News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by JPKab on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @05:51PM (#22540144)
One of my coworkers daughters is affected by this.

The big question this begs:

If there is no refund being offered for the content shifting online from in-person, why have in-person at all?

Is room and board going to be refunded?

If courses being taught online is an acceptable substitute, why have caps on admission at all? Edit: Understood that infinite sized classes aren't workable for human intensive grading, interactions, etc.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by gumby on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:24PM (#22540483)
I don't think anyone believes online is an acceptable substitute to a traditional MIT education, but it's a lot better than nothing, and better than continuing the in person teaching.

I'm an MIT grad and know the benefits of being on campus. In fact I spent more time in the lab than I did in classes or my dorm and that just isn't possible online.

My son's school (Courant) has sent everyone home too, with online substitute, but like MIT that only really works for undergrads.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:07PM (#22540938)
I would have flunked out of Caltech without constant "troll sessions" with fellow students in the dorm helping each other understand the homework problems.

If I was in that situation today, I'd prefer the semester be outright cancelled and replaced with a summer semester.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mygo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:47PM (#22542142)
Not to mention that many students will lose study time dealing with the move, and may likely end up performing poorer than they would have otherwise.

I hope MIT really does take this stuff on a case by case basis. The student who can relocate and be back on their feet in a day will be at an advantage compared to the student who takes longer to settle from the shuffle.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by jedberg on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @01:07AM (#22543156)
Hopefully everything is graded on a curve to at least minimize the performance effects
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @01:23AM (#22543221)
Grading on a curve is nice, but it defeats the purpose of having a standard.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by willj on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @08:27AM (#22545186)
There’s no such thing as an objective standard. Professors change, course materials change, and as with here, circumstances can be different. That’s why we use a curve.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Thursday March 12, 2020 @12:44AM (#22553858)
Caltech institute policy was no grading on a curve. The standard was to be decided on in advance. If half the students failed an exam (which happened) so be it. If half aced it, so be it as well.

Stack ranking in employee evaluations is unfair, and is the same thing as curve grading.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by jedberg on Thursday March 12, 2020 @01:20AM (#22554018)
Stack rankings and curves aren’t anywhere close to the same.

Grading on a curve allows everyone to get a perfect score. Stack ranking means that if everyone is perfect only one person can get a perfect score.

They are in fact opposites.

Also, if half the class fails, that is a teaching failure, not a student failure. The teacher failed to teach the material and/or failed to write a good test.

At Berkeley, if 1/2 the class failed, the professor usually wasn’t allowed to teach that class anymore.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:08AM (#22554217)
> Stack rankings and curves aren’t anywhere close to the same.

Sure they are. The best get a raise/A, the worst get fired/F.

> that is a teaching failure, not a student failure

Let's put it another way. Do you want the pilot flying you across the Atlantic 747 to be graded on a curve where he happened to be better than some of the other students, or graded against "met the standard / did not meet the standard"?

Me, I want "met the standard" every time for someone I trust with my life. The teacher failing to teach is not a reason to pass a pilot who didn't meet the standard.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by jedberg on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:21AM (#22554553)
> > Stack rankings and curves aren’t anywhere close to the same.

> Sure they are. The best get a raise/A, the worst get fired/F.

That's actually not at all how stack ranking works. The best might get an A, or a B or a C, and the worst might get a B or a C or a D or an F.

An example: You give a test that is out of 120 points. Here are the scores:

P1 = 100

P2 = 99

P3 = 98

P4 = 97

P5 = 96

Under a curve grading, they all get A's. Under objective grading, they all get B's. With stack ranking:

P1 = A

P2 = B

P3 = C

P4 = D

P5 = F

Should P5 be given an F or get fired? That's what happens in stack ranking.

> Let's put it another way. Do you want the pilot flying you across the Atlantic 747 to be graded on a curve where he happened to be better than some of the other students, or graded against "met the standard / did not meet the standard"?

A pilot is not the same as your undergrad physics class. The pilot was taught by instructor who has to teach in a specific way, often using specific words, developed over many years by a committee of pilots. They then take a test that 100s have taken over many years, written by a committee of pilots.

The pilot instructor has very little leeway on how they teach the class and has no leeway in the test.

Same with medical boards, or any other standardized test.

But your physics professor probably wrote the curriculum themselves, teach it a different way every semester, and use a slightly different test every time.

And as much as you wish it were true, none of your undergrad classes are life or death scenarios.

So yeah, it makes sense to grade on a curve for an undergrad class.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:40PM (#22560191)
> Under a curve grading, they all get A's.

I think you misunderstand what curve grading is.

> none of your undergrad classes are life or death scenarios.

Except that bridges fall down and kill people when designed by incompetents. You bet your life every day on the competence of engineers.

Employers are NOT interested in curve ranking. They're interested in a degree as a mark of meeting a standard. Caltech's policy is that their graduates meet a standard of quality. A curve is not a standard. Someone who gets sympathetic good grades because of a bad teacher is not of interest.

If you don't accept that, there are plenty of other schools to attend.

