News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by johnyzee on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:40AM (#28105724)
30% of every sale is extortion, but even worse, and further proving the point, is that they prohibit taking payments through any other channel. How is it not illegal for the platform to force the use of their own payment service? Isn't this classic misuse of a monopoly?
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:39AM (#28106259)
> 30% of every sale is extortion

This is either ignorance or delusion. Brick and mortar stores take a lot more of a cut than that, and it isn't like Google's distribution infrastructure is free or something. It's a bit like saying developers demanding 6-figure salaries is extortion.

How the hell did we get to this point? Where ostensibly reasonable people feel entitled to shove their crapware on any storefront they want without paying for it?

> but even worse, and further proving the point, is that they prohibit taking payments through any other channel.

How so? Unlike with Apple, You can deploy Android applications without the store, or distribute on a different storefront for Android.

> How is it not illegal for the platform to force the use of their own payment service?

Companies choose what methods of payment they'll accept all the time. I can't buy a pizza with XBox Bux[0] or whatever the fuck either.

> Isn't this classic misuse of a monopoly?

No. For one, Android and the Google Play Store are not a monopoly. Android doesn't even have a majority market share in the US.

I generally agree that giant corporate conglomerates like Google are a bad thing for basically everyone, but I don't think that diluting the meaning of "monopoly" helps anyone, and neither do silly entitled arguments against paying a commission for distribution.

[0] As an aside, it is especially silly to me that people claim Google Play Store and Apple Store are bad but seem completely fine with the exact same practices on their game consoles.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by the_duke on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:34AM (#28106990)
> This is either ignorance or delusion. Brick and mortar stores take a lot more of a cut than that

This is a completely false equivalence, for two reasons.

A) stores have very limited shelf space they need to allocate. They also carry the cost of logistics, keeping inventory and the risk of bad sales. The cost to app stores for reviews and distribution in comparison is tiny per unit and easily scalable. The only context where this could apply is highlighting of apps, but that is handled via separate advertisement.

B) The high fees do not apply only to app sales but also to in-app transactions. This is where the cost is truly ridiculous and can be called extortion.

Credit card companies, for comparison, charge a few percent. The EU has even limited the maximum interbank exchange fees to 0.2% in 2014. Visa and Mastercard seem to be doing just fine with that cut... (there are additional fees, but it still only a mounts to a few percent)

The equivalence would be Walmart getting 30% for every in-game transaction for games that were bought at Walmart.

On Android you can at least use other payment providers, but on Apple you have to use Apple Pay.

> No. For one, Android and the Google Play Store are not a monopoly. Android doesn't even have a majority market share in the US.

They are a duopoly. Many concerns that are relevant for monopolies apply to duo or oligopolies as well. The companies split up the market and arrive at a comfortable equilibrium where they can milk the customers. They might squabble for market share, but they also coordinate (directly or indirectly) to not hurt each other too much. This can be seen in the matching of the cut they take.

The only reason the stores get away with their pricing is because there is no practical alternative for the average consumer for Android, and no alternative at all for iOS. The Google/Apple situation is indeed a classic economy textbook duopoly.

Calling something "ignorance or delusion" is quite a strong statement with such shallow insight.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by berkes on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:45PM (#28109064)
> This can be seen in the matching of the cut they take.

This is crucial: any efficient market would have them compete on price. Google lowers the fee to 25%, developers move over to Google, so Apple has to follow and lower the fee to 20%. untill we reach the price-point that just about matches the costs made.

Unless you can argue that this 30% is exactly that lowest price-point: just about covering the hosting, staff and some risk, there is the proof that a monopoly is distorting this efficient market.

Proving that the current price is exactly that price-point is probably impossible; we might feel it is far from the actual costs, but we cannot prove it, which is probably one of the reasons this cannot be given as hard proof for a duo/monopoly.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Cu3PO42 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:37PM (#28107973)
While I largely agree with your points, your comparison to MC/Visa isn't sensible. The EU has limited the interchange fee to 0.2% for debit cards and 0.3% for credit cards, but that goes to the card issuing bank anyway. MC/Visa charge scheme fees which were not capped in such a way.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tzs on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:33AM (#28107447)
> Credit card companies, for comparison, charge a few percent. The EU has even limited the maximum interbank exchange fees to 0.2% in 2014.

