News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by rottencupcakes on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:04PM (#25164921)
I seem to remember just about 4 years ago when I logged into Google Voice and it said that Google Voice was moving into Google Hangouts.

https://images.techhive.com/images/article/2014/09/google-vo...

Why does it feel like no other software company has these sort of branding issues?

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by ineedasername on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:57PM (#25166606)
They really just don't seem to have a very well thought out strategy & roadmap for much of anything new/rebranded/merged.

I have no idea what the decision making looks like for this internally, but my impression as an outsider is that there's a lot of short-term empire building. A new product manager/AVP/VP shows up and wants to gather power or just make their mark, so they rebrand or merge or kill a project to show they've done something. If something new is created, it immediately becomes subject to this dynamic.

The only Google products I use that I feel I can rely on for daily use without fearing the rug getting pulled out are Gmail, Gcal, Search, and Docs. (And I don't know how they make money on Docs so I'm still nervous there) I'm not a PaaS users/decision maker so that doesn't apply to me, but if it did then I would still be very reluctant to invest there unless it was part of an easily migrated multi-cloud strategy. I though Music was safe and got burned on that with the YT migration, which is a much inferior player. Even basic things like shuffling a play list and having it endlessly play through it don't seem to work.. at some point it wanders off to some random suggested song I don't own and don't want to listen to.

It will be years before I could feel comfortable making any other sort of Google service a daily driver for a given task, assuming they get their act together.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by telltruth on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:09PM (#25167818)
This behavior is typically because management at the top is technically detached and focused only on financial aspects. This means actual technical strategy gets distributed to large number of desperate managers as opposed to getting systematically aggregated at the top. This same thing happened with Ballmer, Scully and now Pitchai. I think Pitchai and likely others are MBAs as well :).

Aaron Patzer, founder of Pando Daily has said that businesses should subtract $250K for every MBA and add $500K for every engineer. When you have MBA at the top, subtraction weight grows exponentially. I know I shouldn't so severely generalize MBAs so much but here we are... Just like Gates and Jobs, Larry Page chose an MBA to run the business while praising need for "product person" all their lives. All of these CEOs will show continuous revenue growth and doubling of profits somehow while products will linger in the limbo.

It is quite funny that Google has (or had) 6 different meeting apps and during COVID they are no where on the map in this business!

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by disillusioned on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:40PM (#25167905)
>It is quite funny that Google has (or had) 6 different meeting apps and during COVID they are no where on the map in this business!

I wouldn't call "adding 2 million users per day" nowhere on the map... Google Meet is growing tremendously and seeing huge attach rates, even as Zoom continues growth apace as well.

https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/g-suite/how-google-me...

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by vosper on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:54PM (#25167938)
Anecdote: the company I work for has largely moved from GoToMeeting to Meets. It's better than GTM in almost every way, and we were already paying for GSuite.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by IggleSniggle on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:22PM (#25167656)
I’m still sore about Google Music going away. That combined with Photos going paid was the one-two punch for me. In the process of migrating to roll-your-own solutions. There are a lot of good options in 2020!
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by igetspam on Saturday November 21, 2020 @10:27AM (#25170185)
I'm still sore about Reader...

Google Music was decent. This new replacement is not so good. The "I'm Feeling Lucky" mix was generally right. The YT versions are good for about five songs and then trail off into Do Not Like. No amount of thumbs down seems to be making a positive change.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by Tanath on Saturday November 21, 2020 @10:39AM (#25170245)
I'm still sore about Reader too. Fortunately Inoreader is about as good.

I'm surprised thumbing things down isn't helping you - it was the thing that fixed YTM for me. I wasn't thumbing things down enough, now anything I don't want to hear again I thumb down, and I mostly listen to the personalized and discovery mixes. You might need to switch/reload stations for it to take effect. And IIRC the discovery mix only updates on Wed.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jdeibele on Sunday November 22, 2020 @12:50PM (#25179370)
Google Reader has been gone so long that I really don't remember all the features that it had.

One thing that I seem to remember it having was a social aspect. Twitter doesn't treat its lists very well but it is possible to find somebody that you want to follow, then see what lists they're on. Maybe that leads you to other people that you want to follow.

The thing about blogs is that typically the signal/noise ratio is higher than Twitter accounts.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by telltruth on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:18PM (#25167846)
I was an ardent supporter of Google Music. Their web app sucked. It literally took like 10 seconds just to show up! So many missing features and recommendation was worse than someone coded it up in weekend. I still stuck with them, keep paying them and keep suffering. Then they decided to migrate the damn thing to YouTube Music and everything became 10X worse overnight. Now somehow YouTube vides is same as my music! Simple features like proper playlist management were entirely missing. Obviously, lot of empire building is going on here.

