News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ttul on Monday March 09, 2020 @03:38PM (#22528923)
I notice that there are many commenters here offering opinions on the future price of equities. Note that nobody has any idea where equity prices will be in one day, never mind one year or ten years' time. As a retail investor (i.e. not extremely rich), you can't gain any advantage over the market that overcomes your transaction costs.

So relax. There's nothing to do here. If you're contributing to a retirement fund, keep buying. As the market falls, you're getting a discount. If you need to retire in the next five years, you should already have started moving out of equities. It's too late to change that now.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Reedx on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:57PM (#22530302)
To help adopt a sober approach, it's worth watching this interview with Warren Buffett who shares his thinking re: market and Coronavirus.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JvEas_zZ4fM&t=21s

One of the points he makes is that you should think about stocks as businesses. Instead of "I bought a stock" think "I bought a business". That puts you in a better frame of mind and perspective for the long term. i.e., You don't buy or sell a farm based on today's headlines.

The real question is whether things have changed on a 5, 10 or 20 year time frame for the businesses you hold.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by sameerds on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @01:01AM (#22532870)
From a retail investor's point of view, both approaches are wrong. The retail investor can neither "play" the game of stocks, nor understand what it means to buy a business. Not because there is anything magical about either, but because the retail investor has a life too, and would rather focus on their own work for their actual income.

The correct way to look at stock investment is to say "I bought a stake in the future of the world's industry". And that makes you realize what a mind-bogglingly large gamble this is with your savings. People simply have faith that human life will keep improving over the long term, and hence the value of the world's industry will also keep going up irrespective of short term rises and falls.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by virgilp on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @04:03AM (#22533604)
> that makes you realize what a mind-bogglingly large gamble this is with your savings.

Is it a gamble, really? I can't fathom what I could do with my money, should the world economy go to the gutter, big time. Holding cash surely won't help - cash can become worthless, did so many times in the past. Hard assets might help, but it's very tough to know which ones (cans of food maybe, but really? How much can you "invest" in it? And it's really just investing in the apocalypse... you're making a very shitty scenario slightly less shitty for yourself, _maybe_).

The thing is, all we can really do is hope that the future of the world's economy is good; if it isn't, there's really no rock-solid way to isolate yourself from the bad outcomes. Regardless how much you own now.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by NateEag on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:05AM (#22534696)
I'd argue that investing in skills and training is the best preparation for apocalypse scenarios.

I have a younger sister in medical school, and as I say to her about the debt she's taken on for the degree, "Even if there's a nuclear war and the economy and technology evaporate, people will want to keep you alive for your knowledge. They might break your ankles and chain you up to keep access to your knowledge and skills, but you'll be fed even when almost no one else is."

Not that preparing for an apocalypse is necessarily a great use of time - just saying that skills are a better asset for it than physical goods and resources.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by coliveira on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:36PM (#22531130)
Two things make Warren different: (1) he is a professional money manager, which means that he is investing other peoples money. (2) because of (1), he never needed the money he is investing. It is much easier to have long time frames when you're investing money that is not yours.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by njarboe on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:26PM (#22531852)
Warren Buffet still owns 6% of Berkshire Hathaway. Maybe a more correct statement would be "If you have money you don't immediately need to spend, it is much easier to have a long time frame for investing". Hopefully the money in people's retirement accounts is this type of money.

Most money managers have extremely short time frame investment horizons and are just looking to get their 2 and 20.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by xiphias2 on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:02PM (#22531320)
Actually the thinking still holds: it’s better to have some cash besides your business if you would really need it that soon, or be prepared to take out money from your business when it’s cash strapped (I’m doing the 2nd actually, but I’m OK with it, and am prepared for it emotionally).
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by karaterobot on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @12:53AM (#22532837)
Even if that were true, he's still completely right, and this advice is still good! What really makes him different is that he consistently follows the common sense advice the rest of us nod along with and then ignore.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ganeshkrishnan on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:10PM (#22530941)
This makes sense if you have huge quantity of cash where leverage is not an issue. With limited cash, you have to think very different from Warren.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by arsome on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:24PM (#22531044)
That may make sense if you're thinking about short term cash, but for longer term investments it still holds up.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by chenster on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:12PM (#22530960)
I don't disagree. If you are in it for the long term, there's really nothing to worry about. The market eventually will bounce back. It always does.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by AgentOrange1234 on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:33PM (#22531103)
Well, so far...
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by scottlegrand2 on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:44PM (#22531200)
And if it doesn't hopefully you stocked up on toilet paper and purell to trade in the new hellscape economy...
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by RhodesianHunter on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:13PM (#22532144)
The market not bouncing back doesn't necessarily imply Armageddon. Just look at the Nikkei.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by throwaway743 on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:33PM (#22531912)
Banking on bottlecaps
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by infinite8s on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:48PM (#22531997)
And ammo and soap.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by chenster on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @06:04PM (#22621752)
Toilet paper!
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by anm89 on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:01PM (#22531700)
>Note that nobody has any idea where equity prices will be in one day, never mind one year or ten years' time

This is more or less true.

> As a retail investor (i.e. not extremely rich), you can't gain any advantage over the market that overcomes your transaction costs.

This is patently absurd. It's an easily falsifiable statement which is a rare feat in economics. On average, the the average retail investor will not beat the market. That does not mean they can't. All you need to have is literally any correct thesis and the ability to execute on it and you will have an advantage over "the market". I'm not trivializing this, it's not an easy feat, but markets are absolutely full of inefficiencies, and it's obviously not impossible to do better than the average case. This is a complete misunderstanding of the efficient markets hypothesis.

BTW, I'm not recommending that anyone try to time markets.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ttul on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:08AM (#22535538)
I’d like to offer a source to back up my statement about transaction costs: A Random Walk Down Wall Street.

It’s true that even a retail investor can research and implement a strategy that beats the market average. However, their transaction cost - which includes the cost of their time doing research - will, over a large number of tries, eat up this advantage.

Said another way: could _anyone_ reliably beat the market by enough to pay off the costs they expended coming up with their unique winning strategy? Not just you - I am sure you are very smart - but any typical retail investor.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by thebean11 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @01:01PM (#22537194)
I could randomly select any task and then randomly select a typical retail investor and they'd be unlikely to accomplish it. That doesn't mean nobody should attempt it.

Not that I'm advocating trying to time the market, but I don't buy the "the average person can't do it so you shouldn't try" argument.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by darkerside on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:03PM (#22532080)
Half of people do better than average...
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by smnrchrds on Monday March 09, 2020 @11:31PM (#22532520)
But not consistently.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by geomark on Monday March 09, 2020 @11:03PM (#22532392)
Average as in mean? I think you might have meant median.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by hoten on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:48PM (#22531995)
What does it mean for a market to have inefficiencies?
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by coolspot on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:11PM (#22532133)
Seriousness of wuhan virus was known since end of January, but stock market ignored it completely, raging into all-time highs till February 20th.

Regular person could absolutely see it and be prepared. Even today market still doesn’t price in Italy-style or China-style lockdowns.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by austhrow743 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:34AM (#22534302)
Wuhan virus mostly affects the elderly who are largely out of the workforce. It's not the virus that's disrupting markets it's the response, which no, regular people could not see coming. Even experts are commenting on how well China did to respond in such a drastic fashion. Plenty of countries still haven't done anything large scale to address it.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by zeroonetwothree on Monday March 09, 2020 @11:07PM (#22532409)
This is called hindsight bias
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by anm89 on Monday March 09, 2020 @11:43PM (#22532557)
Claiming this after the fact could represent hindsight bias.

