Couple of examples...
On average, I need a car once or twice a week. Maybe three out of every four trips something really dinky like a smart car would do the job, whereas on one out of four I need the mid-sized estate car that I actually own. I live in a small village so to hire a car I'd have to get on a bus to the nearest town, then walk to the car hire place to get the car. That probably adds an hour to an hour and a half every time I need an estate car. Am I going to deal with that BS once every two weeks? Hell no. Even if I did, over time would it cost less than simply owning the damn car? Maybe, but it's pretty fricking marginal. I'd save a bit on fuel, no doubt, but economical cars hold their value much better than those that are less economical so the price of the cars (I always buy used) might not be so different.
I don't "use" my back garden a lot as a place to hang out, but it's certainly a handy place to leave the motorbike when I don't want to put it away, and also a great place for cutting up wood, MDF, and the like when I'm doing DIY.
The space has value that goes way beyond the amount of time that I use it for.
I could list plenty of other examples where this is true.
I think we can agree, this lifestyle is only for people living in the city in downtown or midtown with all amenities nearby.
When I did the math the insurance was close to 50% of my cost. Rest was depreciation, then gas, and maintenance.
Furthermore, the "uncertainty cost" is real. I have to rent a car. Will one be available? Will it be well maintained? Will the check out and check in process go smoothly? Can I get to the car? Etc. Etc. Each one and opportunity for things to go awry and end up in a bad day.
My completely-without-evidence theory is that there is some amount by which we can cut the allowed number of rideshare cars on the road at any time, and while wait times to get a vehicle might increase, the overall time will be the same or less because transit time will be reduced with less congestion.
To be fair, the government’s resistance to the rule of law, international promises or basic human rights is incredibly annoying too, so at least they are being consistent.
it really comes down to how you interpret the arbitrary 95% stated in the article. I agree with both the article and you. I need to sell that mandolin which I play maybe once a month but the patio sofa is here to stay even if I sit on it once a month because they are really nice to look at every day during golden hours. That's 100% usage for me.
To spend 5% of my waking time using my car I'd need to drive for 48 minutes every day, which I'm not even close to. I think it's unfair to count time when I'm asleep as time when I could possibly be using something (other than my bed!).
I think all of this debate points to one thing: the article is written from, and generalising from, a very myopic perspective, and shouldn't in any way be given serious consideration by many people for whom it doesn't and can't apply.
About your backyard, you're using it when you're not actually in it.
The garden, yeah, maybe, but I haven't used it in any capacity since last Friday.
Similarly people thought ebooks would be significantly cheaper, however counterintuitively they're not much cheaper and sometimes more expensive than a physical book because digital books are more convenient for many people.
A book author has basically 100% market monopoly on his/her books. He can set a high price and people who want to read the works will still pay.
Whereas ride sharing companies interchangeable and are in full competition with each other, which, in a healthy market, should bring the price down to the point where they're all only making a marginal profit. The cost of alternative mode of transportation does not come into equation (well unless it's overall cheaper and better - then it will kill the entire market segment).
My province in Canada shuttered the government-owned bus service a few years ago, so that isn’t even an option anymore. There haven’t really been any significant private offerings that have popped up in its place. If you’re in a small town with no car, you’re pretty much screwed!
On the surface, why have any fixed server infrastructure at all, anywhere? Well, if you don't, you're putting friction in front of anybody not authorised to spend to develop / test / prototype something. Yes, you can give everyone a cloud account and let them use that. But even then you'll have people cautiously limiting their usage to avoid accidentally overspending. By contrast, when that server is sitting their idle half the time, I actually feel guilty for NOT trying out some whacky idea on it. Of course, it can work exactly the opposite way - if you DO give all your developers complete freedom to run stuff in the cloud then they have even more liberty than if you give them a fixed server to work with. But I suspect few organisations would tolerate the potential cost risk from that.
It's a subtle mental difference but I think it can play into outcomes in a significant way.
I could see how for small companies, "spinning up a VM" would be a thing to consider carefully - but for bigger ones (and especially for "big data" workloads), cloud computing is really a no-brainer.
