News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Logical Fallacies by orange_tee on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:09AM (#25968432)
I am not well versed into how these logical fallacies are supposed to be applied. Everyone is operating with imperfect information, so no implication will ever be 100% logically tight.

For example, using "appeal to authority", it is logically true that just because a group of Fields Medalists think your proof is wrong, does not necessarily mean that your proof is wrong. But in practice, there is a very high chance you are in the wrong.

Logical fallacies are binary, but the world is more stochastic, so I may be wrong, but I think these logical fallacies do not actually apply to reasoning about the real world. They only work when applied to thought experiments.

But I am no philosopher so I do not know for sure.

Re:Logical Fallacies by syops on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:21AM (#25968488)
An argument can be logically sound but with a false conclusion. An argument can be logically invalid but with a correct conclusion. The role of logical fallacies is to point out unsound reasoning. They don’t demonstrate veracity or lack thereof.

Regarding the appeal to authority fallacy you mentioned. I personally do not believe this is a fallacy. I do agree that the appeal to false authority is a fallacy. We all have to rely on the expertise of others for much of what we believe to be true. Of course said beliefs might be wrong but relying on expert knowledge is not a fallacy in and of itself in my opinion.

Re:Logical Fallacies by MaxBarraclough on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:40AM (#25968589)
> An argument can be logically sound but with a false conclusion.

That doesn't sound right. An argument is sound iff it is logically valid and its premises are true, right? From Wikipedia:

> In deductive reasoning, a sound argument is an argument that is both valid, and all of whose premises are true (and as a consequence its conclusion is true as well)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soundness#Definition

Re:Logical Fallacies by syops on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:29AM (#25968886)
I guess it comes down meaning of “sound”. Let me be more specific.

An argument can correctly use the rules of logic and have an incorrect conclusion. This can happen if some of the premises are false. For example:

All men are immortal. Socrates is a man. Therefore Socrates is immortal.

The rules of logic have been correctly followed but the conclusion is false.

Re:Logical Fallacies by mannykannot on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:26AM (#25969313)
This is indeed an example of a valid but unsound argument (unsound because the first premise is false), and your use of 'sound' is correct here.

Your first post, however, uses 'sound' in a manner that is inconsistent with both this example and correct usage. In particular, where you wrote "An argument can be logically sound but with a false conclusion" you presumably meant 'valid' instead of 'logically sound', as, by definition, sound arguments have true conclusions.

Re:Logical Fallacies by syops on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:30AM (#25970372)
Hence my clarification where I stated the point differently. Yes, valid would have been a better choice.

Do you see that you have taken my phrase logically sound and then switched to sound arguments? Do you think these mean the same thing?

Re:Logical Fallacies by mannykannot on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:20PM (#25971448)
This is a pedantically pointless argument. In the domain of logic, 'sound' has a very definite meaning, so what are we to make of your use of the word 'sound' in a discussion of logic, especially given that you explicitly qualify it with 'logical'? What is the point of phrasing a statement in such a way that it will mislead everyone except those who can see what you actually meant? Those people already know what you are trying to say.

I have not "taken [your] phrase logically sound and then switched to sound arguments". What I did, in the clause "sound arguments have true conclusions", was to make a statement of fact about the meaning of the word 'sound' in the domain of logic. On account of that being so, it would have been unequivocally wrong for you to have written "An argument can be sound but with a false conclusion."

Ah, but you say (this is where it gets really pedantic) you did not write precisely that; you wrote "An argument can be logically sound but with a false conclusion" - but how do you think the modifier logically will be taken here, given that 'sound' has a specific meaning in the domain of logic? Don't tell us that (obviously!) 'logically sound' actually means 'valid'!

Re:Logical Fallacies by xupybd on Saturday January 30, 2021 @02:11PM (#25971979)
Communication is hard. It's harder when both parties are not using the same definitions. I've found this is one of the biggest difficulties in hashing out an argument with a stranger online. With someone I know I can spot when our definitions don't match. Online it takes a lot more back and forth and often is less friendly.
Re:Logical Fallacies by tpoacher on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:33AM (#25968905)
You mean valid. Not sound. By definition if an argument is sound, it is also valid (but not the reverse). And by definition if an argument is sound, then its conclusions are true.