It does not change the fact that the market had an inefficiency in pricing this information into many assets two weeks ago.

If someone bought or sold assets based on a strategy based on this belief (and certainly at least some people did), then they exploited that perceived inefficiency correctly without hindsight.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by anm89 on Monday March 09, 2020 @11:38PM (#22532542)
In this usage it's more like saying that information was "inefficiently" or not fully priced or not fully accurately priced. I'm not arguing that the market mechanism is inefficient, but that the market convenes on prices which in the short term fail to account for some underlying reality.

In an ideal world, markets should be perfectly efficient (near immediate) at exposing things which are misvalued because people can make money if they understand some fact that the market doesn't and then that fact will be accounted for.

In reality they just converge on the average of beliefs weighted by how confident a given actor is for a given belief and how much money they have to put behind the belief, and people are extremely imperfect, especially when it comes to predicting the outcomes of complex systems. Given this, there exist all sorts off "inefficiencies", or times when the current state of the market fails to accurately account for some underlying reality which leaves an exploitable opportunity to buy or sell a mispriced asset.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Phillipharryt on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @12:26AM (#22532717)
There are actions that stop people behaving in a way they would in a perfect market. Laws prohibiting certain sales, taxes affecting companies and investors, imperfect information disclosure, are a few of the big ones.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by bytematic on Monday March 09, 2020 @03:52PM (#22529072)
Most people don't seem to understand that you don't pull all your retirement out at once, so the market going up or down doesn't really affect that
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by dntbnmpls on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:20PM (#22531026)
The problem is that nothing says markets will go up forever. Take japan's nikkei index. Dropped in the early 90s and is still down 50% 30 years later.

Choose the "all" to see the entire chart.

https://tradingeconomics.com/japan/stock-market

It isn't a law of nature that the S&P or Dow has to regain its losses in X number of years. S&P can drop and stay down for decades which can absolutely affect retirees.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by btrettel on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:34PM (#22531511)
I took a graduate level measure-theoretic probability theory class. The professor had this rant about how "buy low, sell high" was a bad idea, it's all about how long you stay in the market. He had a mathematical proof that, if I recall correctly, only held if the random process is monotonically increasing in expectation, which of course is not guaranteed.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by mmhsieh on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:10PM (#22531757)
trading, frictional costs, and the asymmetric psychology of selling winners and riding losers are a better explanation for why buy low, sell high is a bad heuristic to aspire to.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by semi-extrinsic on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:08PM (#22531367)
This is a key point. Especially if we actually start doing something about CO2 emissions, which will mean reducing energy consumption for the next couple of decades. Stock market growth has historically been tightly linked with energy consumption growth.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by xvilka on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:59PM (#22531680)
While the point of probability of staying low holds, I don't think there is a tight coupling with the energy consumption. Surely, nature (business ecosystem) will find a way for growth driver even without energy density increase.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by 205guy on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:32PM (#22531904)
I think nature's growth will be like 1% or less, certainly not the stock market growth people are used to. To me, it is obvious there is a tight coupling: energy does work instead of humans/animals, thus allowing more productivity. When you look at a construction site it's just human directed diesel-energy (with some chemical energy in the concrete).

Much of the developed world is transitioning to a service economy that relies less on the fossil fuels, but it still relies on the inputs that do (agriculture, electronics, offshore manufacturing). And we've set up the economy around fuel consumption: long commutes from suburbia, inefficient houses, processed and packaged foods, etc. And what about the travel industry: burning fossil fuels for no productivity (just realized it acts as a mop for the excess capital).

If we're lucky, we can use the fossil energy to bootstrap the renewable energy, then we can eat farmed foods, drive electric cars, and work on computers remotely. But there just won't be the energy to drive the economy the way cheap energy does.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by mmhsieh on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:09PM (#22531748)
+1. it took about 3.5 decades to return to the levels of the pre-'29 crash. bear markets can indeed drag for decades. stockbroker happy-talk tends to gloss over these facts.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by verbify on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:30PM (#22531884)
If you had reinvested your dividends, you'd have gotten your money back by the end of the war (and you'd only have lost 1 or 2% approximately six years later).

35 years later you would have an annual return (inflation adjusted) of 6% (6.5 times as much as you put in).

And this is somebody who invested in the absolute peak of the market in 1929, and then saw the worst crash in history, followed by the worst war in history.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by panarky on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @12:06AM (#22532640)
Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

Markets can grind lower and lower for decades, each new low triggering bargain hunters to buy, only to drop more.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by verbify on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:32AM (#22534295)
Sure, but that can happen if:

1) Shares were massively overvalued compared to their yields. E.g. if P/E ratios were 50:1 then I wouldn't buy the market

2) There's a fundamental issue in the economy. Plague, war, asteroid, climate change. Whatever the issue, you probably have bigger things to worry about than your retirement fund, and you have no better bets to place

The stock market is just made up of businesses. Businesses make money. Owning part of a business gives you a return. There's no magic to it, no massive extrapolation based solely on past performance. If you think there's a decent chance businesses aren't making money, then you ought to become a prepper.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by nayuki on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:53PM (#22532025)
Did you exclude or include dividends in that assessment?
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by verbify on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:51PM (#22532015)
If you reinvested your dividends you'd be up 25% without taking into account inflation, or down a total of 1.5% if you took into account inflation. Not ideal, but not much different than when you started.

I personally buy an all-world tracker, the Nikkei is an outlier. There could be issues that affect the global economy long term, but if that were the case, I'd have other things to worry about in addition to my investments.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by MR4D on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:49PM (#22532007)
Actually it does, and in a big way.

Let me give a simple example using some round numbers just to show the concept. Plug and play any numbers you want to see how the outcome changes...

Let’s say you have a million dollars in March of 2000, you just retired, and you need to pull out $100,000 to live on. So, in April, you take out $100,000 and now you have $900,000. So you ended up taking out 10% of your principal.

However, the market is falling, and will drop 10% over the next year. So you now have $810,000, and you take out this year’s $100,000 which leaves you with $710,000. Effectively, you took out over 12% of your principal.

2002 is no better, and the market falls a further 13%, and is now down to $618,000. You take out $100,000 for this year’s expenses, leaving you with $518,000.

The next year is even worse in the market, and your nest egg falls 23%, which means you now only have $399,000 left. You still take out your $100,000 and are left with only $299,000.

Thankfully, the next year the market rises 26%. Hallelujah, your nest egg grew to $376,000. However, you still need to take out your $100,000, leaving you with only $276,000. You think your luck has turned around...

The next year the market rises, but only 9%, so your nest egg grows, but only to $301,000. You take out your $100,000, leaving you with only $201,000. Hmmmmm...

The next year the market rises again, but barely - only 3%, so your nest egg is now $207,000. You take out your $100,000 again, and only have $107,000 left. Uhhhh...

Thankfully, the market moves up 14%, and your $107,000 grows to $122,000. You take out your $100,000, leaving you with only $22,000 left.

Finally, in the last year, the market rises 4%, so your nest egg grows to $23,000. You withdraw all of it, and are now broke.

This effect is based on real numbers (rounded) from [0], and represent the S&P 500 market returns starting in the year 2000 (aka, the dot com bust). What happened to this poor retiree is called “sequence of returns”, and it is something that any good financial planner uses to test the durability of his or her projections.

[0] - https://www.macrotrends.net/2526/sp-500-historical-annual-re...

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Klinky on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:20PM (#22532172)
In this scenario:

- This person likely could have drawn social security income, given that it's 2000 and SSI is not bankrupt.