For unmetered usage, imagine that due to some circumstances, you end up having exclusive access to 2 powerful physical machines where you could do anything you want. These machines will be idling 95% of the time, but when you need it, they are ready to serve you immediately, with zero friction.
For metered usage, that would be public cloud, as you described.
> Then friends won't visit, it's more of a hassle to schedule - however infrequent these visits are they'll be even less frequent.
I would MUCH rather stay in a nearby hotel (and have my guests stay in a hotel). I would feel less like I was imposing.
> You'll go fewer places and do fewer things if everytime you want to go somewhere you have to deal with getting a rideshare van.
I think there's likely some truth to that, but it also means I rearrange my life to plan for this better and also to make those outings more meaningful.
> No backyard cookouts, no sitting on the deck, you'll go to the park less frequently
The analogy I use is the gym: I can do workouts at home, but the mental routine I have for getting up and going to the gym means I actually go much more often. Similarly, if there was a nearby park I liked I'd use it much more frequently. I know I felt that way when I lived in the city vs. where I do now in the burbs (note - the burbs weren't my choice ;)
You must be well-off with well-off friends.
My friends would feel pretty bad if I were to pay for their hotel, and it is not an insignificant cost to many (especially since I'm living in the Bay Area).
Crashing on a spare couch? No problemo.
(Even if the economics of the spare couch work out in the favor of the hotel room. There is a utility in the spare couch beyond letting guests sleep on it, and that understanding takes away all the feelings of imposing, at least financially.)
However, all of that ignores the fundamental difference. You're not my guest when you're in a hotel. I can't wake you up for breakfast and make you coffee. We can't watch movies on the couch until either feels sleepy. And so on.
You can't rent the experience of sharing your home with someone if you don't have a home to share.
Couldn't agree more. In most cases I'd rather crash on a friend's couch than sleep on a comfier hotel bed if it means we can hang out until we pass out and not have to worry about getting me back to my hotel.
I don't think extravagantly so, but I have worked in software for a couple decades and saved a lot.
But I think you're confusing the fundamental question here. Sure, when I was in my twenties I crashed at friends' places, and they at mine, all the time. But the article is specifically about the tradeoff of getting a smaller, cheaper, apartment, vs. getting a larger house in the suburbs with a spare guest room. The idea that it's usually a cheaper option to pay for the occasional hotel than to specifically purchase a larger house with rooms you rarely use. Obviously the "crash on my couch" is a different dynamic entirely.
Well then you are well-off. Most people can't swing 5 nights in a high CoL city without months and months of saving. Offering to pay for someone to stay in a hotel creates an extremely bad dynamic when the receiver couldn't easily afford that on their own.
>he idea that it's usually a cheaper option to pay for the occasional hotel than to specifically purchase a larger house with rooms you rarely use.
Yep, but the important distinction is that a hotel room isn't equivalent because it's a very easily measurable monetary burden on the host.
>You must be well-off with well-off friends.
As always, It Depends™. I have friends allergic to our pets, some have significant trouble sleeping on inflatable beds or couches, etc. Some have kids, so one couch / one bed won't cut it.
The only way it's reasonable for them to visit without having pretty major issues after a day or so is when we're all up for setting up a hotel + transportation (or similar)... which ends up meaning it's less often than some other friends.
I'm curious, have you actually paid for friends to get a hotel room while they were visiting you? How did that work?
I'm trying to imagine how I'd even offer without making it awkward. I don't think I could avoid making an already uncomfortable wealth disparity even more cringe-worthy.
I think if I had to go that route I would at least rent an entire house on an AirBnb so I could stay with my friends - that way they're actually staying with me, rather than in a hotel in the same city.
I agree on the larger AirBnB option; I think that's a great way to keep everyone together and (both physically and emotionally) comfortable.
Also, it means that they can basically never propose to come visit you (as they'd put you in an uncomfortable situation of having to approve/deny the hotel expense) and would only come by when you initiate the idea of a visit.
I think it depends on your relationship with the friends. There are some friends where I'd be really sad if they didn't stay with me or I didn't stay with them. We cook and drink together, and stay up late watching movies or TV or just talking, to the point where we don't want to worry about having to get one of us to a hotel.