I think you're just mixing up the terminology a bit.

Re:Logical Fallacies by syops on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:58AM (#25969096)
Well I did use logically sound and not sound argument. I personally don’t see a difference in logically sound and logically valid but I clarified things in my previous post.
Re:Logical Fallacies by Veen on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:26AM (#25969307)
Sound and valid are terms of art in deductive logic. They have clearly defined meanings.

Validity means the form of an argument is such that it's impossible for its premises to be true while the conclusion is false i.e. if the premises are true then the conclulsion must be true. Validity is a formal property of arguments and the relationships between premises. An argument can be valid even if its premises are false.

Soundness means that an argument is valid and that the premises are true (and therefore the conclusion must be true).

These are standard terms that have been used for over a century. You're going to generate a lot of confusion if you choose to use them differently to everyone who has ever studied elementary logic.

Re:Logical Fallacies by syops on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:36AM (#25969385)
Is there a difference in meaning between:

sound argument

logically sound

I'm not aware of these phrases being the same. I took mathematical logic in graduate school many years ago and I've used logically sound to be something different than sound argument.

I'm not disagreeing that valid would have been a better word choice. I did clarify my meaning in a subsequent post. I rewrote my point without using either sound or valid in an effort to be more precise.

Re:Logical Fallacies by mannykannot on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:29PM (#25971522)
Re:Logical Fallacies by MaxBarraclough on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:05AM (#25969151)
> I personally don’t see a difference in logically sound and logically valid

They aren't the same. These are standard terms in logic, as explained in the Wikipedia article.

Re:Logical Fallacies by syops on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:16AM (#25969246)
Obviously I'm speaking in the vernacular and as I stated I used the terms as they meant to me.

Besides logically sound and sound argument aren't the same thing in my mind. One refers to soundness of logic and the other to soundness of the argument. And that was the essence of my point. There's a difference in talking about an argument and talking about the logic used. Logical fallacies are only useful in determining if the reasoning was flawed.

I didn't disagree with anything you wrote and even clarified my meaning so as to be clear. There is also the fact that, linguistically speaking, every person has a unique language. The meaning of words can vary slightly between people who nominally speak the same language. That's why I mentioned to me in my previous post.

Clearly I was not writing in a mathematically precise way. I took mathematical logic in graduate school many years ago but am not qualified to use all of the terminology in a mathematically precise way. But this is an internet forum and not a course in mathematical logic. The standards of rigor are not so strict. Hence my phrase to me ought to have sufficed as far as clarification.

Re:Logical Fallacies by mannykannot on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:39AM (#25969414)
"I used the terms as they meant to me... every person has a unique language."

Private languages are useless for communication, which depends on shared semantics. This thread is a clear example of that, as your first post here is very misleading except to anyone who a) knows that you are using your own private language, and b) actually knows what you mean by your words. In that post, using your own private definition of the various terms under discussion is worse than useless, as anyone who does not know what the accepted meanings are will end up worse off for reading it.

“When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’

’The question is,’ said Alice, ‘whether you can make words mean so many different things.’

’The question is,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master — that’s all.”

― Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking Glass

Re:Logical Fallacies by syops on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:27AM (#25970355)
I agree I should have used "valid" when I used "sound". I also clarified what I meant by "logically sound". I further stated that I was using my parlance when I used "logically sound".

What is interesting is that the responses to me have been about the meaning of sound argument and I never used this phrase. I used logically sound. Do you personally think logically sound and sound argument mean the same thing? I'm asking out of curiosity.

EDIT: Private languages and the acknowledgement of them is not useless. It's a basis for being able to clarify things without a discussion devolving arguments over definitions of words. We all have slightly different ideas of what certain words mean.

Re:Logical Fallacies by mannykannot on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:34PM (#25971020)
> I used logically sound. Do you personally think logically sound and sound argument mean the same thing?

Well, the real point is that it is not clear what you mean here, and consequently what you are writing is likely to cause confusion and misunderstanding. In particular, as I pointed out in an earlier post, you were inconsistent in your own usage, sometimes using 'sound' correctly, and sometimes incorrectly.

