News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by NortySpock on Friday March 05, 2021 @01:50PM (#26360425)
"Commonwealth Fusion Systems announced today that later this year it will start to build its first test reactor, dubbed SPARC, in a new facility in Devens, Massachusetts, not far from its current base in Cambridge. The company says the reactor, which would be the first in the world to produce more energy than is needed to run the reaction, could fire up as soon as 2025."

The key takeaway, for those skimming.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by Sniffnoy on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:40PM (#26361122)
Worth noting, though it's not in the article, that they're aiming for a commerical version (ARC) in 2030.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by rbanffy on Friday March 05, 2021 @01:53PM (#26360458)
I wish this SPARC better luck than the CPUs.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by ape4 on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:07PM (#26361393)
Of course, they were from Sun - the sun does fusion.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by jsharf on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:54PM (#26361966)
haha this gave me a chuckle. underrated comment.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by reaperducer on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:57PM (#26361311)
I wonder if the facility will be called a SPARCstation.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by ksec on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:32PM (#26361043)
A Micro Fusion system SPARC which is similarly named to the CPU from Sun Micro-System.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by mbgerring on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:11PM (#26360791)
You mean to say that fusion is only 5 years away? Amazing!
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by maxcan on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:41PM (#26361138)
5 years away and always will be is a 4x improvement over the previous 20 years away and always will be!
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by Iv on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:49PM (#26361221)
People love to joke about it but I remember 20 years ago, the joke was about it being 40 years away.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by wlesieutre on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:53PM (#26361254)
In SimCity 2000 it didn’t show up until around 2050. Game was from 1993, so that was a 57 year prediction.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by SkyBelow on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:06PM (#26362111)
Given we know how long it has been 40 years away, 20 years away, and now 5 years away, we can estimate how long it will be until it is 0 years away. Unless it goes down by a power of 2 each time.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by coldpie on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:17PM (#26362242)
Zeno's fusion reactor
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by gweinberg on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:30PM (#26362375)
Well, 40 years ago it was 30 years away, so for a while it must have been going backwards.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by tambourine_man on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:49PM (#26361216)
Hopefully not like an asymptotic curve.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by mpalmer on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:46PM (#26361861)
5 minutes away and always will be.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by wolfi1 on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:47PM (#26361196)
fusion is the energy of the future and has been so for the last 50 years
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by willis936 on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:52PM (#26361246)
Just goes to show that something witty is good at convincing a ten year old that something false is true.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by temp0826 on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:22PM (#26361559)
I think it will happen. I mean, Duke Nukem’ Forever actually did eventually get released. Anything is possible!
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by api on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:43PM (#26361155)
Fusion research has been steadily progressing for many years. The "50 years away and always will" quip is baloney.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by dragonwriter on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:07PM (#26361397)
> Fusion research has been steadily progressing for many years. The “50 years away and always will” quip is baloney.

The upthread comment was 20, not 50, and I’ve heard 15 or 20 years away frequently since the 1980s and seen it in things dating back to the 1960s, so, no, its not baloney.

Nor does it necessarily mean that progress isn’t being made, its more of a comment that the unknown unknowns are being converted in known unknowns as fast as a known unknowns are being converted into known knowns.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by function_seven on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:47PM (#26361875)
Just got a new Mac. As I read your comment, my Migration Assistant is doing similar estimates. “13 minutes remaining” then “41 hours remaining” then back again.

It’s been whipsawing between these estimates for the last couple hours.

I think I now understand the state of fusion research.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by api on Friday March 05, 2021 @09:28PM (#26364682)
Think of it this way: how hard is it to estimate the time required for a software project? How successful are most such estimates?

We don't know how long it will take, but at the same time there is visible progress occurring on many fronts: understanding plasma behavior and how to control it, better superconducting magnets, better control systems, solutions to the neutron embrittlement problem, etc.

There's not going to be a single breakthrough... or rather the fusion breakthrough already occurred. We've already learned about fusion and how to trigger it. That happened in the early 20th century.

