Do we know what nobody needs, for real? Sure, there might be some low-hanging fruit, but this seems like an area where Chesterton's fence would apply in spades, lest our judgments age as well as Rick Perry talking about the Department of Energy.
And there's also the fact that it's demand for non-essential things that employs the large portion of people who moved out of farming and other necessities because we got good enough at production that they didn't need to be there.
We might be able figure out how to fund productive things that incentives don't automatically align for, but this sounds trickier than it might seem at first glance.
Fashion, advertising. You probably know the few. Free market under covid pressure will tell us what was the unnecessary crap that was basically just excuse to pay people so they can live.
Maybe, but what do you do with people whose livelihood depend on those superfluous bullshit jobs?
Until we have a system that guarantees a right to life even if you do nothing productive, those busyworks are used to justify giving food, shelter and healthcare to those people.
For this crisis, people are saying, give $1000 to everyone... that money is mostly going to find its way into the pockets of already rich people, and/or those companies that should have collapsed because of bad planning, but now won't. Instead, you could legislate things like food stamps for everyone (with the government paying grocers directly, while at the same time ensuring the money isn't spent on shit like alcohol and cigarettes), and a few months of rent amnesty for everyone (including businesses) (it's not like houses will disappear if somebody doesn't pay the rent).
Either way, government money (ie. tax money) will be funnelled to, in your words, “already rich people”.
Your way is probably worse, because it forces governments to pick winners, which they are notoriously bad at doing.
Because my utility function isn't the same as yours, so outside of goods and services where there is strong reason to believe that the conditions do not exist for markets to work, it's better to provide people fungible currency and allow them to maximize their own utility function through purchasing decisions rather than have a centralized bureaucracy decide what they most need. Also because despite the aforementioned variability in utility functions, agency seems to pretty consistently be positively valued, so centrally imposed selection would be inefficient in utilitarian terms even if it perfectly reflected the recipients utility function before considering agency.
This is being proposed where I live. I'm curious to know who, in this situation, pays the owners of the rental properties for the use of the house, for the expenses and maintenance, for the employees, plumbers, electricians, and contractors, etc. And what about lost profits due for the assumption of the risk of buying properties for the purpose of providing homes for people to live?
First, it is highly paternalistic to tell people what to spend money on.
Second, it takes a huge bureaucracy to manage and enforce controls. Folks still sell their food stamps.
1: https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2017/08/07/5416096...
Indeed, and that's kind-of the point: (1) you eliminate bullshit spending (on things like alcohol, tobacco, lottery) that many people are prone to do, but that they arguably shouldn't (to some extent, those products are "predatory"); (2) it provides a minimal standard (survival) yet incentivizes people to work (be productive) to increase their standard of living (e.g. to be able to buy alcohol); (3) avoids inflation, as only a very limited set of products would be affected by increased demand (in particular, not real estate, as "free" housing would only be available in government-owned real estate) that the government can plan in advance.
My prior is that "bureaucracy" can be reduced significantly with modern IT technologies.
How do you propose to prevent people acquiring drugs, and gambling?
Whose pockets do you think it's going to come out of, whether by taxes or inflation (which is a tax on holders of dollar denominated assets). It's just doing more work for other people along the way.
Well, if America just reversed the past 3 years of tax policy, that money would come out of the pockets of the top 1%, primarily. That's people earning more than $400k a year.
As it is, we are going backwards. The government is literally borrowing money now to give money back, in droves, to rich people, instead of to poorer and middle class people.
People prefer money to buy their own food over government-issued turnips.
There is no debt. There's only the use of "debt" and "lending" as a thinly disguised pretext for feudal tribute used for political advantage.
If we don't work through this it's going to kill us as a species.
Doing strategically useful stuff that generates invention and opportunity instead of making plastic toys that end up in landfill is a different but not entirely unrelated problem.
The WW2 debt problem in the US was managed by roughly tripling the share of the economy taken in in taxes, not just growing the economy. Taxes aren't fixed.
> Going into debt is a big problem if it eats up all of your tax revenue to service it
It's a big problem if it eats up all of your productive output; tax revenue is an arbitrarily-adjustable figure.
OTOH, if your debt is denominated in your own currency, so is (in real terms) the debt itself.
There was the choice what to focus on, and we decided we wanted uncontrolled immigration. Fair choice, but the consequence is that UBI won't work anymore.
The US definitely has an immigration policy. Not to mention that no serious politician today (despite what some media outlets may claim) is running on a platform of open borders.
No, we didn't; US immigration is controlled both numerically and by qualities of immigrants. You may disagree with the choices of controls, but they absolutely exist.
The US is notoriously complicated to gain entry to by legal means.
