Why can't I disable this 'account setting' from the Amazon web portal. Plus, if I mistrust Amazon's repurposing of devices, why would I want an Alexa app installed to potentially repurpose my phone? Funnily enough, Sidewalk was just one of 3 surprising anti-security/anti-privacy settings available only in the app.
You wouldn't. However if you were ambivalent and did not care one way or the other, or unaware of the change, then of course you would not bother to opt-out. This is no doubt Amazon's strategy. And when you opt-out you are forced to install an app that may well have worse consequences than Sidewalk.
This strategy, so often used by "tech" companies, seems to take inspiration from direct mail.1 I have a well-educated friend who, many years ago, found himself working for a direct mail company early in his career. He did not stay long. The people he worked for sounded like dregs, and I think he had a crisis of conscience. Today, ethical standards seem to have fallen. Interesting how the word "hustle", as in "side hustle", has been repurposed by young people as something supposedly respectable. Usually that word implies some sort of con or other underhanded activity.2
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_mail
2. echo -e 'DEFINE all hustle\nQUIT\n'|nc -vvn 199.48.130.6 2628|tr -cd '\12\40-\176'|less
I think it's more redefined as something necessary, as the number of good jobs for young people have been on a continuous downward trend for decades all over the world.
Seems like a genuine customer problem. If you want to set up smart lights through your back yard, or a smart sensor at the edge of your driver, they might not have WiFi connectivity to the rest of your house.
Hence the Sidewalk metaphor - a mesh network allows the devices to hop access from one another.
There is also a pretty detailed Privacy/Security Whitepaper and it's important to point out this before any alarmist "Amazon is spying on you!" pearl clutching: https://m.media-amazon.com/images/G/01/sidewalk/final_privac...
That sounds like a "you" problem, not a "me" problem. If "you" are setting up smart devices where "you" don't have connectivity, "you" should provide the connectivity, not "me". (Note: I don't have a problem with devices piggy backing on/extending their owner's network).
TFA mentions possible issues with FTC and TOS violations with customers' ISPs. But what about overages? Who's liable for those? Is there going to be a metered breakdown of network usage? Will AMZN cover costs of overages due to neighbor usage? What about potential liability issues? Infosec issues?
This just sounds like a too easy setup for a class action lawsuit.
Except Alexa is extensible, so you can't draw any kind of barrier around what's actually being done using that network.
Airtags don’t “get online.” Apple devices take note of the Airtag’s identifying characteristics (I don’t know how this is defined) and report back to Apple having been in proximity to them. They are “dumb” with respect to the internet. Just Bluetooth beacons.
It would be like Ford announcing that they had been putting USB ports in the bumper of every car for the last 5 years, and starting today you can walk up to any random persons car and charge your phone.
I've seen comments on Youtube that seemed shocked that Youtube could trace comments to an IP address! We are deep in it now, approaching a point where the barrier to entry to understand how the technology functions is too much even for capable specialists to fully comprehend the rampant abuse happening at this very moment. How often do we as technical people find out about some new god damned thing some god damned tech company is doing to steal our data or otherwise exploit us as "customers"? And even people who are technically capable of grasping the depth of the power of this technology are still busy hammering away on their keyboards to make it more powerful, having never had to worry about violent psychopaths with political power. We are creating a truly terrifying nightmare of brutal suffering for our grandchildren or their children.
It's really quite similar to Apple's Find My network.
I just wish this was going to some open collective where everyone could benefit, rather than just Amazon customers...
As far as I’m concerned based on Amazon Logistics performance in my area and the impact to the quality of other delivery carriers in my area, Amazon is not afraid to engage in a race to the bottom in the name of market share and profits. Opting me in to Sidewalk will be the straw that breaks the camel’s back and sends me to anyone else except for Amazon when shopping.
Oh, and an ad-delivery mechanism. Ask Alexa to set a timer, and sometimes she'll rebut with "while you wait why not try Amazon Music!" It's absolutely infuriating.
I emailed [email protected] (VIP support team) and they confirmed it could not be disabled by normal means. They disabled it on their end but then had to do it again when somehow it got unset.
The "start with the customer and work backward" mantra that used to be strong in the company is now completely ignored for Alexa it seems. The first domino has fallen. I suspect we'll see many more fall as a result.
If one of the kids botches a request, it might suggest something they could ask, but it's always basic stuff.
I agree with the sentiment that it is a crying shame this technology could be used to help people for whom keyboards become complicated but instead it's used to trick them.
Should you not?
There’s a bit of a spectrum of that. On one end of the spectrum, we all leave our front doors unlocked and our car keys in our parked cars in case someone is stranded and needs to borrow our car. Most of us don’t do that, but that’s what a truly high trust society looks like.
I think it’s prudent to expect any large tech company to violate our privacy to exactly the degree they are physically capable of. It doesn’t mean we should morally approve of them living down to our low expectations of them, any more than we should morally approve of burglars and car thieves exploiting the naivety of people who think they don’t need to lock up their homes and vehicles.
And yes, it is a crying shame that we live in a low-trust world.
you should not excuse people behaving badly because it is to be expected.
if you want to be able to protect against people behaving badly you should learn to expect it of them, expectation of bad behavior enables preparation.
I've never been disappointed expecting people to behave quite badly.