Instead of a single breakthrough it will be continued progress on all fronts until at some point everything matures enough that someone manages to build a proof of concept reactor. At that point investment will flood into the space because it will have been sufficiently de-risked.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by teachrdan on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:48PM (#26361208)
So how far away would you say we are now? Because I remember "10 years away" being said in earnest since back in the early 90s.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by api on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:59PM (#26361326)
I don't know, and I don't think anyone does. It depends on lots of things including funding and what other unknown unknowns there are on the tech/eng tree.

What I do know is that superconducting magnets have been getting cheaper, more powerful, and more compact for quite some time and that's one of the limiting factors on fusion reactor designs. I also know that there is no known physical barrier to net-positive fusion, only engineering barriers.

If I had to totally guess I'd say someone will show net-positive fusion for a brief period of time before 2030... assuming the funding is present. It will not be a fully viable power plant yet but a proof of concept. This will be followed by a huge bump in funding and a race to produce power plants.

... but that's a guess.

It's like asking "when will there be a human base on Mars?" We know it's possible and I think it will happen, but I don't know how long it will actually take. We could probably have one in 5 years if someone wanted to write a blank check.

I would bet that we could have a fusion PoC in 5 years if someone wrote a blank check and fully funded many different credible efforts.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by Ekaros on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:17PM (#26361489)
Fusion is a complicated thing. Even if we reach net positive energy generation before 2030. How much longer will mature power plant design take? Lets say something lasting at least 10 if not 20 years with reasonable maintenance(that is not replacing the whole thing every other year). Not to forget that nuclear plants can run 60 years.

And then comes questions of life-cycle energy inputs and costs. How long will it be to be net positive on these? That is we spend less energy on cooling the coolant for superconductors and overall building the thing.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by willis936 on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:19PM (#26362256)
There have been tokamak and stellarator fusion power plant studies published every few years for the past several decades. Answers to all of your questions and more are in them.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by tsimionescu on Saturday March 06, 2021 @02:13AM (#26365773)
Don't keep us guessing, what is the date these studies came up with?
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by willis936 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @06:07PM (#26380683)
When we decide to fund it.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by simonh on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:09PM (#26361416)
I'm pretty confident it will make it over the line into viability eventually, but it's a really tough problem and it is going to take decades. There's still a lot about the engineering required we just don't fully understand, and it will take a lot of tests and investigation on a lot of different fronts to make meaningful progress. So I agree, we're in it for the long haul on this one.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by pfdietz on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:23PM (#26362296)
Why are you confident it will be viable? Remember, commercial viability means not just that it works, but that it's better than any competitor. Why is it that fusion will win this competition? It's the nature of most technologies to fail in the face of something better.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by simonh on Saturday March 06, 2021 @01:09PM (#26369249)
It just a best estimate, there’s no way to be sure at this stage. Plenty of smart people think it will and plenty think that it won’t. I think there are so many different promising alternative approaches that hope to solve this problem, that on balance I’m not prepared to bet against every single one of them not panning out. It’s just a guess though.

I agree renewables might make it mostly moot, but there’s still the issue of base load. Storage might solve it, but if fusion can be made safe and cheap enough it could still have a niche.

Then there’s Mars and the belt. There’s no guarantee we’ll colonise it permanently, but if we do fusion could be really useful as it’s far enough out that solar is significantly less efficient. Also fusion reactors could be handy power plants for spacecraft. Cheap reusable heavy lift systems may make all of this feasible.

Finally, the future is a long, long time. If we don’t wipe ourselves out, eventually we will every technology that is viable will be achieved (not possible, viable).

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by runarberg on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:21PM (#26362952)
I was reading somewhere that the earliest point for commercial viability will be in the 2060s. By which point we can assume there have been build a lot of renewable energy infrastructure (or else the climate crisis is still in full effect; and I can’t really think about what kind of society will have evolved from that disaster). This should bring down the cost of renewables even more then today as economics of scales grow exponentially. Making the quest for comersial viability of fusion even tougher.

