News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by black_puppydog on Monday April 19, 2021 @05:52AM (#26860869)
The fact that this type of device is virtually inaccessible, short of DIY, is for me a prime example of market failure ever since I learned about transflectives.

Btw I'd opt to replace the "E-INK" in the title with "transflective" assuming HN folks know to tell the two apart.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by andai on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:05AM (#26860967)
Mary Lou Jepsen (who created the One Laptop Per Child laptop also developed transflective displays for the laptop, which could switch between backlit color mode and sunlight-readable monochrome mode.

Later her company Pixel Qi even developed a screen with solar panels inside it, to charge the device while it is used outside. Pixel Qi is now defunct.

Today Jepsen is working on Clearwater, a non invasive brain imaging technology (an infrared headband which reconstructs a 3D image from scattered photons), which can be used for brain computer interfaces.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by userbinator on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:31AM (#26862538)
One Laptop Per Child laptop also developed transflective displays for the laptop, which could switch between backlit color mode and sunlight-readable monochrome mode.

In practice, mono mode was just barely readable in bright sunlight, and the colour mode was a grainy mess for anything with fine detail due to the lack of true RGB pixels[1]. I knew someone who had one of those --- it was more of a cute toy than anything actually useful, and that was at the time when tiny "netbooks" were still common.

[1] http://wiki.laptop.org/go/Display

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by BugsJustFindMe on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:42AM (#26863255)
I had an XO-1 and your description is really selling the display short, it was much more than just barely readable in bright light. Yes resolution was fairly low on the display, but it was first generation technology and the entire laptop cost only $200. OLPC made many questionable decisions, but the screen was good tech. I remember wanting transflective screens in other devices for a long time before finally giving up hope.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by blacksmith_tb on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:13AM (#26863625)
Agreed, the screen was one of the best things about the XO-1. Transreflective displays do live on here and there, I have an Amazfit Bip [1] which uses one.

1: https://www.tomsguide.com/us/amazfit-bip,review-5629.html

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by jschwartzi on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:17PM (#26865334)
Garmin watches also have transflective displays. I've never needed the backlight since I've always got either sunlight or a headlamp.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by dleslie on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:10AM (#26863578)
I have two XO-1s; they're great to use while sitting on the end of a dock, hacking in a remote terminal.

Literally no other screen I have comes close to how readable the XO-1 is in bright light.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by FlyMoreRockets on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:12PM (#26865259)
I also have a couple XO-1s and agree, the transflective screens are excellent. My Kindle Paperwhite has a more readable E-ink display, but isn't _that_ much better.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by phonon on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:15AM (#26861014)
> Jepsen is working on Clearwater,

Openwater.

https://www.openwater.cc/about-us

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by macspoofing on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:41AM (#26861174)
>Later her company Pixel Qi even developed a screen with solar panels inside it, to charge the device while it is used outside.

That's such a pointless gimmick though. Solar panels works best when they track the sun or are at least angled properly. Between the very few times you'd be using your device outside in direct sunlight, and actually having those panels angled towards the sun, you're not going to be charging anything at any reasonable rate. Those panels are completely useless and just add complexity and cost to the design. If you really care, you can buy portable solar chargers real cheap but they are universally mediocre at best.

Why do stupid gimmicks like this? Why not have an efficient device and just charge it from the grid? Or, given that this was made for the developing world, charge it from a generator or a proper solar array or wind turbines ... or the grid (even developing nations will have a grid that functions at least most of the time)

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by II2II on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:08AM (#26862327)
> Why do stupid gimmicks like this? Why not have an efficient device and just charge it from the grid?

I used to have a laptop with dual batteries, so one could swap one battery out with another to have an uninterrupted power supply without having access to the grid. Very few people need an uninterrupted power supply while away from the grid, but some people do. That is why such a design existed. Something like an integrated solar panel may fill a similar niche.

It is also worth noting that a technology should not be dismissed simply because the first iterations appear impractical. If we took that attitude, many of the things we enjoy today simply would not exist. Just think of personal computers from the late 1970's and early 1980's. Few people used them since they were not very practical. On the other hand, that seed of a market both financed the development of the machines we use today and directed the development of the technology towards something we would want to use today. (Put another way: if people did not use that impractical technology in their homes, it likely that computers would remain the tools of large institutions.)

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by nogridbag on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:18AM (#26863688)
Dell used to offer dual battery bays in its business line like the Latitude C840:

https://youtu.be/9XkeTCIC1TA?t=453

Side note: The clips holding in the batteries were the number one failure mode on those laptops.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by rzzzt on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:59PM (#26868803)
IBM/Lenovo themselves supported dual batteries at one point with the Ultrabay expansion slots: https://www.thinkwiki.org/wiki/Ultrabay
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by akvadrako on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:27AM (#26871348)
You don't need dual batteries for that, just an external USB-C powerpack. And they are pretty common.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by II2II on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @08:37AM (#26873726)
Different time, different context.

This would have been around 2010, when powering anything with USB was relatively uncommon. Some USB peripherals required a separate power supply or dual USB connections in order to provide enough power. Devices that charged via USB typically provided a special USB power adapter in order to facilitate faster charging.

Even today, dual battery compartments have marginal utility. Since it is built-in, it offers extended battery life without carrying around extra modules. Spare batteries are mildly more convenient to carry around (no extra cables). Mostly though, it enforces user replaceable batteries.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Renaud on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:06AM (#26862306)
Cost is probably what killed that project, but it's not entirely stupid, although it would certainly be better with a foldable panel at the back of the screen that can be positioned optimally.

