News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by jetrink on Thursday June 17, 2021 @08:59AM (#27539090)
I understand the opposition to another government service on ideological grounds, but the response in Ohio seems merely pro-monopoly and not pro-market. Is there anywhere in the country where state Republicans are looking for ways to increase competition in the broadband market? Everyone uses the internet, I don't understand why only one party is looking for a solution to this problem.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by gaoshan on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:31AM (#27539366)
It is totally pro-monopoly. I live in Ohio and many of our communities are only served by a single provider. Those providers offer fairly sluggish service as well as fairly high costs. People that I work with regularly complain about one or the other. My community discussed community broadband (going so far as to put at least exploring it to a vote on one of our ballots). It was shot down ("Why do we need to increase taxes to pay for this? I already have the internets... no one needs more") and shortly after that we finally got a second provider. Just that second provider caused prices to plummet. I went from being stuck with getting anywhere from 5 to 30 down (advertised as "up to 100") for $75 a month to getting gigabit internet for $65 a month.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by mywittyname on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:50AM (#27539539)
I heard a while ago that Ohio wrote into the Constitution a monopoly on casino gambling.\

Not knowing if I was remembering correctly, I read through the state constitution, and holy hell, they dedicate like seven pages of the constitution to casino gambling for four gambling facilities. For reference, most other sections are a few paragraphs, at most.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by crote on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:17AM (#27539821)
It's not that uncommon, actually.

In The Netherlands, both running a lottery and running a physical casinos are reserved for two state-owned companies. By law, half of the profit goes to charity. The rest goes to the government.

In Sweden, the government-owned liquor chain Systembolaget is the only one allowed to sell stuff containing more than 3.5% alcohol. Norway has basically the same thing going on.

The idea is that things like gambling and alcohol consumption have an overall negative impact on society, but completely banning them will cause even more harm. Having a state monopoly makes it easier to promote safe and moderate consumption, as no profit is required and criminal figures are kept out - at least in theory.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by mywittyname on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:53PM (#27541716)
Well, these aren't state-owned entities, which is a key distinction. Most people are okay with state-run monopolies. This more akin to if The Netherlands updated their constitution to say that only Coca-cola soft drinks are allowed to be sold in the country.

Most states would put something along the lines of, "A state gaming commission will be created, with the duties and structure granted to them by the Congress of <state>." Then pass a subsequent law outlining the nitty-gritty details.

IANAL, but I suppose this is the result of some fuckery by the casino owners. It's probably easier to modify the constitution than it is to get actual laws past.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by charwalker on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:20PM (#27541354)
Oregon has a state run liquor board over distribution. It's great as technically they own all the product in a licensed liquor store so prices are identical. You can walk into any place, make a request for a certain bottle, and it usually arrives in a few days at the same price it would be anywhere else. If only we could apply that model to other services...
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by rootusrootus on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:53PM (#27541719)
And they run a nice, light weight web site designed in the mid-2000s which lets you search the entire inventory for the liquor you want, where to buy it and for how much.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by Steltek on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:08PM (#27543281)
Massachusetts' Constitution practically grants Harvard sovereign immunity. There were different purposes and circumstances 230 years ago however.

https://malegislature.gov/laws/constitution#chapterVSectionI

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by xhrpost on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:03PM (#27542509)
Not sure how it works in other states but in Ohio, voters can vote in changes directly to the state constitution. Thus the constitution is huge. I'm not sure what it takes to get on the ballot but it sounds like a way for special interests to just bypass the legislative process if they can get voter approval. There were 4 casinos permitted in the Ohio constitution change across 2 owners, but no provision for competitors to come in, it's just these 4 until another amendment.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by Kihashi on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:50PM (#27543083)
Unfortunately, any citizen's initiative that is placed on the ballot in Ohio is an amendment to the constitution. This has an upside in that the legislature can't really override the direct will of the citizenry, but it also means that things that might not be a great fit for the constitution are there.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by fanatic2pope on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:18AM (#27539822)
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by lukifer on Friday June 18, 2021 @01:51PM (#27552962)
Roughly one-third of US states have various forms of monopoly over liquor sales; sometimes it's just over wholesaling, and in a few states, only state-run stores are allowed to sell beverages over some ABV: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcoholic_beverage_control_sta...

