News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by _jal on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:20PM (#24760124)
It is funny where people come down on this. I'm far better off not owning a car than if I had one, for instance, whether you measure in money or aggravation. Public transport here is lovely, rentals of multiple flavors plentiful, and maybe I'm strange, but when I owned a car, I knew what it cost me to own per mile or per day of ownership. It was routine for me to mentally estimate the cost of a trip.

But on the other hand, I own a lot of specialty tools that probably only see a few minutes of use per year each, if that. Not having them means waits, sometime long waits, or making something to make do.

Someone who chose to have kids probably prefers the car. What makes sense to own depends on what you do.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by aflag on Monday October 12, 2020 @07:25PM (#24760676)
I haven't owned a car in the past 5 years. But that's mostly because I never took the time to take a driving license in the new country I moved in (and the public transport being so good). However, I really miss it, if I hadn't been so lazy with my driver license this far I'd definitely buy a car, even if I used it once a month or less (driving to work makes no sense here). Sure, it's expensive. But you can just wake up one weekend and decide to drive to a different city, see something you haven't seen before. Also, if you need to buy something you're missing, you can just take your car and go comfortable. No need to wait for a bus or a train in the cold or rain. In these five years I barely left the city, but if I had a car, I think I'd have gone to many places over weekends.
Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by majewsky on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @04:24AM (#24763446)
> driver license

That's the problem for me. I don't have a driver's license because public transit is good enough for 99.9% of trips. There are situations where it would be nice to be able to drive a car (esp. to get a rental car for countryside vacations, or for large Ikea purchases). But getting a driver's license doesn't make sense when you never really use it and fall out of practice, so my money is better invested in the national public transit flatrate card.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by _jal on Monday October 12, 2020 @08:36PM (#24761145)
Between Zipcar and day-rentals, moving heavy things things or randomly taking a trip are trivial.

I don't have a garage, so if I bought a car, I'd likely have to go walk a few blocks to it. When I rent one, the "extra hassle" is I spend a minute on a phone app reserving it first.

I don't see it as a barrier, and at least at my use, way cheaper than a car. But the real gain is not dealing with parking, moving for street cleaning, parking tickets, broken windows, etc.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by etothepii on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:35PM (#24760244)
I suspect your per mile / per day costs were not the marginal ones. Once you've bought a car and insured it the cost per mile is "just" the gas and a penny for wear and tear.
Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by _jal on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:42PM (#24760310)
Cars wear out (depreciation), and insurance costs over time. It is simple math.

But of course you count the cost of the car and not just the gas, otherwise you're not actually comparing costs.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by NoOneNew on Monday October 12, 2020 @07:29PM (#24760697)
>Cars wear out (depreciation)

No.

Depreciation is something you consider if you intend to resell the vehicle. It's independent of wear and tear. It's a financial concept, not an engineering/mechanical concept. Jeep Wranglers, for example, hold a better value compared to the average even if they have higher mileage and age, especially if its in a mountainous local market.

Wear and tear is mechanical repairs and maintenance. Oil changes, tire changes, spark plugs, etc.

A good amount of people buy a certain car and maintain it, intending to run the vehicle into the ground completely.

If you really want to do the "simple math", don't forget about the opportunity costs associated with the wait times, scheduling around someone else's schedule and delays due to public transit and rideshares. That's where you realize just how much a car actually saves you. I used to live in Seattle and Portland for a few years (each). I bit that poisonous apple of, "I don't need a car since I'm going to live in the city". 15-20 minute car commutes would be about an hour on average on public transit (that's if they ran on time). Never. The. Fuck. Again.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by Snitch-Thursday on Monday October 12, 2020 @07:52PM (#24760854)
> A good amount of people buy a certain car and maintain it, intending to run the vehicle into the ground completely.

See my 4runner that's older than I am. I am happy to give it its $400 per year in oil changes and amortized tires, along with $1500 repairs every other year because I know its repair ROI is extremely high (vs. whatever car make the reader believes is unreliable); every repair I make to it represents another XX,000 miles on the road.