You also seem to think that because, in a series of follow-up posts, you can explain what you meant, then it follows that there was nothing wrong with your original post - but if no-one had replied to it, you would not have corrected it on your own, and it would have remained there, sowing confusion among those who did not know it was wrong (and, of course, being useless to those who do know it is wrong.)

The size of the responses to your original post is a clear testament to the way private usage inhibits understanding and spreads confusion (though there would be considerably less if you had simply acknowledged your mistake immediately, and henceforward used 'sound' in its conventional sense.)

> Private languages and the acknowledgement of them is not useless.

I said that they are useless for communication (of course, they can be useful to the extent that they are not entirely private, but that caveat actually bolsters my point.)

>It's a basis for being able to clarify things...

Quite the opposite, as shown here: it's most often a basis for confusion and misunderstanding - and how could it not be? You have to achieve a shared meaning before there can be clarity and mutual understanding.

Re:Logical Fallacies by justin66 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:58AM (#25970060)
You should step back and read the chapter of an intro to logic textbook where the topic of validity vs soundness is discussed. It’s easy to use these terms in a way that expresses your intent.

One nice thing about doing so is that an understanding of validity vs soundness, necessity vs sufficiency, and the truth tables themselves is all you need to understand all the formal fallacies.

All you need to understand about the informal fallacies is, if someone appears to need to discuss informal fallacies, what they really need is a hug. Or a kick in the pants.

Re:Logical Fallacies by simonh on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:47AM (#25968634)
I think appeal to authority gets shaky when you appeal to an authority who's domain of expertise, or specific knowledge and experience might not extend to the issue at hand. It's a matter of trusting the process of scientific inquiry, challenge and verification, not just the person.

So for example I defer to Roger Penrose on anything to do with mathematics, and will absolutely he has earned a voice on astrophysics#, but quantum consciousness microtubules? Nobody is an authority on that, so who knows?

# And to be clear part of his credibility there is in making it clear what he believes with a high degree of certainty and what is more speculative.

Re:Logical Fallacies by syops on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:25AM (#25968854)
Yes, that is why I agree with appeal to false authority being a fallacy. This is what I was referring to in my last paragraph.
Re:Logical Fallacies by swasheck on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:15AM (#25969704)
Those examples of appeal to authority are a lot more nuanced than I’ve generally seen. It’s generally more blunt, like “we interviewed 5 PhDs about climate change and they all state that there’s no good evidence to support it.” Those PhDs however, were not experts in a domain that could validate an assertion on climate change.

The more nuanced versions in the examples make an uncritical assertion, based on an appeal to an authority in a closely related domain, to overturn an established set of “validated facts” (for the domain, say what you want about a religious creed).

Re:Logical Fallacies by hooande on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:58AM (#25969564)
You misunderstood the fallacy. it's not "don't listen to experts". it's "a proposition isn't true only because another person says that it is true". While you may chose to save time by deferring to expertise, you can't use that to convince someone else that an idea is correct.

Logical fallacies are easy to misunderstand, which makes them very dangerous. That's why this website has examples, I guess. This is a case of knowledge that might require a teacher who can give feedback and guide understanding.

Re:Logical Fallacies by threatofrain on Saturday January 30, 2021 @02:37PM (#25972203)
> You misunderstood the fallacy. it's not "don't listen to experts".

It certainly doesn't mean "listen to the experts". There is no such intellectual guidance there. The perspective of "logical fallacy" only cares about whether something must be true, and it has no opinion on how to judge whether something is probably true, or how to develop trust.

Formal methods became fashionable only late in mathematical history, yet mathematicians somehow achieved productivity up to that point.

Re:Logical Fallacies by koheripbal on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:05AM (#25970121)
Maybe the word "fallacy", is in that case, misleading.

The probability that an assertion is true drastically increases if there is a clear consensus among the subject matter experts in that field.

This is important when certain assertions cannot be personally verified.

For example, I cannot personally verify that Pluto has a moon. ...but I can show people pictures of an object that the experts claim is Pluto's moon, and point to various statements that Pluto has a moon.

