News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by xeeeeeeeeeeenu on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @02:18PM (#22416296)
The weather app was literally the only UWP application I was using of my own free will and it was because of its live tile. I liked being able to check the weather by opening my start menu.

I hate the other UWP apps. They're slow, they lack features, they have horrible UIs and they don't integrate well with the rest of the OS. The only reason why I'm using the new "Settings" app or the new calculator is because Microsoft forced me to it.

It's such a shame that Microsoft refuses to acknowledge that UWP was a mistake and keeps porting apps to it.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by cptskippy on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @02:33PM (#22416486)
I don't have a problem with UWP and I really like the new Calculator. Being able to pin the calculator on-top and resize it so that it's touch friendly really boosts productivity for me on a laptop without a 10key. If you're not using a touchscreen then I can see the improvements not being that big of a deal but I'm not aware of any regressions in functionality.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by airstrike on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @02:44PM (#22416611)
I'm sorry, but I find the Calculator app woefully unimpressive.

I can't even type a simple expression with parenthesis. There's no RPN option. There isn't a "financial" setting (only scientific and programmer, for some reason). The list goes on; I'm sure I'm not alone on this one.

It is so, so, so basic it's essentially useless, I end up being forced to open Excel, run Python in the terminal, go on Wolfram Alpha or, worse yet (!!) grab pen and paper to perform basic math.

I know this is unrelated to UWP, but I'd rather they focus less on improving an UI that is inevitably trivial (little boxes with numbers arranged in a grid within a bigger box) and instead added some much needed features.

The fact that I am using a computer must be lost on whoever decided to green light this abomination as the default calculator in any OS ever, let alone one released in the 21st century.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by McP on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:43PM (#22418320)
> I can't even type a simple expression with parenthesis

Use Scientific mode and parentheses work fine

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by airstrike on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @06:08PM (#22418536)
Work "fine" but not quite "great". Made a mistake? Retype the whole expression, as there's no backspace / undo even before hitting =
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by dpwm on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @06:20AM (#22422065)
It sounds like they made the behaviour imitate that of a bad scientific calculator.

I've not used a physical for some years, but even then the Casio ones had a backspace, and had apparently done so for a good few generations.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by xaedes on Friday February 28, 2020 @03:44AM (#22441435)
Yea, the new calculator is kinda bad. But you can search the web for "windows old calculator" and replace the new one with this. It is exactly the calculator as you are used to from Win7.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by WorldMaker on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:28PM (#22417093)
Feel free to try contributing if you think it that trivial to add "much needed features": https://github.com/microsoft/calculator
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by grawprog on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:27PM (#22418181)
So become an unpaid Microsoft employee to re-add features that used to exist and that do exist in nearly every alternative? Don't they make enough money off of os sales, subscriptions, forced ads and telemetry? They need free labour to fix their broken software too?
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by pjmlp on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:47PM (#22418355)
Many people love to be FAANG unpaid employees, why should it be any different for Microsoft?
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by grawprog on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @06:08PM (#22418534)
Why not put those efforts towards an actual open source calculator project that could really use the volunteer efforts and doesn't already have an army of paid employees?

https://qalculate.github.io/ https://bitbucket.org/heldercorreia/speedcrunch/

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by chaorace on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @12:05AM (#22420432)
Is that a rhetorical question, or do I really get to argue the benefits of contributing to one of the most installed calculators on the planet? Contributing to small projects is good, but it's not for everyone and you're definitely kidding yourself if an MIT licensed software on Github doesn't qualify as "actual open source".
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by grawprog on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @11:19AM (#22424350)
Yeah I tend to consider moral and ethical implications of my decisions also, I forget not everyone does.

I feel time spent working on projects for a company that hasn't spent the better part of 3 decades trying to dominate and control the entirety of the computer market using strategies that destroy competition and supress innovation, that tracks and monitors its users, that has such a small amount of respect that it will inject ads into a product most customers are forced to purchase should they wish to own a computer, is more valuable in that it makes the world just a slightly better place, rather than a slightly shittier one.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by pjmlp on Thursday February 27, 2020 @05:33AM (#22432165)
For a moment I thought you were talking about Google.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by fuu_dev on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @08:42AM (#22422765)
Because you want to reach >800M users and want everyone to have access to it?
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by WorldMaker on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:56PM (#22418431)
It's an option.