So that was final nail in the coffin for Google Music. I moved everything to Spotify (thanks Soundiiz!) and realized what I was missing. I thought I would now unsubscribe and stop paying Google Music so someone up there will noice. Guess what? They had no way to unsubscribe for Google Music anymore because they rolled the whole thing to YouTube Premium. So upper management will never know that customer left in droves. The empire builders who are working in this part of Google are super smart but they only use their smartness in building empires.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by hoyd on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:25AM (#25168335)
What replacements for Photos are you looking at?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by IggleSniggle on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:53AM (#25168565)
I was looking at OwnPhotos, Lychee, and Piwigo, but just today I turned up PhotoPrism which might be just the thing (haven’t really checked it out much yet but looks promising...Lychee seems like the tried and true open source solution afaict).

I’ve already dumped Google Drive for self-managed p2p file-sharing so it’s just a matter of hooking it up to a nice interface for family use.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by mceachen on Saturday November 21, 2020 @11:37AM (#25170646)
If your photos are scattered over several drives and you need something to sweep then into one neat pile, try PhotoStructure (I'm the author). The current beta release is available for free in exchange for your feedback.

It's got a bunch of features you won't find with any other photo app: https://photostructure.com/faq/why-photostructure/

but know that the product is young, and my to-do list is long: https://photostructure.com/about/whats-next/

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by IggleSniggle on Saturday November 21, 2020 @01:21PM (#25171561)
PhotoStructure looks awesome. I like how your site is almost a blog about the why-how etc, it showed me that your product is deeply aligned with my goals for a self-hosted photo solution.

I think you should prioritize in your “about” the ease of import from Google Takeouts (which is the killer feature for me personally at this moment anyway). You might also want to have a section that explicitly names the other “big” players in this space, since I didn’t turn up your solution when googling for “self-hosted Google Photos” when I first started down this path.

The one necessary feature that prevents me from choosing this right now vs some of the other open source solutions is a story about how to safely browse my photos using a logon with on any Internet connected device.

Speaking of, this might be a perfect use case for SQRL[0], although I’d be happy with a simple HTTPS username/password story.

Not making any promises, but let me know if you’d accept any help with your to-do list.

[0] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SQRL

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by kace91 on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:47PM (#25167239)
>The only Google products I use that I feel I can rely on for daily use without fearing the rug getting pulled out are Gmail, Gcal, Search, and Docs.

Surely maps as well? Or has there been any bad news I don't know about?

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by telltruth on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:21PM (#25167856)
So everything from pre Larry Lage era :). Definitely nothing from Pitchai's rein!
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by ineedasername on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:08PM (#25167343)
Sorry, forgot about maps
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by bobthepanda on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:33PM (#25166817)
People do pay for enterprise GSuite, so I wouldn't expect anything super crazy there.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by snazz on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:50PM (#25166920)
As a paying Google Workspace customer, I've found changes and improvements there to be well-thought-out and well-communicated. Google Cloud also has an entire deprecation policy, so I'm pretty comfortable relying on those services too.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by chaostheory on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:30PM (#25167681)
Yup, I thought Nest was safe from Google. I was wrong.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by 8note on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:17PM (#25167084)
Why wouldn't they turn off the calendar?

Docs seems ripe for being combined with drive

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by treis on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:45PM (#25167223)
Docs are combined with drive.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by new_guy on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:20PM (#25167648)
> And I don't know how they make money on Docs

By using them you're giving them complete 100% unfettered access to your data, that more than pays for itself.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by edouard-harris on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:45PM (#25167227)
> Why does it feel like no other software company has these sort of branding issues?

Google's internal incentive structure strongly favors shipping — at least, it did back in the day, and I believe that's still true now to a great extent. Steve Yegge said it most concisely back in 2006 [1]: "At Google, projects launch because it's the least-energy state for the system."

The problem is that when one dedicates so much optimization power to shipping, there's less left over for things like maintenance and support. That might not be a huge deal for any individual product, but in the aggregate it sets a higher bar for keeping an initiative running — which presents externally as an excessive proclivity for killing products.

That perception, in turn, erodes user trust in the continuing existence of Google's portfolio of non-flagship products. And that leads to even fewer of those products clearing the bar for maintenance funding, because users are less willing to commit to using a product that may be discontinued.

Google's shipping-first bias was probably a huge advantage for them in the early days. But sometimes a company outgrows aspects of its culture.

