That doesn't debunk "ad hominem" as a fallacy, it just says that sometimes people accuse others of ad hominem when it doesn't apply.
Re:Logical Fallacies
by user-the-name on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:46AM
(#25969470)
Yes, people think "ad hominem" means "he insulted me so I win".
"You are wrong because you are an idiot" is ad hominem. "You are wrong, and also an idiot" is not.
You’re right, I’ve edited.
It’s the abuse of crying “ad hominem” that’s the problem.
Re:Logical Fallacies
by darkerside on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:16AM
(#25969240)
Logical fallacies should be part of a conversation, and shouldn't shut down anything. They are thinking tools, not debate weapons, although they can be used as such.
Re:Logical Fallacies
by koheripbal on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:30AM
(#25970381)
If someone is making an argument with obviously invalid logic, then I think it's reasonable to not continue the conversation if they are unwilling to present a logical argument.
Re:Logical Fallacies
by darkerside on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:07PM
(#25970755)
If you really on logic for everything, people are eventually going to walk away from you. Don't ask me to logically prove that because all I have is the anecdotal evidence of experience.
Not every conversation is a scientific debate. If you want to learn, you should still participate in them.
"The ad hominem fallacy fallacy"
EDIT: debunking -> clarification https://laurencetennant.com/bonds/adhominem.html