News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by supernova87a on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:48PM (#27211963)
I don't mean to distract from the main conversation, but I want to talk about how insidiously evil it is that NFTs can be coded to send the original creator a percentage $ cut off of every subsequent transaction for all time.

If that's not hard coding wealth inequality and a new class of asset owners, I don't know what is. This is disturbing, along with the whole thing itself anyway.

Imagine if cryptocurrency started doing that?

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by dschnurr on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:01PM (#27212148)
The people receiving royalties are the artists in these cases – instead of the record companies, instagrams, and etsys of the world. I fail to see how this won't be a net positive for wealth equality when we're shifting the advantage to those who have historically been taken advantage of.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by klodolph on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:16PM (#27212346)
> The people receiving royalties are the artists in these cases...

This is just factually incorrect. I don't know why there's so much confusion here... it's the creator of the NFT that controls where the money goes, not the creator of the artwork. I don't know why people think that it's the artist that gets the money--that doesn't make any logical sense--how would a system like that even work?

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by dschnurr on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:18PM (#27212371)
The creator is almost always the artist. Provenance is what gives NFTs their value. The value of a Beeple NFT minted by a random user is $0.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by geofft on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:21PM (#27212399)
The value of a Beeple NFT minted by a random user is exactly what the market chooses to value it as.

If it's minted by an agency that helps creators do marketing, and the agency gets the creator to say "Yes, this is a legitimate NFT created on my behalf by this agency, which has been very helpful to me in understanding NFTs, I don't understand these fancy computer things," why would the value be zero?

(This exact scenario plays out all the time in the real world. People bought "Taylor Swift's" album Fearless, which was authorized by her and contained her actual voice and songwriting and paid profits to her and was in all senses legitimate, and paid well over zero dollars for it. And then over a decade later she tells her fans that she doesn't control it and she's recording her own version of the album actually owned by her.)

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by AlexandrB on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:24PM (#27212437)
What stops a record company from including a clause assigning any NFTs (and/or the revenue therefrom) created by the artist during the contract term to them?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by pmulard on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:42PM (#27212671)
Nothing. Just like nothing stopped Taylor Swift from rerecording her entire library to license her music herself. If artists sign their NFT rights away, that's on them.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by btilly on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:39PM (#27213418)
What Taylor Swift did is an imitation of what Prince did long before her.

See https://www.billboard.com/articles/news/cover-story/7348551/... for more.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by packetlost on Thursday May 20, 2021 @10:46AM (#27221785)
That's not really relevant to this discussion though
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by NicoJuicy on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:49PM (#27214288)
What stops someone from creating a nft with the same metadata?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by jjulius on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:43PM (#27212683)
Absolutely nothing.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by btilly on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:05PM (#27212958)
Provenance is what gives NFTs their value.

The question is how you prove that provenance if a niche artist has created an NFT on a niche piece of art. (And, honestly, most of the people who would want to create NFTs are going to be in this category.)

Now imagine an agency whose job was simply to create a digital signature on a work that indicated what they had done to prove a particular piece of art really was produced by the artist who then goes on to sign the NFT. If the agency has an established reputation, then that signed NFT has much more solidly established provenance than an unsigned NFT. Of course that agency has non-zero costs to establish provenance. And adds a non-zero amount to the value of the NFT.

What then, can said agency reasonably charge the artist for this service?

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by echelon on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:27PM (#27212475)
The value of a Beeple NFT minted by Beeple is $0. The market just hasn't discovered that yet.

An NFT has no more value than a JPG.

I'll longbets anyone that says otherwise.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by arcsincosin on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:43PM (#27212684)
I agree but it's worth noting that Beeple was selling JPGs for $5000+ in the mid 2010s as a commissioned artist in the music industry. So the NFTs have also brought some transparency to a successful digital artist along with the crazy valuations.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by sashimi-houdini on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:34PM (#27214131)
This seems like a dangerous bet to make... my take on the NFT "market" is that it's money laundering, wash trading (inflating prices to attract suckers to the market) and perhaps in a small part conspicuous consumption. Mostly fraudulent... but would you bet against a fraud?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by berberous on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:31PM (#27212544)
I would take a broader bet that is not tied to Beeple (i.e. that NFTs of significant artists will have long-term value in a similar manner as a painting).
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by echelon on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:38PM (#27212633)
I would take that broader bet that NFTs will have zero long-term value.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by usehackernews on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:51PM (#27213608)
Explain why -

Is this because you don't have interest in it, or do you have a true justification of this?

