News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by chadash on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:27AM (#25507096)
This title is misleading:

>The Protecting Lawful Streaming Act would apply only to commercial, for-profit streaming piracy services. The law will not sweep in normal practices by online service providers, good faith business disputes, noncommercial activities, or in any way impact individuals who access pirated streams or unwittingly stream unauthorized copies of copyrighted works. Individuals who might use pirate streaming services will not be affected.

This affects platforms, not users. Illegal streaming will not be a felony. Creating a for-profit platform with intent to do illegal streaming will be.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by roblabla on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:43AM (#25507339)
This appears to be correct from reading the (very short) text[0]. Everyone discussing this law should really read the text instead of reading whatever nonsense the media is spinning.

Here's the full text of what is being prohibited:

> PROHIBITED ACT.

> — It shall be unlawful to willfully, and for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain, offer or provide to the public a digital transmission service that

> (1) is primarily designed or provided for the purpose of publicly performing works protected under title 17 by means of a digital transmission without the authority of the copyright owner or the law;

> (2) has no commercially significant purpose or use other than to publicly perform works protected under title 17 by means of a digital transmission without the authority of the copyright owner or the law;

> or (3) is intentionally marketed by or at the direction of that person to promote its use in publicly performing works protected under title 17 by means of a digital transmission without the authority of the copyright owner or the law.

From my understanding, this basically means they'll go after platforms (since they are the ones doing the act of offering to the public a digital transmission service).

[0] https://www.tillis.senate.gov/services/files/A30B0C08-FB97-4...

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by jmull on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:21PM (#25508682)
Sounds like if I, e.g. have a podcast where I play and review songs (without permission), I can be charged with a felony if I, say, take paid ads on the podcast.

Perhaps simply a monetized streaming channel where I dance to the current hits is enough to put me in jail... it’s certainly seems enough to at least put me on trial.

I think you have to wonder: what’s insufficient about the civil and criminal laws? What is the current serious problem with streaming that this very strong law is needed to stamp it out?

To me it seems inevitable that it will be applied much more strongly than what you are thinking. “Purpose”, “intentionally”, “significant”, “primarily” can be, and therefore probably will be, argued to have wide meanings.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by whiddershins on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:28PM (#25508767)
> has no commercially significant purpose or use other than to publicly perform works protected under title 17
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dmurray on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:56PM (#25509105)
It doesn't have to meet that criterion to fit the definition. It could meet clause 1 or (more likely on GP's examples) clause 3 instead).
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by ummonk on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:47PM (#25509692)
What's weird is that the bill doesn't have an or conjunction between clause 1 and 2 lol.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:27PM (#25510087)
That's not weird. The bill says "a transmission service that (1); (2); or (3)". That's just how English conjunctions work when you're joining more than two things.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by ummonk on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:31PM (#25510143)
Yeah, fair enough. I'm just used to seeing most legal codes have a conjunction between each element of a list for clarity, or a description before the list whether each element needs to be satisfied or just one of them.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by pbourke on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:51PM (#25509038)
That seems like a thing that will be litigated. Who knows what it will mean after it’s been through the ringer of the US court system.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Kranar on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:32PM (#25508822)
Yes, if you are the one distributing the podcast directly on a platform you control and the platform is primarily to distribute music you don't own the copyright to, it doesn't matter if you happen to be dancing while the music is playing, that is copyright infringement and under this law would be criminal.

You can always have a podcast that reviews songs, and people have been reviewing songs for as long as there has been music without the need to play substantial portions of the song itself. You just can't be the one distributing songs as a commercial enterprise and then saying that because there's a video of you dancing that makes copyright infringement acceptable.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dylan604 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:30PM (#25511473)
> that is copyright infringement and under this law would be criminal.

Whoa. This is crazy. Laws are stupid in that they can't be custom tailored for the situation of the accusation at hand. If I come out with a 0-day that allows me to bypass encryption of say Netflix that allows me a pristine copy of a video source that I then later stream on a paid-for streaming platform, then yes, that would be stealing. Therefore, criminal.

However, if you're some YT streamer, podcaster, etc that happens to receive money from ad share revenue and you have a segment with some copyrighted music in the background, then that is a far far way off from a criminal act. Civil maybe, but come on.

Laws need to be written so the punishment fits the crime/offense.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Asooka on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:16PM (#25511973)
> that would be stealing

No, that would be copyright infringement, which is not theft.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by mod on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:36PM (#25508863)
"Vocal coach reacts!"

I, for one, will be glad if these go away. (Plus, get them out of my feed, youtube. I don't watch them.)

