News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by phasnox on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:11PM (#22988915)
How many flights does NYC receive per day?

How many does Seattle receive?

The current state of both cities has nothing to do with what they did or didn't.

Same thing with Europe. The most affected countries are the most visited ones. Which also makes me question about the effectiveness of lockdowns.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by raz32dust on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:34PM (#22989080)
> Which also makes me question about the effectiveness of lockdowns.

Lockdowns are definitively, absolutely effective in curbing spread. It is backed by solid evidence of reduction is spread in places where lockdown was implemented, AND we have logical scientific reasoning to explain why. The only debatable aspect is whether they are the best solution, given all the trade-offs. And that is a difficult choice. But given no other solutions, if you can afford a lockdown, it is the right first step while you figure out other options.

Countries have been able to avoid a lockdown if they have sufficient quarantine facilities, contact tracing and hospital capacity. But in the absence of these, lockdown is the most effective way to navigate this.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by rishirishi on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:56PM (#22989262)
Lockdowns were the wrong solution, imo. I think we've underestimated the spread pre-lockdown and the spread during lockdown (grocery stores etc.). We'll know once broad antibody tests are administered. But if the virus has already spread to 30, 40, heck 50 percent of the population, then what the heck are we doing in lockdown...
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by lrem on Sunday April 26, 2020 @04:24PM (#22989918)
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-nether... 3% across Netherlands

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-04-24/corona... "in the most severely affected regions only about 10% to 15% of the population had been infected"

So, um, no, we are nowhere near the 50 percent, at least according to any data we might have. And, depending which expert do you heed and what is the definition of "herd immunity" they're after, we need 70%, 90% or 95% before this is over.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by mlyle on Sunday April 26, 2020 @10:32PM (#22992351)
50-66% is most likely, and perhaps less. Estimates of R0 are mostly in the range of 2.0-2.5.

50% would lower a 2.0 R0 to 1.0. 66% would lower a 2.5 R0 to 1.0. And this ignores that we may have permanently changed behaviors (e.g. handshakes) that facilitate spread, so we may not even need this fraction to curb tramission.

New York City is presently somewhere past 23%, so that's a big chunk of the way to a 1.0 Rt without controls.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by raz32dust on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:39PM (#22989582)
This is again missing the point. You cannot assume such things when lives are at risk. From the point of view of a leader, they knew the following:

- There is a deadly virus out there that is spreading very quickly.

- People who are not showing symptoms are spreading it.

- Community transmission has started

Given these data points, if one leader decided to lockdown sooner and another decided to wait it out, I think it is fair to say that the leader who picked lockdown made the right decision. Yes, if you add an additional data point that 50% of population is already infected, sure, you could argue that maybe it is doing more harm than good. But there is no evidence for this, and this almost certainly was not true when the lockdown decision was made in Washington and California.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by mjevans on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:24PM (#22989460)
What we were trying to do was to get the portion of the population that doesn't take this seriously to actually wash their hands, wear a mask (properly) in public to reduce their viral shedding and limit their trips out as well.

The why, as Washington State Governor Jay Inslee said, "The penalties are you might be killing your grandfather if you don't do it."

It's innocent others; our grandparents, those with known compromised health conditions, and those, even young and likely uninsured, with unknown health conditions, that are being saved.

Putting this another way, I don't care if someone is a smoker in isolation. That's their choice. I care when it spreads and affects others, including myself. The balance of freedom must be considered when conflicts exist, with a bias towards preventing tragedy of the commons.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by bathtub365 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:16PM (#22989387)
> what the heck are we doing in lockdown...

Not overwhelming hospitals.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by linuxhansl on Sunday April 26, 2020 @04:11PM (#22989810)
> But if the virus has already spread to 30, 40, heck 50 percent of the population

_If_ is the key part of this sentence. We simply do not know, which is why - as you point out - testing is key!

If we were strict on lock-down and on testing, we can be very effective with this:

After a few (say 6 or 8) weeks if lock-down we can know with high likelihood who is and who is not sick. Now test all the sick people (and their friends), and start testing the general public for anti-bodies. Then start tracing any new infections.

That requires folks following the lock-down and health measures and the mass availability of virus and anti-body tests.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by wtvanhest on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:14PM (#22989375)
So far, the highest estimates we are getting for antibodies are in the 20% range with dramatically flawed populations (NYC grocery).

Real number is less than that and could be way less than that.