But I suspect that if you think about it, you expect a standard of quality in everything you buy - goods and services. You're not interested in a flexible curve.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by jedberg on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:47PM (#22564540)
> I think you misunderstand what curve grading is.

I think you do. Curve grading is where the top score in the class determines the max score, and everyone is graded accordingly. It's a way of making sure that the test isn't so bad that even the top student can't get a perfect score.

> Except that bridges fall down and kill people when designed by incompetents.

That's true. That's why people who design bridges have to take standardized tests with objecting grading standards designed by groups of experts.

But that has nothing to do with the grading policy of undergrad classes.

> Employers are NOT interested in curve ranking. They're interested in a degree as a mark of meeting a standard.

No, they're interested in a degree as a mark of someone who can finish something that takes four years to complete. I don't care if you went to Caltech or MIT or Cal State Northridge, as long as you can write code.

> But I suspect that if you think about it, you expect a standard of quality in everything you buy

Again true, but I'm not buying people. College graduates are not a product to be bought and sold.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by peter_l_downs on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:51PM (#22542168)
I went to MIT too and with the exception of about three classes, every single in-person class was a waste. The value the school offers is, in order:

- the people you meet - the brand name on your resume - the psets and structured guide to learning hard things

Notice that the last two still work over Zoom. If I were in the hard sciences this might be different but as a professional Software Engineer, the classes were almost entirely irrelevant to me.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by bilbo0s on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:20AM (#22542956)
I disagree.

Maybe your specialty is a different case, but there's no way on Earth that I would have gotten access to the equipment I used without the lab. Doesn't have to be MIT's lab, but someone has to have the ridiculous amounts of money necessary to construct and outfit advanced research labs if a student is to replicate that experience.

And that hypothetical, "someone", would have been unlikely to allow me to use it simply because I taught myself a bit about, say, nanomaterials online.

Let's be frank, if you need a lab, you're screwed.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by ghaff on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @09:43AM (#22545755)
That seems like the most difficult situation. I also assume that there are a lot of people who are/were on track to graduate who need to finish an undergraduate thesis. (I assume those are still required for some majors.) There are only two real choices at this point I would think: Pretend everyone completed the current semester's coursework/projects satisfactorily or require a summer session or some other form of make up time.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by toephu2 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:22AM (#22543804)
> every single in-person class was a waste.

Hundreds of thousands of people have graduated from MIT. I don't think you can categorically say in-person class is a waste for everyone.

As with many things in life, YMMV. Your one anecdotal experience is not going to be the same for everyone.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by gumby on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @10:14AM (#22545999)
I’m sorry you felt that way because for me a huge proportion of the value was the human stuff, not just “networking” which wasn’t even called that back then, but doing pests with others (learning) talking to profs, being exposed via meatspace serendipity to hints I would not otherwise have seen or done, and the like.

I did skip most of the big lecture freshman classes (I was in ESG) which would not have worked for me (my HS graduating class was 39) but apart from them the classes tend to be relatively small.

I’ve never really noticed the value of the brand name but perhaps that’s a sign that it works so well :-(

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by JCharante on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:24PM (#22542684)
Regarding the people you meet, if class resumes normally in the fall then you're only missing 1/2 semester worth of networking.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by j88439h84 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:36PM (#22541213)
> I don't think anyone believes online is an acceptable substitute to a traditional MIT education

I suspect a lot of people believe that

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by an-allen on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:33PM (#22542404)
Would you have paid 50k+ a year for an online education without the interaction you get from being part of the MIT campus a facilities and faculty?
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by JMTQp8lwXL on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:59PM (#22540843)
What about lab work that demands physical access to facilities and equipment? Not everything can be virtualized.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:49PM (#22541339)
I don't know. But if they can solve it, then a true online degree becomes possible, not just in an emergency. That's going to be revolutionary. Twenty years from now, everyone having to move to a physical location to attend a university is going to seem insane... if they can solve it.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by iso947 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:53AM (#22544460)
A key part of moving away from your parents and going to uni is moving away from your parents. You are thrust into a whole new world, and that forces you to challenge your world view.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by raegis on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:50AM (#22543089)
The harder problem is preventing cheating, which is already difficult to do in-person.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by smacktoward on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:26PM (#22540503)
These are good questions, but nobody is going to have good answers, at least not yet. We’re in an unprecedented situation, which means that over the next few weeks just about every institution out there is going to be doing a whole lot of improvising. It sucks, and it’s highly unlikely that everyone who has to make sacrifices will ever be completely made whole. All that can be said is that it beats the alternative.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by samatman on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:29PM (#22540543)
Most of the value of an elite education is signaling: it proves the student had what it takes both to get into MIT, and to graduate.

If MIT switched to an online-only format, that would erode the value of the latter (which, remember, is social proof, not something which is notoriously rational), while open enrollment would obliterate the former.