[1] https://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2006/09/

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by telltruth on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:26PM (#25167869)
Part of the problem is also that lot of Google products are free. So there is no real way to measure bottom line impact when they mess with or kill things outright. Their current upper management is basically MBAs focused only on bottom line so birthing new free products and killing them is not something they care too much about. Birthing is driven by empire builders and killing is driven by Ruth Porat.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by mike_d on Saturday November 21, 2020 @12:26AM (#25168030)
Things at Google aren't killed because they do or don't make money. Sure people have budget meetings and fight over hardware allocations, but things die because no engineers want to work on them. You don't get promoted for doing your job and maintaining things, you get promoted for inventing and doing new stuff.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by igetspam on Saturday November 21, 2020 @10:31AM (#25170204)
That's not entirely true. There have been plenty of shutdowns over the inability to monetize, either directly or via ads or data collection. Products have to have a value add for G or they don't survive. It's just that "money" isn't the only currency. The statement about promotion is spot on though.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jsight on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:27PM (#25166388)
> Why does it feel like no other software company has these sort of branding issues?

Ha, I was thinking this the other day as I was looking at Google Wallet / Google Pay / Android Pay and all the various permutations it has been through.

Play store hasn't been renamed in a while, though. I guess its next.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by SippinLean on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:38PM (#25166474)
Well, Play Music is already gone at least

https://play.google.com/store/apps/theme/promotion_gpm_shutd...

> The Music store on Google Play is no longer available.

> To continue listening to your Play Music library, transfer your library to YouTube Music

You can still Play Books though?

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by phreack on Saturday November 21, 2020 @01:24AM (#25168177)
Every once in a while I accidentally still call it Market. Somehow I found that to be such a great name that it stuck.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by hyperdimension on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:12AM (#25168456)
It really was a good name. Take anyone off the street from the (recent-ish) past and ask them what a 'play store' is. At least the word 'Market' makes a little bit more sense.

Who goes to the store to buy some extra 'play?'

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by dheera on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:26PM (#25165181)
There's Google Voice, Google Hangouts, Google Hangouts Meet, Google Meet, Google Allo, Google Duo, Google Chat. You used to be able to dial from Gmail, and then there was Hangouts Dialer, and now Meet (or is it Hangouts Meet?) is apparently part of Gmail and the Meet app is gone but the Meet website is still there.

I'm honestly confused.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by josephg on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:31PM (#25165241)
Don’t forget google voice, which may or may not be related to the hangouts dialer. I was never sure about that.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by dheera on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:35PM (#25165290)
I used the Hangouts Dialer to dial "from" my Google Voice number, but what I'm confused about is how the Hangouts Dialer is related to Hangouts.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by DebtDeflation on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:59PM (#25165555)
Circa 2014 or 2015 I used Hangouts Dialer with my Google Voice number over my hotel's wifi connection to make free calls when traveling internationally. Felt good man.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by josephg on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:12PM (#25165692)
I used it for awhile when I had a US bank account and lived overseas. I needed a working US phone number to authorize transactions.

I set up a google voice number just for that and it worked a treat.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jdofaz on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:58PM (#25165543)
You could use it to make calls from hangouts even if you didn't have a google voice number
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by harikb on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:29PM (#25167150)
Part of it is their internal obsession for everything being a Chrome extension and all tied to gmail. Just make a freaking native app for something as important as making a call.

For what is worth, I was a happy Grand central user from the very first days.

I wouldn’t even call this “empire building” by people as a sibling comment is suggesting. It is the eternal desire for companies to integrate everything together. Sometimes shit shouldn’t be all integrated together. Single sign on and single profile is not all the panacea that people make it out to be.

I am otherwise a Google fan boy in every sense and I hate what they did with Google Fi. I wanted to signup but I had to choose between giving up my Google Voice number or not having Fi. This is clearly because of this overzealous unification in a big company.

Signup for the free Google voice? Sure we let you choose a number you like? Signup for paid Google Fi, sorry we can’t let you choose a number.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by telltruth on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:29PM (#25167878)
If Microsoft missed the train on search business then Google missed the train on OS business. During Vista days Microsoft was extra-ordinarily vulnerable, people desperately looking for alternatives and some guy at Google decided that the Chrome must be our religion. Overnight priesthood of Chrome had build massive temples that no one outside of Google was interested. They were putting stupid Chrome OS on powerful laptops where hardware didn't get utilized or super under-powered laptops which you always find a scenario you can't use. Imagine if they had taken BSD, put on a great usable UX, an app store, auto sync to cloud and wide range of drivers then a strong alternative to OSX would have been born which would have given run for money to Microsoft.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by wnevets on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:34PM (#25165286)
>Why does it feel like no other software company has these sort of branding issues?

