News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:46PM (#24284256)
These are good steps, but abolishing all wealth-tests entirely would still be better.

There's no wealth-test that prevents a person from losing all their money in highly-leveraged investments - from real-estate to fancy public-market securities. (Over-leveraging into real estate is practically encouraged by public policy.)

There's no wealth test against putting all one's cash into gambling, which can be arbitrarily worse than even the riskiest non-fraudulent startup investment, depending on your choice of wagers. (Official state lotteries are among the worst games, with the most manipulative marketing - to a level of deception that would generate lawsuits & legislation if attempted by private actors.)

There's no wealth test before purchasing legal but addictive & judgement-impairing substances like alcohol & marijuana.

But if you want to put $5-$20K into a friend's business, or a business you know well, the SEC makes it hard unless you're already a millionaire. It's insanely paternalistic & economically destructive - a ghostly holdout from some bad experiences in another era, the 1930s, when the ranges of available information, experience, and alternative temptations were all tiny & quaint compared to the 2020s.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by mywittyname on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:27PM (#24284803)
There's a strong financial incentive for the market to engage in fraudulent activities against investors. And the smaller the investor, the greater then incentive.

Public companies have regulations that help prevent such fraud by requiring things such as audits by third party accounting firms, and regulating how these audits may be performed. Such regulations came about specifically as the result of fraud committed by the owners and directors of companies.

Private markets don't have these regulations because the assumption is that past financial success is indicative of financial sophistication. It doesn't prevent fraud, but at least it helps reduce the likelihood of success.

If you start making private markets open to everyone, then there's no reason to differentiate between public and private markets anymore. Companies will go back to all being "private" because there are fewer regulations, then there will be another Enron, and a subsequent shift towards regulation to prevent another such scandal.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by otoburb on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:34PM (#24284893)
>>If you start making private markets open to everyone, then there's no reason to differentiate between public and private markets anymore.

Couple this with 401Ks now giving retail investors (likely high-fee) choices to invest in private equity[1], and the picture looks much more volatile as the next generation draws closer to retirement.

[1] https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2020-06-19/private-eq...

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by colordrops on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:45PM (#24285035)
It's a matter of principle though. You don't restrict the freedom of individuals to protect them from other individuals that are bad actors. You go hard and strong after the bad actors. What other examples of laws outside of finance can you cite where individuals are restricted in order to protect them from other bad actors? It's absurd and not in the scope of what government should be doing.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by alasdair_ on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:10PM (#24285364)
>What other examples of laws outside of finance can you cite where individuals are restricted in order to protect them from other bad actors?

Pretty much any consumer safety or mandatory licensing law.

Even something as simple as buying a beer - we insist that legal adults are not allowed to buy a beer until they are older.

We insist that adults must be over 21 to buy a handgun in many states, or that (in other states) they must show that they are sophisticated gun owners by passing a firearms safety course.

We let people with special licenses and training (pharmacists) buy opiates openly, yet deny individuals the right to do so without receiving written permission.

We don't allow non-specialists to buy certain kinds of explosives, but we allow others with credentials to do so. The same applies to all kinds of things, up to and including varieties of river frogs (!).

We insist on documented "informed consent" for things like surgery, again to protect vulnerable people from bad actors.

We don't let adults buy many kind of fireworks out of fear that they will harm themselves or others, yet if someone can prove (through obtaining a license) that they are competent, we let them buy and fire huge commercial fireworks.

In short: there are an enormous number of similar restrictions. A lot of them exist because the previous state (no law) caused enough damage that restrictions were added.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @05:17PM (#24287382)
But none of your examples use the reductionist & discriminatory "how big is your bank account" standard as a proxy for a person's responsibility.

What if you had to be rich - far beyond the sticker & insurance price - to buy a car? ("You're not a millionaire? We've decided you should only be allowed to take the bus.")

Rich to buy a beer? Rich to buy a gun?

Rich to buy a bunch of OTC medicines? (Poor people would still need a prescription - from a doctor, or perhaps, under the "rich makes smart" standard, just a rich sponsor.)

Rich to buy fireworks?

Rich to buy certain books, with dangerous knowledge? (Similar to how it is only by private investing that you get a full practical education in how such investments/firms work.)

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by alasdair_ on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:54PM (#24288672)
A simple example: if you are poor and are on medicaid, it’s not possible to have a vasectomy without a 30 day mandatory waiting period to make sure that you are certain. If you are rich and have health insurance (or pay out of pocket) it’s completely fine to do it the same day.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:54PM (#24289061)
That's still not 'wealth' but rather 'ability to pay the costs'. While correlated with wealth, that's not the same bar, and ability-to-pay is far more rationally related.

An entity paying – actually forgoing other possible expenditures of the same money, as in this example Medicaid or some other 3rd-party payor – should have some level-of-control. There's a budget constraint in effect - other priorities they are responsible for will suffer if this one is chosen.

But anybody, regardless of wealth, for whom it's important enough to scrape up the costs can skip that hurdle, in your example. There's no extra legal burden, of thousands of dollars of costs, added by the state just because they're poor. There's no extra complications the government forces onto the counterparty – the doctor – just because the patient is poor, thus deterring the otherwise-mutually-desired activity from happening at all.

(Of course, there are such complications if Medicaid actually pays – hence many doctors avoiding Medicaid-reimbursed patients/treatments.)

And in the end the poor patient still gets the treatment - unlike the permanent freeze-out of unaccredited investors – unless & until they bank $1,000,000.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by clusterfish on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:58PM (#24289103)
Wealth filter on access to healthcare is an even bigger problem than wealth filter on investments.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by colordrops on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @06:11PM (#24287884)
Every one of your examples are of the case of protecting the individual from hurting themselves or others. This is quite different from the question, which is to cite a law that restricts someone in order to protect them from others.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by paulgb on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:07PM (#24288318)
I agree that some of the examples GP gave don't quite fit, but their insight about consumer protection laws is key.