A 30x20cm laptop could get at best 12-10W of sun power with a solar panel on its surface.

You could build a useful laptop with the same spec as a smartphone with a standard 4000mA battery and need about a charge a day in normal use.

Since the exposure of your laptop to the sun would be suboptimal, you may only get 4W for say 5h a day, which seems fairly reasonable and is enough to recharge the battery every day.

Even on bad days, you would probably be able to use your laptop half of the time, which could still be a few hours and enough to make a difference to someone with otherwise no access to technology.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by aj3 on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:21AM (#26861435)
I imagine that in places where electricity is scarce, adults might have different priorities than charging kid's laptop. Maybe the idea is that you leave laptop open in sun if the battery dies and it charges without needing access / permission to use power grid / generators?
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by macspoofing on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:41AM (#26861608)
>I imagine that in places where electricity is scarce

I think that's what most people in the west imagine and that's why this is a gimmick that resonates with well-meaning westerners. Besides the fact that developing world is a diverse place in all aspects (so the the stereotype you're imaging is wrong for the vast majority of the developing world), communication is such an ingrained human need, that communication devices like smart phones are everywhere.

But none of that matters. These panels just do not work well - or at least as well as you can expect given the surface area and whether or not there's enough sunlight. That's why nobody bothers with building them into devices. Besides you can buy little external solar chargers for real cheap. And the external ones are better than the ones built into the devices because you can angle them, and they aren't a failure point you need to worry about (that is, if they die, your device doesn't need to be replaced), and aren't limited to device size. Also, I don't know why you would want your electronics exposed to direct sunlight... Heat is not good for electronics.

Again, I support low-power, energy efficient devices. There is a very real use case for them, and not just for the developing world. But these gimmicks, like building in solar panels into the device, are dumb.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by aj3 on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:03AM (#26861798)
I am married to a teacher and can assure you that even in 'the West' there are kids without personal smartphone and without a single computer/tablet at home.

No idea whether heat aspect is worked around in OLPC somehow by carefully selecting materials used or whatever, my point is that making these laptops self-sufficient would indeed be useful (if at all possible).

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by initramfs on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:54PM (#26868772)
Definitely agree. There is a profit incentive to make laptops powerful but there is very little competition at the low end, unfortunately. I solar powered a microcontroller in indoor light just to prove that powering a computer is possible (96mhz is far more capable than even some early 486 PCs that ran Windows) , and not just a calculator. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ztj_MDNRcI

of course, powering a screen would require much more light, but it's not impossible if there was a full system re-development - from low power monochrome displays to light peripherals. Our group hopes to get a terminal to display on an e-ink, which seems doable: https://forum.ei2030.org/t/paperterm-project-definition-and-...

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by userbinator on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:35AM (#26862571)
Also, I don't know why you would want your electronics exposed to direct sunlight... Heat is not good for electronics.

Also UV. It'll destroy plastics rather quickly.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by freeone3000 on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:15AM (#26863639)
Give them a laptop and put the solar panel on the side? Even in the exact case you're mentioning, they're better as separate devices. (It wasn't done this way because the solar panel would be used for other purposes, but treating the user as hostile is the clearest sign that something has gone terribly wrong in your design process.)
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by lostphilosopher on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:40AM (#26861594)
10+ years ago I had a laptop case with solar panels and an outlet. It worked well; could both extend the battery life and charge when not in use. Not mediocre, and I imagine things have improved? There may be better solutions for low grid envs, but this one is viable.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by gandalfian on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:21AM (#26861917)
30 years ago I had a credit card calculator powered by a solar panel. Ideal pairing. Viewable screen in direct sunlight too thinking about it.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by numpad0 on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:54AM (#26862190)
It’s interesting that electronic calculators are basically the only type of devices ever to have successfully powered by integral solar panels.

There are some electronic price tag products, wireless keyboards, decorative keychain tags, etc. that could work on solar only, but even those are rare.

e: Forgot digital wristwatches. They seem to work fine.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by csharptwdec19 on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:43AM (#26863263)
> wireless keyboards

I really like the Logitech K700 solar keyboards, with two caveats:

- In a couple of mine, the included battery seems to have lost the ability to keep a charge well before you would expect (i.e. a year). This is a bit of an annoyance in that it is a rechargable button cell, not your run of the mill AA/AAA sized NIMH/Lithium bit.

- The build quality on these as far as sturdiness/etc isn't great. And if it ever gets 'flexed' too much, you wind up with broken traces internally, leading to issues where the juice doesn't flow one way or another unless you flex it back in the right way.

I love them in the office, but at home they just don't handle the use of clumsy roommates.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by AshamedCaptain on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:25AM (#26863075)
And it's pretty simple to figure out why it's so for electronic calculators. I had one of these, a modern-ish one though, except that the solar panel was defective and never actually worked. I only noticed after 3 years of use. That's how much the builtin _half-discharged_ coin battery would last... and how useless the solar panel actually is... I would even guess they only put in the solar panel for the look.

You could probably power such a calculator from ambient radiowaves, using a galena crystal...

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by frosted-flakes on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:13PM (#26864415)
A lot of basic solar-powered calculators don't have batteries at all. Covering the solar panel will shut it off.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by kn0where on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:00PM (#26865064)
And a lot of cheap calculators don’t even have real solar cells: https://youtu.be/uLTDuGhqE2w
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by AshamedCaptain on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:43PM (#26865742)
Yeah, what I mean (and has been better put elsewhere) is that the consumption of your average calculator is so low as to be practically negligible (<1mW?), otherwise capable of running for years on a depleted battery. Which is why they may work from such a small solar panel, but at the same time it says nothing about the solar panel itself.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by drewzero1 on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:17PM (#26865331)
I was going to mention watches! I love my Casio Tough Solar and wore it daily for five years. It never reported a charge level less than 'High'. If it didn't say on the box that it was solar, the only thing I would have noticed is that the battery never seemed to run down.