Have you seen the new Xbox names? Microsoft still loves to tack on Office on everything.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by hi5eyes on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:14PM (#25166276)
“while the Xbox Series S won't run the Xbox One X Enhanced versions of Xbox One and Xbox 360 games, it will still be a step above the Xbox One S“
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by corytheboyd on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:55PM (#25166593)
It’s truly insane.

Sony: PS, PS2, PS3, PS4, PS5

Microsoft: Xbox, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Xbox One Series X

There just _has_ to be some monetary reason for this, it’s too insane and has gone on too long for there to not be money involved somehow. Or maybe it truly is just insanity?!

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by majormajor on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:02PM (#25166631)
The naming conversations I've been close to for a couple of decently-high-profile consumer products really were just on the "insanity" side.

Like, everyone's argument made sense from a certain perspective, and the "common sense" ideas weren't perfect, but the compromise solutions that resulted had bigger problems. Problems which the media or public noticed more quickly than the people who had finally signed off on them internally...

My speculation for the early Xbox names would be that part of it was someone insisting that you don't want to be trying to sell Xbox 2 against PS3 - you're one behind! - and then 360 is a fun way to get a "3" in there... but then what next, you have the same problem again, 460 is nonsensical (Xbox 420 would've been fun...!), etc...

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by manigandham on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:27PM (#25167446)
That’s exactly what happened with Xbox being a number behind when coming up with 360. The later versions could've been handled much better though, or at least just stick with increasing numbers (like 720) instead of reverting back to "One" and now "Series X".
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by IggleSniggle on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:26PM (#25167667)
Why do I have the feeling that “Series X” will have only one entry in the series?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by yroc92 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:06AM (#25168290)
There’s two now- the Series S is the entry-level model.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by manigandham on Saturday November 21, 2020 @05:57PM (#25173380)
But that's a different "series".
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by adverbly on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:26PM (#25166781)
I don't know why more products dont follow the software pattern of cycling the alphabet. Pick a unique new name each time, and just run it down the alphabet for the first letter of the name. So easy.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by IggleSniggle on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:33PM (#25167691)
I do really enjoy this approach and have used it affectionately for every computer I’ve owned. It becomes its own entertaining challenge to pick a new name that fits with the theme that began with my first computer, “Ambrosia.” Anyway, definitely seems like an actually useful thing for software versions. Android nailed it.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by helmholtz on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:08PM (#25167812)
Why companies won't name their products after the launch years I will never understand. Car companies seem to do just fine with it. Xbox 2001, Xbox 2005 etc.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by pkulak on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:15AM (#25168310)
Who wants to buy a brand new xbox 2013 in 2020?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by pkulak on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:13AM (#25168307)
Just jump right to 10 like everyone (even MSFT!) does.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jkaplowitz on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:13PM (#25166710)
The odd naming is consistent with MS's history of Windows naming, too. Here's the consumer Windows product line since 1992, ignoring high-end options like NT and Chinese-only releases like Windows 3.2:

Windows 3.1, Windows 95, Windows 98, Windows Me, Windows XP, Windows Vista, Windows 7, Windows 8, Windows 8.1, Windows 10

I mean that sort of goes up as a general pattern, but only generally.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by curlypaul924 on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:15PM (#25167630)
In the case of Windows there were two (maybe three) different product lines all called Windows. The naming makes slightly more sense in that context.

* Windows 1/2/3.0/3.1/3.11/WFW3.11 - 16-bit (with 32-bit extensions as win32s), ran on DOS

* Concurrently, NT 3.1, 3.5, and 3.51 were marketed for servers instead of home users. They were fully 32 bit and separate from DOS.

* Windows 95/97/98 started naming after the year. This line eliminated DOS (from the user's perspective) and was 32-bit without the need for installing extensions.

* Concurrent with Windows 95 was NT4 which had 95's new interface based on Cairo

* At this point it was clear NT was the future for the desktop, so keeping with the year naming came Windows 2000 (which was really NT 5.0, but desktop users were by now used to year naming). But there was one more release of "old" Windows, as Millennium Edition (ME)

* The two names that dont fit are XP and Vista; these are NT 5.1 and 6.0, respectively. And now Windows 7 and 8 make more sense; we are back to the versioning we had starting with NT 3.1

* To make things more confusing, the server versions now started getting named after the year when previously that was the desktops. So we've got Windows Server 2000, 2003, 2008, 2011, and so on.

