News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lettergram on Sunday June 06, 2021 @09:21AM (#27412981)
My 2020 prediction that there will be no more wild caught fish in markets by 2030 seems ever closer...

The truth is, Argentina knows what’s happened but is likely powerless to stop it. If they acted to curb the issue, China would stop bribes to the Argentina leadership and likely impose sanctions of some kinda.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by baron_harkonnen on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:37AM (#27413460)
I'm genuinely curious when all of this will catch up to us. I spend a relatively large amount of my spare time keeping up with myriad of ways we are destroying our environment, the fact that our ecosystem is in deep danger is without question.

At the same time, while I am anecdotally aware we are experiencing a range of shortages right now, it never seems to quite show up in our economic data.

Take for example the FRED data on global fish prices [0]. When you look at that chart you see nothing particularly interesting. You can pore over all of the commodities charts and if that was all the data you had you would soon come to the conclusion that nothing obvious is wrong with our environment (at least from an economic standpoint).

To be absolutely clear, I'm not questioning that something is wrong, I think we're in major trouble. But I am still genuinely surprised that this peril doesn't present itself in any economic data I can find. Any insights into when we will feel this our how/when this environmental destruction will become visible in our economic data would be appreciated.

[0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSALMUSDQ

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by justnotworthit on Sunday June 06, 2021 @02:38PM (#27415206)
It reminds me of the national debt/fiscal gap discussion. Everyone will agree you can't owe a million times GDP, but no one can describe the "limit". Every year and decade you have people crying out that it's unsustainable and will result in collapse, and you have people saying "nah, more". You have examples of countries imploding, and you have the USA with doubles down every X years.

Surely you can't parlay indefinitely, but there hasn't been an implosion yet... until there is... but then everyone who enjoyed the political and financial benefits of parlaying is long dead, their inheritors heavily insulated... or there isn't a financial implosion... or there's some other disaster rendering this disaster moot... or something else (free energy? Second Coming?) appears and fixes it, allowing the reckless to get away with it... if we ever agree on who the reckless were...

We could just follow Taleb's warnings (the precautionary principle, antifragility, black swan events), but we can't even agree on basic reality, and the people who are greatly benefiting off their version of reality will never budge, and the people who might suffer aren't yet born (probably).

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by nomoreplease on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @08:57AM (#27434526)
> Everyone will agree you can't owe a million times GDP, but no one can describe the "limit".

I’ve heard the limit described as “when the nation can only afford the interest payments on the principal” which means the nation can never pay back the principal itself. I heard that 10 years ago

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by mason55 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:43AM (#27413509)
I’d guess given technology advances you’d expect prices to go down, so the fact that they stay flat is actually indicating that fish are becoming harder to find. Similar to how if the price of something stays the same then it’s becoming cheaper because of inflation.

Also, fish are not a long term investment. The price only depends on how hard they are to find combined with demand to eat them sometime soon. If you could buy a fish now with the expectation of selling it later when stocks dry up then I think you’d see a lot more upward pressure.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by HappyDreamer on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:01AM (#27413649)
Another thing cold be if costs for transportation and preparing the fish, storing it etc, grocery store salaries, as of now outweighs the cost of fishing it up from the ocean? (But if so, maybe not much longer.) (I don't know, just wondering.)
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lupire on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:54AM (#27413971)
Animal species almost always grow to consume more unless they are destroyed by predators or exhaust their environment.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lettergram on Sunday June 06, 2021 @03:48PM (#27415740)
> To be absolutely clear, I'm not questioning that something is wrong, I think we're in major trouble. But I am still genuinely surprised that this peril doesn't present itself in any economic data I can find. Any insights into when we will feel this our how/when this environmental destruction will become visible in our economic data would be appreciated.

Simply put, The environmental destruction isn’t what you think. For instance, Based on my experience climate modeling and working with environmental papers - I don’t believe carbon emissions has a meaningful impact on global warming.

Further, and in way of example: the warming should lead to increased food production (they often say as much in their papers). What will happen is greater soil erosion, so we have to protect against that (or we will long-term) have crop problems.

The general point, is the system is more complex than we realize. There are no one-off answers because the system will always be adjusting to try to keep an equilibrium AND so will humans. Farm Fishing is on the rise, protection zones are being setup, global fishing rules have been ignored, but local ones have not, etc etc

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by mixologic on Sunday June 06, 2021 @05:15PM (#27416404)
"Based on my experience climate modeling and working with environmental papers" And what experience is that, exactly?
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lettergram on Sunday June 06, 2021 @06:22PM (#27416905)
I worked with several academics and corporations as a contractor building their simulations. I’ve also read a lot of papers as well, etc.

