Re:Why Buy America Is Bad Law
by rsynnott on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @01:37PM
(#27531228)
I'd argue that the gap between American and European/Japanese automakers was probably smaller than the gap between American and European/Japanese train manufacturers at the time, though.
Also, it's probably far easier to justify inaction on cars because some of the things they're judged on are pretty subjective. A GM exec could plausibly have said something like "we don't need to increase reliability to match Japanese cars, because people don't want that sort of car here; they're too small/whatever". They'd have been wrong, as it turns out, but it wouldn't have been obvious nonsense. Whereas a train manufacturer exec wouldn't have had the same sort of arguments; they'd have _had_ to compete on the things railways care about, which are mostly just reliability.
Also, it's probably far easier to justify inaction on cars because some of the things they're judged on are pretty subjective. A GM exec could plausibly have said something like "we don't need to increase reliability to match Japanese cars, because people don't want that sort of car here; they're too small/whatever". They'd have been wrong, as it turns out, but it wouldn't have been obvious nonsense. Whereas a train manufacturer exec wouldn't have had the same sort of arguments; they'd have _had_ to compete on the things railways care about, which are mostly just reliability.