The probability that Pluto does not have a moon would require a massive conspiracy, or some unimaginable misunderstanding, that the probability is extremely low.

Is it still a "fallacy" to point to the statements of those scientists?

Re:Logical Fallacies by packetlost on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:48PM (#25971156)
This is the correct use of the word "fallacy." The "appeal to authority" fallacy is the belief that because some piece of info comes from someone (it's generally an individual) who is in a position of authority means that it's automatically true. It has nothing to really do with whether the piece of info is accurate or not, and consensus is generally a way to mitigate the issues that arise from this fallacy.
Re:Logical Fallacies by froh on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:46AM (#25970552)
The point is that some retired professor in microbiology takes a little lamplight making claims about covid, which unfortunately are factually utterly and desperately wrong.

Now people refer to him expert in a facebook thread.

That's the "appeal to authority" fallacy, which you could call out.

Extensive use of fallacies is in the active repertoire of demagogues. That's why it helps to study them, a bit, so you recognize a skunk if you meet it in the wild.

Re:Logical Fallacies by prof-dr-ir on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:43AM (#25968609)
Nicely put. Maybe it helps to think of the purpose of those conversations where pointing out logical fallacies might help?

Such conversations are almost always about changing someone's view of the world - sometimes through debate, where conflicting positions are taken and argued upon, and sometimes simply because someone (e.g. you) asks for a clarification in order to know which position to take.

So I think that the idea is that people can at least take well-reasoned positions, not necessarily equal positions, in a world that is not black and white.

The list of fallacies can then be a useful guide to judge the persuasiveness of the arguments of the different sides, including of course your own arguments, and to help you see whether a position might need to change because it is not well-reasoned.

In your example, I can say "I trust Fields Medallists" and therefore judge the proof to be likely wrong. That is a valid position to take. You may say that "the author of the proof is a very talented mathematician" so the proof is likely right, which would be equally valid. What we cannot do, without further information, is to claim that the proof must with absolute certainty be right or wrong - that I believe would be the fallacy here.

Re:Logical Fallacies by bitshiftfaced on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:58AM (#25970061)
> For example, using "appeal to authority", it is logically true that just because a group of Fields Medalists think your proof is wrong, does not necessarily mean that your proof is wrong. But in practice, there is a very high chance you are in the wrong.

The proof is wrong not because the status of those Field Medalists but instead because of the content of their argument. That's all that the appeal to authority is saying.

I'd agree that it's a mistake to relate the existence of a logical fallacies to the probability of a statement being correct. Instead, it only gives information about whether the reasoning of the statement is on solid ground.

Re:Logical Fallacies by threatofrain on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:47AM (#25970560)
But what kind of reasoning is on solid ground when we’re talking about logic... outside of math? Saying logic here is almost lying to ourselves because we’re not expecting anyone to create logical chains of reasoning.

Do mathematicians even use logic as a reasoning tool, as opposed to a proving tool?

Re:Logical Fallacies by bitshiftfaced on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:44PM (#25971122)
Isn't that exactly the question that informal logical fallacies seek to address?

I don't think you can just throw away the word "logic" like that. We try to make arguments using deduction and inference, so there is a logical structure behind them. It's just that it isn't as well-defined and doesn't have the mathematical rigor of formal logic.

Re:Logical Fallacies by threatofrain on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:53PM (#25971804)
Logic a fundamentally different process of intellectual productivity, which is why mathematicians don’t see proving and reasoning as the same thing. Formal methods weren't even widespread until late in mathematical history, yet somehow we had mathematical productivity.

Mathematicians can scarcely describe their own thinking process, and proving is often the last step to mathematical reasoning.

Talking about logical fallacy in ordinary conversation is backward.

Re:Logical Fallacies by kybernetikos on Saturday January 30, 2021 @05:18PM (#25973552)
Many fallacies are perfectly sensible ways to reason in a messy, imperfect world.

ad hominem - someone you know to receive large sums of money from cigarette manufacturers gives you several plausible sounding reasons why cigarettes don't cause cancer. It's an adhominem to doubt his arguments based on your knowledge of how he's getting paid, but it's also sensible.

argumentum ad populum - an argument isn't necessarily true just because lots of people believe it, but in the absence of you being able to work out the absolute truth from first principles, it's completely sensible to take into account what other people believe when you evaluate your options, or what people in your situation have typically believed (appeal to tradition)

denying the antecedent - red sky in the morning implies shepherds should take warning. It's not true to say that just because there isn't red sky in the morning, then shepherds should assume the weather will be fine, but excluding one of the conditions in which shepherds need to be careful is weak evidence that shepherds will be fine.

