News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dalbasal on Sunday July 25, 2021 @07:03AM (#27948271)
One of those "once you see it" articles.

It's a good example of art imitating art. On screen depictions of ER doctors zapping patients back to life with a defibrillator. Adrenaline shots to the heart. Gently putting bad guys to sleep with a concussive blow to the head.

Artists' dramatic depictions become cliche, and cliche becomes our norm. Good to stop and ponder, on occasion, how much of our worldview is shaped by such fallacies.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by TazeTSchnitzel on Sunday July 25, 2021 @08:27AM (#27948662)
There's all sorts of interesting and sometimes subtle negative impacts on the real world that inaccurate depictions in fiction have. I think these mainly happen for situations people are likely to only see in fiction rather than reality.

A mundane example is people turning up to court and behaving incorrectly because they're used to Hollywood depictions.

Another one is people thinking someone using a command-line on a computer must be “hacking”.

More troublesome is dramatically unrealistic depictions of minorities.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dalbasal on Sunday July 25, 2021 @08:43AM (#27948759)
Sure. Also, porn, romance novels, high school social life, prison, mafia, war, psychotherapy...

The world is full of examples where literary cliches have more influence on our biases and expectations than first or second hand experiences. We rarely observe other people falling in love, but we see it in movies and stories all the time.

Hence why this article is subtly brilliant. It reminds us how much of our "knowledge" is actually fiction.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dmix on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:38AM (#27949942)
A big one is 30+ year olds writing the screenplays and therefore dialogue of kids and teenagers which are always precocious and seem adult like. Which young people think they should be at a similar stage of development or imitate them.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by bsder on Sunday July 25, 2021 @07:13PM (#27953821)
I find the whole 25 year old playing a 15 year old more problematic.

Especially for girls, this gives a tremendously powerful incorrect body image signal.

However, even for guys, it's starting to get ridiculous--the actors always have their shirt off, are completely cut and have <5% bodyfat. The only boys who look like that at 15 are short, currently miserable as hell and cutting weight for a tournament (and probably on steroids, to boot).

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by ambicapter on Sunday July 25, 2021 @07:08PM (#27953788)
Or they think that what they're saying and thinking will come out similar to how it came out on the tv show...
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by rrauenza on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:05PM (#27965470)
We steered our kids from all of the Disney Channel tweener sitcoms.. they're awful in that way.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by ako on Sunday July 25, 2021 @07:21PM (#27953864)
Tv violence making us think the world is a much more dangerous place than it really is.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by krisoft on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:35AM (#27949074)
Absolutely. It is also crazy when literally conveniences influence people's thinking.

In serialised fiction where you have a set of "cast members" the writers sometimes feel that they should shake things up. Temporarily put out of action one or the other member of the recurring characters to see how the new group dynamics will evolve. One common trope is where a member of the heroes' group falls into coma. Hijinks happen, the rest of the group copes with the missing member, and a few episodes later when the writers get bored of the scenario they bring back the person from coma. And because the whole motivation for the coma was a plot convenience you will get a quick recovery. A dramatic scene usually occurs where the patient wakes up, frequently due to some stimulus from a friend. You are lucky if you can see one cut scene of the patient recovering afterwards.

Real life coma is nothing like this. In reality a high percentage of those in coma die. They can have all kind of involuntary movements which would confuse someone who expects a sleeping beauty coma. The recovery usually is a long, and arduous process even when someone wakes up and of course there are health risks even after the patient opens their eyes up. [1]

A few weeks ago I had a discussion with my dad. He told me about a friend of his who had a stroke and fallen into a coma. At the time when we talked the friend was unable to breath on his own since days. My dad was super concerned that the friend in question doesn't have life insurance. It felt as if it was a foregone conclusion to him that his friend is going to wake up, and is going to leave the hospital. His only worry was what is going to happen with him after. Now, how much of this was an understandable psychological coping mechanism, and how much of it was due to incorrect representation of coma patients in media is hard to tell. Sadly later the friend passed away.

Luckily my dad didn't had to make any care decisions about his friend. (Of course) But regular people get thrown into situations like that all the time, all around the world. It's already a very stressful situation as a baseline, and then on top of whatever is happening people have all kind of unreasonable expectations swirling in their heads as they go through it. And all because writers regularly run out of material and have a need to conveniently shake things up in their fictional worlds.

1: https://www.livescience.com/739-comatose-patients-falsely-de...

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by detaro on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:38AM (#27949093)
> My dad was super concerned that the friend in question doesn't have life insurance. It felt as if it was a foregone conclusion to him that his friend is going to wake up, and is going to leave the hospital

Wouldn't having life insurance be more relevant for the case where the friend doesn't wake up...?

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dhosek on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:46AM (#27949135)
That was my thought too, but I’m guessing that the commenter’s father was thinking that post-coma, it would be hard to qualify for life insurance at a reasonable rate.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by krisoft on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:49AM (#27950043)
Good question.

This happened in a European country (Hungary) There the health care is free at the point of consumption, so there was no question if he will be taken care of. The problem is if you were not paying your health insurance contributions prior to the illness, the tax authority might force you to pay the cost of your care after you are out of the hospital. Or at least that's how my dad explained to me his worry.

Medical debt is not fun, but clearly tertiary to the problem of not breathing, in my opinion.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by Sniffnoy on Sunday July 25, 2021 @01:25PM (#27951064)
Ah, so you meant health insurance, not life insurance?
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by SV_BubbleTime on Sunday July 25, 2021 @02:26PM (#27951591)
This definitely clears up the original post. Had the same question and couldn’t figure out a simple typo that made sense.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by rodgerd on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:27PM (#27954542)
"I'm not a stalker, I'm re-enacting the 80s teen comedies that I grew up with!"
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by r3trohack3r on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:26AM (#27949827)
I’ve always wondered how much our social interaction is defined by on-screen portrayals of social interactions.

Actors are doing their best to portray how humans behave, but some subset of humans observe a large portion of what “normal” behavior is through a screen. At some point, did humans begin imitating the actors to a large degree, while the actors continued imitating the humans? In other words, did art begin imitating art?

This thought was brought on by watching old movies. Either actors were much worse back then, or people behaved differently, or both. And to what degree did those actors shape today’s behavior?

