I'm all for a Hayek/Friedman approach to the markets, but I think even they would consider above trivialities in comparison with things like a supportive family, spiritual nourishment, a shared culture, social stability, etc. etc. The market needs to be kept in perspective. If all of that (illusory) choice was vastly attenuated tomorrow, people would quickly adapt.
It will relase the capacity of people that are currently brainstorming how to cram their brand of shampoo into their customers homes instead of all the other brands.
This all started with black_puppydog's comment: > I don't agree with the conclusion. We can scale down our economies and still maintain production of essentials by ``drumroll`` scaling back shit that nobody needs.
Anybody whose life would be drastically worsened by having 10 different types of shampoo rather than x hundred needs help.
If I were a dictator, maybe I would think pets are pointless. Another person may think science is pointless.
I think the vast majority of what people want is wasteful, but who am I to tell others what their priorities should be?
And yet, Greta Thunberg.
The point of social distancing and quarantine measures now, is the choice between a hard time for the next few months, even to the point of it being "pointless and depressing"; and death.
I don’t believe anybody is seriously arguing against any of those things.
Science is one of the essentials. Music and art can and should be done remotely. Pets are fine but if you need pretty vest for your dog this season you might make it yourself instead of paying amazon to force people to crowd by hundreds over sawing machines.
People are flexible with their behavior but they have pretty much innate level of happiness. You can feel as much happiness because of a roof that finally doesn't leak as from new marble patio.
The “shit” nobody needs is the main point of living: music, art, science, sharing, pets; the crap you desire versus the essentials.
If we only got what we needed to survive (food, shelter) that would be a pointless and depressing life.