for instance apple has removed apps that help you find other apps. It has removed apps trying to use features available only to apple built-in apps (calling them private interfaces)
but really - the eu and the us are scrutinizing apple's store as anti-competitive. That's a pretty big indicator.
And even when apple doesn't outright remove apps, it cherry-picks design features of third-party apps to add it to their own apps.
myself, I would like to be able to compile and add my own apps to my phone. Just like computers used to be. I cannot do that without asking apple for permission.
And apps helping you find other apps linked to the App Store, so wheres the competition?
Even with "free", and accepting terms and conditions, and using your apple id, and all that stuff - I believe you have to renew the certificate weekly.
and testflight is a developer thing - with lots of extra asking permission.
Identical situation currently plays out on desktop gaming, where anticheat software does not run in WINE or equivalent and you can't connect, and VMs are blocked and will result in bans from multiplayer games, to the point where if you are running normal Windows, you will be removed from the game for having VMware or Docker or anything similar open or running in the background. If you attempt to block these, you are refused service.
It’s kind of like free speech or privacy. Most people don’t need free speech, since they don’t have anything important to say. And most people don’t really need privacy, since they have no important secrets. However, it is very important for a society that everyone has those things, since otherwise society turns into something very ugly.
Likewise, most people probably wouldn’t sideload apps, manage their security keys, or anything else, but by not allowing those things, our society of computers and networking has turned rather ugly compared to what was originally imagined for it.
It is also, of course, ridiculous for a bank or food delivery app to refuse to install their app on a device which is actually controlled by the user when they allow the same device to do the same things on its website, and companies doing such things would have a tendency to lose customers to smarter competitors who don't.
> how many games do you think will want the user to have an unlocked device
Many more will rather be able to attest that the user isn't pirating all IAP.
> It is also, of course, ridiculous for a bank or food delivery app to refuse to install their app on a device which is actually controlled by the user when they allow the same device to do the same things on its website
Ridiculous, yes, but it's still done anyway. The same device is also often not allowed to do the same things on the website, or the website implements similar or identical fingerprinting code. Everything from polling tons of "logged in URLs" like facebook's favicon to detect what sites the user is logged into, to port scanning the user's LAN, none of this should be a thing and should be extremely illegal, but in practice it's abused heavily.
Which the developer will have a market incentive to not want to do, because they can't get money from you if you're not using their product, and unlike phone platforms, most app developers have aggressive competition.
> Many more will rather be able to attest that the user isn't pirating all IAP.
Not really. If the user has an unlocked device, turning them away isn't going to turn a profit because then you lose their business regardless. Better to get the users who don't pirate than to lose them all. And it's not as if the user is going to lock the device back up for most of these games -- especially when there will be other apps that only work on an unlocked device.
> Everything from polling tons of "logged in URLs" like facebook's favicon to detect what sites the user is logged into, to port scanning the user's LAN, none of this should be a thing and should be extremely illegal, but in practice it's abused heavily.
The solution there being to stop patronizing anybody who does that, which everybody should already be doing as a general principle.
Moreover, all this is all rather academic when we could get the actual result by allowing the user to do this to their device and seeing what happens, so it can't be an argument for not doing that. Worst case is not very many people do it, and then still what is it hurting?
If only. Every single major US bank and card company does this. It's terrible.
Uh, well ok unsupported assertion. Apple has always allowed third party calendars, email clients, messaging apps, etc.
It’s always been security, privacy AND battery life. This original iPhone didn’t allow third party apps for a year, and they were only going to be web apps. Eventually they game up with a tight sandbox with strict limits on background processing that protected battery life, privacy and the essential phone functionality from rogue apps.
Being able to buy a tightly managed device that maximizes its battery life and your privacy and security is an important choice for consumers.