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by MikeSchurman on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:52AM (#27950066)
Although I have no evidence to back this up, I believe many try to imitate film (or expect something) in their romantic life, which ends up with them having bad expectations and disappointment.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by b0rsuk on Sunday July 25, 2021 @12:38PM (#27950556)
One of my pet grievances is how love is portrayed. If you were to believe movies, you can get ANY woman if you're persistent enough. Then poor young boys and men set out in the world showering someone else in gifts and attention. Girls with narcissistic tendencies become more, more and more narcissistic and entitled.

Another very damaging myth is that kung fu will save you from muggers. Muggers may have no objections to stabbing you, and if they attack they often attack from surprise. Or really, that a fight looks anything like in a martial arts movie. Go watch a fight in a Karate or Judo championship. It's quite boring, contestants are quite evenly matched and move with respect to each other.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by hutzlibu on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:58PM (#27952395)
"If you were to believe movies, you can get ANY woman if you're persistent enough."

Anyone believing that, would also have to believe, that ANY woman can get YOU, if she is persistent enough. And most would clearly object to that, but yeah logic consistency is not usually a theme of movie romances or of the target audience.

"Another very damaging myth is that kung fu will save you from muggers"

But if you know kung fu (or any martial arts) on a high level, then yes, it usually will save you from muggers. Because martial arts at its core (unless we are talking only about the sports turnament situation) is about situational awareness ALL the time. Meaning you do not get close enough to a person, that might stab you, in the first place. You are aware of dangers. Of people posing threats. You check the persons and places around you for signs of trouble. So you are in control of the situation - so you can be calm. Even when there is indeed trouble. But if fear and anger are not controlling you, you can control the situation and diffuse it. (and knowing that you can take someone out in a moment, helps with the confidence, unless it feeds your ego seeking such moments)

Otherwise yes, martial arts masters bleed as anyone else. I think some world champion of kickboxing was killed in a bar fight. And the mystic glorifications of kung fu and co does lives on in the movies, but in reality it mostly vanished by real bullets

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boxer_Rebellion

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by samatman on Sunday July 25, 2021 @04:27PM (#27952627)
My Sifu in kung fu would get asked about muggers frequently, by new students.

He always stressed the importance of having the laces on your shoes tied, and practicing your wind sprints.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by thaumasiotes on Sunday July 25, 2021 @04:58PM (#27952854)
> My Sifu

This is itself an example of "art imitating art" as per upthread. English speakers use the word "sifu" as part of its own independent cultural tradition. They use it even in contexts where it makes no sense, surrounded by Mandarin references - notably in Kung Fu Panda and less notably here: http://gowdb.com/troops/6582 - because they are sure it's "Chinese".

But if you learned the word by studying Chinese you'd spell it shifu. The English word comes from exposure to southerners who make no distinction between "s" and "sh". But distinguishing those two sounds is not a problem for English speakers.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by samatman on Sunday July 25, 2021 @06:06PM (#27953368)
Shows what you know. Sifu is Cantonese, and that's how he spells it.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by thaumasiotes on Sunday July 25, 2021 @06:14PM (#27953423)
I'm curious where you think your comment contradicts mine.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by samatman on Sunday July 25, 2021 @07:29PM (#27953902)
What in detail? Ok.

> This is itself an example of "art imitating art" as per upthread.

In contradiction to your comment, this is an example of my correctly using Sifu's title, exactly as he spells and pronounces it.

> English speakers use the word "sifu" as part of its own independent cultural tradition.

In contradiction to your comment, I am using the word "sifu" as part of a cultural tradition which came to America from Cantonese-speaking Hong Kong. I'm an English speaker; you are wrong.

> They use it even in contexts where it makes no sense, surrounded by Mandarin references - notably in Kung Fu Panda and less notably here: http://gowdb.com/troops/6582 - because they are sure it's "Chinese".

This may be true, but in contradiction to your first sentence (which I may fairly consider the rest of the paragraph to continue), this is not an example of that.

> But if you learned the word by studying Chinese you'd spell it shifu.

In contradiction to your comment, if you learned the word from a Cantonese speaker you would spell it sifu, which is how it's pronounced. Cantonese is one of the languages called "Chinese", so you are wrong here.

> The English word comes from exposure to southerners who make no distinction between "s" and "sh".

The "southerners" you're referring to include the Cantonese, surely. Who pronounce that word /sifu/, not /ʃɚfʊ/, and spell it accordingly. This is precisely like saying gyoza should be spelled gyatze, or gato should be spelled chat. Meaningless!

> But distinguishing those two sounds is not a problem for English speakers.

Irrelevant.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by thaumasiotes on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:18PM (#27954497)
>> English speakers use the word "sifu" as part of its own independent cultural tradition.

> In contradiction to your comment, I am using the word "sifu" as part of a cultural tradition which came to America from Cantonese-speaking Hong Kong.

This isn't a contradiction; you're agreeing with me.

> The "southerners" you're referring to include the Cantonese, surely. Who pronounce that word /sifu/, not /ʃɚfʊ/, and spell it accordingly.

You might be surprised to learn how the Cantonese spell 师傅.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by MagnumOpus on Sunday July 25, 2021 @01:35PM (#27951177)
High level karate or judo (or boxing or MMA or Muay Thai) championships are usually only tactical and boring because they are evenly matched. They would all whip a „casual“ experienced martial artist within half a minute in a movie-like fashion, who in turn will be able to do that to the man on the street.

(Source: been there, done that, sparred and competed both against world class olympic martial artists as well as complete beginners.)

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by b0rsuk on Sunday July 25, 2021 @04:19PM (#27952563)
"another martial artist" already assumes that you're in some ways evenly matched - you're using the same weapons, and it's 1 on 1. What there are two, one with a metal bar and another with a broken bottle? People like to go in with overwhelming odds, that's why around 80% muggings are men against women. And the weapons they may have may be in their pockets. Fancy playing russian roulette? What if they don't attack one at a time, like in movies?
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by r3trohack3r on Sunday July 25, 2021 @07:30PM (#27953909)
Very much this. Most martial art studios teach over confidence and methods that fall flat on their face in the face of real assailants.

Preaching martial arts as a form of discipline or structure is fine as long as you don’t attach “self defense” to it. As soon as you’re teaching self defense, the content needs to change and very few studios tackle it well.

