News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by 4cao on Thursday September 17, 2020 @12:26PM (#24506623)
This is a very good, if a bit windy, argument.

There would have been no technological progress we were able to enjoy in the past decade or two without the foundations laid by the open PC platform, and the Internet based on open standards.

These open foundations are now slowly being substituted piece by piece with proprietary walled gardens, and conversely we can now witness the pace of innovation subsiding.

In the current environment, there could not be another Google emerging as a successful contender the same way the original Google did, very much like there could not have been another Disney for quite a while, due to all the regulatory restrictions put in place largely as a result of the lobbying on the part of the original Disney: only this time it's more than Mickey Mouse's future that's at stake.

However, as the situation appears to be largely made possible by regulatory failure, the problem is inherently political, and any lasting solution would also have to be of such nature. Thus, while I wish Purism all the best, expecting them to be able to significantly change the situation is unfortunately not realistic.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by m463 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:15PM (#24508067)
I believe the pc revolution was created two ways:

Microsoft became a software giant, and to sell more copies of its software, it had to drive the price of hardware to zero.

This is "complements" joel talks about here [1]

By the commoditization hardware, people bought more copies of windows, and we all benefitted by the relentless march of faster, better, cheaper that resulted.

(The thing is they caused linux to flourish as software got more expensive)

Then apple did the opposite.

Apple is actually commoditizing software to sell hardware. Before the app store, software - very good apps actually - were frequently $39.95 or more.

Apple drove software to zero. It gives away the OS with it's hardware, and apps on the app store started at a few dollars, then 99 cents, then all the top apps were free.

and now data has become the way these free apps can survive and compete. advertisers and data brokers are the ones who fund things, by monetizing our data.

The thing is - I think hardware vendors can be aligned with free software. it sells hardware. purism can succeed. so can pine. and system76.

[1] https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by entropicdrifter on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:34PM (#24508301)
Likewise, we can thank Apple's commoditization of the software market for the rapid proliferation of microtransactions over the last decade.

Hopefully we'll soon see a new paradigm come along and dethrone the whole, "be annoying but just fun/useful enough to exploit the impatient and impulsive" monetization scheme so many microtransaction-heavy apps have taken up in lieu of just charging $5 up front.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by herf on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:51PM (#24509144)
This is well argued, and I think the big change there was the early-2000's DRM ideas: that a hardware platform like the iPod could protect the IP used on it. Initially this was seen as important for music, even though the restrictions got relaxed over time. But the same applies to any digital good.

As a result, we're seeing the software industry squashed (and commoditized) to fit the needs of a couple companies that control hardware today.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by tonyedgecombe on Friday September 18, 2020 @02:19AM (#24513510)
I largely agree although software pricing had been trending down long before the app stores came along. The marginal price of software is effectively zero so you would expect prices to converge on that in a competitive market.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 17, 2020 @12:36PM (#24506760)
> However, as the situation appears to be largely made possible by regulatory failure, the problem is inherently political, and any lasting solution would also have to be of such nature. Thus, while I wish Purism all the best, expecting them to be able to significantly change the situation is unfortunately not realistic.

I always hate this argument.

The idea that Purism is going to topple Apple overnight is pretty unrealistic. Even if they "succeed" it would be years, maybe decades before they're the dominant platform. That's an unreasonably long time to suffer the status quo and it makes sense to try to solve the problem in other ways before then.

But sometimes the regulatory solutions fail, e.g. because the incumbents pour money into the coffers of politicians. And chipping away at the the problem slowly in the market, over a decade or more, until the incumbents are weaker and a political solution can do them in, is far better than a permanent defeat as a result of long-term regulatory capture.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by ksdale on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:19PM (#24507299)
As an aside, here's me totally getting hung up on the chosen analogy - I find it somewhat interesting how fervently some people dislike private toll roads.

"Road I have to drive on and pay for" also describes public roads, it's just not as obvious when you're doing the paying. For the most part, I just have to suck it up and drive the places I need to go, and unlike the private road, I have to pay for public roads even if I don't use them at all.

Besides that, "expensive and well-maintained good/service that everyone is forced to use" basically describes the ideal in government provisioned anything, does it not? I mean, cheap and well-maintained would be better, but I'm not sure that exists anywhere...

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by bleepblorp on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:18PM (#24508758)
Everyone benefits from public roads even if they don't use them, though.

Since the pandemic, I barely use the road network personally, but all the physical goods I buy are transported over the roads, as are all the people who are employed to make them. From a financing perspective, I'm still an indirect road user.

