News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomjen3 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:23AM (#28105926)
You could argue that it is the way they pay for the distribution channels. I can't exactly go in and take a product in Wallmart and then pay target for it.

The way I see it, Apple and Google made the platforms worth something, made the stores, made the development tools, run the stores (which can't be cheap).

They could charge you a flat fee of several thousand dollars per app, but that would stifle competition too much. Instead they charge a percentage of what the app developer makes and ensures that as a user I can always trust the payment option to be save and, if I buy a subscription, to be easy to cancel.

They could allow you to pick your own payment provider, but then companies would still have to pay the 30% tax to Apple/Google, so what would be the point?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by simion314 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:36AM (#28105995)
>they charge a percentage of what the app developer makes

What seems perverse to me is they don't tax you on your profits, I am sure Google and Apple won't like the governments do the same to them.

Btw I understand it is super hard to implement a tax on profits only so it would make more sense IMo to give the developers a choice, pay on what you use (pay for bandwidth, for reviews, for dev tools licenses, for advertising) OR pay the tax. The small devs could chose the tax , the big developers would chose the first one , Apple will have less money from this giant devs but they could keep their high walls for a few more years(I prefer if Apple and Epic don't get a secret deal and this fight continues so judges and us uncover more data about this topic)

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by sitkack on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:47AM (#28106302)
The work done by the app stores isn't linear wrt to the purchase price. Clearly they shouldn't be taking a percentage cut.

Together, GA has a duopoly on app stores and they have set their fees to be the same. That one of them would consider buying the trouble maker on the other platform is just ... telling.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomjen3 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:55AM (#28106344)
I considered the option of pay for what you use, but those prices would have to be massive (tens of thousands of dollars per dev) to even start to make up for it. It would essentially be a monopoly gift for the biggest developers.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by simion314 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:35AM (#28106579)
That seems fishy, can you elaborate?

- bandwidth is not that expensive , so only if the giants would screw you over with inflated prices. You could force the giants to reveal how much it actually costs(though I seen that even in the face of a judge the bastards pretend they are clueless and avoid answering questions)

- app reviews, You pay per review or per hour, maybe you submit a game to Sony or MS and they want a review dude to play it all to ensure is not broken.

-ads , only if you want, this should be an auction system

- dev tools, you should only have to pay for Apple signing your stuff, compilers, SDKs, IDEs should be always an opion for the dev to chose.

Btw, I am including all stores in my critique (including Steam,Sony's Play Station, and Microsoft)

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by remus on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:25AM (#28106187)
I don't think anyone is arguing that Google/apple shouldn't be able to charge to use their stores. What is wrong is the amount they charge and the lack of options if you don't want to pay that fee.

In a non-monopolistic market you can take your business elsewhere. If you don't like apple and Google's cut, you have no options.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomjen3 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:53AM (#28106338)
You are welcome to create your own store or sideload on Android. I will agree with you on Apples store, I wished there was a way to override it hidden well within the settings.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:48AM (#28106665)
Aaah, the good old "you can create your own platform" argument. Please remind me again how that went for Parler and Gab.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by tomjen3 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:21AM (#28107355)
Both Gab and Parlor would have done fine if they had been allowed to create their own platform. I am assuming here that paypal will not dump a google competitor, nor will AWS.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Sunday August 22, 2021 @02:47AM (#28263447)
That's a big assumption when the ex-president of the US got banned from Twitter.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by krapp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:07AM (#28106797)
Both Parler and Gab are currently up and running, so they seem to be doing fine.
Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:48AM (#28107116)
Yes, they are running in the same sense that Xerox is a modern prosperous company and not a shadow of its former glory. It's beyond me how normal people push for centralized monopolies that can end you on a whim.

I have written a long-ish post but deleted it. I just wanna say this new left-capitalist doctrine really scares me. Communism all over again except instead of woke comrades at the Central committee censoring things we got young programmer thought police at trillion dollar companies cancelling you over usage of "blacklist", "master" or not respecting preferred pronouns in a git repo or email.

Don't worry, I'll check my privileges to become sufficiently woke and be a plus plus good warrior for justice.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by krapp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:15PM (#28107778)
You probably should have kept the older comment, as this one is a single vaguely on topic assertion followed up with a pseudointellectual word salad of snark and anti-progressive memes. I'm sure that's verysmart content on the forums you're used to but we try for something better here.

From what I can tell, Gab is the same cesspool that it always was. I assume the same about Parler but I don't know, since I don't have an account. Both still seem popular with Trumpists, QAnon and the alt-right, so I don't know what Xerox-like "former glory" you believe these platforms have lost, but Xerox is still a billion dollar corporation so...