If your curriculum doesn’t teach:

* Pre-incident indicators

* Local law, when is violence justified

* De-escalation branching into explosive violence with maximum damage

* The goal is to escape safely, not submit your opponent (your opponent likely has friends, even if you don’t see them)

* The difference between defending blunt weapons, bladed weapons (don’t put yourself in the blender), and firearms

* Avoiding training “scars” from drilling (like handing a gun back to your opponent after a disarm, which I have second hand knowledge of someone doing in a real confrontation and dying)

* Coarse motor skills > fine motor skills (your adrenaline is pumping, relying on a technical fine motor skill to save your life isn’t going to go well)

You’re not prepared for street violence. Your self defense class is liable to get you killed if you ever need to use it.

So far my favorite honest take on self defense is Kelly McCann’s street combatives series. I’m sure there is better content out there.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by rrauenza on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:10PM (#27965527)
I've also heard this story of "handing the gun back"... In the context of aikido. I could never trace it back to anything. Is your 2nd hand knowledge also through aikido?
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by r3trohack3r on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @12:11PM (#27974127)
He was a Combatives instructor, the story was from a Krav studio he attended and it was another student there.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by rrauenza on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:16PM (#27965603)
My pet peeve is action movies that establish an emotional connection between the hero and the damsel with a obligatory sex scene (often a one night stand)... After which she is put into peril.

It's a lazy way to up the emotional connection between the two characters.

If I recall, more recent movies like Deadpool actually begin to work against it by the hero and damsel being in a long term relationship.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by Consultant32452 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:14AM (#27949310)
I’m not interested in a 2A debate but I find it really interesting how much public misunderstanding about firearms and firearms law comes from movies. One of the biggest is the concept of the “unregistered firearm” used in a crime. There is no firearm registry in the US, so all firearms are unregistered. However, the fact that this is prolific in crime movies leads many to believe such a registry exists. Another is the “Hollywood silencer.” Guns fired with a suppressor/silencer are still quite loud, but movies have people thinking you can have a shootout in a mall and no one will notice.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by nacs on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:01AM (#27949642)
> Guns fired with a suppressor/silencer are still quite loud

A great example of this is the scene from John Wick where Wick and a villain are in a crowd firing at each other with noone noticing.

There is a video with the gun sounds recreated to be more realistic:

https://youtu.be/ws8LAfD_3BA?t=13

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by neolog on Sunday July 25, 2021 @02:25PM (#27951580)
TIL

> Only those firearms subject to the National Firearms Act (NFA) (e.g., machineguns, short–barreled rifles and shotguns, silencers, destructive devices, and firearms designated as “any other weapons”) must be registered with ATF.

> Firearms registration may be required by state or local law. Any person considering acquiring a firearm should contact their State Attorney General’s Office to inquire about the laws and possible state or local restrictions.

https://www.atf.gov/questions-and-answers/qa/how-does-person...

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by Consultant32452 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:48PM (#27952319)
Here's a weird one about the NFA and "silencers." As previously mentioned, it's still pretty loud when you use one. In the US it's very restrictive to own one ($200 tax, 6+ month wait, registration, etc.) but in places like the UK it's the opposite. You're a noise polluter without one and relatively very simple to get even though in UK it's harder to get guns.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by detaro on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:50PM (#27952333)
That's been a topic in Germany too. They are banned, but some argue they really should be allowed as workers protection and to generally reduce noise disturbances.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by Consultant32452 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @04:02PM (#27952426)
We have this in the US too, the Hearing Protection Act: https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/95

But because movies anti-educate people on this subject it probably won't go anywhere.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by a1369209993 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @06:11PM (#27953399)
> Another is the “Hollywood silencer.” Guns fired with a suppressor/silencer are still quite loud, but movies have people thinking you can have a shootout in a mall and no one will notice.

Note that if you do want a mostly-silent, fairly-reliably-lethal ranged weapon, crossbows are probably a better option.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by neolog on Sunday July 25, 2021 @02:39PM (#27951721)
Yup. Even educational videos like [1] are probably using audio compression so they don't show the real loudness.

Research [2] shows suppressed small arms are still well over 100dB (e.g. landing airplane loud) at peak impulse.

[1] https://youtu.be/1VWcGwPJQfc?t=30

[2] https://www.researchgate.net/profile/William-Murphy-18/publi...

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by orthoxerox on Sunday July 25, 2021 @05:30PM (#27953091)
No amount of videos can teach you how loud a gun really is. Especially when you're holding it literally next to your ear to aim down the sights.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by Consultant32452 on Monday July 26, 2021 @09:56AM (#27959394)
When I go to an indoor range, even with two sets of hearing protection on, it takes me about 10 mins to stop flinching every time a shot is fired. And we're not talking about super weapons here, just common stuff like 9mm pistols. I think it's hard to convey in words just how LOUD guns really are.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by NavinF on Sunday July 25, 2021 @05:44PM (#27953194)
Yep. Another silly example is bullets bouncing around the room in movies and in supposed "true crime" fics. A friend of mine was being 100% serious when he raised that as a concern when I was talking about indoor gun ranges vs outdoor gun ranges. He had never seen bullets hitting anything IRL so he didn't know that bullets are made of soft lead and get somewhat squished before falling straight down along the wall.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by 1ris on Saturday July 31, 2021 @05:22PM (#28021665)
There are allegedly "Hollywood silent" weapons, tho. VP-1 and PSS are said to very silent. They are said to make less noise than a clap when fired.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by DoreenMichele on Sunday July 25, 2021 @02:37PM (#27951699)
I think this is actually art imitating science, but that's a quibble.

As for the rest, I heartily agree. I've been thinking about that here lately, how we watch movie fights and they are typically highly choreographed and often visually beautiful forms of dance that likely have nothing at all to do with what real violence looks like.

Not that I want to promote real violence, but I wonder what impact that has on human psychology and how unrealistic it makes some of our expectations when dealing with actual reality when it fails to match up to what we have fed our brains via various forms of media.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dalbasal on Sunday July 25, 2021 @04:00PM (#27952417)
Fair point.

However... I have an illustrates copy of "Origin of Species," with Darwin's original drawings. It's quite beautiful. Naturalists of the day used a style of drawing. It was utilitarian, good for identification purposes. But, it's almost impossible not to see it as an artistic tradition too.

