News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ClumsyPilot on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:07AM (#27233515)
A competitive market would enable me to sort by salary and benefits and apply for the best job.

However companies don't want to compete on salary, and potentialy drive them up - they want maximum leverage. They get more leverage if process is obscure, so that you only agree salary late in the process and for the applicant, pulling out is risky.

The market is not really free - its being manipulated by one side.

Similarly with healthcare you don't know how much you will be charged upfront, so there is no competition on price.

With housing (in UK) there is no competition on quality because the seller doesn't have to disclose any problems with the house. If it falls of a cliff the minute you sign on the dotted line, it's your problem.

You have to pay for the surveyor to find out any issues the house might have, and that means you can only view a few houses before you've paid the house price in survey fees.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by gambiting on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:21AM (#27233646)
>>With housing (in UK) there is no competition on quality because the seller doesn't have to disclose any problems with the house. If it falls of a cliff the minute you sign on the dotted line, it's your problem.

I'm in the UK and that's absolutely not true. If you think the owner knew about the problem and purposefully omitted telling you, then you definitely have a court case and any law firm worth their salt will win this. I bought a house recently and the documents the sellers had to fill out for the solicitors very clearly say there are are no known issues with this house, so if that's a lie then the sale can be rendered null and void.

>>You have to pay for the surveyor to find out any issues the house might have, and that means you can only view a few houses before you've paid the house price in survey fees.

I've had a few mortgages so far and I'm yet to find a bank not willing to cover the cost of a full survey, as the bank also wants to know the house they are securing the loan against is actually worth the money.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ClumsyPilot on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:39AM (#27233839)
In sane countries the seller must comission a survey and provide it to the buyer. The UK system where each buyer comissions a survey is absurd.

I do not understand how the mortgage helps you - you are still paying for it, and if the survey uncovers issues, you either take mortgage on a house with problems, or you are out of pocket.

If you pull out, and next house you view has issues too, you have to take it because at some poijt you run out of money

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by nradov on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:45AM (#27233927)
That's not sane, it's crazy! As a buyer why would I trust a surveyor selected by the seller? I would rather pay inspector myself for an independent opinion. In the US this only costs a few hundred dollars for a typical house, which is a tiny fraction of the overall transaction price.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by maccard on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:48AM (#27235578)
I live in Scotland, and the process here is the seller has to undertake a survey with someone who is accredited. In practice this means that the same 3-4 firms end up doing most of the surveys. It's not just some ranodmer saying "yeah, looks good mate".

> In the US this only costs a few hundred dollars for a typical house, which is a tiny fraction of the overall transaction price.

You know what's even better than _only_ a couple of hundred dollars? The seller paying it once.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by dagw on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:46AM (#27262246)
The seller paying it once.

It's the same in Sweden, that the seller does and pays for a survey. Still common for the buyer to request to be allowed to get a second independent survey done. Of course the seller can refuse to allow a second survey, but that in itself is quite telling.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by edmundsauto on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:25PM (#27237048)
Suppose the seller got a bad report. Wouldn’t they just shop to a new surveyor to get a better one? The incentives are bad in this situation.

Also, even if the money first comes out of the sellers pocket, it’s still being paid by the buyer in the houses cost.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by rapind on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:36PM (#27237186)
Easy way to solve that is making sure there’s a record of all accredited inspections that potential buyers can access. So you have a do-over after fixing something but there’s a trail for the buyer.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by pyuser583 on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:17PM (#27241140)
In they US there’s a very competitive market. But that also means big differences in quality.

I wouldn’t trust an inspector chosen at random, much less an inspector chosen by the seller.

To be clear, I don’t care who is paying - as long as I pick the inspector.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ClumsyPilot on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:54AM (#27234003)
For the same reason you trust an auditor and accountant hired by Tesla to produce quartely earnings report - they are on the hook if they lie.

Surely you do not hire an independant accountant every time you buy stocks?

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Kirby64 on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:45AM (#27234647)
Lie vs. miss is relative. Every single inspector in the US at least has liability that only extends to the cost of their inspection (or, sometimes, 2x their inspection cost...). Hardly enough to cover any losses if there is major damage that is overlooked.

I had a friend who bought a house with major termite damage (i.e., every wall had to be removed to repair the studs basically), and 2 inspectors overlooked the damage. He said in retrospect (after doing a bunch of research on termite damage), it should have been obvious to inspectors, but they missed it.

He tried to pursue legal action against either the seller or the inspectors, and basically was told: impossible to prove seller knew (as there was no repairs done), and inspectors are not held liable.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by lfowles on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:39PM (#27236341)
Hah yes, inspectors try to be as minimally liable as possible. Ours went to great lengths to get us to have someone come out and check the "stains" underneath a bathroom sink without actually saying the m-word that rhymes with cold :)
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday May 21, 2021 @02:02PM (#27237594)
Home inspectors in the US are barely useful.

If you really don't know anything about houses (or feel as if you do not), then having someone walk you through some of the things you may have to face living in a particular house is probably a good idea.

However, even as just an enthusiastic amateur, I know more about home construction and repair than most home inspectors. When I bought my current house I skipped the home inspector, and hired an electrician, a roofer and a structural engineer. It cost me more, but I got seriously informed reports about the property, not just boilerplate fill-in-the-blank PDFs telling me that one of the windows rattled.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by shard on Friday May 21, 2021 @03:52PM (#27239069)
I like your solution of gathering subject matter experts and getting individual reports. Did the 3 of them cover all aspects of the house? I am not an expert so I don't know if anything is left out, does the structural engineer also cover plumbing? Or is that not an issue?
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday May 21, 2021 @04:34PM (#27239604)
I know enough about home construction and repair to be able to assess other items. Actually, I can do my own residential wiring and stud framing etc., but I was moving into an adobe house. This required a knowledge of wiring, construction and roofing that I did not have from previous work that I've done. If the plumbing had been a part of the adobe construction itself, I'd have asked for a plumber too, but it was not.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by AbrahamParangi on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:09AM (#27234150)
An auditor hired by the seller has an incentive to make the seller happy that you cannot eliminate, only reduce through legal threats.

An auditor hired by the buyer has no such incentive.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by teddyh on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:28AM (#27235299)
You’re thinking of the monetary incentive only, which might be too narrow a view.