Apparently they're so successful that other people are doing it now. I saw someone totally unrelated to music reacting to amateur music songs.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Kranar on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:38PM (#25508891)
Well those videos on Youtube won't be impacted by this. This law doesn't go after individuals who upload infringing content, rather it goes after the platform itself. It's unlikely Youtube will be affected by it.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by btown on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:12PM (#25509277)
While that may indeed be the intent, an aggressive prosecutor could make a strong argument that individual streamers dancing or singing unlicensed karaoke are providing a digital service (the word "platform" never appears in the text) that "is intentionally marketed by or at the direction of that person to promote its use in publicly performing works." Which would now be a freaking felony.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dllthomas on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:04PM (#25509848)
Going by the quoted portion of the bill up thread, "platform" doesn't appear in the relevant portions text but neither does "digital service" - it says "digital transmission service".

I am not certain whether that makes a difference.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dllthomas on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:10PM (#25509915)
From the definitions section of the bill as linked above:

> the term ‘digital transmission service’ means a service that has the primary purpose of publicly performing works by digital transmission;

So it probably makes less of a difference than we might hope.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by jmull on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:25PM (#25509428)
> This law doesn't go after individuals who upload infringing content, rather it goes after the platform itself.

Be careful. That's not what the law actually says. It doesn't mention "platform".

The term used is "digital transmission service", which is defined in terms of the undefined term "service". Perhaps there is some established narrow legal definition of the term "service" that will keep this law from being abused? Let's all hope so!

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dllthomas on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:05PM (#25511855)
I would read "digital transmission service" as a service offering digital transmission, but that's not what the bill says. It says "the term ‘digital transmission service’ means a service that has the primary purpose of publicly performing works by digital transmission;" which to my eyes does not clearly restrict it to platforms as opposed to, at, a YouTube channel. Unless, as you say, there is a restriction somewhere unspecified on what can be meant by "service".
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by belltaco on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:20PM (#25509372)
A YouTube channel can be considered a 'digital service'.

I don't see 'platform' in the text, where did you get that from?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by panarky on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:45AM (#25508194)
> for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain, offer or provide to the public a digital transmission service that

If it's a peer-to-peer streaming service where media consumers also serve media to other users, then the argument could be made that users themselves are providing the "digital transmission service".

There may not even be an identifiable, centralized "platform".

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by toyg on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:50AM (#25508263)
> has no commercially significant purpose or use other than to publicly perform works protected

This seems tailored to kill PopcornTime.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by grishka on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:51PM (#25509033)
Isn't PopcornTime free software, which means it has no commercially significant anything? Or is it meant to be read has no (commercially significant purpose) or (use)?
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by toyg on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:31PM (#25510868)
PopcornTime definitely has a commercially significant purpose, even if it’s free: it provides unrestricted access to large amounts of copyrighted material that has undisputed commercial value.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by tinus_hn on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:31PM (#25508795)
You could use PopcornTime for showing copyright-free videos, they exist
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by toyg on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:34PM (#25510890)
The fact that one has to point out that they exist at all, is indicative of how popular or significant they are on that platform.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dylan604 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:31PM (#25511490)
Or how popular they are NOT depending on your viewpoint
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by pseudalopex on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:48PM (#25512328)
That's why it says commercially significant.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by lemonspat on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:02PM (#25508433)
But is that "digital transmission service" run "for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain"? I agree with your theory, but not sure why you removed the qualifier from your theory. This seems more targeted to PopcornTime than bittorrent
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by panarky on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:06PM (#25508481)
Getting media for free is "private financial gain".
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by rkachowski on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:22PM (#25508693)
how so? you don't gain financially by receiving free media in any form, at best you avoid a monetary cost.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by onion2k on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:36PM (#25508868)
You're getting something that you'd otherwise have to pay for. That is legally considered a financial gain, even if it doesn't hold up to pedantic linguistic scrutiny. Legal definitions are often different to everyday language.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by knowhy on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:21PM (#25508671)
In Germany that is already the case. Streaming is "ok" here for the consumer whereas torrenting is illegal and practically dead by now. The legal argument is that you are distributor when using peer to peer. Under German law it doesn't matter if that is done for profit or not.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Asooka on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:20PM (#25512018)
Could this be used to make torrenting a felony then? In the case that you're sharing a commercial work, obviously. You sharing a torrent is essentially you providing a service (being in the swarm, sending chunks), which exists entirely and only to infringe one or several copyrighted works (the files in the torrent).
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by panarky on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:08PM (#25513642)
The prosecution might need to demonstrate that you knew you were serving copyrighted works to others.

