News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by chha on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:28AM (#27013049)
They mention this as a way to recycle plastics, but for me this seems like a perfect way to get lots of tiny plastic particles out and into the environment once the road starts to wear.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by natmaka on Sunday May 02, 2021 @04:10AM (#27013251)
Ready for another batch of "Scientists tracked down a mass killer of $SOMETHING"? See for example https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25431550
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by virtue3 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @07:17AM (#27014190)
yeah... you're not wrong. Plastics are basically organic compounds and they screw around with organisms very easily.

Tho asphalt is already made with bitumen (a petroleum product) so it's not like it's THAT much different. Hopefully we aren't concentrating even more problematic compounds than what already existing in the asphalt.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by gruez on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:39AM (#27014769)
>Tho asphalt is already made with bitumen (a petroleum product) so it's not like it's THAT much different.

Plastics generate microplastics. Does bitumen generate microbitumen?

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by notatoad on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:02AM (#27015384)
yes. the road surface is abraded as it's driven over, which creates oily dust. essentially "microbitumen".

also, road usage already causes microplastic pollution in the form of tire wear, so while including plastic in the road surface might increase the overall volume of microplastic pollution, it won't increase the distribution of it - areas near roadways are already microplastic hotspots.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by refurb on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:27AM (#27016078)
This is the right question. We talk about micro plastics, has anyone looked at concrete micro particles and the effects on humans? What about just the fine dust from top soil? What is the effect on humans?

Reminds me a little bit when people get overly worried about keeping things clean without realizing everything is covered in bacteria that you ingest on a regular basis.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by thatcat on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:57AM (#27015335)
Does bitumen bioaccumulate into food supplies? Why compare the two?
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by 8bitsrule on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:54AM (#27015799)
Ran into this interesting factoid a couple days back:

"Kerogen is solid, insoluble organic matter in sedimentary rocks. Consisting of an estimated 10^16 tons of carbon, it is the most abundant source of organic compounds on earth, exceeding the total organic content of living matter 10,000-fold.... Petroleum and natural gas form from kerogen. Kerogen may be classified by its origin: lacustrine (e.g., algal), marine (e.g., planktonic), and terrestrial (e.g., pollen and spores).... Kerogen is insoluble in normal organic solvents in part because of its high molecular weight of its component compounds. The soluble portion is known as bitumen."

[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerogen]

All from the same (previously locked-up) family of goodies, it seems.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by gilbetron on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:38AM (#27015676)
Here's one thesis that claims it probably does not:

https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/20366224.pdf

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by refurb on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:29AM (#27016093)
Do microplastics bioaccumulate? Or at least in the sense that we think of bioaccumulation?
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by thatcat on Monday May 03, 2021 @08:04AM (#27024005)
Yea, it accumulates in the food chain.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by tlrobinson on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:44AM (#27013130)
This was my first thought as well. I’d rather discarded plastics be concentrated in dumps than thinly spread across the land.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by imhoguy on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:15AM (#27013607)
Or why not use it just to make fundaments, underground insulation or just a ground water barrier. My understanding is that the underground environment causes less degradation to plastics than a one exposed to sun and constant friction.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by amelius on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:50AM (#27014843)
But might affect ground water quality.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by spodek on Sunday May 02, 2021 @07:15AM (#27014170)
Future generations will see our use of plastic like we see asbestos, HCFCs, and leaded gasoline. Nobody denies its utility. It just kills people and wildlife. Once we ban at least single-use plastic we'll recoil with horror at what we did and how long we took after realizing what we were doing to stop ourselves.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by thathndude on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:36AM (#27014743)
I’ve recently come to see this truth. Like reading the vintage ads recommending cocaine to help your tooth ache.

I just hope the future finds a way to undo so much of the damage.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by freeflight on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:30AM (#27015116)
> Like reading the vintage ads recommending cocaine to help your tooth ache.