The solar charging is probably the biggest feature I'm missing in my smartwatch, but at least it has a (low-power, daylight-readable, always-on) transflective screen.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by jschwartzi on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:22PM (#26865416)
One of the really high-end Garmin watches have solar charging: https://buy.garmin.com/en-US/US/p/641375

According to their docs it increases the battery life by up to 3 days when you're not using the GPS.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by drewzero1 on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:41PM (#26865723)
Good to know, thanks! The price is a bit more than I can justify at the moment though, you weren't kidding about the high-end part. That's worth more than my car!
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by macspoofing on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:05PM (#26864309)
>It’s interesting that electronic calculators are basically the only type of devices ever to have successfully powered by integral solar panels.

Because they are ultra-low powered devices. If tiny solar cells can power that kind of device, then it can also be powered through kinetic energy (i.e. user's movement) as well ... Or you could spend $5 and put a standard watch-type battery in there which will last you years. So even there solar panels are a bit gimmicky. But ok, do whatever you like.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by frosted-flakes on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:20PM (#26864505)
On a larger scale, there are a lot of flashing LED road signs or radar speed warning signs that aren't connected to the grid. Instead, they are powered by a small solar panel with a battery for at night. Even simple stop signs on wooden 4x4 posts have these.

At least in my area, the speed warning signs tend to get moved to a different location a couple of times a year, and not having to run any wiring probably makes that significantly easier.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by lixtra on Monday April 19, 2021 @03:29PM (#26866965)
Solar powered parking meters seem to be another example.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Renaud on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:40AM (#26862055)
Calculators need mere microwatts of power to function. A very basic laptop is in the tens of watts.

A difference of many orders of magnitude that you can't compensate by the size of solar panel on a small device.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by supermatt on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:53AM (#26862765)
> A very basic laptop is in the tens of watts

The latest version device in question (the OLPC) is ~5W under normal usage and less than 1W when idle.

Im not sure about an integrated solar panel - im not sure i would want to keep my laptop exposed to the sun - but i was able to keep a 2015 macbook charged with a small solar panel while travelling (approx 4 hours a day of heavy usage).

Obv depends on time of year, location, weather, etc.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by AshamedCaptain on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:06AM (#26863535)
But even 1W is several orders of magnitude greater than the average LCD calculator.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by macspoofing on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:45AM (#26861647)
>10+ years ago I had a laptop case with solar panels and an outlet.

Do you think they would work better if they were built into the laptop screen? Because that's what OP was raving about.

You can get batteries and external solar chargers (they are cheap and come in any size you want) if that's what you want to do. Building them into the device is STUPID. For one thing, you would need to put your device in direct sunlight to charge them ... and heat is not good for electronics. Also, the solar array size will be limited to whatever size your device is, that is: "too small".

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by naikrovek on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:16PM (#26865316)
man, you've got some bones to pick with solar power, don't you?
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by macspoofing on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:42PM (#26865738)
No. I think it's a perfectly fine technology ... but it isn't a panacea and it doesn't make sense for everything that people are trying to cram it into. Case in point, attaching solar panels to a smart phone or a laptop screen. I've conceded (somewhat) that if you really want to, it makes far more sense to get external panels and just plug them in.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by goldenCeasar on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:07AM (#26861331)
Many places in my country have no access or reliable access to the grid and kids have to walk many miles to go to school, in this pandemic with the remote schooling this made millions of kids to miss classes or even leave school.

I can think something like this would be very useful for these kids as chargers and solar panels wouldn't last long in the hand of childrens.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by goodpoint on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:04AM (#26862281)
> Why do stupid gimmicks like this?

This are very harsh words. Do you have evidence to back the claim that the designer did not do proper research?

Perhaps they had reasons to believe that a self-contained device would survive being handled by children, while an external panel would get lost or broken.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by ant6n on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:10AM (#26861347)
Fewer moving parts? How much power does a low powered laptop need while in transflective mode? How much power does a solar panel produce that’s not facing the Sun?

One could cover the front and back of the screen panel on solar panels this way, if it could create a device that’s mostly independent from a grid or extra gadgets to plug in it could be nice. But yeah, maybe an external little solar array would be more flexible.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by macspoofing on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:30AM (#26861507)
>How much power does a solar panel produce that’s not facing the Sun?

Nothing.

>But yeah, maybe an external little solar array would be more flexible.

And those little solar mats are mediocre at best. They just don't work very well. They take forever to charge and require strong direct sunlight. But hey, if you want to use them, go ahead. They are still better than having them built into the device.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by ant6n on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:49AM (#26862725)
So it appears modern smartphones have a power consumption of about a Watt (see cousin post). Assuming a transflective display, that laptop could use a similar amount of power. Assuming a 20cm x 30cm charge area and 1000Watt/m2, you need to only capture 1.7% of the energy of the directly incident sunlight [1]. Or assuming your panel has 10% effiency, you need to get 17% of direct sun light light onto the surface. Thats a fair allowance for clouds and weird angles and whatnot.