Though I didn't just mean patches from "contribute", it could also mean voice/ideas/discussion: instead of pseudonymously complain on HN, there's Feedback Hub and GitHub Issues. As an option that's available.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by airstrike on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:35PM (#22417152)
Not my cup of tea, sorry. I don't need to provide patches to be allowed to bash software I've paid for ;-)
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by WorldMaker on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @04:01PM (#22417400)
Contributions doesn't mean just patches. Also, technically you didn't pay for Calculator, you paid for Windows and got a calculator. The fact that Calculator today is open source adds additional insight that it was always probably a "bonus" accessory, as the most interesting stuff happening to it today are from community contributions.

Anyway, for instance, you could see that RPN is on the radar: https://github.com/microsoft/calculator/issues/128

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:35PM (#22418255)
"Yeah, well technically you bought a car, you didn't pay for an engine, so the engine being crap isn't something you can complain about."

I don't think this sort of argument works.

The reason it's open source is most likely because it's got nothing of value to competitors but lets them point and say "see, we've changed, look we make things open source now"; aka marketing.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by WorldMaker on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:43PM (#22418327)
I find that analogy weak because Windows works fine without a calc.exe or Calculator app, but a car doesn't run without an engine. Calculator is more a cup holder. I'm not trying to stop anyone for complaining about their cup holder, that's a great day-to-day productivity tool for a lot of car owners. Just pointing out that fit/finish/polish on a cup holder comes after the things like the engine.

Fwiw, it seems to go far beyond marketing that Calculator is open source, as community contributions have made it into releases and Calculator has seemed to benefit from more (and more diverse) development resources than it had in XP/Vista/7.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @06:28PM (#22418681)
The engine in Win 10 isn't quite a masterpiece of consumer productivity either.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by philliphaydon on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @07:21PM (#22419044)
You could argue the same for OSX / Linux.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @06:29AM (#22422101)
But if the cupholders break, you take the car in and the manufacturer fixes them, no? If they don't fix them you can return the car.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by grenoire on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @04:34PM (#22417727)
There was a version with all of these features; new version doesn't even have its functional feature parity down...
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by WorldMaker on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:37PM (#22418266)
calc.exe never had RPN support. Some of y'all seem to be remembering a very different calculator than the one built in to Windows. "UWP" Calculator has feature parity with the calc.exe of Vista/7, and has features that calc.exe never had. I wish more of the source control history had been migrated to the git repository, but it's pretty clear from the header comments that one was built out of the codebase of the other (the core of the calculation engine itself goes way back).
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by badsectoracula on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @04:36PM (#22417741)
The regressions are in that it is much slower and wastes screen real estate. 90% of the window size is for faux buttons that have zero purpose for anyone who doesn't use a touch screen on their Windows computer (ie. at least 99% of the Windows users) and the 10% that remains uses oversized elements with wasteful padding.

Here is what i use as a calculator on Windows: http://runtimeterror.com/tools/calc/calc.hta.txt

It looks like this: https://i.imgur.com/eWZfcXB.png

and not only is much faster to open than Windows Calculator (ironic, considering it loads an entire browser engine) but also more compact and doesn't waste any screen space (100% of its window is dedicated to its actual functionality instead of being an obsolete skeuomorphism that was originally made to help people associate desktop calculators with the virtual desktop metaphor used on the Macintosh back in 1984 when actual physical desktop calculators could be found everywhere).

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:41PM (#22418309)
> ie. at least 99% of the Windows users

I bet a lot more than 1% of Windows users have touch screens at this point, since they've become more-or-less standard on high-end laptops.

Mind, it still could easily be < 10%, given how many people have old/cheap PCs.

I don't quite know what the solution is though. The last thing Windows 10 needs in addition to its two separate control panels, command lines, and web browsers are two separate calculator apps.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by olyjohn on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:49PM (#22418372)
At least they only have one kernel running both Windows and the Linux subsystem. Because that is somehow better than just running a Linux VM with a real Linux kernel.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by uncletaco on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @06:26PM (#22418674)
They are running a linux VM with a real linux kernel is WSL2.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by kalleboo on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @06:40PM (#22418762)
Does Windows not have something like the Mac's built-in Spotlight search? On the Mac, whereever I am, I can hit command-space, and in the resulting universal search pop-up I can type in math problems, unit/currency conversations, etc.

Even on iOS I use the search field for math & unit conversions rather than the Calc app, since it's easier to refine/fix your formula

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by gregschlom on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @06:47PM (#22418803)
It does - just press the Windows key to open the start menu and type your expression - but... the math is done by Bing. Which means that 1. it's unnecessarily slow and 2. without internet, your machine can't even show you the result of 2+2.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by viraptor on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @08:02PM (#22419304)
There's nothing uwp-specific about that behaviour though. The classic calculator could be made resizable and gain a "stay in top" option.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by 1996 on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @08:18PM (#22419399)
My calculator is bc in a bash so I don't really care about either.

