It's not (for the vast majority of people the vast majority of the time) but the benefit is to other people not you and well acting in other peoples self interest seems to be seen as weakness in parts of the world (including sadly mine).
FWIW I always wear either a mask or a bandana over my mouth/nose when I'm out and about these days not because I expect it to protect me but because it might protect someone else.
I expect my opinion is swayed by my best friend having Cystic Fibrosis for which Covid19 is essentially a death sentence and a mother who has chronic health issues.
From my perspective alongside all the other advice wearing a mask seems sensible.
Same reason I wear heavy duty motorcycle gear and a helmet when I ride my motorbike - I don't plan for the crash but as the saying goes, you don't wear it for the ride, you wear it for the slide.
If you are near someone in a risk group it seems very good advice to use or even mandate the usage of masks. Same for being around high risk areas such as using any mass transportation. For low risk areas the benefits are less clear and the potential downsides seems to have about as much evidence as the benefits.
But we don't. Because it'd be inconvenient. Safety is not anyone's highest goal.
If you are hanging around and talking to someone at a fairly close distance, masks simply won't do anything other than visually signal distance is required to others. And, in the unlikely event someone sneezes or coughs, it probably prevents widespread contamination of the surrounding area.
The Seattle choir episode and some studies out of China in restaurant air handling systems seems to indicate the virus is airborne and can be spread to others within a fairly large area, with time and proper airflow. This will happen with or without a mask in place, in my opinion.
I'm super nervous about sharing indoor space with people I don't know, so I don't. The more time we can buy ourselves, the better the outcome.
A Google search result for droplet sizes: https://www.pnas.org/content/115/10/E2386
A Google search result for effectiveness of various masks related to particle size: https://blogs.cdc.gov/niosh-science-blog/2009/10/14/n95/
People seem to have a huge misunderstanding about how viruses travel through air (which is how you get stupid memes like this[1]). There aren't isolated viruses floating around passing through spaces 1/10th of a micron or larger. They need a medium of which to travel upon (such as saliva droplets) that are much larger than the virus itself[2] (usually 5-10 microns)
1. https://starecat.com/content/wp-content/uploads/im-wearing-t...
2. https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/04/03/8256393...
Example: measles is spread airborne and the R value is > 10. Coronavirus R value is < 3
Bad ventilation and dry air keeps the airosols floating around making it easier for people to inhale them. The spread in meat factories is one example.
But a mask still can prevent a lot of airosols. While also being limited. There was research that shows a lot of air escapes above and below the mask if someone coughs or sneezes.
FUD around masks and their effectiveness is being deliberately spread by people and groups with a political agenda, primarily through disinformation campaigns on social media. This isn't an entirely organic phenomenon.
Also, there's no character limit here, you can write the entire phrase instead of using obscure acronyms.
But, the reason there weren't rigorous studies supporting mask usage was not because they don't work, but because nobody was willing to run a study where you exposed half the subjects to a virus without any protection just to prove that masks would help the other half. It's the same reason there aren't any double-blind studies proving that parachutes help you if you fall out of a plane.
That was well before the CDC and surgeon general were telling people masks are bad for you don’t buy them. The masks were long gone by then.
No, this is specifically addressed in the SSC piece. The CDC has been against masks for many years; their advice on masks this year was the same advice they've always given. There is absolutely no reason to believe they put any further thought into it than that.
White lies are still lies that cause people to lose faith in any advice you might have.
So it is not that the CDC was malicious / selfish / conspiring. They did what they believed was the best policy response. Even if we know better now that they should have just published instructions on making community masks and advocating their use.
> nobody was willing to run a study where you exposed half the subjects to a virus without any protection
Running the studies is effectively impossible due to ethics constraints. The CDC were probably lying about their reasoning because if you put all these facts together the CDC would not ever be able to take a position on countermeasures until it was clearly too late. I dunno what their idea of Disease Control is for pandemic, but a little bit of "balance of probability" thinking probably happened.
