Where do people get this myth from?
It's just flat out untruthful.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_in_the_United_St...
> The United States is the world's third largest manufacturer (after China and the EU) with a record high real output in Q1 2018 of $2.00 trillion (i.e., adjusted for inflation in 2009 Dollars) well above the 2007 peak before the Great Recession of $1.95 trillion.
US manufacturing capacity keeps going up and up and up.
Maybe you're thinking of employment in manufacturing? Yes that's going down. It's also reducing as a proportion of GDP, but that's not 'capacity', and it's because other sectors have grown even faster.
While statistically, it may be true, literally 99% items in my house are made in China. Paint on the walls is probably still made in US.
Small business and manufacturing industry statistics would be interesting to evaluate here without the rhetoric “Where do people get this myth from?” - daily experience of millions of people does not align with reality of 30 years ago. That’s why.
Comparative advantage is a fine model in a one-shot static analysis. But when modeling in reflexivity, and adjacency, from my perspective as a business operator is comparative advantage is a terrible analytical model.
There are all sorts of industrial activities that supply soft power projection into an adjacent industry. As long as I'm not bleeding money on them, I don't care they don't fit some economists' vision of "highest, best use of capital". That approach to capital-efficiency-über-alles has for a long time now struck me like working physics problems with zero friction.
An example I give is IBM selling its x86 laptop and server division to Lenovo. They weren't consistently hemorrhaging red ink. And given hardware refresh cycles and new projects, those affiliated IBM sales teams were invited in behind the curtains to talk new orders at least once every other quarter with the customers. You cannot buy that kind of access for blood or money these days, and my personal take is as long as it doesn't net you a negative balance sheet at the end of the day, I've seen way worse use of capital on "marketing expenses".
For example, IBM definitely has the sophisticated financing/leasing/etc. structures to have set up sales incentives that enabled customers to start on their x86 hardware, and then seamlessly p2v into their cloud as the initial onboarding of customers' cloud initiatives, and helping them re-design and re-factor for the cloud.
This pattern plays out over and over in many businesses. When leveraged, it constructs a moat out of an ecosystem of inter-related economic activities.
I just wanted to make it clear it was greedy wealthy manufacturers whom abandoned their country in order to make a bigger wad.
Whether or not those models are accurate is matter for debate.
If markets are moving away from that particular niche, the government should not be artificially preserving the conditions under which generations can do the same thing and expect the same result. What happened to personal responsibility?
“Someone’s gotta make stuff” as Elon puts it. Manufacturing of stupid trivial things like buttons and pins is still important to keep high volume manufacturing knowledge and knowhow.
There were countless examples of how quickly manufacturing of A was converted to manufacturing of B. Ken Burns documentary goes much deeper into this and I find it totally fascinating.
Chinese populace has an insane level of "jerry-rigging" capability because of how they bring costs down. This is a huge advantage in war manufacturing theater. This is now questionable as Americans (and Europeans alike) are constantly in consumption mode.
We are at record high real output levels in manufacturing [1]. China and the EU are bigger, and employment in the sector is down, but it’s false to say our industrial capacity has been decimated.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_in_the_United_...
You need to look deeper into what US is producing. Most of which is Oil, Petroleum Products, Cars, Aeroplanes and Defense equipment based on the article you’ve linked.
There has been a massive decline in many other sectors, would be interesting to find a source of industry breakdown. I’ll look for it.
It’s not even purely a question of economics. In a crisis like COVID you can easily prevent exports to meet local demand. Trying to force imports on the other hand doesn’t work.
The supply chain is now firmly planted in Asia.
We've papered this disaster over with debt and asset bubbles.
And still these people act as if we are going to fall for the same old wine & wool just-so story from 18th century England again.