Say a consumer protection law that prohibits an appliance company from selling me a cheap heater that isn't up to code. That law restricts the appliance company's freedom, but it also restricts my freedom to contract with the appliance company. The law is restricting my freedom to protect me.

(Personally, I'm fond of Matt Levine's "stupid investment license" proposal, but I would not be in favor of an "unsafe heater" license)

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by colordrops on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:11PM (#24288341)
But they aren't restricting your freedom. They would be restricting your freedom if some people could buy those appliances but not you. Saying they are restricting your freedom using your example is like saying your friend was put in jail, and thus they are restricting your freedom to hang out with that friend, which IMHO is a bad interpretation.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by paulgb on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:23PM (#24288446)
They're restricting my freedom in the sense that, in the absence of government, I would be free to contract with the seller of the non-certified heater.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by colordrops on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @09:06PM (#24289158)
You are still free to contract with the seller, they are just unable to deliver to you.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by alasdair_ on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:57PM (#24288696)
It is mandatory to have car insurance (to protect others) unless you are rich (if you can prove you have assets to cover a $250k claim, you don’t need insurance). Obviously varies by state.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by colordrops on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @09:04PM (#24289145)
> What other examples of laws outside of finance

Your example still sits within finance.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by CalChris on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @10:15PM (#24289523)
Hiring an unlicensed electrician.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by toby on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @04:13PM (#24286735)
Most of your examples are designed to prevent unqualified people from hurting others, the main exception being the regulated drugs one.

This raises the question of whether a similar system could exist for investments. Do you think there could be a "prescription" investment where you'd need a sign-off from someone with certain qualifications who'd consider your financial position and what you were planning to do?

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by Ericson2314 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:51PM (#24285867)
I'm OK with these sorts of "in defense of us all" regulation, but I think the wealth test in particular is a bit perverse. I think this "anti-classism" critique is better than the libertarian critique.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by mywittyname on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:39PM (#24286385)
Regulations are written in blood.

We didn't have rules, then something extremely bad happened to make people say, "that should be illegal." So it's made illegal. A generation passes and young people look at said regulations, think, "that's a stupid rule," and they revoke it. Goto 10.

Investments that require you to be accredited are often pretty bad ones. All the great opportunities get cherry-picked by those with the right networks. What most people will be investing in are the scraps that all the smart investors passed on. That's how accredited investors get burned and go back to boring old index funds.

If you open these markets up to average Joes, it's going to be a bloodbath. Fox News will switch from running ads to invest in gold to ones for scam companies with fraudulent books. Elderly women will get hounded by phone salesman. We'll go back to the way it was in the 80s.

The problem with caveat emptor is society as a whole gets screwed as well. We all get to live with the economic collapse brought on by the situation.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by throw0101a on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:33PM (#24288935)
> A generation passes and young people look at said regulations, think, "that's a stupid rule," and they revoke it. Goto 10.

See the concept of "Chesterton's fence":

> In the matter of reforming things, as distinct from deforming them, there is one plain and simple principle; a principle which will probably be called a paradox. There exists in such a case a certain institution or law; let us say, for the sake of simplicity, a fence or gate erected across a road. The more modern type of reformer goes gaily up to it and says, “I don’t see the use of this; let us clear it away.” To which the more intelligent type of reformer will do well to answer: “If you don’t see the use of it, I certainly won’t let you clear it away. Go away and think. Then, when you can come back and tell me that you do see the use of it, I may allow you to destroy it.”

* https://www.chesterton.org/taking-a-fence-down/

First determine and be able to explain why something was put in place. If you cannot explain why, you have no right to tear it down. If you can explain the original reason, you may then be able to explain why it may no longer be needed.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by pc86 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @05:46PM (#24287663)
This is true for something like the FAA's FARs where they're trying to save lives.

It is absolutely not true of every nonsensical paternialistic nonsense Congress has passed.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by Ericson2314 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @06:04PM (#24287817)
My preferred solution is UBI + no gambling with the UBI rule. Similar effect in this area (ignoring all the other wonderful benefits a UBI has) but without the nastiness of a net worth rule.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by beambot on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:06PM (#24288755)
Where do you draw the line between gambling & investment...?

Example: Median returns across venture capital are net-negative, even if expected value is net-positive:

https://techcrunch.com/2017/06/01/the-meeting-that-showed-me...

The effect is even more extreme for early-stage startups given the power-law nature of returns.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by Ericson2314 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @11:31PM (#24289880)
Yeah it's all gambling. I'm doing a 180 and saying net worth floor bad, can't spend UBI on it good. The "it" in both cases is supposed to be held constant.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by millettjon on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:07PM (#24286040)
How about if we insisted you have 1,000,000 USD to buy guns or alcohol?
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by aaronblohowiak on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:02PM (#24285256)
> What other examples of laws outside of finance can you cite where individuals are restricted in order to protect them from other bad actors?

Controlled substances (ie: prescriptions,)

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by colordrops on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @06:14PM (#24287920)
That's not why drugs are illegal. In fact you'd be far more protected from bad actors if they were legalized.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by aaronblohowiak on Thursday August 27, 2020 @04:16PM (#24298152)
You need an rx for many things that would be fine otc for paternalistic reasons, that have no “abuse” potential. My post was about rx requirements not prohibition of recreational drugs.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by zemo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:05PM (#24288748)
let's say you want to permit gambling, because people should be free to gamble. Even in the case of permitting it, there are still legitimate reasons to have regulatory systems. For example, if you go to a casino to play craps, you as a consumer have an expectation that the casino is giving you fair dice. Now we could say that such a thing shouldn't be regulated, let the market decide or whatever, but now every time you go to a craps table you have to test the fairness of the dice yourself. So every time someone new comes to the table, they're testing the dice. It would be ridiculous. Even if you ran an entirely fair organization, everyone would be coming to the table and testing the dice because they don't trust the ecosystem, and your ability to have a fun and care-free gameplay experience becomes hampered by bad actors creating an ecosystem of poisoned consumer expectations; it would not only harm players, but it would also harm proprietors that wish to host games with fair dice. Or you can just say "you know, maybe casinos should not have the freedom to give people unfair dice".
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by freedomben on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @09:35PM (#24289318)
Absent government regulation doesn't necessarily lead to the scenario you described of everyone having to test the dice all the time.