There are fees other than those to processes a credit card payment.

Each card brand has its own assorted assessment fees. Some are percentage based and some are pre transaction. Your payment processor also has fees, typically per transaction.

For small transaction, such as a $1 app or song purchase, those fixed fees bring the processing cost to a lot more than 0.2%.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Andrew_nenakhov on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:32AM (#28106562)
> Brick and mortar stores take a lot more of a cut than that

But they do not prohibit the producer from selling their goods elsewhere, and they are not a monopoly intermediary, unlike google.

Also, Google has intentionally crippled Android and background app running, so you have to depend on FCM to deliver notifications, and you can't deliver FCM notifications uf app is installed via apk or fdroid or other third-party appstore.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by kitsunesoba on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:56AM (#28107177)
> Also, Google has intentionally crippled Android and background app running, so you have to depend on FCM to deliver notifications, and you can't deliver FCM notifications uf app is installed via apk or fdroid or other third-party appstore.

FCM could indeed offer support for non-play-store apps, but weren’t background apps on Android leashed in because abuse of the capability was rampant and was torpedoing users’ battery life? I remember this being a pretty big Android issue for less technical users and an annoyance to more technical users.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by zozbot234 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:00AM (#28107211)
> weren’t background apps on Android leashed in because abuse of the capability was rampant and was torpedoing users’ battery life?

Yes, you can still run in the background but you need to show a persistent notification to that effect. The user can then choose whether to hide it.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Andrew_nenakhov on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:51AM (#28107591)
If the user hides it, the app loses background capabilities.

Also, notification area becomes unusable if there are too many persistent notifications. Syncthing, VPN, xmpp client, and you almost have no space for regular notifications, they become stacked.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by zozbot234 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:13PM (#28107754)
> If the user hides it, the app loses background capabilities.

That seems quite incorrect to me. Source?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Andrew_nenakhov on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:23PM (#28108848)
We develop an app that needs to stay in the background (an xmpp client). If a user hides the notification, the app dies in 30-60 seconds.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by zozbot234 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:22PM (#28109345)
Looks like the outcome of some custom/wild "battery optimizer" logic. AIUI, this just doesn't happen on stock hardware without such customizations.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Andrew_nenakhov on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:54AM (#28107612)
> weren’t background apps on Android leashed in because abuse of the capability was rampant and was torpedoing users’ battery life?

This should have been addressed by giving the user a capability to determine power usage by each app and either allow it if he needs the app, or restrict background running.

The way it was done is far from adequate. Also, many manufacturers (samsung, xiaomi, huawei) cripple android even further. See https://dontkillmyapp.com

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ehnto on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:35AM (#28106577)
> How the hell did we get to this point? Where ostensibly reasonable people feel entitled to shove their crapware on any storefront they want without paying for it?

Apple and Google have a duopoly with their respective app stores, they hold the keys to the majority of the customers since the customers only buy through their platforms. So it's different in at least that way. It's not as if I couldn't host my own downloads, take my own payments and give my own authentication, but no one could install my app without a long-winded process they are very unlikely to go through.

It's not like they don't provide services for their cut, I get it, they host the infrastructure, maintain the platform and so on, but I only have to use their services because otherwise I'm selling to a void, a void that they created. This would not be the case had they not captured the entire consumer market with their app stores, and had all their default OS settings on their market leading phones default to only accept their app stores.

If there was a vibrant ecosystem of third-party installer capabilities, say the ability to install something from a website easily with all my own infrastructure like in the wild west days, it wouldn't be an issue (customer easy, not tech wiz easy).

But they lock it all up and funnel everyone through their stores, and so as a seller you're coerced into their ecosystem and they get to take whatever cut they want. We have no negotiating power, we are locked out of customers if we don't participate, and we are regularly screened and bullied by the app approval processes, so the comparison to extortion isn't as far-fetched as you're making it out to be.