Like most simulations, they pretty much only can match reality so closely. for instance, we don’t have many long term measurements, so we make (educated-ish) guesses. Academics also repeatedly run their models, tweaking parameters to get the results they want. Frankly, I don’t trust any research using simulations, after being paid to work on environmental, biological systems, simulations for drones and machines (trucks, construction, etc). (Drones and other machines at least had a way to quickly test).

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by mahogany on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:53PM (#27418511)
> we don’t have many long term measurements, so we make (educated-ish) guesses

Out of curiosity, what are some examples of these measurements/guesses you are referring to?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by eloff on Sunday June 06, 2021 @06:15PM (#27416856)
Funny that's contrary to the experience of > 95% of climate scientists. I would trust that over an unsupported reference to your experience, whatever that is.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by splitstud on Sunday June 06, 2021 @07:27PM (#27417337)
We generally expect models to have predictive value, at least through a set of historic data, before we lens them much credence. We have made an exception for climate models. I believe following basic scientific procedures is a better plan than listening to what amounts to a widely-hekd belief structure. It is particularly galling when we could be using time and effort to combat the proven environmental catastrophes such as air and water qualities, deforestation, and issues such as the one that started this thread.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by eloff on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:05AM (#27423420)
You know all those climate models are back tested with the historical data too right?

Climate modeling is a tricky thing because the system is so complex and we are continually surprised by interactions and effects we didn't expect.

However, climate science is about far more than just models. The models are actually the least compelling part.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by kortilla on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:22PM (#27418330)
> Funny that's contrary to the experience of > 95% of climate scientists.

That’s an appeal to authority though. What’s wrong with the following statement?

“95% of numerologists strongly believe in the predictive power of numerology so therefore we should trust them.”

When people question the foundations of an entire field, presenting a giant sample of people who work in said field an implicitly agree with the foundation by labeling themselves as such isn’t really a compelling argument?

Guess what percentage of catholic priests think faith in Jesus is important?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by eloff on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:03AM (#27423391)
That's a fair point if you're going to question an entire field.

I think the difference in this case is the arguments and evidence presented by climate science is generally accepted by experts and policy makers outside of the field.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by elliekelly on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:09AM (#27413717)
I’m fairly certain I’ve commented about this on HN before but when I went to Antarctica (via ship from Argentina) in 2018 we saw tons of these vessels because the ships fishing for squid use huge bright lights to attract them at night. They looked like UFOs on the horizon. It was a really strange sight.

It was definitely well-known amongst the scientists on the ship that the operations were illegal. I know they made an effort to report as many as they could but my impression was that officials were overwhelmed by complaints and the illegal ships would work together to avoid detection/quickly move to international water so, since it was a losing battle, the government didn’t put forth too much effort.

Whether that’s the real reason nothing is done or just the good reason used to justify their inaction is anyone’s guess. I will say there were a shocking number of ships that I could see and I wouldn’t be surprised if they outnumbered the Argentinian navy.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by galangalalgol on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:28AM (#27413802)
It seems they outnumber the Argentinian fishing fleet 4 to 1, just counting the Chinese vessels which make up only 66% of the total intruders. So probably they outnumber the navy by quite a bit more. Impounding all these vessels would probably not make economic sense. They cant utilize that many vehicles and the people that might buy them would be the people they took them from. They would have to escort each one back to harbor and what do they do with the sailors? Feed and house them for free? Sinking these vessels with all hands with no warning would be the most effective way to handle it, no time wasted escorting and the impact psychologically would be outsized to the vessels sunk. Of course, that would gain them a great deal of negative publicity.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by yumraj on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:43PM (#27414795)
> Of course, that would gain them a great deal of negative publicity.

Negative publicity where? I’m sure within Argentina this would be very popular and if China protests it’ll have to own up that these illegal boats are coming from there, which it may not want to do.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by galangalalgol on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:52PM (#27414859)
That is a good point. The EU and the US likely would condemn it on humanitarian grounds, but Argentina may not have enough trade with them to care.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by borroka on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:22PM (#27418699)
Since we are talking about Chinese ships, it is useful to remember the words of those who have led the party for a long time: "strike one to educate a hundred." Although, when you are as dependent as Argentina is on other countries, including China, to survive, there are few opportunities to educate others.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by nonesuchluck on Sunday June 06, 2021 @03:55PM (#27415785)
Not without warning, no. You wouldn't have to learn much Chinese to announce "we're scuttling this ship in 2 minutes. If you wish to live, you may board this freely provided inflatable."

Their other boats will take them home. Probably have to toss over some of their illegal catch to make room, though.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by Tams80 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:00PM (#27414467)
Sinking a few and then maintaining that threat is likely the only way (as in, if they come back, sink a few more).