The “regulatory capture” principle might apply here – an auditor only meets any one client once in their life, but probably meets some landlords many times, presumably develops a relationship with them, and might want to tend to not upset that relationship.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by jonfw on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:24AM (#27235237)
If I was going to drop the kind of money that I did on my house on retail stocks, then you can bet that I'd be doing some due diligence on my end that's worth at least the same few hundred bucks
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by lotsofpulp on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:33AM (#27234466)
> For the same reason you trust an auditor and accountant hired by Tesla to produce quartely earnings report - they are on the hook if they lie.

“On the hook” has different meanings when you have the enforcement power of the US federal government and criminal courts versus an individual who has to cough up tens of thousands for lawyers in civil court.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by InitialLastName on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:19AM (#27234263)
>Surely you do not hire an independant accountant every time you buy stocks?

Of course not, I let the short sellers do it for me.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Judgmentality on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:13PM (#27236877)
Then you'd miss out on GME, TSLA, and all the stocks that make the most money. That's obviously a viable strategy, but it's certainly not the best in terms of ROI.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by edmundsauto on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:27PM (#27237078)
You also probably miss out on the fraud and negative ROI that the investigations would conceivably uncover.

Also, making decisions around catching Tesla or GME at the right timing in the market… that’s not a great starting point for investment strategy.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Judgmentality on Friday May 21, 2021 @02:37PM (#27238090)
> Also, making decisions around catching Tesla or GME at the right timing in the market… that’s not a great starting point for investment strategy.

I thought the same thing for years, and just avoided the market except for a 401k and stock granted by companies I worked at. Then I got into trading because I thought I could make money trading volatile stocks and I've never looked back (I've already made enough to retire). So far I've only lost money on my value stocks.

To each his own.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by shard on Friday May 21, 2021 @03:56PM (#27239122)
Do you think your case is a typical case? How much does experience count? How much did you need to educate yourself to reach this level? Were there any major stumbles or obstacles? I am encouraged by your story, but am also weary that it only sounds reasonable because all the harrowing details were left out.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Judgmentality on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:44PM (#27242421)
I think I got lucky, but I think luck is required to be successful at anything (including coding). I actually haven't had any bad luck yet, the only stocks I've lost money on so far have been some of my value stocks. I fully expect some of my risky investments to go south.

The best advice I can give is pretty generic - follow the data. First of all actually find the data. Don't trust some finance news rag to tell you anything meaningful, some of them actually have a direct incentive to lie to you. Now that you have the data, what does it say? This sounds simple, but everyone told me I was an idiot to invest in GME in January. They said the same thing in March. So far my investment in GME has more than a 10x ROI. I'm just using GME as an example because it's topical - people tell me I'm in a cult while I'm actively making money betting against them.

"Buy the rumor, sell the news" is pretty easy to understand, just find a stock you know well (I would guess something in tech, like Alphabet or Amazon but whatever) and look at dates for stock movements, rumors, and announcements. You can do this retroactively to find a pattern then try to apply it moving forward. "Never invest in something you don't understand" is general advice outside of stocks, but just an extension of what I said initially - do your own research until it makes sense to you.

I think a huge amount of inertia is just people afraid to try it because they've been conditioned their entire lives to believe they can't make money doing it. I'm quickly realizing how much of this is bullshit (I realize I'm lucky and I understand I'm likely in a local maxima, but I am still extremely confident a lot of the things I've been told are just wrong). So take a small amount of money and invest it and see how it goes. Learn. Iterate. Improve. The goal is to start making money before you lose it. I actually started with just $10k and once I started to figure it out put in more money as I wanted to increase my profit.

At the end of the day it's your money and you should do what you want with it. So long as you understand you will definitely lose money sometimes and are willing to learn from it, give it a go with whatever money you're willing to lose.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by lotsofpulp on Friday May 21, 2021 @03:10PM (#27238548)
Do you work on your own accord then and do not need to subject yourself to a boss?
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Judgmentality on Friday May 21, 2021 @03:28PM (#27238787)
Yep, I quit my job in tech and just do whatever I want currently. I may take another regular job, I may not. I'd hardly even call what I do now "work," although I am still actively investing.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by alistairSH on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:03AM (#27234937)
And in the US, the inspector is typically only liable up to the cost of the inspection, or some pre-arranged value. He also isn't an actual engineer, so is mostly worthless. He'll check the roof with a pain of binoculars, but not necessarily get onto the roof. He'll check the age of appliances, but that's mostly obvious to anybody willing to do a base amount of research. Etc.

If there's anything remotely questionable, they'll punt and tell the buyer to hire an actual engineer (or plumber or electrician), so even more money out of pocket.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by throwawayboise on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:17AM (#27235145)
It's similar with the survey. In a mortgage survey, they basically verify that a house of the specified construction and square footage is on the property where it is supposed to be. Nothing you really couldn't see by just driving by.

When I have bought a house, in order to get a proper survey with the property boundaries marked by stakes I had to pay for that myself.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by FiatLuxDave on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:22AM (#27235224)
Does anybody know if there is a secondary market for home inspection reports? I know that the two times I was involved with a home purchase in the U.S., I needed to hire a home inspector. But the interested party in front of me also had to hire a home inspector. Would it not make sense for the interested parties to split the cost for one home inspector rather than reproducing the work? After all, copying information is almost free, but paying for the time of multiple inspectors is a redundant cost.

Does anybody do this?

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Wistar on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:22PM (#27236098)
A bit tangential:

Back in the early 90s — on a recommendation from a realtor who was a close friend of my brother's — I hired an inspector who was close to retirement. He worked with his wife who served as his assistant tasked with, in essence, taking dictation of her husband's near constant commentary as he conducted an incredibly thorough inspection. Every outlet tested for proper ground, every nook and cranny looked at, wood moisture content, HVAC pitot readings, masonry, roof … just a super-duper detailed inspection that took about 6 hours to complete.

At the end of the inspection, he summed up by saying the house was good and that he had no qualms recommending the house.

Two days later, he stopped by with a three-ring binder that contained his inspection report. It first contained a summary that concisely covered the positive and few negative aspects of the house. Then there was a section about the history of the house: the year built, the name of the builder, changes in the neighborhood since it had been built, earthquakes it had gone through, flood events in the area, and so on. It also included the manufacturer names of things such as the windows, door hardware, etc.

The third section was lengthy, covering the precise state of the electrical, plumbing, structural, envelope, etc, and included all the notes his wife had taken during the course of the inspection. It included a sub-section with warnings about certain materials that likely contained asbestos and would need to be dealt with if we ever did remodeling.

