News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:04PM (#25165605)
- That's from 2014, 6 years ago.

- There's no branding change, Google Voice is Google Voice.

- As an Android user the past 3 years, this is equivalent to Apple transitioning from iChat to iMessage, or when Apple appified/stickerified iMessage.

- It is very strange to see people turning this into a 'product cancellation' - Hangouts was deprecated _4 years ago_, it has a _direct_ replacement, scheduling and providing notice to users as it winds down over _years_ is hardly the irresponsible willy-nilly cancelling the comments here are claiming, especially because this is an integration of another product that is, and always has, its own frontend

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by nikisweeting on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:11PM (#25167052)
> Hangouts was deprecated _4 years ago_, it has a _direct_ replacement

What is the direct replacement? Spaces? Allo? Duo? Chat? Meet? Google Messages? Google+ Messenger? It's hardly clear...

I didn't even know chat.google.com existed until someone on HN linked to it a few weeks ago. I think it's pretty difficult to claim that Google's hodgepodge of overlapping chat products is anywhere close to the iChat -> iMessage change.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:26PM (#25167137)
Think that's a strawman, though you're right, I see this argument often. Coming from iOS -> Android, my mental model is Duo is FaceTime, Chat is Slack, Meet is Zoom. Allo is iMessage.

I don't grok how this could confuse, other than to people who aren't in the ecosystem or using the products at all, and even then it seems to be giving 0 charity to the facts on the ground. No one's bemoaning the deep confusion and duplication they face between iMessage, FaceTime, Slack, and Zoom.

Edit: I'm really, really, tired of understanding, calm, takes that make an effort to have empathy and share info getting downvoted, if it's outside a mono-Apple worldview. It is literally the only tech topic where you can immediately hit -2 for no discernable reason. This didn't used to happen on HN, and that's what used to make it distinctive.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by barnabee on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:47PM (#25167235)
On iOS, if it’s deprecated, what’s the replacement for Hangouts for normal users?

As far as I know there isn’t one. There are people I message with Hangouts pretty regularly and it’s never told me it’s deprecated or suggested anything else to use instead (except for just now, to switch to the dedicated Voice app for Voice, which… fine, but no suggestion to do my chatting elsewhere).

So is Hangouts deprecated? I have no idea. If it is, does that mean chatting with my Gmail contacts is deprecated?

I wouldn’t say it’s a straw man to call it confusing. Maybe the product lineup is less confusing if you’re on Android? But from where I’m sat… yep, confusing!

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:51PM (#25167538)
As parent noted, chat.google.com is the long term replacement, as you noted, Hangouts still works fine and no one's being pushed to Chat yet. It sounds like I'm being glib but you really are onto the nut of things once you've combined those two poles,

I agree, it is confusing! I wanted to make sure you meant 'chat in Gmail' before getting more specific: in that case, we are caught in a cycle of repeatedly noting Google has a deprecation timeline for cutting people over from Hangouts to chat.google.com, that's what the grandparent was referencing. It's virtually identical to Hangouts, just with modernized UI and Google sez a more stable backend. Everything works _just as it always has and will_ for your day to day user.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by Schnitz on Saturday November 21, 2020 @12:51AM (#25168076)
I’ve used Android 2010 to 2012, iOS 2012-2014 with iTunes Match, Android 2014 to 2020 with Google Music and just switched back to iOS with an iPhone 12 mini and Apple Music. I’m on Fi since 2015. After reading your message I realized how I probably should have used Android during the last year. To be honest, none of this was clear to me. I rooted for Android all the way, but at some point I started to migrate off the Google product and into an alternative when I got pushed from one service to the other for no benefits to me. On top of that, Android became more closed, with less and less apps being open source and replaced by proprietary Google apps. Now that I’m back to iOS I’m really amazed how the good parts just haven’t changed. Apple supports bringing my library just as well as iTunes Match did, for example. Also getting voice and sms on my laptop works out of the box, whereas a Fi on Android customer it sometimes worked better than other times for example I have no idea what I would use on a computer now that hangouts will be gone?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:04AM (#25168284)
Android's SMS app offers you to scan a QR code with messages.android.com to text from your computer, a la whatsapp, for all Android users. Additionally, Google Fi users can access voicemail/SMS/phone through that same app https://9to5google.com/2020/10/23/google-fi-web-messages/
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by nikisweeting on Friday November 20, 2020 @08:41PM (#25167207)
I absolutely bemoan the duplication between iMessage and FaceTime. Slack and Zoom are separate companies, different ballgame.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:48PM (#25167524)
I believe you're still able to draw a firm enough distinction between how Slack and iMessage are designed as to understand why they would be separate products. Is that accurate, or does iMessage feel like it could be merged into Slack at no loss to you?
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by nikisweeting on Saturday November 21, 2020 @09:57AM (#25170045)
I don't understand, why would iMessage and slack be merged? They're separate companies.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Saturday November 21, 2020 @11:44AM (#25170714)
Yup! Are you _genuinely_ unable to answer a question about products unless all the products in question are owned by the same company?