Obviously the crews should be taken off first, then returned to land and then deported as soon as possible. There's not much point in punishing them any further.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by galangalalgol on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:54PM (#27414878)
If you are only doing a few, might as well take the boats and use them. There are so many I was thinking you'd need to sink a couple hundred. In which case saving the fishermen is prohibitively expensive.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by bromuro on Sunday June 06, 2021 @08:50PM (#27417824)
So a genuine question - why do these vessel need to stay at these borders? isn’t there enough fish in international waters?
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by geoka9 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:26PM (#27418355)
Not an expert, but maybe because there's more fish in coastal (shallow) waters?
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by HappyDreamer on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:10AM (#27413718)
I wonder, isn't it 1) obvious for the CCP what this amount of overfishing will do?

And, 2)

> These distant-water fleets mainly fish for shortfin squid, which are vital to Argentina’s economy

1 and 2 combined make me wonder if destroying the ocean ecosystem, and damaging Argentina's economy could be a goal in itself, somehow.

Maybe to (now I'm guessing), in the future, get to lend out money to the government in Argentina, if they're in a bad economic situation -- and make the country depend on the CCP or something like that?

I'm just guessing and wondering. However it'd be weird to me if the CCP hadn't thought about what'll happen, because of the overfishing, and they said that, yes this is good for us; it's something we want (the party, probably not the people).

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by istorical on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:40AM (#27413873)
I read a lot of Chinese fantasy fiction (xianxia and wuxia) online and its extremely common for the heroes of the stories to use potions or herbs or magical ingredients to increase their powers and abilities. Something unique about them though is it seems super widespread in these stories for the main character, neutral factions, and enemies / evil factions alike to exhaust discovered resources to extinction, with the main ethical / moral crisis being whether to distribute them according to power or according to fairness. Fights over how big one's share of the pie is are common, and 'evil' characters are often those that express greed by demanding an unfair share. But the question of whether it's a good idea or a moral choice to harvest an entire field of 1000 year old ginseng or stealing all of some rare previously thought to be extinct Phoenix's eggs vs tending to the field and harvesting only a small crop or only taking the resources of older birds rarely comes up.

There are plenty of other cultural differences in these stories but overall I'm always left wondering whether some of these reflect broader cultural attitudes or if this is like if someone tried to get a deep understanding of western culture by reading Spiderman comics and that's it.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by Wameaw on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:16PM (#27414114)
I'd think the culture of games and MMORPG had more influence.

I've seen multiple spins on the scenario you've described, in which some scenarios the exhaustive approach is justified (the half-D world is on the verge of collapse, or about to fall to a corrupting force which will decay the resources, etc.);

is reasoned (if the protag leave the sustainable portion, their opponent or enemy will plunder the rest, basically 0-sum game);

is sustained (instead of harvesting everything, they transfer the resource to their own half-D, or if it's non-competitive, they do leave sustainable parts).

Then other genres of the wuxia and xianxia type where the protag is the leader of a faction, and have the faction resources (garden, mines, etc.).

I think you are thinking too deep into this. Reading a popular novel doesn't mean the readers agree with every action or idea the protag or the author take/presents, popular novel are more like fast food, maybe this fry is a bit too salty, maybe that fry is not salty enough, maybe the cola is lacking ice, etc.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by istorical on Sunday June 06, 2021 @06:32PM (#27416969)
Yeah it's true they don't always fully exhaust resources, but I wonder if the fact that such a large percentage of these worlds (comparatively to western fantasy worlds) are seen as 'well this is all gonna be gone soon anyway whether through natural effects or the actions of another bad actor so we may as well just abuse these resources anyway' doesn't reveal a slight bias compared to western attitudes.

One could perhaps look at the behaviors of Chinese tourists at buffets as another example: https://www.globaltimes.cn/content/976211.shtml

But it's just a curiosity since as you say, it's not a representative sample and it's just a genre of fiction, not some real psychological / sociological study.

I've also heard the explanation that this particular behavior could be a reaction to recent history - in particular the famines that China went through in the 20th century. People still have through direct experience or through their recent parents of grandparents that experience of literally starving.

half-d? = half dimension / pocket dimension? don't know what half-d is.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by Wameaw on Saturday June 12, 2021 @10:33AM (#27484759)
It is an interesting phenomenon, but I'd say how different genres and how the Chinese novelist approach these genres has a greater effect on the outcome. Most times you reason from effect to cause to see why.

So typical Chinese fantasy/ high-level Wuxia/ Xianxia goes protag need resources -> need lots with no strings -> a failing pocket dimension to exploit! -> maybe discovered through conflict / treasure map / etc.

