Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by clarkevans on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:25AM
(#27529572)
A repeal of Buy America would be prudent if it were accompanied with very stiff taxation of products from countries that lack equivalent environmental, labour, and democratic policies. Otherwise, we're asking U.S. based companies to compete with organizations that simply bypass environmental protection, labour protection, or fail to support a democratic government.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by koboll on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:40AM
(#27529781)
This is what I'd like to see most from American trade policy -- not dismantling organizations like the WTO, but rededicating them to promoting human rights and worker protections rather than the interests of transnational capital.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by CogitoCogito on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:47AM
(#27529866)
This is one of the fundamental issues I take with arguments of free trade and how it's best because "different countries focus on what they're best at". That all sounds good if you don't turn on too many brain cells, but there are certain things we do less efficiently on purpose because we hold certain values as more important.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by piva00 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:57AM
(#27529986)
Or maybe supply chains are so globalised and intertwined that you, as an individual, simply has no other choice in a number of categories of consumer goods. Good luck applying your morals against a global economic system.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by cardosof on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @03:48PM
(#27532680)
That is, indeed, a good response and question. Like you can't have a cellphone without giving money to China, for example.
The only way I see is to avoid consumerism, being conscious about it and voting on politicians with that kind of ideal and then, only then, someday, there should be a little bit of a chance for change.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by CogitoCogito on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:56PM
(#27530733)
I kind of agree with you. But the point here is that we shouldn't treat this at an individual level. Individuals will never be able to police supply chains as others have pointed out. But we can certainly have regulators whose job is to do so. In the cases where our regulators don't have that duty to police/ban the import of goods produced contrary to our claimed values, I'd say the hypocrisy points to our not truly having those values as you say.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by atomicnumber3 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:02PM
(#27530042)
How do you reasonably do that, though?
The average person doesn't have the time or expertise to track the supply chain of ~anything they buy. At point-of-sale you're presented with, at best, a price and a brand name. And in many cases nowadays, like on Amazon, the brand name is just throwaway semi-English gibberish that rotates out every 4-8 weeks and has 5000+ fake reviews and is just some generic garbage that's being resold off Alibaba.
I think it's really fair to say this is something that needs to be done by government regulation, not individual people.
Even businesses will struggle with this unless they're in the top % of companies (both $-wise and market capture wise) and can afford to force their supply chain to capitulate to their audits/compliance demands.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by michaelmrose on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:12PM
(#27530163)
We can't really expect people at Walmart to weigh the moral import of two different TVs. The information isnt at hand and quite frankly they are too stupid to do so.
This is why we try to ensure everything they can buy there is unlikely to kill them if used properly. We can likewise that nothing there was made in circumstances or conditions we would find morally unacceptable.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by recursivedoubts on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:42AM
(#27529806)
America's manufacturing capacity has been largely destroyed in all but the highest end goods where there actually is protectionism in place (we may lose high-end semi-conductors soon)
The supply chain is now firmly planted in Asia.
We've papered this disaster over with debt and asset bubbles.
And still these people act as if we are going to fall for the same old wine & wool just-so story from 18th century England again.
> The United States is the world's third largest manufacturer (after China and the EU) with a record high real output in Q1 2018 of $2.00 trillion (i.e., adjusted for inflation in 2009 Dollars) well above the 2007 peak before the Great Recession of $1.95 trillion.
US manufacturing capacity keeps going up and up and up.
Maybe you're thinking of employment in manufacturing? Yes that's going down. It's also reducing as a proportion of GDP, but that's not 'capacity', and it's because other sectors have grown even faster.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by systemvoltage on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:16PM
(#27530219)
This goes against the basic experience of most people that went through the 80’s and remember how basically everything in their living room was made in the US including the TV from Western Electric Co.
While statistically, it may be true, literally 99% items in my house are made in China. Paint on the walls is probably still made in US.
Small business and manufacturing industry statistics would be interesting to evaluate here without the rhetoric “Where do people get this myth from?” - daily experience of millions of people does not align with reality of 30 years ago. That’s why.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by username90 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @02:11PM
(#27531642)
No, the high value part of the chain is putting your brand label on the final box. There isn't much USA is manufacturing that Asian manufacturers cannot do today except the branding.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by falcolas on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @03:25PM
(#27532427)
Yeah, this. It lets them qualify to claim "Made in the USA", except it wasn't, not really. It was made in (China/India/Japan/Malasya/Mexico/Canada/…) and partially assembled in the US.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by knownjorbist on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:55AM
(#27529960)
This is both ignorant of reality & basic economic principles. The US is still the second largest manufacturer in the world(unless you consider the EU as a single entity in that regard), and comparative advantage is a very real(and good) thing.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by yourapostasy on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:31PM
(#27530405)
> ...and comparative advantage is a very real(and good) thing.