Point taken though. This style originates in science, and they had reasons for their style.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by mushbino on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:56AM (#27949603)
I just finished the book Fantasyland by Kurt Anderson. Much of our reality and especially our worldview is constructed and bears no resemblance to reality.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by ronenlh on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:13AM (#27949301)
“live butterflies don’t look like butterflies in pictures, you gotta use dead ones” is like in the Simpsons: “Cow's don't look like cows on film. You gotta use horses.”
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dTal on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:30AM (#27949040)
I'm slowly coming to the highly unpopular view that all fiction is essentially a lie, and therefore damaging. Your brain does not distinguish meaningfully between truth and fiction, at an emotional level. Yes, you can tell stories that capture some sort of essential truth - but writers don't typically hold themselves terribly closely to that standard, and in any case the time is better spent telling of things that actually happened. Every mutilation applied to actual events - in the service of making them supposedly more entertaining - clouds our understanding of them. And it's done on purpose! Inglourious Basterds is an abomination, a deliberate cognitohazard.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dalbasal on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:35AM (#27949071)
Well... If you also come around to the view that most nonfiction is fiction too... you might find yourself in a pretty nihilistic place.

Those depictions of butterflies are intended to be nonfiction.. naturalism. A precise and true representation of butterflies, an artistic culture that people like Darwin were steeped in.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by pixl97 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:47AM (#27949139)
I was going to reply something similar. We dont have access to much thermodynamic truth and the vast majority of our experience is fictionalised in one way or another when it is later described.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by eru on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:13AM (#27949300)
That's a good reason why archaeologists are so keen on digging in garbage. Garbage doesn't lie as much as the written word.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midden

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dalbasal on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:53AM (#27949567)
The garbage itself may not lie, but the process of turning garbage into history is still storytelling. It's very hard to escape. Most anything meaningful, to us, is a story.

A fully empirical/popperian approach to knowledge isn't workable. Or rather, it's extremely sparse. You have to accept that you know almost nothing.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by eru on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:04AM (#27956881)
Well, I guess the full empirical approach would involve a lot of betting and prediction markets?

If you watch or read any business news, people always readily invent just-so stories about why the stock market moved this way or that. So that's the effect you are describing in full effect.

But making many (hopefully successful) predictions in a row is a good yardstick to keep yourself honest buy. See also Slatestarcodex's annual predictions and scoring. Or Bryan Caplan's string of bets.

(Btw, as long as you are not trying to outguess the markets, it's almost too easy to make mostly successful predictions: just predict whatever the market predicts.)

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by indigo945 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:39AM (#27949094)
Any reason you're singling out Inglourious Basterds in particular?

In general, though, I do not believe that this problem is at all limited to the kind of art that we commonly dub as "fiction". For example, in the 19th century, travel diaries of colonial "explorers" were a very popular form of literature consumed by the educated classes in the colonial metropole, and they consisted almost entirely of distortions, willful or accidental omissions and often outright lies. Yet, they helped shape the view the West has of "oriental" cultures and peoples, with many of these cliches persisting even to the current age (i.e. "Orientalism").

Therefore, following your logic, all scientific works are damaging.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by narag on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:35AM (#27949452)
Any reason you're singling out Inglourious Basterds in particular?

Embellishing stories has kind of a social function: to sugar-coat our vision of life. Reality is scary.

When the author presents a blatant lie just because, it's only annoying. At least for me, that movie and the last one are a scam. Sure, there must be a "profound" explanation of director's intentions.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by orhmeh09 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:49AM (#27950044)
Most children quickly develop an appreciation for the distinction between things clearly delineated and presented as fiction before they hit double digits of age. It’s quite peculiar to accuse artists of trying to scam you. Have you ever played a video game? What do you think of them?
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by narag on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:53AM (#27956469)
Not sure the source but there is a rule in fiction that everything has a purpose, as opposed to reality. If the camera stops in an axe, you can be sure someone is going to wield it later.

There is no purpose in those alternate realities, other than being a sadistic fantasy, as another comment points to. Tarantino's universe is very familiar to me. It's based on the series B (or worse) films that we watched as teens.

There is an interesting exploration in Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction and Kill Bill of the obsessive thoughts that old movies raised presenting extreme situations.

I do enjoy goofy details like Uma Thurman in the plane with a katana in the hand luggage. But this is part of the assumed over-the-top tone. Like you said, it's clearly delineated and presented as fiction. The others not so much. A counterfactual historic movie? Now it seems I'm supposed to learn about the plot before watching the movie, or just avoid Tarantino, because I've had enough of that bs.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by speakeron on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:24PM (#27964960)
> Not sure the source but there is a rule in fiction that everything has a purpose, as opposed to reality. If the camera stops in an axe, you can be sure someone is going to wield it later.

That's from Anton Checkov.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chekhov%27s_gun

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dalbasal on Sunday July 25, 2021 @12:01PM (#27950145)
The authors stated intention was to depict a widely held, indulgent, sadistic fantasy.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by ineedasername on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:28AM (#27949413)
time is better spent telling of things that actually happened

How do you know what actually happened outside of your direct experience? Anything that occurred outside the direct experience of a still-living human is known only through the stories people at the time told each other about it: incomplete, imperfectly remembered, biased towards the accounts of survivors who lived to tell their stories or those powerful enough to have their voices heard, even when all involved have the best of intentions of an accurate retelling. Unless the event made a sufficient impact on the physical world (which is itself going to be a very incomplete picture of events) then events older than ~80 years are accessible to us only through such stories.

If you think deliberate fiction is damaging because the human mind doesn't fully distinguish it from truth, even when it knows it to be fiction, then you must hate accounts of "what actually happened" even more: They are often incorrect and yet label themselves as truth, so the human mind is even more likely to take as "truth" something that is incorrect. If the human mind does not always distinguish fiction clearly, then it is even less capable of discerning incorrect accounts of what actually happened from those that are more accurate.

Let's take Inglorious Bastards as an example: What is more damaging, a dark comedy that presents itself as a fiction loosely inspired by actual events? Or a selective sampling of events that presents itself as the truth in denying events like the Holocaust-- something made ever more possible as time passes and those with direct experience die off?

Butterflies in this case are an excellent example of the problems of non fiction as well: The dead butterflies accurately depict what a butterfly looks like by using a pose that shows its full detail a bit better. But in providing that detail it loses the nuance of how a butterfly would look in the wild. And yet a pose from the the wild would give less information about its full visual detail, and no single pose from the wild could fully encapsulate its natural state. This is for one small living thing that we can observe now, today. How much more incomplete of a picture must we have of older events?