- Ideally you have the funds you need to retire in the principal alone, and are only relying on very modest growth rate to fight inflation once you're actually withdrawing from it.

- You shouldn't be withdrawing retirement funds from an S&P 500 index fund investment. The funds should have been in a retirement income-focused fund or low-risk bonds, which would have helped maintain principal even in down years.

- Ideally your house is paid off, so you're not paying down a mortgage, and have significant equity in your home to draw from as a last resort.

I think a more realistic scenario is someone in their mid-50s who thought the numbers were working out in their favor to retire early, only for the market to crash, and now that is no longer looking like an option.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by MR4D on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:39AM (#22536358)
I'm not addressing strategy, just the math to show sequence of returns does impact withdrawals.

Also, while I agree with you position, most people unfortunately are not in that kind of situation (of course, they typically don't have the $1M I used in my example either).

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by outside1234 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @12:06AM (#22532641)
What you really proved is that $1M is not enough to retire.

If you can’t live off the dividends, you don’t have enough to retire.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by MR4D on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:42AM (#22536393)
The dividends (assuming it's in an S&P index fund) are only about $27,000 per year.

You'd actually want a better mix of income generating assets than straight stocks to make sure you have income and are keeping up with inflation.

And a million is more than enough to retire. (Perhaps not enough for you or me, but that's a lifestyle choice.)

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by DarmokJalad1701 on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:55PM (#22532036)
10% is not really a safe withdrawal rate though.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by MR4D on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:43AM (#22536396)
Agreed - it was simple math because I typed it on my phone.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by brazzy on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:47PM (#22530190)
But whether you start your retirement at a time the market is down a lot or up a lot can make a surprisingly big difference on how long your money lasts, if you don't adjust your spending.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by thekyle on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:54PM (#22530799)
Ideally, shouldn't someone planning to retire have already moved more of their money to bonds? Then they could just withdrawal from the bonds portion of the portfolio (which is likely up right now) while the stock market recovers.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by OJFord on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:29PM (#22531084)
However you frame it, there's always a time you start withdrawals. And if when you planned to do that coincides with a dip, of course you'll have second thoughts.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by throwaway743 on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:38PM (#22531937)
Did so about a year ago based on SMAs and momentum. Only wish there was a cash option to put have them move everything to for the time being, but only had bonds as an option.

Best thing is to watch out for the SMA support levels. Just got through a major death cross and looks to be heading further down

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by bluGill on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:20AM (#22535180)
Though you should have options. Don't retire in a down year. Start moving things to safer investments several years before you retire. Don't spend as much that first year. Still the numbers given are good examples and something to keep in mind.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by typeformer on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:27PM (#22531468)
Bonds yields are the lowest they have been since the great recession.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by mactrey on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:35PM (#22531519)
Yields are low because bond prices are high. It's not a bad time to be selling down your bond portfolio right now.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by perl4ever on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:27PM (#22530590)
Doc, it hurts when I do this!

So...

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by t-writescode on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:35PM (#22530646)
Every medical expense, every food expense has the result of costing more of a percentage of your remaining funds. Many costs can’t be put off.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by perl4ever on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:46PM (#22530737)
All costs are on a spectrum of urgency. Food can be put off longer than water. A small plumbing problem can be put off longer than a large plumbing problem. A furnace problem can be put off longer if it's not cold. Replacing a car can be put off longer than fixing the brakes.

There is no such thing as having all your costs due immediately with equal urgency.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by solveit on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:49PM (#22531231)
On the one hand, you're absolutely right. On the other hand, if I'm putting off food or even general house/vehicle maintenance because of market conditions, my retirement has already failed from my point of view.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by bluGill on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:28AM (#22535237)
If you are that badly off you couldn't afford to retire. For most of the US you have a big spending problem because SS is enough to provide food and basic house/vehicle maintenance. (I know a few people who opted out of SS and then did bad retirement planning - but most people didn't even had the option to opt out of SS)

SS isn't much I'll grant. However it is enough to provide the basics.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by perl4ever on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:07PM (#22540321)
I am counting on social security, and I think all the talk about it "running out" is stupid. It runs year by year on the income from that year, so it's completely up to the political will to pay, and whether the people who are working are willing to keep the retired from starving. I assume they will be, because if not, who gives a shit about anything anyway?
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by DevKoala on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:18PM (#22529922)
But it is wonderful for headlines:

"The man who retired on the week the DOW plunged" https://www.barrons.com/articles/he-retired-the-week-the-dow...

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by madengr on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:56PM (#22530294)
Well you can be fucked by your employers 401k manager. The day my wife quit, she was locked out of here 401k for 2 weeks. They divest everything during that term, and you have no control over the timing. She quit near market peak last year (and began re-investing this week), but say she quit this week? It's volatile enough presently that you could lose $$$ of they decide to sell at a low to boost their stock, and you can't re-invest in time.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by froindt on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:09PM (#22530935)
>Well you can be fucked by your employers 401k manager. The day my wife quit, she was locked out of here 401k for 2 weeks. They divest everything during that term, and you have no control over the timing.

What type of a company did your wife work for? I actively learn about personal finance and retirement plans and have never heard of a lockout from a 401k.

> It's volatile enough presently that you could lose $$$ of they decide to sell at a low to boost their stock, and you can't re-invest in time.

Short of working for a privately traded company, or being a very well compensated executive, the shares owned by an individual employee are almost always negligible compared to daily traded volumes. "Selling at a low to boost their stock" wouldn't even move the needle.

Edit: One possibility came to mind after posting. Was your wife's 401k balance under $5,000? If so, the company can force liquidation. And to say doing so would help the stock price would only be meaningfully true on a penny stock.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by madengr on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:06AM (#22535062)
No, $300k. She was locked out for 2 weeks as it was liquidated and a check cut to her IRA. Fortunately there was no volatility then.

My employer changed the 401k match (in company stock) to a single purchase in January. Of course you can sell immediately, but it has the effect of boosting the shares when you do it for over 100k employees.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by froindt on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @12:15PM (#22536716)
Unfortunately the process to move money from a 401k to an IRA (and moving money in general in he US) isn't great. In many instances the check is sent to the individual who then needs to send it to the receiving institution.

I've also read that upon receiving the money, brokerages don't always show it to the end user right away, using it on their end for a few days (and at scale, that matters).

Fair point regarding the 401k match - but are they issuing new stock to complete the match? I haven't looked at how a match with company stock is funded before, but intuitively I'd think they'd issue new stock, diluting existing stock a tiny bit, but keeping the same overall company valuation.

As originally presented I saw the issue with your wife's 401k and padding the stock price as part of the same issue.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by csnover on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @01:22AM (#22532968)
I’m not the OP, but when I left a company where I had a 401(k) and transferred the balance to my preferred brokerage, the source account was frozen for about that long during the approval and transfer process.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by madengr on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:07AM (#22535066)
Yes, and I assume they cut a check to your IRA?
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by csnover on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @02:30PM (#22538097)
Yes, but the longest part of the process was waiting for the 401(k) administrator to actually do that, and once I initiated the process I couldn’t make any changes. This was a while ago so I don’t remember the specific time frames, but it was somewhere between 10–15 business days for the 401(k) to show a zero balance, then 3–5 business days after that for the money to show up in my IRA. I had no control over when something would happen during this process.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Ericson2314 on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:57PM (#22531673)
As Matt Levine wrote

> It’s a little weird for a mutual-fund or hedge-fund manager to have a lot of uninvested assets (why are you charging fees on a big cash position?), while it’s perfectly normal for private-equity managers to invest a bit of their fund at a time and call capital later as it is needed.