Even if we'd discovered masks were a complete waste of time, the cost-benefit of everybody spending $10 for hastily sewn cloth mask was clearly in favour of recommending the idea. We've had entire economies parked up, I'm sure the labour could have been found to do some knitting. As projects go it would have been a very productive use of time. They just didn't want to disrupt the supply of medical masks and showed a rather dire level of panic and unpreparedness.
And they too admitted to spreading FUD about masks, in the misguided belief that stopping average people from using masks would leave more masks for the health care providers.
That should reinforce the important point that we're dealing with unqualified, clown-show/amateur-hour political appointees in multiple levels of government, making critical decisions, at this point, a point in time, unlike most points, where leadership or it's lack matters.
And I know that FUD is just a long-standing acronym for "fear, uncertainty and doubt" and I too could just write that. But being so long-standing, the term not is only convenient but has come mean a particular kind of fear, uncertainty and doubt, that spread through a particular of public relations system.
"Listen, we believe masks are effective but we don't have enough for medical personnel who need them right now so unless you absolutely need one please stay home, stay safe, and leave them to doctors, nurses, and other emergency personnel."
No misinformation and the vast majority of people would have complied.
Lying to everyone just cost them credibility and probably lives when this is all said and done.
Still a major win over our current situation.
Government officials see us behaving like this, they assume we're too dumb and self-centered to do the right thing, so they attempt to manipulate us in order to get us to behave properly.
For you to support claim 1 all you need to do is post links to the meta-analyses or randomised control trials that show the effectiveness of masks to prevent the spread of respiratory disease. There are lots of RCTs around mask wearing to prevent the spread of respiratory disease.
> And they too admitted to spreading FUD about masks
No they didn't. They haven't even changed their advice. Now they say "it may prevent the spread", they definitely don't say "it does prevent the spread", and they're still trying to preserve stocks of medical supplies.
In light of this point, how much would you trust a vaccine approved by the FDA or CDC?
I’ll wait until it’s approved by reputable non-US health care agencies. Especially if a vaccine magically arrives before November 3rd.
There was a severe shortage of N95's at the time, and if the public thought masks were important, there would have been an unprecedented run on PPE and the medical community would have had squat. Given that masks, particularly N95s are actually effective in a Healthcare environment ... it was the exactly the right call to make.
Get the masks to those who it will actually help, not the public for whom it will make a smaller difference.
Once production is ramped, or we have enough PPE, then it makes sense to have a pro-mask policy for the public.
From a communications perspective, it's obviously problematic, but in terms of equipment triage, it's highly rational and we actually want our leaders making these kinds of tough decisions.
The WHO and various governments should have been more efficient in their messaging however.
Uh, you what actually happened? There was been an unprecedented run on PPE and the medical community got squat. It's bizarre to have to recite headline news from two months ago ... doctors in NYC using garbage bags instead of real protection. Hand sanitizer unavailable. Nurses in hospital prohibited from using their own masks and not getting them from the hospitals. The Federal government hoarding PPEs for who knows what asinine reason.
As I said, there was excess demand for PPE, but by and large, most medical staff did have access.
That there were some doctors who were unable, means that obviously there was some shortage.
But Dr. Fauci and the WHO had of indicated that 'every American should wear a mask' - then all doctors would have been wearing garbage bags through the entire affair.
The 'excess demand' from natural concern was bad enough, but 350 Million Americans clamouring for N95's would have wiped out any hope of keeping the medical staff in place.
It was a rational decision given the risks and unknowns: We need to get PPE to doctors because the value to the general public is limited.
A tough and difficult decision at the time, but they did the right thing.
This still happened, though. All the stores that sold masks to consumers sold out, very rapidly, at the same time the Surgeon General was tweeting that they didn't work.
They should've ordered they be pulled from sale, not lied about their efficacy.
Which likely wouldn't happen because it's not like someone who gets a profitable contract from the Federal government, retools their factory, isn't going to then try and squeeze as much production out of that as they can anyway.
Is there a RCT showing masks don't help (or better yet, are actively harmful) against respiratory illnesses spread via droplet? Do you have an explanation for why healthcare workers have "droplet precautions" that require masks when dealing with, for example, flu patients?
