News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by prof-dr-ir on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:23AM (#25645217)
I have lived in five countries now, but not one (local or state) government had an online presence that was nearly as good as the gov.uk infrastructure.

Their websites might not look the part, but they excel (again, in my experience) in their practicality, accessibility and ease of use. And that is exactly what you would expect from a government website.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by ksec on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:27AM (#25645803)
>Their websites might not look the part, but they excel.... accessibility....

I remember they had a design document ( Something similar to [1] [2], but not the exact one I was looking for ) where they list accessibility as their number one priority and a very long list of accessibility requirement. Simply because Government Web Site needs to be accessible by everyone. That means there are certain fancy things and colour scheme they cant do.

I wonder if the stack for Gov.UK are the same as their Petition Site [3] or was it based on something else? They have an Open Source Github account [4] for Government Digital Service which list everything they have open sourced.

[1] https://www.gov.uk/guidance/government-design-principles

[2] https://design-system.service.gov.uk

[3] https://petition.parliament.uk

[4] https://github.com/alphagov

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by chaorace on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:46AM (#25646697)
If there was any remaining doubt about the UK Gov's design chops, check out their Github projects. Just to highlight one... they've published one of the most accessible and intuitive reverse-engineering tools I've ever used: https://github.com/gchq/CyberChef
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by g_p on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @12:53PM (#25648456)
There's also huge amounts of UK Govt infrastructure code available online and open source. For all kinds of things, from all departments.

You could pretty much spin up the code needed to run the boring bits of a country out of open-source code. How about the application for booking secure prisoner moves? [0] Or some nice open source security guidance? [1]

And that's just one department, most others are similar!

[0] https://github.com/ministryofjustice [1] https://github.com/ministryofjustice/security-guidance

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by fluential on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:30PM (#25649867)
Or run your own version of government tax system https://github.com/hmrc
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by gm3dmo on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:28PM (#25652085)
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by mhh__ on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @12:53PM (#25648460)
Slightly different group of people working on GCHqQ's recruiting tools and gov.uk, I would imagine.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by callamdelaney on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:08PM (#25650340)
It's worth noting that GCHQ and GDS (Government digital Service, responsible for gov.uk sites) are different.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by irrational on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:01PM (#25649466)
How have I never seen this before? This is amazing! I've been looking for something like this for ages.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by tyfon on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @01:46PM (#25649224)
We have some form of this in Norway too where companies can be fined for having inaccessible web pages. We will also adopt the EU wide Web Accessibility Directive (WAD).

The department overseeing this has guide lines [1] and tests for web pages/apps/forms etc [2]

[1] https://www.uutilsynet.no/wcag-standarden/wcag-sortert-etter...

[2] https://www.uutilsynet.no/regelverk/testprosedyrar-nettstade...

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by gm3dmo on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:24PM (#25652030)
https://www.gov.uk/service-manual

The service manual is an awesome piece of work.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by the_arun on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @01:20PM (#25648838)
May be if we are in UK, Govt. jobs are good you mean?
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by irjustin on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:06AM (#25645593)
If you're looking for another example that does it well, I'm currently in Singapore. Their websites are fantastic. highly functional and relatively good looking [0].

They have SingPass[1] which is a centralized OAuth for government ID that lets me into things like taxes, identity, etc.

There's a fair argument someplace for too much reach/tracking, but it works really smoothly.

[0] https://www.gov.sg/

https://www.mom.gov.sg/newsroom/press-releases/2020/0624-pub...

[1] https://www.singpass.gov.sg

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by johnchristopher on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:41AM (#25646641)
This doesn't strike me as functional as gov.uk. It's more like your standard wordpress stories site (there is even a section labelled "stories").

edit:

> The www.gov.sg Portal is the official online communication platform and repository of the Singapore Government, providing you with the latest policy announcements, information and news on Singapore. You can also translate Government terms using our translating tool, and search for contact information of public service agencies.

> The Portal is managed by the Public Communications Division of the Ministry of Communications and Information. We welcome your suggestions for the Portal, to help us to serve you better.