A semester of remote teaching won't damage the brand.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by an-allen on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:38PM (#22542432)
Categorically disagree with that. The most valuable aspect of an elite engineering education IMO is getting to participate in a culture of elite professional academics. The spirit and energy which you learn to tackle REALLY ABSURDLY HARD problems is the most important thing I learned from my Rice EE education. Being able to find folks who were putting probes on Mars and Titan and being able to work with them to help build algorithms and visualisations to show insights from the data collected from these foreign worlds... that was the most valuable thing about my elite education... Honestly, most people don't even look at the school or even recognise it when I apply for jobs... The experience and participating with really smart people tackling really hard problems remains the most valuable thing for me 15 years after the fact.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by samatman on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:50PM (#22542805)
This is a mistake on my part which I should have seen coming.

I said "value", and that conflated value to oneself with value to and as perceived by others.

Which are definitely not the same thing, and I was referring to the market value of a degree from MIT.

I don't happen to think half a semester of working remote is going to do much to dampen the intrinsic value of an elite education, either. It will mark the cohort as remarkable, having shared the distinctive experience of being Extremely Online together.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:23PM (#22541083)
> Most of the value of an elite education is signaling

Not in my case (Caltech). It was clear when I got an industry job that a BS from Caltech was at about the same level as an MS from other institutions. But if the institution is large enough, one can get an elite education by careful selection of the classes and professors, and doing the maximum in those classes rather than just getting by.

For example, take honors calculus, not weeder calculus. Don't avoid the math heavy classes. Don't waste your time with easy-A classes. If you don't find yourself studying 6 hours a day, you're not getting an elite education.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by theLotusGambit on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:16PM (#22541955)
> If you don't find yourself studying 6 hours a day, you're not getting an elite education.

Seems like an unhealthy attitude to me. I really dislike the perspective that education is at its best when the learning is most difficult. The best teachers are the ones that make things as clear and digestible as possible. Bad teachers are the ones that want to see you sweat.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:09PM (#22542266)
It isn't about wanting to torture students. I never learned so much so fast before or since - and there was a lot to learn. I prefer teachers that expect a lot from their students.

It's not fundamentally different from athletics. If you want to be a good athlete, you're going to have to work your tail off. If you want to be an incredible engineer like Kelly Johnson, that ain't going to happen if you party through school. Nor would you have any chance of working with an engineer like him.

So ask yourself - do you want to design rocket engines? or cup holders?

---

BTW, as for health, I came out of Caltech a far more confident person than when I entered. I knew what I could do, and was happy about it.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by theLotusGambit on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:32PM (#22542724)
It's wrong to treat the brain like any other muscle. It's more comparable to a neural network (pardon the tautology). You feed in data (knowledge) in hope that some of it sticks and forms new connections that you can use to better tackle new and existing problems. There's no rule of the universe that states that the process of feeding data into the brain has to be challenging.

Now, I'm not arguing that hard work has no merit. Clearly, working hard can increase your rate of knowledge-consumption and get you further faster. For some people, you included it seems, that works out great. For others, the ever-present "110% or bust!" attitude can have serious mental consequences. Accepting that education can happen without rigor won't harm those that intend to push themselves anyway, but it sure would benefit the constantly stressed-out students.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:20AM (#22542950)
> There's no rule of the universe that states that the process of feeding data into the brain has to be challenging.

No pain, no gain. You're simply not going to become an expert in any field, mental or physical, without a lot of hard work.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by hak8or on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @09:37AM (#22545688)
> If you don't find yourself studying 6 hours a day, you're not getting an elite education.

This is absolute nonsense and a garbage mentality, akin to gate keeping.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @08:27PM (#22552283)
In my experience 4 years at Caltech, the ones who didn't flunked out.

Of course, there were a couple unicorns (like Hal Finney) who didn't study and aced the tests, but they are as far beyond you and I as we are from a first grader. Me, I tried studying less, and it simply did not work.

I also have a friend who flunked out of Caltech. About 10 years later he asked if he could try again, and they said sure. He got straight As this time. I asked him if he was any smarter - he laughed, and said no, just that the second time he was ready to work.

I'd guess that if you attended an elite institution and got a degree without studying 6 hours a day, you're either a unicorn or a victim of the institution's marketing department.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by akhilcacharya on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:38AM (#22543883)
Yikes, I wonder what you think of people like me that couldnt get an elite education.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @04:49AM (#22544181)
I don't care if someone has an elite education or not. It's about whether they can do the job or not.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by akhilcacharya on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:22AM (#22554281)
After what you just said, color me skeptical. I went to a state school and got an average-ish CS degree with average-ish internships and research, how far behind am I?
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by WalterBright on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:15PM (#22559878)
I don't know you, so I have no idea. Your employer and colleagues could give you a better assessment. But I can say that an average grade taking the top classes at school is much better than average grades in the minimum-to-graduate classes.

Education doesn't stop with the degree. Good engineers never stop studying to expand their expertise.

I've been working for several decades with other engineers. It's not too hard to see who are the good ones and who aren't. The "aren't" are the ones who solve problems using trial and error, and when they get it to work they don't bother figuring out why it's working.

The "are" engineers will do whatever is required to find out what is actually wrong, work to understand it, and will do a targeted fix.

What kind of engineer you want to be is entirely up to you.