Comparative advantage is a fine model in a one-shot static analysis. But when modeling in reflexivity, and adjacency, from my perspective as a business operator is comparative advantage is a terrible analytical model.
There are all sorts of industrial activities that supply soft power projection into an adjacent industry. As long as I'm not bleeding money on them, I don't care they don't fit some economists' vision of "highest, best use of capital". That approach to capital-efficiency-über-alles has for a long time now struck me like working physics problems with zero friction.
An example I give is IBM selling its x86 laptop and server division to Lenovo. They weren't consistently hemorrhaging red ink. And given hardware refresh cycles and new projects, those affiliated IBM sales teams were invited in behind the curtains to talk new orders at least once every other quarter with the customers. You cannot buy that kind of access for blood or money these days, and my personal take is as long as it doesn't net you a negative balance sheet at the end of the day, I've seen way worse use of capital on "marketing expenses".
For example, IBM definitely has the sophisticated financing/leasing/etc. structures to have set up sales incentives that enabled customers to start on their x86 hardware, and then seamlessly p2v into their cloud as the initial onboarding of customers' cloud initiatives, and helping them re-design and re-factor for the cloud.
This pattern plays out over and over in many businesses. When leveraged, it constructs a moat out of an ecosystem of inter-related economic activities.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by underseacables on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:53AM
(#27529942)
Globalization destroyed America’s manufacturing base. At some point politicians decided we had plenty of manufacturing to spare, so we should give it to other countries who need it more. Now, we are paying for it.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:57AM
(#27529993)
That's disingenuous. What happened is that economists created models that suggested open trade would be beneficial to everyone even if it caused temporary disruption and politicians implemented their ideas, likely with not insignificant prodding from businesses looking to cut costs.
Whether or not those models are accurate is matter for debate.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by azinman2 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:57AM
(#27529987)
I wouldn’t blame politicians. It was very in vogue for businesses to outsource in the last 20 years, and if you didn’t do it, your competition would. It was a race to the bottom that the stock market reacted to, adding to the pressures. That’s the real driver.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by underseacables on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @01:45PM
(#27531344)
I think there is a serious disconnect between those who grew up with manufacturing, will appreciate it perhaps, and those that have no clue. It’s clear from some of these comments that there are some people that grew up in non-manufacturing household, non-manufacturing cities, and I think for them manufacturing is like McDonald’s. The local McDonald’s closed, oh well. I’m sure they’ll find another job. They can learn to code.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by knownjorbist on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @03:32PM
(#27532491)
The ancestors of the people you're describing moved & learned new skills in that scenario.
If markets are moving away from that particular niche, the government should not be artificially preserving the conditions under which generations can do the same thing and expect the same result. What happened to personal responsibility?
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by knownjorbist on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:11PM
(#27530156)
The overall economic cost of trying to maintain generation after generation doing the same thing with the same results far outweighs the people experiencing some pain of having to re-train, go to school or move elsewhere. If anything that's where the government should be trying to help, not trying to prop up industries with our tax dollars.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by systemvoltage on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:25PM
(#27530338)
I think it’s also about resilience of global reliance and disruptions.
“Someone’s gotta make stuff” as Elon puts it. Manufacturing of stupid trivial things like buttons and pins is still important to keep high volume manufacturing knowledge and knowhow.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by systemvoltage on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:52PM
(#27530680)
Definitely defense, if you study history - how bacon grease was collected from homes to make lubricant for cartridges during WWII; making pins and buttons for clothes was turned into component manufacturing for airplanes almost overnight. Within a few days, people worked to convert equipment, draft new mechanisms, turn them at the machine shop, fixer-upper some machines - converted the entire enterprise into making shaft pins and washers.
There were countless examples of how quickly manufacturing of A was converted to manufacturing of B. Ken Burns documentary goes much deeper into this and I find it totally fascinating.
Chinese populace has an insane level of "jerry-rigging" capability because of how they bring costs down. This is a huge advantage in war manufacturing theater. This is now questionable as Americans (and Europeans alike) are constantly in consumption mode.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:56AM
(#27529972)
> America's manufacturing capacity has been largely destroyed
We are at record high real output levels in manufacturing [1]. China and the EU are bigger, and employment in the sector is down, but it’s false to say our industrial capacity has been decimated.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by systemvoltage on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:29PM
(#27530388)
This entire thread is full of “But it’s not declining”.