Here's a thought experiment, whenever someone complains about the app store banning their app and them losing all their income, tonnes of people reply with "You shouldn't have put all your eggs in one basket!" so okay, where are the other baskets? Where else can I sell an app? And be reasonable, be sensible, it's nowhere. There are no other options for a real business operating in a commercial reality. You can technically sell elsewhere, but I can technically sell chocolate bars in the desert, that doesn't make it a reasonable option.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by freeflight on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:57AM (#28107648)
> I generally agree that giant corporate conglomerates like Google are a bad thing for basically everyone, but I don't think that diluting the meaning of "monopoly" helps anyone, and neither do silly entitled arguments against paying a commission for distribution.

Google and Apple very much represent a duopoly, that's just calling a spade a spade.

Nor did I see anybody here argue they should just distribute other people's apps for free.

The issue is over the size of the fee they demand and how they also demand to exclusively use their payment services, so they can extort their 30% fee on every single transaction even past the original distribution.

To apply that example to a brick and mortar store would be the equivalent of the store getting a cut off attachments/replacements the customer directly orders from the manufacturer because the customer bought the original device in the brick and mortar store.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by mrweasel on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:02AM (#28106384)
One small point: profit on retail games are at most 7% and frequently no higher that 3 to 4%. We often saw brick and mortar stores lose money on new releases as advertising and try to upsell electronics. Clothing, toys and electronics do have much higher margins. Toys are at least 40% and I worked with a team dealing with eletronics, if they couldn’t make at least 50% they didn’t want to deal with it. Gaming console is the exception, here margins are 0% or less.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by judge2020 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:31AM (#28106554)
> Gaming console is the exception, here margins are 0% or less.

For reference: https://www.gamesradar.com/ps5-is-being-sold-at-a-loss-but-h...

For both game consoles and phones (mostly on the iOS side) the post-sale revenue is part of the overall profit scheme - PS5 hardware is sold very near-cost but all the money Sony makes off PSN and their cut of game sales becomes profit. Apple makes up-front margin from the hardware but also expects profit from in app purchases - if that wasn’t guaranteed, they might raise prices to make up the difference. Is it anti-consumer? Probably, for both the game console side and the phone side since the consumer ends up indirectly paying more after purchase.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:12AM (#28106445)
I stand corrected. I was only second-hand aware of the kinds of markups you see on physical goods like toys and electronics you see in B&Ms and didn't realize that software was different.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by mrweasel on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:20AM (#28106485)
Please note that those 3-7% margins only apply to games. I never dealt with other types of software.

To make money on reselling games from Blizzard, EA and others you have to be an insanely talented buyer and have very little overhead.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pgcj_poster on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:19AM (#28106889)
> It's a bit like saying developers demanding 6-figure salaries is extortion.

Developers don't typically make that much in any country except the US, and that seems mostly attributable to protectionist immigration laws. So I would agree with your analogy in that Google and US software developers are both in an unfairly advantageous bargaining position that one might call "extortionary" with some degree of hyperbole.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:54AM (#28106342)
Some of your points are very valid.

I do think there is a big difference between Apple and Google.

I also think there is a difference between consoles and general purpose devices that have not being properly explored by anyone and at some point should be identified by the law.

That being said, digital rights are a disaster right now, it will take ages before it's fixed.

Consoles might need to be fixed too: for some reason, digital items cost the same or more than the physical counterpart, but provide you with less (can't re-sell, can't lend). And this doesn't take into account yet the fact that digital libraries will disappear when people die (can't leave to family your account, in theory). So consoles are not a good example, they are the most abusive ones.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:10AM (#28106436)
> I also think there is a difference between consoles and general purpose devices that have not being properly explored by anyone and at some point should be identified by the law.

I disagree and would say that today the difference between these devices is arbitrary. Game console manufacturers don't allow Outlook or Google Docs or whatever on their stores, but there's no reason they couldn't be there. Their absolute control over their platform is no different than Apple's except that Apple is less restrictive.

> Consoles might need to be fixed too: for some reason, digital items cost the same or more than the physical counterpart, but provide you with less (can't re-sell, can't lend). And this doesn't take into account yet the fact that digital libraries will disappear when people die (can't leave to family your account, in theory). So consoles are not a good example, they are the most abusive ones.

I am by no means defending this practice in consoles. I'm objecting to carving out an exception for them. If you believe that phones should be more open as platforms then you should also believe that the consoles should be too.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:18AM (#28106469)
Good point. Yeah, I'd rather have the same rights digitally everywhere. Makes also things easier.