Lockdowns create their own form of havoc, but I think they were the right decision at the time until we had more information.

Now we need to figure a low risk way forward

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by hsitz on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:44PM (#22989615)
In addition, there's little doubt that the infection has spread far more widely in NYC area than elsewhere. The covid-19 death rate per capita in NYC is 3 to 20 times higher other areas of the U.S. So even if NYC area had 20% who had been infected, that would not mean the rest of the country was anywhere close to that; other areas would not be close to NYC infection rate unless there death rates were similar.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by gumby on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:44PM (#22989162)
> How many flights does NYC receive per day?

If you read the article you'll see that doesn't matter. By the time Seattle took action the disease was already widespread in the population at large.

Other factors, like size, density, and use of public transport, are discussed in the article.

> The most affected countries are the most visited ones. Which also makes me question about the effectiveness of lockdowns.

The countries we have the best data on are developed countries. Again, read the discussion on the different tactics and approaches -- lockdown is only one of the issues.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by metaphor on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:51PM (#22989222)
> How many flights does NYC receive per day?

Looking at 2019 passenger statistics for the big 3:

  JFK[1] = 62.6 MM
  LGA[2] = 31.1 MM
  EWR[3] = 46.3 MM
  Total  = 140.0 MM
> How many does Seattle receive?

Equivalent 2019 metric for SEA[4] puts it at 51.8 MM.

So as a ballpark measure, greater NYC process 3x more than SEA.

The CDC[5] reports ~13k cases in WA, whereas NY alone is at ~267k cases; add another ~102k for nearby NJ.

Extending the benefit of the doubt, that's ~20x positive incident for 3x flight activity. Even if we pretend that WA is under-reporting by a factor of 2, and half of NY cases are false positive, the argument still falls flat on its face...keep in mind, NJ isn't even being accounted for in this thought experiment.

[1] https://www.panynj.gov/content/dam/airports/statistics/stati...

[2] https://www.panynj.gov/content/dam/airports/statistics/stati...

[3] https://www.panynj.gov/content/dam/airports/statistics/stati...

[4] https://www.portseattle.org/page/airport-statistics

[5] https://www.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/index.html

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by formercoder on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:53PM (#22989237)
It’s not the sole metric you’d need to regress against. Once those folks get off the plane they are in much closer contact with the rest of the population.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by metaphor on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:21PM (#22989431)
Now extend Tokyo an ounce of consideration in this context.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by notacoward on Monday April 27, 2020 @08:20AM (#22995117)
While I don't dispute the overall conclusion that Seattle handled things better, it's important to remember that infection is not a simple linear process. 3x the passengers does not necessarily mean 3x the cases. It means ~3x the chance of superspreader events directly from passengers, plus a higher chance of such events happening indirectly, and those events tend to be multiplicative rather than additive. On the other hand, it increases the chance that some people will be exposed via multiple paths but counted at most once. So 20x the cases seems a bit high, but 3x would be remarkably low.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by bb2018 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:30PM (#22989052)
I agree. de Blasio did terrible and Inslee acted way faster than Cuomo, but there is a reason that Buffalo is much better off than NYC even though they are both under the jurisdiction of New York law. Anyone who has lived in NYC as well as other cities knows just how different it is.

My family is in New England. Massachusetts has 10x more deaths per capita than New Hampshire even though, if anything, Massachusetts has been a bit ahead in terms of closures and interventions.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by Spooky23 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:55PM (#22989251)
The thing missed is that the spread from China was based on travel from Wuhan primarily. NYC infections came from Iran and Italy.

Saying that New York's approach wasn't science based is absurd. The most notable screwup was the delay in school closures due to the dependence that many have on getting breakfast and lunch at school. IMO, at the time I don't think awareness that asymptomatic "super spreaders" may exist was known. (Assuming that is true, much of the data known to CDC is now classified so it's difficult to really know!)

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by user_50123890 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:47PM (#22989185)
Imagine it's February 2020, multiple european countries decided to start softly locking down due to the scary news from Asia, even though they have barely any cases. Fast forward a week.

Your argument would basically be saying at that point "China has much more cases even though they have stricter restrictions, which means restrictions don't work!"

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by bb2018 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:04PM (#22989317)
That is not at all my argument. I am saying the posted article paints a picture of Seattle and New York City being equally susceptible to a huge explosion of cases. The differences between the two cities (in terms of density, public transit, tourists, etc) is about as significant as between a city like Boston and a city like Manchester, New Hampshire.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by downerending on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:40PM (#22989123)
> Anyone who has lived in NYC [...] knows just how different it is.