(The 4WD and e-locker helps too)

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by lotsofpulp on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @01:53AM (#24762670)
I feel like you can easily get per mile wear and tear costs to be 10 cents or less on Toyotas if you run them into the ground. And with fuel at 10 cents to 20 cents per mile assuming a $2.50 to $4.00 per gallon fuel cost and 20 miles per gallon, and insurance is another 5 cents to at most 10 cents per mile ($600 to $1,200 per year for 15k+ miles), you should be able to get the cost of a mile down to somewhere between 20 cents to 40 cents.
Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by giantDinosaur on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:37PM (#24761434)
Yes, if you live in a city with terrible public transit (from the sounds of it, every US city except about three.)

Very much not the case in cities with excellent PT, where car trips can be far worse.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by majewsky on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @04:28AM (#24763480)
Many cities with good public transit are still bogged down by politicians giving preference to car traffic over PT and bicycles, making journeys by PT slower and journeys by bike more dangerous than they need to be.
Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by cyberdrunk on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:20AM (#24764876)
> A good amount of people buy a certain car and maintain it, intending to run the vehicle into the ground completely.

In such case, yearly depreciation is the cost of replacing the car with a new one, divided by the number of years until you replace it. In my calculations, I estimate I'll be driving my cars 20 years each, and base deprecation costs on that.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by morsch on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @04:00AM (#24763317)
don't forget about the opportunity costs associated with the wait times, scheduling around someone else's schedule and delays due to public transit and rideshares

While you're factoring in intangibles, don't forget to factor in externalities caused by air and noise pollution.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by NoOneNew on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:22AM (#24765300)
I think the best intangible that needs to be taken into account is the self-righteous points. You can't put a price on how high of a high-horse you can get on. Minimalism and rent-culture is just like veganism, if you dont shove it down other people's throats are you really part of the movement?
Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by morsch on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @11:41AM (#24766640)
I don't follow.
Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by jpetso on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:51AM (#24773192)
They're saying it's okay to convince people with arguments about personal sacrifices, but if it's not hurting you directly and immediately then your argument annoys them and they don't want to hear about it.
Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by morsch on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:49AM (#24774223)
That's what they are saying? Air and noise pollution is hurting city dwellers like my family every single god damned day. The solution: move to the suburbs and get a car like everyone else. And here we are.
Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by NoOneNew on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @10:05AM (#24776650)
No.

If you want to bring up the value of intangibles, you then dont get to cherry pick certain intangibles that prove your point as to use them as the basis for your argument. You have to take into many intangibles, both pro and against your own stance to have a decent argument, let alone a realistic solution to the problem.

And if you actually pay attention to the argument, I dont mention to do ONE thing, as you straw manned me as saying to move to the suburbs. I say everyone needs to judge their own situations in an honest and logical fashion to better choose a solution for their personal needs. Not just listen to a random elitist trying to get on their highest of high horses to shame the rest of the population in their superficial future signaling. If you live in a heavy urban area with good public transit and high parking fees, hell no, dont own a car. It's a bad idea. But to imagine the exact same solution can apply to everywhere else in the world is a sign of a small minded twat that's never experienced life outside of their tiny bubble.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by morsch on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @10:39AM (#24777008)
> If you want to bring up the value of intangibles, you then dont get to cherry pick certain intangibles that prove your point as to use them as the basis for your argument.

Literally what I felt you did and why I said to also consider environmental externalities.

I did not make any argument beyond that. I also did not claim you said to move to the suburbs. No idea where you get that from. It's just a thing I'm considering doing, because I can't stand the noise and pollution in the city much longer.

Re:Don’t pay for 95% (2016) by _jal on Monday October 12, 2020 @08:27PM (#24761094)
Yes.

And you don't get any input.

If I purchase something that provides a capability for a given period of time, there is precisely zero reason why I should not think of it as a fractional cost per use. And there are many reasons why I find it a useful thing to do.

I have no idea why this should be controversial.

> I used to live in Seattle and Portland

Your actual claim is you prefer living the car lifestyle somewhere non-urban. Good on you, but irrelevant to me.