I vote with my wallet and avoid buying consoles (but I can't stop my wife from owning one), but there isn't much more you can do about it, sadly.

Politicians tend to be controlled by the money, everyone turns a blind eye to the idea of real digital rights.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:07AM (#28106799)
"Brick and mortar stores take a lot more of a cut than that"

And feudal lords used to take even more. Apple is neither the former nor the latter. They dont maintain a physical supplt chain, or need to raise a fyrd

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:11PM (#28107736)
Sellers can sell at other stores.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by shrikant on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:43PM (#28109045)
This may sound like I'm nitpicking, but if anyone reading this wants to save some money and pay devs more: Google/Apple absolutely do NOT prohibit taking payments through any other channel.

I know plenty of apps where one can buy the subscription at a significant discount directly on the service's website instead of through the stores and it works perfectly fine.

I think the restriction is on obviously advertising that fact in your app. So I'd recommend checking if the subscription you're about to buy through the app can be bought on the website instead.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:20AM (#28105916)
It is not a monopoly a per law definition across most jurisdictions.

Additionally playing sales commissions is a traditional practice in most markets.

Finally, maybe devs would appreciate to pay the 80 to 90% that used to be common on the Symbian, J2ME, BREW and Blackberry shops from mobile operators, about 15 years ago.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by stephc_int13 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:36AM (#28105993)
Armchair lawyers striking again...

I was there during the Symbian era, the commissions at the time were outrageous, but closer to 40-50% than 80-90%.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pydry on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:30AM (#28106216)
Monopolistic behavior in markets where you have limited market power is just shooting yourself in the foot.

I didnt even realize symbian HAD an app store.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by stephc_int13 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:21PM (#28107825)
They didn't, it was managed by carriers, mostly. And Handango on some devices like running Windows Mobile or PalmOS.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:44PM (#28108036)
They eventually did, it was called Ovi Store.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ovi_(Nokia)

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:44AM (#28106284)
Former Finland mobile phone company employee over here, the actual percentages depended pretty much on the territory.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by croes on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:36AM (#28106236)
Doesn't need to be a monopoly, could simply be case of illegal price fixing because all big players took 30%
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Dracophoenix on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:30AM (#28106546)
Is it really price fixing or just copying strategies? There comes a point where the optimal strategy for a firm is to simply do what every one else is doing. Price fixing requires an element of collusion.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:13AM (#28106846)
"the optimal strategy for a firm is to simply do what every one else is doing"

Such a convenient worldview, conpwtition doesn't exist, banks did nothing wrong prior to 2008, etc.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Dracophoenix on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:08AM (#28107266)
Competition requires players to remain in the game. No one is required to make a profit-losing decision realized or unrealized. If they do make such a decision, they're one step closer to going out of business. Survival is an incentive to taking the correct actions.

In an iterative prisoner's dilemma, the optimal solution is most often tit-for-tat or some variation of it. It's logical for one firm to do the same as another until it can obtain a strong hold on a profit-making activity that gives it more degrees of freedom with regards to its strategies. At that point a firm can move from merely surviving to experimentation or it can continue to milk the opportunity for all its worth.

Your cartel argument requires more than sameness of strategy. It requires motive and direct action towards achieving a forced equilibrium (e.g. willfully punishing other market players in concert to dissuade the use of alternative profit-making strategies).

I never brought up banks. What do they and the 2008 recession have to do with online stores and 30% cuts in 2021?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:38PM (#28107994)
"direct action towards achieving a forced equilibrium"

Do you expect the head of Apple and Google to sign a public document "hereby we form an illegal cartel"?

At a minimum the competition and market authority should take an interest as to why there is no competition. If they botheresld to investigate, maybe we would actually find out if there is any wrongdoing.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Dracophoenix on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:37PM (#28110341)
No. But I don't take a 30% cut as an indication of cartel-building when it has existed since Jobs first announced the App store in 2008 [1] and was done at a time where the Walmarts and Best Buys of the world charged 70% if not more. Quite recently Apple sought fit to reduce it's revenue share to 15% after the first year on the store store. Google has done the same. I wouldn't call putting more money in the pockets of developers a lack of competition.