One thing you can do is take the youtube MIT CS courses. It's free. I've taken some of them to fill in gaps in my education.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mav3rick on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:50AM (#22554413)
You're already far behind due to your insecurities or Will an internet forum really guide your life ?

An MIT grad will always have more gates open than an NCSU grad. You need to do other things in your career to lessen the gap. There is no moving past this point no matter who you ask. And no the amount of hard work you do doesn't matter. Everyone of the "elite" school students work hard.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by akhilcacharya on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:11AM (#22554513)
> An MIT grad will always have more gates open than an NCSU grad.

In the immortal words of Amy Klobuchar “are you calling me dumb?”

> You need to do other things in your career to lessen the gap.

Such as what exactly?

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mav3rick on Saturday March 14, 2020 @02:00AM (#22573499)
I stated a fact. You implied it meant you were dumb. The average MIT kid may as well be smarter than the average NCSU kid. But there sure may be NCSU kids smarter than some MIT kids. All of this is relevant to a certain degree. You keep on harping over the same points.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mav3rick on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:09PM (#22564377)
If you had admits from MIT and NCSU, both full rides, which one would you choose ? Let's see what cognitive dissonance you concoct now.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by akhilcacharya on Friday March 13, 2020 @06:45AM (#22566234)
That wasn’t my question
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mav3rick on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:33AM (#22573209)
Answer my question too, what would you choose between the two ? Would brand and prestige play a role in your decision ?

All your posts here disparage higher "brands" than what you have.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by akhilcacharya on Monday March 16, 2020 @11:34PM (#22601367)
I’m not disparaging anything. Only you seem to...

That's neither here nor there really. I'd appreciate an answer!

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mav3rick on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @10:42AM (#22605220)
1. I'm not calling you dumb. 2. It's prestige you're after. It's clear from your answers you want some validation from society. There are brands you can chase - BCG for consulting, Google (no Amazon doesn't carry the same weight), Rhodes scholar etc..
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by akhilcacharya on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @01:05PM (#22607147)
If you're saying Amazon doesn't carry the same weight, you seem to be calling me dumb.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mav3rick on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:10AM (#22613818)
No I am just stating a fact. Also if someone perceives another person to be "better" than you, that doesn't make you dumb. There will always be people smarter than us. If you're chasing validation you can keep going and chasing degrees + institutions.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mav3rick on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @10:43AM (#22605239)
And now please answer MIT vs NCSU ? If you reply with NCSU then we're done here. No point even discussing with someone who is lying.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by akhilcacharya on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @01:06PM (#22607156)
I don't see the relevance of this question
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mav3rick on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:45PM (#22612413)
Why can't you answer it ?
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by sokoloff on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @07:23AM (#22544833)
It’s hard to get into MIT. Once in, it’s just not that hard to graduate. It’s a grind and parts are moderately difficult, but I think the hard filter is up-front (and lossy/random). (class of 1993.)
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by drc500free on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:04PM (#22546896)
Yep. The 4-year graduation rate isn't great, but almost everyone gets there eventually. I know plenty of people who just kept plugging away, dropping classes in the 10th week if they were going to fail. One extreme outlier took 17 years.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by viraptor on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:29PM (#22540537)
> If courses being taught online is an acceptable substitute, why have caps on admission at all?

Mit was probably the first offering serious online courses with recognised certification. You can do their micromaster if you want:

https://micromasters.mit.edu/

So it's not like they don't offer the option. They also published opencourseware if you don't need the paper itself.

I'm not saying they don't provide value locally, but they do push for online education themselves and literally provide you resources for free.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by why-el on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @05:54PM (#22540174)
> If courses being taught online is an acceptable substitute, why have caps on admission at all?

Most assignments are not scored in an automated manner, and the number of staff is not unlimited.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by logfromblammo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @05:59PM (#22540234)
Given the usual university budget and the going rate for overqualified, part-time, and temporary adjuncts, the staff is less limited than one might think.

Remote students and remote adjuncts--what do you need administrators for? Ah, yes, to collect the tuition, attend the luncheons, and issue the credentials.

It would at least put a small dent in the oversupply of Ph.D. holders in some fields.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by agustif on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @06:56AM (#22544708)
Well if MIT/Stanford/Harvard are what they are because of the elitism of getting to study there, and the branding-power it brings to one's resume, it kinda seems obvious they will have 0 interest in have an unlimited supply of students/graduates, which surely would diminish/affect the branding power on a resume of any of those universities programs, if literally a lots of new graduates could be graduating from those schools.

Elitism works in a limited setting, probably not in an limited/open setting...

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by logfromblammo on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @11:04AM (#22546399)
My point is that there is no supply-scarcity limit on university teaching positions. But you are correct that each university has a monopoly on their own brand, so they can restrict supply and raise prices up to the monopolistic competition limit (as the other universities are close substitutes). For the select few universities whose degrees are a Veblen good, the more they charge for their degrees and faculty positions (not just in tuition, but in time, application qualifications, and influence), the more they return in upper-class prestige (not just faculty pay and graduate earnings). You can't project that you only take the top 0.1%, if you admit 0.2% of all high-school graduates.