If you are disregarding fiction for the reasons you gave, you must also disregard nearly all aspects of prior accounts of human events as being similarly flawed and even more pernicious for their claims of being the truth.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by kbenson on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:08PM (#27951963)
Always fun to type up a 10 minute reply on my phone only to find after I post it that someone has said essentially the same core thing hours previously. ;)
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by ineedasername on Sunday July 25, 2021 @04:37PM (#27952701)
We'll, we're mostly tech folks or appreciative of tech: we don't mind, and even encourage, a few levels of redundancy :)

In this case you never know what will get noticed an upvoted to the attention of others. Some repetition for of various viewpoints, especially when made with different nuances, is a good thing.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by Cybotron5000 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:35AM (#27949455)
Fiction (/well-written fiction at least) is an artform, like music or, um, art, or even design you know? It’s a communication medium meant (amongst other things) to convey something of the human experience that is perhaps intangible or illogical. Fiction is normally very honest and open about not being factual. I take your point though that when people take fictions as truth, whether through the reader’s ignorance, or the writer’s misrepresentation, that can be extremely problematic - that is not the fault of fiction I would argue though, but rather of the context/audience that receives it/the manner in which they interpret it (I suppose there are exceptions like parodies/eg. ‘War Of The Worlds’ or something?). I currently read much less fiction than I used to when I was a kid (my mum was an English teacher), but I can assure you that my brain is almost always perfectly capable of distinguishing between the two on some level. I may choose to suspend my disbelief or feel feelings prompted by the material, but am simultaneously aware that this is not objective reality. I agree with your point though that much fiction/fictionalised material that has been interpreted as real has caused much damage - people really like stories (isn’t this an inherent part of our psychology?) and tend to inevitably construct them around even the most dispassionate material (in the same way we tend to anthropomorphise stuff I guess?). Trick is we need some training to help us ‘read’ media with a questioning/‘between the lines’ sort of rationale/focussed attention/looking for bias/manipulation/being self-aware etc etc…
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by coopierez on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:45AM (#27949134)
Not all fiction is attempting to tell a story and pass it off as realistic. A lot of fiction is deliberately and transparently fantasy. A lot of fiction is also metaphorical.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by kbenson on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:04PM (#27951929)
> I'm slowly coming to the highly unpopular view that all fiction is essentially a lie, and therefore damaging.

Does nobody read with a critical eye? I know sometimes I have to give up on a story or series if the things I'm asked to accept pass a boundary, and they're kept consistent.

> Every mutilation applied to actual events - in the service of making them supposedly more entertaining - clouds our understanding of them.

It's impossible to convey with absolute accuracy any event. I would hazard that any representation no matter how accurate it tries to be will be riddles with inaccuracies or assumptions that are represented through bias.

We're screwed from the outset because we're incapable of accepting all the possible stimuli of a situation (and so are recording devices), and any event is also only a part in a series which adds context.

To that you add that it's impossible to impart your own experience without bias (and the imparting of personal experience is the only way to get details other than what we can record automatically), which adds quite a bit to any event.

Everything is something we're getting through a skinner box, and whether marketed as fact or fiction, you have to make choices on what is true or not. Painting fiction with a broad brush as negative likely won't help in the end. All you're doing is taking the inputs that tell you up front they're not necessarily true in the sense of real events (even if they may try to make you think about fundamental things in ways you didn't consider, which is useful) and removing them to prioritize things that are also untrue in some way, but don't have the decency to own up to it.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by hutzlibu on Sunday July 25, 2021 @01:39PM (#27951210)
"Inglourious Basterds is an abomination, a deliberate cognitohazard."

I have to strongly disagree here. Since it was soo absurd, it was obviously a work of fiction. A surreal funny one at that. A gang of jews that blows up Hitler? Yes, a movie can do that. Anyone taking it literal, has definitely other problems in life.

But I do have a problem with movies, that pretend to be historical authentic - but are not. And are therefore effectivly rewriting history. And sadly most, if not all "historic" hollywood productions fall into that category.

This is where I see the problem - when the lines get blurry.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by kbenson on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:14PM (#27952024)
Thankfully, with the recent increase in the popularity of documentary series, people can see two separate takes of an event, for select events, which make it more obvious to the common person the liberties that are taken to make a good movie compared to tell an accurate story.

If we're all lucky, more people will start realizing that it doesn't stop at Hollywood, and there's no reason to expect the documentary was absolutely correct and without bias either (in some respects documentaries can be much worse since they often purport to be unbiased and correct).

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by hoseja on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:01AM (#27956858)
I think the poster is argumenting that even if you recognize it as pure fiction, it still affects you emotionally as if real, at least a little bit.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by hutzlibu on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:26AM (#27957038)
Yes, it is a real story and real stories should affect emotionally. Otherwise no one would want to see a movie. That is part of good storytelling.

It is just not a real historic story and it does not aim to be one. So I do take a bit offense at the characterization from the parent poster as a abomination.

I actually share some of the sentiment - that it is not wise to numb and confuse the mind only with fiction. But fantasy and fiction is a very core part of what makes us human. Or do you take offense that your dreams at night are not real? Having fantasy and imagination is a good thing. It only becomes problematic when people cannot seperate fantasy from reality anymore. And yes, that is a big problem.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by croes on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:25AM (#27949390)
>all fiction is essentially a lie

That's why it's fiction.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by makeitdouble on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:05AM (#27949674)
You can come the other side and accept that all stories, fiction or not, are pure cultural constructions, and choose ones that benefit you on a daily basis.

Some stories will help you overcome chalenges in your life, others will nurture your respect for people, others remind you people you love.

You choose the lies you believe in, hopefully you find ones that help you live your life.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by SamoyedFurFluff on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:37AM (#27949082)
How would you recommend exploring truths that may end up being too politically charged to explore except through fiction? For some time the only way LGBTQ+ and race relations explorations could only occur through fiction. (Arguably, exploring the trans experience can often be limited to exploration through fiction.)
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by AlexTWithBeard on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:53AM (#27949564)
> LGBTQ+ and race relations explorations

Every time I watch a fictional movie about some social issue I ask myself: I've just watched an imaginary story that never happened played by actors who actually never experienced it. Now what?