     [1] 1W / (20cm*30cm*1000 W/m^2)*
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Semaphor on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:31AM (#26861992)
At a metal-festival in Northern Germany I was at in 2019, there was a guy with a 1-2m² solar mat. It was enough to charge his phone and play music. Doesn’t seem too horrible.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by einpoklum on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:36AM (#26862024)
If you have non-utilized surface area / volume in the screen part of your laptop, why not put solar panels in there? Yes, their reception might not be optimal due to angling constraints, but if they're light enough, they might still be useful to have. So you don't know for a fact that it's a gimmick.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by gentleman11 on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:59PM (#26865970)
Brain computer interfaces will be life changing for about 1% of users, but unbelievably invasive for the rest after Facebook etc gets on board (possibly via oculus?)
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by atrus on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:00AM (#26860921)
e-ink displays and 3d printing have both convinced me that patents do more harm than good these days.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by robinsoh on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:06AM (#26862887)
> e-ink displays and 3d printing have both convinced me that patents do more harm than good these days.

I work in the display industry. Not for E Ink. But I have no idea what you're talking about. I see this claim about patents on e-ink repeated again and again. I don't know much about 3d printing so I can't confirm. But each time I've seen this patent claim about e-ink, I ask the poster/commenter what specific patent or patents or data they're talking about and thus far every single time they either go silent or get defensive or in rare occasions acknowledge they didn't know about it and just "felt" it was the case. So could you help me out and explain what data convinced you? You can see my comment history to see all my attempts to try to get at what is the actual truth.

FYI, in my experience in the display industry, the main driver of price at scale is the asymptotic cost of components and materials like TFT backplanes, glue, passive layers, coatings, Indium Tin Oxide. Low volumes are what all of E Inks displays except the ones made for Amazon. That matches up with what I see in the prices.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by dmwallin on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:23PM (#26867548)
This gets into a chicken and egg argument. You are arguing that the level of demand is leading to the current price point, while complainers about E Ink argue that anti competitive practices lead to higher prices which results in a lower demand.

In a competitive market, both are actually true. The fact that there aren't really any major competitors to E Ink in that market indicates however that there probably is some sort of moat (whether it is IP, or otherwise)and that prices are likely higher than they would be in a more competitive market. There are a lot of signs that there is latent demand in the market and lowered prices would lead to an increase in total market volume.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by robinsoh on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @12:31PM (#26876928)
> The fact that there aren't really any major competitors to E Ink in that market indicates however that there probably is some sort of moat (whether it is IP, or otherwise)and that prices are likely higher than they would be in a more competitive market.

I don't know what exactly you mean in the context of the display industry. What do you mean there aren't any major competitors to E Ink? There's tonnes of display products from lots of different vendors. Are you talking about the electrophoretic display industry specifically? If so, then even there there's competitors like ClearInk but its a niche space with low volumes. FYI, the volumes that E Ink reaches even for what is considered "high volume" by them would be considered unacceptably low volume by LCD manufacturers. Ask yourself a simple question. Are you as a VC going to invest a billion into scaling up an electrophoretic display tech startup that may take 10-30 years or would you rather pump that same money into another internet services? Even Amazon pumped billions into Liquavista and then pulled the plug on it after not being able to scale within the time frame Jeff had given them.

> that prices are likely higher than they would be in a more competitive market.

But how are you substantiating that? Do you have awareness of the costs of materials for electrophoretic panels? Are you aware of yield rates? I actually work in the display industry and I have no actual data on that and I would never be able to estimate even order of magnitude cost without knowing those key numbers. So how are you doing making that price estimation? Your claim is equivalent of looking at a sports car market and saying Ferraris would be cheaper if there were more competitors. I hope my explanation is clear enough to convince you of the fundamental flaws in the arguments being made claiming there is "some sort of moat".

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by mensetmanusman on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:45PM (#26866488)
Are you in the US? Is there a display industry in the US for getting backplanes?
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by aeyes on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:42PM (#26864800)
This article has a lot of information about the Pixel Qi patents in the last section: https://goodereader.com/blog/electronic-readers/the-rise-and...

Money Quote: "The Pixel QI license was picked up by John Gilmore, activist, philanthropist, and founder of the Electronic Frontier Foundation. He has released the patents under the Defensive Patent License."

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by AshamedCaptain on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:57AM (#26862811)
WHAT patents. ALL these technologies are about 40 years old. There are even mentions in this thread of the Game Boy / Color since they use very similar stuff.

There are few if any patents involved here -- the problem is that there is just no demand. The moment you show someone the flashy backlighted screen he will go for it 100% of the time and ditch everything else (think: there's a reason people "upgrade" their GameBoyAdvance's to a backlight).

Perhaps if you made a storefront directly illuminated by heavy sunlight...

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by monocasa on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:17PM (#26864464)
The gameboy (and GBC) screens are very different. They're normal LCD screens with a reflective and scattering layer behind them instead of a backlight. E-ink's technology doesn't apply to them.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by AshamedCaptain on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:44PM (#26865771)
Sorry for the confusion, I (as well as the rest of the people who mention it) mean (reflective) LCD overall (since the article is also incorrectly using "e-Ink" ).
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by monocasa on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:59PM (#26865974)
Ah, ok. That probably would have been clear to me if I had given your statements the benefit of the strongest argument you could be making. My bad, that's totally on me.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by zokier on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:50PM (#26866550)
The primary e ink patents also have already expired, they are from late 90s: https://patents.google.com/patent/US5930026
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by monocasa on Monday April 19, 2021 @03:27PM (#26866939)
That is _a_ patent, which is expired, but not the only patent, or the lynchpin of IP keeping people from independently making e-ink style screens.

