to qualify for the cheaper health insurance plan. Workers put the fitbits on drill bits and ran drills to whirl around the fitbit to beat the metrics. Then there was a mass group chat about how to beat the system. Then peoples personal cell phones had to be banned and kept in lockers outside the offices. And around and around and on and on it went. It was literally like Tom and Jerry and everyone was miserable and meanwhile the company wasn't doing well because nobody was focused on getting any high quality work done because of all the distractions and drama over the tracking.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by BLKNSLVR on Monday August 16, 2021 @01:31AM (#28195214)
Good working relationships has the capacity to boost productivity like nothing else. The cost of the unproductive time of a pleasant work-place conversation should be easily out-weighed by 'happy socially-engaged-in-the-workplace employee' pulling out all the stops to solve problems for their colleagues.

I don't believe this can be represented by KPIs, and therefore doesn't factor into (bad) managements' view of the world.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by foepys on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:22AM (#28178241)
The company cannot even look at the employee's work emails unless there are already indications that the employee is acting in bad faith ("Anfangsverdacht").
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by refurb on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:15AM (#28178488)
That doesn’t seem true?

” According to the guidelines, if the use of the Internet and email services is only permitted for business purposes, the employer can check the Internet use of the employees randomly, to make sure that they use it for business purposes only.”

https://www.mondaq.com/germany/privacy-protection/496710/ger...

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by foepys on Saturday August 14, 2021 @02:41AM (#28178601)
This is false for the general case. The employer always needs a reason, e.g. the employee appears to be browsing the internet the whole day instead of working. And even then, the work council has to be consulted.

The employer can look at work emails if it's the last resort (no other means to get the information), they have a reason (like if employee is sick and a customer emailed them directly with important contract data), a member of the work council is present, and it's been cleared by the GDPR person (whatever they're called in English).

Labor laws have been shaped by courts so it's quite confusing, even to Germans. Rulings are often decided by minuscule details that don't appear to be big but often are, so generalizing is hard.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by j16sdiz on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:32AM (#28179070)
I found this unproductive.

If a customer phone the support directly, are they going to hold the phone for hour waiting for approval? Only after the approval, the support can start reading the work email and decided the next step.

Co worker and manager need to aware of the work progress, just in case the employee is sick or something.

Employee should do their private work on their own devices.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by foepys on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:48AM (#28179148)
The company can easily take measures to prevent situations like this by using a proper CRM solution. If the company didn't, it's its own fault. Flaws in internal processes don't legitimize surveillance.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by pessimizer on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:51AM (#28179919)
It's also valuable to co-workers and managers to know if the employee might be engaging in behavior that could get them sick, or if they are looking for another job. So employers should really be able to monitor their employee's own devices, health records, and expenditures.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by j16sdiz on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:37AM (#28179090)
Does German law allow recording support helpdesk phone call?

What make email different from phone call?

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by foepys on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:54AM (#28179181)
The company can record phonecalls with customers as long as the customers agree, which is already being done under the disguise of "improving customer service". The company cannot record all phone calls an employee makes.

The company can simply require all customer communication to go through a proper CRM. This way there is no need to look into an employee's personal inbox.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by jcelerier on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:13AM (#28178184)
Companies are never ever more important than human beings
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by garmaine on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:16PM (#28181805)
Ok sure, but I was asking a technical question about German law, not morality.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by flimflamm on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:04AM (#28178137)
Yes.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by Broken_Hippo on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:17AM (#28179281)
If something is a right, it shouldn't go away while "on company time" - even if they own the computer. You are not an object.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by awsthro00945 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:00AM (#28178102)
>You shouldn't lose all rights

I'm not a huge fan of this monitoring, but why be so dramatic? You aren't losing any rights here, let alone all rights. You do not have a right to use your employer's computer without your employer's permission.

If you want to do something that isn't monitored, just use your own computer instead of your employer's computer. You should be doing this anyway, keystroke monitoring or not.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by jcelerier on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:16AM (#28178205)
> You do not have a right to use your employer's computer without your employer's permission.

Thankfully not true in sane countries

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.lci.fr/amp/societe/video-en...

In short, you definitely have a right to send e.g. personal emails from your work computer and your employer definitely does not have the right to go look into them for instance

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by crispyambulance on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:46AM (#28179650)
> Thankfully not true in sane countries.

I'm not so sure about that. Do large-enough French companies supply their own Certificate Authority to all company computers (like all large corporations)? If so, then they're free to browse/search/store all https communications from any company machine, right?

The assumption is that employers and IT departments will always "follow the rules", but it's impossible to verify something like that. The way corporations would be "caught" would be from huge numbers of whistle-blowers but that's a risky career move for most IT workers.

The good news is IT departments and individuals generally don't care to spy unless there's something really high-value at stake and only then towards very specific "targets". With few exceptions, the vast majority of workplaces tolerate ordinary personal use of corporate computer resources.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by BiteCode_dev on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:15AM (#28178198)
The inside of a company is not a bubble isolated from the rest of the society and with a different set of laws. Despite what billionaires really want it to be.
Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by awsthro00945 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:17AM (#28178207)
That's correct, which is why the same laws that say you can't just take someone else's computer and do whatever you want with it apply within a company just the same. On a company laptop, you do not have the right to do anything on it without permission from the company.

These are the same laws that also allow surveillance cameras not only within company properties, but even in public.

You do not have the right to privacy when you are not in a private space. This applies to company computers just the same.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by vidarh on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:03AM (#28178688)
This kind of dystopia is thankfully not one that everyone lives in.

In Europe you generally have a graded expectation of privacy that does not disappear the moment you enter the workspace.

We recognise that people have needs that are not met if you treat them as automatons.

To your surveillance camera point, I live in the UK which is renowned for the number of cameras. If I point a surveillance camera at the sidewalk in front of my house, I'd break the law.

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by brokenmachine on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:24PM (#28205422)
>To your surveillance camera point, I live in the UK which is renowned for the number of cameras. If I point a surveillance camera at the sidewalk in front of my house, I'd break the law.

Is this true? So your camera is only allowed to point at your property and nothing else? I don't see how this could possibly be true when you're allowed to take photos in public. Or does the fact the surveillance camera is fixed make a difference?

Re:Amazon will monitor workers' keystrokes to 'combat data t... by BiteCode_dev on Saturday August 14, 2021 @01:20AM (#28178229)
That's why there are badges that open doors and laptops, and permissions linked to accounts.