News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by baron_harkonnen on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:37AM (#27413460)
I'm genuinely curious when all of this will catch up to us. I spend a relatively large amount of my spare time keeping up with myriad of ways we are destroying our environment, the fact that our ecosystem is in deep danger is without question.

At the same time, while I am anecdotally aware we are experiencing a range of shortages right now, it never seems to quite show up in our economic data.

Take for example the FRED data on global fish prices [0]. When you look at that chart you see nothing particularly interesting. You can pore over all of the commodities charts and if that was all the data you had you would soon come to the conclusion that nothing obvious is wrong with our environment (at least from an economic standpoint).

To be absolutely clear, I'm not questioning that something is wrong, I think we're in major trouble. But I am still genuinely surprised that this peril doesn't present itself in any economic data I can find. Any insights into when we will feel this our how/when this environmental destruction will become visible in our economic data would be appreciated.

[0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSALMUSDQ

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by justnotworthit on Sunday June 06, 2021 @02:38PM (#27415206)
It reminds me of the national debt/fiscal gap discussion. Everyone will agree you can't owe a million times GDP, but no one can describe the "limit". Every year and decade you have people crying out that it's unsustainable and will result in collapse, and you have people saying "nah, more". You have examples of countries imploding, and you have the USA with doubles down every X years.

Surely you can't parlay indefinitely, but there hasn't been an implosion yet... until there is... but then everyone who enjoyed the political and financial benefits of parlaying is long dead, their inheritors heavily insulated... or there isn't a financial implosion... or there's some other disaster rendering this disaster moot... or something else (free energy? Second Coming?) appears and fixes it, allowing the reckless to get away with it... if we ever agree on who the reckless were...

We could just follow Taleb's warnings (the precautionary principle, antifragility, black swan events), but we can't even agree on basic reality, and the people who are greatly benefiting off their version of reality will never budge, and the people who might suffer aren't yet born (probably).

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by nomoreplease on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @08:57AM (#27434526)
> Everyone will agree you can't owe a million times GDP, but no one can describe the "limit".

I’ve heard the limit described as “when the nation can only afford the interest payments on the principal” which means the nation can never pay back the principal itself. I heard that 10 years ago

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by mason55 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:43AM (#27413509)
I’d guess given technology advances you’d expect prices to go down, so the fact that they stay flat is actually indicating that fish are becoming harder to find. Similar to how if the price of something stays the same then it’s becoming cheaper because of inflation.

Also, fish are not a long term investment. The price only depends on how hard they are to find combined with demand to eat them sometime soon. If you could buy a fish now with the expectation of selling it later when stocks dry up then I think you’d see a lot more upward pressure.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by HappyDreamer on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:01AM (#27413649)
Another thing cold be if costs for transportation and preparing the fish, storing it etc, grocery store salaries, as of now outweighs the cost of fishing it up from the ocean? (But if so, maybe not much longer.) (I don't know, just wondering.)
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lupire on Sunday June 06, 2021 @11:54AM (#27413971)
Animal species almost always grow to consume more unless they are destroyed by predators or exhaust their environment.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lettergram on Sunday June 06, 2021 @03:48PM (#27415740)
> To be absolutely clear, I'm not questioning that something is wrong, I think we're in major trouble. But I am still genuinely surprised that this peril doesn't present itself in any economic data I can find. Any insights into when we will feel this our how/when this environmental destruction will become visible in our economic data would be appreciated.

Simply put, The environmental destruction isn’t what you think. For instance, Based on my experience climate modeling and working with environmental papers - I don’t believe carbon emissions has a meaningful impact on global warming.

Further, and in way of example: the warming should lead to increased food production (they often say as much in their papers). What will happen is greater soil erosion, so we have to protect against that (or we will long-term) have crop problems.

The general point, is the system is more complex than we realize. There are no one-off answers because the system will always be adjusting to try to keep an equilibrium AND so will humans. Farm Fishing is on the rise, protection zones are being setup, global fishing rules have been ignored, but local ones have not, etc etc

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by mixologic on Sunday June 06, 2021 @05:15PM (#27416404)
"Based on my experience climate modeling and working with environmental papers" And what experience is that, exactly?
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by lettergram on Sunday June 06, 2021 @06:22PM (#27416905)
I worked with several academics and corporations as a contractor building their simulations. I’ve also read a lot of papers as well, etc.

Like most simulations, they pretty much only can match reality so closely. for instance, we don’t have many long term measurements, so we make (educated-ish) guesses. Academics also repeatedly run their models, tweaking parameters to get the results they want. Frankly, I don’t trust any research using simulations, after being paid to work on environmental, biological systems, simulations for drones and machines (trucks, construction, etc). (Drones and other machines at least had a way to quickly test).

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by mahogany on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:53PM (#27418511)
> we don’t have many long term measurements, so we make (educated-ish) guesses

Out of curiosity, what are some examples of these measurements/guesses you are referring to?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by eloff on Sunday June 06, 2021 @06:15PM (#27416856)
Funny that's contrary to the experience of > 95% of climate scientists. I would trust that over an unsupported reference to your experience, whatever that is.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by splitstud on Sunday June 06, 2021 @07:27PM (#27417337)
We generally expect models to have predictive value, at least through a set of historic data, before we lens them much credence. We have made an exception for climate models. I believe following basic scientific procedures is a better plan than listening to what amounts to a widely-hekd belief structure. It is particularly galling when we could be using time and effort to combat the proven environmental catastrophes such as air and water qualities, deforestation, and issues such as the one that started this thread.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by eloff on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:05AM (#27423420)
You know all those climate models are back tested with the historical data too right?

Climate modeling is a tricky thing because the system is so complex and we are continually surprised by interactions and effects we didn't expect.

However, climate science is about far more than just models. The models are actually the least compelling part.

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by kortilla on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:22PM (#27418330)
> Funny that's contrary to the experience of > 95% of climate scientists.

That’s an appeal to authority though. What’s wrong with the following statement?

“95% of numerologists strongly believe in the predictive power of numerology so therefore we should trust them.”

When people question the foundations of an entire field, presenting a giant sample of people who work in said field an implicitly agree with the foundation by labeling themselves as such isn’t really a compelling argument?

Guess what percentage of catholic priests think faith in Jesus is important?

Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w... by eloff on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:03AM (#27423391)
That's a fair point if you're going to question an entire field.

I think the difference in this case is the arguments and evidence presented by climate science is generally accepted by experts and policy makers outside of the field.