Why though? Think of them as a one-time map in an RPG or something, where you access once for some material/etc. but can never revisit.

As for the behavior of that bunch of Chinese tourists, I would say that wasting was an issue in the recent generations (but won't be in the next generation), due to a number of factors such as the abundance of food on the market and in restaurant, hospitality (by providing more-than-can-eat), showoff (by providing extraordinary amount of food), corruption (government paid for, no need to hold back), etc.

However, the fight against corruption in recent years and recently passed laws that prohibit display in public and in video of wasting food would mean that the next generation growing up would have a different standard of what should be considered as waste.

Similarly, those growing up in the 70s-90s that had experience of a lack of food variety and amount, would either be very harsh on any waste of food, or would be overly lenient on wasting food.

As to the theory that this behavior came from memories of grandparents that experienced the famines, I'd say it's stretching it. There's too many variables that would affect the amount of influence, especially if the grandparents weren't around to educate about not wasting food. And if the grandparents didn't educate correctly, it could even cause a backlash.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by pimlottc on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:31PM (#27414694)
Sorry, what does "half-D" mean?
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by Wameaw on Saturday June 12, 2021 @10:09AM (#27484623)
Oops, half-D meant pocket dimensions, it's a literal translation of 半位面, half-dimension.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lupire on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:55AM (#27413984)
Is Game of Thrones an accurate model of USA culture?
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by mlindner on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:18PM (#27414619)
Game of Thrones is set in Europe and is heavily inspired by real european history (Hadrian's wall, the war of the roses, etc).
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ptaipale on Sunday June 06, 2021 @04:23PM (#27415987)
Game of Thrones is set on fictional continents (though yes, inspired by some actual European history).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_of_A_Song_of_Ice_and_Fir...

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by vmladenov on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:23PM (#27414164)
The White Walkers were a direct criticism of the US public and government’s inaction on global warming.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ericmay on Sunday June 06, 2021 @06:12PM (#27416839)
No it’s not. And it would be an unfair and silly comparison anyway.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by vmladenov on Friday June 11, 2021 @05:36PM (#27478805)
> No it’s not.

From the man himself: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/16/t-magazine/george-rr-mart...

> And it would be an unfair and silly comparison anyway.

Your personal opinions on the allegory don’t affect the author’s intent.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by thepasswordis on Sunday June 06, 2021 @08:30PM (#27417684)
Game of thrones certainly is an articulation of US cultural norms, yes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hero%27s_journey

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by justinclift on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:10PM (#27414066)
Maybe Scottish history (give or take a few dragons)? ;)
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by Quarrelsome on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:24AM (#27413787)
It might be an error to attribute this to centralised planning. While that is eminently possible (and much easier for the CCP than other governments) this also could just be someone min/maxing their little slice of the pie or anything in between.

Agents of the imperial European powers used to act in the "interests of the empire" abroad without significant oversight ~200 years ago so this situation could be similar with the Chinese fleet being paid with incentives that encourage bending of the rules.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by fencepost on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:48PM (#27414831)
isn't it 1) obvious for the CCP what this amount of overfishing will do?

It's not in their territory, they likely don't give a rat's ass. Ecosystem damage in the western hemisphere might actually be a good aspect for some of those who might crack down on this.

I suspect we're all well aware that vessels and crews of any nation pulling this in China's territorial waters would not be treated kindly.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by FranchuFranchu on Monday June 07, 2021 @07:16AM (#27421230)
I don't think Argentina needs help to destroy its own economy. We're already taking loans from China and buying Chinese vaccines.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by toyg on Sunday June 06, 2021 @09:36AM (#27413052)
> China would stop bribes to the Argentina leadership

No need to inject unsubstantiable allegations in an otherwise sensible comment.

The power imbalance between a small country with long-standing financial issues and a history of inability in enforcing its complex borders, and a rising global superpower, is quite evident.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by oefrha on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:35AM (#27413842)
https://www.nationalfisherman.com/national-international/oce...

> South Korean, Spanish, and Taiwanese vessels conducted 26 percent of estimated fishing activity in the study with nearly 200 vessels. Almost “90 percent of the Spanish vessels that fished along Argentina’s national waters appeared to turn off their public tracking devices at least once, and Spanish vessels spent nearly twice as much time with AIS devices off as they did visibly fishing,” according to the report.

