Re:SEC Modernizes the Accredited Investor Definition
by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:04PM
(#24285282)
> abolishing all wealth-tests entirely would still be better
The problem is the cost of doing diligence. Not investor competence.
In public markets, the cost of producing reports on the issuer. In private markets, almost by definition, it's on the investor. Each investor must thus have the resources, legal at a minimum, to evaluate an opportunity.
Given these resources have a high minimum cost, an investor of limited means is faced with two options: forego the opportunity or gamble. When the latter is chosen, it doesn't just hurt the investor per se. It creates a fecund field for fraud, seedstock for scammers. (To say nothing of the fact that when retail investors lose money, it has social and systemic effects in a way that someone who loses 10% of their portfolio on a failed start-up investment does not.)
I agree that there might be room for a friends-and-family exemption. But private companies should not be allowed to solicit, directly or indirectly, retail investment dollars.
The problem is the cost of doing diligence. Not investor competence.
In public markets, the cost of producing reports on the issuer. In private markets, almost by definition, it's on the investor. Each investor must thus have the resources, legal at a minimum, to evaluate an opportunity.
Given these resources have a high minimum cost, an investor of limited means is faced with two options: forego the opportunity or gamble. When the latter is chosen, it doesn't just hurt the investor per se. It creates a fecund field for fraud, seedstock for scammers. (To say nothing of the fact that when retail investors lose money, it has social and systemic effects in a way that someone who loses 10% of their portfolio on a failed start-up investment does not.)
I agree that there might be room for a friends-and-family exemption. But private companies should not be allowed to solicit, directly or indirectly, retail investment dollars.