I hope MIT really does take this stuff on a case by case basis. The student who can relocate and be back on their feet in a day will be at an advantage compared to the student who takes longer to settle from the shuffle.
Stack ranking in employee evaluations is unfair, and is the same thing as curve grading.
Grading on a curve allows everyone to get a perfect score. Stack ranking means that if everyone is perfect only one person can get a perfect score.
They are in fact opposites.
Also, if half the class fails, that is a teaching failure, not a student failure. The teacher failed to teach the material and/or failed to write a good test.
At Berkeley, if 1/2 the class failed, the professor usually wasn’t allowed to teach that class anymore.
Sure they are. The best get a raise/A, the worst get fired/F.
> that is a teaching failure, not a student failure
Let's put it another way. Do you want the pilot flying you across the Atlantic 747 to be graded on a curve where he happened to be better than some of the other students, or graded against "met the standard / did not meet the standard"?
Me, I want "met the standard" every time for someone I trust with my life. The teacher failing to teach is not a reason to pass a pilot who didn't meet the standard.
> Sure they are. The best get a raise/A, the worst get fired/F.
That's actually not at all how stack ranking works. The best might get an A, or a B or a C, and the worst might get a B or a C or a D or an F.
An example: You give a test that is out of 120 points. Here are the scores:
P1 = 100
P2 = 99
P3 = 98
P4 = 97
P5 = 96
Under a curve grading, they all get A's. Under objective grading, they all get B's. With stack ranking:
P1 = A
P2 = B
P3 = C
P4 = D
P5 = F
Should P5 be given an F or get fired? That's what happens in stack ranking.
> Let's put it another way. Do you want the pilot flying you across the Atlantic 747 to be graded on a curve where he happened to be better than some of the other students, or graded against "met the standard / did not meet the standard"?
A pilot is not the same as your undergrad physics class. The pilot was taught by instructor who has to teach in a specific way, often using specific words, developed over many years by a committee of pilots. They then take a test that 100s have taken over many years, written by a committee of pilots.
The pilot instructor has very little leeway on how they teach the class and has no leeway in the test.
Same with medical boards, or any other standardized test.
But your physics professor probably wrote the curriculum themselves, teach it a different way every semester, and use a slightly different test every time.
And as much as you wish it were true, none of your undergrad classes are life or death scenarios.
So yeah, it makes sense to grade on a curve for an undergrad class.
I think you misunderstand what curve grading is.
> none of your undergrad classes are life or death scenarios.
Except that bridges fall down and kill people when designed by incompetents. You bet your life every day on the competence of engineers.
Employers are NOT interested in curve ranking. They're interested in a degree as a mark of meeting a standard. Caltech's policy is that their graduates meet a standard of quality. A curve is not a standard. Someone who gets sympathetic good grades because of a bad teacher is not of interest.
If you don't accept that, there are plenty of other schools to attend.
But I suspect that if you think about it, you expect a standard of quality in everything you buy - goods and services. You're not interested in a flexible curve.
I think you do. Curve grading is where the top score in the class determines the max score, and everyone is graded accordingly. It's a way of making sure that the test isn't so bad that even the top student can't get a perfect score.
> Except that bridges fall down and kill people when designed by incompetents.
That's true. That's why people who design bridges have to take standardized tests with objecting grading standards designed by groups of experts.
But that has nothing to do with the grading policy of undergrad classes.
> Employers are NOT interested in curve ranking. They're interested in a degree as a mark of meeting a standard.
No, they're interested in a degree as a mark of someone who can finish something that takes four years to complete. I don't care if you went to Caltech or MIT or Cal State Northridge, as long as you can write code.
> But I suspect that if you think about it, you expect a standard of quality in everything you buy
Again true, but I'm not buying people. College graduates are not a product to be bought and sold.
If I was in that situation today, I'd prefer the semester be outright cancelled and replaced with a summer semester.