If power imbalance is the main issue here, surely something can be done about the other 1/3 at least?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ethbr0 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @03:37PM (#27415649)
> a history of inability in enforcing its complex borders, and a rising global superpower, is quite evident

Can't tell if this was a Falkland Islands / Great Britain reference or not.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by waheoo on Sunday June 06, 2021 @09:46AM (#27413107)
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by toyg on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:52AM (#27413591)
In a quick read, I don't see anything in there that could be qualified as "bribe to the leadership". The Chinese finance a lot of countries to ingratiate themselves, but outright bribes to this or that person is another thing. It might well be happening, but stating it with certainty when there is no proof just comes off as a conspiracy theory.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by snthd on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:35AM (#27413838)
https://chinadialogue.net/en/business/6270-illegal-fishing-b... (2013)

>Corruption fuelling illegal fishing

>[Argentine journalist Roberto Maturana] says that in Argentina, these arrangements are facilitated by corrupt officials at the government sub-department of fishing, responsible for granting fishing licenses. ‘Often officials will issue an Argentine license to two different Chinese boats. So whilst one is in port, the other will be out fishing’.

Given Argentina's corruption problem (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_in_Argentina), and China's fishing agenda (https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/11/30/china-beijing-fishing-a... ), it would be a surprise if corruption was not happening.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by jakobdabo on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:29AM (#27413418)
What do you mean a "small country"? Argentina is 8-th largest country in the world.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependen...

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by eliseumds on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:38AM (#27413467)
Shanghai alone has a larger GDP than Argentina, and that's pre-pandemic data.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Chinese_prefecture-l...

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by toyg on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:59AM (#27413628)
In a world of continent-sized superpowers, any country with less than 100m people is objectively small; and Argentina definitely does not compensate for that with high per-capita GDP (they are not even in the top 50).
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by retrac on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:13AM (#27413733)
There's probably only three large countries in the world by your definition then: the USA, China, and Japan. (India, Brazil and Russia's economies are probably too small to meet your standard, all being smaller than the UK's or Germany's.)
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lenkite on Sunday June 06, 2021 @08:21PM (#27417630)
India is actually ahead of the UK and immediately behind Germany.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by BurningFrog on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:18AM (#27413335)
We farm instead of hunt & gather on land since a long time.

The same has to happen in the oceans.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by spockz on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:03AM (#27413669)
We already have ponds for growing non saltwater fish. Farming cattle fish in the ocean would be interesting!
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by rmah on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:30PM (#27414685)
Nations in the far east already have have vast fish farms in the ocean (along the coasts). They are huge and produce huge quantities of fish -- a substantial percentage of fish consumed. But there are species that people like to eat that cannot be farmed economically or at all. So they are caught in the wild.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by prawn on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:08PM (#27414059)
There are already many aquaculture pens in the ocean near Port Lincoln, South Australia, often for tuna. You see them from the air when flying over. Here's a photo of what they look like:

https://www.cleanseas.com.au/custom/files/media/our-farm-2.j...

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by mastax on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:26PM (#27414182)
The issue is that many of the desirable farmed fish like tuna and salmon are carnivores. Farming them still requires catching mass quantities of less-commercially-useful fish along with the issues that has.

Edit: I should say part of the issue. There are other ecological concerns with farmed fish.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ta988 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:15AM (#27413744)
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by pibechorro on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:03AM (#27413666)
Ya, no. Nothing wrong with hunting straight from nature. The key word is sustainable.

If you live on the ocean, you have every human right to fish fo nourishment. The issue here is militarized mass scale industrial fishing, illegally raping reassures to feed foreign people, mostly landlocked people sushi rolls and fish fillet.

What we need is a culture that eats local. Its a consumption issue. Farmed fish are most of the time also destructive to the environment, they are fed less than ideal and sustainable feeds, are not as healthy to eat, and most importantly are not healthy and happy fish, they are slaves in horrible life cycles.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by giantg2 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:14AM (#27413735)
So what are the city people going to eat if it has to be local?

My perspective is that there are simply too many people and they are leading an increasingly modern (high consumption) lifestyle.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by tharkun__ on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:48AM (#27413929)
I would tend to agree. Cities breed lots of problems. Social, economic, environmental, every kind you can imagine. And it creates very very small communities outside those cities which comes with its own problems too (think small town sheriff's tyranny type stuff - yes there's racial profiling etc in big cities as well, didn't say it was a unique problem). Bigger numbers do have an advantage but there is definitely a number that is too large.

I would advocate for lots of intermediate size cities but that doesn't seem to be what anyone in power wants.

Also, are you advocating for Thanos like mercy here? ;)

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by giantg2 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:00PM (#27414013)
Not just that the settlement size is not right, but that the planet can only support so many people. Sure, they estimate it can support up to 11 billion. But that assumes increases in technology and commercial agricultural as well as consumer changes (like little meat). This also doesn't take into account it being sustainable or not.

We need a shrinking population and less consumerism. We are not currently sustainable (and unlikely to become so anytime soon).

