It’s been whipsawing between these estimates for the last couple hours.
I think I now understand the state of fusion research.
We don't know how long it will take, but at the same time there is visible progress occurring on many fronts: understanding plasma behavior and how to control it, better superconducting magnets, better control systems, solutions to the neutron embrittlement problem, etc.
There's not going to be a single breakthrough... or rather the fusion breakthrough already occurred. We've already learned about fusion and how to trigger it. That happened in the early 20th century.
Instead of a single breakthrough it will be continued progress on all fronts until at some point everything matures enough that someone manages to build a proof of concept reactor. At that point investment will flood into the space because it will have been sufficiently de-risked.
The upthread comment was 20, not 50, and I’ve heard 15 or 20 years away frequently since the 1980s and seen it in things dating back to the 1960s, so, no, its not baloney.
Nor does it necessarily mean that progress isn’t being made, its more of a comment that the unknown unknowns are being converted in known unknowns as fast as a known unknowns are being converted into known knowns.