Cocaine didn't result in large scale environmental damage, to this day it's still in widespread medical use as a local anesthetic.

Imho a much more apt example would be something like "plutonium toothpaste" and the fact how humanity has irreversibly changed Earths biosphere by introducing large quantities of atmospheric plutonium 239 during the countless nuclear weapon tests [0].

Any acknowledgement of potential deadly consequences out of that mostly exist in some fringe awareness [1], and pretty much never comes up in any debates around the risks and dangers of nuclear as a source of energy generation.

[0] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0096340215581357

[1] https://qz.com/1163140/us-nuclear-tests-killed-american-civi...

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by spodek on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:55AM (#27015313)
> I just hope the future finds a way to undo so much of the damage.

Future? We can undo it now -- just with life improvements and simplifications, I've dropped my emissions 90%, according to online calculators. I take two years to fill a load of trash at home, which used to be weekly. Many other changes. And one person changing is exactly what causes more people to change.

As a result, Mayors, Congressmembers, and other politicians, CEOs, champion athletes, and more have come on my podcast, helping lead large communities. The Hacker News community is particularly recalcitrant, believing that Mars and fusion are simple and will solve everything while flying less or having fewer children is against human nature and solve nothing, but there's variation.

Systemic change begins with personal transformation.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:10AM (#27015447)
That sounds like work and inconvenience though. Let's just hit the snooze button and hope the mighty people of the future can figure it out se we don't have to make any changes to our lifestyle.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by refurb on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:31AM (#27016108)
No doubt we’ll recoil I know horror, but we’ll probably recoil in horror at plenty of things we don’t know better about…that’s progress.

Thankfully we don’t judge we don’t judge people who made errors in the past out of ignorance. ;)

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by gruez on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:29AM (#27015113)
[deleted]
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by spodek on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:47AM (#27015242)
HCFCs are refrigerants that deplete ozone. They are not made from corn.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chlorofluorocarbon

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by hellow0rldz on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:36AM (#27013085)
Breathable micro-plastics doesn't sound nice.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by shoto_io on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:12AM (#27013591)
I thought that’s happening anyways because we burn most of the plastic waste?
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by kzrdude on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:21AM (#27013634)
In a proper incineration plant it's so hot that there is no microplastics left over
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by shoto_io on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:39AM (#27013712)
But where does it go then? What’s the chemical reaction? Is there only CO2 and water left then?
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by Tuna-Fish on Sunday May 02, 2021 @06:10AM (#27013838)
Mostly, yeah. Of course polyamides also produce some nitrogen compounds and PVC also produces HCl that you have to deal with, etc.

But generally, plastics are very complex long-chain carbohydrates. Burning them at low temperatures produces all kinds of partially combusted horrible byproducts, but properly incinerating them results in just water and CO2.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by m4rtink on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:26AM (#27014668)
I visited an incineration plan once and they showed how the make really sure the temperature is over 900 degrees Celsius st all times so that plastics and biological toxins are properly destroyed.

They also make sure there is lots of air available to the combustion process and thats done in an interesting way. They draw it in via the waste storage bunker solving two issues at once - the stinky air from all the waste gets effectively burned and the bunker is kept as negative air pressure so the smell doesn't get out.

And of course all the exhaust gases pass via a sophisticated fikter plant.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by zo1 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:01PM (#27016349)
Aren't we then shooting ourselves in the foot then by being scared of burning trash/plastic waste? As an interim before solving all plastic waste, it seems like a much better solution than just stacking plastic into giant dumps.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by chihuahua on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:47PM (#27016669)
Perhaps burning trash would be the better solution. But it seems fairly unpopular with people in general, at least in the U.S. - you can imagine how easy it is to generate violent opposition to put a trash-burning facility in any place.