No one who's been to NYC can miss the fact that it's one of the filthiest places in America, from the perspective of disease possibilities. Many parts simply pile their trash on the curb and there are rats are everywhere. People pack into subway cars like sardines, and there's no way to avoid droplet transmission. During my time there, I saw several people vomit in public and just walk off.

There are plenty of great things about the city, but lacking a real culture of cleanliness (e.g., Tokyo), density breeds disease.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by crazygringo on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:48PM (#22989197)
Filthiness, trash and rats have zero to do with coronavirus.

COVID-19 is spread principally by breathing, which is unaffected by cleanliness.

And if you think people are packed into subway cars in New York... have you been to Tokyo?

I'm not saying New York is a paragon of cleanliness, but you will have to show some scientific evidence that curbside trash pickup or the occasional subway rat has anything to do with the prevalence of modern-day diseases. Because they simply do not as common knowledge suggests.

Modern diseases like colds and flus are spread through close contact in schools, office buildings and subways the exact same as they are every other major city on the planet.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by areyousure on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:21PM (#22989435)
> COVID-19 is spread principally by breathing, which is unaffected by cleanliness.

Masks?

> I'm not saying New York is a paragon of cleanliness, but you will have to show some scientific evidence that curbside trash pickup or the occasional subway rat has anything to do with the prevalence of modern-day diseases. Because they simply do not as common knowledge suggests.

Initial reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rats_in_New_York_City#Disease,...

Diseases carried by NYC rats: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25316698

Hong Kong and literal SARS: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12932393/

"Urban Norway and black rats (Rattus norvegicus and Rattus rattus) are the source of a number of pathogens responsible for significant human morbidity and mortality in cities around the world.": https://doi.org/10.1089/vbz.2012.1195

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by crazygringo on Sunday April 26, 2020 @08:17PM (#22991615)
Key quote: "it is unclear how infectious the rats are to residents".

Yes, we all know rats can carry disease, and that this has been a historical problem (e.g. the Black Death).

But it's not like coming into physical contact with a rat, or even their droppings or anything, is a common occurrence in NYC.

In 10 years living in New York City, I've seen a rat maybe 50 times total? Every single one was on the subway tracks (i.e. inaccessible), except exactly once I saw one at the end of the deserted platform, but far away from people.

Now I'm sure there are rats elsewhere, I'm just a single data point.

But nevertheless, to put it simply, getting diseases from rats is not a known public health problem in New York City. You cannot extrapolate a risk here simply from the presence of rats.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by downerending on Sunday April 26, 2020 @09:25PM (#22992033)
If you'd like to see a rat (as in rats), go to one of the city parks on trash day. The cans get emptied 24-48 hours before the trucks pick them up. Go there in the evening and sit maybe 30 meters from the trash heap. Watch carefully. Extra credit: Toss them french fries.

If you're up for a more disturbing experience, go sit on those benches at the south end of Riverside Park--the ones next to the ivy or whatever. Listen for the squeaking. Guess what? Those are rats. Lots and lots of rats, like in Jurassic Park or something.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by downerending on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:09PM (#22989347)
The connection is that the residents have simply come to accept those conditions and many related ones that probably will turn out to be relevant. It's a culture. (no pun intended)

I haven't been to Tokyo, but I have sat and watched groups of rats feast on curbside trash in Upper Manhattan. Many times. (And the roaches--ugh.)

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by mkolodny on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:50PM (#22989213)
How many flights does South Dakota receive?

A tiny number compared to NYC or Seattle. Yet, the state hasn't issued stay-at-home orders, and now they have a major outbreak.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by RickJWagner on Sunday April 26, 2020 @06:48PM (#22990991)
I'm from South Dakota.

So far, they've had 10 deaths. The total projected number of deaths through August 3rd is 93.

New York is projected to suffer 23,232 deaths for the same time period.

https://covid19.healthdata.org/united-states-of-america/sout...

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by jfnixon on Monday April 27, 2020 @12:51AM (#22992978)
The Smithfield outbreak was in an essential industry factory (food production) which would not have been subject to a general lockdown.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by jcims on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:33PM (#22989072)
Here's some stats i dug up the last time when we were comparing LA to NYC...Seattle's differences are probably even more extreme. Sure they could have done better from a policy perspective, but the difference in outcome is not purely driven by policy and the stats between areas with widely divergent levels of transmission opportunity aren't really that comparable.