While it's certainly possible to levy pay-per-use charges for roads, so businesses would pass indirect costs onto their customers. However, it's debatable whether the economic costs of doing so much bookkeeping, as opposed to just funding the road network out of general taxes, is worth the trouble.

Further, pay-per-use road pricing would involve serious invasions of privacy, and income equality impacts, for which the social costs arguably exceed any possible economic benefit.

For public goods that literally everyone benefits from, it hardly seems to be worth the trouble to make sure everyone pays only their share down to the cent.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by jacobr1 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:30PM (#24508902)
FWIW, we ALREADY have a pay-per-use system in the US (even if it isn't fully 1:1):

Petrol/Gas taxes are paid at both the federal and state levels as a proxy to usage.

Commercial trucks must pay for a Heavy Vehicle Use Tax, which again has both a federal and state component.

And of course, there are many new highways and a bridges that are financed with tolls.

And in the places like the UK there are congestion taxes for city centers.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by untog on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:09PM (#24507974)
The difference (as I see it) is that taxes are paid relative to how much you earn/are worth, while road tolls are the same for all. Everyone (outside of major metro areas where you can use public transit) needs roads, and driving to work on a tolled road will hurt the wallets of poor folks a lot more than it will rich folks.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by usetaxes on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:19PM (#24508778)
Public roads are paid for via gasoline taxes, eg a flat usage tax, and are thus nearly exactly as regressive as a toll.

The only difference is that a poor person could choose to drive an economy car, or an electric vehicle, in order to avoid paying their share of use tax. But so could a rich person.

The other difference is that the usage tax is a hidden cost and tolls are not.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by dmurray on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:39PM (#24509022)
Only about 40% of spending on roads in the US comes from tolls and fuel taxes [0]. It's not correct to call them "nearly as regressive as a toll": in terms of regressiveness, they're halfway between funding them from tolls and funding them from income/property/sales taxes.

[0] https://taxfoundation.org/states-road-funding-2019/

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by m463 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:17PM (#24508093)
yes, one person's equality may just be a regressive tax to someone else.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by MayeulC on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:24PM (#24508839)
Toll roads are fine as long as other routes exist to go to the same place, otherwise you artificailly restrict movement:

a) To those wealthy enough to pay

b) to those the toll road agree to let pass

And you have no choice but to increase the toll road's wealth each time you use the road. Moreover, it's a monopoly, which means that the toll road operator has no incentive to keep the road cheap nor well maintained, as long as there is not enough incentive for the public to open a new road.

A slightly better situation to be in is when there are multiple operators with multiple alternative toll roads, unfortunately:

c) That's a waste of duplicated efforts

d) It only works as long as there is no price collusion occuring

e) It doesn't solve the previous points.

And I think this is the point here. Are there viable paths with no tolls on them? We also need strong regulations for basic public service, and ensure that there is no monopoly.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by xiler on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:58PM (#24509220)
Roads are non-rivalrous (to an extent). Meaning during off-peak times a private toll road would likely be under utilized if it were not regulated/subsidized. Another reason is that if a road happens to be the shortest path between a populous area and an in-demand destination it would likely be something close to a natural monopoly. This could potentially lead to high prices, too many billboards, etc.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rivalry_(economics)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by webmaven on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:16PM (#24511935)
> Roads are non-rivalrous (to an extent). Meaning during off-peak times a private toll road would likely be under utilized if it were not regulated/subsidized.

Arterial roads may be non-rivalrous in the same sense as the internet backbone, but the last mile to your home is definitely a natural monopoly for both roads and ISPs. How would you feel about ubiquitous toll roads that start at the end of your driveway?

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by colinmhayes on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:10PM (#24509362)
The entire point of the toll road in Cancun is to keep locals away from the tourists. The toll didn't exist to pay for the road, it existed to create a perfect bubble that Americans could enjoy. That's why it cost three times more than the golden gate bridge.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by clairity on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:40PM (#24512743)
i hated cancun because of that weird desire to recreate an american beach destination in mexico, where, in addition to dollars and english, they also accepted pesos and spoke spanish. just go to florida, ffs.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by nodamage on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:15PM (#24510650)
> These measures are always marketed as being for security from hackers and more recently also in the name of privacy

That's because they are. The reality is the existence of side-loading and third-party stores on Android contributes directly to the spread of malware on the platform, which is why Google has made it more difficult to do so with each successive release of Android.

According to Nokia's threat intelligence report (https://onestore.nokia.com/asset/205835), Android devices were responsible for 47.15% of malware infections compared to 0.85% from iPhones. (Note that even after scaling for the number of devices there is still an order of magnitude difference.) Windows/PCs at 35.82% and IoT devices at 16.17% make up the rest. That's right, Android has overtaken Windows as the biggest malware vector on the planet.