It was/is a sensible strategic move to frame cannabis legalization as "regulate it like alcohol"; but looking at the bizarre patchwork of regulations for each state regarding alcohol (a historical side effect of the gradual elimination of Prohibition), a lot of that baggage is now getting carried over to cannabis ("from grain to bottle" compliance -> "from seed to sale").

I personally consider states and investors getting a steep cut or artificial monopoly to be a lesser evil than tolerating the grave injustice of the War on Drugs, but as legalization becomes more normalized, it's worth paying attention to these details and policy trade-offs on new state initiatives.

Source: Coloradan who formerly worked in alcohol compliance.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by ghastmaster on Thursday June 17, 2021 @11:21AM (#27540574)
The monopoly exists in certain sub categories of internet. Gigabit is limited to the terrestrial providers that each municipality allows access to the monopoly they have on the telephone poles. There are alternatives in most rural areas to the terrestrial services, but not in the gigabit speed yet.

https://www.whistleout.com/Internet/Guides/ohio-satellite-in...

> Viasat's plans start at around $50/month and with it you get an unlimited data at speeds up to 50Mbps

Starlink exists:

https://governor.ohio.gov/wps/portal/gov/governor/administra...

wikipedia: > Starlink beta testers have been reporting speeds over 150 megabits per second

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by pseudalopex on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:22PM (#27541379)
Viasat's plans have 3 Mbps maximum upload, 500 ms minimum latency, low monthly caps, and high contention. Even they acknowledge VPN use might be impractical. The $50 plan is too slow to call broadband according to the FCC. 50 Mbps costs $150 plus equipment rental. It's a last resort for people who can't get terrestrial service.

Starlink availability is limited for now.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by bootlooped on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:14PM (#27541274)
My mom gets some kind of terrestrial radio internet like WiMax for $80+ a month. The speeds are 10Mb up, 1Mb down. The cable company wants a wheelbarrow full of cash to run a line up to the house. There is no phone line run to the house.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by gaoshan on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:34PM (#27542180)
She might be a good SpaceX Starlink candidate.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by cure on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:06AM (#27539158)
Afaik only in Arkansas have Republicans seen the light and are actually supporting municipal broadband (https://www.govtech.com/policy/arkansas-opens-the-door-for-m...). I wonder what made them come to that conclusion, it would be interesting to see if that can be replicated elsewhere.

Everywhere else, Republicans are trying to shut muni broadband out. They are colluding with the legacy ISP monopolies to keep speeds low and costs high.

I find this surprising because they don't seem to consider the long term economic damage this will do to their states. Who is going to want to move there to work remotely if the internet is expensive and slow?

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by falcolas on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:09AM (#27539176)
It honestly feels like short term thinking is dominating not only businesses, but government officials too. It boggles my mind, frankly, because of the exact things you mentioned: losing citizens, economic damage, and so forth.

Perhaps the incentives just aren’t there to think long term, for either business leaders or politicians.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by thayne on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:34AM (#27539396)
It's not surprising. Elected officials care more about getting reelected in the next election than long term effects of their decisions. So they are incentivized to care more about the short term.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by mavhc on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:50AM (#27539536)
In my new world order we'll vote to fire people in charge, not to hire them
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by vegetablepotpie on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:18AM (#27539826)
We have a system like that with judges in some states. Examples of judges failing to be retained are sparse https://ballotpedia.org/Retention_election
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by unyttigfjelltol on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:27AM (#27539330)
Politics is business. Business is about making money. From those foundational facts, it's fair to infer that if state Republican politicians are working to ban cities from providing basic services, the politicians are doing this because they think they can make money doing it.