So how much of a bias is there in behavior is there in practice and rhetoric against cutting your losses, pulling out, and waiting for things to be less volatile/risky-seeming?

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by dnprock on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:30PM (#22530034)
I used to subscribe to these investment talking points and believed in the US equity market. I adopted these attitudes from reading Warren Buffett, index fund, financial advice. These are sound principles. I occasionally revisit value investing, dollar-cost averaging.

But times are changing. The US equity market will unlikely to deliver exceptional returns. Buffett may have a strong bias since he started his investing career post WW2. Buffett may experience only the correlation between the US equity market growth and global growth. Investment return is likely non-ergodic. We're entering new terrority where exceptional returns may come from other assets.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by pbourke on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:41PM (#22530129)
> The US equity market will unlikely to deliver exceptional returns.

With each passing day in this crisis, I think you can make the opposite case. Long-term risk in equities is going down, not up, as the market falls and stocks move toward relatively underpriced from relatively overpriced. Or am I missing something?

The expected long-term return from investing $1 in the stock market now vs beginning of Feb is higher, is it not?

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by pram on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:09PM (#22531373)
The stock market was moving irrationally higher since November, and were not even at 52 week lows right now. So not necessarily.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by aeternum on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:00PM (#22531688)
The expected long-term return may still be lower than the historic average. However stocks are now significantly cheaper than now than they were in the beginning of Feb so it follows that yes, the expected long-term return from investing $1 is higher than it was in Feb.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by carc on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:35PM (#22530073)
Lots of bold, unsubstantiated claims. I think every time there is a big peak, or a big valley, some percentage of people are always peddling "but this is different"
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by peisistratos on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:51PM (#22530244)
> I think every time there is a big peak, or a big valley, some percentage of people are always peddling "but this is different"

When stocks crashed in 1929, it was different. In the US we got the New Deal, which still exists in some form. In Germany we got fascism and then a divided Germany for decades. The 1929 crash had effects felt to this day. The DJIA did not recover its 1929 level (not inflation adjusted) until 1954.

The kings and queens of Europe could point to how things never changed over the past millennia, and moved forward as they always had, until Charles I had his head lopped off in 1649. Then things began changing.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by dnprock on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:10PM (#22530419)
It's useful to read the history of the stock market prior to WW2. It was a casino back then. Our experience post WW2 probably creates a bias. We're used to the stock market stability. But it has some serious structural problem now (e.g. low/0 interest rate). I would not be surprised if it is heading back into casino mode.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by solveit on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:52PM (#22531258)
Sure game-changing big changes exist. But when someone says "this is different", it's almost certainly not different. Both of those statements are true and I see no reason to think we're not in the latter case right now.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by dnadler on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:34PM (#22530067)
What led you to the conclusion that the market will not behave as it has historically over the long-term?
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by btilly on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:03PM (#22530363)
Over the long term. Let's go back 150 years and invest in a random stock market wherever you happened to live.

If you lived in the USA or England, this was a great idea and worked out brilliantly.

If you lived in countries like Italy, Germany and Russia, you lost everything when those stock markets were closed down in the first half of the 20th century.

You can't say "historically over the long term" then project forward for the next 50 years based only by the results of the last 50 years in the market where things have worked out best.

Over our lifetime, equities are indeed the best bet. But not a guaranteed safe one.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by lutorm on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:45PM (#22531206)
If you lived in countries like Italy, Germany and Russia, you lost everything when those stock markets were closed down in the first half of the 20th century.

This may be true, but then we're talking about such large changes that investment advice sort of becomes pointless. I mean no doubt that life would have sucked in those situations, but there's no investment choice that would have saved you either.

Like, if we were sitting today contemplating WW3 breaking out in 1960, annihilating the civilized world, the market going down would have been the least of your problems.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by btilly on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:54PM (#22531649)
I mean no doubt that life would have sucked in those situations, but there's no investment choice that would have saved you either.

Guaranteed saving, no. But keeping an emergency supply of highly portable wealth in the form of gold worked surprisingly well for most of those historical examples. (The ironic exception being the USA where we confiscated people's gold under Roosevelt.)

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by int_19h on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @04:32PM (#22539371)
It didn't work particularly well in Russia, either.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by AgentOrange1234 on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:42PM (#22531173)
This is very interesting. I never heard about these other stock markets. Going to have to look into this.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by dnprock on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:59PM (#22530326)
I think the dynamic of the US equity market has changed. In the old days, you can balance your portfolio between stock and bond. This is portfolio advice from Benjamin Graham's The Intelligent Investor. We can no longer do this because interest rates are heading to 0. Bond investors don't make money from interest rates. Bond traders benefit from rate drop. Bond was an investment. It's now destroyed. We end up with cash and equity.

There's a lot of money pumping into the market by central banks. Markets are no longer free. Central banks manipulate their markets. With these kinds of manipulations, we get diminishing returns. Let's say the economy gets back on its feet. Where does it get the leverage to invest? We're overloaded with debt. The interest rate is probably 0 or negative at that point.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by aeternum on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:08PM (#22531745)
The counter-argument to this is that even with the money being pumped into the market by the central banks, we are not seeing significant inflation in consumer goods.

This implies that the money is being put to work efficiently and resulting in productivity and QoL improvements for society as a whole.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by dnprock on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:01PM (#22532065)
We have not seen inflation. But we're seeing slow growth and negative interest rate. These are signs of diminishing returns. The market has lost its check-and-balance. Bond and lending were supposed to carry risk and skin in the game. Right now, overall growth is delivered through the Fed pumping money. There is no check-and-balance.

With this crisis, governments will likely pump more money. That'll distort the market further.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by aeternum on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @12:13AM (#22532669)
What we've seen throughout history is that economies are typically ruined by two things:

1) Governments or central banks printing or issuing (often not physically) too much money, resulting in inflation that spirals out of control.

2) Governments, central banks, individuals, businesses hoarding money due to fear or other reasons, resulting in deflation that spirals out of control.

Those two are a form of check & balance. The thesis that most central banks now use is that if we can keep inflation steady, then we will have relative economic stability. The interest/lending rates are simply tools through which inflation can be moderated.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by bawolff on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:38PM (#22531141)
The same thing that lead me to the conclusion that the sun will rise tomorrow.

I don't really know for sure, but it seems to fit the pattern and that's the best i can hope for in absence of other data.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by synaesthesisx on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:40PM (#22530120)
Realistically stocks can only go up long-term. It's easy to forget during times of chaos, but in the long run there's no way but up.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by brazzy on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:48PM (#22530209)
The question is whether they'll go up as much as they used to - with global population growth slowing down, there is a case to be made that the 7% long term growth that many people treat as a fact of nature is not in fact a long-term thing.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by dcftoapv on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @02:02AM (#22533156)
I don't agree. There are three things that normal investors should be doing right now:

1 - Assess how you feel. Are you upset by the loss of value? Then you make be more risk averse than you thought. It might be wise to reconsider your asset allocation after this emergency is over. However, it's not wise to redo your allocation while the VIX is above 20ish.

2 - Check in with a financial adviser. This is a good reminder that your financial portfolio matters, and it is smart to use this as a prompt to check in on your financial health.

3 - This is the most important one, but you can't do it if you're not good on #1 and #2. REBALANCE YOUR PORTFOLIO. If you are allocated to risky and riskless assets then it is time to make sure that your allocation is still where you want it to be. It probably isn't. If your allocation to riskless assets is higher than you normally would like then you should sell riskless and buy risky.