According to Kaspersky's mobile malware report (https://securelist.com/mobile-malware-evolution-2019/96280/), 13.89% of users in the United States were attacked by mobile malware in 2019. In some other countries the numbers are significantly higher: 21.23% in Brazil, 24.14% in Mexico, 27.36% in Malaysia, 37.98% in India, and 60.64% in Iran. The overwhelming majority of mobile malware targets the Android platform.

If you want to argue that your right to "freedom" over your device is so important to you that you believe the risk of malware is worth the tradeoff, that's one thing, but don't hand-wave away the very real security benefits of strictly controlled devices as "marketing". It's disingenuous.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by jdofaz on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:54PM (#24510948)
How much of that malware came from the play store?
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by valuearb on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:37AM (#24505139)
“ These measures are always marketed as being for security from hackers and more recently also in the name of privacy, but from the beginning it has always been about ensuring that Apple can control which applications and accessories are allowed on the iPhone, in particular when those applications compete with their own offerings.”

Uh, well ok unsupported assertion. Apple has always allowed third party calendars, email clients, messaging apps, etc.

It’s always been security, privacy AND battery life. This original iPhone didn’t allow third party apps for a year, and they were only going to be web apps. Eventually they game up with a tight sandbox with strict limits on background processing that protected battery life, privacy and the essential phone functionality from rogue apps.

Being able to buy a tightly managed device that maximizes its battery life and your privacy and security is an important choice for consumers.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by bananaface on Thursday September 17, 2020 @12:10PM (#24506407)
Apple's calender, email client and messaging app don't generate revenue, they're loss leaders. There's no reason for them to block competitors to those apps.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by valuearb on Thursday September 17, 2020 @05:57PM (#24510465)
So what competitors are they blocking? Very few.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by bananaface on Friday September 18, 2020 @11:04AM (#24517665)
Competitors to the app store and competitors to Apple's payment processor.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by m463 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:29PM (#24508245)
Even the most cursory web search can easily support his assertion.

for instance apple has removed apps that help you find other apps. It has removed apps trying to use features available only to apple built-in apps (calling them private interfaces)

but really - the eu and the us are scrutinizing apple's store as anti-competitive. That's a pretty big indicator.

And even when apple doesn't outright remove apps, it cherry-picks design features of third-party apps to add it to their own apps.

myself, I would like to be able to compile and add my own apps to my phone. Just like computers used to be. I cannot do that without asking apple for permission.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by valuearb on Thursday September 17, 2020 @05:34PM (#24510237)
You can compile and add your own apps to your phone, using Xcode for free. You can distribute those apps to tens of thousands of people using TestFlight.

And apps helping you find other apps linked to the App Store, so wheres the competition?

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by m463 on Friday September 18, 2020 @12:23AM (#24512983)
wrt my wish to run apps on my phone, you missed the key point where you have to ask apple permission.

Even with "free", and accepting terms and conditions, and using your apple id, and all that stuff - I believe you have to renew the certificate weekly.

and testflight is a developer thing - with lots of extra asking permission.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:53AM (#24505336)
If people actually wanted this then they would be able to sell the exact same device without those restrictions, or have a configuration switch to disable them during a factory reset, and people who want it could still have the one with them. But they don't.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by dylz on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:19PM (#24507305)
I'm kind of curious how many general-purpose non-technical-HN-type people would want this with the connotation that you would need a signed untampered no-sideloading-allowed device to interact with many apps (such as any multiplayer game, all banking apps, any food ordering or delivery app, etc.), so you're permanently excluded from using or touching a significant amount of the ecosystem.

Identical situation currently plays out on desktop gaming, where anticheat software does not run in WINE or equivalent and you can't connect, and VMs are blocked and will result in bans from multiplayer games, to the point where if you are running normal Windows, you will be removed from the game for having VMware or Docker or anything similar open or running in the background. If you attempt to block these, you are refused service.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by teddyh on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:13PM (#24509393)
> I'm kind of curious how many general-purpose non-technical-HN-type people would want this

It’s kind of like free speech or privacy. Most people don’t need free speech, since they don’t have anything important to say. And most people don’t really need privacy, since they have no important secrets. However, it is very important for a society that everyone has those things, since otherwise society turns into something very ugly.