An acquaintance of mine from high school for some reason devoted much of his life to promoting trash burning technology. It seems like a good cause, but a futile one.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by sgerenser on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:14PM (#27019080)
Trash incineration plants (referred to as “waste-to-energy” which sounds like an accurate euphemism to me) definitely generate very strong negative reactions in the U.S. I used to live just a couple miles away from one in Syracuse NY and I thought it was a great idea... recycle and reuse what you can, and everything else gets cleanly incinerated and generates electricity at the same time. There was no detectable smell either. Being supportive of the plant definitely put me in the minority based on all the negative feedback I read online and in the local newspaper.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by chihuahua on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:23PM (#27021002)
I think burning PVC can produce dioxin, which would be very bad if it's not filtered out from the exhaust. Then it depends on how much you trust the facility to have an effective filter installed, and test and maintain it diligently. That costs money, so there will be a tendency to skip the maintenance.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by Tuna-Fish on Monday May 03, 2021 @07:06AM (#27023608)
No. Only partial combustion of PVC produces dioxins. Proper incineration plants do not produce any. So the solution is not filters, but hotter combustion.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by Tuna-Fish on Sunday May 02, 2021 @02:07PM (#27017395)
Some countries have made that decision. For instance, Sweden recycles roughly half of all household waste, and burns almost all the rest.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/21/climate/sweden-garbage-us...

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by imtringued on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:33PM (#27016533)
You have to capture the CO2 and then figure out how to store it or turn it into pure Carbon and then you still have to landfill that.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by CameronNemo on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:33PM (#27016536)
Maybe. The CO2 going to the atmosphere is not great. You have to way that against the risks of plastic pollution from land filling.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by Tuna-Fish on Sunday May 02, 2021 @02:08PM (#27017403)
If you are burning any fossil fuels for power, starting up waste incineration power plants to replace them is a pure win.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by leipert on Sunday May 02, 2021 @06:09AM (#27013836)
Not an expert, but I assume remaining particles are filtered from the exhaust fumes and/or remain part of the remaining sludge.

Pyrolysis seems also like a thing that hopefully becomes viable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_depolymerization

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by shoto_io on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:11AM (#27013585)
I knew that this sort of comment was on top when I clicked the comment section :-)

PS: I’m not saying it’s wrong, it’s just fits the HN sentiment perfectly.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by Jemm on Sunday May 02, 2021 @07:39AM (#27014340)
The article states that there is no advantage to the paving by having plastic mixed in. This begs the question why, other than landfill diversion of plastics, replace aggregate with plastic?
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by loonster on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:14AM (#27015002)
Greenwashing.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by thereare5lights on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:19AM (#27013626)
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by anakaine on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:52AM (#27013775)
Quantity and dosage also matter.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by systemvoltage on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:56AM (#27013190)
Micro plastics are terrifying, but I’m trying to think why exactly. If the road is shedding plastic dust along with the ground full of insoluble things like tar, rock, pebbles and stone; what’s a tiny particle of plastic any different from a grain of sand? I’m not asserting that micro plastics aren’t bad, just trying to understand what are the risks compared to a lot of dirt around us. I think dust on microscopic scale is inorganic insoluble solid particles and we seem to breathe/eat this stuff with no issue. Are polymers any different than dust particles when it comes to risks to humans in inhaling and ingesting it? Is it something else?
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by endymi0n on Sunday May 02, 2021 @04:13AM (#27013262)
Dust is mostly chemically inert, while plastics aren't:

> Results

> Numerous animal studies have shown that exposure to nano- and microplastics leads to impairments in oxidative and inflammatory intestinal balance, and disruption of the gut’s epithelial permeability. Other notable effects of nano- and microplastic exposure include dysbiosis (changes in the gut microbiota) and immune cell toxicity. Moreover, microplastics contain additives, adsorb contaminants, and may promote the growth of bacterial pathogens on their surfaces: they are potential carriers of intestinal toxicants and pathogens that can potentially lead to further adverse effects.

https://particleandfibretoxicology.biomedcentral.com/article...