However, I really like the live weather tile, and I use it every day, sometimes several times a day by just pressing the start button, looking at the forecast, and pressing it again to go back to my app.

It was not intrusive and helpful. I also used the live calendar and mail that way (I hate notifications) -- and the photos too to see if new pics had been synchronized.

I'm afraid Windows 10 is going way from Windows 8, and closer to Windows 7. I don't think this is progress.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by fultonfaknem42 on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:02PM (#22416813)
They have obstacles to overcome, and then there is just the glaring fact that they had so much momentum with Win32.

My biggest gripe is that startup times are just too long. So many times I've gone to launch something like calculator only to have a beefy machine hang for almost a second, if not a full second. It's likely an engineering obstacle that can be overcome but it just makes UWP look like a bad move perf wise.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by WorldMaker on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:31PM (#22417108)
There was a brief period in Windows 8 where (proto) UWP apps launched smooth and fast and the Win32 desktop took several additional minutes to launch. With so many stacks living side-by-side on Windows it seems an interesting trade-off between past apps, present apps, and future wishes.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by badsectoracula on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @04:40PM (#22417783)
I hope future wishes don't involve adding yet another stack though. They need to fix the stuff they have (without breaking them), not introduce new stuff.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by WorldMaker on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:30PM (#22418212)
That's part of my sadness in seeing so many posts here talk bad about the UWP. The UWP barely had half a chance to live, and with Microsoft having to spend so much time in the Chromium codebase and working on Android code, with Electron and React Native seemingly becoming the most common development platforms for them, the future for Microsoft already doesn't seem to be UWP.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by pcwalton on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @08:42PM (#22419518)
> They have obstacles to overcome, and then there is just the glaring fact that they had so much momentum with Win32.

Do you feel the same about the macOS Carbon-Cocoa transition? Nobody misses Carbon anymore, and Win32 is as old as the classic Mac Toolbox.

Eventually they have to shed the old API.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by joshuaissac on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @08:00AM (#22422480)
Major Win32-only applications like Microsoft Office, SAP and countless in-house applications written over the last 25 years are the reason that many companies use Windows.

Microsoft understands that the Windows API "is so deeply embedded in the source code of many Windows apps that there is a huge switching cost to using a different operating system instead".[1] If they force companies to incur that cost by dropping Win32 support, that gives companies the chance to make their application cross-platform at a much smaller additional cost, and shed their reliance on Windows.

Windows licensing fees are still quite a large chunk of Microsoft's revenues, so I think that they will not make this move any time soon.

1. https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-wed-have-been-dead-a...

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by justin66 on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @02:36AM (#22421127)
Win32 support will be there until Microsoft's desktop operating system is no longer called "Windows."

The comparison between Apple and Microsoft vis-à-vis backward compatibility is illuminating, but not in the way you seem to believe it is.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by flohofwoe on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @04:24AM (#22421595)
Cocoa was an improvement though, while UWP is a regression and a massive PITA to work with. Win32 isn't a great API either, and some corners are downright ugly, but when a successor needs more lines of code to get a window on screen but only delivers a small fraction of the features of the old system, something went seriously wrong.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by fultonfaknem42 on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @03:21PM (#22426894)
I can't answer your question exactly. I came around only after Cocoa was established.

This does make me wonder if the transition from Carbon to Cocoa is analogous though. Win32 comes off as more of a "functional" approach to programming (C) and UWP is looking more object oriented (as to C++). It makes me wonder what kinds of conceptual advantages are being brought on board by moving from win32 to UWP. I think that conceptually I am in favor of the transition, and I'd wager that all the issues that arise are common to a functional to object-oriented transition.

But that real questions: What are the benefits? Is it conceptually easier to grasp thus promoting more developer interaction? Are we expecting speed benefits (are the performance losses expected and in range?) Is it a false dichotomy to only look at Functional vs OO? Maybe a context-oriented data approach is more appropriate?

Dunno.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by anthk on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @10:17PM (#22419971)
Win32 is fast and reliable.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by pjmlp on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @02:36AM (#22421125)
And frozen in a Windows XP vision of the world.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by Shorel on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @08:29PM (#22429479)
And Wine. Don't forget Wine.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by majkinetor on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @02:48PM (#22416668)
I REMOVE MS Store and use Chocolatey. MS Store may also eat up 100% CPU [1] which happend to me multiple times which is funny, since I never use it.