Likewise, most people probably wouldn’t sideload apps, manage their security keys, or anything else, but by not allowing those things, our society of computers and networking has turned rather ugly compared to what was originally imagined for it.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:48PM (#24509117)
The advantage of the unlocked device is, of course, that you can then have it forge all of the checks and run whatever apps you want anyway. The whole point is to run any apps you want to. You might end up with some cat and mouse there for the apps like anti-cheat, but they're Turing machines all the way down, and the user themselves doesn't have to develop the anti-fingerprinting technology. Moreover, how many games do you think will want the user to have an unlocked device, if it means they can distribute their game without paying 30% to Apple?

It is also, of course, ridiculous for a bank or food delivery app to refuse to install their app on a device which is actually controlled by the user when they allow the same device to do the same things on its website, and companies doing such things would have a tendency to lose customers to smarter competitors who don't.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by dylz on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:55PM (#24509199)
Yes, it's a cat and mouse game, but you only need to fail a check once, then it's "your account has been suspended indefinitely, please contact support".

> how many games do you think will want the user to have an unlocked device

Many more will rather be able to attest that the user isn't pirating all IAP.

> It is also, of course, ridiculous for a bank or food delivery app to refuse to install their app on a device which is actually controlled by the user when they allow the same device to do the same things on its website

Ridiculous, yes, but it's still done anyway. The same device is also often not allowed to do the same things on the website, or the website implements similar or identical fingerprinting code. Everything from polling tons of "logged in URLs" like facebook's favicon to detect what sites the user is logged into, to port scanning the user's LAN, none of this should be a thing and should be extremely illegal, but in practice it's abused heavily.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:13PM (#24509400)
> Yes, it's a cat and mouse game, but you only need to fail a check once, then it's "your account has been suspended indefinitely, please contact support".

Which the developer will have a market incentive to not want to do, because they can't get money from you if you're not using their product, and unlike phone platforms, most app developers have aggressive competition.

> Many more will rather be able to attest that the user isn't pirating all IAP.

Not really. If the user has an unlocked device, turning them away isn't going to turn a profit because then you lose their business regardless. Better to get the users who don't pirate than to lose them all. And it's not as if the user is going to lock the device back up for most of these games -- especially when there will be other apps that only work on an unlocked device.

> Everything from polling tons of "logged in URLs" like facebook's favicon to detect what sites the user is logged into, to port scanning the user's LAN, none of this should be a thing and should be extremely illegal, but in practice it's abused heavily.

The solution there being to stop patronizing anybody who does that, which everybody should already be doing as a general principle.

Moreover, all this is all rather academic when we could get the actual result by allowing the user to do this to their device and seeing what happens, so it can't be an argument for not doing that. Worst case is not very many people do it, and then still what is it hurting?

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by dylz on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:41PM (#24512069)
> The solution there being to stop patronizing anybody who does that, which everybody should already be doing as a general principle.

If only. Every single major US bank and card company does this. It's terrible.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by hyko on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:27PM (#24508227)
Such a weird analogy/anecdote/humblebrag, because it basically admits that the public roads are technically inferior, and to want to drive on them you have to make up a story about how you’re making the world a better place while literally accepting it as a worse place.

This basically boils down to the old people want the wrong things argument.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:02PM (#24511861)
Public roads are significantly cheaper to utilize, paid for by gas taxes. Using toll roads involves that has tax and then some. And the tolls don't always produce better quality considering the money and resources invested compared to usage.
Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by mark_l_watson on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:52AM (#24505329)
I certainly support the broad philosophy of the article, but for myself, I personally diverge a bit:

I worry most about control: visiting a web site and having political and other ads being based on my browsing history and the treasure trove of my data that gets collected from credit card purchases, web activity, etc. Read Zuboff's surveillance capitalism book.

My Apple Watch and iPhone are mostly stock - I don't generally install 3rd party apps. I feel that the use of these devices is consistent with my dedication to fight back against surveillance capitalism.

I have blogged about this a lot: it is easy to take basic steps like: install the freedom.to app on all your devices and block social media and other time wasting sites for most of the day; use private browsing tabs, and frequently delete all cookies from all browsers you use on all devices; etc.

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by m463 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:32PM (#24508284)
ios and safari are incredibly "leaky" even if you do not install third-party apps.

It would be nice if you could block network connections to the sites you disagree with. Or even find out if they were occurring. But you don't have any control over that - apple prevents it. At least macos has tcpdump and a firewall (for now)

Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads by mark_l_watson on Friday September 18, 2020 @06:23AM (#24514997)
The app available at https://freedom.to supports blocking specific sites, with lots of flexibility. I have been using Freedom for four days, and I already see a positive effect in my day to day life.