You need to look deeper into what US is producing. Most of which is Oil, Petroleum Products, Cars, Aeroplanes and Defense equipment based on the article you’ve linked.
There has been a massive decline in many other sectors, would be interesting to find a source of industry breakdown. I’ll look for it.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by alistairSH on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:53AM
(#27529939)
IIRC, manufacturing output reached an all-time high in 2018. We're doing that in higher-margin industries with fewer workers. So, I'm not sure "capacity has been destroyed" is even remotely accurate in any general sense.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by Retric on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:00PM
(#27530026)
Measuring manufacturing output in dollars isn’t a counter argument. A Yacht may be worth 1,000,000 TV’s, but it doesn’t represent anywhere near the same industrial capacity. Especially if the components of said yacht / car / etc where imported.
It’s not even purely a question of economics. In a crisis like COVID you can easily prevent exports to meet local demand. Trying to force imports on the other hand doesn’t work.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by OldHand2018 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:45AM
(#27529842)
This is a poor article. The main evidence for “Americans can’t build stuff good” is the NYC subway cars ordered in 1970.
Even the most “America First” of Americans will readily agree that manufacturing in the 1970s was horrible compared to present times.
If you actually click on the provided link and scroll down to where it talks about those train cars, you’ll see that the first problem came from running an extended-distance speed test where the average speed over the entire distance exceeded the maximum speed in the design of the train cars. You can’t seriously say that burning out the electric motors as a result of this is a manufacturing deficiency.
Then there is this quote:
> When the R-44s initially entered service, failure rates increased tremendously because of a combination of new technology and inadequate training.
You can probably attribute some of the “new technology” part to manufacturing problems. How much? Who knows? But if your subway system is poorly run and has inadequate training, the best subway cars built in the best factory in the world isn’t going to save you.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by rsynnott on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:23PM
(#27530313)
> Even the most “America First” of Americans will readily agree that manufacturing in the 1970s was horrible compared to present times.
Of course, a big part of the reason for that was presumably lack of external competition in the 70s. If you say to Manufacturing Company X "don't worry about the European and Japanese manufacturers, they're not allowed bid on this" you are unlikely to get the same sort of quality than you'd get if they were.
British car manufacturing is a nice example; in effect, the government forced consumers to buy the British manufacturers' output via protectionism. The result was _legendarily_ awful quality. And by the time the protectionism waned (when the UK joined the EU), it was too late; the industry was so used to not really having to compete that it just couldn't adapt to having to produce a good product, and largely collapsed.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by OldHand2018 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @01:10PM
(#27530893)
> Of course, a big part of the reason for that was presumably lack of external competition in the 70s. If you say to Manufacturing Company X "don't worry about the European and Japanese manufacturers, they're not allowed bid on this" you are unlikely to get the same sort of quality than you'd get if they were.
Yes! (And no). In the US, by 1970, foreign auto manufacturers had achieved a 10% market share, and it had been growing steadily since the mid 1960s. The Detroit manufacturers were fully aware of this, they just weren’t making changes. That was a time of great societal unrest and huge labor strife. It’s not hard to imagine the elites not wanting to save American manufacturing jobs or at least making them competitive.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by rsynnott on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @01:37PM
(#27531228)
I'd argue that the gap between American and European/Japanese automakers was probably smaller than the gap between American and European/Japanese train manufacturers at the time, though.
Also, it's probably far easier to justify inaction on cars because some of the things they're judged on are pretty subjective. A GM exec could plausibly have said something like "we don't need to increase reliability to match Japanese cars, because people don't want that sort of car here; they're too small/whatever". They'd have been wrong, as it turns out, but it wouldn't have been obvious nonsense. Whereas a train manufacturer exec wouldn't have had the same sort of arguments; they'd have _had_ to compete on the things railways care about, which are mostly just reliability.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by NikolaeVarius on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:35AM
(#27529701)
I'm at the point where I think that I'm okay with some inefficiency that at least gives the impression that the nation is trying to take care of its citizens.
Globalization and such have been very good at lowering prices and general increased productivity for most people, but I think its clear that its leaving behind a bunch of people who do not want to be forced into this global market, and get angry about it.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by jeffbee on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:44AM
(#27529829)
The article is about how Buy American in the mid-20th century immiserated generations of Americans with bad transportation and long-term debt. Which aspect of that even gives the impression of caring for our citizens?