Third party certifiers could (and many believe would) emerge as trusted testers. For example, if you own a casino you can request certification from the "Fair Dice Association." They can then certify that your dice are fair. I as a consumer know they're reputation, and I trust their due diligence.

This also has the benefit of utilizing free-market competition to drive down costs and ensure quality. It also avoids granting an authorization of violence, which some people believe is wrong whether it's a "government" or not.

This isn't purely theoretical. It already happens. SOC 2 certification from the AICPA is a great example.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bioipbiop on Thursday August 27, 2020 @12:28AM (#24290110)
The problem here is that somebody has to pay the Fair Dice Association and generally it ends up being the Casino. It also generally pays better to be a dealer than a dice certifier, so certifiers are often weighing the possibility of future employment when inspecting the dice. Finally, the risk of repetitional harm has proven, in practice, ineffective at preventing malpractice.

This isn’t purely theoretical. It has happened repeated in recent history. Arthur Andersen signed off on obvious accounting fraud at Enron due to conflicts of interest. During the GFC, credit ratings companies graded low quality MBS derived securities as ‘triple A’ without bothering perform anything beyond a cursory examination.

Now imagine what would happen if every rando could start playing in the private markets. Well you don’t have to imagine too hard, we did a natural experiment not long ago with crypto currencies. What did we get? Shameless pump and dump schemes organised openly on social media, pyramid schemes, vapourware ICOs, and all manner of other dodgy dealings.

One reason these scams were so hard to stop was that so many unsophisticated scammers and scammees people were involved. The wealth requirement at least reduces the numbers of people involved to a somewhat manageable level. I do agree though, it’d be nice to have a more equitable way to do this. I think this action from the SEC is an important step towards that as it now opens the doors to qualified people that might otherwise fail the wealth test.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by __s on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:12PM (#24288792)
They aren't arguing against regulation

They're arguing that you shouldn't have fineprint that says "if you only let millionaires sit at your table, you can use loaded dice"

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bsder on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @10:51PM (#24289700)
> You don't restrict the freedom of individuals to protect them from other individuals that are bad actors. You go hard and strong after the bad actors.

That's fine. But you first up the enforcement and second decrease the qualifications.

I can tell you from personal experience that the SEC has a lousy record of enforcement against even serial bad actors. And the civil system is even worse.

4 of 9 startups that I have been involved with have had criminal levels of malfeasance and have gone to court and lost--however, that didn't win anybody any money. And the SEC was nowhere to be found. Perhaps I'm just bad at picking startups, but anecdata from my friends suggests that I'm batting better than most and that the fact that they got judgments against them is the unusual part and not the 50% having malfeasance.

Story time of the worst: worked for a startup that had the usual friends and family investment structure. A couple dozen people all at $50K-$100K. No big deal.

Came in to do technical work. Okay, once I got there it was clear that everybody was out of their depth and the work was going to be significantly more than expected. Not unusual, and I'm working hourly with some number of hours defrayed by stock options if I think the idea is useful.

Start down the path. CEO is spending money like water on marketing. That's not unheard of and probably not even a bad idea.

The CEO then gets a "lawyer" from Silicon Valley who attempts a maneuver to take control of the company from the investors without buying them out.

And here come the lawyers.

So, of course, at this point, a chunk of us demand both the financial records as well as the documents behind the maneuver. Denied, so we need to compel the request.

And, of course, once we get the documents, we find that the company has been bled of nearly $1.5 million in cash in what were later found to be illegal arrangements.

Off to court we go. So, what are your options?

You can sue individuals, but that means piercing the corporate veil. You can force the company into bankruptcy, but if you're found against, you can wind up with a big penalty on your hands. You can report to the SEC, who basically ignore you because this simply isn't worth their time to bother with ($10 million is the minimum to even get them to call you back).

And through all of this, you will be spending cash to your lawyers while the opposing side is spending investor cash to fight you. Or, in this instance, has cut a special deal with the "lawyers" by giving them a "retainer" of $300K and now is doing work "for free".

Oh, by the way, the clock is ticking. If you don't push the company into bankruptcy soon, that "retainer" can't be clawed back because it will be outside the time window.

Fine. File a suit to force payment due and force them in bankruptcy.

The opposing "lawyer" shows up and his sole job is to delay while doing nothing. The judge even finds in your favor and admits that he has no sufficient way to penalize the company or the lawyer. And likely won't penalize the lawyer anyway because the court system protects its own--even the scumbags.

And, by the way, a significant cohort of the investors are VERY upset with you. They like the con-man, after all. So, you aren't crusaders for justice; you're interlopers who upset the apple cart.

And, if you're vulnerable, you may get a suit launched against you by the company for "reasons". Yes, it's a nuisance and you will win, but it will cost you even more money.

The moral is: We probably would have been better off to simply let him keep stealing money from people, cut a deal for some level of payment and just walk away.

THIS is the reality you are championing for. Just so you know.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by colordrops on Thursday August 27, 2020 @03:15AM (#24290900)
> THIS is the reality you are championing for. Just so you know.

I understand the current reality. I was in several startups myself, and got caught up in this sort of thing.