I'm willing to take this bet. Just like art, 99% can be bought for $1 at a garage sale, but there will be the 1% that has value to someone.

You are betting against the generation who spends massive amounts on video games costumes, and puts more value into their online image (instagram) than real life image, not finding value in a form of digital scarcity & status. I find that hard to believe.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by intotheabyss on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:14PM (#27213071)
So the condition of your bet would be that all NFTs everywhere have zero long term value? So something like, by 2030, no non-fungible token will have a monetary value?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by saalweachter on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:39PM (#27213430)
I'm not interested in taking the counter party in this bet, but if you were to take a bet in the form "The highest sale price of a NFT in calendar year 20X0 will be no more Y0% of the highest sale price of a postage stamp in that same year.", what would you fill in for X & Y?
[dead]
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by hluska on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:01PM (#27213741)
I’m over forty and quite frankly, I’m tired of this ageist crap. This entire premise is complete fucking bullshit. Do yourself and everyone over 40 you come into contact with a favour and pretend you never believed anything so toxic.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by TigeriusKirk on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:13PM (#27213871)
>This entire premise is complete fucking bullshit

I'm over 50 and this does not match with my observations of the world. Older people, as a general trend, do in fact seem to be resistant to new ideas. There are exceptions, of course. The trend still stands in my experience.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by hluska on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:43PM (#27214224)
Then I’m sorry to say it pal, but you’ve got to get out more. Some of the most rebellious open minded people I know are in their seventies. Age is just about completely meaningless and ageism has no place in intellectual communities.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by btilly on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:23PM (#27214644)
And I'm over 50. My point remains.

Very often things invented when we are older seem to be utterly pointless to us. We literally can't get why people are excited about them. And I see this tendency in people in my age range more than in my teenagers. I personally have to back up and go from first principles to avoid it.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by hluska on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @08:07PM (#27215943)
Everything is exciting - innovation is exciting and new inventions are exciting. If you can't feel it, that's sad and I hope you can get it back but please don't impose your own issue upon an entire age group.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by ASalazarMX on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:11PM (#27213852)
Douglas Adams was a humorist first and philosopher second, quoting him literally is borderline naive.

For starters, not everything invented when you are 15-35 is good. Take reality shows: they were indeed new and revolutionary (exciting idk), but they didn't pass the test of time. Stupid stuff is invented all the time, regardless of people's ages.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by lottin on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:05PM (#27212959)
You're god-damn right.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by rcxdude on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:18PM (#27212363)
In most legitimate uses of NFTs the creator is the artist.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by klodolph on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:57PM (#27212846)
How would you know if an NFT is legitimate? There's no "legitimate" bit on the NFT that distinguishes it.

If you wanted to support the artist, wouldn't it be faster, easier, cheaper, and more reliable to support them directly, through Patreon or something similar?

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by crazygringo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:38PM (#27214824)
But the NFT is supporting them directly, if they minted it.

I personally think NFT's are silly, but there's zero argument to be made that they aren't supporting the artist. The artist minted them in the first place.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by klodolph on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:18PM (#27215257)
> The artist minted them in the first place.

That's completely false. Anyone can mint an NFT. Artists have minted some of them, and other NFTs are created without the artists' permission.

I don't get why people are saying this when it's so obviously false, like, it does not pass the smell test for basic credibility.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by rcxdude on Thursday May 20, 2021 @04:41AM (#27218846)
Are pirate NFTs selling for a significant price? Clearly people are making them without permission, but are people buying them? The high-profile mega-money examples for sure are being minted by the artists.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by crazygringo on Thursday May 20, 2021 @10:43AM (#27221750)
Obviously the discussion is about NFT's the artists minted themselves.