I honestly wonder if fusion will ever be commercially viable. And if all these experiments will simply lead up to us realizing that: “cool, so fusion power is possible on Earth. Now what should we do with it?”

But hey. Maybe it will be the energy of the future on Antarctica or the Moon or something instead.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by jonas21 on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:52PM (#26361947)
> I would bet that we could have a fusion PoC in 5 years if someone wrote a blank check and fully funded many different credible efforts.

If that's the case, then why hasn't anyone written that check? The potential profit from commercialized fusion seems enormous (unlike a mars base), and there doesn't seem to be a shortage of capital seeking large returns.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by dividedbyzero on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:19PM (#26362264)
I guess it would be a really really big blank check, and then you'd still have to get from a PoC to a commercially viable plant and convince the public it's not a hydrogen bomb and it's quite safe and then you'd have to outcompete renewables for decades to get a decent return while you miniaturize your device for use anywhere else than a stationary plant, and then someone starts making a paint with tiny organic solar cells in it and absurdly-efficient batteries and while you can still make a killing for niche applications, it's a pittance compared to your investment. I guess in the end both risks and upfront costs are just way too high to do things that way.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by willis936 on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:14PM (#26362199)
Few people have the ability to write the check.

Musk is the only one that even comes to mind, and he’s on the record saying he won’t touch turbulence.

Still, there is hope.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by cygx on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:19PM (#26361516)
Depends on the funding. The standard response to the 20 years away for 50 years quip is https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:U.S._historical_fusi...
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by tehjoker on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:49PM (#26361904)
Why do you think the funding has been so low?
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by willis936 on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:12PM (#26362186)
The investment prior to any payoff is significant. Few countries, or even groups of countries, have had the excess capital and idealistic interest to solve the problem.

Raegan gutted virtually every US program and refunding has only come back to things that are politically relevant. “That giant science machine that might one day make lots of heat” isn’t high on the “political value” list.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by tehjoker on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:26PM (#26362315)
There was a lot of juice back in the day for research priorities around aviation, nuclear weapons, etc but those were all things that were militarily significant.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by api on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:01PM (#26363368)
Eternal energy security is not militarily significant?
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by willis936 on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:16PM (#26363505)
Not really. Energy scarcity is a very useful geopolitical tool when you're the one with the tap on the oil, the weapons, and the money.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by cygx on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:21PM (#26362282)
Who knows. If I had to make a guess, here are some ideas:

You cannot yet make money with it, so there's no capitalist lobby. Success is not certain, and timeframes are too long for politicians to score points in the election game. It's not as cool as space, and the green faction isn't too keen on the whole nuclear thing. So far, fears about peak oil turned out to be largely unfounded (but do note that we probably did pass the peak as far as conventional oil production in concerned).

If I kept at it, I probably could come up with more theories...

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by runarberg on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:08PM (#26362785)
I don’t think the green faction disagrees with fusion because “nuclear = bad”. I think the fact that current estimates point to the 2060s as the earliest point in time for commercial viability. By that point we will have had to have moved on from fossil fuel (or at least gained net 0 carbon emission) for at least 10–20 years. So nuclear fusion is not a solution to the climate crisis.

In other words the green faction is simply disinterested in nuclear fusion, like we are disinterested in the Large Hadron Collider, sure its a cool experiment, but nothing we should be considering to further our goal of fighting our current environmental disasters.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by cygx on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:32PM (#26363082)
From personal experience, "nuclear = bad" is a thing.

That said, I agree that as things stand today, fusion research is no panacea to climate change. However, note that the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change was ratified in '92, and if we'd decided to go all-in on fusion back then, who knows where we'd be at today...

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by runarberg on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:43PM (#26363188)
Just because some people believe blindly that “nuclear = bad”, that doesn’t mean they won’t change their opinion of fusion once they receive an adequate explanation on how fusion is different from fission. I’ve personally never met anybody in the wild that disagrees with fusion power because of our current track record with fission power. I.e. the believe that “nuclear = bad” does not equate to the believe that “fusion = bad”.