Indeed, it's more a branding website than an administrative tool.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by helij on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:34AM (#25645301)
I on the other hand find the design of gov.uk websites one of the best out there.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by jokethrowaway on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:48AM (#25645436)
I agree UK services are ahead of other countries I've experienced but they are still terrible in my experience. That said I know very well some contractors that worked on gov.uk and they're top notch. That's probably were the technical excellence come from. The bureaucracy and process are the problems.

They're much worse than any UK private company or UK bank I had to work with.

HMRC is terrible, there are tons of error on the payslips, they mess up tax codes all the times, part of the website uses a previous UI and not the cool modern one, several functions need you to call and queue for 1hr or send letters and hope. Having an accountant helps as they have access to a special version of HMRC they can use to do things mere mortals can't.

Childcare services are embarrassing and require you to have a subaccount in your governments account. I've spent 3 months without access because they asked me security questions for the childcare service on HMRC; I provided HMRC security answers and got locked out; the procedure to restore the account involved verifying my identity by providing via email certified copy of various documents. They were extremely slow in replying (sometimes not replying at all), they never returned any copies or originals I sent and they were extremely picky about certifications so I ended up having to send 3-4 certified and original documents.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by vidarh on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:33AM (#25646553)
Most of the problems tend to occur when you are forced to interact with legacy versions of tools that were built prior to the buildout of the new gov.uk.

The old sites are all over the place.

I think part of the reason gov.uk has been a success is exactly that they were not forced to replace old systems wholesale, but were allowed to build out a platform and methodology that works well and replace public facing services bit by bit.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by lucraft on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:46AM (#25646696)
I interviewed at a large UK gov Ministry for a technical architect role a couple of years ago and one of their interview questions was:

"How would you architect new features on top of a legacy system implemented by an external agency that is hard to work with and has many bugs but we are unable to change in any way for contractual reasons?"

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by zebnyc on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @01:13PM (#25648728)
I am curious to know how one would answer to this. Is it related to DDD concepts like maintaining upstream/downstream dependencies, boundary contexts and migrate piecemeal?
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by lostlogin on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @12:44PM (#25648335)
How did you answer?

It isn’t a technical problem...

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by vidarh on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:15AM (#25683873)
Sure, it is a technical problem too. It's a technical workaround to a political problem of not being able to touch the other platform.

My approach to this has been to embrace, extend, extinguish (yes, that was an intentional reference, sorry):

Insert a constrained API "around" the service you can't modify. Change all your services to go via that API instead of direct. Now you can apply the fixes you can to the new layer while finding ways to gradually replace it in parallel.

At the same time the new layer provides a constraint: It should be as narrow as you can get away with - creating a "new contract" with the API consumers about what they're actually allowed to do without negotiating with you, and ensure that any expansion of dependencies on the service you can't touch get documented and appropriate attempts made to avoid increasing complexity (it's good to do this in general, but realistically it's easier to get buy-in to enforce in limited cases like this).

This intersection of tech with procedures and politics lie at the heart of a lot of technical architecture work. A huge proportion of the work we do is not technically hard in and of itself - it becomes technically hard because of organisational considerations.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by baq on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @12:24PM (#25647954)
i'd expect nothing less. only surprise is that there hasn't been any 'hypothetically' here.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by gerdesj on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:02AM (#25646870)
I've been doing self assessment for 20 years now and it almost fills itself in these days - the P60 stuff and pensions etc do anyway. Getting your car taxed is embarrassingly simple and takes seconds as does checking your car MOT and insurance status. I don't have an accountant for SE and I do my wife's as well.

The amount of documentation available is amazing. This is a great example of what's available: https://www.gov.uk/transition . Scroll down to Announcements, hit the first link and you have the full withdrawal agreement in multiple freely open formats.

No it not perfect but it is rather good for this user anecdote.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by gpderetta on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:57AM (#25647518)
I have always had to fill in pension and P60 by hand (not that it is particularly hard); has this changed in the last year? Which reminds me that I need to do the self assesment before the end of the month.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by gerdesj on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @06:10PM (#25664007)
I think it (P60 and Pension) was filled in last year for me as well. The service is being changed quite quickly but I can imagine the pain behind the scenes. Screens that used to look like the old green/yellow thing are becoming rarer and the front screen has more options.