One of my oldest friends has a cat that I'm mildly allergic to, but I will always sleep on his couch when I visit, even though the cost of a hotel room is well within my budget, and a hotel bed would probably be more comfortable than the couch. It's just so much more fun to stay with my friend. I get that this isn't for everyone, but that's kinda the point: everyone has different tastes.
> The analogy I use is the gym: I can do workouts at home, but the mental routine I have for getting up and going to the gym means I actually go much more often.
I've tried at various times to do the gym thing, but I just can never motivate myself. I think it's the overhead that kills it for me, the need to get myself ready to go, transport myself there, get into a routine, change, get myself home, etc. What ends up working for me is going for a 3-5 mile run in my neighborhood. I just change my shirt and pants, throw on running shoes, and go outside. I'm glad you've found a routine that helps keep you on track, but, again: everyone's different.
Not owning a car and taking uber everywhere seemed okay when living in a dense city, until covid happened and Uber all but ceased operations for a while.
The small condo in the city was a great choice when you went out most nights and worked at the office but it sucked terribly when circumstances changed and everyone was home all the time.
The main blockers for me are transaction costs - sure I can rent a car when I want to drive to the mountains but the amount of extra time and effort required means I’d probably not bother.
To be clear: it can work - I lived in central London and never bothered to own a car but, well, I don’t now because even something trivial like carrying around three car seats every time I wanted to take an uber would be so cumbersome I’d never do it.
That's not paying for 95%, that's paying for 99.99%
The math works out this way too - global economic impact from Covid is probably $16T in the US alone.
If I could have spent half my yearly income in 2019 to have a normal year in 2020 I would take that deal in a heartbeat and feel really good about it.
I don't think your math works though. First off we were talking about individual life choices, living small in a big city and paying to rent services/tools as you need them rather than living on a larger property, owning most of the tools/services you need. This isn't a one time cost, its not spend twice as much in 2019 for a normal 2020, its spend twice as much _every year_ in case a 2020 happens.
As for the covid impact, the US GDP was $21T in 2019, there's no way the economic impact in the US is 75% of last years GDP. That's like a civilization collapse level of recession. Lots of business seem to be doing fine, lot's of people are back to work.
Renting/buying a small home and using public spaces like parks and transit/walking, or renting/buying a large home with your own yard, buying your own car, etc.
The large home will serve you much better in a pandemic, cause many of those public options will be closed, but is that worth paying for when a pandemic will happen maybe once or twice in your lifetime?
It's not specifically a pandemic. It's the idea that it's worth being somewhat prepared to deal with things if a major event occurs.
I see a lot of merit to what the author is saying.
However, he completely ignores externalities. Yes, car is not used 95% of time. And he is saying, let's target the 5%. The problem is that it's not 5%, it's rather 3% of planned trips where his model works really well and 2% when you need a car right now and oh... the demand for local car share through the roof, so please wait for next 20 minutes.
And the same is true for everything else. People are buying extra on one hand to use it, but on another case to be an insurance that they can accommodate unplanned.
With COVID, I avoid taxis & ubers; I can take a zipcar-like rental with relatively low overhead, but one isn't always available next to me. When it is, it's sometimes not very clean. Those services have small-ish vehicles (and mostly electric ones) that are fine for city & surroundings, but if I want a weekend getaway I need to use real rental, and that's a lot more overhead (plus, if I get out 3 weekends per month, just the rentals would be more expensive than the car costs - and that, at a lower quality of the rented car; with COVID I don't get out as often, but previously, I used to).
I think living without a car definitely makes sense for some people; and definitely doesn't for others. But that depends a lot on your conditions, location and lifestyle.
Not everything needs insurance. And real insurance has costs that are pretty close to the expected average risk, while buying things just in case could be much more.
And the 1/10000 calculation was not the chance of huge trouble, it's 1/10000 to be unable to get a ride to have any trouble at all. The vast majority of those incidents are going to be worth much less than a thousand dollars. The chance of an event being that major is another factor of 1% or less.
Am I going to pay a thousand dollars a year to avoid a one in a million chance each of missing some important business meetings? Definitely not. Especially when other factors I can't change are much more likely to make me miss a meeting.