Finally, the largest section was what he called a "maintenance work order" arranged as a schedule for the ongoing, recurring upkeep of the house but beginning with things he thought needed to be done immediately, replacement of the circuit breaker box, splash blocks under each outdoor faucet, tuck-pointing some of the chimney's brickwork, etc. And then his estimates as to when he thought systems might need to be replaced, the water heater, furnace, roofing, etc. As I discovered when the water heater burst, his estimates were pretty much spot-on. Over time, I added notes as we upgraded things, added low-voltage wiring, and remodeled the basement.

Nine years later, when I sold the house, the buyer was elated to have this owner's manual and I am fairly certain that the book was key to a very fast sale of the house which we did without a realtor.

As I look back on it now, I realize that inspection was perhaps the best $350 I have ever spent.

When we bought our next house, the inspection took about an hour and produced a few page report, most of it boilerplate.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ayewo on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:57PM (#27236653)
How long was the duration between the 90s purchase and the next purchase? 20 years?

This was fascinating to read!

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Wistar on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:00PM (#27236690)
Spring 1993 to Spring 2001.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by computator on Saturday May 22, 2021 @12:19AM (#27243415)
> very fast sale of the house which we did without a realtor

How did you find a buyer without a realtor? Are you able get into the listing databases without using a realtor? Any special tips for selling without a realtor?

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Wistar on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:01PM (#27267638)
Sorry, I missed this comment. Actually, I have sold two homes without a realtor. Both times were flukes more than anything I really planned.

The first time I mentioned to a co-worker that I was thinking about selling my (first) house. He said that he thought he could be interested. He came and saw the house and agreed on the spot to buy it. That was that. We established the price by asking the realtor who had sold us the house what the price should be and then reducing the price by an amount that was 50% of what the standard sales commission would have been. In essence, we split what would have been the commission with the buyer.

We also split the cost for a real-estate attorney — a few hundred dollars, total — and got it done in just a few days.

The second time was a little more planned. I carefully photographed the house and painstakingly built a website for it with tons of description. Whether or not we hired a realtor, I thought a website would help us sell. This was early 2001, a web presence for a house for sale was still fairly rare.

We contacted the same realtor who had sold us our first home and asked her for a market value for the house. I offered to pay her a fee for her expertise and she declined saying that she knew we'd end up hiring her anyway, and that, "You may have sold your first house on your own but you'll never be able to do it twice."

A few days after the website had gone up, I decided to put a small "for sale" sign in the yard and, no joke, as I was pounding the sign into the ground, a passing car stopped and, longer story short, within a few hours she and her husband agreed to buy the house. The husband was a building contractor and he was especially impressed by the aforementioned inspection report.

As we had done with our first house, we set the price at market minus half the commission so it was well-priced.

We hired the same real-estate attorney who put the sale together. It was super easy and done around the buyer's kitchen table in a single two-hour meeting, followed a few days later by an official closing at an escrow company.

Now that the market in our area is smoking red hot, I am pretty sure we could sell our present home on our own too. We might miss out on bidding war wins but, I think, in the end, we'd come out okay.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by shard on Friday May 21, 2021 @04:00PM (#27239174)
If anyone knows what the magic words are to finding this kind of thorough report nowadays, please share!
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Wistar on Saturday May 22, 2021 @01:58AM (#27243935)
"Time Machine" are the only words that come to mind, alas.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Mountain_Skies on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:49AM (#27235591)
If you happen to select the same home inspector as the other perspective buyer, you can rest assured that they will simply copy over the report and charge you the full amount. It's best to arrange to be there when the inspection happens to prevent this or drive-by inspections.

One of the issues that keeps there from being a neutral third party holding the inspection results is the vast difference in quality in home inspections. Since home inspectors are not liable for anything they miss in the inspections, there are some really poor quality inspectors out there. The third party hiring the inspectors isn't going to be aligned with your interest in hiring the best inspector. Most likely they're going to go with whoever is the cheapest so they can keep as most of the fee you and other buyers are paying them.

In states that license and regulate home inspectors, perhaps part of the requirements could be that every home inspection report has to be part of the public record for the property. If there are multiple inspections, each of them becomes part of the record. A sneaky seller might pose as a buyer and payoff an inspector to give them a good report that becomes part of the record so it would still be in the buyer's interest to hire their own inspector if there is only one inspection report. At some point though, there will be enough inspection reports that your risk of only seeing faulty reports becomes low.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by pyuser583 on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:21PM (#27241182)
I doubt it … after I buy the home, it’s no longer in my interest to disclose any problems.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Der_Einzige on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:03PM (#27235815)
In the current US housing market, you're expected to waive bringing in a house inspector because if you don't, the seller will sell to someone who will (and they likely have 3 all cash offers besides you ready to go).
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by kbelder on Friday May 21, 2021 @02:39PM (#27238109)
That's what we're finding right now. Any attempt at negotiation just means your offer gets binned and the house will go to somebody who'll pony up the money, no questions asked.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by wbl on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:43AM (#27233902)
In the US the buyer hires an inspector after the contract is agreed and the transfer can be voided if the inspector finds serious issues. Typically the price gets adjusted.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by pmorici on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:05AM (#27234113)
Home inspectors are a borderline scam. In my experience they never find any of the real problems and only surface superficial stuff that should be obvious even to a layman.

This probably is because many buyers go with the inspector recommendation of their realtor and realtors aren’t going to recommend someone that is too through to the point of risking the deal.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by reedjosh on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:08AM (#27235022)
In that vein realtors are basically a scam.

A decent inspector can and will find things, but true it may be difficult to find one.

I think the solution is going to be an unpopular take--learn about the world and be able to do a lot of this stuff yourself.

I bought my house without a realtor and without an inspection. My house needed work for sure, but I got a great deal and learning experience in both the buying and repair/maintenance. I spend my evenings working on the house instead of watching tv and eating garbage. Three years later I have a few 100k in equity.

I do wish the world was full of trustworthy people and life was easy, but no number of bureaucratic requirements are going to make these problems go away. If you live in a world you don't understand, you will be taken advantage of.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by pyuser583 on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:23PM (#27241199)
Realtors are a scam.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by cptskippy on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:02AM (#27234923)
> Home inspectors are a borderline scam. In my experience they never find any of the real problems and only surface superficial stuff that should be obvious even to a layman.

In most states, home inspectors are licensed and insured professionals so they can be held liable for obvious omissions from their reports. But there are a lot of holes in the system, and there's no clear guide for inexperienced home buyers to vet inspectors.