You're posting something supporting mask usage.
"Face mask use could result in a large reduction in risk of infection". Somehow turning that into "masks bad" because it's a low certainty finding (inviting further study to confirm) is silly bullshit.
"low certainty (our confidence in the effect estimate is limited; the true effect could be substantially different from the estimate of the effect);"
Here's the bit you need to pay more attention to: "the true effect could be substantially different from the estimate of the effect);"
But, again, feel free to link to any of your preferred research.
"We have a low confidence finding that masks work" is not the "high confidence finding masks don't work!" you seem to think it is.
> But, again, feel free to link to any of your preferred research.
I mean, I'd probably just link the one you did, as it supports my point here.
Lying is never a defensible policy. If there was reasonable concern about run on PPE, then perhaps government order restricting or banning their sale to general population (like it was done by some governments) should be considered.
This seems to have been effective, as most of the restrictions have been lifted and we are back to sporadic local clusters by now.
That doesn’t mean that there hasn’t been a ton of clowny behavior from leadership.
I'm sad that the original messages didn't come across as the nuanced issue that it is. Hospitals need the N95 stuff because they are exposed at high rates for a long time. Hospitals also educate their staff on proper protocol when wearing a mask so that people don't negate the effectiveness by wearing it wrong or touching their face after removing it.
The public isn't educated on proper mask wearing procedure. We don't know how to test that a mask fits properly. We don't have the same training to avoid cross contamination and poor mask hygiene. We don't understand the marginal benefits of masks and how it creates a false sense of security causing us to take more risks and spread the disease more quickly.
So at first, it makes perfect sense to funnel the best masks to the highest risk people and encourage "stay at home" (instead of "go outside with a mask") because it limits disease spread the most and protects the community.
I'm sad that it has turned in to "but they said masks did nothing" as an excuse to not wear them. It was never that they did nothing, it's that masks ALONE is not enough. Masks and proper behavior are necessary together.
If you have the correct behaviour (hand washing, distancing) the mask provides you no benefit.
The only point to wearing a mask is if you are unable to maintain that distance, or you're stuck in a room with symptomatic people. But if you're doing that you're also provided with eye protection and gloves and a gown and copious water for handwashing, and you've probably been trained to don and doff the PPE correctly, and maybe you even have a person acting as a PPE spotter helping you put it on or take it off correctly.
That aside, there is high overlap these days between people that say masks don't work and people that are completely negligent about distancing. It is a little ironic, as there were concerns that belief in masks would make people distance less due to sense of security.
So there definitely was some narrative going around back in March that masks had an actively negative effect for an individual, not just that masks do nothing. That said, anyone who is an anti-masker at this point is being ridiculous.
FUD is no more an obscure acronym than CDC. FFS this is a programming and tech forum, people throw acronyms around all the time.
It. Was. Not. The WHO and CDC both issued guidance that public use of personal protective equipment was a bad idea, for fundamental scarcity reasons. And in both cases the messaging was done poorly in a few spots and could have been interpreted as statement that masks don't work against covid. They were heavily criticized for this at the time, and the criticism was carried by the media. No expert ever told people that masks don't work, or that the public shouldn't wear them. They were telling people to save them for the health care workers!
And getting to the point upthread: that bit of misinformation is, again, something being deliberately propagated by people with a political agenda.
> Seriously people- STOP BUYING MASKS! They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus...
https://twitter.com/surgeon_general/status/12337257852839321...
It's not surprising people got "masks don't work" from that messaging.
> but if healthcare providers can’t get them to care for sick patients, it puts them and our communities at risk!
“ CDC does not currently recommend the use of facemasks to help prevent novel #coronavirus. Take everyday preventive actions, like staying home when you are sick and washing hands with soap and water, to help slow the spread of respiratory illness. ”
Look at the most recent CDC mask advice. They're not saying "masks work", they're using much more cautious language: "masks may work". https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prevent-getting-si...