The old 'absence of evidence is not evidence of absence' one, although I didn't see it on this page. Actually it is. It is weak and incomplete evidence of absence, but in the right circumstances it can be perfectly reasonable to change your opinion on whether something is present or not based on a lack of evidence for it being present.

In the real world, weak evidence is often the best we're going to get and we're often going to be in situations where thought shortcuts are necessary and valuable.

Pointing out fallacies is usually poor argumentation. My pet peeve on this one is the 'burden of proof'. Normal human debate isn't a game with strict rules and a judge that awards points, and I'm not sure it'd be any better if it were. You engage in a debate with someone when you both want to change the other persons mind. If you didn't want to change their mind you shouldn't be debating with them. You're very unlikely to change their minds by telling them that the burden of proof is on them not you (much more likely to end up arguing about who really has the burden of proof, a fruitless and uninteresting topic).

Re:Logical Fallacies by zamadatix on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:23PM (#25975156)
Yeah, nothing about a logical fallacy says it can't be useful just that it's not strict logical proof. As such it's useful to call out that a logical fallacy doesn't equate to/overrule direct evidence or sound logic but that doesn't mean things behind the indirect evidence or unsound logic are inherently 100% useless information in decisions or discussions.
Re:Logical Fallacies by faitswulff on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:03AM (#25968719)
I saw an example of a poorly applied logical fallacy here on HN. The poster was claiming that an app’s popularity was meaningless via argumentum ad populum and that their chosen alternative was “correct.” It’s like arguing that everyone should replace their USD with Bitcoin. In an ideal world, perhaps, but we don’t live in an ideal world; we live in a world where popularity matters. I’m sure there are other examples of this kind of logical purism being misapplied to the real world, especially among programmers.
Re:Logical Fallacies by hyko on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:54AM (#25969068)
I don’t think those examples are right; argumentum ad populum is about relying on the popularity of a belief to prove whether it’s true or false.

What interesting is that in the example of Bitcoin, since currency is little more than a shared belief in something, this would not really constitute a logical fallacy.

Re:Logical Fallacies by faitswulff on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:17AM (#25969251)
Regarding your first paragraph: exactly.

Regarding your second: you’re making essentially the same mistake. There’s no objective argument here, no deliberations on abstract truth that could be easily countered by pointing out a logical fallacy. Just because it’s a shared belief doesn’t mean it’s not beholden to valid yet purely subjective arguments such as “I don’t have any BTC” or “I don’t have the technical ability to use BTC.” In reality, nobody is going to use your product or service because you can make a fallacy-free argument for it. On the other hand, popularity is a very real and useful indicator of utility. You may hate jQuery, for instance, but it’s going to have a plethora of documentation, blog posts, and StackOverflow answers.

Basically - the real world is tolerant and even encouraging of logical fallacies.

Re:Logical Fallacies by hyko on Saturday January 30, 2021 @02:18PM (#25972031)
Yeah, I guess the real world is tolerant of them – otherwise we wouldn’t call them fallacies :) If we’re to get closer to the truth though, we must be intolerant of them (but not each other).

I think it also depends on precisely what statement you’re trying to prove. In the jQuery example you have to get really specific, because just talking about the best can be pretty vague. There are many examples of best where merely pointing to the popularity of jQuery is a logical fallacy, and perhaps some where it isn’t (e.g. the breadth of documentation making development easier). This is really a different class of problem to something more abstract such as the belief in alien civilisations, where the fallacy is more clear cut.

The currency example is a slightly different case though, because it’s the belief in the currency itself that creates the currency. So the statement everyone should replace their USD with Bitcoin is undermined by the overwhelming depth and breadth of belief in USD (misplaced or not). So I don’t think it counts as a logical fallacy, because it goes beyond merely trying to leverage the majority opinion on the subject; the beliefs themselves are absolutely instrumental in driving the relative utility of USD and Bitcoin.