The benefit of a good inspector is that they aren't the buyer and thus have no temptation to overlook things the buyer might miss. A good inspector is thorough and will take several hours to perform an inspection of even a small home.

If you can find a very reputable inspector, it's generally a good idea to use them both when selling or purchasing homes. Inspecting your home before sale can identify issues you can quickly address and it gives comfort to buyers to see an inspection report on the counter when they do a walk through.

I got burned with a home purchase early on in my life because I used my realtor's inspector who wasn't licensed in my state. When we later discovered a foundation issue we had no recourse because the inspection report had a disclosure on it.

A general problem in the US is that it's mostly ok to be misleading as long as you have a disclaimer, and that disclaimer doesn't necessarily have to be upfront or obvious. As a result of have a lot of "Administrations", "Bureaus", and "Authorities" that superficially appear to be governmental or reputable but turn out to be scams.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by awa on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:07PM (#27235873)
Home inspection was super useful for us when we bought our new built house, they found a major issue with the house which would have cost us thousands to fix later
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by jdeibele on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:52PM (#27237462)
I've had the pleasure of working with 3 excellent home inspectors over the past 20 years. They tested and checked things that I never would have thought of. One of them flagged the water heater in our current house for immediate replacement. Sure enough, it started leaking the day after we moved in.

We had asked for various fixes to be made but the seller only did a sewer repair and I think that is/was required for the house to be in sellable condition.

With everybody looking for houses now, a big thing is to put in a bid without requiring an inspection. I'm sure it works out almost all of the time but I'd hate to do it.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Frost1x on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:16PM (#27235995)
In the US, there is a huge market for those peddling certainty and reduced risk while also taking on very little liability of risks associated with the work.

People love security theater where some professional swoops in and assures them everything is fine. In some cases you have to rely on an expert but in many cases, I've found that for anything significant, I can't outsource risk assessment because it's not worth it most of the time. No one doing the assessments have enough liability or incentive to do a deep assessment, it often simply costs too much relative to what you're assessing.

Now if you're completely naive or ignorant about something or the total risk is known and is relatively low, then it doesn't hurt to pay a small fee for the quick risk assessment passover made by an expert who will be more likely to spot things than you. Also, if someone really has significant liability for their assessment, they tend to be very direct to the point of pointing out low risks they normally would brush over.

I recently purchased a home and it was hooked up to a private well. The seller said it was fine, the inspector said everything looked fine based on old test data, and a private well inspector said it looked fine. Not a single one of them thought it was worth testing the water quality beyond the bare minimum, only concerned about quantity. It turns out, I spent a part of 4-6 years developing water quality monitoring infrastructure and performing water quality analyses and had it not been for the knowledge I had and always skeptical attitude, I wouldn't have batted an eye. I told them to all stuff it and perform a water quality test or I was rejecting on other terms. Good thing I was difficult because there were all sorts of issues (bacteria, organic and inorganic issues) and I may have even gotten sick or a guest could have gotten sick.

Years ago I had a health scare and saw three independent doctors that thought it was nothing, even after describing my symptoms but there were too many red flags for me to ignore accept their opinions. I suggested a specific condition to each of them and they brushed it off like I was crazy. They didn't have the same level of risk or incentive for their time in their assessments to push forward and didn't want to acknowledge that even a low level of uncertainty could be true. Sure enough, I found a fourth doctor to check, they listened, and did appropriate diagnostics eventually confirming via lab and in person diagnostics I was correct. This isn't something that frequently occurs, not a hypochondriac.

Professional risk assessment can be useful but you should always be skeptical of it given the lack of liability and incentives many have. They want to get paid and move to their next transaction. Such is our highly transactional society where people really don't care about other people or can't afford to care about other people in the name of efficiency.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by reedjosh on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:11AM (#27235056)
> The UK system where each buyer comissions a survey is absurd.

In the US if a buyer does provide an inspection report to the seller and backs out, then the seller does at least have to disclose any issues found.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Firadeoclus on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:01AM (#27234910)
> The UK system where each buyer comissions a survey is absurd.

UK excluding Scotland.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by aaronax on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:34AM (#27233781)
The bank may be requiring the survey but you are paying for it. If not directly then at least in a very clear indirect way.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by gambiting on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:49AM (#27235595)
The last mortgage I took was with Bank of Ireland, they offered a full survey for £400 but I rang them and asked if they would do it for free if I took their mortgage on completion - they said yes, so I paid nothing for the survey. Other mortgages I had the survey was just included in the mortgage, no extra cost.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by borvo on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:18AM (#27234258)
I’m looking at 5 houses and want to pick the best one. Of course I need to see the surveys now. Tell me which bank is this that will pay for the 5 surveys?
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by cptskippy on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:07AM (#27235009)
What does a survey consist of and why are they so expensive?

In the US we have home inspectors, and we have surveyors. A home inspector is generally responsible for auditing the structure and mechanicals of the home for issues. A surveyor is only responsible for identifying property boundaries.

A home inspection is under $1000, usually $250-500. I don't know what a survey costs as I've never been involved in a property boundary dispute as US homes are generally on large enough plots that encroachment issues aren't that common.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by gambiting on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:53AM (#27235639)
>>What does a survey consist of and why are they so expensive?

They aren't, OP makes it sound like it costs an arm and a leg. The costs are around £300-400, about £500 if you want to pull out all the environmental reports as well, which while not insignificant in itself, is not really a big deal when buying a house for hundreds of thousands of pounds.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by gambiting on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:51AM (#27235621)
>> Of course I need to see the surveys now

Fair enough, I don't know anyone who bought a house this way though. For me personally it was always 1) find a house 2) ask the bank to do the survey 3) based on the survey either carry on with the mortgage or retract my offer. Yes I probably couldn't do 5 houses at once, but I have done 3 houses consecutively this way before, no issues whatsoever with the banks.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by evgen on Saturday May 22, 2021 @01:50PM (#27248760)
You make the offer contingent upon the inspection and have the inspection performed prior to signing. The purpose of inspection is not the find 'the best one' but to determine if there are any major problems that should shift the sale price for the house you have already selected.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by xyzelement on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:45AM (#27233926)
> A competitive market would enable me to sort by salary and benefits and apply for the best job.

I am always surprised to see comments that make it sound like jobs (or, employees) are fungible commodities that can be bought and sold purely on price.