It's wrong. But then, politics, in its current incarnation, is business.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by theshadowknows on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:30AM (#27539353)
And more importantly, make money for themselves and not for the city/state etc.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:52AM (#27539562)
The only reason people hate graft more than they hate boondoggles is because in the former case it's nearly impossible to bury your head in the sand and pretend like the money was smartly allocated.

No matter how you cut it at the end of the day the tax dollars are being squandered on lining pockets they shouldn't be.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by theshadowknows on Friday June 18, 2021 @07:15AM (#27549258)
Extra points for using 'boondoggles' in a sentence :)
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by soco on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:18AM (#27539256)
Could it have something to do with which party supporters are gonna lose more if internet is slow? Can internet be linked in some way to poll results?
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:54AM (#27539581)
Almost certainly not. When you make things marginally worse across the board on an infrastructure matter (in this case by reducing competition) rural areas almost always lose more.
[dead]
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by mbg721 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:57AM (#27539617)
Ah, the grand plan is to complete the process of rust-belt de-industrialization and turn Ohio into the Shire! It all makes perfect sense now...
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:04AM (#27539695)
They would still have 2 Senate votes.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by 8note on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:26PM (#27543528)
The Shire is a bit too happy of a place to vote Republican. You need people to be angry and afraid
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by alentist on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:50PM (#27542351)
The Khmer Rouge was a left-wing (Communist) genocidal regime.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by 8note on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:39PM (#27543695)
Is that to say you don't think right wingers are capable of genocide? Or that they wouldnt do it to people in cities?

If it's purely informational for people who don't know what the Khmer Rouge is, it'd be handy to include why its a comparable situation

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by alentist on Thursday June 17, 2021 @06:25PM (#27545108)
Instead of this knee-jerk reaction, why don't you first read the comment I'm replying to?

> it'd be handy to include why its a comparable situation

akkartik made that bizarre comparison, not me.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by thayne on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:30AM (#27539348)
I'm not sure about at the state level, but several republican controlled cities in Utah also have or are building municipal broadband.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by kyralis on Thursday June 17, 2021 @11:27AM (#27540635)
Republican cities are fine with municipal broadband, because it solves a real problem in those cities - local leaders are generally more pragmatic that way.

Republican state and national leaders, on the other hand, are generally more concerned about their political narrative. They're not the ones impacted by the crap broadband in the cities.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by only_as_i_fall on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:23AM (#27539285)
Certainly not a good thing, but I'd be surprised if this has a measurable impact on the overall attractiveness of a location. Even expensive internet is likely less than 10% of overall expenses and, in my experience, it's very hard to tell if your internet will be good or bad without literally plugging in a modem, which realistically most people won't have the knowledge or means to do.

Call me a cynic but I guess my thought is that if incremental decreases in qol and poor planning were enough to drive people away from the republican party it would have happened long ago.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:28AM (#27539338)
Is there ever bad fiber internet? If a place has fiber to the home, there is a pretty high probability that it is better than whatever garbage the coaxial cable company is peddling.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by sbradford26 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:42AM (#27539455)
I have had fiber at two different houses and the first one was worse in that I could only reliably get 890 Mb down and 920 Mb up. The second house I get 950down/950up with the same provider and same hardware. There is variability but nowhere near as much as cable.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by jschwartzi on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:48AM (#27539519)
Ziply was awful. We got screwed by them when they bought the fiber network in our area, canceled our autopay, and then didn’t bill us for three months until we had racked up a bunch of late fees. My wife spent hours on the phone with them getting the issues sorted out. It was the worst customer service experience I’ve ever had with a broadband provider. I’ve had Charter, Qwest, and Comcast.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:55AM (#27539593)
That’s a people problem. I assume the actual product worked fine though?
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by noobermin on Thursday June 17, 2021 @05:14PM (#27544576)
The Ohio Republicans literally were bribed by a failing nuclear power plant and have faced barely any reprecussions from it due to the gerrymandering and general reliable partisanship in the gerrymandered districts. Only a year later is the (now former) speaker of house being removed from office after being re-elected in 2020! I wouldn't be surprised if the ISPs are also literally (and not even in the figurative sense of legal campaign contributions) bribing someone to put this into law.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by irjustin on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:36AM (#27539402)
They do consider it, but it's lobbying. The ISPs control a lot and have a lot of money to 'donate'.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by ookdatnog on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:46AM (#27540143)
I think it makes political sense for them to do this. The "small government" political platform obviously appeals to large corporations and ideological libertarians, but these groups don't get you a majority in the election. So how do you get average people who don't directly stand to gain from these policies to vote for you?