I mean, if I had odds that low of major illness I probably wouldn't pay hundreds of dollars a month for health insurance either!
As someone who had siblings that required various visits to the hospital for emergency things, using an ambulance each time would have paid for a couple of new cars.
Most healthcare isn't going to cover the use of an ambulance for a broken arm or a bunch of marbles up the nose and waiting for (and using) an Uber/Lyft in these scenarios is also pretty bad.
If it happens that often then the article wouldn't advise you against having a car.
> Most healthcare isn't going to cover the use of an ambulance for a broken arm or a bunch of marbles up the nose and waiting for (and using) an Uber/Lyft in these scenarios is also pretty bad.
If you're going to the emergency room you'll probably be waiting plenty long once you get there.
But on the other hand, I own a lot of specialty tools that probably only see a few minutes of use per year each, if that. Not having them means waits, sometime long waits, or making something to make do.
Someone who chose to have kids probably prefers the car. What makes sense to own depends on what you do.
That's the problem for me. I don't have a driver's license because public transit is good enough for 99.9% of trips. There are situations where it would be nice to be able to drive a car (esp. to get a rental car for countryside vacations, or for large Ikea purchases). But getting a driver's license doesn't make sense when you never really use it and fall out of practice, so my money is better invested in the national public transit flatrate card.
I don't have a garage, so if I bought a car, I'd likely have to go walk a few blocks to it. When I rent one, the "extra hassle" is I spend a minute on a phone app reserving it first.
I don't see it as a barrier, and at least at my use, way cheaper than a car. But the real gain is not dealing with parking, moving for street cleaning, parking tickets, broken windows, etc.
But of course you count the cost of the car and not just the gas, otherwise you're not actually comparing costs.
No.
Depreciation is something you consider if you intend to resell the vehicle. It's independent of wear and tear. It's a financial concept, not an engineering/mechanical concept. Jeep Wranglers, for example, hold a better value compared to the average even if they have higher mileage and age, especially if its in a mountainous local market.
Wear and tear is mechanical repairs and maintenance. Oil changes, tire changes, spark plugs, etc.
A good amount of people buy a certain car and maintain it, intending to run the vehicle into the ground completely.
If you really want to do the "simple math", don't forget about the opportunity costs associated with the wait times, scheduling around someone else's schedule and delays due to public transit and rideshares. That's where you realize just how much a car actually saves you. I used to live in Seattle and Portland for a few years (each). I bit that poisonous apple of, "I don't need a car since I'm going to live in the city". 15-20 minute car commutes would be about an hour on average on public transit (that's if they ran on time). Never. The. Fuck. Again.
See my 4runner that's older than I am. I am happy to give it its $400 per year in oil changes and amortized tires, along with $1500 repairs every other year because I know its repair ROI is extremely high (vs. whatever car make the reader believes is unreliable); every repair I make to it represents another XX,000 miles on the road.
(The 4WD and e-locker helps too)
Very much not the case in cities with excellent PT, where car trips can be far worse.
In such case, yearly depreciation is the cost of replacing the car with a new one, divided by the number of years until you replace it. In my calculations, I estimate I'll be driving my cars 20 years each, and base deprecation costs on that.
While you're factoring in intangibles, don't forget to factor in externalities caused by air and noise pollution.
If you want to bring up the value of intangibles, you then dont get to cherry pick certain intangibles that prove your point as to use them as the basis for your argument. You have to take into many intangibles, both pro and against your own stance to have a decent argument, let alone a realistic solution to the problem.
And if you actually pay attention to the argument, I dont mention to do ONE thing, as you straw manned me as saying to move to the suburbs. I say everyone needs to judge their own situations in an honest and logical fashion to better choose a solution for their personal needs. Not just listen to a random elitist trying to get on their highest of high horses to shame the rest of the population in their superficial future signaling. If you live in a heavy urban area with good public transit and high parking fees, hell no, dont own a car. It's a bad idea. But to imagine the exact same solution can apply to everywhere else in the world is a sign of a small minded twat that's never experienced life outside of their tiny bubble.
Literally what I felt you did and why I said to also consider environmental externalities.