One simple example - two jobs may have the same title (Senior Developer, or whatever) but have totally different expectations of communication skills, leadership skills, ability to handle pressure, etc and would pay very differently. So you (and everyone else) would be tempted to apply for the top-paying job but potentially not be qualified.

Or the situation where a company is very flexible on who they hire and thus would pay a lot more or a lot less depending on what the individual brings to the table.

In a way, I think there's a bit of "you don't know what you don't know" principle at play here. If someone has limited perspective on how career development, seniority, and hiring work, they may really believe that the big problem is "I can't sort my opportunities by salary." Someone with more experience and understanding may recognize how non-fungible people and roles can be in a way that a simple "sort by price" cannot capture.

To use your real-estate analogy, would you ever buy a house that came up first in a price-sort? No, you'd both want to really understand the nuances of the house (location, condition, etc.) and how it compares to your needs and your ability to pay. IE, you'd often take "not the best price" because either there's something wrong with the property or it's just not suitable to your needs." Hiring is much the same.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by piaste on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:10AM (#27234153)
> I am always surprised to see comments that make it sound like jobs (or, employees) are fungible commodities that can be bought and sold purely on price.

I highly doubt that the parent comment meant that he would literally apply to the job with the biggest number with no other consideration.

I read it as the far more modest claim that, if even _seeing_ the number requires a significant investment of time and effort on your side, the efficiency of the market is highly restricted. Especially since, once you do see the number, you usually need to take it or leave it within a short time frame; you can't "open up" a lot of job offers and then pick the best.

To use the real-estate analogy again, how would the housing market be affected if buyers had to put down a deposit to even _see_ the listed price? And if the sellers had the ability to get a complete profile of the buyer before revealing their price? It seems pretty clear to me that the average house price would significantly increase, despite the supply and demand both staying the same.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by analog31 on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:17AM (#27234225)
Interestingly, I use price-sort extensively when doing online shopping. I don't often buy the thing that comes up first, but I certainly use it to help figure out the tradeoff between price and quality, and to filter out items that I have no reason to consider. Also, price-sort eliminates one of the psychological burdens of shopping, which is the manipulative presentation of products by the vendor.

Price-sort is a very crude version of an even more powerful tool, which is: "Show me everything about every product, without trying to manipulate me, and let me organize the data by criteria that I choose, not that you choose." This is why Excel pivot tables are so popular in business.

Anything that makes the job search function less psychological has to be beneficial. Nothing prevents me from taking a pay cut for a particular job that I absolutely love, in a favored location, etc.

Oddly enough, product marketing and hiring share a common feature, which is that both fields have endless amounts of verbiage about how psychological manipulation is actually beneficial to the person being manipulated. If so, it should be an opt-in feature, perhaps even one that people are willing to pay for.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by sidlls on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:09AM (#27234149)
It's a bit presumptuous to suggest the OP "has limited perspective on how career development, seniority, and hiring work".

Also, I most certainly do sort by price when I'm looking for real estate: I have a budget, after all. Same thing with employment: most people have needs that salary requirements can meet, and it's pointless to look for jobs outside the range one can accept. Therefore it's almost certainly the best and most useful first thing to sort by.

Others have more freedom. For example, thanks to a recent IPO I can literally work for no salary and be fine. I have far more freedom to consider other details about a job than 99% of the population.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by xyzelement on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:54PM (#27236586)
> It's a bit presumptuous to suggest the OP "has limited perspective ...

This is going to be very meta and not about salary so feel free to skip :)

When I disagree with someone, I try to find where we are disconnected. It's usually one of two things: we reach divergent conclusions either because we are aware of different facts, or because we're interpreting those facts through different values lens.

A good quick heuristic of a fact missing if when someone talks about either one side of the equation or even worse, makes both sides line up to their conclusion.

For example: "we should use Python - it's the best dev experience, we are only using C++ cuz our lead engineer is stupid" versus "We use C++ because of performance attributes, but I argue we can be fast-enough in Python and get better dev-experience"

The 2nd statement shows awareness of both sides of the argument and then proposes a solution that accounts for them. The 1st side is missing the context for why someone would do something other than what they want to do - suggesting they don't have perspective on that and making it likely that their solution doesn't account for it (or if it does, only by accident.)

In the discussion at hand, the original poster clearly prefers salary ranges and his model for why companies don't publish them is that they are evil. To me that suggests that they are lacking perspectives on the cases where salary ranges are either impossible to share or end up working in the employee's favor. Having had this conversation many times before, I attribute this lack of perspective on not having the senior hiring experience either from candidate or company side where one would have picked up the perspective.

To sum it all up, yet there's a bit of presumption in my suggestion but at the same time - you have to be able to assert things or else you'd never be able to make any points.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by sangnoir on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:07AM (#27234999)
> Or the situation where a company is very flexible on who they hire and thus would pay a lot more or a lot less depending on what the individual brings to the table.

You're making it sound like the companies are being forced to pay the same salary for the same role - they are not, and this is a straw man argument. The companies should publish the salary range - they are free to adjust the offers within the range depending on skills & experience of the successful candidate. If the range is $20k - $180k to cater for the "rockstar" who brings a lot - then they ought to publish that range and be prepared to explain to a candidate why the company thinks a candidate deserves $20k/yr and see how that goes.

An equivalent scenario to what's happening on the job market outside Colorado would be houses being sold without displaying the asking prices - all potential buyers would be expected to jump through all the hoops and be asked to "make an offer" without being able to make comparisons on how much other similar houses on the market are going for. Instead, they'd be asked "How much did you pay for the last house you bought?" or "How much are you currently paying in rent?"

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by vineyardmike on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:37PM (#27237208)
My friend interviewed for an SDE 1 position but after interview, was then offered a role of SDE 2 on the team, since the team was hiring for both, and he was more qualified as a 2.

I think this is an example of flexibility that people bring up. Not that they shouldn't publish the range, but my friend had no idea the other range was open to him.

TO be clear, i agree that they should have to explain "why" if they chose the part of the range, like you say, but i think it misses some edge cases that are not uncommon.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by sangnoir on Friday May 21, 2021 @03:15PM (#27238632)
> [...]but my friend had no idea the other range was open to him.

This asymmetric information is the intention of the employer, but sadly, in most cases it goes the other way: person gets hired as an SDE 2, but earns less than some/all SDE 1's because they are terrible at negotiating, or their salary history was always below market rate and they do not know it. I'm all for companies paying commensurate salaries and having the flexibility to do so - publishing salaries ranges when posting jobs is orthogonal to that.