Bullshit. Most of all because it's not a binary issue at all. Even if masks reduce the number of particles you exhale and inhale only by 30%, that makes a huge difference for the population as a whole.
Parent comment doesn't claim it is binary, or rest on it being binary. Post good quality evidence to show that marks work.
The article points out that contrarians, often conservative, promoted mask wearing until the US government reversed its position and said that masks do work.
Suddenly, anti-lockdown protests, conspiracy theories and mask objecting started happening, and mask wearing became politically polarizing. It would be interesting to see where these people get their information from...one suspects that the answer will be skewed heavily toward social media.
I think the simplest explanation is that the conservative right now views literally every issue as a them-versus-us issue, and as soon as it was clear that "they" thought we should wear masks, a very predictable conservative backlash occurred. I'm not sure if the president helped launch this particular battle in the "culture war" or was just a cheerleader as usual.
Do your own Googling next time.
My question was rhetorical. I know it's not true. I hoped you would look it up and realize your comment was inaccurate.
Their election interference was so wildly successful that they'd have no reason not be trying to inflict further damage on the US now.
To quell your conspiratorial concerns about 'masks' you need only visit most of the rest of the world and find out, particularly in close-quarters E. Asian countries, they've been doing it for some time.
Nobody is suggesting they are perfect, the messaging has been mixed, and we're not exactly sure of their efficiency, all of those things are allowed when supporting a 'pro mask' policy.
America has been losing the battle against COVID while E. Asian countries have been doing very well, and most of the rest of the world is doing 'OK' - popular US debate is the most ridiculous, least credible place for facts.
The CDC has some integrity, but this is a global phenom and literally everywhere else with integrity is taking this seriously.
People are not bing 'lied to' about masks, they're getting mixed messages because the issue is inherently grey.
The US government reversed itself on masks and recommended them before the rest of the English-speaking world. The WHO only endorsed masks a few weeks ago. I don't like Trump, but these are facts.
It seems to have been politicized after Mike Pence visited the Mayo Clinic, and didn't wear a mask, and then Trump was then pushed on the issue, and reacted characteristically. If Pence had set a good example and worn a mask, or of there hadn't been a huge uproar about him not wearing a mask, would the issue have turned into a front in the culture war?
That's not facts, that's spin. From your phrasing, it sounds like you're saying that prior to a "few weeks ago" that the WHO policy was somehow anti-mask. It wasn't, even in January. Their policy was always that PPE should be reserved for health care workers due to scarcity, and in a few (A FEW) instances their wording of that recommendation was poor and might plausibly imply that masks don't work.
No expert ever interpreted the WHO policy the way you people insist on doing. And at this point this insistence is just pathological.
Until Zeynep Tufekci's New York Times oped, the consensus was indeed that "masks don't work" for Covid. I documented numerous instances on social media of healthcare professionals insulting and belittling those who wore masks based on what you describe as "poor wording".
Here is a Time article from 4 March that sums up the expert consensus on masks at that point (in fact it has direct quotes from experts, including an infectious diseases professor, a leading psychologist, and the Surgeon General): that masking was "superstitious", didn't work and claiming that wearing a a mask equated to knocking on wood, or not walking under a ladder. https://time.com/5794729/coronavirus-face-masks/
Not arguing that any of this is a good enough reason to not wear a mask right now, but, I find them pretty darn inconvenient.
It's very uncomfortable. It fogs up my glasses when I’m inside, and covers up a large part of my field of view even when I’m outside. I can't ride my scooter at all because with that field of view loss, I'm worried I'll crash into something. Talking is more difficult, both projecting enough to be heard through the mask and straining to hear others.
I've tried several different masks at this point, so I don't think that's it.
The top of the mask, and the nose-bridge of the safety glasses, compete for the same location on the bridge of my nose.
If I layer them so that the mask touches my skin, and the eye glasses rest on the mask, I have no problem with fogging.
If I layer them the other way: the eye glasses' bridge directly on my skin, and the top of the mask resting on the eye glasses' bridge, I get fog.
Maybe you're experiencing this?
