News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:20AM (#28105916)
It is not a monopoly a per law definition across most jurisdictions.

Additionally playing sales commissions is a traditional practice in most markets.

Finally, maybe devs would appreciate to pay the 80 to 90% that used to be common on the Symbian, J2ME, BREW and Blackberry shops from mobile operators, about 15 years ago.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by stephc_int13 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:36AM (#28105993)
Armchair lawyers striking again...

I was there during the Symbian era, the commissions at the time were outrageous, but closer to 40-50% than 80-90%.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pydry on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:30AM (#28106216)
Monopolistic behavior in markets where you have limited market power is just shooting yourself in the foot.

I didnt even realize symbian HAD an app store.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by stephc_int13 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:21PM (#28107825)
They didn't, it was managed by carriers, mostly. And Handango on some devices like running Windows Mobile or PalmOS.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:44PM (#28108036)
They eventually did, it was called Ovi Store.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ovi_(Nokia)

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:44AM (#28106284)
Former Finland mobile phone company employee over here, the actual percentages depended pretty much on the territory.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by croes on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:36AM (#28106236)
Doesn't need to be a monopoly, could simply be case of illegal price fixing because all big players took 30%
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Dracophoenix on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:30AM (#28106546)
Is it really price fixing or just copying strategies? There comes a point where the optimal strategy for a firm is to simply do what every one else is doing. Price fixing requires an element of collusion.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:13AM (#28106846)
"the optimal strategy for a firm is to simply do what every one else is doing"

Such a convenient worldview, conpwtition doesn't exist, banks did nothing wrong prior to 2008, etc.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Dracophoenix on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:08AM (#28107266)
Competition requires players to remain in the game. No one is required to make a profit-losing decision realized or unrealized. If they do make such a decision, they're one step closer to going out of business. Survival is an incentive to taking the correct actions.

In an iterative prisoner's dilemma, the optimal solution is most often tit-for-tat or some variation of it. It's logical for one firm to do the same as another until it can obtain a strong hold on a profit-making activity that gives it more degrees of freedom with regards to its strategies. At that point a firm can move from merely surviving to experimentation or it can continue to milk the opportunity for all its worth.

Your cartel argument requires more than sameness of strategy. It requires motive and direct action towards achieving a forced equilibrium (e.g. willfully punishing other market players in concert to dissuade the use of alternative profit-making strategies).

I never brought up banks. What do they and the 2008 recession have to do with online stores and 30% cuts in 2021?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:38PM (#28107994)
"direct action towards achieving a forced equilibrium"

Do you expect the head of Apple and Google to sign a public document "hereby we form an illegal cartel"?

At a minimum the competition and market authority should take an interest as to why there is no competition. If they botheresld to investigate, maybe we would actually find out if there is any wrongdoing.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Dracophoenix on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:37PM (#28110341)
No. But I don't take a 30% cut as an indication of cartel-building when it has existed since Jobs first announced the App store in 2008 [1] and was done at a time where the Walmarts and Best Buys of the world charged 70% if not more. Quite recently Apple sought fit to reduce it's revenue share to 15% after the first year on the store store. Google has done the same. I wouldn't call putting more money in the pockets of developers a lack of competition.

[1]https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xo9cKe_Fch8

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomohawk on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:23AM (#28106178)
70% market share is considered a monopoly "on the face of it"

https://www.justice.gov/atr/competition-and-monopoly-single-...

Google holds many monopolies. Is the play store not a monopoly?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by nix23 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:37AM (#28105996)
While i agree with you that playstore is not a 100% monopoly, if anything it is a duopoly (Apple/google). But on the Marketing/AD's side it is definitely a monopoly, that should be addressed first i believe.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by roenxi on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:11AM (#28106135)
I'm not quite finding the angle here to state my thoughts clearly, but there seems to be a definition of monopoly at play in some of these threads that means something close to "I would make more money if Apple/Google made less, plus they already make lots of money so it isn't fair!".

Google/Apple having gained the trust of the market and acting as middlemen to sell access simply isn't monopoly activity. In the same way that renting out space in a commercial complex isn't.