[1]https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xo9cKe_Fch8

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomohawk on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:23AM (#28106178)
70% market share is considered a monopoly "on the face of it"

https://www.justice.gov/atr/competition-and-monopoly-single-...

Google holds many monopolies. Is the play store not a monopoly?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by nix23 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:37AM (#28105996)
While i agree with you that playstore is not a 100% monopoly, if anything it is a duopoly (Apple/google). But on the Marketing/AD's side it is definitely a monopoly, that should be addressed first i believe.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by roenxi on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:11AM (#28106135)
I'm not quite finding the angle here to state my thoughts clearly, but there seems to be a definition of monopoly at play in some of these threads that means something close to "I would make more money if Apple/Google made less, plus they already make lots of money so it isn't fair!".

Google/Apple having gained the trust of the market and acting as middlemen to sell access simply isn't monopoly activity. In the same way that renting out space in a commercial complex isn't.

There is no question they are running these stores to make an outrageous profit. But the monopoly would be expressed by how the gates are closed to alternate App Stores, or in Google is unfairly pushing competitors to their own Apps off the store to make a profit - which given that they generally provide their Apps for free is a hard argument to make. Nobody seems to be making either of those arguments. Particularly the first one would involve more references to Samsung being made.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by mjburgess on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:32AM (#28106223)
Suppose google's chrome started charging websites 30% of their revenue to be accessible in their browser. Is this an abuse of monopoly? Yes.

The issue is HNer's are still living in the "website era" of the internet -- that's ending. We're now in the app era. And devices are the browsers.

Their app stores are monopolies on their devices; in that the person who controls the road is a monopolist, despite the existence of air travel.

That android devices compete with ios devices is irrelevant, in as much as comcast/et al. can say, "go to a different state". The app store is an iOS monopoly -- the hardware apple provides is a road/telephone/browser device for access apps -- the new predominant mode of social/economic communication & infrastructure.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by roenxi on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:37AM (#28106243)
> Is this an abuse of monopoly? Yes.

It isn't though. That is my point, monopoly doesn't just mean big market share + you don't like it. Half the web would go dark to Chrome and everyone would dump the browser in a couple of months if they pulled a stunt like that. Because they don't have monopoly. They only have a very high market share because Chrome is the best browser.

If the best-browser part stops being true there is not reason for the highest market share part to stay true.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by mjburgess on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:26AM (#28106519)
Well I take 'monopoly' to be a pretheoretical concept tied to the moral concequentialist justification of markets: aggregate social benefits.

Ie., a monopoly is whatever situation gives rise to a situation where a company can set prices without regards to legitimate competitive market processes. Where 'legitimate' is effectively a concequentialist constraint concerning aggregate consumer benefit.

There are many theories of /when/ a company is a monopoly; including very narrow case law definitions around pricing.

The pretheoretical use of the term however is taken to permit a broader scope.

And lets be clear: a 30pc surcharge on all our economic activity (whether that be a mastercard or an apple) given no market justification has no justification.

Let there be many app stores on the iphone-- and we shall see what the market price on an app store. If it ends up being 30% then theres no objection.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by feanaro on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:51AM (#28107589)
> They only have a very high market share because Chrome is the best browser.

This is very much a matter of opinion, not something you can reasonably state with a straight face. A large part of Chrome's large market share is the fact that it comes installed as a default on more than half the world's phones and that it's heavily marketed by the world's largest search engine and video hosting website (owned by the same entity!).

It also good enough, for now.

It has nothing to do with it being the best, though.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:48AM (#28106318)
> Their app stores are monopolies on their devices; in that the person who controls the road is a monopolist, despite the existence of air travel.

Not when there are other roads to be taken, regardless of how many pot holes they have on them.

So buy another device, a feature phone, give money to Jolla, FairPhone, whatever.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:20AM (#28106890)
"So buy another device, a feature phone, give money to Jolla, FairPhone, whatever."

You are peddling a fantasy - my bank has mobile only access, and the app wont work on any alternative you lifted. The UK goverment app to apply for riggt to resde for European immigrants won't work either.

What the fuck am i meant to do with those phones?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:46PM (#28108056)
Switch bank if that is so important to you.