When I said:

> You go hard and strong after the bad actors

there is a lot wrapped up in that statement. Not just having more SEC involvement. More like doing whatever it takes, all the way up to refactoring our entire financial system and going after wall street and the federal reserve.

I understand that sounds unrealistic, but the financial class are mostly parasites IMHO, and will eventually kill the host if something is not done. It boils down to class warfare, which the accredited investor BS explicitly reflects.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gvhst on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:57PM (#24285183)
I don't think the direction we are going towards will erode the differentiation between private and public markets. A skill based assessment (required to have series 7/65/82, other designations like CFA will eventually be included) will be a strong barrier to entry. While those exams may be more or less trivial to many hackernews readers, for the general public they represent a significant investment in time and education.

There will also be liquidity differences--even with a broader set of investors--between private and public markets. Thus if a company wants to have liquid equity (which benefits employees) they will need to be public. Additionally, many large institutions have caps on private market investments which are generally smaller than public equity caps. I don't see this changing given liquidity concerns, going public will still be the road to access more institutional capital.

Lastly, your Enron example exemplifies the point that fraud will occur, regardless of private or public markets (and regardless if it is audited by an established third party accounting firm. Arthur Anderson signed off on Enron for years, at it took years for a big 4 accounting firm to recognize the fraud committed by Wirecard). On the flipside, public markets have regulatory requirements which make it easier to research, but just because private markets don't require disclosures doesn't mean there is no information to go off of. Investors can still get enough info to make reasonable investment decisions without disclosures following public company requirements. This gives investors the ability to make their own decisions regarding which disclosure standards are sufficient instead of differing to the SEC. In fact, I believe that Private Markets would experience less fraud if the only requirements were education based and not net-worth based,

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by stickfigure on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:01PM (#24285247)
Seems like there's at least one "third option". The rights of minority shareholders don't have to be as minimal as they are. How about "anyone who owns stock is entitled to look at the books?"
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:06PM (#24285309)
> How about "anyone who owns stock is entitled to look at the books?"

Books and records inspections are expensive for both issuer and investor. For the issuer, it almost always requires legal counsel be retained.

If a company wants to raise private capital from retail investors, the JOBS Act created Reg A+ [1] for them.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_A#Regulation_A+

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by edoceo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:11PM (#24285371)
High Times (the weed mag, now media company) is doing a pretty visible RegA+ for anyone interested to see what that (mess?) looks like.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by jpeg_hero on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @04:58PM (#24287187)
Shhhhhh.

"Specific statutes in the California Corporations Code provide shareholders the right to inspect bylaws, accounting books, records, minutes and financial statements. The California Corporations Code allows the court to enforce these rights."

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by stickfigure on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @06:18PM (#24287954)
Does that apply to Delaware corporations headquartered in California?
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by jpeg_hero on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @06:21PM (#24287980)
no.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by nickff on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:05PM (#24285302)
This is the rule for companies with a certain number of investors (500 IIRC). The problem is that producing the (audited) books is the most expensive part of being a public corporation.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by RayVR on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:22PM (#24288867)
Unfortunately, there’s no shortage of obscure public investments where people can lose lots of money. Options are a classic example. Leveraged ETFs are another. There are many more.

The idea that the SEC should limit access to hedge funds, private equity, and startups is antiquated. A modern approach could simply put the burden on the entity seeking investments. Access to investors with net worth less than $100k could simply require extensive disclosure. Many people would lose money investing in things they know nothing about but this would not be meaningfully different from our current situation.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by jefftk on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:53PM (#24289055)
> Access to investors with net worth less than $100k could simply require extensive disclosure.

That's not all that different from how it works now. Most of the difficulty of public listing is the higher level of disclosure required.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by mcny on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:50PM (#24288636)
> Private markets don't have these regulations because the assumption is that past financial success is indicative of financial sophistication. It doesn't prevent fraud, but at least it helps reduce the likelihood of success.

I don't know how any of this works but my kneejerk reaction is Maybe private markets should have these regulations as well? If a company can't follow these regulations maybe they have no business raising cash in the first place.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by millettjon on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:06PM (#24286026)
Alternatively pass regulations to make private companies over a certain size report more.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by oh_sigh on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:21PM (#24285515)
But isn't it also the SECs job to punish those who commit fraud against investors?

In my mind it is like the NYPD making it illegal to walk down the street at night unless you are 6'2" or above, or have trained in martial arts. After all, there are a lot of people out there who would want to take advantage of a weaker, easier target. And it also just happens to make the NYPDs job easier.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by malandrew on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:11PM (#24285382)
There's a strong financial incentive for the market to lobby for regulations that reduces the amount of competition it experiences when making investments. Keeping out mom and pop investors until you've extracted most of the growth is a very effective strategy to keep prices for good investments down.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by elliekelly on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:32PM (#24284859)
> It's insanely paternalistic & economically destructive - a ghostly holdout from some bad experiences in another era, the 1930s, when the ranges of available information, experience, and alternative temptations were all tiny & quaint compared to the 2020s.

Over the last 90 years we have repeatedly learned very difficult lessons about the individual and societal costs of unregulated securities markets and made changes to mitigate those risks. And this same tired argument comes along, repeatedly, to justify rolling those regulations back so that a handful of people have a chance at striking it rich while we as a group learn those same difficult and expensive lessons all over again.

Our securities markets work. They are predictable, mostly fair, and most importantly, they are trusted. Are all of the rules perfect? No. Do some of the rules and regulations have compliance costs that outweigh their benefit? Of course. There is plenty of room for improvement and we should absolutely identify the areas in need of modernization but you’re advocating we tear the whole house down when you haven’t made an effort to understand why it was built this way in the first place.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by ibeckermayer on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:16PM (#24285434)
> Our securities markets work

According to what standard? Is the fact that I can’t invest $5000 in my friend’s startup an example of our securities markets “working”? Not according to any rationally justifiable standard.