That prestige problem is especially dire with medical colleges in the US. The patient community (aka everybody) desires more numerous, cheaper, and better-distributed physicians, but the physician community desires higher-paying positions that are more costly to fill, with a remuneration premium for working in less desirable territories. So only some hospitals are teaching hospitals, and their residency programs have limited slots. (I think the Army/VA system could possibly break that cartel, by ordering qualified recruits that sign up for a longer term of service to become physicians, and routing their medical training outside of the civilian system. It would certainly drop ER visit prices when those stabilization specialists and trauma surgeons get their 20 and start to "retire" out to civilian jobs.)

If universities are going to order students and faculty to leave campus, they are removing a huge piece of their competitive advantage over universities that already have mature distance-learning programs, but with lower tuition. If MIT takes its campus off the table, the thing they have left is their brand name. That's enough to sustain them, specifically, but there aren't many other universities that could get away with it. The one just up Massachusetts Avenue, maybe, and a handful of others. And they still have to pay for grounds and facilities upkeep, even if they aren't using them as much.

Any other distance learning program could probably hire 1 remote adjunct for every 10-15 remote students and outdo "two sections of lecture hall plus office hours" tenured professors that have a 1:300 ratio. They can use some of the savings for cheap test proctors at distributed--and possibly also shared--evaluation sites. If every surplus Ph.D. can get a part-time remote teaching-support gig for 20 hours a week at $25/hour, they can still keep working the jobs they already have, that don't require their advanced degrees, because their graduate universities did not restrict Ph.D. output to just what the industry could bear.

A degree from MIT might open more interview doors, but there is less difference in switching between schools like Rose-Hulman and Georgia Tech. If campus location is no longer a factor, any student could study at any school. Schools that want to survive under such competition would have to bring down costs, fast.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by nightfly on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @05:54PM (#22540178)
At other schools the online offerings for courses can be more expensive than the in-person offerings.

Online doesn't mean that you have unlimited capacity for students. You still need to grade homework and exams, offer virtual "office hours", answer emails.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by mumblemumble on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:06PM (#22540312)
> At other schools the online offerings for courses can be more expensive than the in-person offerings.

The school where I earned my master's degree had two programs, one online and one in-person. There were several differences, but the most salient one was that the in-person program conferred an academic degree while the online one conferred a professional degree, and the online one had significantly higher tuition.

The fact that many state universities have policies limiting how rapidly academic degree programs' tuition can increase, but not the professional ones, is, I assume, just a coincidence.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by enitihas on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @05:56PM (#22540206)
> You still need to grade homework and exams, offer virtual "office hours", answer emails.

But all of the above can be done by TAs, and do not need a professor. Professor time is much more limited.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by BelleOfTheBall on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:00PM (#22540255)
That still takes 'manpower', which is limited, and there's likely some stipulations that require the professors to actually do one-on-one time with students, not just always delegate to TAs.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by enitihas on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:01PM (#22540264)
Yup, but it should free up professor time by a large amount. Manpower is still limited, but far more manpower is available compared to before.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by petschge on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:14PM (#22540387)
I am at a (small) academic meeting right now and all of the professors in attendance fear how much extra effort this move to online-only classes will be and how it is going to cut into their research time.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by enitihas on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:19PM (#22540435)
Why should there be extra effort for online classes?

My university had a course where an external professor would deliver a mixed online/offline course. Videos were available on institute website. Professor would hold a class every week to go through that week's contents and clarify student doubts.

This saved a ton of effort on the professor's part.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by petschge on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:29PM (#22540545)
Because nothing is set up for it yet.

There is a reserved scheduled class room for the class, but there is no organized zoom meeting yet (or maybe not use zoom after all?).

There is a mail box to drop of home work assignments, but nobody has figured out where students should email things for grading (the prof, the TA or a function account?).

The prof has a set of notes that (s)he writes onto the white board, but not a set of slides to be emailed out. Or might have electronic slides, but they contain annotation that should not be sent out to students.

Everybody has to figure out how to make sure that 200 students can join the zoom session, but have their mic muted. And know how to unmute when they want to ask a question.

Exams for the mid terms might be printed but now need to be (e)mailed. And how do you prevent cheating in an exam that was meant to be taken under supervision with pen(cil) and paper only. Of course you can create an open-book exam where google doesn't help, but that is extra effort. And does not prevent collusion between students.

Somebody need to figure out how to replace lab courses.

And the list goes on. All of that can be fixed. And after a couple of semesters an online class might be no more (or possibly even less, but that is not proven) work than the current offline course. But switching in the middle of a semester with ideally no downtime IS a lot of extra effort.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by ghaff on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @09:14AM (#22545527)
The lab courses and to a somewhat lesser degree seminar-type classes are the really tough question. A course like 2.007 [1] which is one of the best known and most useful classes in the Mech Eng curriculum can't be replicated online to any meaningful degree--especially with zero notice and planning.

I'm honestly not sure what you do at this point. Finish up the semester as best you can and just give everyone a Pass? Force people to attend a summer session whether or not they can afford to not be working? There aren't any good options.