I only use banks that provide access via ATM and Web, in addition to apps.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:16PM (#28109301)
Should I also switch countries? I cant uproot my entire life just to spite google
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:42PM (#28109912)
You don't need to switch country to spite Google, only be more clever with your options and vote with your wallets.

I still carry my Windows Phone around.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by mjburgess on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:27AM (#28106532)
airplanes exist, and theyre owned by a baron too
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:01AM (#28106378)
Is it? I mean, if you think the u. s., it's one thing, but worldwide google has something like 90% marketshare on phones.

That being said, if Google started charging monthly for play store, you can easily change. The same is not true for Apple

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by yyyk on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:26AM (#28106192)
>>How is it not illegal for the platform to force the use of their own payment service? Isn't this classic misuse of a monopoly? >It is not a monopoly a per law definition across most jurisdictions.

It's not so relevant whether the stores are a monopoly or not. They're doing anticompetitive behaviour and misuse of market power, that's illegal regardless.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomjen3 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:23AM (#28105926)
You could argue that it is the way they pay for the distribution channels. I can't exactly go in and take a product in Wallmart and then pay target for it.

The way I see it, Apple and Google made the platforms worth something, made the stores, made the development tools, run the stores (which can't be cheap).

They could charge you a flat fee of several thousand dollars per app, but that would stifle competition too much. Instead they charge a percentage of what the app developer makes and ensures that as a user I can always trust the payment option to be save and, if I buy a subscription, to be easy to cancel.

They could allow you to pick your own payment provider, but then companies would still have to pay the 30% tax to Apple/Google, so what would be the point?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by simion314 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:36AM (#28105995)
>they charge a percentage of what the app developer makes

What seems perverse to me is they don't tax you on your profits, I am sure Google and Apple won't like the governments do the same to them.

Btw I understand it is super hard to implement a tax on profits only so it would make more sense IMo to give the developers a choice, pay on what you use (pay for bandwidth, for reviews, for dev tools licenses, for advertising) OR pay the tax. The small devs could chose the tax , the big developers would chose the first one , Apple will have less money from this giant devs but they could keep their high walls for a few more years(I prefer if Apple and Epic don't get a secret deal and this fight continues so judges and us uncover more data about this topic)

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by sitkack on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:47AM (#28106302)
The work done by the app stores isn't linear wrt to the purchase price. Clearly they shouldn't be taking a percentage cut.

Together, GA has a duopoly on app stores and they have set their fees to be the same. That one of them would consider buying the trouble maker on the other platform is just ... telling.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomjen3 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:55AM (#28106344)
I considered the option of pay for what you use, but those prices would have to be massive (tens of thousands of dollars per dev) to even start to make up for it. It would essentially be a monopoly gift for the biggest developers.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by simion314 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:35AM (#28106579)
That seems fishy, can you elaborate?

- bandwidth is not that expensive , so only if the giants would screw you over with inflated prices. You could force the giants to reveal how much it actually costs(though I seen that even in the face of a judge the bastards pretend they are clueless and avoid answering questions)

- app reviews, You pay per review or per hour, maybe you submit a game to Sony or MS and they want a review dude to play it all to ensure is not broken.

-ads , only if you want, this should be an auction system

- dev tools, you should only have to pay for Apple signing your stuff, compilers, SDKs, IDEs should be always an opion for the dev to chose.

Btw, I am including all stores in my critique (including Steam,Sony's Play Station, and Microsoft)

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by remus on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:25AM (#28106187)
I don't think anyone is arguing that Google/apple shouldn't be able to charge to use their stores. What is wrong is the amount they charge and the lack of options if you don't want to pay that fee.

In a non-monopolistic market you can take your business elsewhere. If you don't like apple and Google's cut, you have no options.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomjen3 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:53AM (#28106338)
You are welcome to create your own store or sideload on Android. I will agree with you on Apples store, I wished there was a way to override it hidden well within the settings.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:48AM (#28106665)
Aaah, the good old "you can create your own platform" argument. Please remind me again how that went for Parler and Gab.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomjen3 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:21AM (#28107355)
Both Gab and Parlor would have done fine if they had been allowed to create their own platform. I am assuming here that paypal will not dump a google competitor, nor will AWS.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Sunday August 22, 2021 @02:47AM (#28263447)
That's a big assumption when the ex-president of the US got banned from Twitter.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by krapp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:07AM (#28106797)
Both Parler and Gab are currently up and running, so they seem to be doing fine.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:48AM (#28107116)
Yes, they are running in the same sense that Xerox is a modern prosperous company and not a shadow of its former glory. It's beyond me how normal people push for centralized monopolies that can end you on a whim.