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by BurningFrog on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:18PM (#27418674)
> the planet can only support so many people

I think this is a big, and very sad misunderstanding.

Back in humanity's hunter gatherer days, we truly lived off what the planet spontaneously produces, and that sustained world population of something like 50 million people.

The we invented farming, and all sorts of technology, and now we're 7000 million.

So how do those 6950 extra millions survive?

I think the best way to think of it is that they (we) produce their (our) own food!

Each mouth to feed also comes with two hands to produce food. The planet doesn't have to do the work. We make our own food.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by shmageggy on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:42AM (#27431656)
This is wrong. By this logic the planet could support infinite people, which is clearly impossible.

> The planet doesn't have to do the work. We make our own food.

We don't just conjure food from the ether, it requires space and resources, both of which are finite. We're already using half of the world's habitable land for farming, and we need to retain some wild spaces to perform all of the ecological functions that farmland can't. There's a limited amount of fresh water, etc.

And food isn't the only bottleneck. If the current population all lived a modern western lifestyle, we'd be emitting an even more unsustainable amount of carbon.

The planet is a closed, finite system, so by definition there must be some upper limit to what it can support.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by giantg2 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @07:03AM (#27433454)
So why do the experts estimate the planet can support between 8 and 11 billion people?

2 hands to produce it? No. Modern agriculture relies on machines for most things. The high yield monocrop pattern is how we feed so many already. I firmly believe that increasing people will decrease suitability.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by rab-the-goat on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:11PM (#27414075)
If they have such a high population and low production that they have to steal other peoples food sources, they're an existential threat to everyone else. What they will eat has been determined, and it's not likely to make the transition to local. So other people's starvation and the mass destruction of habitat will continue to be their externalities.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by giantg2 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:22PM (#27414157)
Much of the fish in the US is imported from China. So it's not just what "they" are eating.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by adventured on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:20PM (#27414625)
Do me a favor and post the latest figures on US domestic fish vs imports, where the imports break out to on a country-by-country basis, along with separating out US domestic fish that are exported to and then imported from China in a processing loop (used for cheaper processing, not actually caught or farmed by China).

That way we can better analyze the context of what "much" actually means.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by giantg2 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @03:48PM (#27415741)
You can do that if you'd like. It's supposed to be 30% of seafood is actual Chinese imports.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lupire on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:03PM (#27414025)
> Ya, no.

Please don't do this.

> are not healthy and happy fish

Citation needed that wild fish are "happy".

And it's dishonesty to assume unsustainable farming and sustainable wild catch in your argument.

Do you have any evidence that sufficient wild catch exists to feed the population?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by matheusmoreira on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:27AM (#27413797)
> Nothing wrong with hunting straight from nature.

Wild animals are likely to have parasites. Farmed animals can be controlled for that.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by Swenrekcah on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:49PM (#27414380)
Farms are often crowded and prime locations for parasites. Fish farms are notorious: https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/supermarket-salmon-riddle...
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by gjhh244 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:42AM (#27413885)
Parasites are no problem as long as you cook the food properly.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by tharkun__ on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:42AM (#27413891)
Farmed animals have a tendency to be a mono culture that is housed on way too little space which is a breeding ground for problems that then need to be controlled by heavy use of pharmaceuticals which is detrimental to human survival.

Think anti biotic use in chickens for example. And the resistances that come with it. And fish tanks that do exist already have some of these issues already as well. How expanding that even more is a good thing is nebolous to me.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by hungryforcodes on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:56PM (#27414439)
Also the animals may not like it.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by pibechorro on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:04AM (#27413673)
*reasources
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by BurningFrog on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:21AM (#27413775)
> What we need is a culture that eats local

This hostility to transporting goods you see occasionally is hard for me to understand.

I mean, I know I disagree with it, but what's weird is I don't even understand the underlying reasoning.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by booleandilemma on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:32AM (#27413434)
Interesting perspective, I hadn’t thought of it that way before.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by kristopolous on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:39PM (#27414299)
Fishing is really barbaric. It's fairly bloodless since we suffocate all the creatures but it's like going to Yosemite and just cutting the throats open of the animals you find, tossing then in a bag and taking them off to sell on the market.

I mean what on earth year are we in again?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ptaipale on Sunday June 06, 2021 @04:26PM (#27416009)
No, at least I don't suffocate fish that I catch. I stun and kill.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by kristopolous on Sunday June 06, 2021 @05:36PM (#27416556)
Also awful. It's not about an individual fish, many people don't understand this.

It's about disruption of an ecosystem that material reality demonstrates we still very poorly understand.

There's exactly zero evidence that anyone other than very specific tribes of indigenous peoples who sustained thousands of years, that humans writ large know how to maintain ecosystems.