In terms of transportation infrastructure the USA is behind countries like Kazakhstan and Morocco. We need all the help we can get from other countries. Indeed, the law we need is that we're forbidden to buy from ourselves, and nobody who has ever planned an American transportation system is permitted to do it again without at least 20 years of remedial experience abroad. We need Buy Not American.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by amjaeger on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:59AM
(#27530012)
Do you have a source or a specific reason to comparing to Morocco? I was there in 2015. The trains were in pretty rough shape, on one of the trains the toilet was damaged and you could see the train tracks... I don't remember any other specifics, but overall the transportation was a bit rough. That being said, I don't know much about the quality of transportation in America outside of the east coast.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by jeffbee on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:33PM
(#27530437)
I don't see why not. Rail links between principal cities are a very good approximation of "average infrastructure" in urban societies. You can go from Casablanca to Tangier in 2h10m. NY to Boston or Washington takes longer. The much shorter trip from Sacramento to San Jose, California, takes twice as long.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by jeffbee on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:41PM
(#27530548)
"""Urbanization of rural areas and rural exodus are the main factors characterizing the demographic evolution in Morocco. Moroccan cities are expected to host 73.7% of the country's inhabitants by 2050 instead of 60.4% in 2014."""
About what other topics would you care to be mistaken?
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by teakettle42 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:59PM
(#27530767)
80% of the US population is urban. Europe’s percentage is even higher.
You think Morocco hitting an estimated 73.7% by 2050 actually supports your position?
It fascinating just how emotionally motivated your reasoning is, to the point that you’re absolutely certain of your position despite it arising from a place of gross ignorance.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by dec0dedab0de on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:50AM
(#27529898)
I personally would rather my tax money be spent in the country, even if it costs more. As a matter of fact I would take it a step farther and say that all Government purchases must be completely sourced in country. All the way down to the semiconductors in their smart phones. We're a large country, with a ton of resources and people, we should not be dependent on anyone else. At least not for anything the governments are doing.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by ghkbrew on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:04PM
(#27530070)
This is how you end up with $500 toilet seats, though.
If something can't be profitably made in the US then the only production for it will be explicitly for the government. And it will be a de facto monopoly and priced accordingly.
Maybe that's a tradeoff you're willing to make to make sure that there is always someone in the US who can make toilet seats. I would rather it be a more nuanced decision than a blanket mandate.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by dec0dedab0de on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:19PM
(#27530253)
I didn't think it through that far, but yes I would be willing to make that tradeoff. Toilet seats are important, and if something whacky happens and global trade is interupted for an extended time, we should have at least one toilet seat maker.
That said, I would also tax all imports to the point that the only imports worth buying are ones that are of a significantly higher quality than their domestic counterpart.
I would also ban trade with any countries that have awful labor and environmental practices. This one would be the most difficult, because how do you define awful? And how long do you keep the ban after they fix things? If you go back far enough the whole world gets banned.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by username90 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @02:20PM
(#27531740)
That is bullshit. 40 years ago the industrialized world was actually industrialized and the developing world was not, so everything was produced in the industrialized world and toilet seats still didn't cost half a months wage for low earners.
Similarly todays Chinese laborers have no problems affording stuff they produce. Industrial production is very efficient, the products aren't super expensive even if you pay the laborers decent wages.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by dec0dedab0de on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @02:38PM
(#27531927)
I think you missed the point they were trying to make.
They are saying that there will be situations where the government has to buy some product domestically, but every private business and citizen imports that same product. The law would cause a domestic manufacturer to exist with the sole purpose of providing that product to the government. Since they won't have any other customers, or any competition, the price will be high.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by anthonygd on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @02:43PM
(#27531981)
Having a single customer doesn't make a monopoly; if anything it gives that customer much more power. There's no reason the government can't do price comparisons even when buying from the US. If you want to sell $500 toilet seats then I'll sell $499 toilet seats. There might even be someone out there who could make them for $498...
Obviously the US can't/hasn't/won't out compete the entire world in all areas but it should be at least competitive.
Competition should extend beyond pure price. National values should be more than politicians talking points. If widget A is made by Uighur forced labor and widget B is made by a middle class labor in a free market, are you willing to spend more for B? How much more?
FWIW - I don't want a blanket mandate either but I don't think you have a convincing argument against it.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by Rebelgecko on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:59PM
(#27530752)
I'm convinced that these sorts of laws would be better if we just bought the foreign equivalent and wrote a check to the domestic manufacturers who weren't chosen.