My overall impression is that we have a rather sensible GOV.UK thingie (not sure of the real brand)

Make sure you settle up before Jan 31 otherwise you'll be fined. HMRC are merciless. Get it done mate.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by gpderetta on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:39AM (#25671502)
I started the return a couple of days ago and the P60 was indeed filled in; I'm pretty sure that it wasn't last year, but I might misremember. The P11 was not, but I don't think I have anything to report as everything is taxed at source for my current employer (I'll double check of course).

The pension (Assuming you refer to the private pension scheme) is not filled in and I already know I have to pay some tax on that as I overshoot my allowance.

I normally get it done a couple of weeks before the 31 and doesn't take more than a couple of days even with triple checking everything, so I should be quite in time.

And yes, TBH filling in the tax return has never been a big problem. It would b e nice to automate a few more things (like computing exchange rates for dividends/capital gains instead of having to look them up) but it is fairly straightforward.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by zucker42 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:32AM (#25645284)
What's wrong with their aesthetics? I've always found their simple design to be quite nice.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by skrebbel on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:33AM (#25645296)
I think he means they don't look particularly "high tech" or something. Which I'd say is a feature.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by mytailorisrich on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:38AM (#25645334)
It's simple and clear. The aim is to convey information, not to be fancy and bloated, indeed.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by blackhaz on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:07AM (#25645610)
And gov.uk's clear design looks better than most of the wild wild web out there, to be honest.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by tclancy on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:56AM (#25645513)
I believe it is: given the focus and care on accessibility for all users, there's a limit to how many whizbang widgets are ok to use.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by g_p on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @01:42PM (#25649177)
Gov.UK had a good article a while back (appeared on HN) where they pointed out the importance of designing for no JS. All official gov.uk sites that I'm aware of will work without JavaScript.

They had an analysis showing how many % of their visits had broken JS support and therefore the need to build for the lowest common denominator.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by gm3dmo on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:34PM (#25652164)
https://www.gov.uk/service-manual/technology/using-progressi...

When a team builds a service using the service manual as a guide so many things become so much easier.

Need to explain something to a non technical manager? The service manual has got you covered:

> Progressive enhancement is a way of building websites and applications. It’s based on the idea that you should start by making your page work with just HTML, before adding anything else like Cascading Style Sheets (CSS) and JavaScript.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by g_p on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @06:59PM (#25664630)
That's the one, progressive enhancement.

A great principle, and nice to see they even think about Lynx accessing the sites [0]

The post I was thinking about with the analysis of why JS/CSS shouldn't be assumed to work was [1].

[0] https://technology.blog.gov.uk/2016/09/19/why-we-use-progres...

[1] https://gds.blog.gov.uk/2013/10/21/how-many-people-are-missi...

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by npsomaratna on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:36AM (#25645319)
I was about to ask this myself. I think their simple design is quite intentional—and it perfectly fits it's purpose.

Addendum: plus being accessible (essential for any govt. service).

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by captn3m0 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:36AM (#25645909)
It all works with JS disabled. Their accessibility callouts are amazing, and they provide you callouts wherever accessibility-related concerns have not been closed (and a form to raise it as well).
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by heavenlyblue on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:54AM (#25645489)
UK only excels in static .gov.uk serving. They are great for informational purposes. The best one actually is the one serving Travel Guidance for any country in the world.

They are light years behind countries that have fully-fledged dynamic services provided by the government accessible through the ID Cards, as it is in the Baltics for example.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by jon-wood on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:27AM (#25645799)
The lack of ID card based auth isn't really the fault of the team behind gov.uk, who provide the best service they can for government SSO in the form of Verify: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/introducing-govuk...

