News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by jmull on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:21PM (#25508682)
Sounds like if I, e.g. have a podcast where I play and review songs (without permission), I can be charged with a felony if I, say, take paid ads on the podcast.

Perhaps simply a monetized streaming channel where I dance to the current hits is enough to put me in jail... it’s certainly seems enough to at least put me on trial.

I think you have to wonder: what’s insufficient about the civil and criminal laws? What is the current serious problem with streaming that this very strong law is needed to stamp it out?

To me it seems inevitable that it will be applied much more strongly than what you are thinking. “Purpose”, “intentionally”, “significant”, “primarily” can be, and therefore probably will be, argued to have wide meanings.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by whiddershins on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:28PM (#25508767)
> has no commercially significant purpose or use other than to publicly perform works protected under title 17
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dmurray on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:56PM (#25509105)
It doesn't have to meet that criterion to fit the definition. It could meet clause 1 or (more likely on GP's examples) clause 3 instead).
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by ummonk on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:47PM (#25509692)
What's weird is that the bill doesn't have an or conjunction between clause 1 and 2 lol.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:27PM (#25510087)
That's not weird. The bill says "a transmission service that (1); (2); or (3)". That's just how English conjunctions work when you're joining more than two things.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by ummonk on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:31PM (#25510143)
Yeah, fair enough. I'm just used to seeing most legal codes have a conjunction between each element of a list for clarity, or a description before the list whether each element needs to be satisfied or just one of them.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by pbourke on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:51PM (#25509038)
That seems like a thing that will be litigated. Who knows what it will mean after it’s been through the ringer of the US court system.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Kranar on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:32PM (#25508822)
Yes, if you are the one distributing the podcast directly on a platform you control and the platform is primarily to distribute music you don't own the copyright to, it doesn't matter if you happen to be dancing while the music is playing, that is copyright infringement and under this law would be criminal.

You can always have a podcast that reviews songs, and people have been reviewing songs for as long as there has been music without the need to play substantial portions of the song itself. You just can't be the one distributing songs as a commercial enterprise and then saying that because there's a video of you dancing that makes copyright infringement acceptable.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dylan604 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:30PM (#25511473)
> that is copyright infringement and under this law would be criminal.

Whoa. This is crazy. Laws are stupid in that they can't be custom tailored for the situation of the accusation at hand. If I come out with a 0-day that allows me to bypass encryption of say Netflix that allows me a pristine copy of a video source that I then later stream on a paid-for streaming platform, then yes, that would be stealing. Therefore, criminal.

However, if you're some YT streamer, podcaster, etc that happens to receive money from ad share revenue and you have a segment with some copyrighted music in the background, then that is a far far way off from a criminal act. Civil maybe, but come on.

Laws need to be written so the punishment fits the crime/offense.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Asooka on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:16PM (#25511973)
> that would be stealing

No, that would be copyright infringement, which is not theft.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by mod on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:36PM (#25508863)
"Vocal coach reacts!"

I, for one, will be glad if these go away. (Plus, get them out of my feed, youtube. I don't watch them.)

Apparently they're so successful that other people are doing it now. I saw someone totally unrelated to music reacting to amateur music songs.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by Kranar on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:38PM (#25508891)
Well those videos on Youtube won't be impacted by this. This law doesn't go after individuals who upload infringing content, rather it goes after the platform itself. It's unlikely Youtube will be affected by it.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by btown on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:12PM (#25509277)
While that may indeed be the intent, an aggressive prosecutor could make a strong argument that individual streamers dancing or singing unlicensed karaoke are providing a digital service (the word "platform" never appears in the text) that "is intentionally marketed by or at the direction of that person to promote its use in publicly performing works." Which would now be a freaking felony.
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dllthomas on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:04PM (#25509848)
Going by the quoted portion of the bill up thread, "platform" doesn't appear in the relevant portions text but neither does "digital service" - it says "digital transmission service".

I am not certain whether that makes a difference.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dllthomas on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:10PM (#25509915)
From the definitions section of the bill as linked above:

> the term ‘digital transmission service’ means a service that has the primary purpose of publicly performing works by digital transmission;

So it probably makes less of a difference than we might hope.

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by jmull on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:25PM (#25509428)
> This law doesn't go after individuals who upload infringing content, rather it goes after the platform itself.

Be careful. That's not what the law actually says. It doesn't mention "platform".

The term used is "digital transmission service", which is defined in terms of the undefined term "service". Perhaps there is some established narrow legal definition of the term "service" that will keep this law from being abused? Let's all hope so!

Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by dllthomas on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:05PM (#25511855)
I would read "digital transmission service" as a service offering digital transmission, but that's not what the bill says. It says "the term ‘digital transmission service’ means a service that has the primary purpose of publicly performing works by digital transmission;" which to my eyes does not clearly restrict it to platforms as opposed to, at, a YouTube channel. Unless, as you say, there is a restriction somewhere unspecified on what can be meant by "service".
Re:Tillis Releases Text of Bipartisan Legislation to Fight I... by belltaco on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:20PM (#25509372)
A YouTube channel can be considered a 'digital service'.

I don't see 'platform' in the text, where did you get that from?