All evidence points to our current practices having massive deleterious consequences and that we are already a few decades into a mass extinction event.

If that's not enough evidence to harbor every ship (or at least 95%) until we figure out what the fuck we're doing, there's no hope.

That's the truly repulsive aspects of barbarism, it's about the combination of ignorance and indifference as to the consequences of our actions

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by Gustomaximus on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:40AM (#27413486)
Some areas are getting destroyed but other countries are very good at managing their fisheries, England, Norway, Australia, Canada and more will be producing wild fish ongoing I would expect.

There definitely seems the need for some international waters rules to be agreed on, but given today's politics it seems unlikely the major powers would approach that with goodwill.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by Tams80 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:08PM (#27414532)
The thing with all those areas is that those countries have the resources to police their waters and would absolutely seize vessels that were in breach of their or international laws.

And if an illegal fishing armada turned up would very likely sink a few vessels to send a message.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by rorykoehler on Sunday June 06, 2021 @02:27PM (#27415114)
Argentina should lease their waters to a country with the means to defend them.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by usrusr on Sunday June 06, 2021 @08:35PM (#27417721)
A country leasing would care just as little about overfishing.

But yeah, don't let perfect be the enemy of the good. But who would be willing to mess with China?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by throwaway2037 on Monday June 07, 2021 @02:55AM (#27419802)
Add Korea and Japan to that list. They are very careful about managing their own fishing grounds, but, sadly, much less so for international waters.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ashtonkem on Sunday June 06, 2021 @09:58AM (#27413189)
The fascinating question is what happens if China tries to back this up with force. The US would probably feel the need to intervene, but I’m sure most of South America would be more than a bit wary having American war ships in the area given what we’ve done down there. On the other hand, better than Chinese warships perhaps?
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by abeppu on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:06AM (#27413687)
Isn't it pretty unlikely for them to try to use force to back up fishing boats secretly popping into Argentina's waters? That would be making a big noise to continue doing something that the fishing fleet was trying to do quietly, basically calling attention to their shady behavior. And wouldn't using force there be close to an invasion over one source of cheaper fish? That would be a really aggressive escalation, might alienate many countries, etc.

Surely China has bigger fish to fry (rimshot) with its foreign relations.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ashtonkem on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:50PM (#27414849)
> Isn't it pretty unlikely for them to try to use force to back up fishing boats secretly popping into Argentina's waters?

Yeah, probably. That's why I said if. It's an interesting scenario to think through, even if it's unlikely.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by hatchnyc on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:52AM (#27413588)
Argentina is a signatory of the Rio Treaty, as such any attack against Argentina would we considered an attack against the United States and most of the rest of South America.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inter-American_Treaty_of_Recip...

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by toyg on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:16AM (#27413746)
That treaty is not worth much of anything these days, too much history has happened since then.

It's true that the US consider South America "their own backyard", but there is a web of complex relationships which makes it unlikely they would blindly help this or that country retaliate against actions from superpowers - short of somebody establishing permanent strategic bases that are direct threats to the US mainland.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by Tams80 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:10PM (#27414545)
I doubt the US would turn down an opportunity to legally and likely popularly trim down the PLAN.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by nahuel0x on Sunday June 06, 2021 @07:33PM (#27417375)
Exactly. This very same treaty was invoked by Argentina when the Falklands/Malvinas war broke out to ask US for assistance against England, and it revealed as wet paper against real geopolitical alliances / calculations.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by hatchnyc on Sunday June 06, 2021 @02:25PM (#27415103)
I'm pretty sure if China went to war with Argentina it would find new teeth.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by galangalalgol on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:14AM (#27413739)
So mostly safe from violent retaliation. How important is their trade with China? If they impound Chinese fishing vessels (assuming they have a coast guard capaple of keeping up with this many intruders?) a loss of trade mught occur.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by stefanfisk on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:30AM (#27413427)
Does China even posses the ability to project power that far in any major sense?
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ForHackernews on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:46AM (#27413539)
Not really, no. China does not (yet) have a blue water navy. They have one, non-nuclear, carrier: https://thediplomat.com/2020/01/with-its-new-aircraft-carrie...
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by 29athrowaway on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:04AM (#27413678)
Ever heard of RIMPAC?

https://youtu.be/ygLwuhQsybw

It's a yearly naval exercise conducted by many countries in the Pacific. In the event of a naval war with China, they would have to fight not only the US but Australia, Canada, Japan, Philippines, and countless other countries.

It would not go well for them, I assure you.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ashtonkem on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:49PM (#27414839)
I was never questioning who would win a shooting war, I was questioning how the Argentinians would feel about it.