I generally have rule about being courteous to our fellow HNers and not doing something that could be cited as evidence of willful infringement (and triple damages), but I'll forgo it in this one case with the disclaimer I'll have around it in order to help dispel the rumors going around here that somehow patents aren't at issue. There are also other patents.

= = = = = = A C T I V E P A T E N T = = = = = =

Do not look at this patent if you work in the space of computer display technology.

https://patents.google.com/patent/US9075280B2/en

= = = = = = A C T I V E P A T E N T = = = = = =

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Qwertious on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:03PM (#26865112)
E-ink displays being held back by patents is a myth. Please either provide a source or edit your comment.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by epakai on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:31PM (#26869412)
Why? The patent space around e ink is dominated by e ink corp over the last two decades. They're working on better driving methods, color displays, and new material compositions. Anybody entering this field is looking at licensing (expensive if current e ink prices are anything to go by) or navigating all of these recent patents to produce something competitive (good refresh rates, high contrast or color).

Starting in 2002 they've done lots just based on these citations of an early patent: https://patents.google.com/patent/US5930026#citedBy

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Qwertious on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:37PM (#26870148)
>Anybody entering this field is looking at licensing (expensive if current e ink prices are anything to go by)

No, that's a result of low economy of scale. LCDs have a massive market, whereas e.g. big e-ink screens have such a small market they're hand-fitted. You're presupposing your conclusion.

I'm not disputing patents exist. I'm disputing whether they have a noticeable detrimental effect on the e-ink market.

I mean, ARM has a licensing fee (of 1c per CPU), but nobody sane would blame that fee for x86 beating ARM in the desktop world.

>The patent space around e ink is dominated by e ink corp over the last two decades.

I'm not sure what your point here is. Yes, they're putting a ton of money into e-ink R&D. They're patenting everything they come up with, because that's how you monetize your R&D so it's not immediately copied by your competitors without seeing a cent of benefit.

There are companies who have developed alternatives, such as Mirasol. That never took off, despite not needing any e-ink patents. This suggests that e-ink is sufficiently better than all alternatives that it's worth the patent cost - either because those alternatives were impractical, or because the patent fees for e-ink just weren't particularly cumbersome in the first place and the real problem lies elsewhere.

Which brings us back to the central issue:

Do you have any evidence that patents are actually causing problems in the real world, besides "patents exist, problems exist, one must be causing the other"?

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by make3 on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:55PM (#26869580)
patents give motivation to companies to invest in research. without patents you possibly would have neither of those things.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by fortran77 on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:38AM (#26862598)
3D printers -- both resin and filament-- are everywhere and cheap today.

And there are many great affordable devices with e-Ink--I have several Amazon ebook readers that I use every day.

I'm not sure I was harmed by any patent.

Many of the things we talk about on Hacker News are covered by patents. Why do you want to shred a piece of the U.S. Constitution (assuming you're talking about U.S. patents) over eInk?

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Miraste on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:19AM (#26863709)
I believe that was GP's point - 3D printers are cheap and ubiquitous because a patent on them expired in 2009. Before that they were expensive and had little tooling or support: useless outside large corporations, despite all the technology involved existing for years and years. I don't know the patent situation of e-ink but patent law was incredibly counterproductive in the case of 3D printing.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Qwertious on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:22PM (#26865422)
3D printers aside (I don't know enough to comment), literally everyone I've seen who claims e-ink is held back by patents is either 1) speculating or 2) repeating hearsay and can't provide a source.

Regardless of the issues with patents in general, in the specific context of e-ink it's an unsubstantiated myth until someone provides some hard evidence.

E-ink patent speculation is especially problematic because everyone on HN agrees that patents are a problem, so it sounds truthy and people want to repeat it as an example of the evils of patents.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by fortran77 on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:07PM (#26866076)
Everytime "e-ink" comes up here in any context, we see people doing a hit-and-run post about patents, with nothing to back it up. I'm wondering what the real agenda is here. Is there some competitor trying to do some sort of astroturfing?
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Teever on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:22PM (#26869362)
Is it every time? It is something that I've only noticed about e-ink posts in the last two months or so. Prior to that I've always wondered why they were so expensive. The posts that I've seen regarding e-ink and patents seem to be very persuasive.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Qwertious on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:12PM (#26870304)
>The posts that I've seen regarding e-ink and patents seem to be very persuasive.

Have you seen any comment that provides actual evidence of causality between e-ink's failure to take off and patent encumberment?

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by dmwallin on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:37PM (#26867706)
What competitors?
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by zokier on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:58PM (#26866628)
its just a meme, and people are bitter because they love the concept of cool eink gadgets that never materialized so they want to have some scapegoat.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by zokier on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:56PM (#26866605)
But things turned out pretty well in the end? That is the whole point of patents: they expire. You say the tech existing for years and years, but few years is very short time, even 20 years is not that long time. Just need a bit of patience.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by robinsoh on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:55AM (#26864195)
> patent law was incredibly counterproductive in the case of 3D printing.

I don't work in the 3d printing industry so I don't have enough knowledge to know that with any level of confidence. It sounds plausible but not sure if it is true. That's why, I am curious whether you do, ie: do you work in the 3d printing industry? How confident are you that the recent proliferation was due to an expiration of a counterproductive patent (which one?) rather than just technologies, volume, demand, industrial production finally coming together and becoming mass market? Has there been any actual detailed analysis or study proving this? The reason I ask is not because I am opposed to the claim, rather I often see unsubstantiated claims like this go unchallenged for a long time. In the case of E Ink, I even saw someone blog that statement and they cited an HN comment about E Ink patents that I had challenged and the poster never responded, and then someone cited that very blog post in another HN comments so it became a circle of references where all the dots on the circle are unsubstantiated.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by monocasa on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:30PM (#26864646)
The lynch pin FDM patent was 5,121,329 which expired in 2009; there were similar later patents in the space around SLA printing that expired in the five years following that. There's been plenty of analysis both from industry and academia that it was indeed holding back the proliferation of 3D printing technology.