Here is an experience I had with the "Fly America Act" (a law saying that government funded travel must be done on American airlines, except in the most extreme circumstances):
I was traveling to a city in a foreign country. That country's flag carrier had a 5 hour flight for $600. The best option from a US airline (Delta) was an indirect flight (around 9 hours each way) for $800. Between the ticket cost, overtime I got for the additional layovers, and extra per diem spent during the layovers, flying on a US airline probably cost the government an extra $1000.
It would've been a win-win-win-win if the government had let me fly the foreign flight and just given Delta a gift of $200
* The foreign airline gets another customer
* Delta gets $200 without having the costs of another passenger, and they'd still be able to sell the seat I ended up sitting in
* The government would've saved hundreds of dollars by not having to pay me overtime
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by AbrahamParangi on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:41AM
(#27529792)
Buying domestic is "inefficient" in the same way that buying insurance is "inefficient". I would expect the pandemic to have reinforced the lesson that when things go to hell, you need to have domestic industrial capacity.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by howmayiannoyyou on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:55AM
(#27529959)
Inefficient over what timeline? Medium term inefficiencies are nothing in the face of supply chain imbalances that leave a democratic country at the mercy of the CCP's now belligerent & long oppressive regime.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by handrous on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:01PM
(#27530038)
I hesitate to even bring him up, but Trump's overt rejection of the neo-liberal trade policy consensus that's been embraced by the leaders of both parties since Reagan, is a highly underrated component of his appeal.
(for the record, no, I don't like the guy, but I think his campaigns and his platform, such as it was, are fascinating and that over-simplifying the story of how he got elected & why people voted for him is a dangerous trap)
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by ddingus on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @03:19PM
(#27532352)
Yes, this is bigger than Trump. Been happening for decades on now.
Honestly, Trump bumbled around and made a lot more obvious to more people. In addition to just being Trump.
I can tell you a lot of people went for Trump, 70 million total this last time, precisely because they saw Trump as not being part of that order. Fascinating indeed!
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by mc32 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:44AM
(#27529832)
I don’t get this.
When we advise other countries how to bootstrap their economies economies will tell them to build up their local economy and import knowledge where needed.
This was the playbook for the “Asian tigers” but also post war Japan (or back to Meiji Japan) and China and we see it in India too...
Hey but when the US wants to do a little of this, then these profiteer advocates get all tied up in knots.
They could not care less about US workers and job losses and skills losses. They only care that the status quo of making money for the interests they represent is uninterrupted.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by onepointsixC on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:41AM
(#27529795)
While Reagan did implement "Buy America", he also removed subsidies for American shipbuilding where as other nations did not. Since then America went from one of the largest ship builders to now almost nothing. It's a national security problem. Now the largest shipbuilders are China, Japan, and South Korea whom all pump billions of subsidies into their industries.
This article would have been far more convincing pre-covid when few worried about supply chains. Today? Forget it.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by pg_bot on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:06PM
(#27530092)
The problem is the Jones act not subsidies. Imagine not being able to drive an imported car in the United States. That's what the Jones act dictates for shipping. Who cares where the ship is manufactured? Almost every ship that is "built" in the United States was designed internationally and is composed of imported parts. It's the buyers of the subsidized product that are the beneficiaries of the subsidy. We should take advantage of other nations' foolish behavior instead of following in their footsteps.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by droopyEyelids on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:04PM
(#27530064)
How can this article claim to analyze the benefits of the law without addressing the strategic importance of maintaining domestic industry?
We're talking the USA's final few manufacturers in essential industry, here. If we give them up, and then get in a war, that means we would almost automatically lose the war. War is still a real thing that happens on Planet Earth.
Even if the equipment our protected domestic manufacturers make is expensive and low quality, there is a world of difference between expensive and shoddy vs 'nothing at all'
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by eatonphil on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:50AM
(#27529905)
This article seems to focus solely on trains. Surely the legislation has an impact on more than just trains. If the point was that the problem that affects trains (the US doesn't have modern, efficient train manufacturers) also affects other industries, the article didn't mention any other industries.
If trains are the only problem, it sounds like the Buy America legislation isn't bad and we should deal with buying trains separately?
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by buildingmateri on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:56AM
(#27529978)
Frankly if anyone actually cared about climate change we would be desperately seeking to shorten supply chains and buy/produce locally. Bringing in everything from Asia when it could be done locally is absolutely terrible for ghg levels and pollution.
Still waiting but not holding my breath for ESG to include "short supply chain".