But if China did decide to project power, the question is not "would the US and its allies win a shooting war", the question is "will the US push back at all?"

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by 29athrowaway on Sunday June 06, 2021 @05:37PM (#27416563)
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ashtonkem on Sunday June 06, 2021 @07:11PM (#27417224)
No, it does not. Treaties require that the parties involved enforce them; like laws they become scraps of paper unless they’re backed up by the sovereign.

Which again returns to the original question; would the US push back, and how far would they go?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by 29athrowaway on Monday June 07, 2021 @01:23AM (#27419259)
I think the US would push back.

The US has many overseas bases in Latin America already... including a few of them in Argentina.

The Rio Pact, the yearly naval exercises, the overseas bases... and the historical precedent of the Monroe doctrine makes it very clear that the US doesn't want any outsiders messing around.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by pvaldes on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:12PM (#27414086)
> what happens if China tries to back this up with force.

Nobody in Argentina would buy Chinese products again, probably.

I predict that if they search a little, would find exactly the same pattern in Ethiopian waters.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by ashtonkem on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:47PM (#27414830)
> Nobody in Argentina would buy Chinese products again, probably.

Sure, but would that really affect Chinese decision making? I imagine that a partial US boycott would have a much larger impact than a full boycott in Argentina. Their GDP is 32nd in the world according to Wikipedia.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by soheil on Sunday June 06, 2021 @06:28PM (#27416943)
> China would stop bribes

What are these bribes you talk of? Can you provide sources?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by jaimex2 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:08PM (#27418603)
It's well known how corrupt Argentina's government is. You don't need to look it up, its common knowledge.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by paulcole on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:09PM (#27414060)
> My 2020 prediction that there will be no more wild caught fish in markets by 2030 seems ever closer...

Are you talking worldwide freshwater and saltwater fish?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by mastax on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:55PM (#27414427)
On average, fish sticks are increasing in much of the world:

https://www.pnas.org/content/117/4/2218

https://sustainablefisheries-uw.org/science-of-seaspiracy/

> Among the assessed stocks in the database, the average fishing pressure increased and the biomass declined on average until 1995, when fishing pressure began to decrease. By 2005, average biomass had started to increase (Fig. 1B). Averaged across all stocks in the database, biomass in 2016 was higher than BMSY, and fishing pressure was lower than UMSY. However, improvement is still needed for 24% of stocks, accounting for 19% of potential catch, which still have low biomass and high fishing pressure compared with MSY-based targets

> Since the mid-1990s, catch has generally declined in proportion to decreases in fishing pressure and was, in 2016, at 54% of where it was in 1989 for assessed stocks (Fig. 1B). This pattern is also observed at the regional level, where the correlation between exploitation rate and catch is generally >0.8 (Fig. 2). Global catch as reported by the FAO also declined during that period, but less so than for the assessed stocks reported here, likely because fishing effort in the parts of the world without assessment has not declined (18).

> Regions that have average biomass near or above BMSY are Australia, Atlantic Ocean tunas, Canada West Coast, European Union non-Mediterranean, Indian Ocean tunas, Norway/Iceland/Faroes, New Zealand, Pacific Ocean tunas, Alaska, the US Southeast and Gulf, and the US West Coast. Although these regions have not avoided the overfishing of all stocks, conservative management has kept most stocks at high biomass. Many areas where biomass was below BMSY in 2000 have seen reductions in fishing pressure and stock increases, including the Atlantic Ocean tunas; the East, Southeast, and Gulf coasts of the United States; the Canada East Coast; and the Northwest Pacific Ocean (Japan and Russia). Tuna stocks in the Pacific and Indian Oceans, which were well above BMSY in 1970, were near BMSY in 2016.

> Stocks in the Mediterranean-Black Sea have low biomass and continue to decline, whereas stocks in South America have declined considerably in the last 20 y and were below target levels in 2016. Fishing pressure in South America has been dropping since the early 2000s. Only 4 of 36 stocks in NW Africa have MSY-based reference points for biomass estimated, all of which are large-volume, small-pelagic fisheries and are therefore unrepresentative of the many demersal fisheries in the region. The stock abundance for those small-pelagic stocks is above MSY targets, but exploitation rates were high (2.5 times UMSY) for the 6 NW African stocks for which exploitation rate reference points exist. Regional assessments (19) estimated that most demersal stocks were overexploited by 2008 and recommended reductions in fishing pressure.

It is of course difficult to create and enforce a regulatory regime to prevent overfishing, but there tends to be buy-in among fisherman once their fisheries collapse.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by nixass on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:30AM (#27413819)
Well, napalm carpet bombing and the fleet from the video is gone, and likely won't come back, ever