Your defense might be that you thought you were only a user, not a dealer with intent to distribute.

And then the prosecution will enter this HN comment into evidence, proving that you knew exactly what you were doing.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by contravariant on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:03AM (#25507612)
Everyone seems to jump to conclusions a bit, though there's still some reason to be wary as I already see 2 ways that this would make it harder for someone to build a new streaming service.

Firstly it becomes very difficult to argue your streaming service has no 'commercially significant purpose' other than piracy when you're not making much money.

Secondly it gives the copyright enforcing industry a big amount of leverage to pressure you into doing things as failure to cooperate could easily be argued to make your platform intended for piracy.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by rndgermandude on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:22AM (#25507847)
>Firstly it becomes very difficult to argue your streaming service has no 'commercially significant purpose' other than piracy when you're not making much money.

It is a bit of a concern, but I see it less of a concern than you.

First, we're talking criminal law here, so the state has to argue their case and prove your guilt, not you have to prove your innocence.

Second, you still get 17 U.S. Code § 512 liability protection (DMCA takedown notices and resulting safe harbor) and if you can demonstrate you followed this in court, it would be a lot harder for the state to argue you deliberate did something wrong, especially if this concerns "user generated content" (harder, not impossible).

Third, you're fucked already anyway, ask Kim Dotcom (from megaupload) about it. If the government wants to come after you, it will, regardless of this law, and even regardless of whether you set foot on US soil ever.

>Secondly it gives the copyright enforcing industry a big amount of leverage to pressure you into doing things as failure to cooperate could easily be argued to make your platform intended for piracy.

Again, the law sets out what you have to do to have liability safe harbor under 17 U.S. Code § 512. If you follow that, it would be hard for the music industry to argue otherwise, and it's also not their place to sue you under this law in the first place. It's criminal law, and therefore only the state can prosecute. However, the music industry certainly would try to nudge prosecutors into bringing charges under this law, and/or bring it up in an civil proceedings to bolster their case. It could backfire for them tho, if the state refuses prosecution, then you have an argument in civil court that what you're doing was not considered illegal and the state decided you are not an illegal streaming service (or at least, that there was no sufficient evidence to make that case).

So I think it's not a great law, especially not if you want to do a (user content) streaming startup, but it's not that bad either.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by cogman10 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:32AM (#25507977)
I think the main issue I've got with this law is the fact that current laws already seem to cover it. It doesn't make sense to me why we needed additional criminal enforcement around, of all things, media streaming.

I'm really not a fan of how much our government bends over backwards to protect Disney's IP.

Kim Dotcom is a great example for how much protection is already enjoyed by copyright holders. It's crazy to expand that.

The other thing that really concerns me about this is how easily it could go wrong. Music, in particular, seems to be filled with legal landmines. Imagine hosting your own webpage for your band covering pop songs. Do you now have to fear federal prosecution?

Cases like this

https://variety.com/2020/music/news/katy-perry-dark-horse-re...

Terrify me for what it'll mean for media. Why? because it wasn't a clear cut "No, don't be stupid, these are totally different songs".

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Trombone12 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:40PM (#25508924)
Uh, that was about a very small bit of two songs that were very similar/identical. The notion that you can't just steal a large part a song and it'll be legal because it's not the full work is a pretty obvious one. Beyond that a ship-of-Theseus type ambiguity kicks in regarding to how much is needed to be taken for it to be thefth, as it does for most things that can be taken apart.

I guess it is worrying that the trial didn't decide if bits that small are protected or not before going on to decide if infringement happened, but I think this is mostly worrying for Katy Perry as it indicates that the hired lawyers are bad at their job.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by rndgermandude on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:52AM (#25508286)
>The other thing that really concerns me about this is how easily it could go wrong. Music, in particular, seems to be filled with legal landmines. Imagine hosting your own webpage for your band covering pop songs. Do you now have to fear federal prosecution?

I don't see anything in the law suggesting strict liability applies, therefore the state has to also show mens rea ("guilty mind"), i.e. the act was willful (or criminally negligent). Or am I missing something?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by tzs on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:31PM (#25510873)
> Kim Dotcom is a great example for how much protection is already enjoyed by copyright holders.

That was downloads. Commercial download piracy did indeed already have a lot of serious legal penalties. Commercial streaming piracy did not.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by r0m4n0 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:43AM (#25508170)
> First, we're talking criminal law here, so the state has to argue their case and prove your guilt, not you have to prove your innocence

Although factually correct, this is not how the system works in most circumstances. If someone in power believes you committed a crime based upon the current law and you get charged for that crime, fat chance you will be arguing semantics in court. You will be taking a plea deal unless you are extremely well funded.