--

'More subway' doesn't really capture it. NYC has ~70x the daily ridership on metro rapid transit.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_rapid_tr...

Overall population density is much higher as well:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b...

NYC also has the lowest car ownership in the nation, so you're basically left with walking or uber/taxi/public transportation just to get to the store/doctor/etc.

https://www.governing.com/gov-data/car-ownership-numbers-of-...

Also ~25% more airline traffic hauling bugs in from everywhere.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_busiest_city_airport_s...

Combined with a long transmissable dwell time before symptoms, wouldn't surprise me if 90%+ of the people in NYC were materially exposed.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by graycat on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:20PM (#22989423)
> Combined with a long transmissable dwell time before symptoms, wouldn't surprise me if 90%+ of the people in NYC were materially exposed.

Looks like you have a possibly important point:

If so, then they would be well on the way to herd immunity and, thus, essentially at the end new cases and the end of the epidemic.

So, for your point, at

https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2020/04/23/andrew-cuomo-1...

is in part:

"Andrew Cuomo: 13.9% of New Yorkers Tested Positive for Coronavirus Antibodies; 21% in NYC"

The 21% is huge.

So, it looks like the virus spread much faster than symptoms indicated and now ballpark 1/4th NYC has been "exposed" to the virus and is either infected without symptoms or recovered without ever having significant or any symptoms. Amazing. So, if want to accept the usual situation for viruses, then the 1/4 of the population soon can't get or transmit the virus.

Ah, but wait; there's more: As at

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/in-four-us-state-prisons-n...

is, call it an exploitation of a captive audience,

> When the first cases of the new coronavirus surfaced in Ohio’s prisons, the director in charge felt like she was fighting a ghost.

> “We weren’t always able to pinpoint where all the cases were coming from,” said Annette Chambers-Smith, director of the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction. As the virus spread, they began mass testing.

> They started with the Marion Correctional Institution, which houses 2,500 prisoners in north central Ohio, many of them older with pre-existing health conditions. After testing 2,300 inmates for the coronavirus, they were shocked. Of the 2,028 who tested positive, close to 95% had no symptoms.

> “It was very surprising,” said Chambers-Smith, who oversees the state’s 28 correctional facilities.

and the article has more such data.

Then if want to accept an estimate that 50% of the population immune means herd immunity, NYC is ballpark half way to herd immunity which would be close to the end of the epidemic. E.g., even people in NYC so far never exposed to the virus would not get infected even from infected new arrivals before they were recovered or dead.

So, a guess is that the virus SARS-COV-2 is very strange in two respects: (1) It is astoundingly communicative, that is, spreads very easily and (2) has some huge fraction of people with the virus but without symptoms.

A guess at an explanation: In NYC, the virus was often getting spread just via the air, e.g., via building central HVAC systems?

The good news, if want to believe all such evidence and related common assumptions, is that we can get to a fraction of the population with immunity large enough to have herd immunity and, thus, essentially be well on the way to the end of the epidemic, all surprisingly quickly.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by klyrs on Sunday April 26, 2020 @04:05PM (#22989762)
> If so, then they would be well on the way to herd immunity and, thus, essentially at the end new cases and the end of the epidemic.

Only, there's no evidence that folks who recover from COVID are immune. Herd immunity might never come, so lockdowns remain beneficial in reducing hospital crowding.

https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/0...

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by graycat on Sunday April 26, 2020 @06:46PM (#22990975)
> Only, there's no evidence that folks who recover from COVID are immune.

Yup. But the usual assumption, experience, history, situation, whatever of viruses is that recovery means immunity at least for some significant time, say, a year or so.

Also, I stated

> So, if want to accept the usual situation for viruses,

I didn't explicitly repeat this qualification just before your quote but went for fewer words.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by mlyle on Sunday April 26, 2020 @10:39PM (#22992387)
A lot of people miss that herd immunity is likely the only reasonable path. Some models show decay to low case counts in a few weeks, but I'm not buying it.

Here in the SF Bay Area, I'm seeing a 40% decay weekly in hospital admissions. If you assume infections outnumber hospital admissions by 20x, it's going to be months before we reach the low case counts (1 per million) needed for contact tracing and suppression efforts amid semi-normal activities. And that's assuming we keep the 40% decay rate, and don't encounter subpopulations with higher Rt's that keep the virus circulating much longer or even growing.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by klyrs on Sunday April 26, 2020 @07:52PM (#22991430)
> so, I stated

>> So, if want to accept the usual situation for viruses...

