Re:Tourists on Tech's Toll Roads
by untog on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:09PM
(#24507974)
The difference (as I see it) is that taxes are paid relative to how much you earn/are worth, while road tolls are the same for all. Everyone (outside of major metro areas where you can use public transit) needs roads, and driving to work on a tolled road will hurt the wallets of poor folks a lot more than it will rich folks.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Public roads are paid for via gasoline taxes, eg a flat usage tax, and are thus nearly exactly as regressive as a toll.
The only difference is that a poor person could choose to drive an economy car, or an electric vehicle, in order to avoid paying their share of use tax. But so could a rich person.
The other difference is that the usage tax is a hidden cost and tolls are not.
Only about 40% of spending on roads in the US comes from tolls and fuel taxes [0]. It's not correct to call them "nearly as regressive as a toll": in terms of regressiveness, they're halfway between funding them from tolls and funding them from income/property/sales taxes.