I’m mostly wondering why we need to make these explicit laws to give more ammo to prosecutors. Is this really something that needs to be addressed now? Do we need to further criminal liability because the copyright enforcing industry can shift the expenses of policing their content onto publicly funded mechanisms?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by ev1 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:34PM (#25510165)
Note that I am not a fan of overarching copyright and crazy patents as is the current US system, and think the DMCA is broken.

My opinion is that I dislike bringing up Kim as a martyr for this every time it comes around/find it somewhat damaging to the argument. The entirety of the data and all servers were hosted in the US. They had vendors in the US, they had a significant US connection and jurisdiction almost certainly applies.

It was/is relatively obvious to pretty much anyone looking in from outside that their existence was largely based upon infringement, like the equivalent of current 2020 file locker providers streamtape, streamhoe, vidlox, fastdl, mixdl, dropdl, videobin, mixdrop, mystream, abcvideo, or the past days of 2shared, 4shared, filesonic, uploadedto... You really only ever saw those links in a few places and you know what they are for, they magically stayed up for months. It isn't a "personal files" argument, they were pretty explicitly knowingly profiting off this kind of activity, especially with megavideo streaming loading every kind of malicious pop-everything ad known to humankind.

The same files/shows/movies rarely lasted more than a day or two on Mediafire or Box.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:27AM (#25507920)
It could also kill streaming DJs and the services that support them.

If I play a DJ set over Twitch it could be argued that I'm doing it for profit because it's a form of self-promotion.

It also means that anyone who receives a DMCA take-down suit on YouTube can be accused of illicit streaming - which puts a lot of compilation creators into a legal grey area. Not to mention creators of original music who are on the wrong end of an illicit rights grab.

While the intent may be go to after pirate streaming, the reality is that aggressive lawyers can easily broaden the scope.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by greggturkington on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:54AM (#25508314)
You (or your venue) are paying paying royalties on the songs in your DJ set.

You're not performing without the authority of the copyright owner or the law.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by zenexer on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:18PM (#25508631)
If I were to share a Plex server with some friends, and that Plex server were to primarily include pirated content (say, whatever we couldn’t get through other streaming services), I’m sure an argument could be made that it’s public and is therefore subject to these laws.

Would a reasonable person with technical knowledge agree that such a scenario falls under this law? No. But do you really think the RIAA isn’t going to put pressure on prosecutors to go after individuals? Do you really think they’ll allow technically-competent jurors?

I don’t trust anyone involved here. There’s no way this won’t be abused to go after average people.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by someguydave on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @12:44AM (#25514762)
Even if individuals are not prosecuted, arguably Plex the company offers a platform this bill is attempting to outlaw.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by plussed_reader on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:48AM (#25507414)
" this law should really read the text instead of reading whatever nonsense the media is spinning."

It doesn't take you more than a few hours to go over 5000 pages of text, Right?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by cbsks on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:51AM (#25507460)
The linked pdf is 5 pages.

It seems like irresponsible journalism to not just include the text in any article written about it.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dvtrn on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:06AM (#25507642)
This is a problem I have with how a LOT of legal topics are covered, Bills, lawsuits and court cases are discussed, the merits opined, but nary a complaint, brief, motion or court opinion gets linked so I can read for my damn self what the actual law as voted on says.

It’s more of a surprise when it IS linked or embedded to read than not

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by omanom on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:08PM (#25509896)
https://www.congress.gov/search

https://www.congress.gov/member/thomas-tillis/T000476

I've had decent results consulting this site.

The bill in question has not, as far as I can tell, been brought up for consideration yet anywhere so the only text that exists is that which is linked in the submission.

Just looking at the co-sponsors alone, I'd be worried about this legislation.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by viridian on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @10:11AM (#25518329)
The bill has been passed. It was added into the omnibus bill as a part of negotiating between the Dems and the GOP.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by viridian on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @10:10AM (#25518312)
I agree in principle, but you wouldn't expect court documents in particular to exist for a new piece of legislation though. In this case we would want the proposed revision to the federal code.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by meragrin_ on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:07AM (#25507661)
But is the text of that PDF the same as the text in the monster bill?
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by roblabla on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:53AM (#25508294)
Yes, it is. You can trivially ctrl+f it to make sure.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by CDSlice on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:51AM (#25507466)
If by 5000 pages you mean 5, you might be correct if you are a really slow reader.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by est31 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:57AM (#25507552)
The entire package that legislators are asked to vote upon is 5000 pages long. It starts on page 2539.

https://rules.house.gov/sites/democrats.rules.house.gov/file...