* Windows 10 is the oddball, skipping 9. I like to think someone at MS was poking fun at Apple, which skipped OS 9 to go straight to OS X, which two years later got the version 10.0. Mac OS 9 came after OS X but before OS X 10.0. I recall reading that 8.5 was originally supposed to be end of the line for classic mac os, but I don't have a source. So now there's 8.5, X 1.0, 9.0, and X 10.0, and everyone seems to think the X is a 10.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by wombatpm on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:28PM (#25167874)
There was also Windows CE fir the ipaq handhelds. This led to the joke that MS was going to combine mobile, server, and desktop into Windows CEMENT
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jkaplowitz on Saturday November 21, 2020 @12:12AM (#25168000)
Never heard that particular joke. Amazing, thanks for sharing.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jkaplowitz on Saturday November 21, 2020 @12:12AM (#25167998)
Yeah, I'm aware of the history. It adds more context to the mess but doesn't really make it sensible.

As for why they skipped 9, I believe I did hear a good reason for that one: people sometimes tested for Windows 95/98 by seeing if the version started with a 9, and they didn't want to clash with that. So this weirdness is simply an unintended side effect of their inconsistency in naming/versioning scheme.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by adrianmsmith on Saturday November 21, 2020 @05:04AM (#25168789)
I've heard that too, but can that be true? Wouldn't a lot of stuff have stopped working on Windows ME (the next edition after Windows 98) if that were the case?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jkaplowitz on Sunday November 22, 2020 @03:12AM (#25175859)
No, this wasn't for Windows executables working or not working in a core binary technical compatibility sense. This was for where either an app or a website needed to test the version number against several possible versions of Windows to determine which version of Windows they were running on and react (or reject) according to the programming.

For later versions of Windows, programmers applied other tests, but none of those tests stepped on the "does it start with 9" test for 95/98. Using 9 for the version after 8.1 would have done so.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by thebosz on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:13PM (#25166713)
The most recent version of Nintendo's 3DS is "New 3DS".

As in, the brand-new New 3DS! New! Buy it today!

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by lostmsu on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:32AM (#25168349)
Well, there also was New iPad
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by echelon on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:42PM (#25166873)
Wii. Wii U.

Consumers were confused.

It doesn't always work.

I'd be willing to bet that Microsoft "loses" this generation, with their confusing name losing sales from parents and non-hardcore gamers that don't know this is a new console.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by corytheboyd on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:46PM (#25166894)
Yeah I left Nintendo out because I just wanted to poke one insane naming scheme at a time :p

Nintendo is just as bad at naming things as Microsoft. And they are very anti-gamer with all of their ludicrous attacks against fan content (most recently, their attack against the competitive melee scene)

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by echelon on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:49PM (#25166916)
I understand not wanting to cannibalize the flagship Smash game, but they could easily sell a remastered Melee and make so much money. They re-release everything else...

Their attacks on fans are so nonsensical. It goes beyond copyright protection. Look at how Sega treats Sonic fans. It's night and day.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by SuoDuanDao on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:28PM (#25166789)
I assume someone gets paid a lot of money to make these decisions, and they don't want people to think they're a drain on resources. That seems to happen a lot when large organizations overthink decisions too trivial for the CEO but too important for the intern.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by petre on Saturday November 21, 2020 @01:57AM (#25168261)
It's interesting how Sony, being a Japanese company, did not skip over PS4, 4 being an unlucky number in some Asian cultures. They even skip the 4th floor in some buildings.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by tech234a on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:21PM (#25167411)
I recently saw a funny YouTube video about this by CircleToonsHD [1].

[1]: https://youtu.be/z1em05goyYU

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by curlypaul924 on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:07PM (#25167339)
Car manufacturers have a similar problem. I think naming is just hard.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jfoster on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:21PM (#25167410)
Or it's easy and gets made hard unnecessarily.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by rconti on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:40PM (#25165362)
Not software, but allow me to introduce you to Infiniti's (carmarker) recent product line revision where every model's name starts with "Q"
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by curlypaul924 on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:21PM (#25167653)
The Q has an historical meaning for Infiniti.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by rconti on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:43PM (#25172612)
The Q45 was their first vehicle, in ~1989. As far as I can tell, their second car was the M30, followed by the J30. Those were different (size) classes, so, historically, they've always used different letters to designate different models. While the QX4 (SUV) came out in, what, the late 90s, and ALSO began with a Q, it's never been a historical convention to just name all of their vehicles with a Q. There were only 2 "Q" vehicles, and one was actually a "QX".