Counterfeits isn't relevant to the discussion here. It's like complaining that tipping a server doesn't work because the cash might be counterfeit. It has nothing to do with the main point.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by pshc on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:52PM (#27213616)
I guess the buck stops at Blue Checkmark providers really.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by rcxdude on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:06PM (#27212971)
Generally when the artist endorses it. NFTs give you a token that represents a piece of art they made which you can move and resell independently, even if the artist is no longer around. I personally am not very likely to buy any, but I can see the appeal (it's much the same as owning the originals of any other bit of art as opposed to a copy). The current cost of creating and moving them around is unfortunate, however (and reflects the immaturity of crypto as a whole. I believe ethereum is working hard to improve their scaling with a plausible plan, so this should improve, but it is a definite problem at the moment)
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by AlexandrB on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:18PM (#27212374)
This is not a property of NFTs, but rather of new, unproven technologies. If NFTs "make it big", there will be plenty of middlemen that spring up to "help" artists sell NFTs while owning the IP rights and collecting royalties.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by dschnurr on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:32PM (#27212547)
Sure there will be middlemen trying to profit due to asymmetry of information / technical knowledge. But as technology marches along the barriers to entry of launching new things trends to zero. Smart creators are increasingly harnessing new technologies to cut out existing middlemen. Podcasts are a great example of this, anyone with a microphone can start an entertainment business now and collect money from direct relationships with advertisers.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by AlexandrB on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:43PM (#27212682)
I think the big news in Podcasts is centralization. Many new podcasts get their money either from "networks" or by being part of one of the podcast walled gardens (e.g. Spotify). I suspect traditional podcasts will go the way of blogs soon and be largely superseded by several competing commercial platforms (think Medium). See, for example, the moves by Apple to turn their Podcasts app into a subscription platform: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/04/apple-leads-the-next-...
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by jjulius on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:41PM (#27212667)
>Podcasts are a great example of this...

And yet plenty of middlemen exist for podcasts, too - Earwolf, Stitcher, yadda yadda. Sure, barriers to entry trend toward zero, but that doesn't mean everyone's going to see what you're selling. Many people will need to partner with someone who can help get their shit in front of people who want it, and those partners are going to want a cut.

Record labels, Instagrams and Etsys will show up to the NFT party in spades.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by billytetrud on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:11PM (#27212285)
There's a difference between making royalties for distribution of copies of an item and making royalties for transferring a single item from one person to another. One makes sense, the other is a weird misleading way to rent to people.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by mattdesl on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:41PM (#27212663)
Royalties apply on re-sale, not every transfer. Royalties on sales going back to the original creator is pretty normal practice in the arts and creative industries (music, writing, art, photography).

The good thing, compared to traditional markets, is that this is something that can be (loosely) enforced with smart contracts, the % rate is flexible, and the current NFT royalties are typically far better for the artists (eg: 10% NFT platform fee instead of 50% gallery fee).

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by lottin on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:11PM (#27213048)
What on earth are you talking about? If I buy a copyrighted work in the second-hand market I don't have to pay any royalties to the original creator. That would be extortion.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by mattdesl on Saturday May 22, 2021 @06:12PM (#27250726)
You are free to do the same (trade w/o fees) with crypto currencies, nothing stops you from sending the tokens directly from one wallet to another or doing a private sale.

But with galleries in the real world (where artists are “represented” - and the model that NFT marketplaces are emulating), the artist will receive royalties on sales.[1]

[1] - https://www.dacs.org.uk/for-artists/artists-resale-right/in-...

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by crazygringo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:41PM (#27214855)
> the other is a weird misleading way to rent to people.

There's nothing weird or misleading about it, and it's got zero to do with renting.

It's simply like a real estate broker commission, gallery commission, or whatever.

The concept of a commission has existed for a long, long, long time.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by billytetrud on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @09:12PM (#27216300)
> It's simply like a real estate broker commission, gallery commission, or whatever.

Except that its not at all like that. You pay a commission to someone who helped you sell something - they did work to help you sell it and you compensate them. Paying an automatic comission fee to the artist upon sale makes no sense. What are they doing to earn that commission? You already paid for their art. It makes no sense to pay again. What this is cannot be called a "comission".

I can see a situation where the artist is paid in total a very small fraction of the total price the art was sold for. Eg in the situation someone brought up where an artist sells a painting for $10,000 and then a few years later its sold for $1 million, I can see the artist maybe getting 10% of the margin between those sales (eg 0.1*(1 million - 10,000)). But even that is dubious to me, since a sale already took place. It just seems really weird to me and I think it has to be justified further than just "this is good for artists" or "artists need more money". Certainly calling it a commission is not at all accurate.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by crazygringo on Thursday May 20, 2021 @10:48AM (#27221825)
I get that you don't like it.

That still doesn't make it weird or misleading or "renting". It's straightforward and clear and ownership.

You're correct in that it's not exactly the same as previous models. It's a somewhat new innovation. And isn't it great to try new things?