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by btown on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:58PM (#25509130)
This makes me realize that torrenting is absolutely under attack here.

If you look at (3), an activity doesn't even need to be for commercial gain if it's "intentionally marketed," and moreover it does not need to actually perform a work to be in violation - it simply needs to be marketed as such and "offer" a service.

Which means that even an individual leeching a torrent (sending no copyrighted material in outbound packets) might arguably be in violation of the act, simply by sending out packets that advertise their membership in the network and the potential for them to upload copyrighted material.

IANAL and this would need to be tested in court. But it's dangerous ground.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by xmichael0 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:44PM (#25508964)
So sharing a Plex library with a few pirated videos is now a felony.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by elliekelly on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:51AM (#25507465)
That's what the linked press release[1] says but looking at the wording of the bill[2] I'm not so sure it's that cut and dry:

> It shall be unlawful to will-fully, and for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain, offer or provide to the public a digital transmission service that...

The term "private financial gain" typically includes an individual receiving anything of value. I agree it doesn't come after the consumers of illegally streamed content but I don't think it's fair to say it only targets for-profit platforms. And it's certainly much broader than targeting "criminal organizations" as the linked (not HN) headline wrongly suggests. Someone uploading protected content in exchange for reddit gold could easily fall within this definition of criminal conduct. People who "trade" files with one another might fall within it, too. I think the linked press release is intentionally downplaying the scope.

[1] "The Protecting Lawful Streaming Act would apply only to commercial, for-profit streaming piracy services. The law will not sweep in normal practices by online service providers, good faith business disputes, noncommercial activities, or in any way impact individuals who access pirated streams or unwittingly stream unauthorized copies of copyrighted works. Individuals who might use pirate streaming services will not be affected."

[2]https://www.tillis.senate.gov/services/files/A30B0C08-FB97-4...

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by neuland on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:03AM (#25507617)
Yeah, I think people in this thread are really underestimating the ability for courts to over-apply laws that talk about commercial activity. If growing food on your own property for personal consumption can be "interstate commerce", then really any human activity can be justified as "commercial advantage or private financial gain".
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by csharptwdec19 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:36AM (#25508034)
I'd be curious to see if another lawyer could turn all of this on the heads of the 'digital market' as a whole.

> and for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain,

What if someone starts a streaming service where they get paid in 'tradable' items in a 3rd party game, where the EULA of said game makes it clear that that such items have no monetary value?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by m4rtink on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:10PM (#25508526)
This really reminds me of attempts to define a non-commercial open source license.

Basically, there aren't any in common use and no non-commercial OSS license was ever approved by OSI as no one could come up with a bullet proof way of defining what is and what is not non-commercial use for free software.

And I'm afraid the same lack of clear definition can get misused here as a result.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by SommaRaikkonen on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:05AM (#25507633)
You quoted the preamble but didn't quote the rest of the text: [...]transmission service that:

(1) is _primarily _ designed or provided for the purpose of publicly performing works protected under title 17 by means of a digital transmission without the authority of the copyright owner or the law;

(2) has _no commercially significant purpose or use other than_ to publicly perform works protected under title 17 by means of a digital transmission without the authority of the copyright owner or the law; or

(3) is _intentionally marketed by_ or at the direction of that person to promote its use in publicly performing works protected under title 17 by means of a digital transmission without the authority of the copyright owner or the law.

Emphasis are mine. It's clear to me through reading this that a service/platform that specifically aims and is marketed as streaming pirating content will suffer the consequences here.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by elliekelly on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:15AM (#25507757)
I envy your gift of statutory clarity. It isn't clear to me. And I can't imagine I'm the only lawyer who can spot the squishy bits of this legislation ripe for manipulation.

The three paragraphs you've quoted are "or" elements. A person need only violate one of the three to be criminally liable. Paragraph 2 is broad enough to include just about anything.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by SommaRaikkonen on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:27AM (#25507923)
Since you're a lawyer, please clarify for me one part so that I can understand. The paragraphs are presented as:

1 - condition 1;

2 - condition 2; or

3 - condition 3.

Does this mean that condition 1 should be applied all the time (1 and 2 _or_ 1 and 3) or (1 or 2 or 3) in order to be liable?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by elliekelly on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:57AM (#25508348)
As the other person commented, I read it as 1 or 2 or 3 though I'll admit this bill has exceptionally poor drafting. Typically to avoid that sort of confusion the "chapeau" would say something like "it shall be unlawful for a person to do one or more of the following" or "it shall be unlawful for a person to do (all of) the following".