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by lumost on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:53AM (#27014861)
Every now and then I read something like this and wonder how long human lifespans would be if you combine modern nutrition, and healthcare but remove the toxicity of our modern environment.

Roman leaders often lived into their 60s/70s.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by okaram on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:19AM (#27015047)
Biden is 78, Pelosi is 81, Trump is 74, and Bernie is 79.

US Life expectancy is 79.8 ... so we have basically made it so a good chunk of people, not just the leaders live into their seventies.

There's a good chance that there's something in our current genome that makes us get old and die ending in our 70s.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by atat7024 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:45PM (#27020459)
> modern nutrition

Uh...

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by pixl97 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @02:18PM (#27017481)
Roads do contain asphalt which isn't significantly different from a long chain plastic. Even worse is the tire dust itself.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by creshal on Sunday May 02, 2021 @04:11AM (#27013256)
Microplastics can penetrate various biological barriers that were designed to keep dust etc. out. These biological barriers are already not perfect, things like heavy metals (lead, cadmium, …) do the same and can cause massive damages, which is why our only solution is to limit their uses and prevent them from leaking into the environment as much as possible.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by systemvoltage on Sunday May 02, 2021 @04:21AM (#27013312)
TIL, thanks for the insight. It's remarkable already that human body can take so much abuse, and still survive.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by nosianu on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:44AM (#27013737)
Multicellular organisms are highly parallel, trillions of cells in a human. Even inside a eukaryotic cell (gigantic compared to far smaller bacteria) there is a huge amount of parallelism and non-linearity like in some assembly line.

The discussions about some health consequences always come up with "death" as the binary outcome measure. This is so useless. There already is an effect for tiny amounts of molecules. Functions in cells work worse, and cells work worse. This affects all of your functions. Since you are only ever exposed to tiny amounts even when it accumulates - e.g. for heavy metals - all those small problems are either not noticed or attributed to age, which of course also advances.

I had the "benefit" of diagnosed mercury poisoning (gray zone - enough to warrant chelation treatment, university clinic researcher doctor who always forgot to send his - very moderate - bills unless I reminded him several times for a year each time, so no over-diagnosis for profit).

From a disappearing nodule in my thyroid that I had had for decades, unchanging, that suddenly disappeared within weeks of chelation to the great amazement of an endocrinologist who had recommended surgery and who ultra-sounded me twice because he could not believe it, to a huge long list of "minor" ailments that I had increased over the decades and that I had ignored and also attributed to age (I never bothered doctors, far from hypochondriac, never thought much of it), to my returning ability for abstract thought, to digestion going from delayed and stinky to perfect (really), from sleep problems to easy and perfect sleep, to never tired, soooo much went away. With the doctors permission and supervision I chelated far longer and far beyond what would have been justified officially, since it kept helping even though measured amounts were getting really tiny.

Only because I saw the contrast, which rarely anyone ever does because for most people it's a very very gradual slope downhill, or they believe it's "genes" or age, do I even consider environmental factors. I once saw a webpage from a decades-long inner medicine clinic doctor who opened a private practice - in which she offered purely psychological bullshit "treatments" that you see from "alternative medicine". Her reasoning, explained on her (old, clinic-time) website: It's either genes or psychology in her clinical experience, meaning you can hardly ever really do anything but mitigation. Environmental factors never entered her mind. (I have no doubt any cases she diagnoses as "real" will be referred to a clinic by her right away, so not critic on her person from me.)

Which make sense, because the science behind the many, many each very tiny amounts of chemicals and their influence is very hard. Diagnosing it on an individual level, and not just on a population level (the latter does not help a doctor when there is a concrete patient in front of them), is even harder. So as a public health administrator allocating funds I perfectly understand why it flies under the radar. Because individual doctors working with individual patients can't really do much of anything. That is then equated with "there is no problem" (or they would do something about it). Oh and the "they didn't die so it can't be so bad" attitude.

.