Perhaps you'd prefer to think of it as more like a transaction tax, which exists in many localities when you sell real estate. E.g. NYC has a 1% transaction tax on sales over $1MM. But here the tax goes to the creator rather than the government.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by billytetrud on Thursday May 20, 2021 @03:00PM (#27225569)
Sure. Its an interesting new idea. I can see that it might have reasonable use cases, but its not clear to me whether its actually an improvement over other kinds of contracts. It would also have technical problems in the case of key change - if the owner has their keys compromised and needs to transfer the record to a new address, do they pay a fee to the original creator for that? And this happens in perpetuity?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by mattbeckman on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:37PM (#27212612)
Transfers are not necessarily sales.

Transaction fees for the Topps MLB cards on WAX, for example, are only taken during the sale when the sale occurs on a secondary Atomic Asset marketplace. There are no royalties to trade or transfer between accounts.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by lottin on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:03PM (#27212933)
These are not royalties. Royalties are paid when you buy a copy of a copyrighted work. And your not paying royalties again if the previous owner has already paid them.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by dumbfounder on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:56PM (#27213676)
I have never heard this take before, you actually think it's evil? Insidiously so? I honestly can't even conceive of what your argument is.

First off, the facts are a bit off, NFTs cannot currently contain hardcoded royalties (or whatever you call it). Right now it is voluntarily paid by the marketplaces that sell NFTs. But I think at some point it will evolve to be guaranteed. Sort of.

But either way, if it's all transparent, then why is it evil? Maybe it acts as a deterrent of sales in the future, but I like that it can be controlled by the creator. It's everyone else's choice on whether to buy it, or whether that constitutes ownership. If you don't like it, don't buy it.

Evil? Really? I don't get it at all. Not one single iota. But, willing to hear your argument for that. "Hardcoding wealth inequality" is hardly an argument. It's not like there are a ton of people creating a new superclass of rich artists. There are a few, but that isn't the way it will shake out long term. At least, any more than traditional art.

Is all wealth inherently evil to you? Maybe that's your argument? I guess that's it?

On your "imagine if cryptocurrency started doing that", I am sure there are cases where this happens. ZCash is one where 10% of mined blocks go back to the original investors and founding team. Not sure how I feel about that, I do think it's high, but I certainly don't think it's evil. If people don't like it, they won't use it, and something will take its place. No biggie.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by esoltys on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:55PM (#27212057)
When I think of "percentage $ cut off of every subsequent transaction" I think of Artist's Resale Right, or "Droit de suite" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Droit_de_suite
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by bitcurious on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:20PM (#27212394)
>Imagine if cryptocurrency started doing that?

Isn't this essentially what proof of steak is? A tax on all transactions proportional to how much you already own, but disproportionately applied to smaller users.

That last bit is key. Speaking of Ethereum for a second - the largest asset owners will be institutions which can transact off-chain, which means that fees are being payed more often by folks that don't have that kind of scale.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by smrq on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:26PM (#27212461)
First we had proof of work, and it consumed all the world's processing power. Then we had proof of space, and it consumed all the world's data storage. Then we had proof of steak, and it consumed all the world's food. Thus ended humanity.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by visualradio on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:50PM (#27213587)
First we had gold, and the Spanish looted the New World to acquire it and found themselves no richer. Then we had real estate mortgages and used deeds to estates instead of gold, and the speculators wrote up intangible asset prices as high as possible to get more money from central banks. Then we had digital gold, and no one used it because money is credit and no one wanted to pay excessive interest to internet goldbugs.

Ideally we would recognize that issuing money is a collective problem and attempt to fix our public money system, which is based on real estate mortgages.

We can fix it by recognizing that when a home has a fixed capital replacement cost of $150,000 and broker has written the comparable sales price up to $400,000 that it is not necessary to publicly guarantee the mortgages at the comparable sales price of $400,000 only the $150,000. Or to at least cap the public mortgage guarantees at double the replacement cost ($300,000) whenever the comparable sales price ($400,000) is greater.

It perhaps goes against libertarian sensibilities to claim that if the labor and material cost of the replacing all of the structures, fixtures, equipment, appliances conveyed with an estate is $150,000 and the comparable sales prices of $400,000 that the estate has 'intrinsic value' of $150,000 rather than just subjective value of $400,000. But with federally backed mortgages the $400,000 is not a long run competitive market value, it is a number which a specific set of brokers and banks have fixed upon which the central bank then commits to backing regardless of how they pick it.