You're saying that we should assume "normal situation" in the face of evidence that your assumptions do not hold. Anything you say based on this faulty assumption is hardly worth consideration.

Folks don't develop immunity to this virus. They can get re-infected immediately after recovering. Herd immunity is a phenomenon observed elsewhere, but not here.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by mlyle on Sunday April 26, 2020 @10:36PM (#22992369)
> Folks don't develop immunity to this virus. They can get re-infected immediately after recovering.

This is an extraordinary claim without evidence.

There's a few case reports of "reinfection", but they are rare. In all cases A) symptoms were mild, and B) researchers were unable to culture SARS-CoV-2 from them. Many viral illnesses have people shed virus again a few times after "recovering", and this seems no different.

A bigger concern is, humans seem to lose antibodies to coronaviruses with time-- this is how we get the common cold again and again. But infections after the first time seem to be less severe, thanks to longer-lived immunity from memory t-cells, etc. And at least for SARS-COV-1, immunity lasted quite a bit longer than typical for other human coronaviruses, with decent antibody titers at 3 years (no followup past then).

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by graycat on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:50AM (#22994389)
> You're saying that we should assume "normal situation" in the face of evidence that your assumptions do not hold.

Not really! As you say, this virus is new. Soooooo, we are short on info. So, we should entertain several possibilities.

I didn't say "should" and, to entertain more than one possibility, only said "If"! Biggie difference.

Yup, we don't know. If we do a lot of very well designed and executed statistical trials, controlled, double blind, randomized, simple random sample, stratified sample, etc., then maybe in five years we will know enough to be sure on all the major points, across seasons, ages, other medical conditions, reinfection, spreading via HVAC systems, therapeutics with dosages, side effects, and contraindications, vaccines with number of shots, contraindications, etc. Ah, just wait five years!!!!

Well, nope, to paraphrase, we go to war with the info we have and not the info we want.

So, for the info we have, from the history of viruses, once recovered, then likely immune for a long time; for now we have to take that seriously and maybe are in effect forced to act as if we believe it.

Yup, there are reports of "reinfection" from maybe China or South Korea -- I didn't pay much attention to those reports due to concerns about, call it, data quality. But, net, yup, maybe in some cases, maybe even in all cases, recovery does not mean immunity.

At high cost, we will be finding out with some relatively good data, and in less than five years! Did I mention high cost?

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by MR4D on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:25PM (#22989022)
> The current state of both cities has nothing to do with what they did or didn't.

I disagree.

Specifically, Deblasio took forever to close the schools. I don’t live in NYC, and I remember when before they closed the schools wondering why they hadn’t done it yet.

So some actions matter more than most.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by jfnixon on Monday April 27, 2020 @01:00AM (#22993014)
There is some evidence schools, and young children, are not spreading the disease. In SG, which did extensive contact tracing early on, there were no clusters associated with schools (apart from one where the cluster was in staff who had minimal contact with students). The early super spreader event from an SG conference resulted in a Covid-19 positive child, and not one case was attributed to this person. Anecdotal, not rigorous, but still evidence.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/21/boy-with-covid...

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by DanBC on Monday April 27, 2020 @01:26PM (#22997885)
There's emerging data in the UK of a syndrome that's connected to covid-19 in children (but it may not be covid). Whatever it is it's not common, but a small percentage across a large population is a large number.

The Paediatric Intensive Care society put out an alert (weirdly using Twitter to do so): https://twitter.com/PICSociety/status/1254508725227982848

https://www.hsj.co.uk/acute-care/exclusive-national-alert-as...

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-52439005

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by shawnz on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:30PM (#22989050)
Washington closed schools only 5 days before New York did (3 if you exclude weekends)
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by predictmktegirl on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:32PM (#22989063)
At the time, that was enough for "only" two doublings in cases at the projected rate of spread.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by jdc on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:28PM (#22989042)
> The current state of both cities has nothing to do with what they did or didn't.

What's your source on that though?

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by guscost on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:31PM (#22989058)
Nobody can back up any of these claims right now, it’s all belief and speculation. If someone says they have analyzed the outbreaks in Seattle and NYC and can control for all the differences between them, they’re delusional.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by ghaff on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:39PM (#22989117)
As I've said before, I strongly suspect that when this is all over, there will be a heck of a lot of deviation in results that don't neatly align with a "stupid government" vs. "enlightened government" dichotomy. Although people will certainly try.