I usually avoid this simply by putting my eye glasses on after my mask is in place.
The surgical mask a friend got for me in March looks near identical to the pack of masks I got recently besides the color but the one she got me fogs up my glasses while the pack I have now never does.
(As a side note, I haven't tried many masks, but I find this one extremely comfortable and effective.)
[0] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B013SIIBFQ/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b...
https://www.npr.org/2020/05/08/853009325/how-to-prevent-glas...
>I can't ride my scooter at all because with that field of view loss, I'm worried I'll crash into something.
Just how big of a mask are you wearing? No mask I've used or seen would prevent this at all, sounds a bit dramatic to me. Plus, why are you even wearing one while riding your scooter? It's not needed unless you're in close proximity to people.
Or just stay in environments (your home, or outdoors with consistently good distancing) where you don't really need the mask.
They've been in stock online, locally at my grocery store, at Target, and at Costco for weeks now. Quite a few stores will hand you a free one if you don't have one (I know Kroger will), and a washable reusable one will set you back a few bucks at most.
If we discovered people weren't wearing their seatbelts enough, getting rid of seatbelts would be a silly mitigation.
I suspect that means you are not out of shape or live in a hot humid place. I wear a mask on those very few occasions when I leave my home but it takes a while to acclimate to it each time and often when I take it off my face is wet. And don't even get me started on the pain of wearing both a mask and glasses in a humid environment. Is it a valid excuse for not wearing one? No it isn't.
Edit: logic correction, I think...
Edit 2: I proofread poorly.
My glasses don't fog up nearly so much as that by simply wearing a mask; little bit on some exhales. So, given the benefits to others, I'm okay with it.
In my experience it is a big inconvenience. The air is not properly mixed, so one breathes back part of breathed-out air. With (cloth) facemask, i have shortness of breath after running up a staircase, and after 15 min of regular walk i start hyperventilating.
While i wear facemasks and consider it a reasonable measure, the government mandate was sometimes excessive. For example, at the start of the pandemic, the government mandated wearing facemasks everywhere outside of home, even in nature far from other people. I stopped to do recreational walks in nature, as it was just too burdensome to do that with facemask. Fortunately, after several weeks, the government noticed that mandating masks in nature far from other people is nonsense and made some exceptions.
Yes, some governments issued nonsense warnings like this. But don't let the dumb proclamations of a few politicians impact your overall opinion on mask usage. These days, most guidances seem to be largely fact-based, thank god.
If what you say is true, all healthcare workers who are wearing masks 8-12hrs a day would be collapsing - and most of them are double-masking with cloth masks on top of N95 masks.
[1] https://forums.studentdoctor.net/threads/trouble-breathing-i...
But let's look at actual data - there's no measurable impact on blood oxygen saturation when wearing masks:
https://twitter.com/MurseWordsworth/status/12767990206738882...
https://twitter.com/AlisonKabaroff/status/127738060548793958...
https://twitter.com/DrRobDavidson/status/1277565585568784385
I'm not entirely convinced by the test shown though. Doing a similar test while doing light exercise would be more convincing.
Another important factor to consider is that people breathe differently. Some people breathe more through their nose, others through their mouth. Maybe this can have an effect? Then there's also the fact that some people can take much stronger breaths (pulmonologists are always disappointed by my spirometry test results).
Mask wearing is important, but it doesn't feel right to just dismiss the reports that some people have more difficulty breathing with masks just because it doesn't happen to me.
I'm guessing the issues people face is less about the masks and more about the sensation of wearing a mask which spikes anxiety levels and causes the sensation of being unable to breath. If Japan can reach near ubiquitous levels of mask wearing without issues especially given their larger elderly population, I'm sure they'll be fine.
Otherwise if they have an actual medical issue that prevents wearing a mask then by all means.
"It works for me" or whichever other anecdote is given to dismiss a valid complaint has never held any water and never will.
> If Japan can reach near ubiquitous levels of mask wearing without issues especially given their larger elderly population, I'm sure they'll be fine.