> i think it misses some edge cases that are not uncommon.

In your friends case, I hope/wish the law covers that scenario whereby the employer is forced to disclose the range for the upgraded when asked - so that all your friend needed to do was ask.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ClumsyPilot on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:09AM (#27234144)
We do recognise that, and that's why you publish a salary range. If your salary range for a dev is 50k - 90k, then publish that. The point, a candidate who know they are a good developer can know what to expect.

If someone shows up for interview with leadrship skills so amazing they can run the whole company and you want to pay them 4x, then it's probably a different job, maybe a TeamLead.

Publish several jobs and just fill one of them, cancell others.

But the argument is bordering on "we are so flexible we have no structure at all and we have no clue what we are doing" and is difficult to taje seriously.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by egman_ekki on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:58AM (#27234863)
> two jobs may have the same title (Senior Developer, or whatever) but have totally different expectations of communication skills, leadership skills, ability to handle pressure, etc and would pay very differently. So you (and everyone else) would be tempted to apply for the top-paying job but potentially not be qualified.

What do you think makes this a problem here? You apply, you interview, the company either gives you the position or not. I don't think anyone would use the salary range as the one and only factor to decide where to apply. It can help to decide where to make more effort or what the comp potential is if I improve my skills.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by bawolff on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:47AM (#27235561)
> To use your real-estate analogy, would you ever buy a house that came up first in a price-sort?

No, but if they also weren't giving me an asking price, that's a huge red flag.

You're right that price is but one attribute of a job, but it is an important attribute. Its not the only thing i am evaluating, but it is one of the things, even one of the more important things.

So yes, i would like to know what the salary range is at the get-go.

Also this is true for pretty much everything - when buying a car, you dont generally go with the cheapest option, there's lots of attributes to evaluate, but if someone refused to tell you the price you wouldn't go with them either.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by matwood on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:30PM (#27236214)
Exactly. And to emphasize your point, a company (or car sale) who is being coy with the price/salary is a huge red flag. They know it's not good and are trying to lure you far enough down the path that you won't turn around.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by vbtemp on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:01PM (#27235781)
> I am always surprised to see comments that make it sound like jobs (or, employees) are fungible commodities that can be bought and sold purely on price.

This!!

- At every company and institution I've worked for, I've never really been in a situation where two people, even if they have the same job title, are line-replacable for one another (unless they are very junior). Everyone has extremely distinct skills, experiences, capabilities whose value is extremely contingent on the needs of the moment.

- Making rules to make things for fair or transparent has the opposite effect. A major institution I worked for came up with an impossible-to-game, no-human-in-the-loop formula for bias-free and discrimination-free compensation. The result? People with equal responsibilities ended up getting paid _vastly_ different amounts. Similarly, people with equal salaries had vastly different levels of responsibility. I don't think a uniform compensation scheme simply works, other than just negotiating 1-on-1 with staff until agreements are reached, and when it no longer works out they ask Mr. Market.

- A company not disclosing salary already gives you enough information. Unless they are a flagship megacorp with well known salary bands and staff levels, and they are not disclosing the salary, then you know it's not competitive salary.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by xyzelement on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:16PM (#27235991)
Agree with your first point.

> Unless they are a flagship megacorp with well known salary bands and staff levels, and they are not disclosing the salary, then you know it's not competitive salary.

Frankly that's not been my experience. I find that especially on the senior level, the variance is so high for what a person could make in a role that publishing the range would just be meaningless. Thus, I take the "lack of range" as a non-signal.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by vbtemp on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:27PM (#27236159)
I see what you mean. If I could refine what I said, I'd put it that for those flagship mega corps, you generally know that it will _at least_ be competitive, and it's just a matter of how far beyond it.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by 908B64B197 on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:10AM (#27235048)
> One simple example - two jobs may have the same title (Senior Developer, or whatever) but have totally different expectations of communication skills, leadership skills, ability to handle pressure, etc and would pay very differently. So you (and everyone else) would be tempted to apply for the top-paying job but potentially not be qualified.

That's because software engineering suffers from tittle inflation (same way grade inflation works really).

Internally there are several "levels" of Senior Engineers at most companies. But what the levels map to is completely arbitrary. I've seen places where senior really means 20 years of industry experience and others where it's more like 5.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ska on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:03PM (#27235817)
You sort of point this out, but title inflation in itself isn't a problem. If everyone could agree that "senior staff developer" in 2021 is what everyone meant by "senior developer" in 2005, we'd be fine.

The real problem, as you point out, is there is no consistency. In reviewing resumes basically ignore titles from any company I'm not very familiar with, and rely on their description of what they have done.

As an aside, many engineers, especially less experienced ones, are terrible at this. As a piece of advice, think about what your resume says about your work if the titles are blacked out.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by 908B64B197 on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:34PM (#27236269)
> In reviewing resumes basically ignore titles from any company I'm not very familiar with, and rely on their description of what they have done.

That's the correct approach. Same holds for job descriptions: what have others at this level band shipped and what were their contributions.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by mywittyname on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:44AM (#27235503)
> So you (and everyone else) would be tempted to apply for the top-paying job but potentially not be qualified.

I don't do this, and I feel like most reasonable people wouldn't do this either.

Let's say you manage to actually get a job that you're not qualified for. There's a strong possibility that you'll be fired, maybe within the 90 day probationary period. At a some large companies, you might get some cover and get passed around from department to department for years. But I've definitely seen a fair number of people fired for non-performance in my career; it's not exactly rare.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Taylor_OD on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:15AM (#27234204)
Eh. I wouldnt buy a house that came up first based on price sort but I would rule out most/all houses that cost less than X. Salaries are the same thing. I'm not going to consider a job that is X amount do if the top range is below that I'll skip it. It's a time saving tool.

Sure there are about a billion other factors to look at but if the salary is a non starter then why waste the time to interview even if everything else was perfect?

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by tshaddox on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:01AM (#27234909)
If I’m looking for a job, it’s already on me to try to limit my search to positions I’m qualified for. Providing me with the salary information for each job doesn’t make that task any more difficult.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by insert_coin on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:07AM (#27234997)
But they don't and yet you still have a job (I hope).

And the reason is because when you are looking for a job other things are more important than knowing the salary even before you apply or they seriously consider you.