I suppose you can call the Q superfluous, and then point to BMW if you want another company that just names cars by number, but at least there's a well-understood history and progression between the 3 series and the 5 series and the 7 series, but I have no idea what makes a Q60 (big number!) a sporty coupe that used to be a G35/G37 and now the QX30 is a small SUV-like-thing, that's, I guess, the size of older G35s but that means the Q60 somehow jumped 3 places in the tens column for no apparent reason.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by telltruth on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:37PM (#25167899)
Microsoft takes cake at branding nightmares. This is because each time CVP/VP gets replaced (usually 3-4 years), they want to "redo" the whole thing because last guy did it all wrong. Despite of all the praise that gets showered on Satya for stock price, he is relatively detached from product side.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by beamatronic on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:03PM (#25166174)
X Microsoft X1 Xbox One X 1 Office Edition
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by JumpCrisscross on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:11PM (#25165002)
I’ve been staying clear of Google Meets for this reason. Zero desire to trust them with something as critical as messaging.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by snazz on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:54PM (#25166948)
Google Meet is a paid Google Workspace product. You can feel fairly comfortable about it compared to their consumer products.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday November 22, 2020 @08:27AM (#25177264)
> Google Meet is a paid Google Workspace product

Nest was a paid, acquired, hardware product. If a product manager gets distracted, any Google product—apart from ads—will, if not fail, dramatically degrade. Google are a terrible company to bet anything important on.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by Tyr42 on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:48PM (#25166909)
Google meet is used for all the meetings internally. I doubt it's going to go anywhere. What would we do, pay for zoom?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by swiley on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:32PM (#25165876)
It's a shame webrtc uses it's own protocol. Otherwise there would probably be dozens of self hostable alternatives.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by fidelramos on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:49PM (#25166556)
It's not dozens, but Jitsi is a very decent open-source self-hostable alternative to Google Meet or Zoom.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by nikisweeting on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:04PM (#25167008)
WebRTC is an open standard, you can absolutely self-host a WebRTC video chat site, and there are many implementations available like Jitsi.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by polynomial on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:45PM (#25165979)
webrtc uses its own protocol?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by polynomial on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:44PM (#25165963)
Google arguably had first mover advantage in the video space which was the promised land even before Covid blessed it.

And yet by the time it hit this year, Zoom took the prize. I think this represents a much bigger fail on Google's part than I have seen being mentioned.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by JumpCrisscross on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:57PM (#25166113)
Nobody expects Google to competently execute. Their failures aren’t newsworthy.

Compare the effect on competitors’ stock prices when Amazon or Apple announce they’re moving into a market versus Google or Microsoft.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by devindotcom on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:15PM (#25166282)
Skype had about a 10 year head start on this and amazingly it's like the one brand I don't hear mentioned at all when it comes to video chat
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by Godel_unicode on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:40PM (#25166488)
Teams has on the order of 75 million daily active users, but it's the typical Microsoft story. Not widely talked about among startups, but totally ubiquitous in most companies.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by lotsofpulp on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:24PM (#25166370)
Both Microsoft and Google dropped the ball bigtime by letting WhatsApp take the whole international messaging market.

I remember how refreshingly easy to use Whatsapp was when it came out. It was such a pain to transfer contacts and images and whatnot before, and having to worry about international MMS/SMS charges. Then this tiny little app comes along and blows all the others away by simple requiring phone number verification.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by mc32 on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:33PM (#25166437)
Didn't they abandon that product for Teams, for enterprise users/customers?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by 1-6 on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:11PM (#25165009)
Autodesk is probably on par if not worse than Google when it comes to branding.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by beambot on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:52PM (#25165506)
Does Autodesk select product names that have close associations with major porn sites? Google has (i.e. YouTube Red).
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:57PM (#25165538)
"YouTube Red is closely associated with a porn site, redtube" is quite a take!
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by dmart on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:07PM (#25166207)
I’m not sure it’s that crazy of a take. Those are, by far, the two most recognizable websites in the world with “tube” in the name. Naming a product in a way that calls to mind the other (for no real reason - the “Red” in YouTube Red doesn’t mean anything) is an obvious branding error.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by Jasper_ on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:47PM (#25166542)
It's the reason they renamed it YouTube Premium after a year or two.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by polynomial on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:47PM (#25165993)
It's a bush league blunder I don't think any really experienced branding team would make.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by JadeNB on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:41PM (#25166495)
Let's just enjoy the beauty of "associating with a porn site is a bush league blunder."
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by kls on Friday November 20, 2020 @06:02PM (#25166160)
You could double down on purchasing existing companies and just leaving them hanging out there. Softimage comes to mind, it was honestly the best of breed in it's space and they acquired it along with wavefront/Maya and just let Softimage languash while they milked it for licencing.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jftuga on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:16PM (#25166734)
>Why does it feel like no other software company has these sort of branding issues?

AWS has entered the chat

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by jrumbut on Saturday November 21, 2020 @01:42AM (#25168229)
About every year the chat system (whatever you want to call it) and the voice system (the one that makes phone calls) is going away or being decommissioned or merged or something, and yet in about 8 years of usage I can't tell you what's actually changed.