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by protomyth on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:06PM
(#27530087)
This whole article is about passenger trains which is not the focus of the majority of the train track in the USA. GE makers and exports excellent cargo train engines.
Picking one very specific, small manufacturing area and claiming in represents the whole is a bit hard to swallow and a really poor argument.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by bandyaboot on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:51AM
(#27529915)
As if the goodness or badness of the law matters. With something like this with such an obvious political angle, the importance of the quality of the law is approximately zero.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by baron816 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:52AM
(#27529931)
Policy is trying to do too much. Clearly, if you limit the suppliers you can buy from, you’re going to be overpaying. And if you’re overpaying, you limit how much you can buy. Investing in infrastructure helps other industries thrive—it shouldn’t be done for its own sake.
Politicians have over fetishized manufacturing. They need to stop promoting and protecting jobs that don’t need an education.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by tuukkah on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:53AM
(#27529936)
The gist:
Left-wing parties in Europe have a term for imports in this circumstance: parallel imports. According to this view, protectionism is justified on labor or ecological grounds, but imports from countries with strong unions and environmental regulations trigger neither justification.
Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by dukeofdoom on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:10PM
(#27530141)
When things started to get outsourced to China, the promoted belief was that we will bring democracy to China. However, seems like the opposite happened, and Communism got more popular in the USA. Less pollution at home and cheaper goods might be worth it though. I'm pretty amazed by the quality of even cheaper Amazon brands, that I can just order from my couch.
The only way I see is to avoid consumerism, being conscious about it and voting on politicians with that kind of ideal and then, only then, someday, there should be a little bit of a chance for change.
The average person doesn't have the time or expertise to track the supply chain of ~anything they buy. At point-of-sale you're presented with, at best, a price and a brand name. And in many cases nowadays, like on Amazon, the brand name is just throwaway semi-English gibberish that rotates out every 4-8 weeks and has 5000+ fake reviews and is just some generic garbage that's being resold off Alibaba.
I think it's really fair to say this is something that needs to be done by government regulation, not individual people.
Even businesses will struggle with this unless they're in the top % of companies (both $-wise and market capture wise) and can afford to force their supply chain to capitulate to their audits/compliance demands.
This is why we try to ensure everything they can buy there is unlikely to kill them if used properly. We can likewise that nothing there was made in circumstances or conditions we would find morally unacceptable.
The supply chain is now firmly planted in Asia.
We've papered this disaster over with debt and asset bubbles.
And still these people act as if we are going to fall for the same old wine & wool just-so story from 18th century England again.
Where do people get this myth from?
It's just flat out untruthful.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_in_the_United_St...
> The United States is the world's third largest manufacturer (after China and the EU) with a record high real output in Q1 2018 of $2.00 trillion (i.e., adjusted for inflation in 2009 Dollars) well above the 2007 peak before the Great Recession of $1.95 trillion.
US manufacturing capacity keeps going up and up and up.
Maybe you're thinking of employment in manufacturing? Yes that's going down. It's also reducing as a proportion of GDP, but that's not 'capacity', and it's because other sectors have grown even faster.
While statistically, it may be true, literally 99% items in my house are made in China. Paint on the walls is probably still made in US.
Small business and manufacturing industry statistics would be interesting to evaluate here without the rhetoric “Where do people get this myth from?” - daily experience of millions of people does not align with reality of 30 years ago. That’s why.
Comparative advantage is a fine model in a one-shot static analysis. But when modeling in reflexivity, and adjacency, from my perspective as a business operator is comparative advantage is a terrible analytical model.
There are all sorts of industrial activities that supply soft power projection into an adjacent industry. As long as I'm not bleeding money on them, I don't care they don't fit some economists' vision of "highest, best use of capital". That approach to capital-efficiency-über-alles has for a long time now struck me like working physics problems with zero friction.
An example I give is IBM selling its x86 laptop and server division to Lenovo. They weren't consistently hemorrhaging red ink. And given hardware refresh cycles and new projects, those affiliated IBM sales teams were invited in behind the curtains to talk new orders at least once every other quarter with the customers. You cannot buy that kind of access for blood or money these days, and my personal take is as long as it doesn't net you a negative balance sheet at the end of the day, I've seen way worse use of capital on "marketing expenses".
For example, IBM definitely has the sophisticated financing/leasing/etc. structures to have set up sales incentives that enabled customers to start on their x86 hardware, and then seamlessly p2v into their cloud as the initial onboarding of customers' cloud initiatives, and helping them re-design and re-factor for the cloud.
This pattern plays out over and over in many businesses. When leveraged, it constructs a moat out of an ecosystem of inter-related economic activities.