I have written a long-ish post but deleted it. I just wanna say this new left-capitalist doctrine really scares me. Communism all over again except instead of woke comrades at the Central committee censoring things we got young programmer thought police at trillion dollar companies cancelling you over usage of "blacklist", "master" or not respecting preferred pronouns in a git repo or email.

Don't worry, I'll check my privileges to become sufficiently woke and be a plus plus good warrior for justice.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by krapp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:15PM (#28107778)
You probably should have kept the older comment, as this one is a single vaguely on topic assertion followed up with a pseudointellectual word salad of snark and anti-progressive memes. I'm sure that's verysmart content on the forums you're used to but we try for something better here.

From what I can tell, Gab is the same cesspool that it always was. I assume the same about Parler but I don't know, since I don't have an account. Both still seem popular with Trumpists, QAnon and the alt-right, so I don't know what Xerox-like "former glory" you believe these platforms have lost, but Xerox is still a billion dollar corporation so...

And if having to abide by the terms of service of app stores, social media platforms, ISPs and the actual laws of the land are too "Communist", there's an entire dark web out there that will let anyone do or say just about anything.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:16PM (#28109736)
> I assume the same about Parler but I don't know, since I don't have an account. Both still seem popular with Trumpists, QAnon and the alt-right

I asked some other dude on this website - do you really want a country with one party in the control of everything (Congress, presidency, governors...)?

I am not from the US, but this is so bizzare to watch. Half of your country voted for Trump, and you just hand-wave them away as "Trumpists" as if they were nutjobs who should be censored. That's half the country which opinions you have just dismissed.

> And if having to abide by the terms of service of app stores, social media platforms, ISPs and the actual laws of the land are too "Communist", there's an entire dark web out there that will let anyone do or say just about anything.

Funny how no one mentions this in posts about China, North Korea, Iran, Syria or Daesh. They have just set their own rules, why should they be labeled as tyranical or authoritatian countries?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by krapp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:20PM (#28110672)
>do you really want a country with one party in the control of everything (Congress, presidency, governors...)

No, but if I have to choose one, I'm not choosing the one that believes in Satanic pedophile cults and Jewish space lasers, and that gathers neo-nazis like flies, so simple math says I have to choose the other one until my country gives me a viable option besides "lesser of two evils."

>Half of your country voted for Trump,

A popular bit of propaganda, but no, Trump never carried the mandate of half the country. In 2016, only about 56% of the voting-eligible population - already a subset of the entire population - voted. Between them, Trump and Clinton each got about 27% of the possible vote, and while Trump won the Electoral College, he lost the popular vote.

In 2020, 66.7% of eligible voters turned out to vote. Biden won with 51.8% of votes cast, against Trump's 46.8%.

>and you just hand-wave them away as "Trumpists" as if they were nutjobs who should be censored

It's common to refer to followers of a particular social, religious or political movement - particularly those associated with a cult of personality - by the name of their leader. I refer to the unique blend of populism, neo-reactionism, persecution complex and conspiracy theory that makes up Trump's politics, and that of his followers, as "Trumpism" and them as "Trumpists" in order to draw a distinction between them and the Republican and Conservative ideals they supplanted.

>Funny how no one mentions this in posts about China, North Korea, Iran, Syria or Daesh. They have just set their own rules, why should they be labeled as tyranical or authoritatian countries?

Well, for one thing, you're confusing the laws of those countries and extremist groups with the terms of service of social media platforms. Twitter isn't beheading anyone, and Facebook isn't sending anyone to concentration camps, so attempts to draw some kind of equivalence between them and totalitarian regimes don't really work.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @03:50PM (#28133401)
> No, but if I have to choose one, I'm not choosing the one that believes in Satanic pedophile cults and Jewish space lasers, and that gathers neo-nazis like flies, so simple math says I have to choose the other one until my country gives me a viable option besides "lesser of two evils."