Everyone does whatever they can get away with, and the moment we accept that everything becomes clear. They are all trying to benefit themselves, just as you are by trying to learn some information before the other party feel the need to share it with you.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by PowerBar on Saturday May 22, 2021 @02:28AM (#27244063)
Salary is the single most important thing to know about a position. If a job doesn't pay enough to cover my mortgage, I couldn't care less about the commute, the inclusive culture or how great their lunchroom is or even whether I'm qualified. It's a non-starter before I even read the description.

Having to write a cover letter, customize a resume and sit through multiple interviews just to find out if I can literally afford to work for you is not acceptable and the only reason companies get away with it is because all the other companies do it. This trend needs to die and it needs to die a decade ago.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by insert_coin on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:48AM (#27273167)
> Salary is the single most important thing to know about a position.

That's like, your opinion. Millions of people go on job interviews everyday without first knowing the salary offered and in fact in most meetings the salary is the last thing discussed.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by PowerBar on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:20AM (#27273394)
Of course the final salary is the last thing negotiated, I don't think anyone is going to argue against that point.

What job seekers are begging for is a salary range being included with the job posting. Not doing so just wastes everyone's time when the company low-balls after the 3rd interview and the interviewee walks out the door.

If you want a junior worker for a junior's salary, that's fine, there are plenty of juniors looking to get their foot in the door, but include a junior's salary range so you don't waste everyone's time interviewing someone who's never going to accept your junior offer.

If you want a senior for a junior's salary and think you'll get one by leaving the salary range blank, go pound sand.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by insert_coin on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:28AM (#27273477)
> If you want a senior for a junior's salary and think you'll get one by leaving the salary range blank, go pound sand.

No one thinks they are getting away with anything but you. I don't get why you are so mad most people don't consider not knowing the salary beforehand a reason not to go on an interview. Not posting the salary on the job ad has never been the reason a position has been left unfilled.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by PowerBar on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:45AM (#27274465)
People don't consider it a reason not to go on an interview because 95-99% of job postings don't include it because they know nobody else does and they can get away with it and applicants don't have a choice. If a reasonable number of postings included a salary range, omitting one would tank an ad's response rates and you'd see the trend change very quickly.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by insert_coin on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:26AM (#27275119)
If things were different, yes, things would be different.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by bb123 on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:26AM (#27233694)
Thats just nonsense. There absolutely is a requirement to disclose known faults with the property, and if a survey (which every buyer does) shows up something serious, there is a legal requirement to disclose it to all parties. Also most banks will cover the cost of a survey.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by sokoloff on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:50AM (#27233972)
The buyer is the only one bringing money into the transaction. Regardless of who signs the check, the buyer is paying for all of the things.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by bb123 on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:39AM (#27234550)
Thats true, but you really can't have it both ways. You either want a professional opinion on the quality of the house or you're willing to run the risk. Anyway, the banks aren't doing inspections for the benefit of the buyer. They want to know that should the house be repossessed they are likely to recoup their investment. The fact the buyer might find something out about the house is a happy side effect.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by mountainb on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:30AM (#27234433)
Inspections are pretty cheap at least in the US. Inconsequential compared to the price of the house or any other expense related to buying, really.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by bb123 on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:39AM (#27234555)
Correct - the homebuyers report on my house cost £300.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by sandworm101 on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:41AM (#27233877)
>> The market is not really free - its being manipulated by one side.

The market is free, it just isn't a healthy market. Those are different concepts. Participants in a totally free market are free to use their size/power/leverage as they wish. A free market is one where the little guy, the job applicant, will be hammered by the big guy. A 'healthy' market is one that is regulated in such a way that the little guy has at least a hope in the negotiation process. This then fosters competition, innovation, yielding a free-but-healthy market. Regulation needed to do those things that the "free" market cannot.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ClumsyPilot on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:59AM (#27234052)
Exactly - if you are free to manipulate the market, then it decends into Mafia game.

If you call that 'free market', then its like communism - a concept that never works in the real world

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ck425 on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:34AM (#27233775)
> With housing (in UK) there is no competition on quality because the seller doesn't have to disclose any problems with the house.

Note that that's an issue on England (and presumably Wales too?). It's not the case in Scotland. Not sure about NI.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Finnucane on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:19AM (#27233622)
In the US, real estate sellers have to disclose known problems, but they can claim they didn't know, and then you might have to fight it out in court. It's still in your interest to get an inspection before closing.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by sidlls on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:12AM (#27234174)
That's why people include inspection clauses in their offer contracts. If the inspection reveals an issue it must then be disclosed by the seller going forward, if the buyer can back out due to the clause.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ensignavenger on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:07AM (#27234131)
This varies somewhat by state, as I understand. Some states only require disclosure for specific classes of problems.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by dghf on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:37AM (#27233814)
> You have to pay for the surveyor to find out any issues the house might have, and that means you can only view a few houses before you've paid the house price in survey fees.

How much are you paying for surveys? Even a full structural survey -- which would be considered over the top for most purchases -- should only cost £1,500 or so.

And you're not going to get any sort of survey for most of the houses you view. You only usually bother with one once you've made an offer and the vendor's accepted it: if the survey reveals anything significant, you either pull out or try to renegotiate the price.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by cecilpl2 on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:03AM (#27234935)
> You only usually bother with one once you've made an offer and the vendor's accepted it.

This is no longer the case in most of North America, where your offer only has a chance of being accepted if it's unconditional.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by true_religion on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:37AM (#27235425)
You know it'd break the cartel-like control companies have over employees if a law were made that all jobs must payout within the salary range posted for the job.

That prevents people from negotiating higher pay than is advertised publicly, so employers would have to tell everyone what their maximum salary could be. Employers would have an incentive to post high maximums rather than miss out on quality candidates.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by noduerme on Saturday May 22, 2021 @03:52AM (#27244484)
The bedrock truth behind this is that companies, even 20 years ago, were far more concerned about both retaining dedicated employees and maintaining customer satisfaction. Has anyone had to try to contact Paypal about a pending payment in the past few years? What about getting a human with authority over minimum wage on the phone at an insurance company?

What has taken place is that the mass of people who were "consumers" have become "users", and are replaceable and disposable; while the employees have been downgraded to associates.

It's not just the feeling of outrage you get when you're trying to establish, with a person, where $1000 someone sent you disappeared to for a month. It's the anti-human system underpinning the idea that we should build an algorithm to keep people on hold longer, the more pissed off they sound about an unwarranted charge.