I just wanted to make it clear it was greedy wealthy manufacturers whom abandoned their country in order to make a bigger wad.
Whether or not those models are accurate is matter for debate.
If markets are moving away from that particular niche, the government should not be artificially preserving the conditions under which generations can do the same thing and expect the same result. What happened to personal responsibility?
“Someone’s gotta make stuff” as Elon puts it. Manufacturing of stupid trivial things like buttons and pins is still important to keep high volume manufacturing knowledge and knowhow.
There were countless examples of how quickly manufacturing of A was converted to manufacturing of B. Ken Burns documentary goes much deeper into this and I find it totally fascinating.
Chinese populace has an insane level of "jerry-rigging" capability because of how they bring costs down. This is a huge advantage in war manufacturing theater. This is now questionable as Americans (and Europeans alike) are constantly in consumption mode.
We are at record high real output levels in manufacturing [1]. China and the EU are bigger, and employment in the sector is down, but it’s false to say our industrial capacity has been decimated.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_in_the_United_...
You need to look deeper into what US is producing. Most of which is Oil, Petroleum Products, Cars, Aeroplanes and Defense equipment based on the article you’ve linked.
There has been a massive decline in many other sectors, would be interesting to find a source of industry breakdown. I’ll look for it.
It’s not even purely a question of economics. In a crisis like COVID you can easily prevent exports to meet local demand. Trying to force imports on the other hand doesn’t work.
Even the most “America First” of Americans will readily agree that manufacturing in the 1970s was horrible compared to present times.
If you actually click on the provided link and scroll down to where it talks about those train cars, you’ll see that the first problem came from running an extended-distance speed test where the average speed over the entire distance exceeded the maximum speed in the design of the train cars. You can’t seriously say that burning out the electric motors as a result of this is a manufacturing deficiency.
Then there is this quote: > When the R-44s initially entered service, failure rates increased tremendously because of a combination of new technology and inadequate training.
You can probably attribute some of the “new technology” part to manufacturing problems. How much? Who knows? But if your subway system is poorly run and has inadequate training, the best subway cars built in the best factory in the world isn’t going to save you.
Of course, a big part of the reason for that was presumably lack of external competition in the 70s. If you say to Manufacturing Company X "don't worry about the European and Japanese manufacturers, they're not allowed bid on this" you are unlikely to get the same sort of quality than you'd get if they were.
British car manufacturing is a nice example; in effect, the government forced consumers to buy the British manufacturers' output via protectionism. The result was _legendarily_ awful quality. And by the time the protectionism waned (when the UK joined the EU), it was too late; the industry was so used to not really having to compete that it just couldn't adapt to having to produce a good product, and largely collapsed.
Yes! (And no). In the US, by 1970, foreign auto manufacturers had achieved a 10% market share, and it had been growing steadily since the mid 1960s. The Detroit manufacturers were fully aware of this, they just weren’t making changes. That was a time of great societal unrest and huge labor strife. It’s not hard to imagine the elites not wanting to save American manufacturing jobs or at least making them competitive.
Also, it's probably far easier to justify inaction on cars because some of the things they're judged on are pretty subjective. A GM exec could plausibly have said something like "we don't need to increase reliability to match Japanese cars, because people don't want that sort of car here; they're too small/whatever". They'd have been wrong, as it turns out, but it wouldn't have been obvious nonsense. Whereas a train manufacturer exec wouldn't have had the same sort of arguments; they'd have _had_ to compete on the things railways care about, which are mostly just reliability.
Globalization and such have been very good at lowering prices and general increased productivity for most people, but I think its clear that its leaving behind a bunch of people who do not want to be forced into this global market, and get angry about it.
It isn’t so much protectionism as government mandated graft.
In terms of transportation infrastructure the USA is behind countries like Kazakhstan and Morocco. We need all the help we can get from other countries. Indeed, the law we need is that we're forbidden to buy from ourselves, and nobody who has ever planned an American transportation system is permitted to do it again without at least 20 years of remedial experience abroad. We need Buy Not American.
I admit I haven’t visited Morocco in 20 years, but based on what I witnessed traveling through the country, this seems incredibly unlikely.
A few major, shiny, “prestige” infrastructure projects don’t represent the average state of their infrastructure.
Which Morocco is absolutely not.
You seem to be viewing things through an extremely western urban viewpoint.
About what other topics would you care to be mistaken?
You think Morocco hitting an estimated 73.7% by 2050 actually supports your position?