Good luck waiting for a viable option. Edit: just realized, not sure if by the satanic pedophile cults you meant the Clintons. You know, the war hawk lady who laughs at videos of beheading while parodying Gaius Julius, one of the biggest mass murderers in history. And the current president, who sniffs children and incestously kisses their grandchildren.

As an outsider, politics in the US is complete shit, maybe instead of participating in tribalism of one side vs another you should seek out ways to hard-reset the system and introduce more political parties, as is common in Europe.

> Well, for one thing, you're confusing the laws of those countries and extremist groups with the terms of service of social media platforms. Twitter isn't beheading anyone, and Facebook isn't sending anyone to concentration camps, so attempts to draw some kind of equivalence between them and totalitarian regimes don't really work.

The end result for me as a user is the same. What's the difference between Facebook and Twitter voluntarily censoring any mention of Tommy Robinson and China censoring anything mentioning Tommy Robinson? In one case its authoritation government doing it, in the other it's some sleazy multinational corp with way too much power doing it. "gO StArT YoUr OwN pLaTfOrM"...

Now tell me, I saw you in a few threads already, usually arguing leftist talking points. Are you an astroturfer? The reason I am here wasting my time writing something that will go completely over you just to get back a response that dismantles my post pedantically point by point is that unfortunately USA exports a lot of stuff. We started getting the BLM/MeToo stuff in Europe too and it's completely absurd.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by TekMol on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:20AM (#28105919)
Your question implies that Google has a monopoly.

As far as I know this has not been agreed up on by a court so far. Or has it?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by MrStonedOne on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:38AM (#28105999)
How is that relevant?

If a court does find that, did they not have the monopoly before the court made their ruling?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by nix23 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:33AM (#28105975)
Well it's a duopoly Apple/Google you need one of the platforms to be remotely functional in today's world, online banking, buying tickets, corona certificates etc...
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by zepto on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:45AM (#28107541)
You can do all that with a $50 android phone.

Nothing about this so called duopoly prevents you from spending money on a gaming device if you like games.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by dvh on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:36AM (#28106239)
Some time ago there was comment on /r/gamedev from someone who implemented their own payment system and visa has like $20 payment cancellation fee, imagine someone buying a game skin for $1, then cancelling and you loose $19, suddenly 30% doesn't look like bad deal at all.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by commoner on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:48AM (#28106312)
There are payment processors that offer chargeback protection for much less than Google's and Apple's 30% fee. For example, both Stripe and PayPal only charge 0.4%.

Stripe Chargeback Protection: https://stripe.com/radar/chargeback-protection

PayPal Chargeback Protection: https://www.paypal.com/us/smarthelp/article/what-is-chargeba...

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by akudha on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:50AM (#28106328)
Woah. Now, how is this ($20 fee) not extortion?
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by travoc on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:21PM (#28107827)
How much do you think it costs a bank to collect and review evidence from the consumer and seller in a charge dispute?
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by capableweb on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:25AM (#28105934)
> How is it not illegal for the platform to force the use of their own payment service?

A) Legislators haven't caught up with how the (digital) world works, so they don't even understand what is happening

B) These "stores" are run by two of the biggest companies on the planet (Apple and Google), so big that they can afford to spend countless amount of money to lobby and influence the legislators so the discussions never even hit the table

C) Both of the above

> Isn't this classic misuse of a monopoly?

Not really. While the App Store has monopoly on distributing apps on iOS, Apple and iPhone are far off from being a monopoly as more people have Android phones. Android phones allow side-loading so can't really claim Android has any misuse of a (potential) monopoly.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by stephc_int13 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:43AM (#28106028)
Sideloading on Android is not viable. And Google is working hard to enforce this situation.

This might be a monopoly. Or at least, I think the current scrutiny from legislators is fully warranted and we should not jump to conclusions because AFAIK the jury will be out for a while.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by distances on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:29AM (#28106208)
Alternative app stores can finally do automatic updates with Android 12: https://www.xda-developers.com/android-12-alternative-app-st...

I don't know the details, but I imagine this is pre-emptive move from Google to avoid monopoly judgements.