Why is #3 so important? Because it allows you to collect a liquidity provider premium. Purchasing risky assets in volatile markets a) stabilizes the markets b) takes the advantaged side of the transaction. A lot of research stands behind this idea. Rebalancing in volatile environments is an easy and reliable way to outperform your peers over the long run.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by mmhsieh on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:07PM (#22531735)
Buying a low cost index will already cause you to beat most retail and most professional money managers. Knowing that fact will gain you an advantage over almost everyone that moves stock for a living.

Also, not too late. Getting out now is like getting out too early in Jan 2018.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by nimblegorilla on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:09PM (#22532126)
> If you need to retire in the next five years, you should already have started moving out of equities. It's too late to change that now.

This is still a great time to reallocate your money. The SPDR fund that I invest in is still about where it was 1 year ago.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by chenster on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:14PM (#22530971)
> If you need to retire in the next five years, you should already have started moving out of equities.

Exactly. People are selling off and further worsen the crash.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by bumby on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:04PM (#22530885)
>you can’t gain any advantage over the market that overcome your transaction costs

I know this is the predominant efficient market adage but is there a case to be made for low volatility portfolios outperforming the market over long periods? [1]

I’m curious especially now that most online brokers have significantly reduced trade costs on ETFs

[1] https://archivefda.dlib.nyu.edu/jspui/bitstream/2451/29593/2...

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Der_Einzige on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:33PM (#22529443)
Than why do I keep getting richer on my puts? Maybe it's because there are actually ways to make money during a crisis...
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by neuland on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:40PM (#22529518)
If you're trading options, you are not an average retail investor. Discussing puts isn't relevant for GP's situation.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by SilasX on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:06PM (#22529806)
So? If you want to buy options, it's relatively easy to transform yourself into such an investor, so that should be fair game for evaluating HNers' potential search space.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by downerending on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @01:47PM (#22537651)
It's not appropriate unless you're a multi-millionaire, and it's not that easy to transform yourself into one.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by SilasX on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @02:16PM (#22537975)
You don't need to be a multi-millionare to make money on options, I just recently cited someone who put a small amount (relative to a multi-millionare) to disproportionately profit from the market declines that weren't priced in.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22526246

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Der_Einzige on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @02:34PM (#22538135)
I put 1000 in, but I could have put on 200$ in.

Options are even MORE appropriate for the non super rich, because if you put a small amount of money in, you either win big or you lose it all. I'm fine with losing 200$ occasionally.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by FabHK on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:41PM (#22530132)
Buying lottery tickets totally works, someone can claim every week.

https://xkcd.com/1827/

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Der_Einzige on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:26PM (#22531057)
It's a lottery ticket except when an event happens that you know more about than most investors.

In this case, investors are dealing with something they know nothing about - Epidemology.

When black swans happen, you can EASILY beat the market. We've known that Coronavirus was going to get this bad for months. We know the R0 rate. We know the CFR. Markets completely failed to "price coronavirus in"

Sometimes, you really can outperform the market but its only possible in situations where financial policy and monetary policy are unable to help. I see that supply chains are grinding to a halt and I know that this means the whole economy is going to be in pain.

But it's okay, keep on thinking that it's all like the lottery and see where you are in 6 months. You'll wish you were shorting the market.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ltbarcly3 on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:15PM (#22531788)
I have no idea why you are getting downvoted.

Rollback to mid Feb. The stock market keeps hitting new highs. Tesla stock is trading for around 5x what it was trading for just weeks before. Meanwhile China is basically shut down and dealing with a deadly illness. The country where everything is made these days is in deadlock, and there's no reason to think it won't spread everywhere. Cases are popping up all over the world. The stock market keeps going up. I start telling people to get out of the market, and everyone acts like I'm a crazy person.

Stop and think about it, is Tesla worth 4x what it was 3 months earlier, when there was no covid as far as anyone knew? A company that loses money every year and can barely make as many cars in a year as VW makes every 2 weeks worth 5x more than VW? A company which makes less than 1% margin on it's best selling car? A company that could go bankrupt in less than a year in an economic downturn? A company that the market thought was worth 1/5 as much 4 months ago? People were saying it was going to $7000 a share. To be worth that it would have to sell every car made in the entire world every year, and people would have to buy 100x as many cars as they do now, by the year 2021. It's a story told by absolute lunatics.

I'm not saying I thought the market was going to crash today, there's no way to predict that. However, anyone who thought the market was not a bubble waiting to pop should not be investing. There are the people who knew it was overvalued and were trying to ride the bubble, the people who were waiting to short it, and people who are acting confused now and saying 'nobody could see it coming'.

Fastforward to now and my put options are up 300%+, and I'm going to hold them until they are over 1,000% up or they expire in the money. I guess it's just like the lottery, except where they tell you the numbers every day all day for weeks in advance.

It's now the evening of 9-March. I'm watching the US market index futures, which are up by almost 3%, and I'm just shaking my head. People think the market will start going up again? Italy just announced it is restricting every person in the country to their houses and only allowing essential travel. The US does not have a better medical system or a less elderly population than Italy, and we have not put in place any precautions or restrictions, other than strongly encouraging people to not get on cruise ships, which they just announced last night, weeks after the 2nd plague ship was sailing around with no port willing to accept them. In 3 weeks the US will be where Italy is today, and the stock futures are going up? The S&P 500 is the same value it was last October, and given all that we know about how disruptive this virus will be, people with lots of money are still betting the economy is better now than it was 5 months ago when everything was going great, and will be worth more tomorrow.

There are a lot of people with a lot of money, and a lot of them are complete idiots. You can beat the market, at least from time to time.

Feb 4th: https://www.cnn.com/2020/02/04/business/tesla-stock-soars/in...

Also Feb 4th: https://www.cnn.com/asia/live-news/coronavirus-outbreak-02-0...

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by bluGill on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:39AM (#22535331)
The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent. (Attribution controversial)

What you write can be true, and yet you can still go bankrupt trying to trade it.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ltbarcly3 on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:16AM (#22635678)
BTW, for the record, my options are now worth over 1500% more. I've sold 4x my original investment. Probably not going bankrupt, but I'm going to go car shopping with 2% of what I just made. Maybe I'm acting irrationally, but then again https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correspondence_theory_of_truth
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ltbarcly3 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:57PM (#22561639)
I can't go bankrupt by buying option contracts.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by anonuser123456 on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:46PM (#22531598)
Not quite.

A lottery is ergodic, while a pandemic is not. No one can know the course of a pandemic early on, so the precautionary principle dominates. Also, income/employment is coupled to the market. If the market tanks out, people can lose their jobs, given the downturn a double whammy for "buy and hold"ers.

Personally, I jumped into cash/Treasuries and made some puts/bets on SPY. In the worst case, nothing happens and I'm out a little money. But my job pays me more money every week, so being out a little money isn't such a big deal.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by skybrian on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:42PM (#22531181)
Even if you are a value investor and in it for the long haul, you may have some opinion about what's a good price versus a bad price. You don't know tomorrow's price but on rare occasions it may be that a solid company's stock looks particularly cheap for a reason you know. Should you ignore bargains entirely?

Also, for many retail investors, transaction costs are now zero. Maybe the conventional advice needs an update?

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by tyingq on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:23PM (#22529348)
"There's nothing to do here."

Maybe. I imagine it's a trigger for some people to review their investment mix. Not saying panic sell at this particularly bad moment, but downturns are an obvious heads up for people that assumed everything would constantly rise. Changing your mix for future deposits might not be a bad idea if your current mix is higher risk than it should be for your age.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by neogodless on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:33PM (#22530059)
Ideally you set yourself up with an Investment Policy Statement which includes your ideal asset allocation (based in risk tolerance and goal-setting), as well as rules for rebalancing, such as 5% drift outside that asset allocation you want.