Masks aren't fun to wear, I was out in one yesterday in Japan and my wife, who is Japanese and has worn a mask long before this pandemic was a glint in a bat's eye, was complaining about being out of breath and uncomfortable.
They're well known for being uncomfortable even in the winter, and they have plenty of negatives beyond that.
Besides, if you saw the way people wore masks in Japan you'd never use it in an argument.
You'd have to rule out confounding variables like panic attacks, nervousness, etc. - especially in first-time medical workers - and obtain actual evidence of impact on oxygen saturation for those anecdotes to be useful.
Second, i also wondered how healthcare workers could use that for full shifts. Perhaps my experience is related to my health issues (asthma in the past). Or perhaps improvised cloth facemasks are just much worse in this regard than surgical face masks or N95 respirators. Cloth facemasks could have just bigger air 'buffer'. N59 respirators with valve and coth mask on top could be much better, as they would have partially separated in- and out- airflow.
https://twitter.com/MurseWordsworth/status/12767990206738882...
And those with chronic health issues also see no problem with masks, despite having existing pulmonary conditions:
https://twitter.com/G17Esiason/status/1277249837059264512
Basically, the volume of air that your lungs can move, in addition to the force of exhaling/inhaling, easily overcomes any air "trapped" in the mask.
Watch the full video. CO2 is addressed.
> You can hyperventilate until you pass out without your blood oxygen saturation changing.
Passing out when you hyperventilate is from too little CO2 rather than “retention.“ The opposite of what is being claimed masks cause.
I don't think wearing a mask will meaningfully affect the breathing of most people, but blood oxygen isn't meaningful in demonstrating as much.
Passing out from hyperventilation is a second order effect of hypocapnia; the proximate cause is cerebral hypoxia, despite the blood being saturated.
I am not saying that there aren't people that have difficulty breathing in masks. I am saying that having difficulty wearing a mask is not normal and you should discuss it with your doctor to find out why.
Talk to a doctor. This is not normal. Running up a staircase is done with oxygen in your tissue, it doesn't involve breathing per se, your body buffers all that you need.
And regardless: there's not NEARLY enough air space behind your mask to store a full (~1L) exhalation. What you claim isn't even physically possible. Gas goes through and around the mask and mixes with your environment.
Frankly, (and I don't say this in spite, I promise!) your symptoms track more closely to anxiety than to any physical problem. Talk to your doctor, you'll probably feel better about things.
It's also possible to experience symptoms like that (thought usually also with intense itching and other sensations that make it clear that it's an allergy) if the max contains an allergen to which you are sensitive. (Some masks contain latex, which is a not-super-uncommon allergen.)
According to Wikipedia, normal level exhalation (tidal) volume is ~500 ml and has ~5 % CO_2. If only 10 % of exhalation (50 ml) is breathed back with 90 % of fresh air, then one is breathing equivalent of ~5000 ppm CO_2.
I am sure that improvized cloth facemasks have bigger air 'buffer' than this. Although measure it precisely would be hard.
Evidence based medicine doesn't exist to protect us against crystal healing (the bullshit that we know cannot work). It exists to protect us against things that sound plausible, against things that sound convincing.
The problem with the "wear a mask" message is how lazily anti-science it is, and how it distracts from the more important message of "keep your distance" and "wash your hands".
People who promote mask wearing say three things:
1) Masks work
2) They work well
3) We have good evidence for this
In healthcare good evidence would be a well run meta analysis of well run RCTs, or well run RCTs. We have lots of randomised controlled trials for mask wearing to prevent spread of respiratory disease. If masks were so strongly effective it would be easy to see the benefit in these RCTs. So why don't we see these benefits in the RCTs?
We have lots of good quality evidence around masks, and it doesn't show a benefit. For use to be able to see a benefit we have to drop the quality of the evidence, and then we start to see some marginal benefits of FFP3 type masks, but not for fluid-resistant surgical masks, and certainly not for cloth face coverings.
The message could have been "we don't know if they work, we don't have the evidence yet, but you should wear one anyway".
Instead we've got this bloke...