[1] https://me-2007.mit.edu/

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by enitihas on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:42PM (#22540660)
Thanks for your detailed reply. This really puts things into perspective.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by lgessler on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:29PM (#22540535)
For one thing, profs often teach some classes repeatedly, which means they dont have to put substantial effort into planning for subsequent offerings. If the planned content is somehow unsuitable for a different medium of delivery, this would take some planning that they weren't expecting at the beginning of the semester.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by colechristensen on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @05:59PM (#22540239)
A university education is not a SaaS product.

We are getting to the point where lectures should be mandated to be recorded and put into the public domain, and the University's value proposition in admission, tuition, and residence should be the everything else involved which could raise the focus away from re-doing the same lectures over and over.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by Jtsummers on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:14PM (#22540394)
There's a lot of value in running through the lecture live with a new class. Different students, different needs.

If my undergrad CS Theory prof had used recorded lectures, it would've been great for 5 of us, and terrible for the other 30 or so. There were sections that they just did not get and needed repetition or clarifying examples. What's more, the students often don't know what they aren't understanding (sometimes they do, but often not). So they don't know how to ask for clarification because they don't know what needs clarification.

Waiting for test, quizzes, or homeworks is often too late. What worked out well for my classmates was the help of the professor and a couple of us who got the material faster. The three of us could observe the class and identify what material (by non-verbal reaction or by questions) needed to be delved into more. Try doing that with a set of recorded lectures.

In the end, perhaps you have a sufficiently complete set of recorded lectures that cover everything. But you still have the challenge of identifying what students need help with and helping them immediately, instead of failing a large portion of a class and hoping you do better the next time.

I mean, this is literally the waterfall vs agile debate. Classrooms are agile and responsive to student needs, recorded lectures are not.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by JabavuAdams on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:50PM (#22541794)
It's a lot easier for students to understand lectures that they would not in-person, when they can pause or rewind video. A lot of misunderstandings are due to lapses in attention. This needs to be considered in any model of relative-effectiveness.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by sarbaz on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:32PM (#22540576)
This sounds pretty silly. There's bound to be a way to make online (or semi-online) learning agile too. Distance learning is basically a solved problem and has been done for hundreds of years.

How about recorded lectures and in-person small group recitations? Or longer office hours? Obviously you have to change the methodology of learning a bit, but I'm sure it can be figured out.

In any case undergrad level science lectures are basically a one-sided info dump where the lecturer is lucky to get so much as an ACK that someone is listening.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by jcranmer on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:55PM (#22540797)
How do you handle things like chemistry labs? Vocational training and art curricula are also going to be very difficult to do remotely, since you're probably not going to have requisite materials at home.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by tropo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:38PM (#22542091)
Let's just go all the way: at MIT, the Nuclear Engineering students get to operate a real nuclear reactor.

Put it on the internet?

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by cultofmetatron on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @10:08AM (#22545952)
labs are not lectures. If anything, moving the lectures online frees up the lecturer to devote more of their resources towards labs.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by petschge on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:56PM (#22540815)
Completely solved problem? What about lab courses?
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by anticensor on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:27AM (#22543827)
> lectures should be mandated to be recorded and put into the public domain

Some minor student issues that can be tolerated when lecture is not recorded, will be completely unsuitable in recording.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by rifung on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:11PM (#22540363)
> We are getting to the point where lectures should be mandated to be recorded and put into the public domain

Does that really make sense? I thought MIT was a private institution. The research is often publicly funded but I don't believe that's the case for the tuition.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by whymauri on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:01PM (#22540266)
I've been told there are currently meetings to discuss the process for partially reimbursing room and board.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by titzer on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:54AM (#22543699)
I am teaching a University course right now. Online is absolutely not a substitute for butts-in-seats, work on the blackboard, live questions, etc, type of style that an actual classroom affords. IMHO it is less work for everyone overall, because being in person and taking notes makes students focus and remember better. I think the outcomes are better.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by nostrademons on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:41PM (#22540656)
> If there is no refund being offered for the content shifting online from in-person, why have in-person at all?

There isn't really a good reason other than some people being more disciplined when there's a human instructor that they see face to face every couple days. Plenty of people self-teach from MOOCs, MIT OCW, or just buying the textbooks and working through the exercises and get just as good an education.

When you go to an elite college, you're really paying for the degree. This is also why there are caps on admission: it creates scarcity value for graduates from that university. When there are fewer graduates with a credential, companies that want to employ them have to compete for a limited number of human resources, which drives up wages. Additionally, the university can impose selection bias on matriculating freshmen who will eventually receive the credential, which helps maintain the reputation of the university's graduates.

If you don't maintain the selectivity of the institution, you end up with what's happening in the mid-tier for-profit colleges, where students take out massive loans for a degree but then it doesn't really improve their employment prospects much. If everybody has a college degree, its financial value is basically 0.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by simonw on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:58PM (#22540833)
"Plenty of people self-teach from MOOCs".

Are there studies (not from the MOOC providers themselves) that demonstrate that this works?

I got the impression that the MOOC thing wasn't working out as well as expected. The hype around them certainly seems to have cooled off since their peak a few years ago.