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by SamoyedFurFluff on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:40AM (#27949969)
Consider that maybe the social issue has lived experiences that couldn’t be safely explored in nonfiction, or maybe the importance such as being validated that your personal experience isn’t a delusion wasn’t for you.

Additionally chances are that with the way progressive pushes are going (blackface/yellowface/white actors playing nonwhite characters is swiftly going out of style) the actors may actually experience the themes being explored. I’m pretty sure black people playing black people in movies about black race relations may have personal experiences with such!

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by AlexTWithBeard on Sunday July 25, 2021 @12:53PM (#27950734)
> (blackface/yellowface/white actors playing nonwhite characters is swiftly going out of style)

We now only have to make sure the chess players are impersonated by real FIDE masters and Queen Elizabeth by someone who has at least 1/8th royal blood.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by eru on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:14AM (#27949307)
Perhaps look farther afield?

Eg race relations were pretty bad in the US, but in the UK, culturally still pretty accessible, a black person could always use money to buy status.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by SamoyedFurFluff on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:39AM (#27949483)
I still think in the UK there was limited appetite for nonfiction accounts of racism of UK people. (There may still be limited appetite for effusively positive nonfiction about Travelers, or general nonfiction about the Troubles that may be taking “a side”.)
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dTal on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:48AM (#27950029)
>effusively positive nonfiction

"Effusively positive" sounds like it would be deliberately distorting reality in order to present a point. I'm sure there's plenty of appetite for accurate documentaries about Travelers.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by SV_BubbleTime on Sunday July 25, 2021 @02:36PM (#27951681)
> "Effusively positive" sounds like it would be deliberately distorting reality in order to present a point. I'm sure there's plenty of appetite for accurate documentaries about Travelers.

One of the Assassin‘s Creed games has an exploration mode, and if you walk by one of the outdoor “classrooms” the narrator will explain that while they show boys and girls learning together, the reality was that only boys were present in the schools, and that the creators here specifically chose to show the way it “should have been“.

They spent some unknown amount of money on this major feature that toured all around their map, tons of real photos and documentary about how they captured the feel, interviews with historians… centering on historically accurate, but when it came to controlling their own wokeness for a second, they had to present the “effusively positive“.

I don’t care what they do, but it was an admission that they didn’t really care about nonfiction, and made me untrustful of the remaining content.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by eru on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:00AM (#27956849)
I don't know, seems like a reasonable compromise to explain what changes they made?
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by hprotagonist on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:00AM (#27949213)
I’d suggest that to understand this matter in more detail, watching Rashomon might be useful —- but that basically tanks your argument.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by kbutler on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:23AM (#27949803)
The fact that our brains can recall fantasy as reality is a form of "misattribution". It's only one of many ways that our memories are inaccurate, to speak nothing of the various biases and inaccuracies that are incorporated even in the most faithful attempts at recording or reporting factual stories.

To paraphrase a common aphorism - all stories are false, but some are useful.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by howaboutnope on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:25AM (#27949818)
I hate just dropping a wall of quotes, but I also don't want to say the same thing in more and worse words... so I put my response on pastebin as a compromise ^^ https://pastebin.com/L18AvH13
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by SV_BubbleTime on Sunday July 25, 2021 @02:38PM (#27951714)
The Big Brother one was jarring. Too much.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by CharlesW on Sunday July 25, 2021 @02:01PM (#27951378)
> I'm slowly coming to the highly unpopular view that all fiction is essentially a lie…

This isn't just "not unpopular" but universally, intrinsically understood.

“We all know that Art is not truth. Art is a lie that makes us realize truth at least the truth that is given us to understand. The artist must know the manner whereby to convince others of the truthfulness of his lies.” ― Pablo Picasso

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZZBfZyJ-2s

> …and therefore damaging.

This claim that "all fiction is damaging" is inconceivable to me. How does one develop empathy if one is incapable of imagining anything other than what they've directly experienced?

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by JTbane on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:29PM (#27952166)
Okay, Plato, I guess we should ban poetry for corrupting the youth...
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by manachar on Sunday July 25, 2021 @01:24PM (#27951053)
Of course all fiction is a lie.

All words are a lie. All narratives are built of symbols and cliches and agreed upon fictions in an attempt to point to reality. Reality is a thing we cannot touch or experience directly and is always filtered by our tools, experiences and perceptions. Even math might be merely a model, one where we convince ourselves integers actually exist (where does one thing become separate from another when reality seems to be built of atoms with probabilistic shells of elections and waves of electromagnetic interactions?)

As for being harmful? Well, fiction and non-fiction narratives are all powerful tools for shaping how we perceive of our reality. They can be harmful or helpful. Some of our favorite fictions are things like justice, freedom, liberty, or any conception that we all have rights.

Additionally, when we tell fictions we are crafted a world we can aspire to. We make gods and heroes to imagine what it would be like to be better. We make villains and demons to remind us of what we should avoid. Without these I do not believe we would be in a better place. One could even call these noble lies.

Of course, this does mean fiction can be dangerous and should be selected carefully. Ayn Rand has a peculiarly powerful hold over people because her fictions are good at making a deep impression on people. Vacation Bible Schools and overtly Christian education are aimed at controlling the narrative young minds receive. Then there's the constant mythologizing of history done to legitimize modern political stances (e.g. Civil War was some sort of lost cause about state's rights, Mayflower was the first "real" colony, founding "fathers" were near perfect, etc.).

Narratives are powerful. Worth noting Plato came to your same conclusion in his Republic. Essentially deeming all myth and plays and stories as too dangerous to be allowed.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by yesenadam on Sunday July 25, 2021 @08:08PM (#27954132)
> All words are a lie.

I'm having a hard time believing that you believe that. e.g. Take the words "All", "words", "are", "a", and "lie"—they are all lies?!

I can't think of a way most of these words could even conceivably be a lie; a lie is most usually a statement or sentence, or built from those. To say that words "are a lie"..well, I think I must misunderstand you, yet reading the rest of your comment, it seems you meant the literal meaning. Although mostly you talk of narratives and fictions.

Also, it seems you are using "a lie" to mean "false", the way people sometimes do, although they are two very different things. "All words are untrue/false" doesn't sound so impressive, I guess, or "No words are true" etc.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by manachar on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:00AM (#27955502)
When I say all words are a lie I am aiming for the same observation of Magritte's "Ceci n'est pas une pipe" or the old koan about the finger and the moon.