I often see comments like this, and I truly wonder if anything would prevent people from using Amazon. I don't want to criticise you specifically — it's so easy to say you would switch but becoming increasingly difficult to do. And motivated cognition is really a thing.
Alexa advertising to me, becoming a nuisance, and coopting my internet connection all happen close to me.
I ordered two HomePod Minis to replace the Echo Dots in my home yesterday. Amazon will no longer have a foothold in my home, and won’t have visibility into my shopping list or other usage.
I cancelled Prime last year so have been shopping around more...I've consistently been able to find cheaper prices elsewhere with free 2 day shipping.
Sometimes people on HN try to analogise to something like a retail industry where a customer can be observed through their purchases. However there is a major difference. The purchase. That is the ultimate goal of the retailer attained. A purchase. The retail business is not some honeypot to gather information on people. It is trying to make sales. Users of "free" internet-connected products and services generally do not make purchases from the provider of those products/services. They are not fulfilling the goal of the business: to make money. Thus, the company must find paying customers somewhere else.
Particularly amusing is the oft-used "justification" of [we spy on you] "to make our ["free"] products and services better." Sometimes participants in "the industry" suggest they are trying to make products and services better for users. Other times it less clear exactly who the improvements are (purportedly) intended to benefit. Of course the ultimate goal, because this "industry" of spying is considered by them as a "business", is to make things better for paying customers. If they fail to collect information from users, they do not make money and the "business" fails. Even non-profits supported by deals with advertising companies feel compelled to conduct "telemetry". Not learning about users is deemed unacceptable.
"Spy or die".
To that I ask: what problem does Alexa solve?? Why does one need a device to switch the lights?!? or turn music on or off. How much is one willing to pay for a minuscule, incremental particle of convenience.
This may be an unpopular opinion, but I think Alexa users only have themselves to blame.
Assisted living for many.
For both of these it's the ease and affordability that it brings.
For what it's worth, the only way to Opt-Out from Apple's broad network like this is to disable all "Find My" network tracking, so you'll never be able to remote control your own phone using its standard radios if you wish to disable the tag network stuff.
The canonical anti-example is this: You buy a smart TV, but don’t give it your WiFi password. No problem, it connects to any Amazon device whether in your house or next door, and now it can sell information about what you watch, how many people its camera can see are in the room, words you say aloud in its presence, &c.
At the engineering level, Apple’s mesh looks like Amazon’s mesh in exactly the same way that at the engineering level, an iPhone looks a lot like a high-end Android phone. What’s different between them is what Amazon uses its mesh network for, just as what’s different between an iPhone and an Android phone is what Google uses its access to your devices for.
Apple obstructs adtech and tracking. Google builds its business on adtech and tracking. Apple uses its mesh network to find items. People fear that Amazon will use its mesh network to spy on you in the name of revenue.
Selling access to a mesh network to other providers will become an additional source of recurring revenue from what would have otherwise been one time revenue source (hardware sale).
It will be no different than Amazon competing w/ FedEx and UPS using it's delivery engine
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/04/29/amazons-ads-business-nears-7...
Amazon's track record with privacy and security is much more Apple-esque than Google-esque
With cheap flash, we could do a lot of high-latency high-bandwidth data transport with just existing movements.
We could eliminate telecoms overnight but we just don’t have the organization to do it. Like, every house used to have a VHF/UHF receiving tower on it.
But if you act like an exit node, you could be screwed if you live in a place where an IP is enough to be found guilty and nobody runs a public wifi. But you can always tunnel your outside traffic out over TOR.
Imagine wanting to move data from city A to city B, so they'd decide to do a Tinder match of a girl from City B to this guy from City A, so he'd visit her a lot and be the data conduit...
And few good opportunities for caching either.
Would be cool to have a seamless system where you put in your Netflix request and a couple days later, the shows arrive because the aircraft has a Pi loaded with SD cards on it and boots at ground level.
This is what netflix used to do.
Not true. I just checked on my own phone, and the toggles for "Find My iPhone" and "Find My network" are separate. Disabling the latter only warns you you can't locate your phone "even if it's offline", i.e. if the "standard radio" is off.
A busybody, myopic, minor corporate executive wanting to implement a known technique for more career growth. (See Comcast, Apple, et al.)
I wrote my guess elsewhere in this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27358758
tl;dr Amazon will resell access to Sidewalk to device manufacturers, allowing them to cost-effectively bridge the "telemetry gap".
> If you don't want your smart tv to spy on you, then don't give it your wifi password.
So we’re kind of lucky they at least announced it as they could have just turned it on and opted everyone in.
Of course when the radio inspector comes knocking on my door because Amazon has loaded the wrong firmware into my box (without my knowledge) it's me who's breaking the law, not Amazon
It's not that difficult to run cable and use power over ethernet.
I'm sure it would be no big deal if I just took a few cents from you and all your family members every day to buy my coffee each day?
https://www.tomsguide.com/reference/what-is-amazon-sidewalk
Added to my list for the next time I'm on the phone with my parents, for our (weekly at this point) how-to sessions on "stopping the industry I work in from spying on you". I really, really wish product managers would understand the kind of ecosystem they're building, and the kind of customer blow-back they will enable by optimizing for $$$ under the guise of "making things easier".
Side question: what problem does Amazon thinks this solves? Bad connectivity experiences for Ring users?
Edit: changed the link to a better guide linked elsewhere in the thread