So if equities are down 20% but bonds are stable (or better!) you end up selling bonds high and buying equities while they are cheaper.

If you didn't plan ahead, you shouldn't be making plans now. If you have cash or other assets with less growth potential, it may be a good idea to sell some to buy equities. But before you do that, zoom out and look at 5 years of index fund prices. This 20% correction reaches back to about December 2018. But has not appreciably negated the growth between 2009 and then!

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Aeolun on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:44PM (#22529571)
Probably want to change the mix in a few months, not right now.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by edraferi on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:21PM (#22529943)
Assuming you're over-concentrated in equities, yeah. But if you're under-invested in equities, this would be a decent time to start getting more. No telling when the market will bottom out though, so as always be careful.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by downerending on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @01:45PM (#22537634)
If you can predict that the market will go down, yes. But you cannot--that's the whole point.

You could transition more slowly to get the "dollar cost averaging" effect, but that has its own risks.

If your mix is wrong, it's best to fix it pretty quickly.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by leakybit on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:03PM (#22529773)
Unless you use robinhood which has no transactions fees.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by swsieber on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:12PM (#22529855)
> robinhood

It's easy to have no fees if your customers can't make transactions.

To be less snarky, I'd avoid them if you're trying to time the markets.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by missosoup on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:30PM (#22530036)
For those not in the loop: it's been impossible to make transactions on a number of platforms including Robinhood due to the overwhelmingly high load causing those platforms to fail. A lot of people were basically locked out from trading.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by walshemj on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:17PM (#22530998)
I got a warning when I logged into Interactive Investor (UK) this morning and its still there now.

"Please be aware that due to exceptional market volatility, there may be situations in which it is difficult to obtain a price for your trade."

Will be interesting to see what effect the Budget statement on Wednesday

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by verbify on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:37PM (#22531934)
I think the government are damned whatever they do. A massive fiscal stimulus admits there's a massive problem (and the government has been trying to project a quiet confidence that this is something under control), so markets will tank. A small response could be seen as inadequate.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by chrisjc on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:25PM (#22530571)
Or you know... Feb 29th, every four years.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by alasdair_ on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:51PM (#22530777)
They completely failed three different times in the past couple of weeks. The Feb 29th thing was a red herring.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ozi on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:22PM (#22531033)
One does not simply "use" Robinhood on a day like today. Or the last 3 large down days since Coronavirus. System-wide failures abound.

Expect your orders to not execute as intended and money to be lost.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by lukewrites on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:12PM (#22529860)
There are still costs to your transactions, not least of which is the information gulf between you and an institutional investor with a Bloomberg terminal.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by darawk on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:26PM (#22530003)
Not really. The only cost to your transaction is the bid-ask spread, which is extremely tight in liquid US equities.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by glouwbug on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:14PM (#22529879)
Their fees come in the form of unexpected downtime at high volume.

A free system gets you only so far

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by skellera on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:06PM (#22529810)
Not just Robinhood. Charles Schwab and some others have moved this direction too.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by perl4ever on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:47PM (#22530743)
Virtually everybody went to zero commissions, more or less.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by kaycebasques on Monday March 09, 2020 @03:54PM (#22529091)
> Note that nobody has any idea where equity prices will be in one day, never mind one year or ten years' time.

> So relax... keep buying

lol

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by jfengel on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:10PM (#22529230)
The error, actually, is in the first part rather than the second. We don't know where it will be in a day or a year, but there's good reason to think we know where it will be in ten years: about twice where it is now. It might be only 1.5x or it might be 3x, but it's not very likely to fall very far outside of that range.

Given that, if you have ten years to wait before you need your money, it's as good a place as any to put your surplus earnings today. Not to sell your car or borrow money, but as a reasonably safe long-term thing to do with money that you will use for your retirement.

And then forget about it. Buy a broad index and don't worry what it does on a daily basis, even days like today. Perhaps especially days like today.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by phreeza on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:31PM (#22529430)
The counterexamples that have been brought up elsewhere on this post are Gold (still below 40 year high) and the Nikkei (still below 30 year high).
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by evanpw on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:58PM (#22529725)
Gold is a single concentrated bet, not really comparable to a stock-market index, and the Nikkei shows why it's important to diversify outside of your home country. For almost everyone, "buy the global market portfolio and forget about it" is the right advice.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by phreeza on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:15PM (#22529890)
While I agree that this advice is better than picking stocks, something always rubs me the wrong way when it is repeated like it is an absolute fact. Like they say in the commercials, Past Performance Is No Guarantee of Future Results.

I can't say what form it will take, but I can definitely see a future where the pendulum swings back from ever more indexification.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by jfengel on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:25PM (#22529993)
I agree with you. I believe the biggest problem with indexification is that it encourages a generic flow of money into the market, regardless of whether the market can handle it or not. Although the market isn't just gambling, and there is real underlying value, it's not an infinite source of value to give returns to anybody buying into it. Eventually there can be too much money chasing too little corporate earnings, and the market gets overpriced.

I don't think it's unreasonable for a person with spare cash to expect to get a reliable 5% or so long term just from the inevitable progress of technology. That may not continue forever, but if it ends, the problems will be bigger than just what index fund to purchase. The world will be a very different place.

(Or the market could be, if people stop seeking to raise capital there, but that's also a very different future and hard to predict.)

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by evanpw on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:39PM (#22530117)
Every time you buy a stock, someone sold it to you, so flow of money into the market isn't something that's easy to define in a meaningful way. And even if a lot of the invested capital is passive (maybe half of the US stock market), almost none of the trading is, and that's what determines prices.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by jfengel on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:02PM (#22530345)
Money flows into the market when people earn it and use it to buy stocks. Every stock purchase is matched by a stock sale, but most stock sales turn around and become new stock purchases. That's a net long term inflow of money into the stock market, from people purchasing stocks with their earnings (often, via retirement funds).

Most of the actual trading is traders trading to each other, and that shouldn't raise the market cap long term (though it does create volatility). But there is also real inflow of money into the market.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by kpommerenke on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:22PM (#22531834)
As industrialized countries age, there will be relative more people in retirement compared to people in their working years. As a result, the money being pulled out of the stock market will grow relative to the money being put into the market. That is one of the reasons that we shouldn't expect to see the same stock market returns as in the past.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by evanpw on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:29PM (#22530028)
I agree with your first part, but not the second. Even if there's a future where the total market has zero (or negative) return on average in the long term, it doesn't mean that it's any easier to find the temporary exceptions. And lower volatility is still good even if everything has zero expected return, so diversification still helps.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by FabHK on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:31PM (#22530040)
One thing to keep in mind is that the Nikkei 225 (like most indices except the German DAX) is a price index, and, (like the Dow) a mediocre one at that.

A better index is the Topix, and that’s available in a total return (and net return) variant (that is, including dividends before (or net of) taxes)).

A fairly low dividend yield would suffice to make the total return index exceed the 1990’s high by now. (It’s not trivial to find the data to confirm this for free.)

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by jfengel on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:53PM (#22529686)
The Nikkei high was wildly artificial; its price-to-earnings ratio indicated that there was an enormous bubble. The US stock market is (probably) currently inflated, but by a factor closer to 2 (or less) than 10.

(I've looked less into the price of gold, which has a weird place in people's minds and would require a lot more research than I've put into it.)

It's entirely possible, of course, that the US is entering a long-term economic disaster of a kind it has been courting for decades: government borrowing, student loans, Baby Boomer retirement, etc. But US companies have been earning money, and in general that does justify the belief that they merit a stock price that's roughly where it is now; somewhat lower, but not radically different.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by phreeza on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:25PM (#22529996)
Could it be that the E part of the P/E Ratio is currently also significantly inflated? For the tech sector I could definitely see that happening due to the influx of VC money, causing unsustainable b2b spend on cloud&ads, which currently show up as earnings for FAANG but may quickly subside when VCs pull out?
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by jfengel on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:24AM (#22535207)
It's entirely possible. Earnings are historically high, and the Fed has been pumping money into the economy for over a decade. But it hasn't translated into higher consumer inflation, which has actually been below the Fed target. So the companies are earning money without raising prices, at least on the consumer basket of goods.

FAANG, as you say, are B2B and don't show up as inflation. It's entirely believable that that's all fake money that will disappear from the market when the going gets tough. Whether it will come back... well, you probably don't want my complete unfocused brain dump which all comes down to "I dunno".

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by jjoonathan on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:38PM (#22529499)
Also, the fact that the Nikkei's behavior is typically attributed, at least in part, to a demographic trend that's likely to hit the US within our lifetimes.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by kaycebasques on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:26PM (#22531058)
I guess my parent comment was too cheeky and internet-y but I'm making a serious point here. There's an unbelievable quantity of people here on HN who recite adages about the unknowability of the future (which is good advice!), and then proceed to give very specific recommendations on how to behave in the future, and those recommendations are packed with assumptions about what the future entails. I'm sorry to pick on ttul here but the cognitive dissonance is just astounding.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by totalZero on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:18PM (#22529294)
> As a retail investor (i.e. not extremely rich), you can't gain any advantage over the market that overcomes your transaction costs.

Sure you can. You develop a system, learn how to find information, and make good predictions of future human behavior. You should learn the ins and outs of the product you're trading.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by santoriv on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:56PM (#22529711)
Very few active fund managers can consistently beat their indexes. Why do you believe you would be better over a long period of time?

Vanguard Study of Actively Managed Funds vs Index Performance: https://personal.vanguard.com/pdf/ISGIDX.pdf

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ltbarcly3 on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:06PM (#22532105)
You are assuming fund managers want to maximize returns for investors. That is not the game they are playing at all.

Fund managers have pathological incentives. People won't hand them money if they say 'I'm going to just hold this money as cash for the next 1-5 years until the market goes completely irrational in a way that I can make you 5x returns, but in the meantime I'm going to charge you 2% per year on the balance'.

They have to put that money in to something or they won't be given money in the first place.

Secondly, funds play games with the money, because investors are not sophisticated and there is a ton of dumb money in retirement accounts. People look at the past returns and choose funds that have a high past rate of return. Fund managers know this, so they set up 15 funds with different strategies. One of them has a high rate of return, by luck, while 14 do much worse. Then they expand that fund 10x by quoting that high rate of return.

Fund managers can make more money by not optimizing how much money they make for you, if you measure them by how much money they get paid to manage other people's money you'll see they are playing that game very well.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by manigandham on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:25PM (#22529987)
Note that report is Vanguard marketing material and most managed funds have specific mandates (like maintaining a certain volatility or investing in certain securities) other than maximizing gains.

This is why hedge funds underperform indexes in bull markets but beat them in turbulent times.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by FabHK on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:38PM (#22530101)
> This is why hedge funds underperform indexes in bull markets but beat them in turbulent times.

Agreed on the first part; I’d want to see hard statistics (after fees) on the second part (and, no, citing the 3 or so famous exceptions that are closed to outside investors and might have used illegally obtained insider information doesn’t invalidate the larger point).

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by manigandham on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:03PM (#22532078)
Hedge funds trade gains for consistency. They don't publicly report numbers though and aren't meant to be public funds (that's what ETFs are for) so it's hard to get full stats, but it's common knowledge in finance.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by nl on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:25PM (#22530563)
This is why hedge funds underperform indexes in bull markets but beat them in turbulent times.

Hedge funds have only outperformed the market twice since 2008.

Once was during the financial crisis of 2008 (-19% vs -37%) and once was 2018 (-4.07 vs -4.38).

It's unclear what benefits you are getting here.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by samsonradu on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:02PM (#22530871)
The market after 2008 has been on a historically low volatility and a record bull run isn't it?
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by manigandham on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:05PM (#22532097)
That aligns with what I said, although there are plenty of private hedge funds that don't report their returns. The benefit varies for each client.

An example would be a real-estate company that has holdings in a fund. Preservation and low volatility is far more important than raw gains and can be used as collateral to offset losses in physical property valuations.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by austhrow743 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @06:46AM (#22534360)
>Very few active fund managers can consistently beat their indexes.

Funds profit from managing more money. The more money you manage, the harder it is to find plays that use a significant amount of it. So it makes perfect sense that funds would increase in size until they perform at a rate similar to indexes.

>Why do you believe you would be better over a long period of time?

The fully loaded cost of even a junior analyst would be in the hundreds of thousands a year. Independent day traders can focus on strategies that leverage such a tiny amount of capital and result in such a tiny return that it's not profitable for a fund to be looking at. Keeping in mind that "too small for a fund to worry about" can still be "shitloads of money" for 99% of people.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by totalZero on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:35PM (#22530075)
Beating indices in a correlated bull market isn't the same thing as making money consistently.

The contrapositive of your argument is that anyone who is holding cash outperformed the S&P today. Though true, it sounds silly to say that someone who goes about his day with a $100 in his wallet is outperforming the market, no?

In a disperse market, single stocks chosen correctly will outperform the index. In a correlated bull market, the index will outperform.

We are not exactly in a bull market right now.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by IAmEveryone on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:29PM (#22529399)
The efficient market hypothesis would like a word with you.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by cryptoz on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:38PM (#22529505)
I just googled that to inform myself.

> The efficient market hypothesis in financial economics that states that asset prices reflect all available information

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficient-market_hypothesis

The efficient market hypothesis seems easily disproven with a number of modern examples. Climate change for example - there is significant information available, but markets act as though the information is fake. Leading investors and corporations have for decades denied the risks associated with economic growth backed on non-renewable, polluting and greenhouse-effect-causing energy sources.

The hypothesis does not account for common irrational behavior among people; that real news is considered fake, or real crises considered non-crises.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by totalZero on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:53PM (#22529688)
There is also a matter of weighting. Some facts are known but viewed as uncorrelated or unimportant to the stock price. Facts may be obvious, but wrongly discarded as irrelevant.

I think of markets as a real-time implementation of information theory. There are certain facts that exist, and they are not all known although they may be discoverable. As they become known, or are considered more heavily, those facts bleed into market prices.

In this view, the market is a collective model of the world and thus it is not reflective of all true information.

The model overvalues the confidence and beliefs of people who have money. Sometimes, these people trade stock of companies that deal more with lower-income individuals. Their knowledge of those companies is limited, but over time they may converge toward a better understanding.

Also, sometimes there are errors in interpretation of easily discoverable facts. After 9/11, interest rates went down, but the market didn't price that into auto sales despite 0% interest auto loans being offered to the market.

The market is a model that perpetually converges to a set of facts that are constantly shifting. There is always a gradient (like osmotic pressure) between the model and the reality it represents, so there is always some motion in the market.

And there is always a set of expectations about the future that must be reflected in the model. These expectations have a wide variety of distributions, some are gaussian, others are bimodal, etc. That adds another layer of complexity in getting the model to converge to an appropriate expected value.