What are you referring to here?
I am certain that you know what I am referring to, but want to avoid a serious discussion by playing with technicalities. No thanks.
I live in a relatively small city on the island state of Tasmania, and am probably way behind on some aspects of global politics.
IMHO, even as a recovering laissez-faire libertarian type, the real reason for those jobs is to create funnels of money to the top of society to make a very tiny fraction of the population obscenely wealthy. The bigger scale and the glitzier the funnel, the bigger the fountain of cash for the execs to splash around amongst them. Billionaires are a mathematical anomaly, and those busywork jobs are their payment for us not decapitating the bastards like it's 1789, coupled with an absolutely stunning propaganda blitz that hoodwinked us mere techie upper-middle classers into believing they earned it, deserved it, worked hard for it. It's a lie; a lifetime is not long enough to learn 120,000 lifetimes worth of wealth, and I don't give a shit how many warehouses or webpages your minions make.
(sorry, this whole thing isn't directed at you; more like the Bezoses of the world).
Give them work in production of things people need or delivering things people need.
> system that guarantees a right to life even if you do nothing productive
How could such a system work? Wouldn't that motivate everyone to stop being productive ?
The “shit” nobody needs is the main point of living: music, art, science, sharing, pets; the crap you desire versus the essentials.
If we only got what we needed to survive (food, shelter) that would be a pointless and depressing life.
I'm all for a Hayek/Friedman approach to the markets, but I think even they would consider above trivialities in comparison with things like a supportive family, spiritual nourishment, a shared culture, social stability, etc. etc. The market needs to be kept in perspective. If all of that (illusory) choice was vastly attenuated tomorrow, people would quickly adapt.
It will relase the capacity of people that are currently brainstorming how to cram their brand of shampoo into their customers homes instead of all the other brands.
This all started with black_puppydog's comment: > I don't agree with the conclusion. We can scale down our economies and still maintain production of essentials by ``drumroll`` scaling back shit that nobody needs.
Anybody whose life would be drastically worsened by having 10 different types of shampoo rather than x hundred needs help.
If I were a dictator, maybe I would think pets are pointless. Another person may think science is pointless.
I think the vast majority of what people want is wasteful, but who am I to tell others what their priorities should be?
And yet, Greta Thunberg.
The point of social distancing and quarantine measures now, is the choice between a hard time for the next few months, even to the point of it being "pointless and depressing"; and death.
I don’t believe anybody is seriously arguing against any of those things.
Science is one of the essentials. Music and art can and should be done remotely. Pets are fine but if you need pretty vest for your dog this season you might make it yourself instead of paying amazon to force people to crowd by hundreds over sawing machines.
People are flexible with their behavior but they have pretty much innate level of happiness. You can feel as much happiness because of a roof that finally doesn't leak as from new marble patio.
On the other hand, I suspect heavily propagandised blinkers are even harder to shift during a crisis than in more stable times. Fearful people are driven to protect what they have, and are apt to react violently to do so. The "normal" global economy is a catastrophe, but we'll have to return to it (if such is possible) for some time at least.
Your comment would've been stronger without this line.
One concrete thing that will come into focus, especially in this US election year, is the healthcare system. If the virus overwhelms the capacity in the US, it will be constantly in the news. There's no better use of the attention than to have that debate about how healthcare should be done.
About the BS jobs, yes, there's undoubtedly a lot of those. I think the only way they go is if the crisis hits the economy so hard that many businesses collapse and are rebuilt, without those jobs. This would be a catastrophe for an awful lot of people. Now, one thing that might prove to be the difference between business going down and not is government intervention. So it's going to be interesting what level of aid is offered.
My sense is the government will try to save as many businesses as possible, not taking the chance to clean out the mess left from two decades of excessively cheap money.
Maybe this will help to introduce basic income and to finally part with the silly notion that to survive you need an excuse of having some job even if that job is manufacturing products and services people don't really need and tricking them into buying those.
I understand the motivations for what you propose, but I do not see how it would work in practice before going into full-authoritarian mode.
Having more money isn't useful in this situation. You already get the essentials and can't buy non-essentials because they aren't being produced.
I mean that with UBI you can fix the idiocy of creating real fake jobs to keep people busy, but you won't fix people wanting to buy silly things.
If the supply will be lower because people won't need to manufacture them to have an excuse to not starve to death, price of silly things will go up and that does wonders to people's wants for silly things.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
;)
The bullshit jobs are mostly the good jobs right now. The travel, restaurant, and entertainment industries are filled with non-bullshit jobs that are going away in the next week.
In other words, you’re asking for half the world to get a different job.
That's half of Silicon Valley gone then.