Requiring loans which expand legal tender to be issued on at least half security of the replacement cost of non-obsolete fixed capital would be a reasonable short term reform to stabilize the public money system in case private crypto money doesn't work out.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:26PM (#27212456)
I've always felt that the best way to prove steaks is with forks.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by ASalazarMX on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:18PM (#27213932)
It's a shame that ecoins with proof-of-steak can't be ecofriendly. Maybe that's for the best, since you could accidentally eat your steaks and lose your money.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by baryphonic on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:15PM (#27215232)
You referring to proof-of-steak directly releasing greenhouse gases in the form of bovine farts?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by bitcurious on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:30PM (#27214734)
Quick, invest in Beyond Meat! It’s the future of blockchain.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by bondarchuk on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:13PM (#27212299)
You can just wrap the NFT inside a holding contract, then trade access to the holding contract without triggering an actual sale. At least on ethereum you can do this.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by swinglock on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:13PM (#27212306)
> Imagine if cryptocurrency started doing that?

It happened, that's SafeMoon. Sounds like a Ponzi scheme? That's their selling point!

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by RobertDeNiro on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:55PM (#27212046)
Not surprisingly, that's the part that sold Mark Cuban on NFTs. The infinite money stream.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by Pils on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:59PM (#27212886)
I believe this is wrong. Creator percentage isn't coded into the Ethereum-based NFT's themselves, it's done at the marketplace level. Currently, if you bought an NFT on Foundation and sold it on Opensea, there isn't a way to encode directly into the NFT a guarantee Foundation's royalty agreement would be followed.

EIP-2981 is the draft protocol-level NFT royalty implementation, but you will note that it's opt-in and NFT marketplaces do not need to respect it (although theoretically they could be blacklisted/sued). It explicitly outlines why a non opt-in implementation wouldn't work:

> It is impossible to know which NFT transfers are the result of sales, and which are merely wallets moving or consolidating their NFTs. Therefore, we cannot force every transferFrom() call to involve a royalty payment, as not every transfer is a sale that would require such payment. We believe the NFT marketplace ecosystem will voluntarily implement this royalty payment standard to provide ongoing funding for artists and other creators, and NFT buyers will assess the royalty payment as a factor when making NFT purchasing decisions. [0]

The only non opt-in royalty percentage implementation I know of is Euler Beats, but that royalty percentage only applies to printing new NFTs through their bonding curve. If you bought an Euler Beat print through a third party, you could simply use the safeTransferFrom function and avoid royalties entirely.

As someone pointed out in this thread, this arrangement is very common for high end art already, since it helps keep incentives aligned between collectors and the artists.

[0] https://eips.ethereum.org/EIPS/eip-2981#universal-royalty-pa...

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by seibelj on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:20PM (#27215270)
I am an author of this EIP. You are correct. It is impossible to enforce unless the chain itself has NFT trading as part of a core feature. Otherwise it’s the honor system. But IMO this will be quite successful given the social pressure.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by smegger001 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @10:39PM (#27216747)
pardon my ignorance but how exactly does it force royalties to transfer? couldn't a owner just transfer the underlying etherum coin that is used for the NFT to another wallet address just like any other ethereum coin? and likewise exchange it in a new smart contract?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by thebean11 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:05PM (#27212210)
This is about as easy to enforce on the blockchain as it is in meatspace...

All you have to do is "wrap" the NFT in a smart contract, then move the smart contract around. The NFT itself is not moving (its owner is the smart contract) so it won't trigger the fee.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by dschnurr on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:15PM (#27212332)
Some artists choose to attach "perks" to their NFTs – i.e. meet and greets, access to private communities. They could choose not to honor these perks for NFTs held by contracts. They could even choose to re-mint the work if the new owner is doing nefarious things with the old one (though many would see this as a dubious action)
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by scatters on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:09PM (#27213017)
Eh, so write a warrant to buy the NFT for a dollar, then sell the warrant.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by thebean11 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:23PM (#27213191)
I think that would be difficult to do trustlessly though, without a smart contract holding the NFT. How can I force you to send me the NFT if I exercise?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by newsclues on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:22PM (#27212410)
Can you embed a smart contract in an NFT so that if you wrap or otherwise sell outside of the initial chain, it’s null and void and the rights revert back to the creator to auction again?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by thebean11 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:35PM (#27212584)
Good question, I'm not sure if you can programmatically check if an address belongs to a smart contract but it wouldn't be surprising if you could, and prevent transferring ownerships to those addresses.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by chrischattin on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:55PM (#27212055)
Artist sells painting for $1k. Buyer then sells painting for $1M. Next buyer sells for $10M. Original artist only made $1k on a $10M painting. Shouldn't the original artist be able to participate in the upside of their creation?