I did not make any argument beyond that. I also did not claim you said to move to the suburbs. No idea where you get that from. It's just a thing I'm considering doing, because I can't stand the noise and pollution in the city much longer.
And you don't get any input.
If I purchase something that provides a capability for a given period of time, there is precisely zero reason why I should not think of it as a fractional cost per use. And there are many reasons why I find it a useful thing to do.
I have no idea why this should be controversial.
> I used to live in Seattle and Portland
Your actual claim is you prefer living the car lifestyle somewhere non-urban. Good on you, but irrelevant to me.
Plenty of people in the world live in much smaller places. See HK apartment or the "average" Tokyo apartment as examples.
I owned a car for 19yr old but haven't for 14 of the last 20 years. I don't miss it. But I live somewhere where I don't really need it.
Similarly with cars (in a couple, you are designated driver half the time, you have to look for parking, etc.; although I do have to own a car to go to the mountains, that's one use case that is simply not covered by rideshares and such), backyards/parks (doing stuff in the backyard is just boring, it's much easier to convince me to go to the park).
Indeed one would expect the "95%" owned versions to be inferior to the specialized ones; after all, the latter are specialized for a particular purpose, rather than a compromise faux replica like a guest room or a backyard.
But the thing op is talking about are visits to friends specifically, not visit in the same city. Those are the sort of visit when you come in for 2-3 days and both families intend to spend evening together and do activities together. So, the late night return is not the issue, because evening is spent together. And yes, saving money for visitor is one of purposes. Other is to make logistic of "being together as much as possible, being able to drink together after kids were put to sleep" is another. Yet another is to make it easy on granda when she visits or even babysit.
It is clear that you dont do those, which is obviously fine. But other people do.
I was thinking about what this person would consider the worst offender on this front in my lifestyle: early in the summer, we bought a teardrop camper trailer. I calculated how many nights of hotels it would take to even out the price, and it was a lot. But it also unlocked a bunch of trips this summer that we would have never taken without it. We could have rented a similar trailer for each of those trips, and we did look into that before we bought the trailer, but again, it was a hassle. In practice, we simply wouldn't have taken those trips. So a straight utilization comparison is not the right one.
In these cases, we trade money for convenience, instead of money for finished goods we can't or won't make ourselves (eg, pros are less likely to hurt themselves, so I hire them).
Then there are forcing functions. If you want to lose weight, don't keep snacks in the house. When my place had a postage sized lot, most of it in shade, I volunteered on a public spaces project and met a lot of cool people. (Also, I can highly, highly recommend walkable neighborhoods.)
I would wager that the author has better than average organizational skills if they can pull all of these things off. But perhaps instead of thinking of it as a grocery list, pick a couple of them that are easy to put down again, try them on and see how they feel. You can always buy a pickup truck later, or rent a bigger apartment.
I wouldn't want to rent a van for the same reason I never invited friends over when I couch surfed the first few months I moved to a new city
I guess it just depends what matters in your life. Some people like nice cars, its a depreciating assets and poor investment choice but if it makes you happy that's a lot of hidden value not being accounted for
I used Zipcar for ~3 years in San Francisco (closest location was 6 minutes away by foot), then bought a used car (my apartment has a garage spot for me). We're a family of 2.
Zipcar was nice, but I avoided using the car most of the time. When I bought a car, I found some sort of relief, and I of course ended up using the car way more frequently than Zipcar, while still biking around in SF most of the time. I did many more outdoor/weekend trips, in the order of 5x/6x.
But I think it as all just preferences on a spectrum.
Does this actually happen? I'm serious. I'd like to hear some stories of offering to pay for your friend staying at a hotel room while they are coming to visit you (and them actually accepting that offer). How does that even work? I mean socially, in terms of etiquette, embarrassment, and power imbalance?
That's why doing the math once and then no longer worrying about it makes sense. I generally am opposed to paying for what I don't use (prevalence of unlimited data plans in the US drives me nuts), that's why the article resonates with me - I usually frame it as "don't optimize for the edge case". What the post misses to me in the house example is that homes usually at the very least maintain their value, so the added expenses are only related to maintenance (higher property tax, cost of heating, cleaning, etc).