You can see an example of drafting for (1 and 2) or 3 in paragraph 4 of the definitions section to give you a better idea of how the language and structure would differ in this section if it were intended to be read as (1 and 2) or (1 and 3).

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by mlyle on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:43AM (#25508165)
1 or 2 or 3.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:39AM (#25508085)
> This title is misleading

The title isn't misleading. You're just providing more details than exists in the title, which is the purpose of the link, which does provide that information.

But more to the point, the most objectionable part of this isn't the specific details of the streaming changes. It's... what business does any of this have in a Coronavirus relief bill? It's preposterous.

I feel like honest legislators should really start using this process against itself. The next time there is an omnibus bill like this, insert a line that says something like "every part of the December 2020 Coronavirus relief act not directly related to Coronavirus relief is repealed" and then let it sail through with that in the same way this did. Give them a disincentive to do things this way because they'll just lose it again next year.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:47AM (#25508222)
> what business does any of this have in a Coronavirus relief bill?

We didn’t have a coronavirus relief bill until yesterday. Bridging votes is part of policy negotiation.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by danShumway on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:18PM (#25510008)
5,500 pages of bridging votes? A bill that's so large that people literally don't have the ability to read it before they vote on it? Policy negotiations are normal. This is not normal.

I mean, heck, why bring up separate bills in Congress at all? Let's put off all legislation for the entire year and then we'll pass everything as one bill when it comes time for the spending bill. We don't even need to meet during the year, we'll just do the entire process via backroom deals and give people a few hours to sign on before they vote yes or no on everything for the entire year. It's not a broken legislative system, it's just compromise! /s

Yes bills are complicated, yes, compromise is necessary, but also there are obvious lines we can cross where there's no reason for a bill to be so bloated and discordant, and this bill crosses those lines.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:36PM (#25510930)
> 5,500 pages of bridging votes?

I'm not defending omnibus bills here nor was I above. I was defending pork. Even small bills are susceptible to legislation unrelated to the headline title sneaking in. That isn't always a bad thing.

> there are obvious lines we can cross where there's no reason for a bill to be so bloated and discordant

Conciseness takes work. Messes are easy. Rushed bills are heavy because the work of whittling it down hasn't been done.

In this case, I happened to be close to a senior Senate staffer as this bill was getting wrapped up. The way it works is each team takes a section and masters it. Tracks it from start to finish, keeps tabs on interested and affected parties, and reaches out to experts for clarification where necessary. This gets compiled into notes for senior staffers who distill it into policy and negotiating points for the elected. When I asked detailed question about the bill, knowledgeable answers came back within minutes. There is no Gell-Mann amnesia, at least not on this Senator's team. Anybody claiming they didn't have time to review the legislation is lying, unprepared or incompetent.

I agree something is given up by not having any single person with complete knowledge of the bill. But in a crisis, you don't have a choice between a concise non-existent bill and the hodgepodge. It's between the uncased sausage and going hungry. This was a self-inflicted crisis. There were months to do what was pushed against a deadline. In that, I find institutional failing. But given the deadline and the process, a big bill with some junk in it is not a bad outcome.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by danShumway on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:48PM (#25511057)
> But given the deadline and the process, a big bill with some junk in it is not a bad outcome.

It's a terrible outcome, you just may have not had a better one available to you. But let's not mince words, a 5500 page bill that no one has read in its entirety and that Congresspeople are blindly voting on because they literally do not have any other choice except to shut down the government during a pandemic -- that is a bad outcome.

> There were months to do what was pushed against a deadline. In that, I find institutional failing.

I strongly agree. I think where we differ is that I'm looking at the end result of that process as the fruits of that institutional failing, not as some kind of heroic last-minute turnaround that saved the day.

I don't mean to disparage the work you or others put in here, but you can have a multi-month project that gets ignored until the last week and you can accurately say at that point that there's no other choice but to throw something together in a few days to satisfy the requirements, and you might even do something incredible to get any finished project at all. But that doesn't mean the result isn't terrible.

I'm not giving anybody kudos over this, people should be looking at this result and saying, "something is seriously wrong with our political system that a bill like this is what we ended up with." That should be the main takeaway. A political system that only works during crisis, and that can only get the legislation passed when there's no other choice except to shut down the government -- that's a broken political system. It's not something anyone at any point in the process should be proud of.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:01PM (#25509817)
It is, but should it be?

The large majority of people agree that there should be Coronavirus relief. The people refusing are only doing so in order to perpetrate a stick up on something they know everybody wants in order to get something in that not everybody wants.