So honestly I don’t believe that there exists people in the wild who’s opinion is: “No to fusion! Because nuclear = bad”, and if they do exists, I don’t think they are of anywhere near size and numbers required to influence public funding.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by pintxo on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:12PM (#26360806)
A five time improvement over the previous estimates
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by Veedrac on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:37PM (#26361093)
ITER is aiming for Q>1 in 2035 IIUC, so 3x.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by pintxo on Friday March 05, 2021 @07:48PM (#26364190)
I was more sarcastically referring to the - I thought - common saying that fusion will always be 25 years into the future.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by Fordec on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:50PM (#26361230)
Wasn't ITER supposed to be built by now? DEMO was supposed to start in 2033 as the successor to ITER.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by cygx on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:50PM (#26361906)
If you try to coordinate design and manufacturing among 35 participating states, delays tend to happen.

Perhaps also noteworthy from a historical perspective is that the whole thing was proposed by the Soviet Union, which doesn't even exist anymore. The US also pulled out of the collaboration in '98, necessitating a redesign; they rejoined in 2003, but congress periodically tries to pull the plug...

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by Veedrac on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:20PM (#26361542)
ITER, like many oversized government programs where funding and structure are almost entirely political, has had delays. First plasma (not full power) was originally scheduled for 2016, and is now 2025.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by gary_0 on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:31PM (#26362384)
See also: The SLS program (the "Senate Launch System").
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by willis936 on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:54PM (#26361267)
It depends on which baseline you're referring to and how many more times the US would back out of its financial commitment after that baseline was made.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by the-dude on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:20PM (#26360897)
Six.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by asien on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:51PM (#26361919)
Technically speaking we already have « fusion ».

The problem is we don’t have « stable fusion » this one will take another 5-6 years.

Then we need « positive yielding fusion » today fusion has negative yield... that’s another 5 -10 years at least.

Finally we need «commercial scale fusion reactor » like France did with their Nuclear Reactor massive investment from post war to today in order to make cost and delay acceptable.

That would be 2040 at least for industrial nuclear fusion.

I have no idea what humanity will look like in that timeframe.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by garmaine on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:07PM (#26362124)
TFA is about stable, positive yield fusion in 5 years.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by wongarsu on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:33PM (#26362406)
"produce more energy than is needed to run the reaction" is a great milestone, but "economically competitive method to produce electricity" is the real goal and requires a good bit of work beyond that
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by mrfusion on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:50PM (#26363260)
But even without that it could be immensely useful for space travel and colonization. And also for remote environments.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by fchu on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:52PM (#26361940)
The key difference here is that it's a venture backed effort, which signals something very different from large state-financed research efforts like Iter.

Namely, that there is a path to financial viability

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by willis936 on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:20PM (#26362269)
MIT’s product isn’t the reactors: it’s HTS coil winding. That’s the proprietary tech they are developing and planning to sell.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by jgalt212 on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:27PM (#26362338)
VC backed and

> Namely, that there is a path to financial viability

I see what you did there.

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by agumonkey on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:11PM (#26362179)
IF (if) everything goes to plan than 5 years is quite fundamental considering the amount of implications about safer cheaper energy.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by Florin_Andrei on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:29PM (#26361634)
The "only X years away" jokes are predictable, but we'll know soon enough if they can do 20 Tesla - and if they can, then the time tables should be reset.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by DesiLurker on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:45PM (#26362534)
at this rate we might get fusion before James Webb space telescope becomes fully functional!

ref: https://xkcd.com/2014/

Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by NortySpock on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:29PM (#26360999)
The test plant is 5 years away, but yeah, net-gain in energy is the target.
Re:Fusion startup plans reactor with small but powerful supe... by anotheryou on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:30PM (#26361654)
"fire up" != energy positive and ripe for production