> “Back in March, it was difficult to even have anybody take you seriously when the CDC and WHO said the opposite,” said Jeremy Howard, a data scientist and entrepreneur who has become a major advocate of universal mask requirements. In response to the lack of support, he launched a bipartisan campaign called Masks4All that lobbied for widespread mask-wearing and argued that masks were a crucial, if not the most important, part of the COVID-19 response.
...ignoring the science around handwashing and distancing and focusing on mask wearing.
I don’t get this impression at all. In fact, I was thinking that if someone wears a mask, then they are more likely to be doing the other things (more or less reliably)
I'm a huge proponent of individual rights, but what often gets overlooked in these conversations is that my right to do something often conflicts with someone else's right to do something else.
COVID-19 has turned out to be no more deadly than any other seasonal respiratory disease. Lockdowns were ineffective. The data on this is clear and gets clearer every day (though you won't find it reading the stories on HN of course).
That means we should not be doing things any differently to other years. Which includes masks.
It's amazing how almost universally visceral, impulsive responses such as this fail to provide references to such data.
Try these sites for a flavour:
http://inproportion2.talkigy.com/
https://swprs.org/a-swiss-doctor-on-covid-19/
https://hectordrummond.com/2020/06/29/this-is-what-we-shot-o...
These links have a UK/Europe focus but the story is the same everywhere.
Re: lockdown does nothing. Take a look at the analyses by the major investment banks. They're all reaching the same conclusions because the data is public and anyone can analyse them. No correlation between lockdown severity and course of disease.
For me, some who has been wearing masks since before it became government mandated (though I recently stopped outdoors unless it’s crowded, as we barely have any cases; and it’s not as if more than 1 in 100 wear one outdoors anyway), masks are the single biggest inconvenience of the whole Sars-CoV-2 pandemic. I become slightly more claustrophobic (when in a store) and it feels like I have slight trouble breathing properly.
As I said, I’m a mask proponent, but I feel like all those statements of "wear a mask, it’s nothing" are hurting credibility.
I believe people there know that it's for the benefit of others but they understands that if everyone does it, everyone benefits? Unusually, this can be hard for people to understand.
Japan has a culture of conformism enforced by social pressure, and many places are now mandating that they be worn, that's why the masks are worn en masse of late, but often they're worn for privacy when you've little personal space. People still don't do what they're told and there's basically zero social distancing even where there's markings to guide people.
Nothing except an airtight seaal can stop it.
This is vastly amusing. Before late 2019, folks like me complained about laws against wearing masks in public. At protests, for example. While mailing stuff, or buying money orders. To circumvent facial recognition.
So now when I go out, and everyone is masked, it feels like such a bloody victory! Except that it is uncomfortable, when it's hot and humid. But hey.
A lot of members of society view not wearing one as an act of courage. A friend's mother will tell anyone she encounters who is wearing one that they are a ninny and a coward. So for some people it is also an indicator of courage/weakness.
A study lets me tell her she is an idiot. Preventing others from being called also cuts into the "ninny" narrative.
It seems like skin contact isn't quite so likely to spread the virus but breathing in exhaled droplets is.
Incidental interaction doesn't seem to spread the virus that well, so wearing a mask significantly reduces the risk to people like your grocery clerk.
It seems like general contagiousness isn't the primary mode of transmission, but instead the vast majority of cases come from superspreaders.
All of those indicate that mask wearing is probably more beneficial than expected.
If skin contact were the primary mode, then masks would likely have downsides as they tend to provide a warm, wet spot for the virus to hang out until you touch it.
Like lead paint or Thalidomide masks may only seem to be positive on the surface.
Without proper science it's wrong to make laws about it.
I suppose there are two answers to that question. One, health officials want to know if masks give a false sense of security so they can spend their time promoting measures that will actually make a difference. Two, folks just want a reason to avoid the minor inconvenience or, worse, have been led to believe that mask mandates seriously impinge upon their rights. My concern is that the most common answer is the second and articles like this only serve to confuse people at a time when we need to accept that we must make small sacrifices to solve this problem.