Oh and by the way, completely non-scientific and my opinion after watching myself through many boring cycles:

- The common cold helps "getting stuff out". Significantly. I now wonder if eradicating it will have worse long-term outcomes for other issues. Also, not taking medicine to lower the symptoms for example for a good nights sleep might actually be better, the symptoms are part of that "getting stuff out". Yes it's very uncomfortable. It's horrible if you have to get up and go to work the next day.

- The best treatment by far are low stress (no alarms to wake you up to go to work when you would still sleep), sleep, rest as needed (during the day, just lying down and letting the mind go off somewhere - no reading or listening, the brain has to have "free time" to do things on its own - work from home is best!), walking (needed to get things moving, from my body experience the normal blood and ECF circulation is not sufficient.

- Changing sides left/right/left/right/... "I cannot find sleep" actually already is part of the brain's cleanup cycle! A lot of time spend in that phase may be an indicator that there is quite a bit. Clearly, having to get up for an early commute the next day adds stress and makes this hard to bear. But I recommend to accept it. It's a natural reaction, not something that should be suppressed. Yes it makes nights "work".

- The last 1-2 hours of sleep, that some (many) people find makes them more sleepy and groggy, are essential (okay, all phases are, but that's the one people like to skip).

- Being groggy after an afternoon nap is the same. Part of "getting stuff out".

You can call me out on any of this and I have no way to contradict you apart from anecdotes without any scientific value (nothing was measured, for example).

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by wruza on Sunday May 02, 2021 @06:38AM (#27013974)
If true, this story convinces me even more that we must develop a superhuman at all costs, to at least overcome the current stupid and abusive societal and environmental formats, but something completely irrational to that cause (called ethics) forces us to tread water in the status quo.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by refurb on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:34AM (#27016134)
I mean, we use plastic as implants in bodies like heart valves and joints. Hell, it’s a lot of Teflon. I think the jury is still out on the effect.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by creshal on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:55PM (#27018446)
We also still use mercury amalgams in tooth fillings, that doesn't mean we should pollute the environment with random unrelated mercury compounds.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by refurb on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:08PM (#27020604)
You missed my point. How toxic are plastics when we use them for implants?
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by rini17 on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:20AM (#27023059)
The widely-used polymer molecules which the plastics are named of are mostly stable and harmless (actually, too stable, microplastics problems stems from that). But

1. plastics need other additives to have the required properties and these are sus

2. plastics over their lifespan dissolve/release other substances you don't want to keep in your body.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by rini17 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @04:16AM (#27013279)
Oh, there are issues with breathing any kind of dust. Big issues. We should avoid adding dust into the air.

Plastics, unlike inorganic dust, bind to heavy metals and organic pollutants. Animals (of all sizes, but this concerns mostly plankton) mistake them for food and this causes pollutants to concentrate in the food chain.

Microplastics in soil also lower yield and have other adverse effects on crops (but this afaik needs to be studied more).

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by hh3k0 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @06:35AM (#27013958)
> What’s a tiny particle of plastic any different from a grain of sand?

Here you go:

> The smallest microplastic particles are capable of entering the bloodstream, the lymphatic system, and may even reach the liver.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/oct/22/micropla...

And they're -- additionally to the above -- often endocrine disruptors, carcinogenic, causing male infertility, most probably playing a role in all sorts of chronic diseases.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by CTDOCodebases on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:42AM (#27013729)
From what I have read plastics contain chemicals that interfere with our endocrine system.
Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by amelius on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:52AM (#27014856)
> Micro plastics are terrifying

Micro plastics are in lots of cosmetics already.

Re:Michigan asphalt company paves first US public roads cont... by raverbashing on Sunday May 02, 2021 @04:58AM (#27013507)
Roads already have a lot of tire dust due to tire wear, I don't think this will be a significant extra source of pollution.

> The polymer solves a longstanding problem that the asphalt industry has encountered since the first attempts at using recycled plastics in roads, namely how plastic separates once it's melted into the hot asphalt.