Re:Logical Fallacies by faitswulff on Saturday January 30, 2021 @04:18PM (#25973088)
I’m not arguing that it’s a logical fallacy, I’m arguing that it’s outside the scope of logical fallacies. In fact that’s why I’m using it as an example.
Re:Logical Fallacies by nkozyra on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:18AM (#25968475)
Argumentative logical fallacies apply to conclusions/truths, not suspicions or intuitions.

They're meant to do exactly what you are asking for here: eliminate a binary rule from deduction.

Re:Logical Fallacies by pessimizer on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:17AM (#25968464)
Determinations of chance aren't material, they're a matter of perspective and a tool to use when making decisions. The chance that a wrong proof is correct is 0%, and the chance that a correct proof is correct is 100%, no matter what any selection of Fields medalists feel about it.

Whether, when you're making a business decision, you go with the lone whacko or the Fields medalists is a different question.

Re:Logical Fallacies by FabHK on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:54AM (#25969067)
Yes, the "appeal to authority = fallacy" can be employed to shut down legitimate arguments, as well as the "ad hominem = fallacy". There is a great clarification here:

"The ad hominem fallacy fallacy"

EDIT: debunking -> clarification https://laurencetennant.com/bonds/adhominem.html

Re:Logical Fallacies by bena on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:11AM (#25969196)
That doesn't debunk "ad hominem" as a fallacy, it just says that sometimes people accuse others of ad hominem when it doesn't apply.
Re:Logical Fallacies by user-the-name on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:46AM (#25969470)
Yes, people think "ad hominem" means "he insulted me so I win".

"You are wrong because you are an idiot" is ad hominem. "You are wrong, and also an idiot" is not.

Re:Logical Fallacies by FabHK on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:49AM (#25969493)
You’re right, I’ve edited.

It’s the abuse of crying “ad hominem” that’s the problem.

Re:Logical Fallacies by darkerside on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:16AM (#25969240)
Logical fallacies should be part of a conversation, and shouldn't shut down anything. They are thinking tools, not debate weapons, although they can be used as such.
Re:Logical Fallacies by koheripbal on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:30AM (#25970381)
If someone is making an argument with obviously invalid logic, then I think it's reasonable to not continue the conversation if they are unwilling to present a logical argument.
Re:Logical Fallacies by darkerside on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:07PM (#25970755)
If you really on logic for everything, people are eventually going to walk away from you. Don't ask me to logically prove that because all I have is the anecdotal evidence of experience.

Not every conversation is a scientific debate. If you want to learn, you should still participate in them.

Re:Logical Fallacies by bjt2n3904 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:15AM (#25968786)
This is known as the "logical fallacy fallacy", which rarely shows up on these lists.

"orange_tee made an appeal to authority, therefore every conclusion he is attempting to draw is false and can be rejected out of hand."

It's a very jejune debate tactic, by people who have just dipped their toes into logic for the first time, and have discovered a brand new way to shut down arguments.

Re:Logical Fallacies by yters on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:51AM (#25969514)
Fallacious parts of an argument cannot contribute to its soundness. Fallacies either contribute untrue premises or invalid deductions, such as affirming the consequent. This is a matter of fact.
Re:Logical Fallacies by duedl0r on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:56AM (#25968678)
"appeal to authority" is a good example in our current situation. How many doctors are talking crap about Covid? Here lies one of our problem about misinformation. Too many people are just regurgitate opinions of "doctors".

Generally speaking, I like to use fallacies for myself, just to be aware about certain pitfalls. Not so much about discrediting others, but rather not fall into one myself.

If I realize other people are using fallacies to support their argument, it helps me to build an argument against it. Just don't use it naively: "you're wrong because of fallacy number 42". Using it like this is a bad habit, because of the wast number of fallacies, you can probably kill any discussion.

Re:Logical Fallacies by tpoacher on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:43AM (#25968983)
this is because fallacies deal with deduction, not inference. still useful tools though.