This thread feels pretty suspicious IMHO, I really, really doubt you're missing the point this widely due to irrelevant details.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by antonvs on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:39PM (#25172591)
You feel like the one missing the point here. The discussion is about a change within the Google product line, what do Slack and Zoom have to do with it?

I get the impression you may be treating this as "what are the leading products in each niche for the overall ecosystem," but that doesn't really have anything to do with what's being discussed.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Saturday November 21, 2020 @07:18PM (#25173745)
I see:

I, at least, wouldn't clamor for the merger of an Apple-owned Slack and iMessage.

The point being, people are conflating work messaging apps with personal messaging apps and acting like having unique versions of both is a problem. It's not.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by nikisweeting on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:18PM (#25172007)
The thread is about duplication of products within a company's ecosystem, what I'm not understanding is why drawing a comparison between Slack and iMessage having some duplication is relevant. (also for the record I'm not downvoting you at all, HN likes to brigade when it comes to Apple/Google ecosystem stuff)
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Saturday November 21, 2020 @07:26PM (#25173790)
Interlocutory techniques like refusing to engage with the posts as written, and instead nitpicking, cause those outcomes.

I highly, highly, highly doubt that you were so deeply confused by the Meet/Slack Allo/iMessage analogy that you needed me to spell out 'hypothetically, if Apple owned Slack, which of course it doesn't, would it be more usable for you to have Slack merged with iMessage?' Your complete lack of charity in interpretation forces lengthy, caveated, responses in drawn-out threads, emphasizing downvotes, and ensuring several opportunities for downvotes.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by m_t on Friday November 20, 2020 @05:57PM (#25166107)
> It is very strange to see people turning this into a 'product cancellation' - Hangouts was deprecated _4 years ago_

So, let me get this straight. 6 years ago, Google made the Google Voice user move to hangout, and 2 years later it was deprecated?

It just seems worse.

Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by refulgentis on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:19PM (#25166746)
6 years ago, you could turn on a feature that let you receive Google Voice calls and messages in Hangouts.
Re:Google plans to shut down Google Voice integration with c... by antonvs on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:57PM (#25172708)
There was a strong push to move from Voice to Hangouts. A couple of years ago the speculation was that Voice would be cancelled. See e.g. https://www.computerworld.com/article/3564825/google-voice.h... :

> But then, well, Google...Googled. It let Voice languish for years, without any attention or updates, then awkwardly half-merged it into Hangouts and had it rot away unattended for years. And we all know how the whole Hangouts saga ended (or is still in the process of ending, I guess we should say).

> A few years ago, though, something unexpected happened: Following years of neglect, Google suddenly brought Voice back to life.

You can find discussion of it on HN, e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19022660 :

> Don't get me started. I think my Google Voice / Hangouts account will be deprecated soon, or has been, and will be eliminated, or maybe not. It's not clear. It never is.

> Google voice has been all but deprecated at this point. The form for buying credits has been broken for a year, and calls calls to my google voice number no longer get forwarded to my phone / google hangouts.

Perhaps if you didn't live through all this, you don't get why people find it annoying.