My hunch is that it's only a small subset of people that thrive with MOOCs.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by ghaff on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:03PM (#22540891)
Outside (mostly) of CS, there is a lot of engineering/science coursework that requires access to labs and other physical plant that can't be replicated online. Even in the humanities, I'm not sure the degree to which you can replicate in-person seminars with videoconferences.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by tkgally on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:20PM (#22541975)
I teach graduate and undergraduate courses in the humanities at a university in Japan. We don't know yet what will happen with our new school year, which begins in April, but some of the faculty have already started to experiment with online tools to see what might be feasible.

Each semester I teach a graduate seminar that typically has about a dozen students, all sitting around one table in a cramped room. The format is ideal for discussions, as we can all see and hear each other and read each other's expressions and gestures in real time. (Needless to say, the format also seems ideal for spreading coronavirus infections.)

If I had to, I could teach the seminar using Google Meet or a similar service, though it would be difficult to replicate the spontaneous interaction of the in-person discussions. However, there might be advantages to online discussions, such as allowing people more time to compose their thoughts before speaking or writing. I won't know until we try.

My bigger concern is with two freshman courses that I am scheduled to teach starting in April. While graduate students are already socialized to university life, first-year undergraduates are being exposed to it for the first time. I worry how well newly admitted students would be able to adjust to the university if they are still sitting at home by themselves in front of their computers. (Most students at our university live at home or in their own apartments, not in dormitories, so the housing issue is not so serious.)

Other commenters here have noted the difficulty of moving lab classes online. To those I would add foreign-language classes that emphasize spoken interaction and practicums in subjects like nursing, medicine, physical education, etc.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by thulecitizen on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:49PM (#22540730)
To me what you write are great arguments for tuition free universities, like the ones in Sweden. It makes society much more equitable and egalitarian. This whole artificial scarcity thing is such a lose-lose for everyone in society.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by nostrademons on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:09PM (#22540956)
To me it highlights one of the big failings of markets, which is that a tool/credential/innovation only has economic value if it's used by some but not all producers in the market. Once it becomes universally adopted it becomes an opportunity for rent-seeking by the producer of that tool/credential/innovation.

In some ways this is the great strength of capitalism, because it provides an incentive to adopt innovations that helps overcome the status-quo bias that most humans have. But it also encourages firms to restrict access to their suppliers and tear their competitors down rather than building everybody up.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by thulecitizen on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:01PM (#22541437)
Agreed.

Have you read any Guy Standing?

“ …today, a tiny minority of people and corporate interests across the world are accumulating vast wealth and power from rental income, not only from housing and land but from a range of other assets, natural and created. ‘Rentiers’ of all kinds are in unparalleled ascendancy and the neo-liberal state is only too keen to oblige their greed.

Rentiers derive income from ownership, possession or control of assets that are scarce or artificially made scarce. Most familiar is rental income from land, property, mineral exploitation or financial investments, but other sources have grown too. They include the income lenders gain from debt interest; income from ownership of ‘intellectual property’ (such as patents, copyright, brands and trademarks); capital gains on investments; ‘above normal’ company profits (when a firm has a dominant market position that allows it to charge high prices or dictate terms); income from government subsidies; and income of financial and other intermediaries derived from third-party transactions.”

What are some of your go to authors, areas of interest? Or in other words, who are you grateful for, for their influence on you?

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by an-allen on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:37PM (#22542752)
This is perhaps one of the more ignorant comments on this thread.

> When you go to an elite college, you're really paying for the degree.

In many cases, you go to an elite college to pay for the experience to learn from, engage with, and collaborate with the world's best scientists, thinkers, engineers, and professors. In some cases, like Rice, if your parents make less than 130,000 a year - you don't pay a dime. Undergraduate tuition is pennies to these institutions whose endowments are orders of magnitudes larger than the revenue from tuition. I look at it like this... My degree cost quite a bit a year... in exchange for that I got to study, learn, work in labs with scientists doing things that without me paying the entry fee.. I would have never been able to do. It's not like you can just walk up to a group of NASA researchers and IEEE fellows and say... hey can you send me GBs of data from the Huygens probe and provide me hundreds of thousands of dollars of computing power to play around with that data? Will you let me use your multi million dollar clean room to learn about lithography? Will you let me use that nanotube growing lab to learn about growing carbon nanotubes? If you are just paying for the degree you are doing yourself an offensive disservice.. and I would suspect one day you will look back and realise what a waste you made of the opportunity.

> This is also why there are caps on admission: it creates scarcity value for graduates from that university. When there are fewer graduates with a credential, companies that want to employ them have to compete for a limited number of human resources, which drives up wages. Additionally, the university can impose selection bias on matriculating freshmen who will eventually receive the credential, which helps maintain the reputation of the university's graduates.

There are caps on admissions for a wide variety of reasons - but largely because the faculty of the individual schools within these Universities are working to create a culture and a learning and discovery environment.. these goals are threatened when you have too many students to support while at the same time supporting the research that actually makes the university a worthwhile place to study.