Being in a adjacent field of other robotic control that utilized 3d printing for our own prototyping before and after the proliferation I can also confirm the patent licensing being a major impediment to proliferation of the technology. We had high enough margins that we could spend $100k on a 3d printer before 2009. But the field has been revolutionized since then from the democratization and even our own processes changed heavily once we could have a bank of printers rather than just one. Sort of like the change of a a company sharing a mainframe with a guy dedicated to keeping it going versus ubiquitous microcomputers.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Miraste on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:46PM (#26864863)
I'm not in the industry, just a hobbyist, but this is well established. There are dozens of companies making printers, filament, models, tutorials, software, and innovations that legally couldn't exist while this patent was active. Universities, makerspaces, and small to medium sized businesses (and hobbyists) didn't have access to the tech because of it.

Here is the patent in question: https://patents.google.com/patent/US5121329A/en

And here's a short explanation of the impact: https://creax.com/insights/the-influence-of-patents-on-3d-pr...

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by robinsoh on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @12:44PM (#26877109)
> And here's a short explanation of the impact: https://creax.com/insights/the-influence-of-patents-on-3d-pr...

I read the article and came away unsatisfied. I was hoping to see a clear analysis like "here's an inventor who was blocked from producing his product by a patent infringement lawsuit" and here's a series of patent infringement lawsuits that blocked inventors from innovating. Instead I felt the main points were broken due to contradictory statements in the article.

They started with: "Commercialising these kits was actually an infringement on Stratasys’ patent but Stratasys did not stop this from happening."

Which contradicts: "Everything changed by the end of 2009, the expiration date of the famous Stratasys’ patent after 20 years."

I see that Reprap was commercialized in 2006 prior to the patent expiring which clearly contradicts above as well.

There's limited factual data in this article. Claims like "Everything changed" seem like strong claims that ought to be substantiated rather than defended using "feels right" kind of explanations.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Miraste on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @03:22PM (#26894251)
I don't think the level of proof you're looking for exists. There weren't any lawsuits because nobody started companies because they knew they'd be sued out of existence. I can tell you that Stratasys was aware of and leaning on the (open-source, non-commercialized) RepRap project at the time:

https://reprap.org/forum/read.php?1,13528

and that they're more than willing to sue small companies, even after their main patents expired:

https://3dprintingindustry.com/news/stratasys-lands-blow-in-...

They eventually settled that suit because the patents involved were a bit weak, but I doubt they would've settled if the earlier ones were still in force.

I don't know where you saw that RepRap was commercialized in 2006 but as far as I know that's not true. Here's a history of the project by its creators which puts the first RepRap-based company in 2009: https://all3dp.com/history-of-the-reprap-project/

You could probably buy pieces on forums before that but Stratasys wouldn't target individual forum posters with runs in the single digits.

Makerbot, Prusa, Creality, FormLabs, and the other big names in small-scale 3d printing are all post-2009 companies. Here are some more recent examples of patents blocking 3d printing: https://techcrunch.com/2016/05/15/how-expiring-patents-are-u...

The SLA (liquid) section is the most relevant; it mentions how FormLabs lost a lawsuit for building one early. Other companies didn't attempt to beat the patent, but Prusa, Creality, and Makerbot (ironically now owned by Stratasys) all began selling SLA printers shortly after the patent expired. I don't have statements from the executives that they waited because of patent issues, but barring that the situation seems clear.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by fortran77 on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:10PM (#26866122)
Exactly. I have two low-cost (Prusa) 3d printers going in my office lab right now. It wasn't until recently that technology, software, and infrastructure for filament and SLA supplies lined up to allow the current "explosion".

In the early days, Stratasys and others really did "invent" significant things in the classic sense of the word. We're not talking about "one click purchase" patents here. Allowing them exclusive use of their invention for a couple of decades didn't seem to hurt anyone.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Miraste on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:50PM (#26867814)
Cheap SLA printers couldn't have happened until recently because of the screens, but there's nothing in FDM printers that wasn't available in the 90s. Sure it didn't "hurt anyone," people don't need 3D printers, but it stopped a whole subfield of engineering from existing for twenty years. Personally I call that detrimental.

At least it's not as bad as the other IP protections. If the lawyers who brought us copyright law had gotten into patents, we'd be eagerly anticipating the launch of the consumer television.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by fortran77 on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:32PM (#26869422)
Nothing? What about the cheap and powerful single board controllers?
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by Miraste on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:08PM (#26869679)
You'd think so, and some printers like the Prusa Mini use newer 32-bit controllers, but a lot of the most popular models (other Prusas, most Creality models, etc.) use the ATmega 2560, which is an 8 bit controller that came out in 2006 and isn't much different from what was available in the late 90s. They didn't exist in 1989, but they weren't far off.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by monocasa on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @01:07AM (#26870894)
Oh, we for sure had 8 bit microcontroller chips in 1989. A quick look back through old editions of Radio Electronics looks like you could buy an 8039[0] in 1989 for $1.95 qty 1. PICs were pretty nice back then too.