There are a lot of points at which business logic taken to its fullest fruition turns out not to be good business. We tend to hope the market will rebel against the excesses of companies that treat users as interchangeable parts. But the reality is we (coders) are contributing to the de-humanization of the majority of humanity, in many of these small interactions and small-change money collecting circumstances. That's our job. But at some point we should be able to see the circle closing around us; we're exempt because we can hack our way through the thicket of junk it takes to get our identity back if it's stolen, a new job if our startup shuts down; we are constantly re-inventing ourselves and innovating.

But we are not our users. We wouldn't even want our users to be us.

The point as I take it, of this, is that screwing your employees is treating them as users; and treating users the way we have, for a long time, is also self-defeating and bad for society.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by brundolf on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:08PM (#27236802)
Weekly reminder that sometimes a functioning market can only be maintained via regulation.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by dboreham on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:41AM (#27233870)
Hmm. I lived in the UK (both England and Scotland, which are slightly different) for 1st 1/2 of my life then moved to USA. In my experience the housing market is one of the few things that is handled pretty much the same.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by neves on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:27PM (#27236172)
This is a strong signal that this law must be expanded to the other states.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by calvinmorrison on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:21AM (#27233643)
Sort of, except recruiters definitely know salary ranges. I don't always use recruiters but I did previously and was placed well every time. They're a annoying middleman that can really help.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by nairboon on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:15AM (#27233585)
There should be a job board exactly like that, with base salary x + y% per year specific experience for 1-10y, z% 11-20y etc. and u% per year for general industry experience.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by quotemstr on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:40PM (#27237261)
> A competitive market would enable me to sort by salary and benefits and apply for the best job.

There is no fixed salary for a job. That's the whole point. It's a negotiation, where candidates with unique skills can negotiate higher compensation that reflects their unique skill-sets and contributions. What you want is to impose a one-size-fits-all rule on the market. That's going to produce misallocation and inefficiency.

> view a few houses before you've paid the house price in survey fees

Surveys and inspections cost a few hundred dollars. Houses cost several hundred thousand dollars at least.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ClumsyPilot on Friday May 21, 2021 @06:41PM (#27240863)
"It's a negotiation, where candidates with unique skills can negotiate"

Every snowflake is special and unique too, but nobody cares when they are shovelling their driveways. Stop spreading incredulous fantasies, companies that hire 3000 JS-React mashing "agile' dev have salary ranges, HR has them, and you can find out about them once you are hired. They just don't want to publish them upfront.

Maybe if we are talking top leadership positions this argument has credence, but for most of us they aren't bending over backwards and putting together unique compensation packages.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by ramblerman on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:14AM (#27234190)
> A competitive market would enable me to sort by salary and benefits and apply for the best job.

The idea that there would be a bunch of generic job listings with fixed salaries makes you essentially a replacable drone with no unique value, and sounds horrible to me.

Also a free market doesn't need to be absolutely transparent. That's just something you would want because it sounds like it would be easier, but uncertainties about the future, unknowns, and consumer wants is what drives the whole pricing game to begin with.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by cblconfederate on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:41AM (#27233882)
Profit most often rests on the asymmetry of information, thats why monopolies are so profitable
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by compiler-guy on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:41AM (#27234586)
Monopoly profits are based on dominant market power, not asymmetry of information.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by insert_coin on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:15AM (#27235102)
Where is the "dominant market power" coming from?

Asymmetry of information is what got you to the top. You know more than your competition, more on a productive process, on consumer behavior, on business partners, on leveraging financial avenues, on political "contributions", on questionable use of insider information, etc.

And Information is what keeps you at the top: knowing who to "lobby" to create convenient regulation that hurts your competition the most, is the most effective way monopolies use to stay that way.

Monopolies are not monopolies in the abstract, they have to fight everyday to keep being a monopoly and they do that by leveraging information asymmetry.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by dcow on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:28AM (#27235301)
It’s not simply asymmetry of information though. Monopolies often have an incredible amount of financial power that they deploy against people trying to enter their market. Or maybe a company is on top because of their execution. I really don’t think the entire phenomenon can be explained by information asymmetry.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by insert_coin on Friday May 21, 2021 @06:17PM (#27240662)
The financial power comes from somewhere.

> Or maybe a company is on top because of their execution.

I already explained that part.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by compiler-guy on Friday May 21, 2021 @06:23PM (#27240722)
The at&t monopoly came about via government power, and the only fighting it did was to keep the government enforcing and maintaining the monopoly.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by insert_coin on Friday May 21, 2021 @06:33PM (#27240807)
> The at&t monopoly came about via government power,...

That is what I wrote, yes. AT&T knew who to "lobby". That is information asymmetry.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by compiler-guy on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:02PM (#27241027)
You would have to establish that no one else knew who to lobby, which is far from clear. Also I know exactly who to lobby for certain things I need from the city, but that clearly isn’t enough, because my lobbying efforts have failed miserably.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by insert_coin on Saturday May 22, 2021 @02:09AM (#27243980)
The asymmetry is in more than one area, those where only examples, and they probably have an asymmetric advantage over you in all areas.

That is why, even if you know who to lobby you can't get a meeting, but they meet everyday. You don't know who to bribe to get a meeting. And on and on.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by cblconfederate on Friday May 21, 2021 @02:10PM (#27237703)
Dominant market power is maintained by having control of information in a market. Google has control on the information about advertising and user searches that competitors don't. Amazon uses comprehensive sales data that others don't. Apple uses its power to enforce ignorance of competition to its customers.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Der_Einzige on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:06PM (#27235848)
You can only get dominant market power with an asymmetry of information (about how to produce whatever thing it is that gets you dominant market power). This is why we have IP laws...
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by compiler-guy on Friday May 21, 2021 @06:22PM (#27240711)
The at&t monopoly obtained power via government grant. There are many others. We have IP laws to avoid monopolies among other reasons, but they aren’t the only way to get monopoly power.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by an_opabinia on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:28AM (#27235297)
If people want to better negotiate their salaries, they have to unionize. Everything else is just unproven, speculative, untested pitter patter.
Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by gryn on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:54AM (#27235664)
why do you think a union would help in this ?

I live in france and all big enough companies are mandated to have union, doesn't mean that they help with salaries.

Re:Companies excluding Coloradans from remote jobs to avoid ... by Mauricebranagh on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:31PM (#27236233)
Is this a managerial / professional union?

Those normally negotiate the banding and the COL increases and also know what the rates are.

Unions in the entertainment industries do :-) underpay or stiff workers and you get put on the "call first list" this is the PC name for another type of list.