Certainly the impulse to protect grandma’s life savings from predatory fraud is a good one. But the proper way to better society is through empowering individuals to make better decisions. An example of a better system along this principle would be a local (county/state) investment office that you go through that checks over the terms of the deal to make sure the terms are legal and the parties are fully aware of what they’re getting themselves into. That would protect against fraud, without violating my right to freely and consensually associate with other consenting adults. “Others might do a bad thing, therefore you should be banned from doing a good thing” is not a logically coherent standard — yet that is the essential argument of the SEC and it’s “accredited investor” protections.

Your view that these markets are “working” is merely an indication that you lack imagination. How much better would the world be if there weren’t arbitrary restrictions on economic exchange? It’s impossible to know, but history shows that advancements in liberty and justice have breed unprecedented wealth.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by elliekelly on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @05:03PM (#24287232)
> “Others might do a bad thing, therefore you should be banned from doing a good thing” is not a logically coherent standard — yet that is the essential argument of the SEC and it’s “accredited investor” protections.

No. That is not remotely close to summarizing the SEC’s stance on accredited investors or the regulations the SEC enforces to protect retail investors. The securities regulations are, at their core, a disclosure regime. They aren’t intended to police for bad investments and they aren’t intended to prevent you or I or anyone else from making stupid decisions with our money. They’re merely about how much information must be furnished to potential investors before they invest. That’s it.

If you want to sell securities to everyday folks, they have to be registered. Full stop. Any unregistered sale is an exemption to the rule but anyone can register their securities for sale and provide potential investors with a prospectus and some basic information about the investment.

Generally speaking the registration and disclosure requirements are eased or exempted for people with a higher income not because they’re smarter and can avoid bad investments or because they’re better situated financially to absorb the loss. It’s because they have the resources to do the diligence and hire people ask the questions and get the necessary information to make the investment. Think of it as outsourced compliance. Rather than the entity paying for the cost of registering the securities and everything that entails the investors pay for it up front.

And that makes sense. If I have a question about Apple’s prospectus I can’t ring Tim Cook and ask for more information. What you see in the disclosures is what you get. But if I’m one of the 35 unaccredited investors in my friend’s company and I have a question I can absolutely call the CEO and get the answers.

And now think about the middle ground: JFrog, for example, before they filed their S-1. If you or I invested $5,000 and we had a question about operations do you think we’d get answers? No way. If Elon Musk invested and he had the exact same question do you think he’d get answers? Of course.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bpt3 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:24PM (#24285548)
What exactly is stopping you from investing $5000 in your friend's startup?
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by voxic11 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:50PM (#24285857)
Presumably Rule 506(b) which prevents fundraising from nonaccredited investors. There is an exception for up to 35 non-accredited investors but taking money from even one non-accredited investor greatly increases the disclosure requirements on your startup. So the startup would essential need to do disclosure as though it were a public company.

https://www.sec.gov/smallbusiness/exemptofferings/rule506b

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:27PM (#24286258)
> the startup would essential need to do disclosure as though it were a public company

Not quite that onerous. But the start-up and investor would each need to spend at least $5,000 on legal diligence. This would likely be true with or without the rule—if you don’t understand the preferred investors’ terms, you aren’t qualified to invest.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bpt3 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @05:11PM (#24287311)
Rule 506(b) doesn't prevent it entirely, and keep in mind that the vast majority of companies aren't venture backed startups, and I believe would be covered under Rule 504.

You absolutely don't need to do disclosure like a public company if you have non-accredited investors.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by otoburb on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:32PM (#24286311)
To cross all the t's and dot all the i's, you might be able to join a friends-and-family round under Rule 504, but your founder friend should still do the due diligence to ensure the participating friends and family investors reside in states where such an offering is exempt from registration/qualification under state blue-sky laws[1].

IANAL. Hopefully your founder friend will have had a startup attorney to ask about all of this.

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/blue_sky_law

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bpt3 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @05:12PM (#24287330)
Any founder who is looking to take funding from anyone should have a startup attorney to ask about this.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bsanr2 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:25PM (#24285562)
>Over the last 90 years we have repeatedly learned very difficult lessons about the individual and societal costs of unregulated securities markets and made changes to mitigate those risks.

And then mostly dismantled those changes, in an environment when financial entities have more reach and capital to spin into dubious schemes than ever before. What could possibly go wrong?

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bobthepanda on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:05PM (#24284497)
How many of those are capable of creating systemic financial risk, though?

People in the '20s were literally mortgaging their house and car to buy stocks on margin en masse because they took in advertising and word of mouth that told them it was a good idea. You could theoretically also do that at a casino, but practically speaking that's not a big problem.

Look at the crypto hype-train that got latched onto by people who didn't do their homework on crypto, or the craziness of WSB on reddit. We are still capable of letting that happen today.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by asdff on Thursday August 27, 2020 @03:58AM (#24291134)
People in the 90s were doing the same to buy beanie babies. People will do dumb things with their money. That being said, I don't think things like pattern day trading bans have ever been beneficial to the retail investor. It just keeps poorfolk from engaging in strategies used by wealthier people regularly.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bobthepanda on Saturday August 29, 2020 @08:23PM (#24320368)
People will do dumb things with their money, but the point of the regulation is to increase frictions on lots of people doing dumb things with their money at the same time. "Beneficial to the retail investor" has nothing to do with it.

If one person can't pay their home loan for the month that's the borrower's problem. If millions of people can't pay their home loan for the month that's the bank's problem, and generally speaking that's enough to start bank runs.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bsanr2 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:33PM (#24285666)
My guess is that there is some amount of overlap between the crypto/WSB crowd and, say, the people who kickstarted (read: were structurally prohibited from investing in) Oculus.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by vmception on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:14PM (#24284599)
Which is why there shouldn't be any prohibition exclusively in the securities market. There are even higher wealth tests in some aspects of the commodities market.