You convince them that governments are intrinsically ineffective, that the private sector will systematically perform better. This is presented almost as a law of nature, if you disagree you simply don't understand economics.

The existence of a clear and prominent counterexample (a government-run competitor outperforming privately owned businesses) is pure poison to this story, so they cannot allow it to exist.

They -- knowingly, deliberately -- choose to hurt the people they represent and the economy of their state to save their political platform.

[dead]
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by ryukafalz on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:36AM (#27539410)
The government is beholden to the first amendment, unlike the (small number of) private ISPs.

Even if they weren't, in almost all cases we're talking about municipal broadband as an additional option, not the only option. One that would drive down prices through competition and whose operators have a vested interest in their users having a good experience regardless of how remote they are.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by throw0101a on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:03AM (#27539674)
A lot of muni broadband is the government owning the cables/fibre (OSI Layer 1/2) and then having ISPs sell IP (Layer 3) to those connected.

See Utopia in UT for example:

* https://www.utopiafiber.com/isp/

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by phaedryx on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:39AM (#27539438)
The way it has been proposed in my city is that they will build out the fiber and let the ISP's compete for my business with services and price. It sounds good to me and doesn't sound like they are trying to exert a lot of "control". I still could go with cable internet or something if I don't like how the city is managing it.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by dylan604 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:40AM (#27539445)
My concerns about freedom of speech are not any less because a "public" company is in control either though. We've already seen the current crop of ISP does some super shaddy shit with the data running through their pipes, so non-government ISPs are not the panacea you might think they are.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by mbg721 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:52AM (#27539563)
Even a lot of otherwise die-hard conservatives have seen that privatization and agglomeration of local utilities isn't all rosy. At least local government is reasonably accountable to its constituents.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by mcphage on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:36AM (#27539413)
> So you're not seeing any concerns about letting the government control your internet?

Laws forbidding municipal broadband fall squarely in the “government control your internet” camp.

> Especially when this idea is proposed by a party who is vocally against freedom of speech and a few other freedoms?

Well that’s the nice thing about municipal internet: the government is controlled by the first amendment, unlike corporate broadband. So if you’re worried about being censored by your internet provider, I’d stick with the internet provider which is constitutionally forbidden from doing that.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by fitblipper on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:44AM (#27539478)
I love how you put that! When the utility is operated by the government we, the people, have more direct control of how they operate.

We don't have to put up with laws which encourage mass surveillance and data retention [1], 3rd party doctorine which makes all of your data owned by the provider you are using so you have no rights over them, and the governments ability to just ask or provide a gag ordered request to get all your data.

This cuts out the middle man and allows us to demand our communication rights directly from the government instead of muddying the waters by allowing a 3rd party corporation advocate against the consumer/citizen.

[1] https://techcrunch.com/2017/03/28/house-vote-sj-34-isp-regul...

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:19AM (#27539844)
You're not wrong but I think the end result of really depends on the state or city. Government isn't actually accountable if the voters don't hold the politicians accountable for the actions of the bureaucracy.

In my area any government service or department always accumulates over time all sorts of backhanded ways to manipulate the poor, ostensibly for their own good by proxy of societal good (which is basically just a charitable way of saying "forcing them to act the way a bunch of jerks with million dollar homes think they should"). It's not quite to the level of "unpaid parking tickets get your house skipped by the trash guys" but every year there's yet another "scandal" where they get caught pushing that kind of envelope and have to promise not to do it again.