> If you don't maintain the selectivity of the institution, you end up with what's happening in the mid-tier for-profit colleges, where students take out massive loans for a degree but then it doesn't really improve their employment prospects much. If everybody has a college degree, its financial value is basically 0.

I'm going to argue that what is happening at the mid-tier for-profit colleges is that they are actually not providing their students with a quality education or network that improves their employment prospects.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by nostrademons on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:48PM (#22542798)
I have a degree from an elite college (Amherst, #1 liberal arts college in the country at the time I went). I took a gap year before and worked as a professional software engineer, where I learned a massive amount. Then I spent 3.5 years taking a variety of interesting courses that have been utterly irrelevant to my future career prospects, before flunking out of my physics major, switching to CS, and completing that major in a semester using the knowledge I learned while working as a professional software engineer.

You're paying for the degree. If you want to take interesting courses, learn cool stuff, socialize with intelligent students, and meet Nobel-prize-winning professors, most professors will let you audit their course even if you're not a student at the university, particularly if you seem genuinely interested in the material. (Hell, I'd taken half a dozen college courses as a high-school student before I even got to college.) It just won't count toward the degree, because the colleges know that their business model is selling a limited credential that the rest of the world values very highly.

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by an-allen on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:16AM (#22542935)
Honestly, I paid for access to labs and researchers and the network after graduating.

I dunno about Amherst but Rice students and alumni also have insane access to the worlds coolest toys - https://sea.rice.edu/instruments/all

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by neets on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @05:55PM (#22540192)
Aren't undergraduate ivy league programs more about signaling status than actually becoming educated?
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by narak on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @05:59PM (#22540238)
MIT isn't ivy league and probably the least 'about signaling' school in the US...
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by csallen on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:08PM (#22540336)
Yes and no. It's been 10 years since I graduated, but I doubt much has changed. The curriculum is rigorous, the students are smart, and people are serious about learning. But nevertheless, going to MIT does signal something much stronger than the vast majority of other schools, and MIT students are highly aware of that, as is the institution itself.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by kelnos on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @04:08AM (#22544022)
MIT may not signal the same thing that an Ivy does, but it certainly signals something, and the faculty, staff, students, and graduates are certainly aware of and use that.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by downerending on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @01:02PM (#22547447)
Pretty sure my school you never heard of has MIT beat on that one.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by TylerE on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:51PM (#22540747)
cough Media Lab.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by ericd on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:20PM (#22540443)
The signalling is definitely a thing, but the bigger thing is just getting together with lots of smart people and working together to learn this stuff.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by toss1 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:37PM (#22540620)
NO

Perhaps for some, but everyone I knew while I was an Ivy undergrad was doing their level best to take advantage of the benefits of that amazing environment of smart, educated people, both the profs, the visiting speakers, and the other students. Since then, it has been what I've learned, not what signaling I could do that has helped me most (tho I'm not the most social person, so YMV).

One thing I really learned there (among other places), is that it really pays to learn from the best -- you have to go through a learning process, and best to learn it once going directly to the top level, vs. a watered-down version and then re-learning. (of course, you can't instantly jump to the top level, but just getting the clues form those who work at the top levels as you work your way up the curve is a huge benefit).

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by an-allen on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:49PM (#22542490)
This comment. All this nonsense about elite universities being just about the degree and signalling is absolute rubbish. Elite universities are elite because they are made of some of the most influential thinkers, scientists, engineers, and professors in the world. Getting to participate in problem solving with these people is what makes these educations valuable in my opinion. I learned more from watching my professors tackle hard problems and reason themselves through them than I did from the actual material they were attempting to tackle. There is something to be said about the techniques and culture of the worlds best academics.
Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by toss1 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:20PM (#22547029)
Exactly

Yet my above comment, a factual 1st-person account -- nothing more, nothing less -- earns multiple downvotes with no dispute/discussion.

Evidently, anti-intellectualism and 'anti-establishment' virtue-signalling is dominant even here on HN... Sad to see. (yup, let the downvotes begin --- sheesh)

Re:MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester by droithomme on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:27PM (#22540512)
> If there is no refund being offered for the content shifting online from in-person, why have in-person at all?

Most MIT undergrads pay no tuition, even though tuition is something like $70,000 a year there. They have a massive endowment and are thus on average one of the lowest cost colleges in the US, though not as low cost as Princeton. What refunds could they give?

> Is room and board going to be refunded?

Undoubtedly.

> If courses being taught online is an acceptable substitute, why have caps on admission at all?

Most of MIT's undergraduate course work is on line and free for anyone to take. Many take advantage of that. They also have a Masters program, the first year of which anyone who wants to can take it for free. Those who do well are admitted to the second year.

MIT's way ahead of other universities on online education and does extremely well with it. The main "problem" is that MIT is in the top two engineering schools in the world, their classes are extremely rigorous and it simply is not for everyone. 99% of the world population, to be blunt, are not intelligent enough to do well there. And MIT has no intention of dumbing it down to be more "fair and equal" in accordance with the democratic ideal of minimal expectations.

But yes, there are effectively no caps on admission if you want to take online classes there. You won't get an MIT diploma, but you will learn the material and what you do with it is up to you.