It fascinating just how emotionally motivated your reasoning is, to the point that you’re absolutely certain of your position despite it arising from a place of gross ignorance.
If something can't be profitably made in the US then the only production for it will be explicitly for the government. And it will be a de facto monopoly and priced accordingly.
Maybe that's a tradeoff you're willing to make to make sure that there is always someone in the US who can make toilet seats. I would rather it be a more nuanced decision than a blanket mandate.
That said, I would also tax all imports to the point that the only imports worth buying are ones that are of a significantly higher quality than their domestic counterpart.
I would also ban trade with any countries that have awful labor and environmental practices. This one would be the most difficult, because how do you define awful? And how long do you keep the ban after they fix things? If you go back far enough the whole world gets banned.
Similarly todays Chinese laborers have no problems affording stuff they produce. Industrial production is very efficient, the products aren't super expensive even if you pay the laborers decent wages.
They are saying that there will be situations where the government has to buy some product domestically, but every private business and citizen imports that same product. The law would cause a domestic manufacturer to exist with the sole purpose of providing that product to the government. Since they won't have any other customers, or any competition, the price will be high.
Obviously the US can't/hasn't/won't out compete the entire world in all areas but it should be at least competitive.
Competition should extend beyond pure price. National values should be more than politicians talking points. If widget A is made by Uighur forced labor and widget B is made by a middle class labor in a free market, are you willing to spend more for B? How much more?
FWIW - I don't want a blanket mandate either but I don't think you have a convincing argument against it.
Here is an experience I had with the "Fly America Act" (a law saying that government funded travel must be done on American airlines, except in the most extreme circumstances):
I was traveling to a city in a foreign country. That country's flag carrier had a 5 hour flight for $600. The best option from a US airline (Delta) was an indirect flight (around 9 hours each way) for $800. Between the ticket cost, overtime I got for the additional layovers, and extra per diem spent during the layovers, flying on a US airline probably cost the government an extra $1000.
It would've been a win-win-win-win if the government had let me fly the foreign flight and just given Delta a gift of $200
* The foreign airline gets another customer
* Delta gets $200 without having the costs of another passenger, and they'd still be able to sell the seat I ended up sitting in
* The government would've saved hundreds of dollars by not having to pay me overtime
* I would've gotten home sooner
This is likely to result in growing unrest among the people who are both impacted and increasingly done with that kind of leadership.
(for the record, no, I don't like the guy, but I think his campaigns and his platform, such as it was, are fascinating and that over-simplifying the story of how he got elected & why people voted for him is a dangerous trap)
Honestly, Trump bumbled around and made a lot more obvious to more people. In addition to just being Trump.
I can tell you a lot of people went for Trump, 70 million total this last time, precisely because they saw Trump as not being part of that order. Fascinating indeed!
When we advise other countries how to bootstrap their economies economies will tell them to build up their local economy and import knowledge where needed.
This was the playbook for the “Asian tigers” but also post war Japan (or back to Meiji Japan) and China and we see it in India too...
Hey but when the US wants to do a little of this, then these profiteer advocates get all tied up in knots.
They could not care less about US workers and job losses and skills losses. They only care that the status quo of making money for the interests they represent is uninterrupted.
This article would have been far more convincing pre-covid when few worried about supply chains. Today? Forget it.
We're talking the USA's final few manufacturers in essential industry, here. If we give them up, and then get in a war, that means we would almost automatically lose the war. War is still a real thing that happens on Planet Earth.
Even if the equipment our protected domestic manufacturers make is expensive and low quality, there is a world of difference between expensive and shoddy vs 'nothing at all'
That argument has been pretty much made obsolete since the invention of the atom bomb...
If trains are the only problem, it sounds like the Buy America legislation isn't bad and we should deal with buying trains separately?
Still waiting but not holding my breath for ESG to include "short supply chain".
Picking one very specific, small manufacturing area and claiming in represents the whole is a bit hard to swallow and a really poor argument.
My TLDR is that you have to use american-made ships when transporting product from 1 US port to another.
The US government regularly suspends the act, like it did during the recent oil issue on the east coast: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-13/biden-lif...
The CATO institute (right leaning group) pushed to drop it 2.5 years ago: https://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/jones-act-...
[edit] and cruise ships
Politicians have over fetishized manufacturing. They need to stop promoting and protecting jobs that don’t need an education.
Left-wing parties in Europe have a term for imports in this circumstance: parallel imports. According to this view, protectionism is justified on labor or ecological grounds, but imports from countries with strong unions and environmental regulations trigger neither justification.