Private industry here is a little more trustworthy in the "won't abuse you" regard. Of course they'll try to screw you out of every penny you have but that's pretty much where it begins and ends. Whereas with government there are all sorts of aspects they care about.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:02AM (#27539668)
Oh yes, this. In every small Iowa town they have private ISPs/ cable service. Hurray free enterprise! But they're all monopolies, given by the city to some favorite son. The biggest house in any midwest small town, is the cable guy. Gouging the highest prices the locals will tolerate.

That's what Republican 'free enterprise' looks like.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by jliptzin on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:04AM (#27539689)
When Republicans say they are pro-business they actually mean they are pro-entrenched corporate oligopolies.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by axaxs on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:52PM (#27543841)
This isn't clearly a R vs D issue, perhaps localized. TN has a surprising amount of gigabit muni broadband in very, very red areas. Though another R has done her damnedest to stop that.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by stronglikedan on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:29PM (#27542119)
Replace "Republicans" with "Politicians" (at the state and federal level), and the statement is just as correct. I believe the problem is allowing private money to affect government, but I have no idea how to fix it.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by CountDrewku on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:24AM (#27539299)
Doubtful... it seems neither party is interested in breaking up monopolies. They'd both rather bend them to their interests is some selfish power move.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by nobody9999 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:51AM (#27540184)
>Doubtful... it seems neither party is interested in breaking up monopolies. They'd both rather bend them to their interests is some selfish power move.

Except reality[0] doesn't comport with your statement. That's not to say that the bills proposed are perfect, but they are from one party (and not the one trying to block municipal broadband in OH).

Just some food for thought.

[0] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/06/five-new-bills-a...

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by CountDrewku on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:30PM (#27542128)
>but they are from one party (and not the one trying to block municipal broadband in OH).

Did you even read the article you linked? There's clear Republican involvement...

"“Big Tech companies are stifling American innovation with their monopolistic behavior,” said Rep. Lance Gooden (R-Tex.), who co-sponsored two of the bills.""

"Bipartisan movement

It’s unclear whether any of these bills will pass. The last one, the Merger Filing Fee Modernization Act, appears most likely at this point since it’s a relatively incremental piece of legislation that already has bipartisan support in both chambers. But the fact that the other bills, which garnered bipartisan support in the otherwise highly partisan House, suggests that a major overhaul of antitrust law may be imminent, even if these specific bills don’t survive."

>Except reality[0] doesn't comport with your statement.

Let me know when they pass....

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by dylan604 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:41AM (#27539451)
What's the point in the breaking up, if you just let the pieces reassemble a few years later?
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by frockington1 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @11:20AM (#27540562)
Campaign buzzwords. It's the same reason neither party will actually do anything about 2A or abortion. Can't get your base riled up if the issue is resolved
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by dylan604 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:50PM (#27546596)
I would love to see an amendment passed that limits all campaigns to the 3 months immediately preceding an election. Campaign, get elected, go to work, and not campaign, get elected, immediately start campaigning again. It's never not campaign season. Except we can't pass an amendment because everyone is campaigning.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by dboreham on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:00AM (#27539104)
Because corruption.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by partiallypro on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:23PM (#27542745)
No party is -actually- looking for a solution to the problem. The main problem is municipal monopolies which the federal government has no control over (ie Charter pays the city a fee to be their only cable provider in X neighborhood or AT&T won't lease line space to competitors on their utility poles, etc.) Local government have vastly more powerful controlling interests than Washington in terms of a company can just up and leave. Google tried to get around this but has ultimately failed the majority of the time.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by thayne on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:37AM (#27539421)
It sounds like this is just one provision in a big budget bill. My guess is it didn't even factor into how most of the legislature voted at all. I wouldn't be surprised if some of them didn't even know it was in the bill.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by WhompingWindows on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:27AM (#27539933)
Pro-market and pro-monopoly are mere principles which don't matter when the sausage gets made. Politicians have no problem keeping their fingers on the scale, provided they get paid well for the service.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by binaryblitz on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:03PM (#27541130)
Because politicians in the US exist to accept bribes for personal gain. Very few of them seem to give two shits about anyone besides themselves. Especially on the right side of the aisle.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by bionhoward on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:25AM (#27539301)
There's a serious argument to be made to keep the government out of areas which ought to be free market territory. If there's not enough demand for internet in these areas to justify multiple service providers, perhaps that's OK, because to provide the service would be a waste of resources... Just because internet is a utility does not mean the government ought to be the one providing that utility.

