That doesn't sound right. An argument is sound iff it is logically valid and its premises are true, right? From Wikipedia:
> In deductive reasoning, a sound argument is an argument that is both valid, and all of whose premises are true (and as a consequence its conclusion is true as well)
An argument can correctly use the rules of logic and have an incorrect conclusion. This can happen if some of the premises are false. For example:
All men are immortal. Socrates is a man. Therefore Socrates is immortal.
The rules of logic have been correctly followed but the conclusion is false.
Your first post, however, uses 'sound' in a manner that is inconsistent with both this example and correct usage. In particular, where you wrote "An argument can be logically sound but with a false conclusion" you presumably meant 'valid' instead of 'logically sound', as, by definition, sound arguments have true conclusions.
Do you see that you have taken my phrase logically sound and then switched to sound arguments? Do you think these mean the same thing?
I have not "taken [your] phrase logically sound and then switched to sound arguments". What I did, in the clause "sound arguments have true conclusions", was to make a statement of fact about the meaning of the word 'sound' in the domain of logic. On account of that being so, it would have been unequivocally wrong for you to have written "An argument can be sound but with a false conclusion."
Ah, but you say (this is where it gets really pedantic) you did not write precisely that; you wrote "An argument can be logically sound but with a false conclusion" - but how do you think the modifier logically will be taken here, given that 'sound' has a specific meaning in the domain of logic? Don't tell us that (obviously!) 'logically sound' actually means 'valid'!
I think you're just mixing up the terminology a bit.
Validity means the form of an argument is such that it's impossible for its premises to be true while the conclusion is false i.e. if the premises are true then the conclulsion must be true. Validity is a formal property of arguments and the relationships between premises. An argument can be valid even if its premises are false.
Soundness means that an argument is valid and that the premises are true (and therefore the conclusion must be true).
These are standard terms that have been used for over a century. You're going to generate a lot of confusion if you choose to use them differently to everyone who has ever studied elementary logic.
sound argument
logically sound
I'm not aware of these phrases being the same. I took mathematical logic in graduate school many years ago and I've used logically sound to be something different than sound argument.
I'm not disagreeing that valid would have been a better word choice. I did clarify my meaning in a subsequent post. I rewrote my point without using either sound or valid in an effort to be more precise.
They aren't the same. These are standard terms in logic, as explained in the Wikipedia article.
Besides logically sound and sound argument aren't the same thing in my mind. One refers to soundness of logic and the other to soundness of the argument. And that was the essence of my point. There's a difference in talking about an argument and talking about the logic used. Logical fallacies are only useful in determining if the reasoning was flawed.
I didn't disagree with anything you wrote and even clarified my meaning so as to be clear. There is also the fact that, linguistically speaking, every person has a unique language. The meaning of words can vary slightly between people who nominally speak the same language. That's why I mentioned to me in my previous post.
Clearly I was not writing in a mathematically precise way. I took mathematical logic in graduate school many years ago but am not qualified to use all of the terminology in a mathematically precise way. But this is an internet forum and not a course in mathematical logic. The standards of rigor are not so strict. Hence my phrase to me ought to have sufficed as far as clarification.
Private languages are useless for communication, which depends on shared semantics. This thread is a clear example of that, as your first post here is very misleading except to anyone who a) knows that you are using your own private language, and b) actually knows what you mean by your words. In that post, using your own private definition of the various terms under discussion is worse than useless, as anyone who does not know what the accepted meanings are will end up worse off for reading it.
“When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’
’The question is,’ said Alice, ‘whether you can make words mean so many different things.’
’The question is,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master — that’s all.”
― Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking Glass
What is interesting is that the responses to me have been about the meaning of sound argument and I never used this phrase. I used logically sound. Do you personally think logically sound and sound argument mean the same thing? I'm asking out of curiosity.
EDIT: Private languages and the acknowledgement of them is not useless. It's a basis for being able to clarify things without a discussion devolving arguments over definitions of words. We all have slightly different ideas of what certain words mean.
Well, the real point is that it is not clear what you mean here, and consequently what you are writing is likely to cause confusion and misunderstanding. In particular, as I pointed out in an earlier post, you were inconsistent in your own usage, sometimes using 'sound' correctly, and sometimes incorrectly.
You also seem to think that because, in a series of follow-up posts, you can explain what you meant, then it follows that there was nothing wrong with your original post - but if no-one had replied to it, you would not have corrected it on your own, and it would have remained there, sowing confusion among those who did not know it was wrong (and, of course, being useless to those who do know it is wrong.)
The size of the responses to your original post is a clear testament to the way private usage inhibits understanding and spreads confusion (though there would be considerably less if you had simply acknowledged your mistake immediately, and henceforward used 'sound' in its conventional sense.)
> Private languages and the acknowledgement of them is not useless.
I said that they are useless for communication (of course, they can be useful to the extent that they are not entirely private, but that caveat actually bolsters my point.)
>It's a basis for being able to clarify things...
Quite the opposite, as shown here: it's most often a basis for confusion and misunderstanding - and how could it not be? You have to achieve a shared meaning before there can be clarity and mutual understanding.
One nice thing about doing so is that an understanding of validity vs soundness, necessity vs sufficiency, and the truth tables themselves is all you need to understand all the formal fallacies.
All you need to understand about the informal fallacies is, if someone appears to need to discuss informal fallacies, what they really need is a hug. Or a kick in the pants.
So for example I defer to Roger Penrose on anything to do with mathematics, and will absolutely he has earned a voice on astrophysics#, but quantum consciousness microtubules? Nobody is an authority on that, so who knows?
# And to be clear part of his credibility there is in making it clear what he believes with a high degree of certainty and what is more speculative.
The more nuanced versions in the examples make an uncritical assertion, based on an appeal to an authority in a closely related domain, to overturn an established set of “validated facts” (for the domain, say what you want about a religious creed).
Regarding the appeal to authority fallacy you mentioned. I personally do not believe this is a fallacy. I do agree that the appeal to false authority is a fallacy. We all have to rely on the expertise of others for much of what we believe to be true. Of course said beliefs might be wrong but relying on expert knowledge is not a fallacy in and of itself in my opinion.