News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by dschnurr on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:18PM (#27212371)
The creator is almost always the artist. Provenance is what gives NFTs their value. The value of a Beeple NFT minted by a random user is $0.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by geofft on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:21PM (#27212399)
The value of a Beeple NFT minted by a random user is exactly what the market chooses to value it as.

If it's minted by an agency that helps creators do marketing, and the agency gets the creator to say "Yes, this is a legitimate NFT created on my behalf by this agency, which has been very helpful to me in understanding NFTs, I don't understand these fancy computer things," why would the value be zero?

(This exact scenario plays out all the time in the real world. People bought "Taylor Swift's" album Fearless, which was authorized by her and contained her actual voice and songwriting and paid profits to her and was in all senses legitimate, and paid well over zero dollars for it. And then over a decade later she tells her fans that she doesn't control it and she's recording her own version of the album actually owned by her.)

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by AlexandrB on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:24PM (#27212437)
What stops a record company from including a clause assigning any NFTs (and/or the revenue therefrom) created by the artist during the contract term to them?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by pmulard on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:42PM (#27212671)
Nothing. Just like nothing stopped Taylor Swift from rerecording her entire library to license her music herself. If artists sign their NFT rights away, that's on them.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by btilly on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:39PM (#27213418)
What Taylor Swift did is an imitation of what Prince did long before her.

See https://www.billboard.com/articles/news/cover-story/7348551/... for more.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by packetlost on Thursday May 20, 2021 @10:46AM (#27221785)
That's not really relevant to this discussion though
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by NicoJuicy on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:49PM (#27214288)
What stops someone from creating a nft with the same metadata?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by jjulius on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:43PM (#27212683)
Absolutely nothing.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by btilly on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:05PM (#27212958)
Provenance is what gives NFTs their value.

The question is how you prove that provenance if a niche artist has created an NFT on a niche piece of art. (And, honestly, most of the people who would want to create NFTs are going to be in this category.)

Now imagine an agency whose job was simply to create a digital signature on a work that indicated what they had done to prove a particular piece of art really was produced by the artist who then goes on to sign the NFT. If the agency has an established reputation, then that signed NFT has much more solidly established provenance than an unsigned NFT. Of course that agency has non-zero costs to establish provenance. And adds a non-zero amount to the value of the NFT.

What then, can said agency reasonably charge the artist for this service?

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by echelon on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:27PM (#27212475)
The value of a Beeple NFT minted by Beeple is $0. The market just hasn't discovered that yet.

An NFT has no more value than a JPG.

I'll longbets anyone that says otherwise.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by arcsincosin on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:43PM (#27212684)
I agree but it's worth noting that Beeple was selling JPGs for $5000+ in the mid 2010s as a commissioned artist in the music industry. So the NFTs have also brought some transparency to a successful digital artist along with the crazy valuations.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by sashimi-houdini on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:34PM (#27214131)
This seems like a dangerous bet to make... my take on the NFT "market" is that it's money laundering, wash trading (inflating prices to attract suckers to the market) and perhaps in a small part conspicuous consumption. Mostly fraudulent... but would you bet against a fraud?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by berberous on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:31PM (#27212544)
I would take a broader bet that is not tied to Beeple (i.e. that NFTs of significant artists will have long-term value in a similar manner as a painting).
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by echelon on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:38PM (#27212633)
I would take that broader bet that NFTs will have zero long-term value.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by usehackernews on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:51PM (#27213608)
Explain why -

Is this because you don't have interest in it, or do you have a true justification of this?

I'm willing to take this bet. Just like art, 99% can be bought for $1 at a garage sale, but there will be the 1% that has value to someone.

You are betting against the generation who spends massive amounts on video games costumes, and puts more value into their online image (instagram) than real life image, not finding value in a form of digital scarcity & status. I find that hard to believe.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by intotheabyss on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:14PM (#27213071)
So the condition of your bet would be that all NFTs everywhere have zero long term value? So something like, by 2030, no non-fungible token will have a monetary value?
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by saalweachter on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:39PM (#27213430)
I'm not interested in taking the counter party in this bet, but if you were to take a bet in the form "The highest sale price of a NFT in calendar year 20X0 will be no more Y0% of the highest sale price of a postage stamp in that same year.", what would you fill in for X & Y?
[dead]
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by hluska on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:01PM (#27213741)
I’m over forty and quite frankly, I’m tired of this ageist crap. This entire premise is complete fucking bullshit. Do yourself and everyone over 40 you come into contact with a favour and pretend you never believed anything so toxic.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by TigeriusKirk on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:13PM (#27213871)
>This entire premise is complete fucking bullshit

I'm over 50 and this does not match with my observations of the world. Older people, as a general trend, do in fact seem to be resistant to new ideas. There are exceptions, of course. The trend still stands in my experience.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by hluska on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:43PM (#27214224)
Then I’m sorry to say it pal, but you’ve got to get out more. Some of the most rebellious open minded people I know are in their seventies. Age is just about completely meaningless and ageism has no place in intellectual communities.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by btilly on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:23PM (#27214644)
And I'm over 50. My point remains.

Very often things invented when we are older seem to be utterly pointless to us. We literally can't get why people are excited about them. And I see this tendency in people in my age range more than in my teenagers. I personally have to back up and go from first principles to avoid it.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by hluska on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @08:07PM (#27215943)
Everything is exciting - innovation is exciting and new inventions are exciting. If you can't feel it, that's sad and I hope you can get it back but please don't impose your own issue upon an entire age group.
Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by ASalazarMX on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:11PM (#27213852)
Douglas Adams was a humorist first and philosopher second, quoting him literally is borderline naive.

For starters, not everything invented when you are 15-35 is good. Take reality shows: they were indeed new and revolutionary (exciting idk), but they didn't pass the test of time. Stupid stuff is invented all the time, regardless of people's ages.

Re:Cryptography experts trash NFTs on first day of RSA Confe... by lottin on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:05PM (#27212959)
You're god-damn right.