And then comes questions of life-cycle energy inputs and costs. How long will it be to be net positive on these? That is we spend less energy on cooling the coolant for superconductors and overall building the thing.
I agree renewables might make it mostly moot, but there’s still the issue of base load. Storage might solve it, but if fusion can be made safe and cheap enough it could still have a niche.
Then there’s Mars and the belt. There’s no guarantee we’ll colonise it permanently, but if we do fusion could be really useful as it’s far enough out that solar is significantly less efficient. Also fusion reactors could be handy power plants for spacecraft. Cheap reusable heavy lift systems may make all of this feasible.
Finally, the future is a long, long time. If we don’t wipe ourselves out, eventually we will every technology that is viable will be achieved (not possible, viable).
I honestly wonder if fusion will ever be commercially viable. And if all these experiments will simply lead up to us realizing that: “cool, so fusion power is possible on Earth. Now what should we do with it?”
But hey. Maybe it will be the energy of the future on Antarctica or the Moon or something instead.
If that's the case, then why hasn't anyone written that check? The potential profit from commercialized fusion seems enormous (unlike a mars base), and there doesn't seem to be a shortage of capital seeking large returns.
What I do know is that superconducting magnets have been getting cheaper, more powerful, and more compact for quite some time and that's one of the limiting factors on fusion reactor designs. I also know that there is no known physical barrier to net-positive fusion, only engineering barriers.
If I had to totally guess I'd say someone will show net-positive fusion for a brief period of time before 2030... assuming the funding is present. It will not be a fully viable power plant yet but a proof of concept. This will be followed by a huge bump in funding and a race to produce power plants.
... but that's a guess.
It's like asking "when will there be a human base on Mars?" We know it's possible and I think it will happen, but I don't know how long it will actually take. We could probably have one in 5 years if someone wanted to write a blank check.
I would bet that we could have a fusion PoC in 5 years if someone wrote a blank check and fully funded many different credible efforts.