These things just haven't been challenged in the courts because those wealthy enough don't know or consider this is an issue, and people less wealthy aren't even exposed to these kinds of opportunities and probably also can't afford the court challenge.

I think there is room for a challenge and invalidation of the entire concept because the wealth test actually used to be different kinds of tests as recently as the 70s. Those were no good because it led to arbitrary discrimination by the brokers and companies. And now we are back to that because FINRA licenses are more standardized.

Can likely invalidate the entire concept with more recent case law such as spending is speech via 1st amendment, 5th amendment and 14th amendment equal application of laws in comparison to the wealth/access dichotomy as well as ability to speculate and gamble in other markets.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by tptacek on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:07PM (#24284528)
Is there a variant of this framing that doesn't also argue against all securities regulation and a return to the status quo ante of the Great Depression? Because the Accredited Investor standard essentially bypasses securities disclosure laws. Without it, every company would obtain the benefits of being public company, with none of the associated obligations.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:33PM (#24284870)
Sure: replace all wealth tests with competence tests.

Then, no competent poor person would be legally locked out of an investment opportunity, by state enforcement power, that would be legally-encouraged for any incompetent wealthy heir.

Requiring that someone has to be able to deliver the funds, sure.

Perhaps, that they have to prove competence via some testing certification.

Perhaps, that they have to match some scaled risk threshold, when relying on systemic benefits: we only give you tax-advantaged retirement accounts, or full unemployment coverage, if you don't put more than X% of your net worth in 'risky'/non-public securities.

Those would at least be objectively-linked to a person's abilities, or the magnitude of risks they're projecting on the community.

But wealth tests in state regulation codify a class system: "You can't buy this, even if you have cash-in-hand, even if you're an expert, even if the spillover risks are infinitesimal, unless you're already rich." Such discrimination against the poor should be just as illegal as that based on race, gender, national origin, sexual preference, religion, etc.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by icedchai on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:18PM (#24288833)
Are you eager to lose money or have it tied up for years and years with almost no likelyhood of ever seeing it again? Yes, there are some good private investments, of course. But the vast, vast majority, at the level you or I are going to see, without a network, are probably junk. You're better off investing in public markets.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:55PM (#24289082)
I don't believe you know anything about the kinds of deals available to me or where I should best invest. (What's your record & credentials?) I trust my decades in this industry more than your hand-waving assertions-of-futility.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by icedchai on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @09:27PM (#24289280)
That's fine. I've been in this industry since the 90's. My opinion is unless you have literally millions of spare cash to make a ton of seed investments (like 50+), it's not worth it. You will probably not see a pay off.

I qualify as an accredited investor based on net worth. I have invested in private companies, both through employee stock options and as a preferred seed-stage investor. However, I keep most of my funds in self managed brokerage accounts. I will not quote returns here, I am not here to boast, I'll just say I do beat the S&P by a significant percentage.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by stickfigure on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:06PM (#24285305)
How about Matt Levine's "Certificate of Dumb Investment"?

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-09-24/earnin...

-----

1. Anyone can invest all they want in a diversified portfolio of approved investments (non-penny-stock public companies, mutual funds and exchange-traded funds with modest fees, insured bank accounts, etc.).

2. Anyone can also invest in any other dumb investment; you just have to go to the local office of the SEC and get a Certificate of Dumb Investment. (Anyone who sells dumb non-approved investments without requiring this certificate from buyers goes to prison.)

3. To get that certificate, you sign a form. The form is one page with a lot of white space. It says in very large letters: “I want to buy a dumb investment. I understand that the person selling it will almost certainly steal all my money, and that I would almost certainly be better off just buying index funds, but I want to do this dumb thing anyway. I agree that I will never, under any circumstances, complain to anyone when this investment inevitably goes wrong. I understand that violating this agreement is a felony.”

4. Then you take the form to an SEC employee, who slaps you hard across the face and says “really???” And if you reply “yes really” then she gives you the certificate.

5. Then you bring the certificate to the seller and you can buy whatever dumb thing he is selling.

6. If an article ever appears in the Wall Street Journal in which you (or your lawyer) are quoted saying that you were just a simple dentist, didn’t understand what you were buying and were swindled by the seller’s flashy sales pitch, then you go to prison.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by hinkley on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @10:40PM (#24289655)
There’s an old Jerry Lewis bit where the clerk has no ink pad so she just slams the stamp into the back of your hand so hard that it cramps up into a claw.

The claw is how the next clerk knows you’ve been through the other line. That could replace the slap part of the process.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by slavik81 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:10AM (#24290319)
The Wikipedia page on accredited investors had the "big boy letter" in the related links, which I thought was funny. It appears to be a less bombastic version of the concept: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_boy_letter
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by WrtCdEvrydy on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:01PM (#24285974)
LOL, that would be interesting, but would never happen.

Someone will argue the language has some ambiguity and the lawsuit will impact the SEC for 'failing to protect the public'

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by mmm_grayons on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:22PM (#24284721)
I'm of two minds about this - on one hand, we don't want shoe-shine boys losing their savings on a bad investment. On the other, if my friends and I want to pool our money to make an investment I resent being kept out of that sort of thing. Things like opening it to VC fund analysts make a ton of sense.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by nokcha on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:28PM (#24284814)
How about a knowledge/skills test instead of a wealth test? Something like the bar exam, but for investing instead of law. That would keep out people who have no idea what they're doing, without unfairly keeping out knowledgeable middle-class citizens.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by thursday0987 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:39PM (#24284955)
did you even read the SEC announcement? it is literally the first bullet point:

* add a new category to the definition that permits natural persons to qualify as accredited investors based on certain professional certifications, designations or credentials or other credentials issued by an accredited educational institution, which the Commission may designate from time to time by order. In conjunction with the adoption of the amendments, the Commission designated by order holders in good standing of the Series 7, Series 65, and Series 82 licenses as qualifying natural persons.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by madamelic on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:41PM (#24285762)
Cool, I was bummed when I googled Series 7 and saw I needed to be sponsored.

Looks like series 65 is the way to go since series 82 also requires sponsorship.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by mindcrime on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:52PM (#24286531)
Looks like series 65 is the way to go since series 82 also requires sponsorship.

Depends. If simply passing the exam was enough, that does seem semi-reasonable. But if it requires you actually be licensed by your respective state, then the rabbit-hole goes much deeper. I looked at the requirements here in NC, although I don't know how representative they are of other states, but basically you'd have to register with the State as an investment management company (which would probably entail registering an LLC or something), and then pay them $300 / year to keep up your registration. Add the $200/ year or so for the LLC filing fees, as well as the paperwork requirements (annual report, etc), tax filings, and suchlike, and you're talking about a barrier that while not insurmountable, is still going to be fairly steep for most people.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:52PM (#24285125)
Yes, that's exactly in line with how I'd like the SEC to go further than these initial promising steps.

More competence-evaluation – ideally constantly recalibrated according to the performance & satisfaction of those approved. Do some certifications/skills-tests strongly predict later competent investing? Increase their weights. Do others seem to be easy backdoors that lead to lots of burned investors? Decrease their weights.

Manage for the goal - wealth expansion & a vibrant private investing ecosystem – without the archaic oversimplifications "rich are competent to do whatever they want, and young/poor are incompetent so must be kept on a short regulatory leash".

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:04PM (#24285282)
> abolishing all wealth-tests entirely would still be better

The problem is the cost of doing diligence. Not investor competence.

In public markets, the cost of producing reports on the issuer. In private markets, almost by definition, it's on the investor. Each investor must thus have the resources, legal at a minimum, to evaluate an opportunity.

Given these resources have a high minimum cost, an investor of limited means is faced with two options: forego the opportunity or gamble. When the latter is chosen, it doesn't just hurt the investor per se. It creates a fecund field for fraud, seedstock for scammers. (To say nothing of the fact that when retail investors lose money, it has social and systemic effects in a way that someone who loses 10% of their portfolio on a failed start-up investment does not.)

I agree that there might be room for a friends-and-family exemption. But private companies should not be allowed to solicit, directly or indirectly, retail investment dollars.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by hinkley on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @10:46PM (#24289681)
Family rips each other off all the time. And for some reason it’s the cheated party who has to risk being ostracized if they don’t let it go.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by GCA10 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:01PM (#24285244)
Actually, the information asymmetries in public vs. private can be huge -- and I don't mind a little SEC paternalism at all.

I had an OMG experience trying to look up a very interesting non-public software company on SharePost a week ago. They will offer me a chance to buy something. I don't get any clarity on the cap table, so I'd be completely in the dark on preferences, dilution, etc. I'm being asked to offer a price range before seeing any trading history. And there's no availability (at first) of any financial history.

There's potential here to make a uniquely bad investment in what might be a uniquely great company. We won't cry a lot of tears for rich people who make some bad investments in the dark. For people living closer to the edge, having them get fleeced has spillover effects that are ugly enough to argue against letting it all play out with total laissez-faire.

Especially if lax rules invite the hustlers to overwhelm the market. (Gresham's law)

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by georgeecollins on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:10PM (#24284559)
>> There's no wealth-test that prevents a person from losing all their money in highly-leveraged investments - from real-estate to fancy public-market securities.

That is an exageration for publicly traded securities. It used to be possible (in the roaring '20s) to be 10:1 leveraged in public stocks. The SEC forbid that because so many people were wiped out. Nowadays retail stock accounts can under-perform, but it's a big deal when a lot of people see their portfolio decline by 30% -- think 2009.

People have gotten wiped out in large numbers on real estate. I just think it is an exaggeration to say people are taking huge risks with a normal stock account

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by nickpinkston on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:24PM (#24284743)
No, it's still easy for any asshole to get a margin or options account and lose a ton of money.

Here's a recent news story: "20-Year-Old Robinhood Customer Dies By Suicide After Seeing A $730,000 Negative Balance"

https://www.forbes.com/sites/sergeiklebnikov/2020/06/17/20-y...

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by georgeecollins on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:36PM (#24284908)
I didn't say it is impossible. It's just relatively rare. The point of the SEC is not prevent anyone from doing something stupid and losing a lot of money. The point is to keep lots of people from doing something stupid. And in particular, to keep lots of people from doing the same stupid thing at the same time! (1929, 2008.. )
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by nickpinkston on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:01PM (#24285237)
I'm unsure how rare it is, but even if it is rare, it may be because anyone motivated enough to know what a margin/options account is and to get one may be sophisticated enough to not lose all of their money doing it.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by bjt on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:51PM (#24285110)
Worth noting that he didn't actually lose a ton of money. Bad UI just made it appear so.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by mbesto on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:10PM (#24285370)
Correct. And there is technically an audit for options trading that says you need to understand how they work before a broker lets you use it. Honestly, options trading is not exactly easy to understand to the lay person and there are generally limits on how much you can lever in them.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:43PM (#24285019)
You can trade futures, even in many retirement accounts, sometimes with just a few thousand dollars in the account. Such futures can wipe out any amount of principal in as little time as you could wire money to a sketchy private investment.

Many of the people defending these 1930s-style regulations, as if these regs truly protected people from themselves, seem to also be stuck in a mid-20th-century view of what the investment & informational environment is like.

If someone is truly gullible & risk-seeking, any amount of capital can be destroyed in any number of legally-approved investments/gambles, almost instantly. The 'Accredited Investor' rules just lock the less-wealthy out of one small and not even especially risky corner - a place where the less-wealthy could potentially better-deploy local knowledge. So this old rule is now just paternalistic friction, without any real personal or systemic wealth protection.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by nickpinkston on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:24PM (#24284755)
There are even leveraged ETFs for those without margin accounts:

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/leveraged-etf.asp

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by smabie on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:06PM (#24288309)
It's not particularly hard to get much higher leverage using futures. Leveraged ETFs don't go above 3x, so they're kind of middle of the road between margin accounts (2x) and futures (10-20x). Or with forex trading, retail investors can get like (50-400x).

In terms of risk, it's important to consider the volatility of the underlying and the leverage ratio.

New home owners are taking on massive leverage on a new home purchase, but usually the low volatility of real estate protects them from too much pain.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by georgeecollins on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:37PM (#24284938)
Yes, but those ETFs are professionally managed high leverage accounts. It's not your uncle day trading at 10:1 margin.

And I know your uncle can probably find a way to make a crazy risky investment. The idea is just to try and cut down on that to avoid systemic risk.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by thekyle on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:50PM (#24286497)
At least with a leveraged ETF you'll never lose more than you invested.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by throwaway_kufu on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @11:44PM (#24289933)
These law weren’t enacted to keep people with less wealth out, but because people with less wealth were fraudulently victimized in mass.

The masses now are most certainly just as, if not more, susceptible to fraud now then they ever were. Then people were literally selling stock certificates on the street, now people line up like sheep to be lead to the slaughter and fight their way to the front.

This may be celebrated like a much needed deregulation, but this was pushed by some deep pocketed special interests that can’t wait to give the unemployed masses the ability to day trade right from their phones.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by nradov on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @05:01PM (#24287221)
I know several regular middle class people who became "accredited" investors by simply lying on the form. While I don't condone that, it seems like no one really verifies assets in most cases.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @05:33PM (#24287536)
Indeed, & that's one of the things fueling my righteous anger here.

Several now very-rich, even 'celebrity' tier investors have mentioned that they simply faked the accreditation at a crucial early stage.

Of course, there's survivorship bias in such stories. But I feel like a sucker for not doing that - and thus losing money in approved things like NASDAQ instead. Or being over-concentrated in my own risky projects – which no SEC rule can protect a person from! – where other private investments would've been usefully uncorrelated.

I could've survived a 100% loss in whatever dozen or two startups I might have taken a flyer in – but in fact, they wouldn't have all cratered, and even if they did I'd have had far more insight into investing, and a broader network, than otherwise. Instead, that valuable experience was reserved for the rich, and those willing to lie about their riches.

So who is this rule protecting, exactly?

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by awinder on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:06PM (#24286027)
I always love to see the "fancy public-market securities" lingo upfront :-). I'm interested to see how this plays out, even though I'm not sure I agree, but this may be the last time to make the information density argument. This time should be a good test of that, and it's one of these things that I hope (not too hard) might just inform some policy and take a policy hostage off the table.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by lootsauce on Thursday August 27, 2020 @12:39AM (#24290161)
Agree it's paternalistic, but you really want to educate yourself whatever the requirements. https://www.macrovoices.com/aia/218-accredited-investor-acad...
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by RockIslandLine on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:19PM (#24285478)
"But if you want to put $5-$20K into a friend's business, or a business you know well, the SEC makes it hard unless you're already a millionaire."

What do you mean? Individuals are still allowed to sign contracts. So write up a specific contract.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:39PM (#24288560)
The SEC makes it easy to use standard arrangements if the investors are 'accredited'.

But mixing in any 'unaccredited' investors drives up the legal complexities and costs, through extra liabilities. A generous (or desperate) founder might still go through the extra headaches to take money from a wider circle, but many potential knowledgeable investors are encumbered and essentially frozen out, simply because they are sub-millionaires, due to extra legal hurdles. It's like everyone who's not a millionaire is a minor, not trusted to contract like an adult - but not based on age or competence, just net worth.

Millionaires face no such restrictions – and thus enjoy the state's support in preserving for themselves privileged, first-look access to a class of potentially-lucrative investments.

It'd be like if millionaires were granted their driver's license on request, because hey, they can be trusted. And we'll waive their fees for permit applications, because they surely hired good advice before applying. Car registration, marriage license? Free if you're rich, we know you won't be getting into any trouble.

But you're not a millionaire? Find a rich sponsor willing to be a counterparty, and pay extra fees, because you poor folks are just too risky to [drive, build, marry, etc].

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by RockIslandLine on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @10:46PM (#24289679)
"legally complex" is different from "impossible".

And yes, people who have years worth of expenses saved are clearly better able to accept risk than someone with $10K in an IRA.

You're not making persuasive arguments here at all. An in both theory and in practice I'm on your side.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by m0zg on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:40PM (#24286396)
It's not really a "wealth test". It's more of a "is this person likely to have proper legal counsel" test. Or at least that's how I understand its intent.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @05:36PM (#24287562)
The 'accredited investor' definition is absolutely & literally a "wealth test".

It does not ask if you have legal counsel. Indeed, even being an investment-specialized, bar-licensed lawyer yourself, drafting agreements upon which other 'accredited investors' depend, wouldn't make you 'accredited'!

But having $1,000,000 in the bank would. Prior wealth.

Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by m0zg on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:47PM (#24288615)
Yes, but someone with $1M in investable capital will almost certainly have a lawyer and they will not be easily taken advantage of. I don't think you can require a lawyer per se in this country. I didn't come up with this myself - that's what Robert Shiller (of Case-Shiller index fame) says in his economics course, which I did take.
Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition by incompatible on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @11:09PM (#24289787)
In any case, we aren't supposed to have "one law for the rich and another for the poor".