There is no question they are running these stores to make an outrageous profit. But the monopoly would be expressed by how the gates are closed to alternate App Stores, or in Google is unfairly pushing competitors to their own Apps off the store to make a profit - which given that they generally provide their Apps for free is a hard argument to make. Nobody seems to be making either of those arguments. Particularly the first one would involve more references to Samsung being made.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by mjburgess on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:32AM (#28106223)
Suppose google's chrome started charging websites 30% of their revenue to be accessible in their browser. Is this an abuse of monopoly? Yes.

The issue is HNer's are still living in the "website era" of the internet -- that's ending. We're now in the app era. And devices are the browsers.

Their app stores are monopolies on their devices; in that the person who controls the road is a monopolist, despite the existence of air travel.

That android devices compete with ios devices is irrelevant, in as much as comcast/et al. can say, "go to a different state". The app store is an iOS monopoly -- the hardware apple provides is a road/telephone/browser device for access apps -- the new predominant mode of social/economic communication & infrastructure.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by roenxi on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:37AM (#28106243)
> Is this an abuse of monopoly? Yes.

It isn't though. That is my point, monopoly doesn't just mean big market share + you don't like it. Half the web would go dark to Chrome and everyone would dump the browser in a couple of months if they pulled a stunt like that. Because they don't have monopoly. They only have a very high market share because Chrome is the best browser.

If the best-browser part stops being true there is not reason for the highest market share part to stay true.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by mjburgess on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:26AM (#28106519)
Well I take 'monopoly' to be a pretheoretical concept tied to the moral concequentialist justification of markets: aggregate social benefits.

Ie., a monopoly is whatever situation gives rise to a situation where a company can set prices without regards to legitimate competitive market processes. Where 'legitimate' is effectively a concequentialist constraint concerning aggregate consumer benefit.

There are many theories of /when/ a company is a monopoly; including very narrow case law definitions around pricing.

The pretheoretical use of the term however is taken to permit a broader scope.

And lets be clear: a 30pc surcharge on all our economic activity (whether that be a mastercard or an apple) given no market justification has no justification.

Let there be many app stores on the iphone-- and we shall see what the market price on an app store. If it ends up being 30% then theres no objection.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by feanaro on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:51AM (#28107589)
> They only have a very high market share because Chrome is the best browser.

This is very much a matter of opinion, not something you can reasonably state with a straight face. A large part of Chrome's large market share is the fact that it comes installed as a default on more than half the world's phones and that it's heavily marketed by the world's largest search engine and video hosting website (owned by the same entity!).

It also good enough, for now.

It has nothing to do with it being the best, though.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:48AM (#28106318)
> Their app stores are monopolies on their devices; in that the person who controls the road is a monopolist, despite the existence of air travel.

Not when there are other roads to be taken, regardless of how many pot holes they have on them.

So buy another device, a feature phone, give money to Jolla, FairPhone, whatever.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:20AM (#28106890)
"So buy another device, a feature phone, give money to Jolla, FairPhone, whatever."

You are peddling a fantasy - my bank has mobile only access, and the app wont work on any alternative you lifted. The UK goverment app to apply for riggt to resde for European immigrants won't work either.

What the fuck am i meant to do with those phones?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:46PM (#28108056)
Switch bank if that is so important to you.

I only use banks that provide access via ATM and Web, in addition to apps.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:16PM (#28109301)
Should I also switch countries? I cant uproot my entire life just to spite google
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by pjmlp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:42PM (#28109912)
You don't need to switch country to spite Google, only be more clever with your options and vote with your wallets.

I still carry my Windows Phone around.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by mjburgess on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:27AM (#28106532)
airplanes exist, and theyre owned by a baron too
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:01AM (#28106378)
Is it? I mean, if you think the u. s., it's one thing, but worldwide google has something like 90% marketshare on phones.

That being said, if Google started charging monthly for play store, you can easily change. The same is not true for Apple

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by yyyk on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:26AM (#28106192)
>>How is it not illegal for the platform to force the use of their own payment service? Isn't this classic misuse of a monopoly? >It is not a monopoly a per law definition across most jurisdictions.

It's not so relevant whether the stores are a monopoly or not. They're doing anticompetitive behaviour and misuse of market power, that's illegal regardless.