Also, this just reinforces the argument for projects like Starlink -- which could change the game in rural broadband. Conservatives have a lot of motivation to oppose government programs and that does not necessarily make them corrupt.

What America needs is more intellectual + centrist + pragmatic conservatism to counter Trumpist BS, not necessarily more government programs....

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by Server6 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:50AM (#27539531)
Internet access should be considered a utility and explicitly NOT subject to "free market" territory. It's a core driver of our modern economy and essential for pretty much everything these days. It should be mostly if not wholly subsidized by the state like the interstate highway system.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by natex on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:45AM (#27539482)
A municipality's decision to implement common locally-owned internet as a public utility IS the free market. The State should not get to decide what's a "waste of resources" for me and my neighbors.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by bluGill on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:58AM (#27539624)
If your neighbor doesn't use the public internet for whatever reason, then making your neighbor pay for it is a waste of resources.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:06AM (#27539708)
And some people do not have cars or children in schools or use the food banks or go to community college.

Not everything is about the individual cost/benefit, and individuals can benefit from society wide benefits.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by taeric on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:41PM (#27543715)
Further in this direction. The neighbor that doesn't use this internet will still benefit from the value of new jobs and opportunity that it will bring.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by foo_barrio on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:18AM (#27539824)
"If there's not enough demand..."

Demand is not that simple. There could be tons of latent demand and the internet seems to be one of those things that seems to show induced demand as well. People are incredibly adaptive and may be working around the problem of crappy internet one way or another.

If there was just straight up "demand", these near-monopoly ISPs form a market of "you can't vote for whoever you want as long as I get to choose the candidate" type systems. That does not a healthy market make and supply/demand do not work out like it does in econ 101 textbooks in unhealthy markets.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by bildung on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:53AM (#27539567)
> What America needs is more intellectual + centrist + pragmatic conservatism to counter Trumpist BS, not necessarily more government programs....

I don't think this is about Trump, GOP governments have failed to reduce government programs for 5 decades now, and almost always resulted in more deficits: https://miro.medium.com/max/700/1*pqIXolEpzpTNktAgIclA-A.png

From the outside (I'm not from the US) it looks like the small government talking point has been empty rhetorics since inception.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by josefresco on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:55AM (#27539591)
> free market territory

The free market in the United States for broadband Internet has failed. Time for plan B.

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by iso1631 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:06AM (#27539706)
DSL, Cable, 4G, wifi, starlink, GEO satelite.

There's plenty of options

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by antifa__ on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:19AM (#27539839)
Yup. Plenty of 10mbps options.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by iso1631 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @11:12AM (#27540433)
Why is that. There's clearly the potential for competition, there isn't a monopoly on internet provision - the investment to set up a WISP is minimal.

Why isn't the market providing that competition? Why can't you run fiber through your sewer for example? who owns the sewer?

Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by tclancy on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:00PM (#27541803)
What free market? In most places in the US cable and Internet service is a local monopoly. This argument is getting more and more threadbare as the Republican Party gets more outré.
Re:Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on muni... by antattack on Thursday June 17, 2021 @09:20AM (#27539268)
I presume religious groups that support Republicans see internet as a source of evil.

https://www.technologyreview.com/2014/04/04/13684/how-the-in...

"the drop in religious upbringing, the increase in college-level education and the increase in Internet use—that together explain about 50 percent of the drop in religious affiliation."