National ID cards are a particularly thorny issue politically, there's been a few attempts to introduce them, all of which have been noisily shut down in parliament because of privacy concerns. There isn't really any single database of people in the UK, with different ministries having their own databases. In principle this seems like a pretty good approach, even if it does mean that things like authentication with web services is a bit clunky.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by marksomnian on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:59AM (#25646840)
GDS are clearly aware of this problem and are working on this as well, with "GOV.UK Accounts" [0]

https://gds.blog.gov.uk/2020/09/22/introducing-gov-uk-accoun...

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by gm3dmo on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:44PM (#25652255)
> UK only excels in static .gov.uk serving

I'd put forward Gov.uk/pay and Gov.uk/notify as very successful transactional services that operate on a massive scale. They have been particularly good for local councils who just hook up to Notify and Pay. The parts where security is paramount are handled centrally. It stops councils having to "roll their own".

Universal Credit is a transactional system handling billions in benefits. When the conservative government shut down the economy in March it seems to have coped pretty well:

https://dwpdigital.blog.gov.uk/2020/12/14/dwps-agile-respons...

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by fakedang on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @12:30PM (#25648054)
There's a nice episode of Yes, Minister showing why ID cards are a particularly thorny issue. One of the indicated reasons was how it's akin to Nazi armbands.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by bartread on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:33AM (#25645293)
> I have lived in five countries now, but not one (local or state) government had an online presence that was nearly as good as the gov.uk infrastructure.

It is a neverending source of wonder to me that, whilst our government may be a shambles[0], our government services are so fantastic. They really are very impressive and, for the most part, very easy to use. Clearly a group of people have invested a lot of time and effort into this, and to me they demonstrate very clearly the value of investing heavily in user experience.

Also, the site is almost never down, which is good for somebody like me who tends to remember that they need to do thing X at random-o-clock at night.

[0] Not intended as an especially partisan statement as I have been known to vote Conservative (and over the last few years have criticised both Labour and Conservatives pretty equally), but I think it's tricky to argue that, as an example, sending 3 million kids back to school for 1 day before changing your mind demonstrates competent leadership.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by acta_non_verba on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:12AM (#25645653)
This is the main advantage of western democracies, right? Institutions and the day to day running of the country are separate to the executive.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by iso1210 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @12:19PM (#25647867)
I believe they're known as "Unelected bureaucrats"
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by thu2111 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:43PM (#25650010)
I think you're seeing differences between job cultures more than politicians vs civil service. Politicians are doing crazy stuff and reversing direction 24 hours later all over the world because that's what public health "experts" are doing. The WHO is notorious for it, they have routinely made contradictory announcements within days or weeks of each other in 2020 and this will probably continue in 2021. Public health is just making it up as they go along and this is reflected through politicians, who basically just do whatever they're told by their "expert" committees even if it makes them look foolish.

gov.uk is run by software engineers, presumably pretty good ones. They make decisions based on data and know how to interpret it.

One thing that has become super clear to me in 2020 is the huge quality gap between CS culture and public health culture, at least in research. Public health research papers and especially epidemiology papers contain not just severe errors all the time but are flat out deceptive in ways I just never see in the output of CS research or the software industry. For example I never encounter bogus citations in CS papers but that happens all the time in epidemiology papers. Public health research superficially looks and feels like science but when you scratch the surface the scientific method has gone AWOL, good data practices have gone AWOL, basic logic and integrity has gone AWOL. It's just a disaster zone.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by ignoranceprior on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:50AM (#25646054)
In the US, 18F does a good job:

https://18f.gsa.gov

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by systemvoltage on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:46AM (#25646699)
Agreed. I like the US design system more than anything else out there: https://designsystem.digital.gov/

It’s incredibly well thought out and designed.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by rvz on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:06AM (#25645601)
If there is one thing that the UK government gets praise for by the general public, it has to be gov.uk (secretly).

Everything else, they're at the top of the Tower of Blame.

Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by aledalgrande on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:34PM (#25649918)
I know some of the people that worked on the gov.uk project. They are really good.
Re:Busiest hour ever in the history of Gov.uk 17M page reque... by cblconfederate on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:32AM (#25646530)
i m glad the greek govt copied their design: https://www.gov.gr