The Northeast US is, at least in parts, some of the worst in the world that is known about and, other than being pretty dense, it really doesn't map to especially poor government response by reasonable definitions. Perfect hindsight doesn't count.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by jdc on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:39PM (#22989121)
Seems reminiscent of astronomy with less accurate measurements.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by jorblumesea on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:30PM (#22989515)
King County has had ~400 confirmed COVID deaths while NYC has had ~12,000. Number of flights, population, all that stuff doesn't explain a x30 increase in deaths.

If you read the article, they largely discuss NYC's inability to arrive a decision promptly, which allowed things to spread. Also, resistance to the idea of social distancing looks like it made things much worse.

It's like everyone who is commenting here didn't even read the article and is just spouting opinions.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by bigpumpkin on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:38PM (#22989113)
Arguing against the short term effectiveness of lockdowns is like arguing against physics. If on average the number of people a person come in contact with decreases, it will definitely decrease the infection rate.

The long term effect is arguable since we don't know if we can prevent the majority of people from getting infected.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by mkolodny on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:12PM (#22989367)
> The long term effect is arguable since we don't know if we can prevent the majority of people from getting infected.

That's why the phrase "slow the spread" makes sense. Even if we can't prevent people from getting infected eventually, we can slow the spread enough that hospitals can handle incoming patients. If everyone gets infected at the same time, there won't be enough ventilators to treat everyone.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by sub7 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:49PM (#22989648)
If you don't think lockdowns have dramatically reduced the number of infections, you are incorrect.

More visitors may kick off more chains of infection (so higher numbers) but that's just linear growth. Stopping exponential spread is what prevented something far worse than what we have seen.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by jfnixon on Monday April 27, 2020 @01:02AM (#22993023)
We don't even know the order of magnitude of the infection count, and you are making claims about how the lockdown is reducing them? That's not reason, that's faith.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by user_50123890 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:39PM (#22989120)
It's actually suspected that the whole epidemic in Europe originated from the first confirmed infection in Germany. A woman from Shanghai who had a business trip with her car manufacturer. That same manufacturer happens to have a factory in northern Italy.

Some Italian scientists did an RNA analysis on samples from infected people from Italy, and confirmed they descended from the first German case.

Basically, if this hypothesis is true then German quarantine and/or exposure tracking failed. Had they played it safe and properly quarantined the entire staff of the office building , Europe's coronavirus pandemic might have gone entirely differently.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by lukastr0 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:45PM (#22989173)
> It's actually suspected that the whole epidemic in Europe originated from the first confirmed infection in Germany.

According to virologist Dr. Drosten, this idea has been mostly disproven. Some scientists believed it initially but after more debate, the consensus has emerged that both Italy and Germany got their virus directly from Wuhan or Shanghai.

Source (in German language): https://www.ndr.de/nachrichten/info/coronaskript174.pdf page 79

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by christkv on Sunday April 26, 2020 @04:37PM (#22990054)
The Milan area hosts more than 100000 Chinese foreign workers. Madrid nearly 200000. How many came back from vacation in December and January taking the virus with them? I think this was seeded earlier than we think.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by jaynetics on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:49PM (#22989202)
Nextstrain has a nice graphical overview of virus pathways.

It might well be that containment failed, and that a single person caused hundreds or thousands of the deaths in Italy, much like patient 31 in South Korea.