Some new features, the icon, what it's next to? If they were actually going away I'm not sure how they could communicate that to me in a way I would believe at this point.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by corobo on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:24PM (#25167120)
Google is an ad company keeping itself busy. Busywork doesn't communicate with other busywork it just sort of spawns and dies
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by klipt on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:28PM (#25167145)
Yeah, someone in Hangouts probably got promoted for leading the integration of Voice, now years later someone in Voice plans to get promoted for undoing it.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by ricardo81 on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:06PM (#25165637)
Seems like if a product doesn't dominate a space, it's on shaky ground. At least search, youtube, maps, gmail have been relatively stable.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by solinent on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:17PM (#25167634)
The only products I use from Google originated somewhere else except Search and Gmail. Now I don't use Search or Gmail, either, Search started just giving me products to buy around the time they changed the algorithm, and I have lost trust in Gmail.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by disown on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:26PM (#25165826)
> Why does it feel like no other software company has these sort of branding issues?

This caught my eye. My initial reaction was to disagree that google was a software company and that it's more of a "tech/search/social media" company. Microsoft is a software company, not google. But the longer I think about it, the more it becomes apparent that google is a software company. It just provides its software as a service/subscription for your data.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:04PM (#25165605)
- That's from 2014, 6 years ago.

- There's no branding change, Google Voice is Google Voice.

- As an Android user the past 3 years, this is equivalent to Apple transitioning from iChat to iMessage, or when Apple appified/stickerified iMessage.

- It is very strange to see people turning this into a 'product cancellation' - Hangouts was deprecated _4 years ago_, it has a _direct_ replacement, scheduling and providing notice to users as it winds down over _years_ is hardly the irresponsible willy-nilly cancelling the comments here are claiming, especially because this is an integration of another product that is, and always has, its own frontend

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by nikisweeting on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:11PM (#25167052)
> Hangouts was deprecated _4 years ago_, it has a _direct_ replacement

What is the direct replacement? Spaces? Allo? Duo? Chat? Meet? Google Messages? Google+ Messenger? It's hardly clear...

I didn't even know chat.google.com existed until someone on HN linked to it a few weeks ago. I think it's pretty difficult to claim that Google's hodgepodge of overlapping chat products is anywhere close to the iChat -> iMessage change.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:26PM (#25167137)
Think that's a strawman, though you're right, I see this argument often. Coming from iOS -> Android, my mental model is Duo is FaceTime, Chat is Slack, Meet is Zoom. Allo is iMessage.

I don't grok how this could confuse, other than to people who aren't in the ecosystem or using the products at all, and even then it seems to be giving 0 charity to the facts on the ground. No one's bemoaning the deep confusion and duplication they face between iMessage, FaceTime, Slack, and Zoom.

Edit: I'm really, really, tired of understanding, calm, takes that make an effort to have empathy and share info getting downvoted, if it's outside a mono-Apple worldview. It is literally the only tech topic where you can immediately hit -2 for no discernable reason. This didn't used to happen on HN, and that's what used to make it distinctive.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by barnabee on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:47PM (#25167235)
On iOS, if it’s deprecated, what’s the replacement for Hangouts for normal users?

As far as I know there isn’t one. There are people I message with Hangouts pretty regularly and it’s never told me it’s deprecated or suggested anything else to use instead (except for just now, to switch to the dedicated Voice app for Voice, which… fine, but no suggestion to do my chatting elsewhere).

So is Hangouts deprecated? I have no idea. If it is, does that mean chatting with my Gmail contacts is deprecated?

I wouldn’t say it’s a straw man to call it confusing. Maybe the product lineup is less confusing if you’re on Android? But from where I’m sat… yep, confusing!

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:51PM (#25167538)
As parent noted, chat.google.com is the long term replacement, as you noted, Hangouts still works fine and no one's being pushed to Chat yet. It sounds like I'm being glib but you really are onto the nut of things once you've combined those two poles,