[0] - An 8039 is a version of the 8048 that was in the original PC keyboard, but rigged up with an external EEPROM for program code instead of the normal mask ROM. They were probably secretly 8048s that were programmed with some other customer's code in the mask ROM, but then fused off for whatever reason.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by hakfoo on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:00PM (#26870243)
Even if you didn't have a free-standing cheap microcontroller, couldn't you do a "Winmodem" style scenario where the printer is a bag of dumb mechanical bits tethered to a PC doing all the heavy lifting in software?
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by rasz on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @01:39PM (#26877825)
You will like 1987 Atari SLM605/SLM804 Laser printers. They had no electronics inside other than the power supply. Instead a dongle was shipped with 19pin Atari ST DMA port (ASCI, very similar to SCSI) on one end, and 37 pin connector for the printer on the other. It contained two microcontrollers, Intel 8253 timer chip, Toshiba TC9142P dedicated Direct Drive Turntable motor controller :), bunch of buffers and some chips I cant identify.

https://manualzz.com/doc/7345398/atari-slm804-service-manual...

Unlike all the other printers up to late nineties there was no high level computing smarts neither in the printer nor in the dongle. It was a Software Defined printer fully controlled by Atari ST (computer UI froze during printing to maintain tight timings), just like post year 2000 HP LaserJet 1000 and later Windows "host based" non PCL printers. As a result of this Atari ingenuity you ended up with a combo of Atari ST computer, 640×[email protected] Hz monitor, DTP software (for example Calamus) and a Laser printer costing less than just the Apple or IBM laser printer alone, and as a bonus it printed 2-3 times faster.

So yes, 3D FDM printer at reasonable price was totally possible in late eighties leveraging cheap 16bit computers for control logic.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by xioxox on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:31AM (#26861107)
I have a Toshiba R500 - it's a machine ahead of its time - transreflective display, SSD, very light, long battery life, nice keyboard. Unfortunately the CPU and memory are limited, otherwise I would be using it today.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by black_puppydog on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:08AM (#26862326)
Would you be willing to part with it and ship it to the EU? :) I've been hunting on ebay for these every now and again, but I'm not quite desperate enough to piece one together from the parts I can find.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by macawfish on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:54AM (#26862779)
Well and there are large, high resolution full color transflective displays out there! It's really frustrating that these aren't available. My mental health would improve substantially if it were easier to work outside.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by ohazi on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:33PM (#26865581)
Availability is also one of the principal problems with e-Ink, and is directly related to the patent issue. It is next to impossible to source e-Ink displays (even at outrageous prices), or to work with E Ink corporation in any capacity unless you are huge and are in a market they are interested in. Making another generic ebook and can credibly claim that you might sell half a million? Maybe they'll talk to you. Work for Lenovo and want to put an e-Ink layer in a trackpad? "We're not pursuing that market segment at this time." It's not an open market, and they haven't been interested in moving beyond ebook readers for the last decade.

Smaller designers who want access to the technology can't get it from a western company, because none are stupid enough to attempt to design a competitor while E Ink the company is still around to sue them.

Fairly recently we've started to see Chinese electrophoretic displays crop up, and I can actually get a devkit or buy them by the low thousand, because E Ink isn't going to be able to sue them in China. But you still don't see them designed into very many products sold in the west, because it would be easy for E Ink to stop the end product from being sold.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by macawfish on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:14PM (#26869305)
Transflective displays are different from e-ink though, I believe the term usually refers to liquid crystal displays:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transflective_liquid-crystal_d...

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by wjdp on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:35PM (#26867674)
If nobody can buy these displays, who is keeping the E Ink corporation in business?
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by varispeed on Monday April 19, 2021 @03:28PM (#26866954)
What is preventing someone from creating a display with the same concept as e-ink? This is not a new technology and the idea has been around since 70s.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by UI_at_80x24 on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:53AM (#26862761)
In my experience the Palm Pilot Pro had the best view-ability of any electronic device (GameBoy being a close second) in (outdoor) full sunlight.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by comboy on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:43AM (#26862083)
The title is very misleading, these are not even comparable.

Btw, why aren't transflective displays more poplar? They doesn't seem as technologically challenging as e-ink and there clearly is some market for rugged phones/laptops/tablets. It seems they would be a perfect fit for some construction site type of uses.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by rbanffy on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:38AM (#26861161)
Yeah... The e-ink, combined with 30fps is very misleading. I guess most people would immediately know what it is with the PixelQi name.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by ChrisClark on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:58AM (#26864231)
I really loved my Dell Axim long, long ago. Specifically because of the transflective display. The Ipaqs were only reflective, great in sunlight but needed a front light panel over the screen for use indoors, not always evenly lit. The transflective seemed to be the best of both worlds, reflective in sunlight and backlit for a more even light.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by emteycz on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:49AM (#26863338)
Patents aren't part of the market, it's regulation.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by black_puppydog on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:08AM (#26863556)
That's actually the fairest point of critique about my rambling that I've heard in a while, and I have been rambling about this since 2012. :D

That being said, the Toshiba Portege showed that a big manufacturer can produce these at scale if they want to, and they haven't continued with it. If someone here is willing to share stories from the trenches if that particular battle ground, I'm all ears. :)

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by dannyw on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:54AM (#26864177)
I really want this now. I'd pay $2k in a heartbeat.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by guffaw5 on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:56AM (#26864212)
The creator posted on reddit [0] that they are exploring making these commercially available (in small quantities). Maybe you could reach out and get one?

[0] https://old.reddit.com/r/thinkpad/comments/mtf3hf/thinkpad_m...