I'm not seeing the "evil" here. Just a way for creators to cut out the middle men. Or, just a different way of structuring a contract.

There's a lot of moralistic FUD against crypto on HN right now. Feels very much like a coordinated propaganda campaign.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by hervature on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:36PM (#27212594)
Do you feel the same way with collectible cars? Every time a 69 Thunderbird is sold, Ford should get a cut in the upside? How do you feel about the inverse? If a painting goes down in value, is the artist on the hook for the downside of their creation? The answer is no, the creator handed over the creation on sale. Anything else would need to be hashed out in a contract which would drastically reduce sale price.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by chrischattin on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:44PM (#27212695)
I don't have feelings about it either way. I think you're reading way too much into my comment. It's just a new interesting way to structure a contract. Neither good nor evil. I certainly don't think it's "evil" like the comment I replied.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by hervature on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:53PM (#27212805)
Yes, I did forget the OP. I don't understand how people getting paid is evil either. Whether that comes in a huge lump sum at the beginning or in interest overtime, it doesn't really matter. There is going to be a cash flow analysis that will tell you how much one version of the contract is worth relative to the other. My comment was more that these contracts aren't new, they just aren't particularly useful because it is hard to think of a contract in perpetuity.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by solomonb on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:40PM (#27212644)
In that scenario all future paintings from that artist go up in sale price and the artist profits.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by cdelsolar on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:03PM (#27212183)
yes, agree with the FUD comment, please stop, you're making my crypto drop
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by gfxgirl on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:52PM (#27212791)
That's not how things are supposed to work AFAIK. I go buy a book, DVD, CD, video, etc for $10. I can then resell it for $8 or if it becomes rare for $20. The original creator only gets the first $10

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by hatsunearu on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:21PM (#27213169)
Well, it's how everything else works, but there's no saying that it's meant to be this way.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by twox2 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:54PM (#27212816)
Behind the scenes the NFT is just a smart contract standard. The royalty isn't really baked into the contract itself, but the platform that's using to exchange it.... So lots of projects with this perpetual royalty might get moved to another platform like opensea or rarible, and the royalty goes poof.

Also, the royalty is just artists getting commission on their work. Most NFT minting platforms worth anything allow the artist to mint from their wallet.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by geofft on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:26PM (#27212463)
Moreover, how is this not just a form of DRM?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by a1369209993 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:26PM (#27215325)
You can still copy the underlying data however you like - if the NFT says http://example.com/foobar.jpg you can just do `wget http://example.com/foobar.jpg`, regardless of whether you've even seen the NFT, and assuming you can access foobar.jpg at all, you can then copy it however you like.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by sneak on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:31PM (#27214094)
> but I want to talk about how insidiously evil it is that NFTs can be coded to send the original creator a percentage $ cut off of every subsequent transaction for all time

This is not accurate.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by skilesare on Thursday May 20, 2021 @03:51PM (#27226232)
They've already been designed. You just have to go all the way with it to create something interesting Http://catallax.info
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by ketamine__ on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:54PM (#27212037)
I thought this comment was a joke at first. What's wrong with creators getting royalties? Is there proof that artists are too wealthy (in general)?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by geofft on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:19PM (#27212382)
Two things.

First, in the real world, creators stop getting royalties after the item expires and goes into the public domain, and there's a pretty strong view that the time for that is already too long and the beneficiaries of that long period tend to be companies instead of creators. I would say that there is in fact a widespread belief that the heirs of Walt Disney are too wealthy, despite the fact that Walt himself was a creator.