If you want your stupid garbage into the law, convince the majority of people that it's the right thing to do on its own merits. Horse trading against unrelated legislation is despicable, and doing it in the context of something people don't have time to read before they vote on it is even worse.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by chadash on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:56PM (#25509775)
The admins changed the title. The new title seems to be more accurate.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dang on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:29PM (#25510113)
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by skeeter2020 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:15PM (#25508599)
That's just how the press release on the sponsoring senator's web page spins it. It's essentially a combination of "don't worry if you've got nothing to hide" and "we're only going after the big bad criminals not everyday people who watch GoT once or twice".

But look at the actual text; there is enough ambiguity and opportunity here to use this as the launching pad for very questionable prosecution. If you're in a P2P network and getting free media does it qualify as a commercial enterprise and material gain?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Digory on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:48AM (#25508229)
This affects sharers, not freeloaders. "Platforms" are easy to create in the minds of judges.

It creates felonies like:

"Hey, if you'll chip in a few bucks, I can run a plex server for the dorm."

or

"Hey, neighbor, sure you can use my wifi to watch Netflix, if you'll pay half."

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by zenexer on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:22PM (#25508687)
Looking at the text of the law, I disagree. It doesn’t require that the service be commercial. The criteria are loose and broad enough that while they may appear to target platforms, they could certainly be abused by creative lawyers to target individuals.

Do you really trust that the RIAA won’t pressure prosecutors into targeting individuals? Heck, if you run a home media server, a good team of lawyers could probably convince a technologically-incompetent jury that you’re subject to this law.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by t-writescode on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:21PM (#25509377)
I'm not a lawyer, of course, but how do you read this part:

> It shall be unlawful to willfully, and for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain, offer or provide to the public a digital transmission service that...

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by zenexer on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:45PM (#25509672)
“Private financial gain” and “commercial advantage” are so broad that a decent lawyer could probably convince a carefully-selected jury that just about anything falls into one of those two categories.

We found Google’s ad tracking code in your server! (No need to tell the jury how ubiquitous Google Analytics is.) Something like that.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by elliekelly on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:25PM (#25509430)
(for purposes of commercial advantage) _or_ (private financial gain)
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by sleepysysadmin on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:28AM (#25507925)
>This affects platforms, not users. Illegal streaming will not be a felony. Creating a for-profit platform with intent to do illegal streaming will be.

That is already a crime. It's called Commercial copyright infringement and comes with rather extreme. This is even in international law. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Counterfeiting_Trade_Agre...

My read of this proposed bill is that it's not misleading. Illegal streaming by users becoming a felony. No different than what SOPA was proposing. Willful infringement becoming a felony is their goal and they will achieve it.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Mindwipe on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:34AM (#25507997)
Criminal copyright infringement didn't cover streaming previously.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by from on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:56AM (#25508339)
https://www.justice.gov/usao-edva/pr/eight-defendants-charge...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/12/16/men-plead...

https://torrentfreak.com/movie-pirate-pleads-guilty-faces-fi...

I think it did. The Jetflicks (essentially bootleg Netflix for $10/month) founders plead guilty to criminal copyright infringement and money laundering just recently. There was also a case covered on TorrentFreak of someone in Nevada running a similar scheme who just plead guilty to criminal copyright infringement.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by sleepysysadmin on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:12PM (#25508559)
>Criminal copyright infringement didn't cover streaming previously.

Why not?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by mackal on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:30PM (#25508790)
Fun fact, this is how Crunchyroll started. Illegal for-profit streaming site which eventually turned legal. And now Funimation is set to buy the site for $1.175b from AT&T.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by piokoch on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @04:53AM (#25516085)
I think that is perfectly correct approach, it should not be allowed to steal someone's profit.

Although I am a bit surprised since this law also applies to movies that are not profitable. In such cases producers should be happy that someone wants to give access to them despite loosing money while doing it.

One notable example of such unprofitable movie is "Return of the Jedi", which, after 40 years, has not provided any net income. Not even one cent. I am really impressed by heroism of all those movie producers that keep working so hard even though they earn nothing.

Or maybe it is not true that those movies are not profitable, maybe, for some strange reason, law enforcement is able to track all those pesky pirates, fish them from New Zealand hideaways, but is and was not able to retrieve a single tax dollar from movie studios for the past 70 years.

That's a puzzle which is apparently somehow missed by venerable members of US Congress and Senate.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by 300bps on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:00PM (#25509145)
If the law is passed it will be used as a sledgehammer to stop anyone from doing something they don’t like. It opens up the possibility of being interpreted as a for-profit platform.