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by rasz on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:59AM (#26864243)
There is an ebay link with 7 available right in the YT description
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by guffaw5 on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:50PM (#26867828)
Wow! 10 sold for ~$600 each!
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by cfjgvjh on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:05PM (#26868842)
Considering how expensive E-ink based products are, I'm not really surprised that it sold.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by rasz on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @04:28AM (#26872125)
Its not e-ink. It a ~$110 transreflective screen mounted into ~$200 laptop using $50 converter, laser cut bezel and some ingenuity.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by krupan on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:54PM (#26864984)
Thank you for this link. The discussion there on reddit is, sadly, way better than the one here.

Hacker News, RTFA before you comment. Don't comment if you don't really know what you are talking about. Please.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by mtgx on Monday April 19, 2021 @05:58AM (#26860912)
Qualcomm has had this tech for about a decade, but failed to commercialize/improve on it:

https://www.theverge.com/2012/7/23/3178117/qualcomm-mirasol-...

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by fractallyte on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:15AM (#26861879)
It belongs to Apple now...

(https://appleinsider.com/articles/15/12/15/apple-has-taken-o...)

And Mirasol is a different technology than Pixel Qi.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by chrisjc on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:27AM (#26863088)
Wow, I had no idea about this even though I was somewhat following the 'e-ink' technologies quite closely.

An ipad with a colored 'e-ink'/LED hybrid screen would be such a perfect tablet in my opinion (even though I've never owned an ipad).

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by bigfudge on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:43PM (#26865750)
It would require a major iOS re-write though. Designing for e-ink is a really different paradigm, both statically and in relation to UX interactions. I just returned an onyx boox note because although the hardware was quite nice, the UI was just garbage. I'm sure Apple could do it, but it does't seem very on-brand for them. I'm waiting of a delivery of an RM2, but I'm still not that hopeful that they have solved the problem of reading an A4 academic PDF. Yet another reason to kill off the commercial academic publishing industry — we can get proper epubs of papers!
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by mbar84 on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:22AM (#26861442)
Please be aware that "market failure" is also a technical term in economics, relating to positive and negative externalities. Your use appears to be the (by now probably dominant) colloquial use.

I personally would not use this term, just as I would not use e.g. "to beg the question". I wonder if this phenomenon has a name, along the lines of "euphemistic treadmill".

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by selfhoster11 on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:53AM (#26863384)
> I personally would not use this term, just as I would not use e.g. "to beg the question". I wonder if this phenomenon has a name, along the lines of "euphemistic treadmill".

I intentionally use "beg the question" with the new meaning to do my part in cycling out the old meaning as quickly as possible. The "old" meaning is a waste of precious linguistic bandwidth, spent on a concept that is very rarely invoked (and could be just as easily invoked with something like "presupposes the facts", which is more intuitive).

If language is dynamic, then braindead vestigials should be bulldozed out with prejudice, especially when they tie up prime real estate.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by mbar84 on Monday April 19, 2021 @05:34PM (#26868199)
If a term is overloaded, and if the purpose of language is to communicate, then I think the better approach is to drop the term as a lost cause and switch to alternatives for both uses, rather than fight and endless battle. For the two meanings I use "raises the question" and "circular reasoning" or "the conclusion was already part of your original assumption".
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by balefrost on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:29AM (#26863829)
If you're after intuitive language, why not use "raises the question" or "leads to the question" instead?
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by black_puppydog on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:54AM (#26861720)
I use "market failure" colloquially I guess, yes.

I use it to mean that despite demonstrated technological viability by multiple vendors, and despite the devices providing a solution to the issue of actual portability beyond closed rooms, the market has failed to make these devices accessible.

IIRC one of the problems is that the benefit doesn't become obvious in "good" lighting conditions like a walmart building. In that way I'm putting much of the blame in this on the buying side of the market for making shallow, lazy buying decisions. But the producers are equally to blame here. Nobody made a serious first move, so no competition evolved, despite the availability of transflectives being technically governed by market forces.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by mbar84 on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:10AM (#26861846)
I don't know enough to judge the root cause. My ideological priors would make me look to blame the government granted monopoly patents on the display tech.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by emteycz on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:58AM (#26863436)
Then I'd suggest to use another term, e.g. just failure.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by goodpoint on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:16AM (#26862390)
"market failure" has various interpretations and objections:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_failure

The way black_puppydog used it fits the term quite well.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by mbar84 on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:01PM (#26868394)
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/marketfailure.asp

> A market failure occurs whenever the individuals in a group end up worse off than if they had not acted in perfectly rational self-interest. Such a group either incurs too many costs or receives too few benefits.

> Even though the concept seems simple, it can be misleading and easy to misidentify.

> Contrary to what the name implies, market failure does not describe inherent imperfections in the market economy

> Additionally, not every bad outcome from market activity counts as a market failure.

As I say, I think he's using it in a very much more colloquial manner: "I don't like the outcome of the market process", which is fine.

Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by psychometry on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:09AM (#26862919)
Everyone who's tried to fight a war against language change has lost.
Re:Thinkpad X230 with “e-Ink” display at 30fps [video] by mbar84 on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:10PM (#26868467)
Very true and for different terms we all are on battlefields waging a war that we mostly are not even aware we're in. As part of the mob, we just steadily walk over the minority who coined the term and plow them ever deeper into the muddy ground. Such is life... and death.

I still find it worthwhile to point out when somebody uses a jargon term from an academic discipline, so they maybe can leave the battlefield and its senseless slaughter and instead and chose some other formulation.