On the other hand, without those extra deaths, authorities would simply have waited a bit longer with a lockdown, people would have acted as usual for longer, and the end result might just have been very similar with a delay of a few weeks.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:46PM (#22989182)
This just makes it worse. NYC is denser, more interconnected, more unqeual, more public transit oriented, and all these other things that make it high risk. Being a higher outbreak risk, they should have taken more precautions earlier, rather than fewer precautions later. The difference in number of cases in each region isn't the story. It couldn't be, precisely because these places are so different. The story is the differences how each region approached precautions. You'd hope NY, as a higher outbreak risk, would have been more cautious and more willing to listen to experts than Seattle.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by graeme on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:16PM (#22988961)
More specifically, NYC/NJ had lots of flights from the European epicenter. The west coast has more flights from Asia, which had a comparatively small number of cases.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by mlyle on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:23PM (#22989012)
I think that this breaks down when you look at the case progression. Likely west coast cities and NYC/NJ had similar case counts at the beginning of this, but made different interventions and had drastically different outcomes.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by __s on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:29PM (#22989046)
Yep, in Canada British Columbia's case count was ahead of Ontario until mid March. Now the latter is an order of magnitude more severe
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by kaesar14 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:22PM (#22989005)
That's supposing that Chinese numbers are accurate. Which I don't believe.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by asdff on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:53AM (#22994112)
LAX is the port of entry for most of the asian world in the US and LA is doing far better than NYC due to leadership choices alone.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by rishirishi on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:15PM (#22988953)
As I see it, lockdowns are not effective and were a massive mistake. You may find this epidemiologist's perspective to be interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfN2JWifLCY
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by TimJRobinson on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:35PM (#22989092)
From looking at the current infection graphs Sweden is about to have a very bad time. When 99% of epidemiologists are saying one thing and you have to seek out a contrarion ask yourself if you're really being helpful or just trying to confirm your existing beliefs.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by mardifoufs on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:18PM (#22989405)
People have been saying that about Sweden for about 2 months now yet we still don't see any catastrophe happening there. Their hospitals are doing just fine, they aren't overwhelmed and there is no uncontrollable mortality. Why would Sweden suddenly do much worst now? It's curve has flattened and they are even closing emergency ICUs they setup but never had to use.
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by NotSammyHagar on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:27PM (#22989490)
Sweden has a pop of about 10 mil, Switzerland has a pop of about 8.5 mil. Sweden is projected to have about 10,000 deaths, Switzerland under 2,000; accounting for their population differences, Sweden could have avoided 8,000 deaths if they had locked down. 8000! source is IHME, https://covid19.healthdata.org/sweden, https://covid19.healthdata.org/switzerland. This also applies to the nordic countries like Denmark, Finland, Norway as compared to Sweden too.

Sweden did start much more slowly that switzerland but they clearly are vastly underperforming in saving their citizens.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by misja111 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:45PM (#22989625)
The death rate in Sweden is comparatively high but it is too simple to just blame it on their avoidance of a lockdown.

You took Switzerland as an example, but if you would have taken Belgium, Sweden would do actually very well. Still, Belgium took quite strict lockdown measures and in a pretty early stage.

What really seems to have had a significant result on keeping the death rate down, is testing: countries like Germany and Switzerland are testing often and early and have done so already in an early stage of the outbreak. This way they were able to treat patients early and to protect vulnerable patients against others in their surrounding that were infected.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:57PM (#22989267)
That is an important question to ask, but I think in this case the answer is that it's helpful.

That other 99% really don't seem to know for sure lockdowns are effective; the only arguments I've ever seen them present are "my model says they're effective" or "it would be strange in principle if they weren't". (Some laypeople draw dishonest comparisons to control measures for the Spanish Flu, but epidemiologists know that these measures didn't include orders to stay at home or close all businesses.)

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by user_50123890 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:49PM (#22989206)
Sweden has about 10 times more deaths than their neighbours. Oh and this is with 80% of the population in VOLUNTARY lockdown, their bars and restaurants are open sure but they're empty.

The US would probably be at over a million deaths by now if life had continued normally without lockdowns.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by mardifoufs on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:15PM (#22989384)
Norway doesn't count its deaths in the same way Sweden does and in any case Sweden's hospitals are not getting close to being overrun. Remember, curve flattening isn't about avoiding infections it's about spreading our rhe infection rates to allow the healthcare system to better cope. Also, Sweden is doing better than a lot of locked down countries so in any cade it's weird to only compare them to their immediate neighbors. Québec is similar to Sweden in a lot of ways but still has a higher mortality rate even if the province got hit a lot later than Sweden did
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by RickJWagner on Sunday April 26, 2020 @06:52PM (#22991020)
I think we're all reasonable people here on HN.

I also think we have many different ideas about what's best. (Again, all people I assume are smart.)

This is just a hard scenario. There is no obvious 'best' answer. There may not even be a 'right' answer.

Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by DanBC on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:16PM (#22989392)
Do you have links to the Norwegian and Swedish statistics showing what methods they're using please?
Re:Seattle’s leaders let scientists take the lead, New York’... by rishirishi on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:52PM (#22989230)
There is also the likelihood of this virus to have already infected a large % of the population. Antibody tests will confirm that.