Living in permanent social distancing, waiting to die from 3rd or 4th infection ... is not a humane way to live.
Think about the dense crowds on airports, for example. How many of those people actually have to use an airplane to get where they need to be? I bet a lot of those are flying to a business meeting that could have been a telco or a chat instead. Or if their job turns out to be a bullshit job, the meeting would be entirely pointless.
No, in this theoretical ideal perfect world you are proposing we conjured into existence in a matter of months, they would take up productive jobs. So they would be going to work, meeting people, socialising and spreading the virus just as much as they were before. It's no the same problem.
I believe the argument is that UBI could be conjured in to existence.
$1,000 * 12 * 327,000,000,000 = $3,924,000,000,000
Collected US tax revenue for 2019 was $3.46 trillion. Even if you could afford it in terms of money, it still wouldn't change anything, because you still have the same amount of goods available.
UBI would for most people be offset by increases in payroll taxes, so for the majority it would be a small overall change in income, up for some and down for others, dramatically buffering the cost compared to your calculation.
Overall I'm a UBI skeptic, I don't see any way it could herald in a utopia of freedom some of it's proponents imagine. That's wishful thinking, but as an emergency measure to help people through a severe crisis like this it might make sense.
https://www.loniya.org/storage/pdf/1535752644.pdf
It's an excellent introduction into the problems of capitalism for those not particularly interested in communism and just trying to get their feet wet.
Like it or not, the U.S. armed forces underpin the world's current economic system and its relative peace. The prosperity as a result of America's control is called Pax Americana [1].
Some might consider the U.S.' powers undesirable, but I'm not arguing in favor of the general desirability of Pax Americana here. I'm just saying: keep in mind that "keeping U.S. forces at home" and significant scaling back of the foundation of Pax Americana is not desirable from both an economic perspective (for nearly everyone) or military perspective (for probably everyone).
Don't get me wrong - Pax Americana will end at some point, but it's in the best interest for everyone that this will be a mostly gradual change. For all Americans or non-Americans, it's not desirable that the U.S. withdraws its global army for any reason, including this calamity [2].
-
[0]: Nukes aside, the United States army has the sheer striking force to obliterate any other armed force world wide. In a "U.S. versus the rest of the world combined" scenario, the U.S. would still have a good chance of winning.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_Americana
[2]: Not the point of my post, but I don't believe this would even be a reasonable calamity for the U.S. to withdraw its armed forces for at all - outside of a small percentage of reshuffling things. Not playing down the trouble we're in at all, but we should also be making an effort to make a relative return to normalcy well within this year / within a couple of months. This is what's already being done in China.
Maybe that was the case before USA clearly displayed its military inaptitude in nearly every conflict it has chosen to involve itself with over the last decades.
People of the world now strongly suspect that USA military underpins peace no more than bullys presence underpins calmness in the playground.
The utter dominance of America's armed forces has achieved extraordinary peace and prosperity since World War II, since its dominance has prevented numerous smaller scale conflicts or new world wars. Me saying this isn't trying to diminish the terrible suffering that has happened in the world since World War II, but it's pointing out that historically speaking the suffering and stupidity should have been far worse.
The US armed forces don't embody peace in the slightest, but they do achieve it just by virtue of existing and being so dominant.
Does USA really prevented more wars since WWII than they caused?
Absolutely. This is not just my opinion, it's also the opinion of historians and geopolitical experts. And moreover, it has historical precedent. The Roman Empire's dominance also ushered in a period of peace and prosperity, coining the original term Pax Romana.
It might be a hard view to accept while having background knowledge of the suffering caused by US armed forces, and the stupidity and crimes committed. But that's just a lack of imagination of how much worse it could have been, and how much worse it was before WWII ended.
But I forgot already what my original point was. :-) I'll try to educate myself about historical evaluation of Pax Americana.
"Militarism is the belief or the desire of a government or a people that a state should maintain a strong military capability and to use it aggressively to expand national interests and/or values."
If you keep your army at home you're not really using it aggressively to expand national interests.
Starting with an overblown healthcare admin system in the US, IMHO, but also including less inflammatory non-essential things like yet another range of plastic toys and luxury perfumes and and and.
Essentially in this scenario, we should take this as an opportunity to prune all Bullshit Jobs [1] and focus on things securing social, mental, and healthcare subsistence.
Oh and maybe just don't move troops all around the planet to fuck up other people's place. It wasn't a good idea before, (both during the 1918 influenza wave and after that) and it's certainly not a good idea now. Save that money and manpower, put it to use for something constructive for a change.
There you go, I guess I just pissed on every holy cow this crowd has. You know where the downvote button is.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs