It’s true that even a retail investor can research and implement a strategy that beats the market average. However, their transaction cost - which includes the cost of their time doing research - will, over a large number of tries, eat up this advantage.
Said another way: could _anyone_ reliably beat the market by enough to pay off the costs they expended coming up with their unique winning strategy? Not just you - I am sure you are very smart - but any typical retail investor.
Not that I'm advocating trying to time the market, but I don't buy the "the average person can't do it so you shouldn't try" argument.
Regular person could absolutely see it and be prepared. Even today market still doesn’t price in Italy-style or China-style lockdowns.
It does not change the fact that the market had an inefficiency in pricing this information into many assets two weeks ago.
If someone bought or sold assets based on a strategy based on this belief (and certainly at least some people did), then they exploited that perceived inefficiency correctly without hindsight.
In an ideal world, markets should be perfectly efficient (near immediate) at exposing things which are misvalued because people can make money if they understand some fact that the market doesn't and then that fact will be accounted for.
In reality they just converge on the average of beliefs weighted by how confident a given actor is for a given belief and how much money they have to put behind the belief, and people are extremely imperfect, especially when it comes to predicting the outcomes of complex systems. Given this, there exist all sorts off "inefficiencies", or times when the current state of the market fails to accurately account for some underlying reality which leaves an exploitable opportunity to buy or sell a mispriced asset.
This is more or less true.
> As a retail investor (i.e. not extremely rich), you can't gain any advantage over the market that overcomes your transaction costs.
This is patently absurd. It's an easily falsifiable statement which is a rare feat in economics. On average, the the average retail investor will not beat the market. That does not mean they can't. All you need to have is literally any correct thesis and the ability to execute on it and you will have an advantage over "the market". I'm not trivializing this, it's not an easy feat, but markets are absolutely full of inefficiencies, and it's obviously not impossible to do better than the average case. This is a complete misunderstanding of the efficient markets hypothesis.
BTW, I'm not recommending that anyone try to time markets.