Second, there's no reason to believe this won't lead to the exact sort of mechanisms that plague existing royalties - e.g., a young singer makes a (smart) contract with a recording studio to have the studio count as the "creator" of the work as far as the contract cares, and the singer is just performing work for hire, in exchange for marketing, promotion, initial funding, and connections. A singer who has absolutely no resources but their talent is probably going to say yes to that, because it's better for them in the short term than going it alone, and the odds are against them (not every talented young singer can become famous). But the profits continue to flow to the recording studio for all time.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by jcranmer on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:32PM (#27212549)
There's another thing you're missing: First Sale Doctrine. In the world of physical goods, once you've sold a copy of something, you have no rights whatsoever to constrain what people can do with that copy. Authors don't see a dime for used book sales, for example.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by twox2 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:56PM (#27212830)
But the IRS still gets a perpetual royalty on every subsequent sale. Why can't the producer?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by geofft on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:47PM (#27213529)
Because "the IRS" (not sure which jurisdiction you're in, but here in the US, it's actually the local and state government) is an entity controlled by elections that is obligated to spend its budget in ways decided on by elections, and therefore can reasonably exist forever. The royalties are not for the benefit of the IRS. A state or local government is sort of like an offline DAO, if you're familiar with DAOs. A producer does not live forever, and the producer's heirs get to spend things as they see fit.

Also, in many cases, the local government does not get a royalty on every sale - certain sales, such as to non-profits, do not get taxed.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by twox2 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:59PM (#27213715)
I'm not talking about literal royalties. If I have an item that I buy new (or used) and it's not a depreciating asset, and I sell it, then I owe income tax or capital gains, don't I? And then when the new owner sells it a few months or years later as is common in the case of collectibles, they have to pay income tax or gains on their sale as well, and this continues for the entire life span of the object.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by geofft on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @07:53PM (#27215871)
Oh, I assumed you were talking about sales taxes, which is the most obvious case of a DAO-like organization taking money on every sale, as a percentage of the selling price.

Income taxes and capital gains taxes are on your profit, not on the sale itself, so they're less analogous. If you as a taxable entity don't net make any money, you don't owe any income taxes (more or less); if you as a taxable entity don't make any profit on an asset you bought some time ago, you don't owe any capital gains taxes (more or less). So both of those are much more reasonable than a royalty on every sale - they don't follow the asset around forever, and you only have to pay a percentage of the money you made if you're in fact making money. It seems like, if I buy an NFT at $10000 and then sell it a month later for $9000, some of that $9000 goes to the creator of the NFT and not to me.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by twox2 on Thursday May 20, 2021 @08:59AM (#27220526)
"It seems like, if I buy an NFT at $10000 and then sell it a month later for $9000, some of that $9000 goes to the creator of the NFT and not to me."

Yes that's correct. That makes it very appealing for creators like artists. I can see how that might be off putting for you though, but I think over time this will become "priced in". Also, only ver few creators will have an active aftermarket for their work. Most will not have a single aftermarket sale.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by ww520 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:11PM (#27212282)
Isn't that what copyright is about?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by toss1 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:37PM (#27212609)
Not quite. Copyright prevents Bob from misappropriating Alice's work. E.g., Bob purchases a painting from Alice for $100. Bob can not legally now use that painting as a source to make and resell copies.

But Bob can sell the original painting to Charlie for $200 and pocket the entire $200 from Charlie. Alice has nothing to do with that sale, and does not profit from any subsequent sale.

But if Alice sold Bob and NFT instead, when Bob sold it to Charlie, perhaps $180 of Charlie's money would go to Bob and $20 would also go to Alice.

And this would hold true for every future sale, so when Alice died and became a famous dead artist and her works sell for $200K, her estate gets $20K, etc.

To me, this is the sole redeeming value of NFTs, but only if artists can actually keep those rights and revenue streams. The usual path of such things is that middlemen insert themselves to engage in their usual rent-seeking behaviors.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by platz on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:58PM (#27212866)
NFTs don't liscence or provide rights to artworks; they are useless to artists.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by ww520 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:08PM (#27212988)
RIAA collects a loyalty every time a song is played just because they hold the copyright. Why isn’t there moral outrage on that?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by bsedlm on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:55PM (#27212821)
just sounds like automated royalties to me (with infinite copyright). AT least when an NFT does this, it is known in advance; as opposed to legistative action changing the goal posts during the match.

Also, I suppose there can be a way to cancel the royalties by making a meta-NFT (of sorts) that "owns" the NFT which stays in one place forever so that the meta-NFT can be traded instead.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by nathias on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:50PM (#27213582)
compare it to what actually exists in the mainstream not some dark fears of possible dystopias ...
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by vb6sp6 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:56PM (#27212070)
do you feel the same way about royalties?