I agree, it is confusing! I wanted to make sure you meant 'chat in Gmail' before getting more specific: in that case, we are caught in a cycle of repeatedly noting Google has a deprecation timeline for cutting people over from Hangouts to chat.google.com, that's what the grandparent was referencing. It's virtually identical to Hangouts, just with modernized UI and Google sez a more stable backend. Everything works _just as it always has and will_ for your day to day user.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by Schnitz on Saturday November 21, 2020 @12:51AM (#25168076)
I’ve used Android 2010 to 2012, iOS 2012-2014 with iTunes Match, Android 2014 to 2020 with Google Music and just switched back to iOS with an iPhone 12 mini and Apple Music. I’m on Fi since 2015. After reading your message I realized how I probably should have used Android during the last year. To be honest, none of this was clear to me. I rooted for Android all the way, but at some point I started to migrate off the Google product and into an alternative when I got pushed from one service to the other for no benefits to me. On top of that, Android became more closed, with less and less apps being open source and replaced by proprietary Google apps. Now that I’m back to iOS I’m really amazed how the good parts just haven’t changed. Apple supports bringing my library just as well as iTunes Match did, for example. Also getting voice and sms on my laptop works out of the box, whereas a Fi on Android customer it sometimes worked better than other times for example I have no idea what I would use on a computer now that hangouts will be gone?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:04AM (#25168284)
Android's SMS app offers you to scan a QR code with messages.android.com to text from your computer, a la whatsapp, for all Android users. Additionally, Google Fi users can access voicemail/SMS/phone through that same app https://9to5google.com/2020/10/23/google-fi-web-messages/
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by nikisweeting on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:41PM (#25167207)
I absolutely bemoan the duplication between iMessage and FaceTime. Slack and Zoom are separate companies, different ballgame.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:48PM (#25167524)
I believe you're still able to draw a firm enough distinction between how Slack and iMessage are designed as to understand why they would be separate products. Is that accurate, or does iMessage feel like it could be merged into Slack at no loss to you?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by nikisweeting on Saturday November 21, 2020 @09:57AM (#25170045)
I don't understand, why would iMessage and slack be merged? They're separate companies.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Saturday November 21, 2020 @11:44AM (#25170714)
Yup! Are you _genuinely_ unable to answer a question about products unless all the products in question are owned by the same company?

This thread feels pretty suspicious IMHO, I really, really doubt you're missing the point this widely due to irrelevant details.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by antonvs on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:39PM (#25172591)
You feel like the one missing the point here. The discussion is about a change within the Google product line, what do Slack and Zoom have to do with it?

I get the impression you may be treating this as "what are the leading products in each niche for the overall ecosystem," but that doesn't really have anything to do with what's being discussed.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Saturday November 21, 2020 @07:18PM (#25173745)
I see:

I, at least, wouldn't clamor for the merger of an Apple-owned Slack and iMessage.

The point being, people are conflating work messaging apps with personal messaging apps and acting like having unique versions of both is a problem. It's not.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by nikisweeting on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:18PM (#25172007)
The thread is about duplication of products within a company's ecosystem, what I'm not understanding is why drawing a comparison between Slack and iMessage having some duplication is relevant. (also for the record I'm not downvoting you at all, HN likes to brigade when it comes to Apple/Google ecosystem stuff)
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Saturday November 21, 2020 @07:26PM (#25173790)
Interlocutory techniques like refusing to engage with the posts as written, and instead nitpicking, cause those outcomes.

I highly, highly, highly doubt that you were so deeply confused by the Meet/Slack Allo/iMessage analogy that you needed me to spell out 'hypothetically, if Apple owned Slack, which of course it doesn't, would it be more usable for you to have Slack merged with iMessage?' Your complete lack of charity in interpretation forces lengthy, caveated, responses in drawn-out threads, emphasizing downvotes, and ensuring several opportunities for downvotes.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by m_t on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:57PM (#25166107)
> It is very strange to see people turning this into a 'product cancellation' - Hangouts was deprecated _4 years ago_

So, let me get this straight. 6 years ago, Google made the Google Voice user move to hangout, and 2 years later it was deprecated?

It just seems worse.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:19PM (#25166746)
6 years ago, you could turn on a feature that let you receive Google Voice calls and messages in Hangouts.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by antonvs on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:57PM (#25172708)
There was a strong push to move from Voice to Hangouts. A couple of years ago the speculation was that Voice would be cancelled. See e.g. https://www.computerworld.com/article/3564825/google-voice.h... :

> But then, well, Google...Googled. It let Voice languish for years, without any attention or updates, then awkwardly half-merged it into Hangouts and had it rot away unattended for years. And we all know how the whole Hangouts saga ended (or is still in the process of ending, I guess we should say).

> A few years ago, though, something unexpected happened: Following years of neglect, Google suddenly brought Voice back to life.

You can find discussion of it on HN, e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19022660 :

> Don't get me started. I think my Google Voice / Hangouts account will be deprecated soon, or has been, and will be eliminated, or maybe not. It's not clear. It never is.

> Google voice has been all but deprecated at this point. The form for buying credits has been broken for a year, and calls calls to my google voice number no longer get forwarded to my phone / google hangouts.

Perhaps if you didn't live through all this, you don't get why people find it annoying.