Arguing about whether it's a lie (i.e. intentionally deceptive) or "just" untrue in a non-legal setting seems pedantic.

Words lie to us. They make all appearances at being the thing we are referencing without a lick of their reality. Worse, we sometimes forget that words are just agreed upon fictions and use arguments about those fictions instead of getting at the reality of the matter.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by yesenadam on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:23AM (#27956296)
I don't think it's pedantic at all. It seems to me rude of you to say so. It's a very important distinction in everyday life, including in HN comments, between saying something that isn't true, and actually lying.

No-one thinks the word "pipe" is a pipe, nor does it claim to be a pipe.

And amid your claims of words being totally unreliable and deceptive, you seem to think I will know exactly what you mean by your words. Etc. Let's agree to disagree.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by JohnHaugeland on Monday July 26, 2021 @09:40AM (#27959223)
You are extremely pedantic. This is a fact, and in no way an insult even if wrong, despite that you may dislike it.

All ten of your last ten comments are you attempting to teach strangers, without having been asked, despite not being an expert, based in your beliefs, without evidence.

It seems likely that the reason you feel insulted is that you know that it's true and don't want to face it

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by yesenadam on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:52PM (#27966475)
Hehe ok, that sounds damning.

> All ten of your last ten comments are you attempting to teach strangers, without having been asked, despite not being an expert, based in your beliefs, without evidence.

So I looked.. ready to face an unpleasant truth about myself. I was pleasantly surprised that "All ten" is nothing like true.

1. > Yup, better would be "pronounce a surname from a non-English speaking culture in a way that sounds reasonably correct."

Here I was agreeing with the parent.

2. > > "A" as in the "au" in "caught"

> Not an expert, but I can't offhand think of a language where this is even approximately how a is pronounced—which ones are you thinking of?

Parent and others evidently agreed as they soon changed the line to "A" as in "ah" (like "ah, I see"). Someone replied to my comment with a helpful link, my next comment was to quote from their link what I'd learnt from it, in the hope others could learn that too.

Hmm I notice most of these threads now have your comments added, the kind of comment which more nearly fits your description of mine, I have to say.

The next two comments are in this thread, me objecting to "All words are a lie".

4. My next comment was in response to an AskHN, Why is Martin Gardner no longer popular

> Well, first I'd want to confirm or not the assumption in the question: Isn't he? Popular compared with when? etc.

I see you have replied to that one too now, in part :

"HN has too many people who attempt to look wise by doubting things without cause, when the actual wise thing is not to discuss your doubts, but to address them

Unfortunately, the normal behavior is invisible, so people randomly admonishing one another gains the false appearance of being regular...

> Popular compared with when?

The past.

The sentence makes this clear and unambiguous, as does our lack of time travel. "

Ok.. that's getting creepy and silly. Please stop commenting on my comments. Your initial damning criticism of me seems to apply much more nearly to you, as is extremely common when advice or insults are given on this planet. Bye. I will report you immediately if you continue doing this. It's nowhere near OK. Stay away from me.

(I looked at 5 further recent comments of mine, none of them at all fit your description. There's a few like "That's a fascinating book, and led to a fascinating wikipedia rabbit hole, thank you!" I'm puzzled how you came up with your "All ten", I think you didn't even look. Very strange.)

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by yourenotsmart on Sunday July 25, 2021 @08:06AM (#27948559)
This probably disproves the hypothesis that consciousness shapes reality, because if it did, the millions of brainwashed people watching movies would have turned the reality into a set of movie tropes.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by beebeepka on Sunday July 25, 2021 @08:31AM (#27948693)
Not sure I understand what you're trying to say here. Do you agree people are influenced by movies or not?

I think we all immitate and there's very little, if any, truly original... thoughts/behaviours

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by sethammons on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:06AM (#27949682)
I take their meaning as a poke at those who believe that "if you will it, it will be." There were some who believe(d) if you gathered a stadium of people and told them all to think about the candle in the center of the stadium self-igniting that through the power of shared belief it would. If this were true, then, to op's point, a bunch of reality would be changing to match people's mental expectations as influenced through media tropes. And since we don't see that, then people's thoughts likely don't influence reality.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by TazeTSchnitzel on Sunday July 25, 2021 @08:29AM (#27948679)
Why can't they have subtle impacts?
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by yourenotsmart on Sunday July 25, 2021 @08:40PM (#27954275)
Subtle impact is always a given as people affecting their own understanding affects their actions, and their actions shape the reality around them.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by cratermoon on Sunday July 25, 2021 @07:56PM (#27954068)
Hackers typing out ... well, anything. Or the worst of all: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkDD03yeLnU
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by geoduck14 on Sunday July 25, 2021 @08:09PM (#27954136)
Lolol. I was hoping for NCSI's "we must hack faster... TWO people on the same keyboard"
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by cratermoon on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:06PM (#27962866)
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by sneak on Sunday July 25, 2021 @05:39PM (#27953157)
In movies, the phone would revert immediately back to a dial tone when the other party hung up.

That's not how any phones ever worked even back when they used dial tones.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by b0rsuk on Sunday July 25, 2021 @08:36AM (#27948734)
I like the phrase "art imitating art", but it's broader than that. For example people with no interest in antique, Greece or Sparta are fans of Spartans. In reality, Sparta was a North Korea of the antique world, AND it had profoundly average combat performance. No matter how you slice it, they were completely average as far as won battles go!

https://acoup.blog/2019/09/20/collections-this-isnt-sparta-p...

If you filter out naval battles, it doesn't change anything. If you remove battles where they fought in a coalition with other Greeks, their win rate even drops slightly.

There is some evidence they may have had a slight advantage in leadership, because they had more leaders and their units were a bit smaller so they could perhaps operate more independently and seize opportunities on a field of battle (a strategy perfected by Romans). But overall, their strategy was bad even by antique standards - check out the Peloponesian War (with Athens). Spartans just had a good PR.

Dead butterflies is a meme (in the old meaning of viral idea). Spartan military excellence is a meme too.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by kleton on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:37AM (#27949466)
Some criticism of Acoup's analysis of their combat performance. All of the defeats listed are either not infantry battles or ones where Sparta was heavily outnumbered. It's hardly surprising that they would lose battles over 500 v 1000, and no contemporary commentators claimed that man for man they were that much better than their peer poleis. If you did a "wins above replacement" analysis for pitched infantry battles, they would come out ahead, at least until the Battle of Tegyra (375), when Boeotians had figured out an effective infantry doctrine after years fighting Sparta.