And if having to abide by the terms of service of app stores, social media platforms, ISPs and the actual laws of the land are too "Communist", there's an entire dark web out there that will let anyone do or say just about anything.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:16PM (#28109736)
> I assume the same about Parler but I don't know, since I don't have an account. Both still seem popular with Trumpists, QAnon and the alt-right

I asked some other dude on this website - do you really want a country with one party in the control of everything (Congress, presidency, governors...)?

I am not from the US, but this is so bizzare to watch. Half of your country voted for Trump, and you just hand-wave them away as "Trumpists" as if they were nutjobs who should be censored. That's half the country which opinions you have just dismissed.

> And if having to abide by the terms of service of app stores, social media platforms, ISPs and the actual laws of the land are too "Communist", there's an entire dark web out there that will let anyone do or say just about anything.

Funny how no one mentions this in posts about China, North Korea, Iran, Syria or Daesh. They have just set their own rules, why should they be labeled as tyranical or authoritatian countries?

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by krapp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:20PM (#28110672)
>do you really want a country with one party in the control of everything (Congress, presidency, governors...)

No, but if I have to choose one, I'm not choosing the one that believes in Satanic pedophile cults and Jewish space lasers, and that gathers neo-nazis like flies, so simple math says I have to choose the other one until my country gives me a viable option besides "lesser of two evils."

>Half of your country voted for Trump,

A popular bit of propaganda, but no, Trump never carried the mandate of half the country. In 2016, only about 56% of the voting-eligible population - already a subset of the entire population - voted. Between them, Trump and Clinton each got about 27% of the possible vote, and while Trump won the Electoral College, he lost the popular vote.

In 2020, 66.7% of eligible voters turned out to vote. Biden won with 51.8% of votes cast, against Trump's 46.8%.

>and you just hand-wave them away as "Trumpists" as if they were nutjobs who should be censored

It's common to refer to followers of a particular social, religious or political movement - particularly those associated with a cult of personality - by the name of their leader. I refer to the unique blend of populism, neo-reactionism, persecution complex and conspiracy theory that makes up Trump's politics, and that of his followers, as "Trumpism" and them as "Trumpists" in order to draw a distinction between them and the Republican and Conservative ideals they supplanted.

>Funny how no one mentions this in posts about China, North Korea, Iran, Syria or Daesh. They have just set their own rules, why should they be labeled as tyranical or authoritatian countries?

Well, for one thing, you're confusing the laws of those countries and extremist groups with the terms of service of social media platforms. Twitter isn't beheading anyone, and Facebook isn't sending anyone to concentration camps, so attempts to draw some kind of equivalence between them and totalitarian regimes don't really work.

Re:Google “contemplated buying some or all of Epic” to stop ... by VelkaMorava on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @03:50PM (#28133401)
> No, but if I have to choose one, I'm not choosing the one that believes in Satanic pedophile cults and Jewish space lasers, and that gathers neo-nazis like flies, so simple math says I have to choose the other one until my country gives me a viable option besides "lesser of two evils."

Good luck waiting for a viable option. Edit: just realized, not sure if by the satanic pedophile cults you meant the Clintons. You know, the war hawk lady who laughs at videos of beheading while parodying Gaius Julius, one of the biggest mass murderers in history. And the current president, who sniffs children and incestously kisses their grandchildren.

As an outsider, politics in the US is complete shit, maybe instead of participating in tribalism of one side vs another you should seek out ways to hard-reset the system and introduce more political parties, as is common in Europe.

> Well, for one thing, you're confusing the laws of those countries and extremist groups with the terms of service of social media platforms. Twitter isn't beheading anyone, and Facebook isn't sending anyone to concentration camps, so attempts to draw some kind of equivalence between them and totalitarian regimes don't really work.

The end result for me as a user is the same. What's the difference between Facebook and Twitter voluntarily censoring any mention of Tommy Robinson and China censoring anything mentioning Tommy Robinson? In one case its authoritation government doing it, in the other it's some sleazy multinational corp with way too much power doing it. "gO StArT YoUr OwN pLaTfOrM"...

Now tell me, I saw you in a few threads already, usually arguing leftist talking points. Are you an astroturfer? The reason I am here wasting my time writing something that will go completely over you just to get back a response that dismantles my post pedantically point by point is that unfortunately USA exports a lot of stuff. We started getting the BLM/MeToo stuff in Europe too and it's completely absurd.