> They're slow, they lack features, they have horrible UIs and they don't integrate well with the rest of the OS.

This is the case with almost all android apps too.

[1]: https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/windows8_1...

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by vezycash on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:13PM (#22416942)
MS shot themselves in the foot with the store on PC. I don't get why I can't use the store from my browser. I want to sign in to the bloody store from any browser of my choice, click the download button and have store app do the downloads in the background.

One other problem the store has is that it handles poor network horribly. Or rather, it just can't work with poor internet.

Play store on the other hand is a master piece. It will open even offline (I tested it right now). It will show a cached page from last time.

Even settings work offline. And finally, the play store will alert you when you're back online.

MS store on the other hand will throw an incomprehensible ERROR Code at you.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by non-entity on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:21PM (#22417017)
Tbh outside of maybe a sandboxing aspect, UWP made zero sense to me when Windows Phone fully died. Before that, the ability to have one codebase target both desktop and mobile seemed interesting at least, but now, it would seem that there are only a tiny of handful of applications that could be useful as universal between the remaining UWP targets (desktop, xbox, IoT, whatever else)
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by pjmlp on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @04:36PM (#22417749)
UWP is what .NET should have been since the beginning, an improved COM, and an alternative design solution to Longhorn ideas.

From that point of view it makes perfect sense.

What it did not make sense was creating an incompatible .NET runtime for it, or the way it was introduced with device specific APIs (Win 8, Win 8.1), using shared code folders.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by wayneftw on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @02:41PM (#22416575)
You can install the old calc.exe by downloading it from a reputable source or copying it from a Win7 machine.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by tryptophan on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @02:46PM (#22416645)
I use speedcrunch(open source and super fast) for my quick calculating needs.

I dont see any advantage of win calculator over it.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:38PM (#22418274)
Looks nice, and latest version is on Chocolatey, just installed it. Thanks.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by agumonkey on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @06:32PM (#22418708)
have you tried scoop ?
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by lostmsu on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @02:30PM (#22416447)
Yes and no. In the days when all apps leech your data, I want the sandbox that UWP provides. Do not know if it is feasible for MS to make it work properly with "legacy" APIs.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by cptskippy on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @02:41PM (#22416577)
They would have to do some sort of virtualization since there's literally no restrictions on what APIs you can access. There's so much cruft and invalid paradigms in the old APIs it makes sense to roll new ones.

I think the approach they're taking to refactoring the Control Panel into the Settings App is smart. They're dog-fooding the Frameworks they're expecting others to use, slowly migrating functionality that's relevant to a modern Windows platform, and keeping existing functionality around until they've replicated it.

I also like that the apps are responsive. I use the snap feature a lot and it's nice that the Apps will adapt to the dimensions I relegate them to.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by uxp on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @08:30PM (#22419459)
I'm a .NET developer and I can't tell you how many times I've searched for documentation and come across something that's targeting UWP which is different than WPF and entirely not the same as WinForms and it takes way too much energy trying to identify why exactly the documentation isn't what you want. I thought Microsoft was more or less sunsetting WinForms until they also announced WinForms for .NET Core a couple months ago. https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/core/porting/winform...

I literally have no idea what Microsoft is doing anymore. Sometimes it feels like Linux was 10 years ago when I would accidentally install Konquerer on Gnome and all of a sudden I had two desktop systems installed and my root drive had doubled it's consumed harddrive space. It basically worked, but it was a terrible experience.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by robotnikman on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @04:09PM (#22417495)
The Windows 10X preview actually does this by running Win32 apps inside their own container, with their own registry, kernel, drivers, and isolated from the rest of the rest of the system.
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by lostmsu on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @10:51PM (#22420135)
Is there a technical article on this?

Also, drivers? o-O

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by mc32 on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @04:50PM (#22417860)
Why don’t they just have a toggle, either global or per application. Live tiles, yes/no. Then the user has a choice of high/low resource usage and “busy-ness”
Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by prostheticvamp on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:56PM (#22418435)
I think they do?

I’ve definitely enabled/disabled the tiles on an individual basis. I just don’t recall whether it’s universally available to all programs, or a particular subset.

Re:Windows 10 live tiles reportedly getting killed by Microsoft by BenjiWiebe on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @09:26AM (#22423148)
They do. Right click the live tile, and click "Turn live tile off".