Locast is a non-profit platform that streams local channels. It’s been sued left and right by broadcasters. So far unsuccessfully. Is this law the next step in putting pressure on them and others?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by 1f60c on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:11AM (#25507707)
> Creating a for-profit platform with intent to do illegal streaming will be.

Hasn't this been the case since... forever?

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dang on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:27PM (#25510091)
Yes, the submitted title was "Illegal Streaming to be a felony soon". That broke the site guidelines quite badly. They ask: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize." We've changed it now.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by milankragujevic on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:56PM (#25509102)
> Creating a for-profit platform with intent to do illegal streaming will be

Wasn't this already a felony? I clearly remember getting into legal problems with MPAA when I was 15 years old and made an online version of Popcorn Time, and that wasn't P2P.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by gruez on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:46AM (#25507378)
Does this change anything? Isn't criminal copyright infringement already a thing?
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dfxm12 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:54AM (#25507501)
Lookup "streaming loophole". This new law would make commercially offering a service of pirated content a felony whereas previously, it would have been a misdemeanor.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by xtracto on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:40AM (#25508121)
Goodbye IPTV... it was really good while it lasted.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by sukilot on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:54AM (#25507503)
This is an alternate angle, which allows prosecution without trying to count how many copies were streamed.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by simonebrunozzi on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @03:38AM (#25515680)
They could have done it 10-15 years ago, and Youtube and YouPorn would have not skyrocketed. (it's well known that their initial growth was mostly due to illegal videos being uploaded by users).
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by vmception on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:41AM (#25507299)
commercial is a simple as running ads
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by anonunivgrad on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:47AM (#25507401)
Running ads on copyrighted content that you didn't pay for is pretty nasty. Is that your position, defending profiteering off of someone else's content?
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by sukilot on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:55AM (#25507517)
"someone else's" is a view of property rights that not all hold.

"profiteering" (vs just covering costs) assumes facts not in evidence.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by vmception on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:50AM (#25508253)
I didn't state a position. You assume I implied one. The point was that this will cast a wide net over many services, in response to people pointing out who it wouldn't affect as it didn't seem they considered how most "amateur streamers" operate.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by nevinera on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:46AM (#25508205)
Yeah, but will that kind of nuanced phrasing get you to the top of a news aggregation site? ;-)
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by syshum on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:46PM (#25512304)
Yes because copyright law is never abused far far beyond the plain text reading of the law... never

/s

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by chadash on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:57PM (#25509779)
Note, it seems that the admins changed the title, with the new title being more accurate.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by kitotik on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:35PM (#25509552)
There would be no YouTube if this were on the books back in the day.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by croes on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:28AM (#25507929)
Isn't the use of an illegal service already a felony?
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by bigwavedave on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:58AM (#25508369)
> Isn't the use of an illegal service already a felony?

This doesn't cover the use of an illegal service. This goes after the platforms offering such content/services, not the individuals consuming the content/services.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by croes on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:40PM (#25508917)
I'm not talking about the new bill. If it's already illegal they don't need another law to go after the users.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by bigwavedave on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:22PM (#25510035)
This has nothing to do with users, so I'm not sure what your point is. A different example might help us communicate:

> "Hey guys, that relatively new way of dealing drugs is no longer a misdemeanor, now it's a felony."

> "But isn't using drugs already a felony?"

> "... yes, they already have a law to go after users; this new law just reclassifies the type of crime it is for cartels offering drugs."

> "Yeah, I'm not talking about the new bill. If it's already illegal they don't need another law to go after the users."

No laws have changed for consumers. I'm not sure what you're trying to say, please clarify.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Mindwipe on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:32AM (#25507985)
Not even remotely.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by uncomputation on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:23PM (#25508702)
It’s also not “to be a felony soon.” The bill hasnt even passed.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by PointyFluff on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:07AM (#25507657)
Either way, this is bullshit forced through into "must pass" legislation because they know this shit wouldn't pass otherwise.

This is fundamentally evil. Our senators are a pile of shit-enabling shit.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dang on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:30PM (#25510125)
Please don't post like this to HN. Perhaps you don't owe shit-enabling senators better, but you owe this community better if you're posting to it, and the site guidelines specifically ask you not to: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Edit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25498551 is also not ok. Could you please review the guidelines and use HN as intended?

[dead]
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by t-writescode on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:05PM (#25509201)
Calling them subhuman makes the implication that a human would be above such acts - and by implication that the person making those claims would be above such acts and protects the person from self-reflection.

It is dangerous to ever consider another person less than human.