Not only that, but several different assets are interlinked. For example, if you buy a large block of call options on a high-volatility name, the market-maker will probably buy stock as a hedge. But in the absence of an upcoming event, he will buy patiently over the course of several trading days in order to minimize the price change resulting from his purchase ("delta impact"). So the market knows that the market-maker traded options, but he has an incentive to hide his hedging activity from other market participants so that they don't front-run him. As a result, it takes time for the purchase of the delta via options to be reflected in the underlying stock -- even though the options trade was printed on the exchange immediately and publicly.

Even if markets were efficient to known information, their price moves do not arrive at equilibrium instantaneously. There is an information gradient -- a kind of osmotic pressure between what is truly happening and what is reflected in the price -- that takes time to normalize itself.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by selestify on Monday March 09, 2020 @07:55PM (#22531274)
That’s a fascinating explanation. Did you come up with it by yourself?
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by asdff on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @02:33AM (#22533273)
You are thinking about what is logically efficient, but the market is also concerned about what is emotionally efficient.

A certain proportion of people believe climate change is a hoax, a certain proportion stand to make a lot of money shaping policy as if it were a hoax. With the coronavirus, merited or not the panic is real and the markets are reflecting that panic.

In a world economy driven by consumer spending, how people feel is more real than what is actually real for the market. Therefore, the market is always at its most efficient.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by deepnotderp on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:58PM (#22529723)
Out of the all the casualties of the virus, the efficient market hypothesis has got to be one of them...

Where were efficient markets when all news from China pointed to a pandemic?

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Raidion on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:07PM (#22529819)
They were down slightly, marking the public's general consensus that while the news was worrying, that there was still a good possibility of containment. If you feel like you have a better understanding of risk than the markets do, it's pretty dang cost effective to buy puts, and you can make a LOT of money with very well understood downsides.

In November 2002, when SARS was first identified S&P was at ~909, it dropped to 846 in March 2003, and was back up as the virus was shown to be under control. Obviously lots of factors in play, but we're very susceptible to hindsight bias as a species.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by deepnotderp on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:55PM (#22530285)
I did buy bear ETFs
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by evanpw on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:18PM (#22529921)
The human lifespan is too short to distinguish between luck and skill for most low frequency traders. You'd have to see dozens of potential pandemics as severe as this one to know if you were "right". But it's empirically true that the average active trader underperforms the market. I build short-term trading strategies at my day job, but at home I just buy and hold some boring vanilla index funds. One nice thing about higher-frequency trading is that you have enough statistical power to quickly see lots of "obvious" ideas fail miserably. It teaches humility.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ltbarcly3 on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:08PM (#22532115)
The efficient market hypothesis says you will never find money on the ground, because someone will always find it before you.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by Nasrudith on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:06AM (#22535056)
That is a misunderstanding akin to saying price differences by location cannot exist. It factors in all /available/ knowledge and the abilities aren't perfect either. Even if everyone was omniscient there is time to converge to the inevitable end state and perfect knowledge doesn't exist.

Expecting walking or driving around to provide free money wouldn't be workable. The closest precedent are the venerable professional of the poor - urban scavenging for discarded valuables like recycling. And this goes to well before the industrial revolution. To say a tradesman it wouldn't be worth taking their bones from a meal to sell to a gluemaker and just discarded it in the street. To the desperately poor it was input they could turn to money and was sort of a proto street cleaner to a society lacking modern waste disposal infastructure and institutions.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by ltbarcly3 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @01:13PM (#22537303)
Walking around with the same strategy and constraints as everyone else won't work.

Lots of the money in the market is being traded by people who are managing over a billion dollars. They have to find investments that can absorb hundreds of millions of dollars. Your example of people collecting bottles is a perfect analogy of how anyone not moving millions of dollars can find good investments.

Also, it assumes that information is basically the same as 'news'. It's unlikely you will happen to be set up to respond to news as fast as whoever is fastest. However, to use information requires knowledge and comprehension, which is not considered at all. Most money on the market is being moved around by robots using fairly basic statistical models.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by manigandham on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:18PM (#22529913)
That's the price at a instantaneous moment in time. Trading requires that price to move, which it does as new information constantly arrives.

You can interpret that data differently, find your own data, and make your own predictions on future data.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by totalZero on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:35PM (#22529473)
The efficient market hypothesis is that markets are efficient to present public information.

If markets were efficient to the present value of the future price at all times, then there would be no such thing as insider trading and hedge funds would all lose money.

You can make money by making inferences about present facts, or taking views on future occurrences.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by greenshackle2 on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:31PM (#22530046)
Exploiting inefficiencies for gains is the mechanism by which EMH is supposed to work, so you're right that some people must be making money by trading intelligently.

But professionals have advantages that are difficult to match for small-time investors like: single-digit millisecond latency with exchanges, specialized hardware, sophisticated back-testing systems, proprietary data sources (market data, weather, retail data, etc. any data source you can thing of, some hedge fund is buying it), 60+ hours a week to work on their strats, qualified peers to bounce ideas, volume-discounted broker fees, etc.

Even then, professionals beat the market pretty inconsistently. Many people, including professionals, mistake luck for skill. So I think skepticism is justified when people online claim to have strategies that beat the market.

If you are one of the few who can actually consistently come up with strategies that beat the market, unless you are already rich, it might be worthwhile to work at a hedge fund and take a cut of the profits from trading large sums of other people's money instead of trading your own.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by totalZero on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:43PM (#22530149)
You can't say there are inefficiencies for institutions to exploit, but no inefficiencies for anyone else. Choose a consistent framework for how you view markets.

There are fast alphas, and there are slow alphas.

If you're an institution making markets on index ETFs, you can make money by having more accurate spot prices for the basket. Fast alpha.

If you're a vol trader, you are more worried about convexity of gap moves and the shape of the vol surface. For me, this means following the story of the name and thinking about where the vol surface doesn't properly reflect tail risk. Slow alpha.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by greenshackle2 on Monday March 09, 2020 @10:46PM (#22532305)
Good thing I didn't say that, then!

I just assign very low prior probability that "this hobbyist investor I've just met on the internet can beat the market" is true. Not zero, but low. And I think it's a pretty well justified prior.

As a corollary to that, I don't think it's good advice to tell the average retail investor to try their hand at trading because most of the time it will not work out.

If you have managed to do it, more power to you.

The advantages I mentioned was what I saw at a not particularly large hedge fund with short to medium term trading strategies. They didn't do just market making, hedge funds do vol trading too.

Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by kpommerenke on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:48PM (#22531998)
Well, there are (small) inefficiencies for everyone to exploit. For example, a stock is mispriced and you expect it to return an additional 1% when the mispricing disappears. The difference between an institutional investor and a retail investor is that the institutional investor can invest $100 million in the stock and make $1 million of profit, while a retail investor with $100,000 will make only $1,000. As a result, institutional investors can afford to spend a lot more money on research, hardware, data, etc. It's very hard to compete with that as a retail investor.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by martinpw on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:15PM (#22529889)
I'm not clear why you mention insider trading here? Insiders have access to information that is not present public information, and so is not priced into the current value of the stock.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by thoughtstheseus on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:20PM (#22529937)
The the strong form of the EMH includes inside info, all info in existence.
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by kpommerenke on Monday March 09, 2020 @09:50PM (#22532010)
Yes, but no one claims that the market is strong form efficient. The question is rather whether the U.S. stock and bond markets are weak form (prices include all past trading data) or semi-strong form efficient (prices include all publicly available information).
Re:Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet by mempko on Monday March 09, 2020 @05:54PM (#22530267)
What do you say to someone starting to save now when the climate crises is now happening? Humanities ultimate cosmic event is happening. How can you reasonably save for something like that?