Plutarch on the Theban victory over Sparta at Leuctra (371).

>For in all the great wars there had ever been against Greeks or barbarians, the Spartans were never before beaten by a smaller company than their own; nor, indeed, in a set battle, when their number was equal. Hence their courage was thought irresistible, and their high repute before the battle made a conquest already of enemies, who thought themselves no match for the men of Sparta even on equal terms.

That battle wiped out the Spartiate class for a generation, killing 400 out of 700. This opened the way for Thebes to liberate Messenia in 370, which was the majority of the Lakonian helots, and it was all downhill for Sparta after that.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by karpierz on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:45AM (#27949515)
I think if you're going to do an analysis of military strength, you have to do it in context of the political system that produces it. If your society results in supersoldiers, but also causes you to regularly fail at diplomacy and end up outnumbered in wars which you end up losing, I wouldn't say that your military record is successful.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by kbenson on Sunday July 25, 2021 @02:40PM (#27951733)
But this isn't really an analysis of military strength as much as one of unit strength, if I understand what's being presented.

The meme isn't that Sparta was awesome, the meme is that spartan soldiers and units are awesome.

I don't think most people think that a society that turns it's children out on the street to fend for themselves to toughen the ones that survive is good or worth any awe, but that doesn't mean that people can't look at the end result and think one specific aspect is worth respect.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by kleton on Sunday July 25, 2021 @10:50AM (#27949550)
They won the Peloponessian war (plenty of diplomacy and coalition building) and remained dominant until 371, which was the first war they lost. It was a pretty respectable record.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dmix on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:33AM (#27949892)
I’m not seeing much connection to North Korea here.

They have awful diplomacy, no real coalitions (besides China which is more of a complete one sided economic dependency and a constant source of trouble), a poor military track record besides perfecting sabre rattling and a single small US ship from the 1950s as their most prominent war prize, no one is trying to imitate them, they rely heavily on raw numbers over ability in a defensive posture built up over generations, etc.

I’m trying to think of where the analogies begin…

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by b0rsuk on Sunday July 25, 2021 @12:28PM (#27950449)
Brutal dictatorship. 90% of population living in poverty (The Helots in Sparta were hunted for sport by Spartiates, particularly as a coming of age ritual).
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by birdyrooster on Sunday July 25, 2021 @02:38PM (#27951713)
Did they kidnap foreigners to do research or translation?
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by danielheath on Sunday July 25, 2021 @07:36PM (#27953957)
AFAIK, At that point in history “kidnap foreigners for their labour” was a feature of every settlement over a few hundred people in size.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by b0rsuk on Sunday July 25, 2021 @12:16PM (#27950317)
> Some criticism of Acoup's analysis of their combat performance. All of the defeats listed are either not infantry battles or ones where Sparta was heavily outnumbered.

It cuts both ways. Classic example is Thermopylae. The total number of Greeks is estimated to be between 5200 and 7700, but you very rarely hear any number higher than 300. The Spartan fame was manufactured, for example by historians like Herodotus.

Why does one have to resort to cherry picking to prove Spartan military excellence? Why aren't they self-evident?

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by blix on Sunday July 25, 2021 @01:18PM (#27951012)
Herotodus lists 300 Spartans at Thermopylae, and over 5000 Greeks. It is possible that there are two different numbers because they describe two very different things.

Spartan military excellence is likely exaggerated, but it is also likely that there was a significant time period where their soldiers were individually superior to other communities, primarily as a result of better nutrition. Nutrition in early Greek agricultural communities is notoriously awful, while the severe inequality of Spartan society allowed them to maintain a realtively well-fed warrior class.

Individual quality doesn't scale, however, while raw quantity does. The Spartans were able to demonstrate excellence in results on a small scale, such as the conquest of Messina, but as quantity became a more important factor they simply couldn't compete even as they maintained some degree of individual excellence.

There are many things to dislike about Spartan society from a modern standpoint (such as their brutally oppressed slave underclass), but it is important to remember that this is a feature of almost all early agricultural societies.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by dalbasal on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:08AM (#27948906)
I'd say the spartan meme is also an example of art imitating art. Other greeks, and later Romans started this meme. They admired Sparta's dedication to conservative fanaticism, romanticized it and told stories about them. We still tell the stories, based on older stories based on older stories.

Meanwhile, we have very little direct access to "reality." In fact, unmediated reality is pretty elusive.. when you stop to think about it. Win rate statistics and other such "objective" views into reality are a pretty sparse source of information.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by rodgerd on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:26PM (#27954539)
On art-imitating-art, I read an interesting interview in The Comics Journal in the late 90s, wherein the interviewee bemoaned how poor the state of comics art hat become; the norm in the 30s, 40s, and 50s had been artists who had trained as illustrators or in fine arts, and even when they portrayed horror or superheroes, their work was grounded in a knowledge of how bodies worked.

Over time, though, more and more of the artists had learned by copying the golden and silver age work. And then copying those copies.

The end point of which was Rob Liefeld being unable to draw feet and his other atrocities of posture, proportion, or indeed a sense of where a human's organs might reside.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by BurningFrog on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:38PM (#27952239)
I didn't read the article, but measuring military skill by how many battles you win is very tricky business.

To have a battle, you need two armies. If army A is clearly stronger than army B, B will typically admit defeat without going through the unpleasant process of being slaughtered to the last man. At least if they have reasonable expectations of a life after surrender.

So battles that are actually fought are normally pretty even. That doesn't mean every fighting force is equal to every other. The militarily stronger side gets their way by having a credible threat of settling things by force if needed.

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by Andrew_nenakhov on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:03AM (#27949657)
One thing is clear: Spartan PR department was undefeatable.
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by b0rsuk on Sunday July 25, 2021 @12:32PM (#27950476)
"Spartan" should be a popular name for marketing and PR agencies, not for military :-).
Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by gverrilla on Monday July 26, 2021 @01:52PM (#27962653)
> Sparta was a North Korea of the antique world

what do you mean by that? this has been debunked [0].

0: Werner Jaeger, Paideia

Re:Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017) by wnevets on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:09PM (#27951983)
>No matter how you slice it, they were completely average as far as won battles go!

and they absolutely surrendered!