Unlimited data plans are totally worth it (particularly with visible where it’s only $25/month on party pay).
Reducing the amount of decisions you have to make frees you from drudgery - I’d argue it’s one of the best places to leverage money.
I don’t believe it’s possible to do the math once and no longer worry about it. Every time you call a ride it’s a purchase decision.
That's highly individual. I pay approximately that much with pay-per-GB data plan. Except now that I'm constantly home, I don't use the data, so my bills are lower.
> I don’t believe it’s possible to do the math once and no longer worry about it. Every time you call a ride it’s a purchase decision.
Same - it is an individual matter. I can definitely remember cases where I worried about not using something after I paid for it in advance and feeling bad (gym memberships immediately come to mind). Paying in advance makes every moment of your life into a "should I use the things I paid for now or later?" decision.
I still take the subway, I don't worry about it at all. The weather is part of the decision, the 2 EUR something aren't. I don't even know how much it is, exactly.
In my case, I know I don't expect to call a ride every other day, at most once or twice a month (even less now when bars are closed – but that's an edge situation). I know the approximate cost of a ride, typically €12, surge pricing may go up to twenty. So at the most, I expect calling a ride to cost me €20 a month.
That's less than what resident parking would cost for a car for the same month (a few years ago it was €9 / week). So the ride-sharing wins. I can think about this once and re-evaluate the situation every year. Yes, sometimes I may spend more on rides, sometimes less, but on average it's a cheaper way of getting around. So even though every time I call the ride it's technically a purchase decision in that I can decide not to do it and walk / bike / take the metro (assuming it's still open), it could be argued that I had already decided that in this situation I would call a ride. So no decision fatigue.
Note that driving my own car isn't exactly a "decisionless" process. I have to think where I'll go, whether I'll have easy surface parking (free) or whether I'll have to purchase underground parking. Plus, bonus points for underground parking being paid by the hour, so now I have to make a decision every hour about whether I want to stay out (purchase more parking) or leave.
Also, with regard to the data plan, we don't have those in France (that I know of). My plan has 40 GB and I've got it because it was cheaper than my older 15 GB plan. I know my usage never has me go above 3 to 4 GB. If an unlimited plan was available for a few more euros, that would be a net cost to me, for no practical gain in peace of mind or anything.
I suppose not everybody has a "boring routine-based" life so this approach may not work in each and every situation.
Hey, when some people think of the outdoors they think of a communal BBQ in the apartment quad. When some people think "park" they see green grass. When they think 'walk the dog' they mean go to a fenced acre with sections for small/medium dogs. Such people are urban dwellers who probably shouldn't venture past city limits.
But some of us own labradors, huskies or even wolfhounds. Walking them means a car ride to a river with a few miles to run. When we think "park" we think Zion or Jasper ... not Central. Some people like to rollerblade to the corner starbucks with their Havanese dog on a retractable leash. I prefer to save my coffee money and spend it on a proper car to haul me, my canoe and my chocolate lab to a river beside a mountain.
Remember the old Nissan commercials: Dogs_love_trucks.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_aYZrvG5BkY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XCKSXvhbQU
> Friends visiting from out of town? I’ll pay for their hotel, so I can live in a smaller, cheaper, better located condo for the rest of the year.
Then friends won't visit, it's more of a hassle to schedule - however infrequent these visits are they'll be even less frequent.
> I have to schlep a bunch of kids far away? I’ll get a Modo minivan, a local car share, for a few hours. Let someone else maintain that gorgeous van.
You'll go fewer places and do fewer things if everytime you want to go somewhere you have to deal with getting a rideshare van.
> Need some outdoors time? Walk a couple blocks to a park. I’m not interested in mowing something I only use a couple hours a week.
No backyard cookouts, no sitting on the deck, you'll go to the park less frequently.
It's the same for the rest of it, there are good reasons to reduce some of these things but the reasons he gives dismiss the true value.
Even owning a car vs. rideshare, sure rideshare can work out to be cheaper (sometimes) but having every travel decision be a purchase decision is a lot of overhead and is a constant pressure not to go somewhere.